Free Essay

Christmas Carol

In:

Submitted By maryam58
Words 1295
Pages 6
D1: unit 5
The way the media presented the MMR case in front of the public created a great contribution towards the public perception. It has also had a negative impact on the scientific information, which was given out parallel to the rumors regarding the link between MMR vaccine and autism.
In 2003, a science based film named "Hear the silence” has influenced the media by naming Dr. Wakefield as "Bad Scientist" [6].This seemed to have disregarded the value of a scientist and his knowledge in front of the public. On the other hand, the media have done their best to emphasize the MMR vaccine scare by putting headlines " MMR LINKED TO AUTISM" in newspapers like the "EVENING STANDARD" [6]. All of this highly influenced people’s thinking and resulted in a lot of parents refusing the MMR vaccines for their children. However, when Dr Wakefield’s theory got proven as a "Swine flu outbreak" as said in an article of Media Influence, it opened people’s eyes about the reality behind the false link.
The impact of the media on public was made by using Sensationalistic Language to attract the public’s attention. It is a sensitive topic because it questions parenthood and whether the parents are taking the right decisions for their children’s health. Whilst this aspect was important, media also sketched scientists as respected and intelligent human beings who are not meant to make mistakes. So why was it that they destroyed this image in front of general public? The answer can be that partially, media runs on headlines or the big disastrous news that can be fed through every home television in order to get everyone’s attention and run big news channels. Same is the case for reporters who write articles for the newspapers.
Interestingly, this historical case of the supposed link between the MMR vaccine and Autism, media contributed on a huge scale by spreading the news like fire through their news feed without having solid evidence of this claim. Even the person who suggested the supposed link, Dr Wakefield was not against the MMR vaccine. He suggested whether there was a link or not but the media caught it to spread the news across the country within days. The media blew up this specific issue in public by playing with the feelings of worried and petrified parents.
In an essay of the MMR vaccination debate by Kate Ho, many different opinions by the public were mentioned. It came across that people questioned the safety of MMR vaccine. David Elliman, a consultant at St George’s Hospital stated “There is overwhelming evidence of the safety of the combined MMR vaccine. No study has shown a link between MMR vaccine and autism and bowel disease, whereas a number have produced evidence that there is no link” [3]. This emphasizes that there are multiple evidences and strong letters, supporting the vaccination for immunizing the children's. In the other view of Merck and Co express, about the unsafety of vaccines by saying “No vaccine is 100% effective and 100% safe" [3].This then questions the reliability of the vaccine and demonstrates how the media coverage influenced people’s perception and made them develop doubts regarding the MMR vaccine.
The media increase the fear of MMR vaccine and referred to it as cause of autism but in the Dept of health press conference in 2001 on 22nd January, the government was trying to win the war against the words said by Dr.Wakefield. Dr.Elezabeth Miller said “The safety of MMR has been looked up with extremely independent research groups who have then concluded that there is no such link between MMR and Autism" [2]. However, the public then raised an issue with this stating that if there was no evidence, this does not necessarily mean that there would be no evidence in the future either. Worried women who had young children waiting to be vaccinated raised this specific worry in a documentary on MMR vaccines.
In effect, media had played a huge contribution by putting forward the issue in a negative way but on the other hand, after the MMR vaccine scare was proven to be a hoax and the combination of worthy results by multiple researchers in various countries were publicly known and provided as evidence, it provided an insight on the actual truth. This suggests that science is totally based on evidence and hypotheses are made but without evidence, they hold no basis. In a survey of public perception by medical students concluded that 70% people said that they believe that mostly scientist always came up with the true theories or ideas but 30% had different views about scientific theories [1]. The reason behind this we could simply detect by the evident case of MMR scare of how people become victimized to a false theory that has no strong evidence behind it.
In BBC News on 19 May, 2003, 06:19 GMT 07:19 UK it was shown that 48% of people think that when it comes to health safety,the journalist shouldn’t report the theories until it has been proven to be correct by science or confirmed and accepted by researchers. The 30% of public in the public survey stated that Dr.Wakefield’s concerns about the vaccine should be reported worthy [5]. However, many scientists throughout the world rejected the association because for years, MMR vaccines have nearly almost eradicated these fatal illnesses in children and adults likewise. This survey is just an example of media’s influence on the way public thinks and how it can challenge the trust that we have in scientists or science as a society.
The social media has always impacted public perception. In a survey of 30 people did by medical students in college, we find 80% people from the general public thinking that science has made life much easier in understanding the nature of life. Although, 20% of the public thinks that science is getting harder to understand and science is a posing threat towards how we should lead our lives [6]. These surveys do make one think about the varied thinking approach in our general public.
In conclusion I feel like the media connect different aspects and figures to make news e.g. the scientific figures from the perception of science and then the public perception regarding it. Media tends to have a positive impact on the public but in sensitive issues such as the one of MMR vaccine and the autism link, media influence has resulted in many people risking not getting their children vaccinated and it has increased the cases of children suffering from measles, mumps and rubella. So it is of utter most important that media uses information with a firm basis and evidence before quoting it so the information conveyed to the public has truth and it also maintains the respect that we hold for science and scientists in our society.

