Premium Essay

Comparing My Last Duchess 'And Porphyria's Lover'

Submitted By
Words 686
Pages 3
To be jealous, by definition, is “feeling or showing of someone”. One may be jealous of another due to an achievement or them being close to another person that they hold dearly. Typically jealousy can be expressed by enemies and friends, but mostly by lovers. The jealousy between lovers can be so intense that it causes extreme consequences. Most of the time the couple just parts ways and bids adieu. However, in the stories “My Last Duchess” and “Porphyria’s Lover”, both written by Robert Browning, the lovers are set to kill in order to satiate their jealous tendencies. Both main male characters in these stories believe that their lovers set out to purposely infuriate them causing the jealousy. Despite this, neither the Duchess nor Porphyria …show more content…
He then goes on to talk about how due to the attention she was given by others, “her looks went everywhere”(24). He believed that she appreciated the affection and attention of others more than she appreciated the ‘greatest’ gift he could have offered her: His “nine- hundred- years- old name”(33). Alas, she tragically died by an unknown cause. However, it is highly suggested that he murdered her or had her murdered after stating that he tried to change her behavior previously. “Oh sir, she smiled no doubt, whene’er I passed her; but who passed without much the same smile? This grew; I gave commands; then all smiles stopped together”(43). She was a kindly woman who smiled at those who complimented her, yet he took that as unfaithfulness and unappreciation. “A heart- how shall I say- too soon made glad, too easily impressed; she liked whatever she looked on . . .”(22). How the Duke perceives the Duchess is mainly in his own mind than what is actually true in reality. He believes she is unfaithful solely because that is what he thinks he is seeing even though what is actually happening in that she is simply a kind …show more content…
Due to this she refuses to accept his marriage proposal since that would mean dropping her name, forcing her to enter into a lower class. The man does not understand this and it makes him fairly upset and jealous of her social ranking. In order to soothe his pain she cuddles up to him, he told of how she was“murmuring how she loved me- she too weak, for all her heart’s endeavors to set its struggling passion free from pride”(21). After hearing so, he “knew Porphyria worshipped [him]: surprise made [his] heart swell, and still it grew while [he] debated what to do”(32). After deciding to strangle her with her own hair he laid her to eternal sleep on his shoulder so that she would love him forever more. His desire to have her love, her devotion, to him drove him to murder her so that she would never question her social status again, inducing another jealous episode. She never meant to cause him jealousy, she was only wanting to consider heavily whether it would be worth giving up her status in society. She attempted to make him feel better, to forgive her. “When glided in Porphyria; straight she shut the cold out and the storm, and kneeled and made the cheerless grate blaze up . . . and, last, she sat down by my side and called me. When no voice replied she put my arm about her waist, and made smooth her white shoulder bare, and all her yellow hair displaced . .

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Comparison Plays/Poems

...Literature Essay - Draft Throughout the four poems; "To his Coy Mistress" "My Last Duchess" "Porphyria's Lover" and "Havisham." there is a constant attitude towards women and themes such as violence, possession and patriarchal society are present. However these all differ in nature and theme despite the resounding attitude towards women. THCM is written in 17th Century and the poem depicts a man's urges to will a woman into bed with him. The poem has a light tone and humorous aspects throughout. In contrast MLD which is written in 19th Century has a much darker and menacing tone; it is about a controlling Duke and his previous duchess and unravels the dark story behind them. PL is a Victorian poem, the poem is gothic, crude and perverted in parrts with a man's strange insane intentions. However all these poems are linked by the idea of the male possessing and controlling a woman. H on the other hand is a woman's interpretation of a 19th century fictional character and how this character is left with feelings of violent hatred after being let down in marriage by her fiancé who has wed her to gain some of her riches. The theme of the poem is violent and confrontation but does compare and contrast with PL with the gothic nature. These four dramatic monologues do vary in storyline and tone however he same themes are made apparent in all of them and is what gives these poems a link and comparisons. Desire, death, domination and obsession as well as the balance of control between...

Words: 3218 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Poetry Gcse Summary

...The Beggar Woman by William King | The Poet: William King (1663-1712)Little is known about William King except that he was educated at Christ Church College Cambridge, and made a living as a lawyer and judge while writing occasional satires and comic verse, most of which were published anonymously. | The Beggar Woman is like a story, it suggests that it should be read to people. This is again because it is aimed at lower class and uneducated people who would have to have someone read it to them rather than reading it for themselves. It is written in the tradition of the street or broadside ballads, printed stories in verse that were sold cheaply and passed around for pleasure, often dealing with popular scandals and murder stories. In a time before the popular press and television chat shows, these ballads satisfied a need for entertaining stories, a tradition that has deep roots in oral traditions of storytelling and wandering minstrels.At the beginning of this poem, there is a description of a gentleman out hunting, which is an upper class activity, as they are the only people who could afford to take part in such an expensive activity, also by the fact he is described as a 'Gentleman' suggests he belongs to the upper class or 'Gentry'. The 'Gentleman gets separated from his group and spots the 'Beggar Woman'. He then propositions her for sex. She obliges and they wander off into the nearby wood. She is described as 'game', because really to the man that is all she is...

Words: 4592 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Kant Questiions

...White Man’s Burden (Handout) Summary & Annotation: A straightforward analysis of the poem may conclude that Kipling presents a"Euro-centric" view of the world, in which people view society from only a European cultures point of view. This view proposes that white people consequently have an obligation to rule over, and encourage the cultural development of people from other ethnic and cultural backgrounds until they can take their place in the world by fully adopting Western ways. The term "the white man's burden" can be interpreted simply as racist, or taken as a metaphor for a condescending view of non-Western national culture and economic traditions, identified as a sense of European ascendancy which has been called "cultural imperialism". A parallel can also be drawn with the charitable view, common in Kipling's formative years, that the rich have a moral duty and obligation to help the poor "better" themselves whether the poor want the help or not until according to Europeans, "they can take their place in the world socially and economically." The term "white man's burden" is a phrase that became current in the controversy about the United States acquisition of the Philippines after the Spanish-American war of 1898. It was a concept that was the responsibility of white Europeans to bring "proper" European civilization to the nations (mostly brown, black, red or yellow) that did not have it. The underlying thought was that Europeans were correct in their beliefs and...

Words: 5749 - Pages: 23