Free Essay

Compare and Contrast of Theorists

In:

Submitted By 73tweety
Words 1292
Pages 6
When you compare and contrast the theories of Alfred Adler, Carl Jung, Karen Horney and Erik Erikson with the theories of Freud, you will see that their theoretical perspectives, major concepts and approaches to theory have a little bit of the same views and some very different views from each other.
Carl Jung's method in psychotherapy is similar to Freud's. In some rare cases, if the Freudian approach is not acceptable, Jung would implement an equivalent method that would guide the patient to a personal dispute with the archetypes within the collective unconscious(Burger, Ch5, pg101). This dispute aims at the consumption of archetypal images; the individuation process leads to the awareness of the psychic wholeness made in conjunction with the conscious and unconscious. The conscious mind needs to include archetypal materials of the basics of completeness.
Jung’s own experiences with schizophrenic people has built up his idea of the collective unconscious. He initially followed the Freudian theory of the unconscious forming wishes that were suppressed and later refined his own theory on the unconscious, the most important part being the archetype.
Archetypes make up the structure of the collective unconscious; they are psychic intrinsic dispositions that lead to knowledge and represent human behavior and certain positions (Burger, Ch5, pg102). Things like mysterious and religious involvements, power and failure, and also birth and death are controlled by archetypes. Self is the most important archetype of all; it is the center of the psychic person, the wholeness. It is made up of the unity of both the conscious and unconscious through the individuation process.
This archetype concept that Jung writes about comes from the replicate observation that myths and common literature that contains well specified themes that appear all the time and everywhere. These themes are representations of archetypes and are often in our thoughts, illusions, fantasies, and dreams. Archetypes images manifest themselves through our visions and dreams; they do not have a specific shape. They might resemble our instincts, but until they manifest in our intentions or actions, they cannot be recognized.
Jung said that religious experience is linked with the archetypes of the collective unconscious. The collective unconscious means that human beings are provided with a psychic archetype layer within themselves since birth; it cannot be acquired through education or any other conscious effort, it is a comprehensive reference to human knowledge (Burger, Ch5, pg101).
Alfred Adler was a world renowned psychiatrist and philosopher who stressed the desire to comprehend individuals within their social background. Alder addressed crucial and contemporary issues such as parental education, equality, lifestyle, the holiness of individuals, and the influence of birthing order. He believed that we all have one main goal and desire which is to belong to something and feel important.
Alders’ theory says that when we feel inspired, we feel proficient and thankful and will be cooperative and feel connected. When we are discouraged, we might act sickly by completely withdrawing and give up. We find ways to express and accept encouragement and find social interest that help us feel encouraged and satisfied.
His practice and theory shown to be very productive when applied towards the growth and development of children(Burger, Ch5, pg98). Those who follow him believe that a child that misbehaves is a depressed child. Helping a child feel appreciated, competent and important is a very efficient way of coping with problematic child behavior.
The Adlerian psychology centers on ones effort to satisfy for their self-seen inadequacy to others. These feelings of inadequacy may come from one’s views in the family prospective, especially if experiences of embarrassment occurred early in life; or a if there is some kind of physical defect or condition that exists.
Adlerian’s concern themselves with the unique understanding of private beliefs and strategies in one’s lifestyle that is created throughout childhood. Understanding this lifestyle serves as a reference for each individual’s behavior, attitude, and private view of themselves and the world around them (Burger, Ch5, pg99). If we look at our childhood experiences, we can examine the patterns and methods of behavior that may repeat itself and try to gain some kind of meaning and acceptance to heal and grow so change can occur.
Karen Horney’s theory was related to her personal life and showed how she dealt with her problems. Her ideas of psychoanalysis and neurosis are associated with inner conflicts and viewed as one of the best theories in her area (Burger, Ch5, pg111). According to Horney, neurosis is how people manage control over their interpersonal issues on a daily basis. Another one of her theories that she talks about is the idea of personality in conjunction with psychoanalysis; her theories on this are looked at more in-depth to show how much she disagreed with Freud.
Neurosis is a somewhat mild, personality disorder that is represented by excessive anxiety or uncertainty and an amount of social or interpersonal mental illness (Dictionary). It is described as an individual that has trouble managing certain circumstantial stressors that result in problems within themselves.
Horney believed that neurotic attitudes and feelings are driven by the way you live; it cannot be diagnosed without looking at one’s cultural background. Horney feels that Freud ignored the cultural factors that can lead to false acquisitions; it can also disrupt the understanding of what drives our attitudes and actions.
Horney believes a neurotic is someone who is driven by their emotions and the things that happen within their lives; Freud suggests that their real self is driven by their concept of ego. Horney thinks that Freudian’s theory about fixed obsessions on sex interfere with someone and their family, attitudes and values. Freud believes they are sexual impulses from nature that every human being has. The emphasis of this is that a neurotic should be aware of their surroundings and their inner-self and know who they are.
Erik Erikson discusses his ideas and views on psychosocial stages; Freud ideas about structure and the topography of personality influenced him greatly. Erikson was an ego psychologist, his emphasis is on the aspect of culture and how the struggle in society can take part within the ego itself, whereas Freud was an id psychologist and emphasized on the struggle between the id and the superego.
Erikson says the ego develops as it fixes its crises that clearly social in nature. This involves being able to build a sense of trust in others, developing a sense of identity in the community, and allowing the next generation to get ready for the future.
Erikson broadens the view on Freudian thoughts by concentrating on the adaptive and innovative characteristic of the ego, and to broaden the belief of the stages of personality development so it includes the whole lifespan (Burger, Ch5, pg106).
Erikson took the five stages and proposed a lifespan model of development up through the age of 18 and extended it by three stages beyond that up through adulthood (Burger, Ch5, pg107). He suggests that there is still a lot of room to continue one’s growth and development throughout their life. There was also a great deal of emphasis on the pubescent period because it is an important stage for developing one’s identity.
Along with Freud and many others, the belief is that personality develops in a fixed order and builds upon the previous stage. The conclusion to this developmental timetable is a wide and unified group of life skills and capabilities that function together within the independent individual. However, instead of concentrating on sexual development like Freud, he was concerned in how children socialize and how it might affect their sense of self.

