Free Essay

Behavior Model of Personality

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By arasnic
Words 1655
Pages 7
Singer’s Moral Guilt T
PHI 208
January 7, 2013

Peter Singer’s goal in “Famine, Affluence and Morality” was to try and to get people all around the world to realize that they, as human beings, have a moral responsibility to help other human beings in need if they can. He argues that the way we view moral issues and our moral conceptual schemes need to be altered, and in fact the whole way in which our society takes our way of life for granted. Peter Singer’s argument is that “if it is in our power to prevent something bad from happening, without thereby sacrificing anything of comparable moral importance, we ought, morally, to do it”. (Singer, 1972). He believes that everyone in similar circumstances as himself should give as much as possible, up to the point that they might also be at risk of poverty themselves. He argues that if everyone in society all across the world did this, that the world would not only solve the Bengal crisis, but would also end world hunger all together. That also by not contributing to helping people suffering from tragedies we are not being morally responsible as a race to our “global village”. Counter points to Peter Singer’s argument that he makes are as follows: First he states that the view that he has taken on the Bengal crisis and world hunger may seem “too drastic a revision of our moral scheme”. (Singer, 1972). That in fact people would not judge other people in the way that he suggests they should, that they would save their judgment for people who actually violate some moral norm, such as theft, murder, etc. Society would not condemn a person who indulges in unnecessary luxury or material items instead of giving to famine relief. Singer’s response to this counter-point is that giving money to a relief fund or charity is considered charitable but is not looked down on by society if you do not contribute to an effort. A charitable man is praised but a man who contributes nothing is not condemned, he argues that this way of looking at the matter cannot be justified. He uses the example of a person who buys clothes to look “well dressed” instead of staying warm, should instead use that money for the relief because they are not sacrificing anything significant if they continue to wear the old clothes instead of purchasing new ones. A second counter-point Singer makes is that it is sometimes thought that overseas aid should be the government’s responsibility and that by giving to a private charity, it allows the government and noncontributing members of society to escape their responsibilities. This counter-point seems to assume that the more people who contribute to a privately organized relief fund, the less likely it is the government will take responsibility for any aid. Singer on the other hand believes that the opposite will actually happen. He makes the point that it is more plausible that if no one will voluntarily give help that “a government will assume its citizens are uninterested in famine relief and would not wish to be forced in to giving aid”. (Singer, 1972). He also makes the point that unless there is a definite certainty that by not helping private relief funds, that would bring a massive government contribution. Everyone should give now to end any type of suffering. Singer’s last counter-point is that some might believe that until there is effective population control, giving to the relief fund will only save Bengal refugees now and postpone the starvation of future people and children in the area. Those who support this idea often cite facts about the population explosion and limited scope for expanded production. Singer’s rebuttal for this, as he previously states in arguments for other counter-points is the belief that people do not want to end suffering now in fear of the outcome in the future. He goes on to point out that one cannot absolve themselves from any obligation now for fear of future outcomes. He also reiterates his position from earlier arguments, which one ought to be doing all one can to help the relief, that if this was the case, one could promote population control thus ending famine. Singer’s concept of marginal utility, is an idea where he proposes that “I and everyone else in similar circumstances ought to give as much as possible, that is, at least up to the point at which by giving more one would begin to cause serious suffering for oneself and one’s dependents.” (Singer, 1972). This idea supports his argument by saying, if everyone gave so much to the point if they gave anymore they would be worse off than the people they are trying to help, that this would end famine and everyone would be on the same level of marginal utility. Singer’s concept of duty and charity in his argument are vastly different from the normal views of what society might have pertaining to duty and charity. Singer believes that though society sees a person give money at his own leisure as charitable, until that person gives almost everything to the cause that this is not charitable. If that person can afford to buy things that person “wants” and does not actually “need” than that individual has not given enough to help others. By doing this, that person can potentially keep someone from starvation rather than buying material items the person does not actually need to survive. Singer describes charity as something that is “good to do, but not wrong not to do.” (Singer, 1972). Society does not condemn people who do not give to the fullest potential or at all, but praises the ones who do give. Singer notes that in an article written by J. O. Urman, Urman explains that duty is something that society tells us what we must do, versus what would be good to do and not wrong not to do. Singer concludes that this is most likely the present division between duty and charity. He also says that the moral attitudes are shaped by the needs of the people in the society. Even though most of society has some moral views on violations of normal moral standings such as killing, stealing and so on within itself, he argues that it is just as morally important to prevent the starvation of millions of people elsewhere in the world even though they are outside of one’s immediate society. Singer further expresses his point about duty and charity by quoting Decretum Gratiani saying “The bread which you withhold belongs to the hungry; the clothing you shut away, to the naked; and the money you bury in the earth is the redemption and freedom of the penniless.” (Singer.1972). My personal opinion on Peter Singers argument falls somewhere in the middle of his position. Though I have a strong moral view on helping others in need, I do not feel that Singer has the appropriate attitude or even a realistic idea of helping people who suffer from famine. First, it offers no evidence supporting the idea of marginal utility, instead he gives the reader a moral guilt trip. I find it a hard argument to stand behind that if people across the world were to give up everything they possibly can to others, this would solve the world famine issue. Everyone being on the same level of poverty will result in no one starving, personally does not add up to a solution for me. As Al-Noor Nenshi Nathoo explains in his article, “In the thirty odd years since Singer first published his seminal paper, the idea of addressing poverty exclusively through direct transfers of resources as a means towards the goal of long-term development has been largely dismissed as potentially destructive, disrespectful of the dignity of poor peoples, and, ultimately, ineffective”. (Nathoo). My second argument against Singers position is that we all are morally obligated and in fact it is our duty to do the most we can and give as much as possible to the relief and if we do not, we are doing something that is morally wrong ourselves. I feel very strongly about helping people in need and I would never want anyone to suffer from famine, but it seems Singer would anyone with the ability to give up everything they worked for without question. It does not seem logical to me to go to such extreme lengths without knowing who I was helping and just how I am helping this person. Dale Jamieson points out such problems in his article “Nor are those who suffer in famines always passive victims struck down by the fickle finger of fate. They are often agents in highly complex political struggles. Those who suffered most in the Ethiopian famine of 1983-1985 were ethnic groups hostile to the government or involved in the civil war”.(Jamieson) Now this may just be one example but Jamieson goes on to explain that famines are usually never caused by nature alone, they are often the outcome of a crumbling economy, political struggles and war. It seems to me that just because you cannot or choose not to completely donate your entire life to someone who you have never met and did not cause the outcome of their situation, does not make you any less moral than someone who might have.

