Free Essay

Catch 22

In:

Submitted By RebMc
Words 499
Pages 2
Catch 22
Mr. Secretary, By your request I have researched the directive known as Catch 22. After extensive research through various sources, I am now able to present you with the information I have gathered. I will first define the term for you then I will explain what I see as the best solution to your proposal of its reinstatement. A Catch 22 is essentially a paradox by which a statement leads to the contradiction of that very statement. The term Catch 22 was coined by Joseph Heller and refers to the US Army clause 22 which states: “All persons with mental issues should be removed from active combat upon request; however, requesting removal from active combat is a sign of mental stability as it is the self preservation function of the brain working.” An individual’s recognition of his mental state shows his cognitive ability to understand and value his own safety, therefore, making his mentally capable of the duties at hand. So you see, Mr. Secretary, the Catch 22 is a very assuming and entrapping clause that only takes into account one’s ability to recognize self-preservation. As defined above, the Catch 22 directive is an entrapment tool that was used by the US Armed Forces to avoid losing capable soldiers in a time of high stakes and world war. Mr. Secretary, I believe your interest in re-instituting this clause must have been stifled by the above mentioned; however, if you believe there is sufficient reason to press on with this proposal, allow me to curb your enthusiasm. Although there is concern about soldiers claiming mental issues to circumvent their duties, I believe Catch 22 is not the answer. The United States military is deployed worldwide for a global peace keeping force, not a repelling force for another militant giant. In this day and age we can afford to sacrifice numbers for safety. There are many brave men and women who are willing and able to serve the positions we need in our armed forces; we should have no qualms about releasing individuals due to mental instability. Safety is another reason I believe that re-instituting Catch 22 is a poor decision. The dynamics of the armed forces are based largely the ability to trust the individuals next to you. With this clause enacted, members of squadrons with affected members will be more likely to feel and ultimately be in greater danger than those without. We simply cannot ask on our soldiers to defend their country and peace abroad while there are individuals who are dealing with mental issues and endangering their colleges. With that being said, Mr. Secretary, you now see my stance on the issue of re-enacting the Catch 22 clause into the armed forces. I have provided you with enough information to make an informed decision yourself, but I do hope you use my above reasoning and ultimately determine that we are in no need of using the said directive.

With Respect,

student

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Catch-22

...Catch-22 “You wouldn’t be normal if you were never afraid. Even the bravest men experience fear. One of the biggest jobs we all face in combat is to overcome fear.”(ch. 9) In times where desperate times call for desperate measures, the novel Catch-22, writing by Joseph Heller, follows the life of a B-25 fighter pilot named John Yossarian, in addition to other members of his squadron. Yossarian is the key protagonist of the novel who finds a more important mission than the one assigned to him while in the air force, and this is to preserve his own life at all costs. Over the course of this novel, this young man finds himself stationed on a small island of Pianosa, off the west coast of Italy, in the Mediterranean Sea. Placed under the command of Major Major, and Major De-Coverley, as well as General Dreedle, Yossarian now finds himself faced with the predicaments of an overbearing and abusing bureaucracy, as well as the contemplation of sanity vs. insanity as his ticket out of this station. The theme to be best directed with Catch-22 is the unknowing between truth and falsehood. In addition to that, is the blind sight between who are really your friends, and your enemies. Joseph Heller presents a vast arrangement of symbolism in the novel. First and foremost being the man in the white cast at the start of the novel. When he was brought to the hospital, the other men viewed him in such a way that it was ignored that he was a man, but was seen more as a viewing...

Words: 876 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Utilitarianism In Catch 22

...In Catch 22, the other major characters in the book don’t act out of fear but rather what they believe is right, even though it may not be what everybody else thinks is right the character still does it because it’s what they believe is right, and this way of thinking is also applicable to the real world. In Thrasher’s “Democrats: don't try to work with Donald Trump. Just say no,” Thrasher talks about how the Democrats shouldn’t try and negotiate with Donald Trump but they should instead stand up and fight anything Trump tries to do. Thrasher believes anything Trump does or any act he tries to pass will only lead to the embarrassment of the country and he is calling for his fellow democrats to stand up and not just accept the policies and actions of Trump but they should try to fight his actions and policies because it’s what they believe is the right thing to do....

