Free Essay

Critical Paper 3- Walmart

In:

Submitted By avisarsharma
Words 271
Pages 2
ETHC 3311 – Ethics Fundamentals
Critical Analysis #3
Due: Friday, June 12th @ 9:00pm MDT
On page 128 of McLachlan (2009), use Exercise 4.4 as a guideline to writing journal #3 with two opposing right versus right views.
The 2 articles for comparison are on pages 287 to 290. They are:
· article one - “ROB Ranks Wal-Mart Among Canada’s Best Employers”;
· article two - “The Cost of Walmartization”.
State your position after presenting the arguments from the 2 articles by answering this question: After analysis of the two articles, would you still shop at Wal-Mart? Why? Why not? Format: APA style of writing. 3 pages, not including the cover and reference pages.
This is a mini example of how to treat your research paper. Of course, you will research and read on more than two opposing publications on the ethical issue of your research paper. Remember, once more, to ground your analysis in relevant course theory. While you are asked to offer your perspective (as to whether you’d shop at Walmart), you are asked to ground your rationale within an appropriate ethical framework – this is not meant to serve as an opinion paper.
_____________________________________________________________________________
FORMAT
Theoretical Approach of Author in Article 1
Theoretical Approach of Author in Article 2
Backup the Approaches for Author 1- Three to six sentence paragraph
Backup the Approaches for Author 2- Three to six sentence paragraph
Compare and Contrast
Which Article is more convincing? Credentials, Facts and Stats, Balanced, etc- Paragraph
Opinion Piece- Short Paragraph
_____________________________________________________________________________
ROB Ranks Wal-Mart Among Canada’s Best Employers
- Market News, March 29, 2007
The Cost of Walmartization
- Znet, January 16, 2005

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

First Paper

...First Paper The traditional retail model has focused on finding high-margin, high-volume products or services because limited space means reduced space inventory. For example, organizations such as Walmart select the biggest hits from the broadest genres, called the “short head.” The short head means Walmart will only carry a select mix of country, pop, and rock that is calculated to provide the greatest cost/benefit. The business model of Amazon is different. Amazon provides the short head but also provides the “long tail” of more than 100,000 different audio selections. The competition for customers between the Walmart and Amazon marketplace is profoundly changing the face of retail business today. Using the assigned reading and the Argosy University online library resources, find at least three scholarly articles that address similar current trends related to e-business and how e-business is changing the face of businesses today. Using your company or a real-world example from your research, respond to the following: * Describe how technology is changing the face of businesses today. * Describe the most critical business processes that utilize information systems in your selected company. * Explain how IT makes the company’s business processes faster, cheaper, more accurate, and customer-savvy than that of competitors. * Cite at least three sources found in your online library research. Give reasons and examples from your research to support your responses...

Words: 276 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Walmart Amazon Supply Chain

...Widad Alharthi 822694 Di Cao Wasinee Phornnarit Yang Chan Table of Contents Introduction: 2 1. Supply Chain Management Practices 4 1.1 Walmart 4 1.1.1 Strategic allignemnt 4 1.1.2 procurement and distribution 5 1.1.3 Logistic and distribution management 5 1.1.4 Inventory management 6 1.2 Amazon 8 2. Strategic Alliances 9 2.1 Walmart 9 2.2 Amazon 10 3. Technologies employed in the SC Network 11 3.1 Walmart 11 3.2 amazon 13 4. Challenges and risks 14 4.1 Walmart 14 4.2 Amazon 15 5. Comparison of sustainable strategies in Supply Chains 16 conclusion 17 References: 18 Appendices: 19 Section A: 19 Section B: 19 Section C: 20 Introduction: Executive summary: This report provides an analysis and evaluation of the current supply chain strategies employed by two leading retail corporates, Walmart and Amazon. The report draws attention to the following aspects; supply chain management practices, strategic alliances, Information Technology, challenges and risks,finally sustainability in the supply chain. Method of the analysis includes reviewing a collection academic journals from different databases, analysing company’s annual reports and viewing news article for new trends and announcements about the company. The finding of this paper shows how both companies apply different supply chain models to support their business strategy but yet some similarities appear especially in technology aspect of the...

