I’m trying to figure out if Adnan is guilty or not, but i’m stuck. I’m in a pickle. There is evidence that makes it seem like Adnan killed her, but there is also evidence that proves he didn’t do it. Adnan says he didn’t kill her, but his friend Jay says he did. Adnan is mainly in jail because of the story Jay told the Police. There was no physical evidence that Adnan killed Hae besides a couple fingerprints and Jay’s story.
The state used Adnan's religion against him in court. Adnan was Muslim so there was no dating, no drinking, and no smoking. Adnan broke all of those rules. Adnan lied and hid that he had a girlfriend from his parents. The court thinks that if he could lie about not having a girlfriend he could lie about not killing her. Since Adnan kept secrets and told lies the state is using that against him in court. The state also labeled him as bipolar. They thought that maybe when they broke up he got furious and killed her. There was no physical evidence to prove that Adnan killed her. The only so called evidence they had was Jay’s story. …show more content…
They weren’t best friends, they only hung out when they were smoking weed. In Jay’s story, that he changes multiple times, he said that him and Adnan went to the mall. At the mall Adnan apparently said to Jay “I’m going to kill that bitch!” Jay at first took it as a joke, but later Adnan left Jay with his phone and car to go kill Hae. Jay tells the police that Adnan called Jay and told him to come pick him up at Best Buy. When Jay got to Best Buy Adnan showed Jay Hae’s body that was in the trunk. After that Jay drives Adnan back to track practice, so that people could see him there. On the way to track practice Adnan was bragging to Jay about how he killed her with his bare hands. After practice they go to Jay’s house to get shovels. They dug a six in hole that took about twenty minutes to bury Hae’s body in. That was Jay’s story. Adnan says that none of Jay’s story is