Free Essay

Amba 610

In:

Submitted By chintanchotli
Words 2172
Pages 9
| Final Exam | AMBA 610 | April 16, 2013 |

|

Issue 1 – Ethics and Legal Environment The Badaracco’s video file from 2002 lists many important and critical analysis methods for finding a solution to right vs. right problems. He lists four main questions and three tests that will be answered in this answer to find the solution to how the HR should handle the situation with Sansa.
Which way of proceeding will get the best net-net consequence? Badaracco’s (2002) right vs. right framework has the first question as what will get the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people. In this question, Sansa’s pros and cons are to be compared with the pros and cons of other employees of Iron Throne Industries (ITI). If HR lets Sansa to work as senior VP at ITI without her having an MBA, many other employees who have worked hard to get an MBA to apply to such positions might feel angry and distrust. Others might feel the credibility of their company has gone down. If she can falsify on resume, she could falsify other documents as well. On the other hand, if Sansa is let go for the reason of lying on the resume and not having an MBA, which was a requirement when she was promoted, the company would be losing an excellent employee who has shown that she is more than capable of her job. In this case, letting Sansa continue to work as a senior VP not only helps Sansa but also to all the employees of ITI as she has been an outstanding worker and would further increase revenue in the company. Which individuals’ rights cannot be violated, no matter what? First and foremost the rights of all employees and ITI cannot be violated. Although each employee should have an equal opportunity at the senior VP position based on their educational requirements set by the company and their work history, a decision has to be made such that the company’s well-being and the employee’s jobs are insured. Having stated that, the employees of ITI have the right to have a leader who is most capable of leading them. As is with many other senior VPs at ITI, non-MBA holding person has been proven to lead the company and so for the wellbeing of the company, Sansa should be allowed to retain her position as a senior VP. What messages do I want to send about my ideals and principals? Badaracco (2002) asked a sub-question for this issue, what is the uncrossable line? As an HR representative, Targaryen should send the message that the company’s principals and ideals are to follow the truth. Since Sansa initially lied on the resume of having an MBA, she cannot be given that position until she has met the requirement. The company cannot allow someone who has falsified documents to work for them. Their principals would be threatened. What will work in the world as it is? To answer this question, Badaracco (2002) suggests thinking outside of the box, having an imaginative idea. The solution for HR of ITI would be to allow Sansa to work as a temporary senior VP while she completes her MBA and would regain full senior VP status once she has obtained the degree. This way the company can keep their principals and ideals while satisfying the economic freedom of its employees. The three tests. Badaracco (2002) specifies three tests that could help in getting to the most “right” answer. The first test is the newspaper test (Badaracco, 2002). This test can be understood as, find the solution that would work best if it were to be published in the newspaper. From the answer of the fourth test above, if Sansa is allowed to work and study at the same time, this news headline would make ITI look very friendly and positive. It would show that they care for their employees and they value results as well. Walk a mile in someone else’s shoes (Badaracco, 2002) is the second test. Or as Badaracco (2002) said how would you like your kids to be treated? Having Sansa shown the company that she is more than capable of work as a senior VP, even if Joffrey was my child, I would have Sansa work for the company as she has out worked him. The final test is the obituary test (Badaracco, 2002). As the times moves on, the HR representatives can look back and see that they made the right choice by allowing Sansa to study and work at the same time. Allowing Sansa to work, might have ensured the future of ITI to be positive and also ensured that the employees of ITI had a company with lots of opportunities.
Issue 2 – Organizational Environment
In deciding whether or not to produce larger quantities, what factors should this organization consider? One of the first factors they should consider is to look at their general and specific environment. General environments include political, international, technological, economic, environmental, and cultural forces while specific environments include the customer, competitors, distributors and suppliers (Jones, 2013). The first thing is to check if there are any competitors; assuming there is competition in quality made stuffed snakes, the resources will be scarce and valuable. If the company can install the new non-customized machinery for mass production, they still need raw materials from suppliers. The company needs to analyze and examine the cost of obtaining raw materials from suppliers at lower costs if they intend to sell the new snakes at only $20. It can be assumed that an organic structure is currently in place because of highly customized products offered, but according to Woodward’s argument of technological imperative, the company has to adopt a mechanistic structure in order for it to be effective (Jones, 2013). The company should be ready to accept these changes and be prepared to change their organizational structure before investing in mass production technology. The cost of buying new technology is also a big factor for the company. The capital of the company needs to be examined and see if it can afford buying new technology and labor skills. A new programmable method also needs to be created for the mass production of snakes. The cost of this non-customized manufacturing method creation will have to be added to the total cost. Since it is assumed that there is demand for the snakes, the company has to consider the overall transition cost and see if it still can be profitable.
