Free Essay

Case Study Analysis

In: Business and Management

Submitted By matty
Words 1921
Pages 8
Case Study Analysis Part A (“Power Play for Howard”)

James Carruthers, Matthew Chouinard, Amber Hawes, Mike Knowlton, and Shellie Mapes

MGT/445

March 21, 2011

Dr. Michael Charter

Case Study Analysis Part A (“A Power Play For Howard”) Every year, hundreds of millions of U.S. dollars are verbally tossed back and forth during negotiation talks between teams and players. The contract of a player expires and the player may be traded for another player, or essentially bought by another team. The value of a player greatly depends on (a) his playing power and (b) his fan base. In the case of Juwan Howard, a player for the Washington Bullets/Wizards, both his playing power and fan base made him a wanted player by many teams when his contract with Washington expired in 1996. Negotiations became heated, particularly between Miami and Washington, until a miscalculation in the negotiation terms resulted in Howard signing with Washington for another term.
Case Summary Juwan Howard was a professional basketball player in the National Basketball Association (NBA) and was looking to renegotiate his contract with his then-current team, the Washington Bullets. This would give Washington the first chance to make an offer. He had the option to renegotiate after 2 years and decided to do so. Washington's new general manager, Wes Unseld, made an original offer of 78.4 million dollars. This was not satisfactory as the open market had determined his worth much higher and many teams joined in on the bidding. The Miami Heat and Washington Bullets (among other teams) started bidding. Miami eventually outbid the others, making an offer worth over 100 million dollars. Howard accepted the contract and it appeared that he was to be a member of the Miami Heat. Problems arose when the NBA was informed by Alonzo Mourning (another player with the Miami Heat) that he too had been signed to a 100 million dollar contract. This is important because the Heat had not informed the NBA of this proceeding and also because the signings of both Howard and Mourning to those contract would far exceed the NBA's agreed upon salary cap. There were also other discrepancies, such as "unlikely bonuses" which were deemed likely by the NBA forcing them to add those numbers to their salary cap, which they did not do. Other rule violations were made by the Miami Heat as well that invalidated Howard’s contract. The Miami Heat's owner, as well as the president of the team Pat Riley, was upset with the move and both the NBA and the players union brought in arbitrators jointly. If the Heat were to be found liable, the league could void Mourning's contract, fine the club 5 million, suspend Riley for a year, lose draft picks and still not end up with Howard. Washington could resign Howard only if the NBA restored their “Larry Bird rights.” The provision, which was named after the former Boston Celtics star, allowed teams to exceed the salary cap in order to re-sign their own players. The Washington Bullets and Unseld lost their “Larry Bird rights” to Howard when they renounced his contract. But if those rights were renewed, the Bullets amount that they could spend on Howard would be limitless. Howard was declared a free agent. That was challenged by the Heat, but days later the Bullets' "Larry Bird rights" were restored and Juwan Howard was signed by the Washington Bullets.
Benefits

This was about to be one of the biggest moments of Juwan Howard’s professional basketball life. Howard’s agent, David Falk, was entertaining new offers from other clubs to secure a new, long-term contract for Howard. With several teams interested in bidding in his services, his availability created a bidding war - just the situation that Falk wanted in order to obtain the best deal for his client. Although Howard received interest from a number of teams, the Miami Heat and his own Washington team showed the greatest interest.

This bidding situation benefited Howard, as both teams had to outdo each other to land the contract. With Howard and Falk receiving multiple offers, they could establish higher goals, make fewer concessions, and be more selective with new offers. The ability to compare competitive offers will also give Falk an indication of how aggressive each team will be as Howard gets close to a final decision. This was defined as having the Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement, or BATNA (Lewicki, Saunders, & Barry, 2006). Identifying the best alternative to a potential agreement strengthened Falk’s ability to secure the best possible contract terms for Howard.

The Washington team used all their available resources to convince Howard to remain in Washington. Their initial offer did not impress Howard, as Falk had assessed Howard’s market value to be much higher than this offer. Washington attempted to leverage their current relationship, showing how adding other free agents would improve the team’s performance (Lewicki, Saunders, & Barry, 2007). By appealing to Howard’s sense of responsibility to his current team and community, Washington was asking Howard to consider the intangible benefits that only their team had to offer, hoping that money was not the only determining factor in Howard’s ultimate decision. This was an example of selective presentation, in which the negotiator presents only information that supports their case and differentiates them from others (Lewicki, Saunders, & Barry, 2006).