References

Singer, Peter (1972). Famine, Affluence, and Morality. Philosophy & Public Affairs Vol 1 pp 229-243

Jamieson, Dale (2005). Duties to the Distant: Aid, Assistance, and Intervention in the Developing World. The Journal of Ethics 151-156

Nenshi Nathoo, Al-Noor. (2001) Rationalized Selfishness or Reasonable Skepticism?
Objections to Singer and Unger on the Obligations of the Affluent. Retrieved from http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=Al-Noor+Nenshi+Nathoo+&btnG=&hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C36

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Personality Traits

...Personality development theory Evelyn Harris Psych/504 4/1/2013 Tracy Maceillo Personality development theory This paper will serve as a fact sheet and will answer questions pertaining to the gene environment and interaction influence personalities, personality expressions in cultures, twin studies, temperament, and the characteristics of constancy over a period of time. The term personality was originated from a specific place and is exponentially more complex although there are some assumptions when developing theories on personality alone. Any type of behaviors that are produced by a conscious choice is known as a free will or forces that are deemed as determined by a person’s control. In my opinion, free will expressions are contrary to the power to choose their actions and the extremity of influence in factors of heredity is none other than influenced by environmental factors. The term personality was originated from a specific place and is exponentially more complex although there are some assumptions when developing theories on personality alone. These factors are learned behaviors in which plays a significant role in the predetermined role of personality traits. For instance; if I do not follow good eating techniques I am most likely to contract high blood pressure and diabetes like my grandparents, aunts and uncles or possibly heart disease like my mother. For these reasons it can definitely be assumed that we as human beings do have free will and the choices...

