...Critical Argument Analysis Essay ENG/215 1/26/2015 Jennifer Rainville | Immigration Control Introduction Illegal immigration is a big problem in the United States. If you ask around where you live you will get so many different views and arguments. Realistically immigration has resulted in the laws having more illegal immigrants live and work here in the United States. I have read three different articles on the pros and cons of illegal immigration. Immigration is becoming a normal thing in the United States and it shouldn’t be. Summary In the article “Let Us Give Thanks to Our Immigrants” by Rupert Murdoch, he shows some evidence to support his agreeing with illegal immigration. He shows support on how they have contributed to the education in America. Whereas in the articles “The Winners in Immigration: Public Prisons,” by Aubrey Pringle, and “Republican Views on Immigration,” by RepublicanViews.org shows support on why immigration is not good for the United States. Murdoch shows that many of the high paying jobs in the United States are held by immigrants or children of immigrants. Whereas Pringle and RepublicanViews.org shows that our government is suffering because of all the illegal immigrants in our country. Argument Murdoch is pro-immigration. He has provided evidence to show why he supports immigration. He also was an immigrant himself and all his family was from Scotland. He does state though that these days it’s hard to talk about the benefits...
Words: 1059 - Pages: 5
...In today’s world we face a big problem. The ongoing problem is what are we going to do about illegal immigrants. According to Oxford English Dictionary, immigration is “the action of immigrating; entrance into a country for the purpose of settling there” (OED). Immigration is a very hot topic in the United States today. There have been many debates and discussions about the issue in regards to if immigration is beneficial to our country or if it’s not. There are millions of illegal immigrants in the country today. Many people think that these immigrants area big problem for our economy and other factors of the government. In reality these people have been doing the opposite. Immigration is all over the country and you have more than likely encountered some before. Immigration is a very important topic for a reason. The United States has been running well because of it but then again these immigrants are stealing many Americans jobs to an extent. There are many positive benefits that come from immigration. These include an increase in demand, more investment, increased operation, and more jobs being taken (Nadadur 1041). These all affect the economy of the United States in a positive way. Demand for jobs is increased because of the incoming flow of people that are looking for jobs. They come to America with the intent of getting a good job and being able to support their family. These jobs might not always be the best jobs but they still get to do more than they could at homeland...
Words: 1059 - Pages: 5
...Illegal Immigration and Border Policy In recent years, Illegal immigration has been a contemporary political and social debate. It has been the platform of many politicians, especially in the southwest, and it is often a popular subject in news media. People in favor of strict immigration policy often claim that illegal immigrants are costly to the American economy and that they take American jobs. The border control policy is ineffective, it is often too costly for its effectiveness. Border policies have increased the number of immigrant deaths in the deserts of border states. Not only that but the US/Mexico border is harmful to the environment. The anti-immigration policy that's currently in effect goes against a rich cultural history in North America. Lastly, popular arguments made for strict immigration will be brought to light. In 2006, George W. Bush signed H.R. 6061, also known as the Secure Fence Act, in an attempt to increase border security and expand the US/Mexico Border. Prompted by heightened national security measures after 9/11, the bill was designed to "help protect the American people" and marked " an important step toward immigration reform" (Bush 2006). The bill doubled funding for border security, increasing expenditures from $4.6 billion in 2001 to $10.4 billion in 2006. This money went to "[authorize] the construction of hundreds of miles of additional fencing along our Southern border" and to "[deploy] thousands of National Guard members to assist...
Words: 1810 - Pages: 8
...In the Opposing Viewpoints Article “There Is No Evidence That Illegal Immigrants Take Jobs from Americans” it reasons that illegal immigrants do not take away or steal jobs from Americans. Illegal immigrants take jobs that most Americans will not do, but many use that fact as evidence that illegal immigrants do take jobs away from Americans. Another argument that many opposers make is that if illegal immigration is downsized, more jobs and higher wages will appear for those with legal status or citizenship in the U.S. Although that may bring a good argument politically, it does not mirror the truth of America’s great work market. America itself is a diverse nation. Almost anywhere you can find any person from any country working wherever because that’s one of the great things about the U.S. No matter if you have legal status or not, you can work almost anywhere. Also, immigrants tend to boost employment effects in the long term. Immigrants rise employment rates, create new jobs, and have a positive impact in America. I agree the article’s argument....