The Miami Heat established themselves as the aggressor among the teams vying for Howard. With Pat Riley, a four-time championship winner as their general manager, they could assemble an attractive offer that could appeal to Howard as both a player and an individual. As a team that was a perennial playoff participant, the Heat tried to show Howard that Miami was a place where Howard could achieve both his personal and professional goals. With Miami offering the most money and having a winning organization, Riley could be confident that they had the most to offer Howard when compared to any of the other teams. The Heat also showed willingness to accommodate any additional requests made by Howard, and those concessions could help eliminate other competitors in the race (Lewicki, Saunders, & Barry, 2007).

Costs

The precedence of NBA negotiations became heightened for the leagues top players in 1996 with many subsequent charges assumed beyond contractual agreement. Negotiating for players became much more expensive with the competition of a few key players. The case of Juan Howard, the Miami Heat, and Washington Bullets was one of the largest and most expensive negotiations as of 1996 (Lewicki, Barry, Saunders, 2007, p.616).

Juwan Howard was coming off of an initial contract with the Washington Bullets as a free agent after two years. The existing contract in Washington was for $37.5 million per seven-year contract and a free agent status after two years completion. Because Howard had proven his abilities both on and off the court, the Washington Bullets had some renegotiating to do or else lose their star player. The Miami Heat general manager had pulled out all the stops to negotiate for Howard. Howard experienced the plush luxuries intriguing the star player to feel at home in Miami. The costs between the general managers of Miami and Washington were not apparent but both teams spared no expense with attracting the attention of the star.

The legal expenses of gaining Howard on the Miami Heat were found to be more costly than anticipated. The Miami Heat exhausted compensation above the collective bargain agreement with the union and team owners’ agreements thus nullifying the Howard contract (Lewicki, Barry, Saunders, 2007, p.621). The legal expenses were not stated in the article but could be estimated at elevated levels due to the public status of the situation.

Howard ultimately received a resigning contract with the Washington Bullets worth $105 million excluding perks for a period of seven years. The costs for such contracts relevant to a team’s bottom line are expensive, but the rationales for such expenses are anticipated to generate new and larger revenues for the teams profit. Even though the negotiation was not intended to be so costly on the intent of Howard, the end result of renegotiating his existing contract proved to be a large raise exceeding expectations.

Risks

As with any negotiation, there are risks for all parties because each side wants what is best for himself and is not always willing to compromise. In the case of Juwan Howard, he had become eligible to be a free agent and wanted to continue playing basketball for the Washington Bullets. When he entered negotiations he was only concerned about what he would receive and had some high demands. He wanted a $100 million contract to stay in Washington and some perks such as a hotel suite and a limousine for transportation (Lewicki, Saunders, & Barry, 2007). The biggest risk Howard faces is not obtaining the contract with the Bullets that he wants and unfortunately that happens; however another team, the Miami Heat were also interested in him and take the steps to procure him by meeting all of his his demands (Lewicki, Saunders, & Barry, 2007). If another team had not been interested in him, Howard could have been out of a job or forced to settle for less money than he wanted.

The Bullets team managers had to assess the needs of the team and decide what would be beneficial to the entire team and not just one person. Because Juwan Howard was such a fan favorite, if the team’s management does not retain him the team could lose money because Howard’s fans may follow him to the new team. It had appeared that by not meeting Howard’s demands the Bullets had lost a popular player, however because the contract with the Heat came under scrutiny by the league and going to arbitration, Howard was able to return to the Bullets (Lewicki, Saunders, & Barry, 2007). Under new negotiations, the Bullets gave Howard the money he was demanding but thought it better to treat him the same as the other players in regard to the hotel suite and the limousine, the team’s management believed it better to not treat him better (Lewicki, Saunders, & Barry, 2007).

Conclusion The negotiation case study of Juwan Howard and the Miami Heat v. Washington Bullets/Wizards illustrated a number of important factors required in a successful negotiation. First, the need to outline the goals for the parties involved. Howard wanted to be paid what he and his agent felt he was worth; the teams involved wanted to supply their fan base, club, and team with a star player while limiting costs. Second, the importance of research prior to entering negotiations is addressed. Had the Miami Heat realized outright that it offered Howard an invalid contract term, time and money would not have been wasted on lawyers, negotiations, and communications. Thirdly, the weight of the risks, costs, and benefits is addressed for all parties involved. Each team had to consider what would be risked, the costs (in money and benefits), and the benefits should Howard sign or not sign; Howard had to determine his own risks, costs, and benefits per the teams’ offers. Ultimately, Howard was essentially forced to settle and sign a contract with his original team because research was not properly conducted by one of the vying teams.