Words: 576 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Catch-22 Analysis

...The title Catch-22 means a contradictory course of action. Within the book, Catch-22 is used as a military rule. Basically, a pilot could be grounded from flying missions if the military deemed a pilot crazy. According to the rule, however, only a rational mind would be concerned for one's safety in the face of danger. Therefore, there is absolutely no way to for a pilot to become grounded, whether the pilot was sane or insane. There are a few other cases where this rule, Catch-22, is explained throughout the novel. The author sums it up best: "If he flew he was crazy and didn't have to; but if he didn't want to he was sane and had to." In Catch-22, a few of Joseph Heller's most important ideas that he is trying to convey are the absolute power of bureaucracy, the advantages people take in a free enterprise system, and the dehumanization of the pilots. The underlying idea that bureaucracy has total control over the war is evident throughout the novel. Throughout the novel we are told about the pointless missions Yossarian's squadron are forced to fly in. The commanding officers are risking the lives of their soldiers only for personal gain. The whole idea of people taking advantage of a free enterprise system is clearly portrayed throughout the novel. Throughout the novel, Milo is capitalizing on the goods that both sides need. He is taking complete advantage of the system and is making a fortune running a black market syndicate. He will even sacrifice his fellow American soldiers...

Words: 510 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Catch 22 Archetype Essay

...Catch 22: A Postmodern Archetype American author Joseph Heller is considered to be a part of the postmodern era of literature which occurred between the decades of 1940 and 1970. (“Postmodernism”). The decade of the release of Catch 22 and other novels such as Slaughterhouse Five, Lost in the Funhouse, and Gravity’s Rainbow is often marked as the peak decade of the postmodern era. (Matterson). The content of Joseph Heller’s Catch 22 coincides highly with the typical characteristics of postmodern literature. Catch 22 contains the anti-hero archetype, unusual narrative techniques such as fragmentation, paradox, and unreliable narrator, as well as strong connections to WWII, which was a precursor to the postmodern era and a common topic of postmodern...

Words: 701 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Moral Ambiguity In Catch-22

...With his impact on the 20th century, Heller managed to create an intense feeling of moral conflict and views on the political times of World War II with satirical comedy, his character, Yossarian’s, expressions and his critical orientation on the War setting he is currently situated in. Through Heller and ”Catch-22” ,a solely American phrase was born as the classic ‘Stalemate’ phrase, a no-win situation that applies to real life and veterans at home, something relatable to the public and readers. Imagery of falsehood in reality. Institution is based on expectations and reality in the book. When Colonel Cathcart and Peckham agree to move the bombline and have missions set for Bologna(Ch.12), Yossarian and his mates prepare for suicide as this...

Words: 1586 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Insanity In Catch-22 By Joseph Heller

...Modern Connection Essay Throughout the course of the story, the development of PTSD is one of the many factors that develop the major theme of insanity. Within the novel Catch-22, Joseph Heller implements many elements and signs of future PTSD to add to the depth and further develop the theme of insanity and the causes of it through the main characters. The common theme of insanity is developed by the author through elements that can now be described as precursors to PTSD. The news article written by Sebastian Junger describes the characteristics and statistics of PTSD within the United States. PTSD is described as Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, which typically occurs after battle experiences for veterans. During the story, Yossarian encounters...

Words: 349 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Catch 22 Chaplain Opinion Analysis

...Justin Eng AP English 1O April 19, 2013 Catch-22 Essay- 2003 Prompt Joseph Heller’s Catch 22 is a novel of extreme confusion and conflict with physical and societal enemies. May of the characters face situations in which different aspects of their lives clash together and tear apart the individual’s personality. Such is the case with the chaplain, a religious person on the front lines of a chaotic war. The chaplain’s religiousness and the institution of the Army collide multiple times, leading the chaplain to question himself. The chaplain is one of the few purely good characters in this novel; despite all the negativity in his surroundings, the chaplain stays faithful and thinks of his family very often. He makes a few friends in Nately and Yossarian, and he tries to do anything for them, including grounding Yossarian. However, the chaplain’s attempts to institute religious practices and help his friends are blocked by the officers in the Army. When the chaplain tries to persuade the officers to ground Yossarian, he shows his faith in his friends, but that notion clashes with the institution of the Army. The chaplain’s desire to stand up for his beliefs is blocked by his fear of the soldiers, especially Colonels Cathcart and Korn. Eventually the chaplain loses his purity and innocence; something clicks inside him after Nately dies. He starts to lie, as he figures out that lying is more efficient and effective than telling the truth. The chaplain also helps Yossarian escape...