What additional factors should be considered if Snuggly Snakes decides to expand to Poland, Armenia, and possibly Asia? The company should have a specific plan or strategy in place for their organization before considering expansion into Asia, Poland and Armenia. The company should decide and assign authoritative duties and responsibilities between home and abroad managers for an effective global operation. An organizational structure must also be decided that best connects domestic and global divisions for a smoother exchanges of values and core competences. An effective coordination would lead to better transfer of core competences and cultural values. Jones (2013) mentions four specific strategies for global expansion; multidomestic, international, global and transnational. In multidomestic strategy, the values are duplicated and authority is decentralized at each overseas divisions. A global geographic structure is used in multidomestic strategy. It is mostly used to make and sell the same products in different countries. Since there is no contact between each division, no integrating mechanism is needed (Jones, 2013). In international strategy, companies use global product group structure and international managers are controlled by product group managers (Jones, 2013). In global strategy, the manufacturing is located at a single global location that would maximize efficiency but this creates coordination and integration problems (Jones, 2013). The transnational strategy uses the matrix structure and it solves the problem of centralized structure by having multiple divisions per product group in each country (Jones, 2013).
In order for them to expand globally into markets such as Asia, Poland, and Armenia, they must look at the environments in these locations. As mentioned above for mass production, environmental forces also play a role in global expansion. The company must also look at environmental complexity, dynamism, and richness as well. These three factors cause uncertainty in the environment. The company should analyze these factors and see how the strength and interactions of general and specific forces change overtime in specific global locations. The global supply chain management must also be established to direct exchanges of raw materials and finished goods. The company must also look at from where the cheapest raw materials can be bought. In global environment, the raw materials could be bought from anywhere so they need to find the most efficient way to produce the snakes. It could be such that the cheapest way to produce snakes would be to move the manufacturing to another country. A lot of factors need to be analyzed such as tariffs on imports and exports, marketing costs, labor costs, production costs and other costs before the company decides to go abroad. Although one marketing method may work domestically, they might not work internationally. The company also needs to factor in local businesses in other countries that could help them sell and market the snakes.
Recommendations. Assuming the company can buy raw materials to manufacture the non-customized snakes at low costs and assuming there is high demand for them across the borders, the company should invest in mass production initially for the domestic market all over America to analyze if the product is profitable. If the company finds the costs of production to be very high compared to their selling price, the company may need to adjust their organizational strategy. If they are found to be successful, the company should initially duplicate similar methods abroad for selling the snake. Of the four strategies talked about, global strategy might be a better choice because the manufacturing would remain at home while they could still gather resources from around the world to lower costs.
Issue 3 – Critical Thinking
What are the issue and conclusion? The issue here is clear and stated in the first line of the paragraph; “who is the greatest director in the history of the movies?” The author provides many reasons as to why s/he believes that Stephen Spielberg is the best film maker ever. The author emphasizes that no one even comes close to Stephen Spielberg.
What are the reasoning fallacies in the argument? The argument is full of fallacies; in almost each sentence, there are no credible reasoning provided by the author. Using the approach provided by Browne and Keeley (2011), there have been several fallacies identified; one of them is “appeals to questionable authority” (p. 80) that is the author tries to use authority figure that might not have any expert knowledge on the issue at hand. In this case, the author uses “cousin Vinnie” who has seen more movies than anyone the author knows, but just by seeing more movies does not make one an expert in critiquing movies. Therefor Vinnie’s suggestion that Spielberg is the best film maker has no credibility. Next fallacy is “ad populum” (Browne and Keeley, 2011, p. 79) where just because majority of people favor a decision does not mean it’s the right one. Even though there is no reference to the claim that Spielberg has had six movies that were top grossing in their respective years, if it were to be believed true, that still does not make him the best film maker. Many people watch his movies but that doesn’t make him the best. Another fallacy is “ad hominem” or name calling (Browne and Keeley, 2011, p. 75) and is seen when the author suggests people who do not see Spielberg as the best film maker is an “idiot.” The author attacks others and appeals to emotions of readers by using such words as “idiot” or in other case “bogus.”
What is the value assumption? Value assumptions, according to Browne and Keeley (2011), are specific beliefs and preferences over another. In this case the author values movies that are more action packed, that include “cool special effects” and “fantastic adventure.” Clearly the author depicts other forms of genre to be boring as s/he describes them as “artsy” and “have subtitles.” The author values movies that have action and adventure more over movies that entice emotional feelings and “make you think.”