References
Lewicki, R., Saunders, D., & Barry, B., (2006). Negotiation (5th ed.). New York, NY: McGraw Hill.

Lewicki, R., Saunders, D., & Barry, B., (2007). Negotiation: Readings, Exercises, and Cases (5th ed.). New York, NY: McGraw Hill.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Case Study Analysis

...Our Advantages & Disadvantages |Internal Advantages  | |Advertising - Social network, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Website, Radio stations, Global events, Television ads, Email, memberships,| |word of mouth, YouTube, Google, tumbler  | |Promotions - Loyalty cards, reward systems, | |Staff - Availabilities, customer service, RSA, flexible hours, training, work ethics, problem solving, team working, honesty, | |integrity, professionalism, create brand excitement through innovation   | |Attractions – Live music program, food and drinks, atmosphere, personalized booths, entertainment, celebrities, merchandise, late night| |business | |Food & Beverages  - Lunch, Dinner, Starters, mains, desserts, bar packages | |Entertainment - Weekly and monthly entertainment included local and international artists  | |Merchandise - Selling products in store collectables, clothes, accessories, online...

Words: 2230 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Case Study Analysis

...Case Study Analysis Numerous problems have arisen throughout the current employment process. As a result, This Study is an effort to analyze and determine methods to enhancement this complex procedure. From the facts gained, its believe that an absence of experience and proper planning, followed by inability to complete the entire task essential to hire new personnel in an appropriate manner. Carl Robins, a recruiter for ABC, Inc. with the company for six months, successfully hired fifteen write out 15 employees. He arranged orientation for new employee in June with the intent of having all the employees working by July. On May 15, Carl’s Supervisor, Monica Carrolls, informed him about organizing the employment issues, for example, training schedule, policy booklets, orientation, manuals, policy booklets, drug tests, and a host of other issues. He guaranteed all arrangements were complete in a timely manner. When reviewing the new trainee’s records numerous problems surfaced. For example, Robins witnessed incomplete paperwork was unfinished, not one trainee went to the clinic for mandatory drug test, and the trainee orientation manuals were piecemeal or had pages missing. Discouraged, Carl took a quick walk, returns to work, checks the scheduling of the training facility for use in trainee orientation, and discovered that Joe had reserved the room for the entire month of June from technology services. He comes back to his office astonished and puts his head down on his desk...

Words: 1120 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Case Study Analysis

...Running head: CASE STUDY ANALYSIS PAPER DRAFT Case Study Analysis Paper Draft University of Phoenix Essentials of College Writing COMM 215 Paula Moore March 02, 2009 Case Study Analysis Paper Draft While only three copies of the orientation manuals were found and several pages were missing from each, some new trainees did not have applications completed. Many of the new trainees did not have transcripts on file. Carl Robins which was the new campus recruiter also discovered that none of the trainees had taken the mandatory drug screen. The new hire orientation was due to take place June 15, Carl not knowing the training room was already booked for the entire month of June had a problem. Carl was very confused and frustrated not knowing what to do next. ABC Inc hired Carl Robins in early April as the new campus recruiter. Carl had only been on the job for six months. Being a determined individual he decides to hire 15 new trainees to work for the operations supervisor. Carl figured everything within the company was run correctly and all paper work should have been in place for the process of hiring new individuals. The training schedule consisted of, drug tests, orientation, policy booklets, physicals and tons of other issues. To begin this process Carl needed to go over all the necessary paperwork needed for the orientation beginning on June 15. The first problem found was some of the new trainees did not have applications completed or their...

Words: 1087 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Case Study Analysis

...Case Study Analysis Larry Dean Psy 322 June 2, 2014 April Ward Case Study Analysis When a company makes the decision to market their product or service to multiple cultures, they must be very aware of the intricacies and differences between each of the cultures. While some customs or traits associated with a particular culture are very overt or obvious, others may not be. Detailed analysis must be done to ensure that all of these traits have been considered. Failure to do so could result in a lack of profits at best and a negative hit to a brand name at worst. Two case studies give examples of companies attempting to market and sell their products and services in new cultures. Case One: Japan to Apple’s iPhone: “No Thanks!” When Apple unveiled its much anticipated iPhone to the United States the response was overwhelming. The iPhone broke new ground in smartphone technology with its touch display, 3G data network capability and internet-based applications and utilities. Apple enjoyed huge sales and revenue in the United States. Similar success was enjoyed when the iPhone was released in other countries around the world as well. Overall, the feedback was very positive. So when it came time to release the iPhone in Japan, analysts estimated a million sales. Revised estimates after the release, however, were a staggering 50% lower at 500,000 units sold. There was initially much confusion as to why actual sales were so much lower than what was initially anticipated...