Words: 585 - Pages: 3
...Immigrants in USA The effects immigration had on the American political institution. American politics changed greatly as lots of immigrants began on their quest for a better life in America. With many immigrants coming to American, politicians started seeking out ways to win the support of the immigrants as they were potential voters in upcoming elections. In the midst of immigrants coming from every part of the world, politicians began addressing major events from countries substantial immigrants came from. Many immigrants began running for public office because they would be supported by members of their own ethnicity. With larger quantity of voters, many immigrants were successfully elected into public offices. Immigrants were a key feature of commercial and industrial growth of America. Without Immigrants, America would be majorly impacted as many immigrants are working the jobs that many Americans don’t want to do for low wages. If immigrants were gone, much of the food we need to survive would be gone as many farmers would go bankrupt having to pay high wages to workers. The United States immigration law/policy doesn’t reflect American political values. The immigration policy takes away the rights of immigrant’s equal rights and opportunity to become citizens of our great nation. With this law/policy many citizens of different ethnicity are discriminated as being illegal immigrants when they are actually citizens of this country. Takes away rights of immigrants to...
Words: 928 - Pages: 4
...In other words, this bill would mean that certain illegal immigrants who qualify would be able to receive permanent residency in the United States of America in as little as six years. Qualifications include: be of good moral character; having arrived in the United States before age sixteen; be between the age of twelve and thirty-five at the time of bill enactment; and most importantly, have lived in the United States for at least five consecutive years prior to the bill’s enactment. This last point is of importance since it serves as one of the key arguments proponents use when arguing for the DREAM Act, more on that...
Words: 1642 - Pages: 7
...v. Doe The Supreme Court case of Plyler v. Doe in 1982 was the argument between a Texan Superintendent of the Tyler Independent School District and the Supreme Court dealing with one of the illegal immigration issues in Texas with considering its bordering location to Mexico. The issue was whether or not the Fourteenth Amendment protected illegal aliens and their children to have school funding provided for them, or if they were not considered to be the implied people whose rights were protected under this clause. Plyler's case was about how the state should not fund schooling for illegal immigrant children. Especially since they most likely do not contribute their money for state taxes like other legal Americans which, in return, help fund the school system. Therefore, the school district was trying to charge the undocumented immigrants an annual $1,000 fee for tuition in order to compensate for the lost state funding. One of the arguments supporting this idea was how easily people can cross the Mexican border, and how they are drawn towards the idea of free education. I personally believe that they made this idea portray that these illegal immigrants were purely taking advantage of the free education because...
Words: 562 - Pages: 3
...Another popular claim by proponents of a closed border is that immigrants are criminals and therefore will increase the crime rate and so the American borders should be closed to them. On the contrary, reports have shown that immigrants are less likely than native-born Americans to commit crimes. Jacob Stowell et al. found that areas where large numbers of immigrants were present, crimes in these areas were reduced (Stowell, Messener and McGreever). The Cato Institute in his report entitled, “Criminal Immigrants: their Numbers, Demographics, and Countries of Origin” comes to the same conclusion as they found that immigrants were less likely than native-born Americans to be incarcerated (Landgrave and Nowrasteh). These facts do not change that Americans believe the rhetoric that immigrants are more likely to commit crimes. In fact, most already...
Words: 1243 - Pages: 5
...Representatives proposed an immigrant reform bill addressing border security, legalization of the undocumented, interior enforcement of immigration laws, and fixes for our dysfunctional legal immigration programs” * Where was the bill introduced? The bill was introduced to the Homeland Security Committee Who proposed the bill and why? The bill was proposed by Chuck Schumer .this bill make it possible for undocumented immigrants go achieve a legal status and also to make the borders secure. * What would the bill do if passed? Where are the people that it would affect? If this bill passed it would improve the border and add more border patrol agents .the people that would be affected are people who live in Texas. * How does it aim to affect illegal immigrants? It aims to affect illegal immigrants because it would be hard to travel to the United states * How might it affect the government? It might affect the government in a neutral way. Because of the amount of money for them to go through the process and in a good way if they pass ithe bill it would dimish the crime rates the United States. * How might it affect other citizens? It might affect other citizen by keeping them safe, because some of these illegal immigrants can be violent. * What are the arguments for the bill? What are the arguments against it? The arguments for this bill would be that This bill should be passed for a better enlargement of the U.S economy. For example: Immigrants from Mexico crosses...
Words: 439 - Pages: 2
...people have made bold decisions against it like California is having a law against Asians that aren’t naturalized not being able to own any land. Other laws trying to make laws that open up new opportunities for immigrants. I believe that there should be a law for and against immigration or a compromise between the two completely opposing sides. You see all over the news about gangs and people who are posing threats to society. I believe that if an illegal immigrant is found and he is posing a threat to society, he can be thrown in jail, prison, or be deported depending on how bad the crime they committed was. For all of the illegal...