Words: 1442 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Behavioral Models of Personality

...Behavioral Models of Personality Critique Draya Ashlee Ashford University Abstract This paper explores my knowledge and opinions on the Behavioral Models of Personality (BMP). This article will show the various theories of BMP present Behavioral Models of Personality Critique Personality is the combination of characteristics and qualities that mix together to form an individuals very distinctive character. The ability to have an perfectly untainted personality may be unheard of, and for many may sound ridiculous. Different models of personality help us to categorize the different aspects of one’s personality, how a personality problem can be recognized, and how to effectively treat an personality illness. I will critique the behavioral model of personality by looking at the theories present , the major contributors to the field, the different methods of inquiry , along with the strengths and weakness of the model , and how possible future research may be done to further elucidate the role of this model in understanding personality. The behavioral model of personality closely focuses on the “emphasis on studying what is observable challenged psychology and` personality researchers to meet higher empirical standards.” (Magnavita, J.J. 2012). Such observable events that occur inside of the human mind, which are acted outside of the human mind , better known as our actions. It is usually based on inductive thinking...

Words: 772 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Personality and Illness

...FIVE MODELS OF THE PERSONALITY-ILLNESS CONNECTION 1 Researchers use models to study the relationship between personalities and health which focus on how specific variables influence one another (Wiebe & Smith, 1997). According to Larsen and Buss (2008), the variable related to stress is considered a subjective internal feeling, which generates a response to events that are perceived “uncontrollable and threatening” (p. 589). Therefore, the level of distress, rather than by the type of event one has experienced is examined in relation to ones own individual personality. An early archetype that explores the relationship between personality and stressful events that affect health is the interactional model. The way in which a person copes with events and the impact these events have on an individual directly relates to personality. This model indicates that coping skills are related to individual personality. If a person with type A personality became infected with a virus and has not slowed their activity level to allow the body to recover, this person could become very sick. In this way, the duration and intensity of a stressful event or illness is related to how one copes. Although stressful events are destined to occur, "personality factors determine the impact of those events by influencing people's ability to cope" (Larsen, Buss, 2008, p.589). In later research, psychologists became aware that the interactional model has...

Words: 680 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Consumer Pschology

...Rebecca Zellner Professor Joseph Ben-Ur MKGT 4311-Buyer Behavior Exercise in Consumer Psychology 1. Describe, define and explain all relationships between all the systems in Freud’s theory. According to Sigmund Frued analyses, human personality consists of three interacting systems: the id, suger ego, and the ego. These elements of personality work together to create complex human behaviors. The id consist of primitive and impulsive drives impelled by the pleasure principle consisting of basic physiological needs such as thirst, hunger, and sex which the individual seeks immediate satisfaction without concern for the specific means. For example, an increase in hunger or thirst should produce an immediate attempt to eat or drink. The id is established in early life such as an infant that is hungry, he or she will cry until the demands of the id is met. However, immediately satisfying these needs is not always realistic or logical. If we were ruled entirely by the pleasure principle we might find ourselves indulging or participating in wrongful behaviors not thinking of the outcome. In comparison the super ego is conceptualized as the individual’s expression of society’s moral and ethical codes of conduct. The super ego’s role is to ensure the individual’s needs are met in a socially acceptable fashion. Lastly the ego is the individual’s conscious control. The ego’s role is to monitor and balance the impulsive demands of the id and the sociocultural constraints of...

