Premium Essay

Adam Smith - Division of Labor

In:

Submitted By 09goddess
Words 1725
Pages 7
Alyssa Pratt

DOES ADAM SMITH GIVE TWO CONTRASTING VIEWS ON THE DIVISION OF LABOR BETWEEN BOOKS ONE AND FIVE?
The question on whether or not Adam Smith gives us two contrasting views on the division of labor has been debated for hundreds of years. However to truly answer this question we must first narrow our scope to determine whether the division of labor is beneficial to the society as a whole and is a goal worthy of pursuing from an economic standpoint. Adam Smith says ‘yes’ at first but later changes his mind upon realizing that, the division of labor could result in a deterioration of the human mind and social instability. More specifically, in Book One, Adam Smith points out that the division of labor is necessary and can bring about technological change as well as make the citizens of a nation more prosperous. However, in Book Five, Adam Smith talks about the deleterious effects of the division of labor on the work force and the inequality that it brings to society. In this essay, I will give a more detailed account of Smith’s view on the division of labor in Book One and Five of ‘The Wealth of Nations’. I will then proceed to crystallize why these two views are incompatible with each other. In Book One Adam Smith presents the positive effects of the division of labor. He believes that it makes society as a whole more productive and creates an economic surplus which everyone can enjoy through trade. He then illustrates how the division of labor actually accomplishes an increase in productivity. Firstly, the division of labor achieves this goal through a commonly known economic concept called ‘learning by doing’. The way this works is that by giving the brain a simple task to focus on your body will achieve high degrees of skill at this task, i.e. workers become more dexterous. For example, if you are a baker and your only task is to

Alyssa Pratt

mix

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Adam Smith

...Adam Smith Adam Smith is known for his vast knowledge of economics, he is considered to be the father. We may recognize him from his book The Wealth of Nations. The Wealth of Nations informs us that if we maximize the markets behavior than a free trade environment could be made available. In this essay I will discuss the importance of Smith’s theory, along with how he would develop plans to help the economy. Adam Smith grew up in a market environment in which Mercantilism was thought to be the best theory to help build a countries capital. Mercantilism “is a system in which a country attempts to amass wealth through trade with other countries, exporting more than it imports and increasing stores of gold and precious metals. It is often considered an outdated system.”(Vocabulary .com Retrieved April 13, 2013) Smith expressed his thoughts about the mercantile system, he thought the system had inconsistencies, and a countries wealth was not based upon its prosperity. He also thought that production should increase in the free market. The division of labor was a suggested policy. The division of labor theory is the “separation of manufacturing process into distinct and simple operations which are then delegated to specific hands or machines to perform”(Division of Labor Retrieved on April 13, 2013). He thought that this would increase the number of productive workers against the number of unproductive workers. Smith was...

Words: 1176 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

A Comparison Between Adam Smith and Karl Marx

...A comparison between Adam Smith and Karl Marx The purpose of this essay is to evaluate and discuss how economists Adam Smith and Karl Marx contributed to current management practices and, more specifically, how they influenced the field of economics. Through critical analysis, we will explore the theories of Adam Smith and Karl Marx. Adam Smith’s contributions, from division of labor and the shift from a mercantile society to a capitalistic one as proposed in his “Wealth of nations report,” will be critically evaluated as to determine both their relevance today and the influence that they have had. Similarly, Karl Marx’s theories that helped to develop the economy in its most prosperous time will be critically evaluated to determine their influence and relevancy today. Although very distant in their theories and time, both men have played key roles in the development of economics, while in turn influencing current management practices. Both men were able to change and introduce new philosophies while reacting to the circumstances of their times, while creating legacies through their works that are still relevant in today’s vastly different circumstances and society. Adam Smith Scottish economist Adam Smith, born in 1723, is responsible for the initial development of economics in the eighteenth century and provided the framework for how we approach economic issues today. Smith was an “advocate for a free market society where international trade through both imports...

Words: 2499 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Adam Smith

...Introduction Known as one of the founding fathers of economics, Adam Smith is one of the most influential writers of his time. His works seem to be able to transcend time and cultures to the extent that his books are still in circulation today and are heavily debated. From his first famous work “Theory of Moral Sentiments” to “An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations” Adam Smith showed that he was a leading mind in the field of political economy and for that matter human nature. He is able to explain a variety of economic influences based on his overlying concept of rational self-interest in a free-market economy. But just like any other great mind revered in history they all have to start somewhere, and his was in Scotland. Adam Smith was born and raised in Scotland in the year 1723. At the age of 14 years old he was admitted into the University of Glasgow on a scholarship. He studied moral philosophy there until he switched colleges and then attended Balliol College at Oxford. He graduated with an extensive knowledge of European literature and moral philosophy. Preceding his graduation from Oxford University he returned to his home country to give a series of lectures that contributed to him being elected as the first chair of logic in 1751 and subsequently the chair of moral philosophy in 1752 at Glasgow University. A few years later Adam Smith published “Theory of Moral Sentiments” which was well received by the general public and eventually...