Words: 1655 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Case Study Analysis

...Case Study Analysis COMM/215 July 7, 2014 Case Study Analysis The recruitment and hiring of new employees take experience, effective communication, and time management skills. Carl, who is new to his recruitment position, hit some roadblocks when he hired his first batch of recruits. This case study analysis will identify the key problems Carl encountered, alternatives to his current situation, and look at possible solutions so he may avoid these problems in the future. BACKGROUND Carl successfully hired fifteen employees for the Operations Supervisor in April. His goal was to have all the new employee files completed, have them oriented in June, and have them working by July. Carl was responsible for making sure the employee files were complete, scheduling the orientation and providing all written material for the new hires. When contacted by Monica, the Operations Supervisor, he assured her that everything would be arranged for the June 15th orientation. Just prior to June 1st, when Carl was going over his new trainee files, he discovered many problems that would affect his plan for his new hires to complete their orientation on June 15th. KEY PROBLEMS Carl’s lack of experience and time management is a key issue; it left him vulnerable to problems. Carl also failed to communicate effectively with his team members and his new employees. Carl encountered three key problems. The first problem found was that the files for the new employees were incomplete...

Words: 1171 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Case Study Analysis

...ABSTRACT This analysis of the information technology infrastructure at United Parcel Service (UPS) begins with a general overview of the company’s information technology (IT) environment to establish awareness of the size and complexity of this corporation. It includes a macro-level breakdown of the technology infrastructure of UPS ranging from the data centers to the PCs currently in operation. The study also more closely analyzes the software and database structure of UPS along with an analysis of the company’s E-commerce activities. It includes an interview with Tom Creech, the North Florida District E-commerce manager at UPS. Finally, research was conducted to evaluate the emerging technologies that UPS is implementing and employing to support the business strategy and maintain its competitive edge. INTRODUCTION A case study is a "published report about a person, group, or situation that has been studied over time." If the case study is about a group, it describes the behavior of the group as a whole, not behavior of each individual in the group. Case studies can be produced by following a formal research method. In doing case study research, the "case" being studied may be an individual, organization, event, or action, existing in a specific time and place. Case studies are analyses of persons, events, decisions, periods, projects, policies, institutions, or other systems that are studied holistically by one or more method. The case that is the subject of the inquiry...

Words: 3212 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Case Study Analysis

...Case Study Analysis Introduction On this case study analysis paper we will look at Car Robin’s facing major problem as the new recruiter for ABC, Inc. He had only been employed with the company for six months when he was promoted to this position. He just recently recruited fifteen new trainees; yet, it appears that his lack of experience, lack of communication, and lack of organization has led to several problems occurring before the new trainees are supposed to begin training. Prioritizing his actions he has to handle the situation in timely manner. If he can’t not handle it within the time span he will have to minimize the damage and finally, he will have to plan for these kinds of things not to happen in the future. Background Carl Robbins, a new campus recruiter for ABC Inc., was assigned the job recruiting new hires to work for the Operations Supervisor, Monica Carrols. He hired 15 new trainees to work with Monica. This was Carl’s first recruitment effort. Car had scheduled a new hire orientation, which was to take place on June 15. He wanted to have all of the new hires working by July. On May 15, Monica contacted Carl about the training process, orientation, manuals, police booklets, physicals, and drug screening which Carl would coordinate for the new recruits. Carl secures his boss that everything would be set in time. (University of phoenix material 2012) After Memorial Day weekend, two weeks for the orientation training, Carl finds that the applications...

Words: 1356 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Case Study Analysis

...and reflectively deciding what to believe or do. Critical thinking means making reasoned judgments. Basically, it is using criteria to judge the quality of something, from cooking to a conclusion of a research paper. In essence, critical thinking is a disciplined manner of thought that a person uses to assess the validity of something: a statement, news story, argument, research”. Critical Thinking plays a an important role in the case study analysis by giving us a foundation for a deeper learning and integration of the reading. Without thinking critically about what we are studying , we wouldn't be able to learn in a meaningful way or we wouldn't be able to learn deeply enough to have our thinking corrected and enhanced. The purpose of this case study analysis paper is to provide the case study background, identify key problems in the study, provide alternatives, propose solutions and offer a recommendation in the case of Carl Robins by utilizing the critical thinking skills. Background The case study presented in front of us is a case study of Carl Robins, a new campus recruiter for ABC, Inc., who in his first recruitment effort successfully hired 15 new trainees to work for Monica Carrolls, the Operations Supervisor (University of Phoenix, 2015). Carl Robins successfully hired 15 new trainees and scheduled new hire orientation date for June 15 with an intention and hope that the new hires would be readily eased into their job roles in the following month, month of July...