Words: 2077 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Developmental Psychology

...Developmental Psychology examination questions Extended responses questions identify how the different elements of emotion - expression, recognition, and regulation - develop across the lifespan Human psychology throughout the lifespan is exhibited through the three important elements of emotion, which include; emotional expression regulation of emotional experiences emotional recognition This essay will discuss each of the three elements in the following life developmental stages referring to biological evidence and well know developmental stages referring to biological evidence and well know developmental theorists where appropriate. The three life stages in this essay will be infancy and childhood, adolescence and adulthood. Emotional expression is a key aspect of learning in which the individuals recognizes how to apply emotions that are socially appropriate and in keeping with the emotional development of that person. During infancy, the use of facial expressions is a key means of communication to establish biological needs. For example crying when to be fed or laughing when defecating. At this stage of infancy usually about the first months of birth, key cognitive functions to express emotions such as smiling is reflexive, independent of external stimuli. With the advancement of age of 2 - 3 months this reflexive motor is replaced by social smiling, typically when the baby sees his or her caregivers face. From the ages of 4 - 5 years, emotional...

Words: 2241 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Personality

...Introduction Personality is defined as the consistent pattern of emotions, thoughts and behaviours that define a particular individual as well as the psychological mechanisms that bring about such aforementioned tendencies (McShane, Olekalns, & Travaglione, 2013). It also refers to individual reactions and interactions with others hence, it is an inner psychological feature as Hiriyappa (2012) describes. This predisposition explains behaviours and attitudes of employees hence a core determinant in organization behaviour as Kumar, Bakhshia and Rani (2009) explain. Personality results from an amalgamation of nature and nurture factors. In the latter, innate qualities such as brain and hereditary factors, determine personality forms. In the former, brain stimulation aspects that define personality occur through genetic transmission (Parikh & Gupta, 2010). In the latter, genetic and molecular structures found in chromosomes, determine individual personality. Nurturing factors that determine personality are sourced from personal experience, behaviour and empiricism. Physical factors regarding a person’s appearance define one’s personality when interacting with others (Jennifer & Gareth, 2008). The culture of societies determines its members’ personalities particularly on aspects of interaction, cooperation and coordination in relationships. Religious and cultural factors also shape up personalities. This is because norms, regulations and convictions determine individual...

Words: 1562 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Personality Paper

...concept is the idea that behavior learned through watching others. This term is coined observational learning. Social-Learning theory, in contrast to Behavioral theorist , do not believe that reinforcement is responsible for all learning. In fact Social learning theorist Albert Bandura extended research which not included social learning but also included behavioral and cognitive learning to be incorporated. This was the main reason to which some refer to social learning theory as social-cognitive theory. Social- Learning Theory also assume an individual's behavior, environment and personal qualities influence one another. Social-Learning theory believe that optimal observational learning can be acquired through three model. One of which is live model, in live model an actual person is demonstrating the behavior. The next model is verbal instruction. In this model the individual is instructed in detail the behavior and how to engage in that behavioral. The last model is symbolic, influences in this model includes television, radio, movies, internet, literature etc. As well in the model fictional or real demonstration of the behavior. As well Bandura believed that there are steps in which modeling process involved. The first step is Attention. In Attention one must pay attention to the behavior that is being modeled in order to learn. The second step is Retention, here one must be able to recall details from the modeled behavior, especially if behavior is to be learned and to...

Words: 908 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Together Nature and Nurture Shape Human Behavior.

...determines human behavior has been going on for many years now, is it nature or nurture? The broad scope of human behavior has compelled researchers across various fields to systematically analyze what compels individuals to act the way they do. Is human behavior encoded in genetics or does it evolve by way of individual experience and environment. Through the review of recent empirical data across these various fields it is clear that both nature and nurture plan an important role in the development of human behavior. Subsequently multidirectional models have emerged with a mounting emphasis on how nature and nurture act independently in addition to collectively each forever shaping the other. Together Nature and Nurture Shape Human Behavior. The discussion concerning the appropriate significance of genetics and environment in human behavior has been around for quite a long while. This topic has generated massive attention, throughout the years, gaining numerous supporters on both sides of the debate. This attention essentially, has lead to some of the most remarkable psychological discoveries in recent years. The terms nature and nurture can be traced back to13th century France, expressed by Francis Galton in 1874 (Nature versus nurture, 2011). The term nurture in refers to the manner in which behavior is shaped by culture and environment. It builds its foundation on John B. Watson's theory of behaviorism, which suggests that human behavior is learned...