References:
Burger, J. M. (2011). Personality, Eighth Edition. Mason: Cengage Learning. Retrieved from: http://gcumedia.com/digital-resources/cengage/2010/personality_ebook_8e.php

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Fddfsdfsd Fsfsdffs

...termpaperwarehouse.comHow to Write a Comparative Analysis Throughout your academic career, you'll be asked to write papers in which you compare and contrast two things: two texts, two theories, two historical figures, two scientific processes, and so on. "Classic" compare-and-contrast papers, in which you weight A and B equally, may be about two similar things that have crucial differences (two pesticides with different effects on the environment) or two similar things that have crucial differences, yet turn out to have surprising commonalities (two politicians with vastly different world views who voice unexpectedly similar perspectives on sexual harassment). In the "lens" (or "keyhole") comparison, in which you weight A less heavily than B, you use A as a lens through which to view B. Just as looking through a pair of glasses changes the way you see an object, using A as a framework for understanding B changes the way you see B. Lens comparisons are useful for illuminating, critiquing, or challenging the stability of a thing that, before the analysis, seemed perfectly understood. Often, lens comparisons take time into account: earlier texts, events, or historical figures may illuminate later ones, and vice versa. Faced with a daunting list of seemingly unrelated similarities and differences, you may feel confused about how to construct a paper that isn't just a mechanical exercise in which you first state all the features that A and B have in common, and then state all...