Words: 3566 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Law & Ethics

...“Adam Smith’s Work as it Applies to Modern Society” By Mour August 25, 2011 Referenced Book: Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith Adam Smith was a visionary; He described the issue of the Wealth of Nations in twofold, why a society driven by self-interest can exist on the other hand, describes how the “System of natural liberty” appeared and how it works. Book 1 – Of the Division of Labor The World as today The wealth of an industrial nation is the power of labor and the division thereof in order to increase the input of all type of production. Smith explained “The division of the Labor” does not originate itself from human wisdom or of a plan, but is the consequence "of a certain leaning natural one to all the men, that the door to do business and exchanges something to another. And the motivation of this tendency to the exchange is not the benevolence, but the personal interest, that is to say the desire to improve his living condition for the better. Smith concept of wages of labor is a fundamental metrics to satisfy the effort required to produce goods and manufacture a product. The profit (return on sales or investment such as rental properties, commercial building and equipment), buy or sale stocks are conceptual means of increasing an owner’s return on investment. Smith demonstrated that the division of labor will add more efficient methods of doing different...

Words: 1822 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Adam Smith

...ANALYTICAL ESSAY 1: How Adam Smith Has Shaped Our Economy For The Better Jose Arguello University of Redlands July 25, 2013 Introduction The purpose of this paper is to analyze and discuss how Adam Smith’s economic theories have shaped our economy for the better. This paper will define Adam Smith’s major economic theories and relate them to today’s economy. This paper will conclude with recommendations on how some of these theories can be improved. Discussion When people think of Adam Smith they think of Adam Smith “the economist.” In fact, many don’t realize that Adam Smith was a philosopher at heart. From that critical thinking space as a philosopher, Adam Smith developed his economic theories. Adam Smith obtained a professorship at Glasgow teaching moral philosophy. “Here, Smith developed his passion for liberty, reason, and free speech. In 1740 Smith was awarded the Snell exhibition and left to attend Balliol College, Oxford.” (Buchanan, 2006) These are important facts about Adam Smith because it gives us an insight to his philosophy and eventually into his economic theories. Furthermore, before Adam Smith wrote his well-known work, The Wealth of Nations, he wrote The Theory of Moral Sentiments. It is important to note that in writing The Theory of Moral Sentiment, Adam Smith’s goal “was to explain the source of mankind's ability to form moral judgments, in spite of man's natural inclinations towards self-interest. Smith proposes a theory of sympathy...

Words: 2699 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Wealth of Nations

...Inquiry on Adam Smith’s “Wealth of Nations” Deonisio Ed Benigno C. Manuel Strayer University Law Ethics and Corporate Governance 500 Professor Glen Trimper March 2, 2011 Term Paper Abstract The principal objective of this term paper is to show my understanding on the “Wealth of Nations” book by Adam Smith. The book contains a collection of ideas and thoughts made into essays that were synthesized in the creation of this book. It tells us information on how the economy progressed from using primitive forms of currency like cows and shells to using metals like copper, silver and gold in doing barters and exchanges. It also talks about how division of labor improved the efficiency and quality of the work produced by laborers. This book expresses its opinion on how poverty and wealth affects the economy. Allan B. Krueger (2003) from Princeton University said that no book has had more influence on economists thinking and economic policy other than “An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations” by Adam Smith (p. xi). Some questions the validity or authenticity of some of his ideas that was written in this book. Advanced related ideas were found to be written by ancient Chinese philosophers like Confucius in the late years of Zhou dynasty (1027 BC - 256 BC). It was also believed that he borrowed some of these ideas from his French contemporaries. Nevertheless The Wealth of Nations was regarded as the founding work of modern economics and that...

