Premium Essay

Carlo Ginzburg's The Night Battles

Submitted By
Words 957
Pages 4
The history of witches has been exhaustively documented and analyzed, yet historian Carlo Ginzburg’s offering, The Night Battles: Witchcraft & Agrarian Cults in the Sixteenth & Seventeenth Centuries, is a remarkable standout. The book focuses on the Friuli region of northeastern Italy from the 1570s to the 1640s, a time when the Holy Inquisitions were in effect. Ginzburg is the first to explore the existence of the benandanti, or ‘good-walkers’, holy defenders of the harvest against the destructive forces of witches, as well as their historical influence. The benandanti offer a refreshingly positive twist on the relationship between Christianity and magic that is different from the typical cynicism of the Church . The Night Battles maintains that the benandanti exist as a concentration of previous widespread …show more content…
The first section of the book drew from court records detailing the bendananti’s existence, the next their roles in society, and the last their assimilation. This results in a concise chronological contextual narrative of information. A distinct example of this is that some interrogations include a benandante retracting previously self-positive statements and starting to add heretical elements to their nighttime escapades . Ginzburg’s documentation of the diffuseness of pre-benandanti beliefs was present, but his execution fell short. A whole interlude-like section of the book is dedicated to this argument, which then disrupts the flow of the first argument and serves as an almost nonsensical tangent. Funereal benandanti were used to connect the good-walkers to goddesses and their hordes, but their relevance and importance was otherwise neglected. This caused confusion, because without conciseness, the baseless argument overflows and feels too ambitious in nature to have been properly pursued as just a byline in The Night

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

The Night Battles and Peasants of Early Modern Europe

...The Night Battles Composing of most of the European population in the 1500’s and 1600’s, peasants played an important role in the development of Europe. In his book The Night Battles, Carlo Ginzburg gives a unique perspective on the lives of Friulian peasants through the analysis of inquisitorial records. During the inquisitions, peasants were categorized as witches or benandanti, which literally means well-farer. “The benandanti were a small group of men and women, who because they were born with a caul, were regarded as professional antiwitches. They told inquisitors that, in dreams, they fought ritual battles against witches and wizards to protect their villages and harvests from harm.” (Ginzburg. Back Cover) Although the lives of the benandanti were more exciting and dangerous, similarities do exist between ordinary peasants of early modern Europe and the Friulian benandanti. From the way they lived their lives and were uneducated, to the way they stuck together and were easily manipulated, the Friulian peasant and the ordinary early modern peasant share several characteristics. One of the major similarities between the benandanti peasants described by Carlo Ginzburg in The Night Battles, and the ordinary peasant from the early modern period is the importance of agriculture and farmland. Of the many characteristics that define a benandanti, perhaps the most reoccurring is that they are all defenders of their crops and farmland. The Friulian peasants revolved their lives...

Words: 893 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Gaspurotto Religion

...their lives centered on their nocturnal supernatural journeys. They believed that their spirits left their bodies and flew into the countryside, where they would do battle with malevolent witches who threatened the local harvests. In fact, it was part of their religious duty to defend their community from the wrath of the devil. This understandably confused the Catholic Church, who would begin to interrogate the...

Words: 1679 - Pages: 7