Words: 1300 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Accomodating Differences

...Running head: COMPARE AND CONTRAST CHART AND PAPER Compare and Contrast Chart and Paper Alice Dailey Grand Canyon University 313 N June 2, 2012 Module 5 Compare and Contrast Chart and Paper Comparison of Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs with Skinner’s Behaviorist Theory |Issue |Maslow |Skinner | |Define Motivation |Maslow identifies two types of needs; deficiency |Skinner theory of motivation was stem between | | |needs and growth needs. People are motivated to |behavior and consequences. His theory used operant | | |satisfy needs at the lower of hierarchy before |conditioning in which reinforce and punishers shaped | | |seeking to satisfy those at the higher level needs. |behavior. | |How Motivation Changes |Maslow’s hierarchy of needs moves from basis to move |Skinner’s principles of motivation Practical | |For Elementary Versus |advance, from need to know to understanding, and the |reinforces: Elementary; reinforcement schedule, | |Secondary Students |desire to become all that one is capable of becoming.|reward students for desires behavior, motivate | | | |students to...

Words: 979 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Roy and Johnson Comparison of Nursing Theory

...The purpose of this essay is to compare and contrast nursing metaparadigms formulated by Sister Callista Roy’s Adaptation Model and Dorothy Johnson: The Behavioral System Model. These two theorist are identified as grand theorist of the post-positivist era (1950’s-1990’s). The contrast and comparison is structured as Roy’s and Johnson definition of person, health, environment and nursing. Roy defines persons as an adaptive systems with cognation and regulatory subsystems working together to continue adaptation. Roy uses four modes of adaptation (physiological, self-concept, role function, and interdependence) that has to stay balance in order for the person to function at an optimal level. Johnson defines persons as behavioral systems with seven substructures (security, recognition, basic body supply, waste evacuation, sexual needs, defense, and fulfillment) needs to balance to prevent illness. Roy’s model is adaptive and Johnson’s theory of person is reactive to internal/external impulses. Roy defines environment as all conditions and all states of affairs in one’s life that affect development and behavior. Johnson explains environment as internal and external surrounding. Both theorist environments are influenced by one’s current situations that are fixed and those surrounding that are self-restrained. Johnson’s explains health as an adequate and capable function system. Johnson also defines health as observable system balance and security. Roy’s health is the state...

Words: 501 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Macbook Pro

...Compare and contrast the traditional roles of managers presented by Fayol’s early writings with more contemporary research of Stewart and Mintzberg. Introduction The roles of managers cannot be easily described as some people, such as Fayol, Stewart and Mintzberg, all have different interpretations of the phrase. Mullins (2005) said that the role of managers where that they are “essentially an integrating activity which permeates every facet of the operations of an organisation”. This essay is going to compare and contrast the interpretations of roles of managers as they are all different. There are two types of views, the traditional approach of the 19th and 20th century, and the systems approach from the 1960’s onwards. Fayol had a traditional approach to the roles of managers where as Stewart and Mintzberg had more of a systems approach. Comparisons Fayol’s approach is quite similar to Mintzberg’s way of classifying manager’s jobs. Fayol’s suggested that there were 5 main roles of managers, these being planning, organising, commanding, coordinating and controlling. Mintzberg suggests that managers have quite similar roles as they have to be able to be a leader and communicate well. These are the two main roles of any manager as they need to be able to a good leader. If they have good leadership skills then they will get the trust from employees and the job will get done effectively. If you were to have a very weak leader then they would not have the authority to get anything...

Words: 1949 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Comparison of the Traditional Roles of Managers Presented by Fayol’s Early Writings with More Contemporary Research of Stewart and Mintzberg.

...Compare and contrast the traditional roles of managers presented by Fayol’s early writings with more contemporary research of Stewart and Mintzberg. Support your answers with examples. Introduction The roles of managers cannot be easily described as some people, such as Fayol, Stewart and Mintzberg, all have different interpretations of the phrase. Mullins (2005) said that the role of managers where that they are “essentially an integrating activity which permeates every facet of the operations of an organisation”. This essay is going to compare and contrast the interpretations of roles of managers as they are all different. There are two types of views, the traditional approach of the 19th and 20th century, and the systems approach from the 1960’s onwards. Fayol had a traditional approach to the roles of managers where as Stewart and Mintzberg had more of a systems approach. Comparisons Fayol’s approach is quite similar to Mintzberg’s way of classifying manager’s jobs. Fayol’s suggested that there were 5 main roles of managers, these being planning, organising, commanding, coordinating and controlling. Mintzberg suggests that managers have quite similar roles as they have to be able to be a leader and communicate well. These are the two main roles of any manager as they need to be able to a good leader. If they have good leadership skills then they will get the trust from employees and the job will get done effectively. If you were to have a very weak leader...