Words: 1898 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Health Problems

...The multifunctional model is a model that recognizes the multi-fractural nature of health and illnesses. It is not as clear or simple that illnesses are caused by a single factor. It has been found through research over the years that a number of factors, as how the different factors relate to and determine both illness and health issues in people. A number of factors makeups the multi-factorial model like the environment, different stressors, social cultural traits, and behavior. These ranges of factors include problems and different forms of stress in and out of a person’s control. There may be many factors that cause illness like genetic, family upbringing, traumatic events, and life experiences, all of these factors can have a positive or negative effect on a person. Some people can also create illness depending on the person's reactions and coping abilities. With any disorder, there are many factors to consider. Behavior Personality and behavior figure in a large number of health issues in people. The factors are seen in a large number of death’s the can be prevented in the United States alone. First cigarette smoking is one of the leading causes of preventable illnesses and diseases; According to Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2010) in 2009 the CDC reported more than 443,000 deaths from smoking and second-hand smoke combined. The CDC also reported the nearly 46 million people in the United States smoke despite the risk factors like cancer...

Words: 1129 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Essay

...What is Personality? -Pattern of psychological characteristics (traits) that differentiate us from others and lead us to act consistently across situations -Know the defense mechanisms be able to identify which defense mechanism the person is using -If a person is having a problem, be able to identify which stage that person developed that fixation. Personality consists of traits • Traits: relatively enduring predispositions that influence our behavior across many situations Example: extroversion, conscientiousness Lecture Overview • Development of personality – Psychoanalytic theory – Cognitive-behavioral approaches • Measuring personality • Causes of personality differences Freud’s Psychoanalytic Theory Beginnings: Clash between mind and body – Freud initially believed in mental disorders were somatogenic (lookup) • BUT 2 important observations that made him think perhaps this is not the case – Glove anesthesia – Hypnosis treatment for “grande hysteria” involving reports of patients traumatic experience of catharsis, disappearance of symptoms • Freud concluded mental disorders were psychogenic Core Assumptions of Psychoanalytic Theory 1. Psychic Determinism All thoughts and behaviors have a cause (no randomness) 2. Symbolic Meaning All thoughts and behaviors have meaning Ex. Male accidentally breaking chalk while writing 3. Unconscious Motivation We cannot fully understand why we do what we do Reasons for actions are beneath our conscious...

Words: 1296 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Cognitive Personality

...Cognitive Personality Approach Introduction Psychology definition is the study of the human mind and human behaviors. It is an theoretical discipline and is applied science in which seeks the understanding of individuals and groups by establishing overall principles, along with researching specific form of cases. There are many different approaches to psychology such as humanist, behavioral, and cognitive. One must understand the cognitive approach before truly understand the cognitive personality approach. Cognitive psychology “is the scientific investigation of human cognition, that is, all our mental abilities – perceiving, learning, remembering, thinking, reasoning, and understanding”(Lu & Dosher, 2007, p. 1). As the term ‘cognition’ comes from the Latin word “cognoscere”. Cognitive psychology is the study in which how people obtain and apply knowledge or information to their everyday lives. It is a modern form that includes a set of new technologies in the field of psychological science. The study of human cognitive is traced back to Aristotle De Memoria in Hothersall in 1984. The overall concept of cognitive psychology began with the cognitive approaches to psychological issues in the late 1800’s and early 1900’s with the work of Wundt, Cattell, and William James. It claimed the first half of the approach during the 20th century with the behaviorism approach in cognitive psychology. Within this dissertation it will be covering different aspects of cognitive personality...