Words: 3354 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Sweatshop

...although they have the small income. In this article, the author used others’ opinion, details and facts to develop her topic. The data and cases were enough to prove the argument, and the evidence was very creditable and believable. Although this article argued in the opposite way with me, it gave my article a new perspective about the sweatshop labors. What's more, the author gave me a good evidence about counterargument, which work at the sweatshop is better than no jobs. Then I can refutation this counterargument that the sweatshop conflicts with the moral standards. In this way, I can make my argument stronger. Meyers, C. (2004). Wrongful Beneficence: Exploitation and Third World Sweatshops. Journal of Social Philosophy, 35(3), pp. 319 – 333. doi: http://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9833.2004.00235.x This article argues that apparel manufacturers and their contractors do exploit workers frequently. Trough the research, the author...

Words: 1017 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Final Project

...assessed in measurable way. 2. What, if anything, can be done to reduce the daily variability in pickup call-ins? Can the driver be expected to be at several locations at once at 5pm? To reduce daily variability in pickup call-ins, the company should avoid call-ins during peak time; what I mean is that the company can offer to its customer’s deals to call at maybe nights when the network is not that busy so people for important calls only can use and benefit from the network. By offering deals to clients that call at night times the driver might be able to make to several place before peak time which is 5pm. This strategy can be apply in order to reduce the business during the day time so the driver can easily and correctly do their job. 3. How should package pickup performance be measured? Are standards useful in an environment that is affected by weather, traffic, and other random variables? Are other companies having similar problems? Package pickup performance should be measurable by surveying the customers. Customers can give an idea of their satisfaction, about how the goods are coming to them. Feedbacks are necessary for the company so that it can generate new ways of improvement. Standards are useful in an environment that is affected by the weather, traffic and other...

Words: 2016 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Test

...Running head: Walmart Information Systems 1 Walmart Information Systems Research Project-Group2 CIS 511 Fall 2011 Amber Slemmons, Brooke Williams, Cheri Evans, Ismael Molina, & Wesley Belz Walmart Information Systems Walmart Information Systems Executive Summary: 2 Walmart, the billion dollar retail giant, has grown significantly over the past five decades, incorporating numerous different types of information systems into their daily operations. The company is well recognized for their innovation when it comes to utilizing the latest technologies and information systems to maximize their profitability. Information systems structures and processes play a critical role in Walmart’s success and today they are bringing that innovative spirit to the market as they move toward full implementation of Radio Frequency Identification (RFID). This technology allows for Walmart’s operations to function efficiently and effectively as they are capable of sending and receiving real time data to the networks. By doing so they are able to communicate the information to the retailer and the product manufactures making it possible for Walmart to remain competitive in the retail industry by properly controlling its inventories. This report will explain how Walmart has utilized several information systems throughout the course of its history such as: point of sale, satellite communication systems, data warehouses, retail link systems, electronic data interchange (EDI), and most recently...

Words: 4729 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

Economy

...company in particular that has developed strategies that were influenced by microeconomic changes. A great example is when McDonald’s entered the Chinese market they had to take into consideration consumer taste and acceptance in China. They had to decided whether or not to have the menu in Chinese or English and whether or not to take on the American menu or add more Chinese influenced menu items. Cost also played a part in the China market. Beef was much more expensive and so therefore could only reach a certain percentage of the people. Half of McDonald’s sales in China had been of chicken product with beef only making up 35 percent . 2. Compare and contrast McDonald’s strategies in China with those in Walmart in Mexico. Walmart competitive strategies: Walmart changed its...

