Premium Essay

Behaviourism

In:

Submitted By booga
Words 640
Pages 3
Differences between Psychodynamic and Behaviourist Approaches
Assumptions - The Psychodynamic Approach assumes that it is our unconscious mind, that we have no direct control of, that produces our behaviour. The Behaviourist Approach assumes that it is our past learning history that determines our behaviour, as Behaviourism assumes that all our behaviour is learned.
Methodology - The Psychodynamic Approach tends to use Case Studies to investigate the cause of our behaviour. The Behaviourist Approach tends to use Experiments, but has the tendency to gather data using Observation, this is because of the importance Behaviourism places on observable behaviour.
Scientific Approach - The Psychodynamic Approach takes a very idiographic approach. That means that a lot of the information has been interpreted by one individual and has not been objectively measured. The Behaviourist Approach, on the other hand, tends to use an objective, scientific approach, where behaviour is directly observed by an independent observer..
Reductionism - When something as complex as human behaviour is explained by the Psychodynamic and Behaviourist Approaches, they each simplify human behaviour in terms of their own approach. The Psychodynamic Approach explains human behaviour in terms of unconscious motivation, and the Behaviourist Approach explains it in terms of the importance of learned behaviour.
Determinism - When looking at the factors that are thought to control human behaviour, the Psychodynamic Approach tends to suggest factors involving our unconscious mind, whereas the Behaviourist Approach suggests factors arising from our learning history.
Therapy - The Psychodynamic Approach uses Dreams Analysis, which taps in to our unconscious mind, as a basis for therapy. The Behaviourist Approach uses Aversion Therapy, which is only interested in 'training' the person to change

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Behaviourism

...1. Introduction – What is Behaviourism It is well documented that behaviourism has had a significant role to play in scientific psychology since the early part of the 20th century. Before this period, early psychologists such as Freud focused on emphasising the importance of the unconscious mind and its effects on human behaviour. In these early days psychology had developed from philosophical studies, so the approaches used were similar to those adopted by the philosophers at the time. The main approach used the method of introspection, which tried to understand the mind through the analysis of an individual’s thoughts, feelings and experiences (Hayes, 2008). However, this approach was later criticised for its subjectiveness since one person’s introspection can differ from another’s (Gross, 2003) and that although introspection can reveal an individual’s private experiences it cannot be objectively measured or observed by others (Smith et al, 1998). The concept of behaviourism as a formal school of psychology was introduced by the American psychologist, JB Watson in 1919 (Carlson et al, (2000). Following a series of experiments he conducted on animals which included cats, dogs, monkeys and rats, he came to the conclusion that psychology should not be concerned with the mind or the consciousness. He suggested that psychologists should instead focus on the external observations on the behaviour of animals or humans in order to understand how the environment influences the...

Words: 1868 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Behaviourism vs Psychodynamic

...note), offers different approaches to studying and explaining behaviours, the main approaches includes, behaviourist, psychodynamic, cognitive, humanistic and biological. In this essay, two of the approaches (behaviourist and psychodynamic) will be discussed. There are two categories of behaviourism; radical which explain operant conditioning and classic or methodological behaviourism which explains classical conditioning. Watson (1913, 1919,) developed and popularised methodological behaviourism, while . . . as Morris (1988) recorded, Skinner's radical behaviourism start to be recognised within the academic folklore, in the late 1950s. Psychodynamic perspective was originally explained in the publication by Freud (1900) titled The Interpretation of Dreams, although there are many other psychodynamic theories based on Freud’s ideas (such as Jung’s, Adler‘s, and Erikson’s). This essay is purposed to highlight the similarities and differences between the two aforementioned psychological approaches (behaviourist and psychodynamic). Behavioural approach emphasises scientific study of only observable and measurable behaviours, responses and their environmental determinant. In behaviourism learning theory applies and it has a focus on human behaviour as primarily a function of experience (nurture) instead of biology (nature). To a large extent, learning theories have been the foundation of many applications of psychology. Skinner explained behaviour with his experimental...