Words: 3250 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Group Study

...Law, Ethics, and Corporate Governance – LEG 500 Section 001003 Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations Reviewed Strayer University Alexandria Campus Touraj Behmand SID:1121701137 Professor Glen A. Trimper March 02, 2011 Table of Contents Abstract 3 Book I: Of the division of labour 4 Book I: Of the origin and use of money 5 Book I: Of the natural and market price of commodities 6 Book II: Of the Division of stock 7 Bibliography 10 Abstract Adam Smith was born in Kirkcaldy in 1723. He entered Glasgow University at the early age of fourteen. He studied logic, metaphysics, math and later Newtonian physics and moral philosophy under some of the leading scholars of his day. He is famous for his theory that nations achieve their wealth and function best where individuals are free to use their skills and capital in their own self-interest, at their own good judgment and risk. But isn’t that the same as entrepreneurship? In today’s capitalism society each individual is seeking prosperity by risking his or her own capital to gain self-interest. The availability of such option for individuals is what Smith calls freedom. Is that why Smith is also known as ‘the father of capitalism’? Smith taught that prices and wages will automatically reach optimal levels when such freedom is permitted. For instance, jobs that require special training will result in fewer people making that investment and, therefore, ultimate higher wages. This explains why engineers make more money than...

Words: 2159 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Free Trade

...Davila Modern Europe Professor Hagai M. Segal September 29, 2015 Why Free Trade is Superior to Mercantilism The Industrial Revolution brought great success to the British Empire. It helped establish the Empire as one of the leaders (if not the strongest) of the European powers that would colonize lands all over the globe. By the end of the 18th century, Britain had amassed global economic power, and needed to regulate it somehow. The British government's plan of action was to enforce regulations on trade in order to keep control of what was produced, and what would benefit the motherland most. Adam Smith, arguably the most influential economic theorist in modern history, coined this system as 'Mercantilism,' and felt it was not optimal. Economic development and growth is inhibited by the mercantile system because resources are not allocated for maximum efficiency. For Smith, natural tendencies for exchange rooted in the self-interest of individuals would lead to an improved standard of living. Mercantilism was situational. As described by the Library of Economics and Liberty, it is a "system of political economy that sought to enrich the country by restraining imports and encouraging exports." Economic nationalism is another way to perceive it. The system originated in the 16th century when European powers began fighting over resources, often leading to armed conflict between each other (LaHaye, 2004). The objective of the mercantile system was to sustain a trade surplus...

Words: 1226 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Father of Economics - Adam Smith

...During the 18th century, when Adam Smith lived, the most important social, moral, and technological presumptions had matured. These assumptions have helped to shape the market system as the publicly accepted and entrenched economic lifestyle, and the basis for cultural and even ethical relationships. The presumptions were market intensification and the spread of money operations, as well as the need for accounting and technical production, not the seizure of new lands or colonial conquest, as it used to be, but the accumulation of wealth became the source of vitality for many nations. At the same times, the type for economic man, the one who is absorbed with resource realization, was formed. The history led Smith to become one of the most authoritative of there new global manifestation of life and theoretical trends approvers. He wrote to works called The Moral Sentiments and The Wealth of Nations (Ross) In these works he analyzed two the most important social and individual areas of life, spiritual and materialistic, he tried to philosophically justify the already mentioned era changes as the ones that are best fitting humanity, the spiritual being of nations and ensuring the material well-being. The book called The Wealth of Nations earned the title of the “father of economics” title for Adam Smith (Say). The goal of this paper is to review and analyze the economical achievements of Adam Smith for world history and the world today. Smith was born on June 5th, 1723 in Kirkcaldy...

Words: 3144 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Adam Smith: the Father of Economics

...Adam Smith was one of the most well known economists and philosophers of all time. The first record of Adam Smith was when he was baptized on June 5, 1723 in Kirkcaldy, Scotland. He then was a student at the Burgh School, University of Glasgow, and then proceeded to attend Oxford at the ripe old age of 14. Adam Smith was obviously a very bright individual, and it showed when he published his first book in 1759 called The Theory of Moral Sentiments; though this book focused more on human morality rather than economics. A few years later, Adam Smith published his most famous work, The Wealth of Nations. This book was the first insight into looking at a fully political economy. As opposed to just looking at an economy by using gold and silver, Smith argued that an economy should be measured by Gross National Product. This idea of GDP was a revolutionary idea at the time because most economists believed that a nation should just use gold and silver to measure the strength of their economy. In his book, he also theorized with an idea of division of labor. The idea of division of labor is that if you were to specialize labor forces, the overall productivity, or GDP, of an economy would bolster greatly. These ideas, though very well known, are probably not as well known as the idea of the Invisible Hand. The idea of the Invisible Hand really has two different ways of thinking, first, Smith argued that the reason that we would get the items we needed (food, materials, etc.) is because...