Words: 517 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Insanity In Joseph Heller's Catch-22

...contagious." (Heller, 14) Insanity is something Yossarian wishes that he could catch. To his disappointment, the only thing that he will catch, is a quandary known as a catch-22. All that Yossarian wants, is to make it safely back to his home in the United States, but his absurd superiors and the catch-22 make it nearly impossible for him to do so. Yossarian is an undercover genius, who acts like a madman in an attempt to escape his situation. When Heller first introduces the protagonist, Captain John Yossarian, one might believe he is mad because he enjoys being ill in a hospital. Later, the reader finds out that Yossarian is there only to wait out the war. This led me to believe that he is a genius because although his strategy is a bit selfish, it is keeping him alive and well. It is not until Yossarian asked to be grounded that the first catch-22 comes into play....

Words: 499 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Comparing the Historical Context of Slaughterhouse-5 and Catch-22

...Although ironic, the stories from anti-war novels tend to be set around war zones or environments, with characters whose lives somehow revolve around a specific period of warfare. This is the case in Kurt Vonnegut’s Slaughterhouse-5 and Catch-22 by Joseph Heller. Their respective main characters, Billy Pilgrim and John Yossarian, are differently characterized, but their objective as soldier fighting for the United States in World War II is the same. They are located in abundantly different regions, Billy in Dresden, Germany, while Yossarian finds himself in the Italian island of Pianosa. To ironically display the theme of anti-war, Slaughterhouse-5 accurately represents a marking event in world history taken from actual experiences while Catch-22 presents a real location but with fictitious events. Slaughterhouse-5’s story is mainly focused around Billy’s experience during his time spent in Dresden as a prisoner of the Germans. Dresden is known for its cultural and artistic splendor, with churches (such as the Frauenkirche), concert halls and gardens which contribute to its fame. In the novel, the American soldiers were transported to the city by foot and later by train to finally reach Schlachthof-fünf, German for slaughterhouse five. The bombing is foreshadowed many times before its actual execution in the novel, and at one point even directly contradicted by an Englishman before the departure: “You needn't worry about bombs, by the way. Dresden is an open city. It is undefended...

Words: 600 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

How Does Heller Use Satire In Catch 22

...Joseph Heller does a wonderful job explaining that in his novel “Catch-22”. “Catch-22” is a satirical novel that can be confusing but still sends out a great message. “Catch-22” can be looked at as a smaller present day society suffering from an overdose of irrationality. It provides entertainment and tells a story of someone who just wants to survive. ​Heller uses a man named Yossarian who is a pilot in World War II to highlight the struggles of day-to-day life. Yossarian is Heller’s protagonist. Yossarian joined the navy to explore the world but this exploration would eventually become a nightmare with time. Yossarian realizes life as he knows it could come to an end at any...

Words: 430 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

What Role Does Religion Play In Catch 22

...How does religion play role in a novel Catch 22? Religion plays role in the novel because many aspects in the novel are associate with believe in God. In addition, novel starts and ends with chaplain, and some debates happen because of belief in God. However, many characters in a novel do not believe in God, and only some believe in God. Moreover, chaplain is uncertain about God presents, and characters are not thinking well about the God. Therefore, religion is one theme of the novel, which has influence on characters and symbolization of God. Yossarian and Lieutenant Scheisskopf’s wife do not believe in God. They have interesting conversation about God. Yossarian says, “He’s not working at all. He’s playing. Or else He’s forgotten all about...

