Premium Essay

Argument Against Transracial Adoption

Submitted By
Words 1064
Pages 5
19 years ago, a 19 year old Hispanic woman named Sasha realized she was pregnant for the second time. Her first pregnancy, two years earlier, had already caused tension in her family and she was even disowned by some of her relatives. When her parents found out about the second pregnancy, she was kicked out of the house and told to put the baby up for adoption. While this was happening, a Caucasian couple from Kalona, Iowa had been trying get pregnant with no success.
Through family and friend connections, a plan was set in place for the Caucasian couple to adopt the Sasha’s baby. Sasha’s mother was not happy about this. A Hispanic child should be raised by Hispanic parents. Some of the adoptive parents’ relatives were not happy either. White …show more content…
Since then, they have maintained their opinion on the issue. According to the NABSW in their latest position paper written in 2013, transracially adopted children are “disengaged from their cultural background [and] . . . denied the opportunity for optimal development and functioning” (Preserving Families of African Ancestry 4). Although this is true in some cases, there are many things adoptive parents can do to teach their children about their cultural and racial background and help them develop a racial …show more content…
That doesn’t mean there aren’t things I wish had been different. For the majority of my life, I lived in the primarily white town of Kalona, Iowa. Even though I always knew I was Hispanic, I wasn’t until high school that I truly realized what being Hispanic meant.
As I started college, I began to question my identity. Can I really call myself Hispanic if I didn’t grow up in that culture, I look “white,” and I don’t speak Spanish? I began to slightly resent my parents and even my birth mom for not giving me to a Hispanic family. But I realized that it’s not my parents fault. When I was adopted, my parents didn’t know many other people how had adopted transracially and they couldn’t get much help on the internet as it wasn’t as prevalent during that time as it is today.
Even though transracial adoption is becoming more of a norm in the United States, there is still a lack of resources for parents who choose to adopt transracially. In order to combat this problem, there should be free classes offered to adoptive parents in order to teach them the things written about in this paper. It is important for transracial adoption to be a positive experience for both the adoptive parent and the adoptee. Not only is this an important issue to those who are a part of a transracial adoption or those thinking about adoption, but I also believe that transracial adoption is one small, but important step in our

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Direct Contact and Its Impact on Challenges Facing Adopted Children- a Literature Review

...29 8) Bibliography………………………………………. 30 1) Abstract This literature review explores the concept of direct contact, and what impact it has on the challenges that face adopted children. It begins by discussing adoption, contact and the meaning of these concepts. The key findings are then analysed and discussed in correlation to social work practice. From the literature analysed it would seem that direct contact has a positive impact on the challenges facing adopted children. These include, identity development,attachment development and reduced feelings of loss. Recommendation for future practice and research; although there is much to be learnt from research that has been carried out to date, simple formulas and rules cannot be applied; decisions made around contact require case by case assessment of the risks and benefits. Furthermore, long term, large scale research needs to be carried out to examine the effects of direct post adoption contact on children’s lives as they continue to develop and their needs change. 2) Introduction Children in families formed by adoption have challenges, or ‘additional tasks’ (Neil,2002) to negotiate that do not concern families formed by birth (Brodzinsky, 1990; Triseliotis et...

Words: 8546 - Pages: 35

Premium Essay

Hrmt-200

...Letter of Transmittal 10thJanuary, 2013 Mr. Tajuddin Ahmed Course Instructor, HRM-370, School of Business, North South University Subject:Case report on ‘Wal-Mart Stores Inc: Dominating Global Retailing’. Dear Sir, We are truly privileged to have you as our instructor in HRM-370: “Managerial Skills and Development” and we are pleased to inform you that, we have been able to meet the schedule to complete the case analysis on “Wal-Mart Stores Inc.: Dominating Global Retailing”. We have tried to employ our best knowledge to analyze the case as meticulously as possible and it sure had offered us the opportunity to enhance our knowledge in regards to HRM-370. Furthermore, if you have any queries about the case report, please feel free to ask any of the group members for further cooperation. Sincerely Yours, RonikaKarmaker | (ID#111 0750 030) | | TanjiaHaqueNirjhar | (ID#111 0137 030) | | Sunny Isnain Hassan | (ID#103 0692 530) | | Ankur Chandra Kuri | (ID#102 0831 030) | | SaifuddinZiku (ID#103 0157 030) ________________ Table of Contents Executive Summary 3 Background …………………………………………………………………………………..4-13 Needs Assessment …………………………………………………………………………..14 Main Issue ……………………………………………………………………………………….16 Internal/External Needs Assessment…...………………………………........18-29 Existing Arrangements.………………………………………………………………..24-36 T&D Plan …………………………………………………………………………………….37-42 Proposed...

Words: 11980 - Pages: 48

Free Essay

The Martian Child by David Gerrold

...to know about children. For a moment, I was actually looking for the folder labeled Martian. "He thinks he's a Martian," Ms. Bright repeated. She was a small woman, very proper and polite. "He told his group home parents that he's not like the other children - he's from Mars - so he shouldn't be expected to act like an Earthling all the time." "Well, that's okay," I said, a little too quickly. "Some of my best friends are Martians. He'll fit right in. As long as he doesn't eat the tribbles or tease the feral Chtorran." By the narrow expressions on their faces, I could tell that the caseworkers weren't amused. For a moment, my heart sank. Maybe I'd said the wrong thing. Maybe I was being too facile with my answers. The hardest thing about adoption is that you have to ask someone to trust you with a child. That means that you have to be willing to let them scrutinize your entire life, everything: your financial standing, your medical history, your home and belongings, your upbringing, your personality, your motivations, your arrest record, your IQ, and even your sex life. It means that every self-esteem issue you have ever had will come bubbling right to the surface like last night's beans in this morning's bath tub. Whatever you're...

Words: 14333 - Pages: 58