Words: 1682 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Wal Mart Case Study

...[;’p// Walmart Case Study: Half a Century of Supply Chain Management SCM 607 Dr. John Wu March 15, 2014 Table of Contents INTRODUCTION 4 BACKGROUND OF THE COMPANY 4 GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 5 KEY ISSUES 6 EXTERNAL ANALYSIS 7 Economy 8 Customer Behavior 8 Technology 8 Politics & Legal Aspects 8 INTERNAL ANALYSIS 9 Company Culture 9 Operations 9 Purchasing & Suppliers 10 Inventory 10 Logistics 10 SWOT ANALYSIS 11 Strengths 11 Procurement 11 Distribution 12 Store Network 12 Information Systems 13 Weaknesses 14 Procurement 14 Store Network 14 Human Resources 14 Focusing on the Supply Chain 14 Opportunities 15 Focusing on the Supply Chain 15 New Initiatives and a Reorganization 15 Threats 16 Human Resources 16 DECISIONS 17 CONCLUSION 18 EXHIBIT 3 19 EXHIBIT 3 (continued) 20 EXHIBIT 3 (continued) 21 EXHIBIT 5 22 REFERENCES 23 Walmart Case Study: Half a Century of Supply Chain Management INTRODUCTION Walmart dominates the retailing industry in terms of its sales revenue, its customer base, and its ability to drive down costs and deliver good value to its customers. After all, the world’s largest corporation, employing 1.8 million associates worldwide, takes pride in having received numerous accolades for its ability to continuously improve efficiency in the supply chain while meeting its corporate mandate of offering customers everyday low prices. Walmart demonstrates how a physical product retailer...

Words: 4242 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Big Data

...business-related cybersecurity scenarios. Competencies: Critical thinking, communication skills Select three organizations within the same industry from the list below and     1.    Briefly describe the organizations and their missions (stated on their web site).     2.    Identify and list the similarities and differences among the organizations’ privacy policies.     3.    For each organization, recommend changes to their policies that could (a) better protect customers’ or consumers’ privacy, and (b) give the organizations more flexibility to use personal information of customers while still avoiding privacy or liability issues. Readings 1. U.S. citizens and non-U.S. citizens’ rights as granted in the 4th amendment, the Freedom of Information Act, the Privacy Act of 1974, the Communication Assistance for Law Enforcement Act (CALEA), the PATRIOT Act, the Protect America Act, and the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act 2. Additional privacy protective laws including the Fair credit reporting Act, and the Electronic Communication Privacy Act 3. Industry specific privacy laws–HIPAA, GLBA, and HITECH—p. 124-136 in the custom textbook You may need to use trade journals and newspaper stories in your reference list.  However, try to avoid opinion pieces (like blogs) that may not be factual.  You may state your own opinions, but these must be strengthened by scholarly references.  PS: Prepare your paper in Word format. It should be double-spaced with one-inch...

Words: 1023 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Human Resource Management Strategies of Wal-Mart

...Human Resource Management Strategies of Wal-Mart       TITLE OF ASSIGNMENT:   Human Resource Strategy of Wal-Mart inc Table of Contents Table of Contents (This page) ------------------------------------------------------------------------2 1.0 Introduction ------------------------------------------------------------------------3 2.0 Wal-Mart Human resource strategy ------------------------------------------------------------------------4 2.1 Recruitment and selection ------------------------------------------------------------------------4 2.2 Training and development ------------------------------------------------------------------------6 2.3 Employee motivation and Reward / benefits         ---------------------------------------------------------7 2.3.1 Financial benefits   ------------------------------------------------------------------------8 2.3.2 Health and awareness benefits   ------------------------------------------------------------------------8 2.4 Performance management               --------------------------------------------------------------------------9 3.0 Challenges faced by the human resources -----------------------------------------------------------------9 4.0 Recommendations to overcome these challenges     -----------------------------------------------------10 1.0 INTRODUCTION Human resource management according to Wilton (2011) in his book “an introduction to human resource management” is a phrase used...

Words: 4646 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

Online Files

...Chapter Eleven: Order Fulfillment Along the Supply Chain and Other EC Support Services 11-1 Online File W11.1 What Services Do Customers Need? Insights on online customer services: ◗ Customer preferences. Customers tend not to do much self-service in terms of getting information from companies (e.g., only 19% use FAQs), so they require attention. As more companies offer online self-service, though, this situation is changing. When contacting companies for information, customers use e-mail more than the telephone (71% versus 51%). ◗ Types of service. Four types of service exist, based on where the customer is in the purchase experience: during shopping (search products, compare, find product attributes); during buying (questions on warranties, billing, receipt, payment); after placing the order (checking status in processing and in shipping); and after receiving the item (checking return procedures, how to use the item). ◗ Problem resolution. Customers expect quick resolutions to problems, and expect problems to be resolved to their satisfaction. Therefore, easy returns and order tracking are desirable. ◗ Shipping options. Several shipping options are usually needed to make customers happy. ◗ Fraud protection. Customers need to make sure that sellers or others are not going to cheat them (Chapters 9 and 14). ◗ Order status and updates. Customers want to have some way to check on the status of their order, which involves tracking either by phone or online. These services...