References
Badaracco, J. (Host). (2002). Defining moments [Video file]. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.umuc.edu/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct =true&db=fsv&AN=2861c&loginpage=login.asp&site=ehost-live&scope=site
Browne, M. N., & Keeley, S. M. (2011). Asking the right questions: A guide to critical thinking. Boston: Pearson
Pearson custom resources, AMBA 610. (2013) Boston, MA: Pearson Learning Solutions. Jones, G. R. (2012). Organizational theory, design, and change (7th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, Inc.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Amba 610

...In one of my working place, my supervisor was very generous and very kind to the group members. He never created any pressure to anybody so that everybody worked with freedom. In my supervisor’s eyes group member’s mistake was a part of learning process. He always appreciates for completion of a part of the work. The group members like him a lot. In six months of my working time, one of the very expensive instruments broke down. Since the instruments broke, the samples had to go out in a contract laboratory for analysis. For analysis of samples, Hospital had to spend big amount money instead of earning money. It took more than month to fix the instruments to perform the tests again. However, my supervisor was fired in other instances that I did not know. But one thing I knew that the instrument that broke down was not maintained properly. At that time I did not know what “system thinker” is. After this online MBA class, now I noticed what eventually happened at that time. To my analysis it was a system failure. My supervisor was very kind to his group but he did not take care the whole system. He made a decision to send the sample outside for analysis which was a part of the temporary solution. If the instrument was taken care routinely as it was supposed to it might not happen. According to Reed (2006), “senior leader should see not only the parts of the system but also the whole picture.”In a similar voice, Seddon (spring, 2008) mentioned that “the system governs performance...

Words: 282 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Amba 610 Rubrics

...Grading Criteria - Individual Assignment Critical Thinking in the Legal Environment: Torts and Products Liability Objective 1: Apply models of critical thinking and systems thinking to address complex organizational issues. Objective 4: Analyze the link between ethics and organizational effectiveness Objective 5: Apply legal concepts in the business environment to managerial decision-making and implementation Competencies: Critical Thinking, Information Literacy/Research Skills, Communication Skills Assignment: Research the McDonald's and Pearson cases, and in 10-12 double-spaced pages compare and contrast the facts, law, and merits of the two lawsuits by answering the following questions. Include an introduction and conclusion in your paper. |Criteria |Exceeds Expectations |Meets Expectations |Below Expectations | |Assignment Questions | | | | |1. What are the facts? |Clearly identifies and explains a majority of|Generally correct in identification of |Does not correctly identify the relevant Facts. | | |the relevant Facts in each case. |the relevant Facts, but includes some |Important facts are missing and/or there are an...

Words: 1039 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Ki Exam Amba 610

...Knowledge Integration Exam Jeremy Thomas Gugliotta University of Maryland University College This case involving Angela has the ethical decision of what action to do is not that difficult to assess, using the information provided she must act accordingly within the parameters set forth by the law. Angela is a mid-level manager at a transitional pharmaceutical company who happens to be a widowed mother of 3, depending on her 80 thousand dollar salary from work. Angela has been very pleased to work for this employer due to their prestigious standings. The pharmaceutical company has just finished its second phase of testing on their new Ebola drug. The drug is a very important piece to the company and their strategic growth plan. One of the problems that the company must overcome is that of animal testing in an attempt to get approval from the Federal Drug Administration (FDA) to begin their stage of human testing. Without successful human testing their drug will never possess the ability to go on the market. Unfortunately for Angela her boss in a private meeting requested that she change her report to show false information, to a federal agency, to assist the company. This in fact is the issue that Angela is faced with, what to do? When her boss requested this, it puts Angela in a very hard position; lie and hurt the company, or tell the truth and possibly be punished by the company? In falsifying a report to the FDA, Angela would be committing a felony. The request of such...