Words: 1606 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Case Study Analysis

...Case Study Analysis The success of marketing a product or service in other countries is affected by the product itself and consumer demand. According to Weber (2002), when marketers are looking to export their products or services to other countries they need to understand the consumer’s demands, expectations, and tastes in the region. Not all consumers feel and think the same way. For example, consumers in Hong Kong have different historical and cultural views than Mainland China, although they may have similar cultural values (Weber, 2002). Consumers within these two regions may have different preferences and environmental standards. The same could be said for Japan. Therefore, when marketers are trying to enter other regions they must understand the region’s culture and behavior toward a product or service. Marketers must also understand demand factors of that region, such as economic and social. Case one: Japan to Apple’s iPhone: “No Thanks!” Although technology is used all over the world, different countries can provide many challenges when trying to introduce new technologies to them. Apple found this out when trying to introduce the iPhone in Japan. According to Frommer (2010), reasons the iPhone was not successful in Japan was because Apple failed to understand what the Japanese consumer expected of an iPhone and the competitive marketplace. Although the iPhone is successful in the United States, many consumers in Japan believe the phone’s technology is old and...

Words: 1152 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Case Study Analysis

...Case Study Analysis Felix Cruz University of Phoenix COMM 215 October 25, 2012. Dr. Santiago Case Study Analysis My suggestions for Arthur to make this summer of replacements hires more successful than those in the past are pretty simple. But in order to obtain these suggestions we must review this case with details to see where the missing factors are. I pretend to review the case of Arthur Reed a warehouse supervisor of the Blue Grocery Stores. He had been in the business for over 20 years and he is in charge of the shipping dock, both first and second shift. The issue here starts when the company gets close to summer because apparently, most of his senior staff suddenly wants to take theirs vacations. The ones that do not get vacations trends to make call-ins related to sickness without any advice in advance which make this a stressful situation for Mr. Reed. This supervisor has to deal with these absences and personnel shortage situations in a daily and weekly basis. He had tried to implement different options such as replacing workers but unsuccessfully because of the higher cost for both the employee and the employer. In addition, we sum the fact that, it is hard to keep people in this job, especially since replacements were not guaranteed any minimum hours or given any benefits and they will be paid at $6 dollars per hour which is a very low rate compared to the higher cost of uniforms, steel-toed boots, and the payments for the union dues. After making...

Words: 1166 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Case Study Analysis

...Case Study Analysis Chevy Mae C. Duque COMM/215 Essentials of College Writing November 17, 2014 Linda Boyer Case Study Analysis After reading the problem that Carl is facing, I have concluded that it was a mere lack of preparation on his part that caused it. Even though it is only his first ever recruitment effort as a new campus recruiter, Carl should have taken specific steps to prepare. I don’t think it’s too late for him to fix the problem, he just needs to regroup with his new trainees and reschedule the orientation. It was early April; Carl Robins had only been working at ABC for six months when he first set out his recruitment effort and successfully recruited 15 new trainees to work for Monica Carrolls, the Operations Supervisor. He let his new hires and Monica know that the orientation will be on June 15, in hopes to have all the new hires to be working by July. Exactly one month prior to the scheduled orientation, Monica raised her concerns about the new hires to Carl regarding; training schedule, manuals, policy, booklets, physicals and drug tests. Carl assured her that they would all be arranged and ready in time. But it wasn’t until after Memorial Day, about one to two weeks after Monica’s reminder, when Carl decided to go over the trainee files to finalize the paperwork needed for the orientation. That’s when he found all the issues concerning his new hires, with only two weeks left until the scheduled orientation. Some of the new hires did not complete...