1. Maryam, survey on (perception of science, unit 5), 2015, 09/20/15.
2. Published on 3 May 2012, MMR vaccination documentary 2002, access on 10/10/2015 and can be accessed by https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cpyjnys3Nf0.
4. Kate ho the MMR Vaccination debate, 2015, accessed on 11/05/15 can be accessed by this following link http://homepages.inf.ed.ac.uk/s9904132/MMR.pdf.
5. http://nrvs.info/faqs/vaccines-and-autism/.
6. BBC News, Parents misled by over MMR, 19 May, 2003, 06:19 GMT 07:19 UK http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/north_west/3038607.stm
7. Published on 27 Feb 2013, Drama/movie about Dr. Andrew Wakefield & the parents of vaccine injured children, accessed on 11/04/2015 can by open by following link https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FkYGSGKI16Q

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Christmas Carol

...“Men's courses will foreshadow certain ends, to which if persevered in, they must lead . . . But if the courses be departed from, then ends will change”. Discuss. Set against the backdrop of nineteenth century London, Charles Dickens' timeless novella “A Christmas Carol” illustrates the transformation of the protagonist Ebenezer Scrooge from a cruel and and greedy miser to a kind and benevolent human being. Throughout this “ghostly” tale, Scrooge is placed on a psychological continuum that allows readers to observe his gradual progress from a recluse to a man of compassion to highlight the abundance of life's riches when material gain does not become one's “golden idol”. Through characters such as Jacob Marley, Dickens not only emphasises on the inevitable doom of those who act selfishly as they will lead a life full of regret and isolation from those they love but also highlights how selfish actions can lead to devastating consequences that not only affect one's life but also the lives of those less fortunate. However, Dickens also conveys the moral message to his readers that through guidance and the willingness to be enlightened by others, we all have the capacity to change ourselves, and in the process better our lives and the lives of others. Fixated with materials goods at the expense of human connection, Scrooge's lack of morality is evident in the novella through his Malthusian mindset regarding the poor, as he claims that “if they be like to die, then they had...

Words: 1037 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Poverty In A Christmas Carol

...Charles Dickens author of, A Christmas Carol, realized how horrible times had become so he decided to write this novella to help educate the rich and poor alike. When he was in the process of writing A Christmas Carol, he observed the many ways the poor were suffering and what he could incorporate into his novella to create awareness for it. When he finally finished his novella, his dream to create awareness for the poor who were suffering began to become a reality. More and more people were being affected by A Christmas Carol, mostly since it opened their eyes to treacherous reality of poverty. He changed the way many middle class and upper class thought. They began to hold sympathy for the less fortunate in their country and started to help rather than stand there and do nothing.Once the middle and upper class began to help out the poor, the economy boomed. The aristocrats gave the poor jobs, money, and assistance. They did what they could to help bring people out of poverty, because they did not want to turn into a “Marley”, Scrooge's old business partner whom led a horrible afterlife of suffering and despair. The middle class also helped, in the small ways they could. They gave food to the poor, helped to serve them, and even set up systems that could bring people out of the neverending cycle of poverty. In Dickens time...