Words: 2252 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Amba 610 Question 1 Week 4

...AMBA 610 Question 1 Week 4 University of Maryland University College 1. What are the differences in the design models? Compare and contrast the standard airline organizational functional structure model with the hybrid structure based on independent business units Functional Structure: • All functions report directly to a CEO (centralized authority) • People with the same set of skills are group together (individual specialization) • Characterized by horizontal differentiation • Peers in the same function can supervise each other (as per Jones, chapter 15) • Likely to develop norms to increase effectiveness and develop core competencies, and to use standards as a measure of productiveness. • As business becomes more differentiated, the functional model can develop problems with effective communication, measurements, locations, new customer groups, and strategic problems. Hybrid/Business Unit Structure: • Each “unit” reports to a manager, who is then responsible to the corporate center and CEO (decentralized authority) • People are grouped into “functions” according to market/customer demands, and work to achieve goals together (joint specialization) • Characterized by an increase in both vertical AND horizontal differentiation from the functional model. (vertical is 3 levels instead of 2, horizontal is 12 functional groups instead of 9) • Tasks are coordinated through mutual adjustment, with the different business units working together to increase efficiency...

Words: 466 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Amba 610 Knowledge Integration Exam

...VIDEO DOCUMENTATION SERVICE BUSINESS PLAN (SAMPLE) Executive Summary Safe Keeping has been developed through much research to address public concern with protecting their property. Owner John Walter worked in law enforcement for over twenty years, with the last five as a commander for the burglary unit of the Eugene Police Dept. Safe Keeping will go into businesses and private residences and make a video tape record of all the belongings in that business and residence. We will also act as a consultant in advising people on how they can better protect their property. All videos are strictly confidential and a copy of each will be stored in a vault at our business location. Start up expenses are $4,000 including the cost of a video camera. The start up costs are being financed by John Walter. Safe Keeping's target market strategy is based on becoming an attractive choice for businesses and private homeowners in the greater Eugene, Springfield area. Our target markets will be small to large businesses wanting documentation of their belongings for insurance purposes. Private home owners will also be targeted with the same services. We want to provide superior in customer service, security knowledge, and maintain the strictest confidentiality. There will be a simple but comprehensive website developed by an outside consultant, maintained by John Walter. The website will show what services we have to offer and what the associated costs will be. Owner John Walter will manage all...

Words: 6330 - Pages: 26

Premium Essay

Amba 610 Essay Week 1

...ESSAY WEEK 1 I worked as a teacher in a private Pre K School in Shreveport Louisiana for almost a year. Management, at where I worked, had started out as a solo entrepreneurship; then it grew into a corporate business. It was truly managed by the traditional way of management. Neither the employees nor the customers was happy with the way of management. There were supervisors, for group of classes, who worked for one manager for the whole school. Classes had children from age new born to five years olds. Also, before and after school programs were being held in the same organization. Working with kids is a very serious and challenging job, because it requires special talents. It can be very enjoyable but at the same time very stressful. Supervisors did not have any authority whatsoever, they were the ones dealing directly with teachers who had direct relations with children and knew the core of the problems and report to their supervisors. Supervisor were told basically to carry information from management to the teachers. Supervisors main task was to make sure the teachers were only doing what manager wants them to do and not otherwise. This system worked like a robot house. But children are not robots they do have different attitudes, needs, and learning abilities etc. Teachers and supervisor were feeling the pain and seeing what needed to be different around but they were not given freedom to do improve the quality in the organization. There were many different issues...

Words: 1017 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Amba 610 Case Study Wk 3

...Case Study: The Board Member’s Relative   The text of this case is presenting us with what, often, managers are confronted with: a dilemma, and how after all they have to struggle to make an ethically decision. This response to the conference will be approached in three different phases using two different methodologies or frameworks, and a set of questions accompanying the case study to evaluate and analyze the situation or issue presented in the case in order to make a reasonable judgment and how to proceed to make an ethical decision. The text to be analyzed throughout this discussion is “the Board Member’s Relative” case study (case). 1. Using Browne and Keeley methodology The basis for evaluating the case here is some of the steps (issue, reasons, value assumptions and conflicts or descriptive assumptions, significant omitted information, and possible conclusions) developed by Browne and Keeley (2012) in their book titled: Asking the Right Question: A Guide to Critical Thinking. -          What is the issue? What recommendation should be made? Ellie, the Purchasing manager is confused and confronted with this dilemma. -          What are the Reasons? There are many reasons why Ellie is confused about what to do. Doing the right, the ethical thing, or please her boss. The most important reasons are:          Camille’s Coverings is owned by a board member’s daughter.          Camille’s Coverings is expressly presented and its bid handed to Ellie by the CEO...