Words: 1183 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Behaviourism vs Cognitive

...Assignment 1 Critically evaluate some of the central themes within psychology Behaviourism VS Cognitive This assignment will critically analyse two of the core approaches in psychology- Behaviourism versus the Cognitive approach. Behaviourists believe that all behaviours are gained through conditioning; conditioning occurs through interaction with the environment. Behaviourists say our responses to environmental stimuli shape our behaviour. If the environment surrounding us is altered- our thoughts, behaviour and feelings are also altered. Cognitive psychologists study the ways in which humans mentally process information. They study internal thought processes such as thinking, perception, language, memory and attention. The cognitive approach also looks at how we treat the information that we gain and what responses this leads us to have. Behaviourists say we are a product of our environment. They believe that we are born a blank slate and we can be manipulated whereas Cognitive psychologists believe we were born with cognitive functions like memory or perception. Behaviourists believe we all learn in the same way, therefore it is acceptable to associate results from experiments that are carried out on animals; with humans. This could also be seen as a downfall for the behaviourist approach as they do not anticipate any difference between animals and humans behaviour. Cognitive psychologists believe if they want to know how people think then they need to gain knowledge...

Words: 2382 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Theories of Behaviourism

...E-Leader Manila 2012 A Comparison of Two Theories of Learning -Behaviorism and Constructivism as applied to Face-to-Face and Online Learning Dr. Mary Anne Weegar Dr. Dina Pacis National University San Diego, CA, USA Abstract The two theories of learning discussed are Behaviorism and Constructivism. Skinner and Watson, the two major developers of the behaviorist school of thought sought to prove that behavior could be predicted and controlled (Skinner, 1974). They studied how learning is affected by changes in the environment. The constructivists viewed learning as a search for meaning. Piaget and Vygotsky described elements that helped predict what children understand at different stages (Rummel, 2008). Details of both theories illuminate the differences and connections between the behavioral and constructivist theories in relationship to how children learn and how their behavior is affected. How curriculum and instruction work with these theories to promote learning and how educators view learning with respect to both theories are also reviewed. Introduction Many students enrolled in institutions of higher education in the United States have had experience with both face-to-face and online classes. Educational researchers have begun to examine the technological characteristics of online classes which contribute to making online classes equivalent to face-to-face classes in relationship to their pedagogical effectiveness. The growth of online learning has changed the traditional...

Words: 5888 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Psychodynamis vs Behaviourism

...The Individual and the Society The individual and society is study of the relationship between an individual and the society and the process through which an individual learns about culture, norms and values of a society. This allows for integration and a sense of belonging. Each society has different values and norms which help to promote unity and coherence. Values are the things we regard as important, true and right. It may differ from individual to individual and also cultures and may be as a result of gender, beliefs and religion. In an African society, a male child is brought up to recognise he is a breadwinner and consequently taught the value of working hard to provide for his family, on the other hand education may be seen as wasted on a female child because she is meant to be provided for by her husband. In such a society education is not valued in females. Values change and evolve because today most societies have accepted the importance of education in both the male and female child. There are still some restrictions in some societies like in Saudi Arabia where women are not allowed to freely mix with men in the work place. Some of the change in values can occur from experiences in the secondary socialisation process. The change will allow for development, growth and modernisation. For instance a traditional Muslim male takes his wife to see a doctor for checkups will insist he wants a female doctor to attend to her. With time he begins to see the gap created...

Words: 3578 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Behaviourism V Psychodynamics

...Introduction: This paper is a Service Review for Mr Jo Smith, who has been reluctant to engage with his support network agency. Due to his reluctances i.e. resistance, engagement was crucial in initiating a review of the support Mr Smith was currently receiving. Recently, Mr Smith agreed to meet with the two support workers, Rae Mondi & Ena Shebelle, to begin the process of reviewing his support plan. Herein, is the report of that meeting. Initial Engagement for a Revised Service Plan Ena Shebelle and I, Rae Mondi, visited Mr Smith at his home. The realisation that Mr Smith had afforded us this opportunity moved us to inform him that, as part of his support network, the agency would like to review his current Service Plan in order to make improvements. We informed Mr Smith that although we have initiated this process we are required to seek and gain his permission to conduct this process. Mr Smith was hesitant, at first, but asked us to explain what the process involved. We explained the planning process, with special emphasis on his central role in the authorship of the contents and the methods deployed to implement the new plan. With his agreement secured we planned for our next meeting to reassess the current service plan as far his needs are concerned and how we can better support him. The meeting ended with Mr Smith informing us that he will try his best to be at the meeting, a week from today, at our Southport office. Reassessment of Service Plan The meeting...