Words: 1949 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Psy210 Personalities Theory Activity

...The three theories that I have chosen to compare and contrast are trait theory, learning theory, and humanistic theory. Each theory has a different approach of how to determine how a human behaves. Each theorist has their own way of determining one’s behavior and many theorists believe that they are correct in their theory while another theory is incorrect. The trait theory has suggested that individual personalities are composed of broad dispositions. Psychologist Hans Eysenck came up with the five factor model for the trait theory. This model represents five core traits that interact together to form the human personality. The five traits are more commonly described as extraversion, agreeableness, conscientiousness, neuroticism, and openness. Trait theory is descriptive and will deal with genetics to determine a personality. With the learning theory theorists believe that if we practice a certain behavior enough that we would essentially learn that behavior to be normal for us. Albert Bandura has become one of the most influential theorists when it comes to the learning theory. He believed that people could learn behaviors by watching others. Learning could also be linked to a permanent change in a person’s behavior. Humanistic theory focuses on the meaning of life and self-actualization. This theory developed the hierarchy of needs. Abraham Maslow developed the hierarchy of needs based on what he believed was the order of biological needs for survival. Humanistic...

Words: 350 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Statistical Applications

...Running Head: WATSON AND PALEY: COMPARISON AND CONTRAST Watson and Paley: Comparison and Contrast Penelope K. Gates RNBC HCS350 Jean Watson received her nursing diploma from “Lewis-Gale School of Nursing” in Roanoke, VA, in 1961. She went on to complete her undergraduate and graduate studies at the University of Colorado. She obtained a “PhD” in educational psychology and counseling in 1973. Her primary work has been in the psychiatric field of nursing. Dr. Watson has taught many nursing courses through the years as well as did research and wrote numerous books and articles. Most of her work since 2000 has been on her theory and philosophy of caring. She has traveled and lectured across the world, studying and lecturing on her theories on nursing. In 1980, Watson and her associates started the “Center for Human Caring” at the University of Colorado (Alligood & Toomey, 2010, p. 92). Watson wrote her first book on the philosophy and science of nursing in 1979. She developed “10 carative factors”, which Watson describes as being the main ideas of nursing. The carative factors consider the persons involved in practice of caring. She believes in instilling faith and hope and being sensitive to self and others. Watson’s carative factors also are based on developing a trusting relationship with the person or patient. The creation of a healing environment that respects the wholeness and dignity of the person is a carative factor. Watson also looks at the human beings...

Words: 1302 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

8 Trends You Need to Know Now

...Technology Paper Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for EDUC 8111: Principles of Social Change Walden University April 24, 2011 Comparing Tyack and Cuban With Dewey on Social Change 2 Abstract The essay material will examine the viewpoints of the Assumptions Tyack and Cuban concerning the Public Schools traditional strategies and social change will blend gradually to form the essay that compare the theories of John Dewey involving traditional and progressive approaches of schooling pertaining to their purposes and assumptions about Public Education. Comparing Tyack and Cuban With Dewey on Social Change 3 How Tyack and Cuban Assumptions and Purposes Differ from John Dewey approaching Public Education The title of the essay paper is How Tyack and Cuban Assumptions and Purposes Differ from John Dewey Approaching Public Education. The essay will discuss the assumption and purposes of both theorist John Dewey and Tyack and Cuban about public schooling reform and social change. The organization of the essay will first analyze the central concepts of Tyack and Cuban and the theories of John Dewey. The Assumption and Purposes of Public Education will be discussed from three view points. Similarities, Differences, and Uniqueness are researched from three topics. (1) The Assumption and Purposes of Public Education. (2) Quality and Integrity with the Politicization...