Words: 1762 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Amba 610 Individual Paper Assignment Essay

...How Does Establishing Not-For-Profit (501c(3)) Status Benefit the Marketability of an Organization? Abstract Every type of organization both small and large needs marketing to survive and continue in business. Even though marketing may not be the reason why an organization was established, it stands as the core of business behaviors. Any type of organization can become a not-for-profit organization, but why? Why compete with for-profit businesses or go through the hassle of becoming established with the IRS? Not-for-profit organizations continue to show growth in its market of the US economy, equaling or even rivaling with their for-profit counter parts. How Does Establishing Not-For-Profit (501c(3)) Status Benefit the Marketability of An Organization? A Review of the Literature Not-for-profit organizations (NPO’s) serve a very important role in society and thus, are often given a special status. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) is very selective when granting Section 501 status. Any organization can establish itself as a NPO, as long as it meets the metrics laid out by the IRS. The Section 501 status grants tax-exempt status within 24 different categories of organizations. (Andreasen & Kotler, 2008)     1. Are Not-For-Profit Organization Business Savvy? 2. What are the perceptions of Not-For-Profit Organizations? 3. How do Not-For-Profit’s differ from For-Profit Organizations? 4. Why become a Not-For-Profit Organization? This review of...

Words: 1916 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Amba 610 Cliffside Holding Company Critical Thinking Analysis

...Analysis Using Critical Thinking Model: Cliffside Holding Company Memo University of Maryland University College Introduction Amidst this barrage of information in today’s world, it is often difficult to make a decision and stand by it, assured that it was the most advantageous to all those involved. Fortunately, critical thinking is a tool available to assist in making well thought out decisions in the face of contradictory opinions and impulsive actions. In Asking the Right Questions: A Guide to Critical Thinking, Browne and Keeley (2013) explain that critical thinking is “reacting with systematic evaluation to what you have heard and read” (p. 4). They further assert that critical thinking “requires a set of skills and attitudes that are built around a series of related critical questions” (p. 4). By asking the right questions, we employ the skill of critical thinking to enhance what and how we process information. To examine the concept of critical questions, this paper will analyze a business document from Cliffside Holding of Massapequa using the critical thinking model outlined by Browne and Keeley (2013) in Asking the Right Questions. Analysis Mr. Anil Ravaswami, Vice-President (VP) of Human Resources (HR) of Cliffside Holding Company of Massapequa (CHMC), wrote a memo to CEO Cynthia Castle in response to her request for the evaluation of a proposal for a new leadership development program to be designed for Cliffside’s junior insurance executives (personal...

Words: 2691 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

The Manager in Organizations and Society Final Knowledge Integration Assignment

...AMBA 610 The Manager in Organizations and Society Final Knowledge Integration Assignment Spring I- 2011 Please read all instructions carefully before you begin. Failure to read and understand instructions could result in an unsatisfactory grade on the assignment. If you have questions about the assignment, contact your instructor. Don't wait until the last minute to read the assignment and clarify any questions you might have. If you wait until Saturday or Sunday night, your instructor might not be available to answer your questions at that exact moment. Include your responses to all issues in ONE document labeled with your last name and "final," -- e.g. "Smithfinal"-- and post in your Assignment Folder no later than midnight Sunday, March 6. Do not post a separate document for each question part. No extensions may be granted on this assignment, so be sure to submit it on time and check to make sure that the document you submitted is readable and what you intended to submit. Your final document should include ONE reference list at the end that includes all of the references you used in your responses. The reference list is required but will not count toward the allowed number of words. In addition to the reference list, you should cite sources in your text when appropriate. ------------------------------------------------- Please note that this is an individual assignment.  Any discussion or collaboration regarding the assignment constitutes a violation...

Words: 2498 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Final Exam

...to the reference list, you should cite sources in your text when appropriate. ------------------------------------------------- Please note that this is an individual assignment. Any discussion or collaboration regarding the assignment constitutes a violation of UMUC's Academic Dishonesty and Plagiarism Policy. Direct any questions about the assignment to your instructor. Be sure to base your discussion of these issues on the theories and principles in the reading you have done throughout this seminar. This is not a research project. The purpose of the assignment is to demonstrate your knowledge of and ability to apply the principles and theories discussed in the course materials. Do not consult sources outside the assigned AMBA...