Words: 514 - Pages: 3
...Corporate “Citizen” Ian S. Davis Webster University Abstract A small, but observable amount of undocumented immigrants come from Asian countries, primarily south and eastern Asian countries. Pew statisticians place that number at approximately four percent (475,000) of the undocumented population (Batalova, Terrazas, 2010). According to Tony Choi, a South Korean illegal immigrant who has been in the United States since he was 8, “Many Asians consider schooling, and life in general, in the West as superior to that in their home countries. Moving to the United States, particularly in pursuit of better education, can be part of an upward strategy for many South Koreans who later become unauthorized immigrants” (Lim 2013). Choi and his family came to the United States during the financial crisis of 1997 due to his father’s failed business. Often documented immigrants come for educational purposes but do not understand the visa program, and apply for a tourist visa which runs out very quickly. They end up staying ignorantly beyond their authorized time in pursuit of a better education and employment opportunities. One of the largely overlooked aspects of the North American Free Trade Agreement is how the trade pact catapulted illegal immigrants over the borders in record numbers. A flood of highly subsidized corn inundating the Mexican market has exiled millions of rural farmers. Prior to the enactment of NAFTA, Mexican bureaucrats claimed that manufacturing jobs would...
Words: 2225 - Pages: 9
...The pivotal topic of national security is also thoroughly discussed in Border Fencing Is Crucial to Ensure American Security. The article states that America’s borders are largely unprotected and penetrable, which can lead to dangerous criminals seeping in and wreaking havoc in our nation. The article also goes on to discuss that border fencing is essential to the efforts to combat illegal immigration from foreign countries in order to protect the citizens of America. The author claims that border protection has proven to be an effective method to handle illegal immigration with verifiable results (Duncan Hunter, 2007). This argument ties into the fear that amnesty would cause the administration to decline in the implementation of border security...
Words: 287 - Pages: 2
...the arguments have become more intense. Whether it was a warm or cold welcoming, the idea of immigration has continued to occur. Although the essence of immigration started centuries ago with Mass Migration, the excessive overflow of immigration peaked at Ellis Island in 1907, with about 1 million immigrants being processed. Today, the 2000 U.S. Census Bureau accounted 12 million illegal immigrants currently residing in the country. By 1925, Ellis Island became known as the primary detention and deportation-processing center. According to the Congressional Budget Office there are a number of reason whys immigration has continued for so long. For example, immigration is known to reunite families by admitting immigrants with families that are currently in the United States. Further more, our country admits specific skilled workers for their own benefits and protects refugees that are already in danger in their own country. The most important reason why immigration is currently progressing in the U.S. is because the idea of diversity is important. Now, there are three different types of admissions, Permanent, Temporary, and Illegal Immigration. Permanent admissions contain lawful permanent residents along with aliens with green cards. The next type of admission is Temporary admission for it allows immigrants to come into the country for a specific purpose. or tourism. They come on a work visa that is not eligible for citizenship through naturalization. Lastly we have Illegal admission...
Words: 1615 - Pages: 7
...1.Find a bill relating to illegal immigration. It must be current or have been considered within the past year. 2.Research the bill. You may find this Activity helpful in conducting research. Find answers to the following questions: What is the bill's title and description? Where was the bill introduced? Who proposed the bill and why? What would the bill do if passed? Where are the people that it would affect? How does it aim to affect illegal immigrants? How might it affect the government? How might it affect other citizens? What are the arguments for the bill? What are the arguments against it? 3.Imagine you will be giving a speech to Congress or to the state government considering the bill. Write a speech where you explain the background of the bill (answers to the research questions in Step 2), and then take a position on whether the bill should pass or not. Be sure to give facts to back up your opinion. This is a formal, informative, and persuasive speech, so be sure to write in the third person (do not use "I think" or "I believe" or similar phrases with "I"). 4.Cite the sources of your information in MLA Format. Include this bibliography with your speech when you submit it to your instructor. 01.02 What Is Citizenship? (Honors Extension) The bill, titled to provide discretionary authority to an immigration judge to determine that an alien parent of a United States citizen child should not be ordered removed, deported, or...
Words: 555 - Pages: 3
...citizenship we are inviting illegal immigrants to flock to our country for a free citizenship incentives. As closing proposition I would like to deconstruct the opposition’s arguments stating that EVERY SINGLE ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS CHILD SHOULD BE GRANTED CITIZENSHIP. I would also like to crystalize my opening proposition’s remarks and in addition, construct some new arguments and offer some solutions. Granting citizenship to the children of illegal immigrants makes illegally crossing into America a goal Well over 300,000 babies are born in America EVERY YEAR to illegal immigrants. These parents sneak into America illegally. Totally ignoring our laws that we as LEGAL citizens are obligated to uphold. Totally undermining our citizenship by taking advantage of the benefits that America offers, all while not paying taxes and not adhering to our government. How do we punish these criminals? By granting their children immediate and full citizenship. They are afforded every benefit America has to offer. Food stamps, well fair, public education, healthcare, and every other government program we have. They almost will certainly be using these benefits because as an illegal immigrant you are not permitted to work in the US. It’s easy to see why immigrants are sneaking into America: if they establish themselves with a legal citizen baby they are afforded a better life here by taking advantage of our generous government. If we stop giving every baby born to illegal immigrants citizenship, we would...
Words: 1194 - Pages: 5