Words: 692 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Economics

...or of Their Price in Labor, and Their Price in Money” is the fifth chapter of a book called “Weath of Nations”. This book was written in 1723-1790 by Adam Smith. According to this writer, every man is poor or rich to some extent that he can afford to enjoy the conveniences, necessaries, and life amusements. However, after the division of labor, it becomes a small part of these with which man owns labor can fully satisfy him. This is to mean that, the greater part of them must be derived from other people’s labor, and that the man must be poor or rich according to the quantity of labor that he can afford to buy or secure. This chapter argues that the commodity value, to the person who possesses it, or who means not to consume or use himself, but switch it with other commodities, is just equal to the amount of labor which enables him to command or purchase. This is to signify that labor is the only trusted measure of the exchange value of all commodities. (Smith, 1977) According to Adam Smith, the real price of everything is the trouble and toil of acquiring it. Whatever everything is worth to the person who has acquired it, is the trouble and toil which it can save him, and which it can impose on other people. Adam notes that, whatever can be bought with money can as well be bought by labor, as much as it was acquired by the toil of one’s body. Adam argues that, the money actually saves us this toil. They contain some value of a certain amount of labor which we exchange for...

Words: 900 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Hello Korea

...Discussion Questions for Smith vs. Marx (October 8, 2013 pp. 134-165) An Essay on the Background of Business Ethics: Ethics, Economics, Law and the Corporation 1. What is philosophy? A conversation. 2. What is "philosophical ethics"? A conversation about conduct, the doing of good, and the avoiding of evil. 3. What is "business ethics"? A conversation about right and wrong conduct in the business world. 4. Business ethics was once known as “the world’s most famous oxymoron” until about thirty years ago. What happened to change that view? Newspaper headlines of foreign bribes, Wall Street scandals, exploding cars, whistleblower conflicts and civil rights in the workplace allowed the view that value questions are never absent from business decisions to come into play and that moral responsibility is the first requirement of a manager in any business. From then on, it has become the general consensus that a thorough grounding in ethical reasoning is essential preparation for a career in business. 5. How was the “ruling class” defined in the seventeenth century according to Karl Marx? The ruling class in every age is the group that owns the means of production of the age’s product. In the 17th century, the product was almost exclusively agricultural and the means of production was almost exclusively agricultural land; landowners were the aristocrats and rulers. With the coming of commerce and industry, the owners of the factories joined the ruling class...

Words: 1055 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Wealth of Nations

...The Wealth of Nations Chapter I – Of the Division of Labour Summarize: Division of Labour is thought by Smith to increases Wealth of Nations. Increase in skill, dexterity and productivity of labor is most affected by DOL. The idea of the division of labour relates primarily to the specialization of the labor force, basically the breaking down of large jobs into many tiny components. Under this system each worker becomes an expert in one isolated area of production, thus increasing his efficiency. The fact that laborers do not have to switch tasks during the day further saves time and money. By allowing machines to step in to help with the production, the operation will be simpler and make into routine. Machines make production process speeds up its level and produce goods faster. Argumentation: The audience that the author was writing for were capitalists. This is supported by the writer's suggestions in the article. Adam Smith suggests that manufactures should divide its labor force into obvious groups. Each of them should do different operation instead of having a single worker doing all of the operations by himself. The main focus of Adam Smith's The Wealth of Nations lies in the concept of economic growth. The only factor that he mentions that effects the growth is the supply of labor. However, in modern economics, other factors such as land, capital, technology, knowledge, and etc. also influence the productivity of the labor, therefore, the wealth of the nations. ...

Words: 725 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Sdfsdgd

...gold and silver is international trade. II. THE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS OF THE THEORIES: 1. CLASSICAL INTERNATIONAL TRADE THEORY In the late 1790s, the point of mercantilism was challenged by the classical economists. Based on criticizing the mercantilism, Adam Smith proposed the division of labor theory. It has been 41 years from Adam Smith proposed the absolute cost in his the Wealth of Nations in 1976 to David Ricardo proposed the comparative cost in his the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation in 1817. This is the foundation period of international trade theory, that is, the Classical period. The absolute cost of Adam Smith is based on the division of labor theory. Adam introduced the division of labor theory to the field of international trade and established his absolute cost theory, thus demonstrating the fact that a nation can make the sources of each country most efficiently used to gain the increase of the total production, the enhance of consumption level and the save of labor time as long as the nation specially produce the products of which its production cost is lower than any other country in order to exchange the products of which the cost is high than any other country with its cost-low products. Adam pointed out that the base of...

Words: 1878 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Dead Economics

...these insights and built these durable models? We can learn from their masters.” (Buchholz 9). Again and again Smith name’s is mentioned. Smith...

Words: 1232 - Pages: 5