Words: 892 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Gold Mining with Mercury

...Most miners of the Amazon lead a very polluted way of life. They pollute the environment they live in and they pollute themselves. The, "garimpeiros" as the miners are called in Brazil are independent farmers of the gold that flows beneath the rivers of the Amazon rain-forest. Their daily routine of early mornings, long hard days, and late nights drinking and taking cocaine contribute to their way of life. Their only goal in life is to drill for the gold dust which seems to collect at the bottoms of waterfalls then use the profits for illegal self indulgences like cocaine. To extract this gold dust they must combine mercury with the dust, and because of the mercury’s chemical make-up it is able to extract the gold from the useless rock and debris. The mercury, however, isn’t the cleanest element for the environment. Many garimpeiros carelessly use the mercury then dump it into the rivers polluting the water and the food. Also, the dust from the mercury gets inhaled by the miners, contributing to their polluted way of life. All day dragas, which are boats used for mining the bottom of rivers, are pulled to locations where gold is thought to be found, moving and polluting. Then there is the common drug use among these farmers. To sum the garimpeiros’ way of life, they live a life of drinking and drugs, women and murder. So the polluted way of life is obvious, men poison the waters and the food and then ultimately themselves, with the illegal activities of the mining trade in Brazil...

Words: 456 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Informed Consent and Refusal

...case because social workers have never really been able to offer their clients unlimited confidentiality because in recent years the demand for accountability has increased as well as greater access to information in records, mandated child abuse reporting and expanding court involvement in professional decision making (Kagle J, Kopels S. P.1 1994). Now more than ever therapists are faced with their obligation to protect their client’s privacy as well as the duty to protect third parties from harm. Especially when dealing with potentially violent clients who are court ordered to ascertain therapy. The therapist’s duty is to report back to the court or probation or parole officers while also maintaining confidentiality. It seems like a catch 22. These vague mandates can potentially hurt therapist – client confidentiality. Each state has different statutes and most states enclose when it is appropriate to breach the confidentiality agreement which is when there is...

Words: 403 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Ghhg

...Дневник читателя READER’S JOURNAL Ernest Hemingway. The Old Man and the Sea (1952). Joseph Heller. Catch-22 (1961). Tennessee Williams. A Streetcar Named Desire (1959). Iris Murdoch. The Black Prince (1973). Jerome David Salinger. The Catcher in the Rye (1951). Michael Ondaatje. The English Patient (1992). Ray Bradbury. Fahrenheit 451 (1953). Ken Kesey. One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest (1962). Edward Albee. Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf? (1962). Arthur Miller. Death of a Salesman (1949). ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- Ernest Hemingway. The Old Man and the Sea (1952). ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- FULL TITLE · The Old Man and the Sea ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- AUTHOR · Ernest Hemingway ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- TYPE OF WORK · Novella ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- GENRE · Parable; tragedy ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- LANGUAGE · English ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- TIME AND PLACE WRITTEN · 1951, Cuba ------------------------------------------------- ...

Words: 43588 - Pages: 175

Premium Essay

Week 6 Discussion 1 Contract Mgmt

...* From the e-Activity, determine the basic guidelines that a successful vendor should always follow in the solicitation process. Include an example to support your response. * Determine what Procurement Contracting Officers for the government are looking for in their evaluations of small-business offers. Select the three most important factors that the officers would consider during the evaluation of a small-business offer. Provide a rationale for your selection. Once a vendor has have found the appropriate solicitation he or she must be sure to read all documents thoroughly, so you understand all of the requirements. Example, failure to submit all required documentation could result in an offer being returned; which, in turn will greatly increase the processing time. Here are some basic guidelines a successful vendor should always follow: * “Read the solicitation thoroughly and follow the instructions. * Provide the requested information in the appropriate format. * Submit your completed Standard Form 1449 with your electronic signature when responding. Only the person legally authorized to enter into contracts for your company should sign the form. * Submit a dated copy of your commercial pricelist(s), with the appropriate Special Item Number (SIN) next to each offered item. Also include the Commercial Sales Practice Format (CSP-1), to provide details about your pricing history. Pay close attention to the pricing included in...

Words: 535 - Pages: 3