Words: 1033 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

A Christmas Carol

...How does Dickens use language and Imagery to show that Scrooge's desire for wealth has affected his character and Behaviour and that of the people around him? 'A Christmas Carol' written in 1843. It was the first of five short Christmas books written and published by Charles Dickens. 'A Christmas Carol' was the most successful novel in the series. Soon after its publication, all of the copies were sold. Since its publication, the story has been sold in a variety of forms. 'A Christmas Carol' has been adapted for stage, radio, movies and television; however, the book remains the most popular telling of the tale. The book 'A Christmas Carol' is not simply a book about Christmas. Charles Dickens used the theme where people are sensitive to philanthropy- (loving your fellow man) and generosity so it had universal appeal. Charles Dickens wrote the novel because he wanted to publicise the plight that the poor suffered; the story bore extreme relevance in it's time and he embodied his philosophy that we should love our fellow man in his work. This is very poignant in a Christmas Carol as Scrooge adapts into a character who learns that he can still love his fellow man. This concept is summed up in the book when it says that 'if a man's spirit does not walk around the earth in life it is condemned to do so in death. 'Belle breaks their arrangement, one which was made when he was a poor man because 'Another idol has displaced me'. She thinks she is no longer as important to Scrooge as...

Words: 441 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

A Christmas Carol

...A Christmas carol Characters: Scrooge: Greedy, cold-hearted, hates Christmas, selfish, people should only buy whatever they need, rich, lonely, hates people, ignorant, owns a business, and old man, no one wants to be firneds with him, a real business career is most important to him, lonely as a child, loves Fan (sister) stingy, father was similar to scrooge. Development: In the end scrooge is very generous, family becomes more important, feels guilty of his former actions, feels sympathy, second father for Tim, from bad person to good person. Tiny Tim: -He is very sick - Bob’s son. - he believes in the good in all people, and he enjoys life very much. - he has faith. - the opposite of the “first” scrooge Bob cratchit: - Tim’s father - A family man, who tries to take care of his kids. – he is working for scrooge. - He always believes in the good in people, and he tries to stay faithful, always. - very little money, big contrast to Scrooge. Belle: Scrooges ex-fiancee, Scrooge’s love of his life, did not get married because at that time, money was most important to him. - Scrooge highly lost hope in people after that. Fred Hubbert: Rich, wife(Janet, does not understand Scrooge.)He loves Christmas. Positive, believes Scrooge can change, and example of what Scrooge could have been, if he had married Belle. Fan: Loves Scrooge, and Scrooge loves her. Has faith in the father figure, like Tim. Jacob Marley: Business partner, identical with Scrooge...

Words: 339 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

A Christmas Carol

...‘A Christmas Carol’ covers a period of 24 hours from Christmas Eve to Christmas Day. It is a simple morality tale of the radical change in the character Ebenezer Scrooge from being bitter, iron fisted and miserable to becoming a new, openhearted and charitable man. The novel was first published in 1843, a time when many of the wealthy people neglected the old Christmas spirit of charity. In addition, the Industrial Revolution had further done away with the simple pleasures of the season. Dickens’ intentions in writing ‘A Christmas Carol’ were not only linked to his own childhood and sympathy for the poor, but he was also making an appeal to the rich people of society to mend their selfish ways. Dickens is able to show the change in Scrooge’s character by establishing what Scrooge is like at the very beginning of the story with the first two words he says: ‘“Bah! Humbug!’’ ’It is clear from the dismissive tone and the two exclamation marks that Scrooge has no patience with the idea of Christmas as a special time. At the start of the novel, Dickens is using Scrooge, someone who associates happiness with nothing but money, as a classic example of a wealthy person in the 19th Century. He does this with Scrooge inquiring of his nephew ‘“What reason have you to be merry? You’re poor enough.”’ Scrooge’s manor in saying this reveals certain elements of his character such as his shallowness and uncaring nature. In Scrooge saying this it demonstrates to the reader that Scrooge does...

Words: 2488 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

A Christmas Carol

...A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens. In this extract we are presented with Scrooge. From the beginning Scrooge is presented as a miser. In the extract we find out that he is an old, rude and ignorant man that doesn’t appreciate others around him. Dickens uses different language techniques to describe Scrooges appearance as clear as possible. In the opening paragraph Dickens uses imagery to create a vivid impression of Scrooge. He is described as ‘a tight-fisted hand at the grind-stone’, and this metaphor suggests that Scrooge works hard for his money but is very tight with his money. In the opening lines Dickens includes similes. ‘Hard and sharp as a flint.’ Flint is a hard stone that was used with iron to create sparks before people used matches. This makes me think that Scrooge would have very sharp features, a pointy nose and always has a scowl on his face. This then gives you an idea of what Scrooge looks like. The other simile in the opening line is ‘solitary as an oyster’, this shows that Scrooge is alone. He is a solitary person, who avoids other people. This quotation is also an example of foreshadowing. Overtime oysters open up and inside them are a pearl, Dickens has used this because throughout the book Scrooge will eventually begin to open up. Also in the first paragraph of the extract Charles Dickens uses alliteration. ‘Secret, and self-contained, and solitary as an oyster.’ The effect that the alliteration gives makes you focus on the words more. The words ‘secret’...