Words: 1582 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Psychoanalytic Theory vs Behaviourism: Motivation

...Psychoanalytic theory vs behaviourism: motivation Freud's psychoanalytic theory with its model of the mind and its central concepts provides a better interpretation of one's behavior and accounts for behavior on a wider scope of issues than does the radical behaviorist theory of B. F. Skinner. Skinner successfully explains human behavior in terms of operant conditioning and reinforcing agents. He changes the focus from Freud's internalized (mental) processes to the importance of the external environment. Skinner emphasizes the importance of the directly observable behavior. However, he fails to completely account for behavior, excluding the original motivational drive. In contrast, Freud succeeds in construing the origins of behavior and motivation, which makes the psychoanalytic theory of Freud more adequate as a theory of personality. Throughout history humans have been puzzled by human behavior, the reasons behind it, and have been faced with the consequences of their own as well as others' behavior. Many studies have been done and theories developed in an attempt to explain this fascinating area of human existence. Among many theories and theorists, Freud's psychoanalytic and Skinner's radical behaviorist theories have been selected and looked at throughout the following paper. Theory of personality that Freud introduced together with its concepts, many deemed romantic, unprovable and sometimes obscene, has shaped the way humans view themselves in many cases...

Words: 2538 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Comparison Between Behaviourism and Psychodynamic

...2.1 Explain the role of the midwife in relation to other health professionals. There are many health professionals that work alongside Midwives. Each professional has their own unique skills that make them needed in this specific area. Doctors work closely with midwifes to a certain extent. Doctors are normally the first point of contact as they will confirm the pregnancy and will refer their patient to their local hospital where they will meet their midwife. As doctors are medical professional, if a midwife had a patient with a high risk pregnancy, the midwife would need to contact their doctor to have regular check-ups. A paediatrician are also another type of doctor, they are specialised in caring for babies and children. A midwife may ask for paediatrician assistance if they are concerned about any health issues related to the baby’s growth, development or any diseases that the baby may have. Midwifes may ask a social worker to help support pregnant women who have issues that are a cause of concern, for example: women suffering from domestic violence, drug abuse, live in poor conditions and young teenage mothers who may need help with housing and benefits. Social workers help give advice and guidance in areas where a midwife is not specialised in. A midwife may need an obstetrician assistance if her patient is needed to have an emergency caesarean section, has suffered with pre eclampsia and has placenta previa. Obstetrician are also another type of doctor that is...

Words: 1935 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Suggest the Significant Differences Between Behaviourism and Psychodynamic Approach to Understanding Human Behavior.

...the significant differences between behaviourism and psychodynamic approach to understanding human behavior. Suggest the significant differences between behaviourism and psychodynamic approach to understanding human behavior. Suggest the significant differences between behaviourism and psychodynamic approach to understanding human behavior. Suggest the significant differences between behaviourism and psychodynamic approach to understanding human behavior. Suggest the significant differences between behaviourism and psychodynamic approach to understanding human behavior. Suggest the significant differences between behaviourism and psychodynamic approach to understanding human behavior. Suggest the significant differences between behaviourism and psychodynamic approach to understanding human behavior. Suggest the significant differences between behaviourism and psychodynamic approach to understanding human behavior. Suggest the significant differences between behaviourism and psychodynamic approach to understanding human behavior. Suggest the significant differences between behaviourism and psychodynamic approach to understanding human behavior. Suggest the significant differences between behaviourism and psychodynamic approach to understanding human behavior. Suggest the significant differences between behaviourism and psychodynamic approach to understanding human behavior. Suggest the significant differences between behaviourism and psychodynamic approach to understanding...

Words: 261 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Behaviourist Assumptions

...It is from Ivan Pavlov’s (1849-1939) study of dogs that the behaviourist approach took the theory of classical conditioning. Behaviourism believes we learn to operate in our world by forming associations between a particular stimulus and the most appropriate behavioural response, stimulus response unit’s, which explains why we behave the way we do. Classical conditioning attempts to account for this through learning by association. Watson used this in his conditioning of his case study ‘little Albert’. He conditioned a baby to fear that which he previously had not by associating it with an instinctive fear. Watson was able to conclude from this that phobias are not a result of the unconscious, as psychoanalytic had believed, but were the result of conditioning. E.L. Thorndike’s concluded for his experiments on cats that there were two laws of learning; the law of exercise and the law of effect. The law of exercise stating that the more times a task is carried out the better we become at it; learning having taken place. The law of effect says that there is a link between our behaviour and its consequences. Thorndike showed we not only learned through Pavlov’s stimulus-response conditioned behaviours but also because behaviour has resulted in a positive outcome in the past. B.F. Skinner, influenced by Thorndike, contributed to behaviourism with the concept of operant conditioning. Operant conditioning requires a reward or unpleasant consequence during the learning process to...