Words: 297 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Free Range Food Case

...HOW FREE RANGE CAN MANAGE TO MAINTAIN ITS "ECO-FRIENDLY OPERATIONS INTERNATIONALLY Environmental concern has been the recent trend as more companies strive to go green in their operations and production processes. Not to be left behind in this great and powerful industrial revolution is Free Range Company, which was among the starters of this trend since one of its main objectives has always been social responsibility through concern for the environment.  Even as Free Range Company plans to roll out to new international markets in France, United Kingdom and beyond, the main question to ask is whether Free Range Company will be able to maintain its eco-friendly operations in the international new markets and how the company will achieve this. The answer to this question is yes, Free Range Company will be able to sustain its “Go green” policy through coming up with effective strategic plans at both functional and business level. The prospects can never be brighter than now for Free Range Company and others of its kind embracing ecofriendly operations. One of the reasons why Free Range Company will be able to maintain its ecofriendly policy is that it will be able to cut down on production cost, especially cost of energy. Going green means adoption of more energy efficient programs, for example cogeneration which involves using the heat of steam used in industries to first generate electricity before channeling it to other industrial uses. This may even form an...

Words: 674 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Planning

...AMBA 640 / AMBA 640 HYBRID COURSE MATERIALS ASSIGNMENTS Acme Mexico City and Application of World-Class Operations and Information Systems Management Techniques and Production Planning and Strategy for Toyota North America (Version 06/01/15) Background Information for Acme Mexico City Acme Home Improvements, Inc. was founded in 1982 in Raleigh, North Carolina, USA. By mid 2015, the company had 125 stores along the US East Coast from Florida to Maine. Its annual sales are currently ~$5,400,000,000 with $280,000,000 net income. The average store is about 100,000 square feet with an additional 10,000 square feet of outside garden center. The stores typically carry 40,000 different products from 5,000 vendors worldwide. Major US competitors include Ace, Home Depot, Lowe's, and TruValue. All four operate already in Mexico. 1 In the interests of seeking greater profits and buffering against downturns in the US market, Acme has determined to follow these and other competitors to Canada and Mexico. In the latter, it has established, in accordance with Mexican law, a joint venture with local interests, known as Acme Home Improvements de México, SA de CV ("Acme de México" or "Acme Mexico City"). (SA de CV = Sociedad Anónima de Capital Variable, a Mexican corporate form.) There are five major product groups within each Acme store: plumbing and electrical supplies, building materials, hardware and tools, seasonal and garden/yard items, and paint, flooring and wall coverings. Each store...

Words: 3105 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Case Study

...A Case Study Analysis: A Question of Loyalty Introduction This case study analysis describes Sam Adams dilemma, whether or not to give a favorable recommendation to the board of directors for his friend and former colleague Bud Wizer. Sam was told by corporate that Bud listed him as a personal and professional reference on his job application. This triggered emotional turmoil in Sam because his friend was allegedly fired for sexual harassment from his last position. Sam’s values and moral standards will be tested during this analysis. Will Sam be loyal to his friend and say yes, or will he be loyal to his company and tell what he thinks he knows? I will use Professor Badaracco framework, questions and test to analyze Sam’s dilemma and provide recommendations for what he may say to the board of directors. I will start by using question number one from Badaracco’s framework, which way of proceeding will get me the best net-net consequences? In this first step we are asked to explore the pros and cons of Sam’s ethical dilemma to determine who will win, who will lose and at what cost. As I create my list I see that the risks are significant. If Sam decides to tell corporate about the alleged Sexual Harassment information about Bud and the information is not true or proven, corporate may view Sam in a negative light. If he does not tell corporate and they find out later that he knew his reputation could be tarnished and the level of trust that corporate has for him now will...

Words: 946 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Asking the Right Questions

...Asking the Right Questions-11 Step Analysis Introduction “I know it’s good to be a critical thinker and to be able to ask lots of good questions, but I don’t know what questions to ask or how to ask them.” (Browne & Keeley, 2011) In our text “Asking the Right Questions: A Guide to Critical Thinking (10th Ed.) The authors explore the benefits and necessity for critical thinking as it relates to the process of asking the right questions to make an informed decision and conclusion to an argument. The authors Browne and Keeley (2011) give two different approaches that can be taken in order to achieve success in critical thinking; the Interactive approach which involves evaluation of what is being read or heard and the sponge approach which involves little thought because you are simply absorbing everything you read and hear. With a good combination of the two one can successfully go through the critical thinking process and ask and answer all the right questions. So what are the right questions? Browne and Keeley give 10 questions that create a stairway to successful critical thinking. I am going to go through the 10-question model and examine a Memo written by Ms. Mary Ford the Director of Human Resources of APEU to Mr. Hector Fuentes the President of APEU local No. 121. I. What are the Issues and Conclusions? An issue is a question or controversy responsible for the conversation or discussion. It is the stimulus for what is being said (Browne & Keeley, 2011). There are...

Words: 976 - Pages: 4