Words: 862 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Similes In A Christmas Carol

...The Use of Adjectives Charles Dickens is one of the best known and most read writers from the victorian-era. My initial thoughts of a Dickens’ novel, is length. Sheer uninterrupted length. Dickens used extensive, intimate and over descriptive language in all his writing, making sentences and paragraphs seem endless. Yet, I believe, it was a style that worked for him. Powerful adjectives, similes and metaphors are strongly associated with his writing style. Dickens’ description of Scrooge in ‘A Christmas Carol’, “Oh! but he was a tight-fisted hand at the grindstone, Scrooge! a squeezing, wrenching, grasping, scraping, clutching, covetous, old sinner!” is an excellent example of his ability to portray the character while engaging the reader....

Words: 251 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

A Christmas Carol Symbolism

...In A Christmas Carol, Charles Dickens uses symbolism to enhance his themes. In this novella, Scrooge was excluded ever since he was a boy. As he grew up, he started to isolate himself from society, and bought a cold, dark, and lonely house in which people wouldn’t enter. Dickens also used Robinson Crusoe to show how miserable an excluded life can be. Charles Dickens employs symbolism to reinforce the theme of social exclusion in A Christmas Carol. Scrooge was initially excluded by his father from his own house. Scrooge was kept away from the home and stayed at school even during Christmas time. The Ghost of Christmas Past showed Scrooge a scene of him as a little boy, watching all the other children have fun during the holidays with their families....

Words: 764 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Symbolism In A Christmas Carol

...“No space of regret can make amends for one life's opportunity misused.” This quote from in Charles Dickens’s novel, A Christmas Carol, is spoken by the ghost of Jacob Marley to Ebenezer Scrooge. In the scene, the spirit is trying to convince Scrooge to change his miserly ways before it is too late. Throughout the book, Dickens uses symbolism in the ghosts that visit Scrooge. After reading Thomas C. Foster’s book, How to Read Literature Like a Professor, I have also been able to recognize that the book might also be somewhat political. In Dickens’s book, the first ghost that visits Scrooge is his old business partner, Jacob Marley. Marley, who was once like Scrooge, essentially begs him to become a better, less selfish person. Now, Marley’s character is full of symbolism. It is even stated in the book that the thick chains that weigh down his body are representative of the “chains he forged in life.” They represent his greed and his wrongdoings that keep his locked down. When his physical appearance is described, it even says...

Words: 729 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Christmas Carol Essay

...redemption. Discuss By the end of A Christmas Carol, the main protagonist, Scrooge, is worthy of redemption. For someone with such wealth, Scrooge was an unusually morose and unhappy character, particularly at Christmas. At the start, Scrooge was unhallowed and resolute in his views about Christmas, and would not be persuaded that it was a time for kindness and merriment. However as the novel progresses, Scrooge changes his ways and displays qualities of a good person. His benevolence, kindness and generosity make him worthy of redemption. Scrooge finally makes up for his mistakes and become more friendly and charitable. This is largely as a result of the four ghosts’ visitations and his experiences with them. His witnessing the past, present and future have impacted towards changing his personality. Scrooge’s visitations with the three ghosts changed the way he viewed people and taught him about kindness and respects. During Marley’s visit, Scrooge listens to all the hardships Marley endured while he was busy making money in unscrupulous ways. Marley hopes to save Scrooge from sharing the same fate. He tells Scrooge that he didn't learn until he became a ghost that charity and kindness were the important aspects of living, but by then it was too late. He informs Scrooge that three spirits of Christmas Past, Present and Future will visit him during each of the next three nights. Dickens uses the invention of Christmas Spirits to elucidate (clarify, explain) on Scrooge’s...