Words: 1080 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Leadership

...Final Exam BUS520/Leadership and Organizational Behavior • Define leadership. Discuss the reasons as to why leadership plays a critical role in the field of Organizational Behavior. Compare and contrast the following leadership theories/styles: 1. Trait Theory 2. Path Goal Theory 3. Transformational Leadership 4. Autocratic Leadership Leadership is the process of influencing others and the process of facilitating individual and collective efforts to accomplish shared objectives (Schermehorn, Osborn, Uhl-Bien, Hunt 12th Edition 2012). In our day-to-day life, leadership can be viewed as either actual or potential. Leadership is an important function of management, which helps to maximize efficiency and to achieve organizational goals. A leader is a person who starts the work by communicating the policies and plans to the employees from where the work actually starts. A leader proves to be playing an incentive role in motivating employees with economic and non-economic rewards. A leader not only supervises but also plays guiding role for all employees to help them perform effectively and efficiently. Strong leaders have the ability to encourage and nurture those that report to them. They are also able to delegate in such a way, as people will grow. Leaders are looked at as role models that lead by example. ...

Words: 1564 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

A Comparison of Theorist

...A Comparison of Theorists Many of the greatest theorists of the past decade have helped form the foundation of knowledge. In this paper, this writer will compare two of the most talented theorists of the time. Abraham Maslow and B.F. Skinner are just two of the many theorists that have formed the organization in today’s classrooms. This paper will address the differences in the theories and the similarities. It will describe how each theory can be implemented in the learning environment of an early childhood classroom. Lastly, it will describe each theory that will be compared supported by research. Comparison of two Theories Operant Behavior Conditioning of Burrhus Frederic Skinner (1904-1990) BF Skinner renowned for his theory of Operant Behavior (Maslow and Skinner: n.d.). He is known for, his leadership in the field behavior modification through conditioning. This states that behavior is affected by the consequence that follows the behavior. This is a practice teachers, utilize in the classrooms every day as part of the classroom management process: if the behavior of the child or children is unacceptable, the consequence will not be favorable. If the behavior is positive, the consequences will also be positive. Really, Skinner's theory states that good behavior is reinforced while bad behavior is reprimanded (Maslow and Skinner, n.d.). Ultimately, Skinner believed that in order to change behavior there had to be a positive stimulus to reinforce that behavior. Added...

Words: 1324 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Introdution to Management Unit 1

...all over the world strive to achieve in order to obtain the maximum profits. Management theories evolve from certain business gurus' perspectives on how to run the most efficient business, although some of them are arcane and hard to implement; many feature plenty of good concepts that are practiced in thousands of businesses. (Ehow, 1999-2012) The video discusses Classical, Behavioral, Systems and Contignecy maanagment theories. In this paper I will compare and contrast the previous mentioned theories and dicsuss which one I think is more important and why. The classical management theory is a method of management thought in which theorists determined how to find the best possible way for workers to perform their tasks. The classical management theory is divided into two branches, the classical scientific and the classical administrative. The classical scientific branch comes from the scientific mindset of attempting to increase productivity. During the height of the classical scientific theory, theorists would use almost mechanical methods towards labor and organization to achieve goals of productivity and efficiency. Some of the basic techniques of the classical scientific theory include creating standardized methods for a task and dividing work between employees equally. The classical administrative theory focuses on how management can be organized to achieve productivity. Henri Fayol, a leading figure in management theory, devised several management...

Words: 494 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Economics

...Cited Length: 1187 words (3.4 double-spaced pages) Rating: Red (FREE) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - My research of Classical Economics and Keynesian Economics has given me the opportunity to form an opinion on this greatly debated topic in economics. After researching this topic in great lengths, I have determined the Keynesian Economics far exceeds greatness for America compared to that of Classical Economics. I will begin my paper by first addressing my understanding of both economic theories, I will then compare and contrast both theories, and end my paper with my opinions on why I believe Keynesian Economics is what is best for America. Classical Economics is a theory that suggests by leaving the free market alone without human intervention; equilibrium will be obtained. This theory was the first school of thought for economists and one of the major theorists and founders of Classical Economics was Adam Smith. Smith stated, “By pursuing his own interest, he (man) frequently promotes that (good) of the society more effectually than when he really intends to promote it. I (Adam Smith) have never known much good done by those who affected to trade for the public...