Words: 747 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Nature Vs Nurture Vs Nature Debate

...against nature nor nurture; nor am I biased to one side. The psychological theories (e.g behaviourism, cognitive psychology, biological perspective) that augment their respective altercations, while valid and fundamentally true, can be misconstrued by others, since we all collect different experiences throughout our lifetime. We all (at some point in our lives) face the effects of nature and nurture to some degree—regardless of the impact. While it is true that some of us are raised with more nurture than nature (and vice versa), it may be erroneous to conclude we are solely one or the other. I view myself as someone who has been heavily influenced by nurture as many people I have met throughout my life have affected me in ways I never thought were possible; as a result, I am able to cognitively think about the friendships (nature) and make rational decisions as to what I should do. Incidentally,...

Words: 540 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Four Forces In Psychology

...In this assignment I will be summarising the theoretical thrust of the four forces in psychology which are natural sciences, psychoanalysis, transpersonal psychology and existentialism, phenomenology and humanistic psychology. I then chose to do the historical development and key principles of natural science otherwise known as behaviourism. Theoretical Thrust Natural sciences Natural science was about observing and experiencing. The way to understand experience was through colours, tastes, degrees of brightness, and contours but this was later on said to be wrong by Gestalt psychologists. Behaviourism was influenced by an article written by John. B. Watson. He stated that psychology must reject all reference to consciousness. Behaviourism...

Words: 832 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Psychodynamic And Socio-Cultural Perspectives On Learning

...During the past month or so, we have discussed several perspectives on learning such as Behavioural, Developmental, Psychodynamic, socio-cultural and humanist perspectives. Behaviourism has been an influential theory in educational psychology. Behaviourism was based on the belief that behaviours can be measured, trained and changed. Developmental perspectives is concerned with child development. Psychodynamic perspectives is concerned with the development of ‘self’. It is primarily a study of factors that may affect a child’s behaviour and development such as childhood experiences affecting emotions and behaviour as adults and the various conflicts throughout childhood that affect overall personality. Socio-cultural perspectives studies learning...

Words: 1089 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Behaviorists Explain Maladaptive Behaviour in Terms of Learning Principles That Sustain and Maintain It.

...“Behaviorists explain maladaptive behaviour in terms of the learning principles that sustain and maintain it. Discuss this statement and show how a behaviourist’s approach to therapy is in stark contrast to a psychoanalytic one”. I will begin my essay by describing the development of behaviourism. This will show how its roots are completely different from those of psychoanalysis. It will also reveal something of the methodology of behaviourism and the principles behind it. This will provide the ground for developing a fuller description of maladaptive behaviour and those elements that 'maintain and sustain' it. I will conclude by contrasting the positions of the Behaviourist and the Analytical Psychologist underlining the ethical issues involved. The first striking contrast between psychoanalysis and behaviourism lies in the fact that the former was developed in Europe in order to meet the therapeutic needs of patients while the latter grew out of the Progressive Movement (P.M.1880-1920) in the United States. This movement arose from three main sources: 1.The industrial revolution. 2. Scientific Rationalism. 3. Liberal political philosophy. The P.M. wanted scientific thinking that had created a new society so swiftly, to be brought to bear on every aspect of life. 'Progressives transformed, professionalized and made "scientific" the social sciences, especially history, economics, and political science’. (Wikipedia) According to the P.M. The...

Words: 2747 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Psychology

...•behaviourism-the study of behaviour in an objective way. •social learning theory/cognitive behaviourism •attachment theory •evolutionary theory •behavioural genetics •Piaget’s theory of cognitive development •Erikson’s theory •developmental systems Define and describe the following research methods •correlational study •experimental study •cross sectional study •longitudinal study Study Questions 1. Define cohort and briefly summarize at least one major difference in how different cohorts, past and present, are experiencing childhood, old age, and adulthood (pp. 5-9). Cohorts are the birth group we grow up with through life. The past childhood cohort was growing up in a time when there wasn’t terrorism, internet, and when a child would quit school to help his fathers business. Nowadays, children are exposed to the media, social cliques and must stay in school for the duration of there childhood years. 2. Summarize the impact of socio-economic status, culture and ethnicity, and gender on development (pp.9-12). In the developing world, people are struggling for survival and their living standards are very bad, while in the developed world, things are the opposite. Culture and ethnicity place a huge tax on the development of man or woman. There are many different types of culture and ethnicity based on our parents’ background in most cases. In a Collectivist culture, one might be accustomed to hiding his feelings and always allowing the...

Words: 1031 - Pages: 5