Words: 1006 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Examples Of Social Injustice In The Christmas Carol

...A timeless theme is a theme that has no beginning or end. It is relevant in all times. A great example of a timeless theme is social injustice. Social injustice is seen throughout society more and more as the rich keep becoming richer. There has always been a great divide between the rich and the poor, but the divide keeps growing. The people who are well off are selfish and greedy meaning they don’t care about anyone but themselves. The theme of social injustice can be witnessed throughout the Christmas Carol play, the book and in today's society. Although the play is set in a different time period, it still teaches important lessons. In the story, Ebenezer Scrooge starts by having no feelings for anything or anyone. In the end, he changes...

Words: 522 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Ghost In A Christmas Carol

...A Christmas Carol is a very deep story about a man named Scrooge who redeemed himself from being and mean old man who hates christmas to ok guy who likes christmas just like he did when he was just a boy. This redemption happened because of the three ghost who appear in the story of the christmas carol. The name of the three ghost were past, present and yet to come and they were named because of obvious reasons. The first ghost shows Scrooge the past and its visions of Scrooge loving christmas as a boy and this gets scrooge all teary eyed. The second ghost shows Scrooge how he is living and Scrooge doesn't like what he sees, he sees that he is just a mean old man and no one like him as a person. The last ghost is what really hits Scrooge the hardest....

Words: 533 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

A Christmas Carol's A Christmas Carol

...A Christmas Carole is about Ebenezer scrooge who’s a man who doesn’t understand the meaning of Christmas. He doesn’t care about other people, he just cares about money. The night before Christmas Eve, the ghost of his dead friend visits him, his friend was just like him, loved money and didn’t care about anyone but himself. But now he came to warn Ebenezer. He says that he will be haunted by three spirits: the spirit of Christmas past, the spirit of Christmas present and the spirit of Christmas yet to come. Every night one. The first night Ebenezer is visited by the ghost of the Christmas past. He takes him to Ebenezer’s childhood, from when he was a little boy and Ebenezer felt the hopes, joys and cares long, long forgotten but they also went to the time that Ebenezer was engaged, to Belle, she broke op with him because of his greediness for money. He was devastated....

Words: 465 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Christmas Carol Analysis

...Cesar Granda E.G 121 When reading A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens you realize that Scrooge’s childhood has a huge impact on his adult life, his adult self is a mirror image of his child self, both in his emotions and relationships. This becomes apparent when the ghost of Christmas past appears and takes Scrooge on a journey back into his childhood days. His childhood really molds Scrooge into the person he becomes later in life. Scrooge was a lonely and withdrawn child because he lost connection with the only parent he had left after the death of his mother at childbirth. His father sends him away to boarding school and refuses to allow the young Scrooge to return home. This disconnection from the only parent he has left leads young Scrooge to become introverted and lonely. Having been deprived of a father figure he probably could not have sustained a relationship with other boys, in fact, it probably was the opposite of that. Boys at the school could easily have picked on him for the situation he was in. At Christmas time this becomes more apparent when all the boys return home with Scrooge being the only one remaining in school. All of these events take a tremendous toll on the young Scrooge’s psychological state that culminates on Christmas day when he is alone in the deserted school reading a book next to a fireplace: “Suddenly a man, in foreign garments: wonderfully real and distinct to look at: stood outside the window, with an axe stuck in his...

Words: 679 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Christmas Carol Review

...well defined so as to construct scenes of frost covered brick alleyways in London, England, around Christmastime. The plot, which many are extremely well acquainted with, follows the miser Ebenezer Scrooge, who not only neglected to celebrate Christmas himself, but also expressed spitefulness to those who could not pay off investments. Ignoring his worker’s, Bob Cratchit, ill young child and poor family, more poverty across and beyond the city, and those who needed consolation, Scrooge was visited by the ghost of his late working partner, Jacob Marley, seven years to the day after his death, falling on Christmas Eve, and told to mend his ways, so as to avoid a miserable fate like his. Scrooge was consecutively visited by the Ghost of Christmas Past, (specifically of Scrooge’s), the Ghost of Christmas Present, and the Ghost of Christmas Future, where he saw how he had once had happiness, and of how there was much suffering in the world. This corresponds to the theme of the book, which is of how a moral transformation can occur when one sees others in need, or reflects on his wrongdoings in life with repentance. This internal drive to change for the better was demonstrated when Scrooge observed Bob Cratchit’s house with the Ghost of Christmas Present; at first, he commented on Cratchit’s slovenly behaviors and inefficiency, but after he regarded an ordeal with his family, he saw the tension he had caused them, and felt remorse. Second, the setting to the novel was also of surprising...

Words: 907 - Pages: 4