Words: 1342 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Homework

...preschooler Jasmine. Watch the following video to learn more about the similarities and differences of developmental theories. Study of the Child: Theories of Development I, produced by Herzog, Milan & Herzog, Shanta (Learning Seed, 1997), 29:02 mins obtained from Alexander Street Press Education in Video from AUO Library. Compare and contrast the approaches of each of the four perspectives (Piaget, Erikson, Skinner, and Vygotsky). Explain how each theorist would approach the issue of cognitive development in early childhood. Describe how Keith’s advice to Jasmine’s parents might vary depending on his theoretical perspective. What role would society and family play in Jasmine’s cognitive development at this stage of development? What cultural, psychosocial and physical influences will be seen? Incorporate information learned in your readings and at least one peer-reviewed* article from the AUO library to support your conclusions. * Peer reviewed means an article from a reputable journal, which can be found in the library. Peer reviewed indicates that other professionals in the field have reviewed and deemed it worthy of publication, in contrast to much if what we find online: someone posting something they want, without someone else verifying that their methods were rigorous enough and the study is valid. Use your book and course lectures as your primary resources, as well as articles from our library. If you...

Words: 509 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Cj 305 Final Exam

...types of office policy that influence prosecutors’ decision making according to discussion by Jacoby, Mellon, and Smith 3. Describe and discuss the major ethical issues for judges as presented in your text 4. Discuss the various forms of forensic testimony and why they have been criticized 5. Where do rules of behavior for attorneys come from, and how are they enforced? 6. Discuss the number of innocents who may be imprisoned. What are the sources for the estimates? What are the criticisms of the sources? 7. Discuss the seemingly contradictory ideal that to ensure the natural rights presented by natural law theorists there must be both less government involvement and more government involvement. 8. Define punishment and then discuss the major rationales of punishment. 9. What are Mackie’s three types of retribution? Compare and contrast them 10. Describe how CO’s have discretion similar to police officers and court personnel. 11. List and describe some forms of corruption committed by CO’s. 12. What are some ways to reduce corruption in the prison environment? 13. Describe the discretion of probation and parole officers and provide examples of ethical and unethical applications of discretion 14. Discuss ethical issues for probation and parole officers and differentiate them 15. Describe the types of probation officers and ethical issues for each. 16. Explain how Abu Ghraib can provide us with lessons for managing the ethical...

Words: 401 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Psychology

...1. Compare and contrast various views of Hinduism, Buddhism, and Taoism. Hinduism is a religion meaning part of three main parts which include Vishnaism, Saivism and the Saktism. People must therefore follow the gods from one of the above three. Budhism on the other hand comes from the word buddhi which can be defined as the process of waking up. Budhism is therefore the awakening philosophy. These origins of this philosophy are derived from Budha who awakened at the age of thirty five. Taoism on the other hand is an ethical or religious tradition from the Chinese faith. Tao means something that is the source of and force behind all that exists. In comparison, Hinduism is about understanding Brahm, from within the Atman which roughly means from within the soul, whereas Budhism is all about finding Anatman which is not soul. Hinduism is about finding the highest life by removing bodily distractions from life. Taoism on the other hand means the way, which is a Chinese quotation meaning Tao is found in the world through nature and can be experienced through a mystical experience. Buddhism is carried out in Monasteries, nunneries and temples while Hinduism is carried out in a temple. In comparison, both Buddhism and Hinduism and Taoism embrace the use of statues and pictures.in addition to that both also follow the Dharma which is the common religious law. In Budhism, the clergy consists of monks and nuns who follow teachings of the Budha under the name Sangha whereas in Hinduism...

Words: 1511 - Pages: 7