Words: 3109 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Week 4 Paper

...Personality Analysis PSY/ 405 April 29, 2013 Dave Brueshoff Personality Analysis In this paper I will compare and contrast dispositional, humanistic and existential theories of personality. I will also give the basic underlying assumptions of each of these approaches to personality and analyze the characteristics to each of these theories. I will also explain the interpersonal relational aspects that are associated with these theories. According to aboutpsychology.com Humanistic theories of personality stress the basic goodness of human beings and the need to achieve one's full potential. Learn more about some of the major humanistic theories of personality. Comparing and Contrasting When looking at the humanistic and existential theories of personality these theories the individual on a holistic sense. Humanistic and existential theories and dispositional theories are all similar because they all search for an understanding the importance of behavior based on the individuals personal perception of life. All these theories focus on conscious decision making, free will and abilities. According to Abraham Maslow he looked at the humanistic approach to personality as taking full advantage of opportunities available to them and explores new ideas that would improve their life. Maslow also believed that there are many opportunities to people but first they have to be self-actualized. Maslow referred to these qualities in those who are self-actualized, as B-values (Feist...

Words: 1295 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Aggression: Biological or Learned

...Aggression is any hostile behavior by an individual person that inflicts physical or psychological damage onto another individual. It can take on a physical form, such as physical acts of violence. It can also take on psychological forms, such as verbal threats or verbal abuse. There are many different theories which aim to explain how aggressive personalities are developed. Theorists who adhere to the Biological Approach to Personality believe that genetics play a large part. They argue that there are biological indicators which make certain people more prone to aggressive personalities. They argue that aggression is not necessarily inherited, but certain predispositions pared with certain factors in an individual’s upbringing can spawn aggressive adults. Theorists such as Albert Bandura believe that personality characteristics such as aggression are learned. According to the Behavioral/Social Learning Approach to Personality, individual personalities are developed through observation and experience. Specifically, aggressive personalities are learned much like other behaviors are learned as a child grows and experiences different things.Research has shows that children predisposed to violence and aggression grow up to be aggressive adults.   Aggression, as defined by Merriam-Webster is “a forceful action or procedure (as an unprovoked attack) especially when intended to dominate or master” (Aggression, 2012). It is “hostile, injurious, or destructive behavior” that can vary in terms...

Words: 1215 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Origin of Baptist

...Faster speed, offline reading, and more. Last edited 3 days ago by an anonymous user Personality psychology Personality psychology is a branch of psychology that studies personality and its variation between individuals. Its areas of focus include: Construction of a coherent picture of the individual and his or her major psychological processes Investigation of individual psychological differences Investigation of human nature and psychological similarities between individuals "Personality" is a dynamic and organized set of characteristics possessed by a person that uniquely influences his or her cognitions, emotions, motivations, and behaviors in various situations. The word "personality" originates from the Latin persona, which means mask. In the theatre of the ancient Latin-speaking world, the mask was not used as a plot device to disguise the identity of a character, but instead was a convention employed to represent or typify that character. Personality also refers to the pattern of thoughts, feelings, social adjustments, and behaviors consistently exhibited over time that strongly influences one's expectations, self-perceptions, values, and attitudes. It also predicts human reactions to other people, problems, and stress.[1][2] There is still no universal consensus on the definition of "personality" in psychology. Gordon Allport (1937) described two major ways to study personality: the nomothetic and the idiographic. Nomothetic psychology seeks general laws that can...

Words: 12161 - Pages: 49

Premium Essay

Dispositional and Learning Theories

...Personality Analysis: Dispositional and Learning Theories Analysis of personalities helps to give a better understanding for human behaviors and the process in which people learn. Theorists have worked for years discovering new theoretical approaches. Gordon Allport studied the personalities of individuals because that approach gave more definition to individuality and emphasized the uniqueness of the individual (Feist & Feist, 2009). Describing an individual with general traits only classifies people as a group. However, Allport believed to accurately know a person is by knowing the person as an individual. Individuality makes people different, no one person is the same; because people have different personalities the abilities to learn will be different too. Albert Bandura’s social cognitive theory observes the manners in which people learn. Observational learning allows people to learn without performing actions or tasks (Feist & Feist, 2009). Basically people do learn from direct experiences but also learn from observing various tasks and actions by others. Most important the factors that give the answers to questions can be found through these forms of research and development. Dispositional Theories and Personalities Allport began his research of individual psychology by introducing his morphogenic science. Morphogenic science is the study of an individual, gathering information, and important data about the individual. Allport’s approach to personality theory...

Words: 1454 - Pages: 6