Words: 1077 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Case Study Analysis

...Case Study Analysis David Berwanger Comm/215 April 23, 2011 Gloria Reeves Case Study Analysis Even though very inspired, and goal driven, Carl managed to make a few mistakes that may have been avoided. These mistakes have now put him in danger of possibly not being able to put the new hires to work on time, which leaves the company is the same predicament of not having enough employees on the clock. Eager to prove that he was the man for the job as a Campus Recruiter, he hired 15 new hires and may have been able to get away with a fewer number of new recruits. He should have started by making sure that the current budget supported the salary for 15 new hires. Next, he should have looked at the company’s training schedule to confirm that the training room he wanted to use was in fact free to reserve. Now there is a group of people expecting to receive training and nowhere to train them. This kind of action on behalf of the company can cause employees to self-terminate their employment and seek gainful employment elsewhere. Once Carl scheduled everything, he should have been tracking things on a regular basis to make sure that everything was on schedule. Waiting until the last mine to ensure everything was in place cost a lot of valuable time in creating a contingency plan. In addition, he should have personally created employee files for each of the candidates and managed them personally until orientation was completed. If he would have checked earlier on the paperwork...

Words: 1240 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Case Study Analysis

...Case Study Analysis Majida Ismaili Alaoui COMM/215 November 25, 2012 Gretchen Treadwell The peer review process is a positive asset, and neutral tool. The benefit of the review, allowed me to pinpoint my weaknesses, and reinforce my strength in writing. The objectivity of the review, made me feel comfortable, and allow me to take the criticism from its positive side, therefore I will make a serious effort to rectify my mistakes and take in consideration my peers feedback. My reaction to the peers’ comments was positive as it helped me see the reader perspective to my work, which is a reflective mirror. In consequences, I reflected on the message I intended to send through this case analysis study. The peer review comments helped me mostly in accepting and to be open to other’s suggestions and feedback. Another positive aspect of this exercise is also acquiring the possibility to read and reflect on my peers work also and learn from their strength and weaknesses, so it is beneficial in both ways. The least helpful aspect in this review is that I wished that my peers gave me more palpable examples regarding what I should avoid and what I should reinforce. Carl the new campus recruiter for ABC, Inc., has promised Monica, the operations supervisor that he will deliver 15 new hires by June 15. Assuming that the process of hiring is as simple as he made it sound. These employees, according to Carl will be ready and capable to fulfill the company’s orientations. Carl is...

Words: 1740 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Case Study Analysis

...Case Study Analysis Introduction This case is about a man named Carl. He works for ABC Inc. He hired 15 new applicants. There was a list of tasks that he was given to complete for the new trainee orientation by June 15. Since he was new to his job and unexperienced, he was unsure of how to handle making sure the pre-employment paper work and screenings were complete. Checking to make sure that all the supplies needed were available and that the conference room wasn’t booked for the same time that he needed. What problems appear in this Case: In this particular case, there are multiple problems. First, there is the fact that Carl took on a big task without much experience under him. He didn’t plan ahead in case something happened. He scheduled orientation without making sure everything was ready to have an orientation. None of the applicants can go to a new hire orientation without completing the application process or a drug screen. He didn’t even make sure the training room was available be reserving it. Carl didn’t check to see if he needed to order new manuals. He assumed that the company had enough on hand. When he checked there was only 3 and each of them had numerous pages missing. Solution to problem: With Carl being unexperienced in hiring new employees, he should have asked for help from the start. If he would have asked for help, he most likely would have received it and it would not have been stressful. In reality though, he did not...

Words: 600 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Case Study Analysis

...After reviewing this case I was alerted of several things that went horribly wrong. The person having the problems, Mr. Robbins, unfortunately did not take the correct steps in setting up the new hire orientation; because of this, he has a mess on his hands. Possibly a case of taking on too much too soon, he has made a mess of his assignment. Firstly, he failed to ensure his paperwork was in order until it was almost too late, secondly he did not make sure that the meeting room was free and clear for him to use during the time he needed it. There were many ways Mr. Robbins could have avoided and prevented these issues from occurring and we’re going to discuss a few of them here today. In early April, Mr. Robbins recruited several new hires despite being one himself. He had found 15 prospective employees and was hoping to get them through orientation and working by June 15. Two and a half months time seemed like more than enough time to accomplish this goal. In May, the woman he was recruiting for, Ms. Carroll, called Mr. Robbins to discuss and instruct him on what she wanted done. Mr. Robbins insured her everything would be taken care of. Here is the first mistake Mr. Robbins made. He told Ms. Carroll everything would be taken care of and did not follow this up with action. He waited until after Memorial Day to pull files on the new hires. He should have ensured the new hires were up to par shortly after recruiting them. He did not make sure they had completed applications, mandatory...

Words: 1404 - Pages: 6