Words: 7887 - Pages: 32

Premium Essay

Strategic Hr Plan

...November 3, 2014 Instructor Table of Contents Executive Summary………...……………………………………………………………………3 Choice of Organization - Walmart……………………………………………………………….5 Environmental Analysis………………………………………………………………………….6 Divisional Effectiveness Measurements...……………………………………………………….8 Final Report………………………………………………………………………………………9 Cultural HR Issues……………………………………………………………………….10 Emerging HR Issues………….……………………………………………………….....12 Five Year Action Plan……………………………………………………………………………16 References………………………………………………………………………………………..17 Executive Summary Walmart is one of the world’s largest retailers, serving communities worldwide and employing millions throughout their growing organization. This global organization has faced large amounts of scrutiny over the years and has seen legal repercussions from failure to comply with labor laws. Continuing to grow and rise above competitors, Walmart’s strategic HR plan needs to address some of these key opportunities and set the right employees in place to deliver on the company mission and vision. An effective strategic plan will also benefit the organizations reputation and image, both internally and externally. Ongoing pressures and cultural HR issues Walmart faces includes environmental preservation and the companies initiatives to “go green”, as well as the organizations reservations and discouragement towards unionization. These are issues Walmart can...

Words: 3385 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Human Resource Strategy of Walmart

...resourse strategy of University of Salford Salford Business School Course: MSC Management Module title: Human Resource Management TITLE OF ASSIGNMENT: Human Resouce Strategy of Wal-Mart inc Name: Agbasimelo E. Ifeanyi Roll no: @00316215 Instructed by: Abdoulie SALLAH Table of Contents Table of Contents (This page) ------------------------------------------------------------------------2 1.0 Introduction ------------------------------------------------------------------------3 2.0 Wal-Mart Human resource strategy ------------------------------------------------------------------------4 2.1 Recruitment and selection ------------------------------------------------------------------------4 2.2 Training and development ------------------------------------------------------------------------6 2.3 Employee motivation and Reward / benefits ---------------------------------------------------------7 2.3.1 Financial benefits ------------------------------------------------------------------------8 2.3.2 Health and awareness benefits ------------------------------------------------------------------------8 2.4 Performance management --------------------------------------------------------------------------9 ...

Words: 4668 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Analysis of Green Supply Chain Management in the Retail Industry

...should be addressed throughout the supply chain. This had led to the emergence of the concept suggested to as Green Supply Chain Management (GSCM). This research provided a concise background and challenges of green supply chain through applying qualitative analysis on potential implementation in existing literature. This research was use secondary data to analyze a single case study, which is a case study of Walmart GSCM. Data was collected through a quality source by process of evaluating the information sources. The research analysis have shown seven strategies that used at Walmart: Identifying goals, metrics, and new technologies, Providing network partner assistance to suppliers, Certifying environmentally sustainable products, Incentive for green products, Consolidating direct suppliers, Developing a sustainable standard, and Zero waste. In a conclusion, it was possible to understand that GSCM is one of the emerging approaches for retail industry. This approach had help the company differentiates from its competition and made its supply chain more efficient. This paper was useful in providing suggestions to the retail industry and other industries to either modify the GSCM strategy adopted within organization in order to achieve the required target, or identify the most suitable GSCM strategy to be implemented. Keywords: Supply Chain Management, Retail industry, Green Supply Chain Chapter 1: Introduction The world is warming. The average temperature has risen by...

Words: 8726 - Pages: 35

Premium Essay

Strategic Management 4e11

...4E11 Final Assignment You must be familiar with Wal-Mart, the US giant discount retailer. For the purposes of this course and drawing on the material we have discussed in class, I would like you to (1) evaluate Wal-Mart’s current strategy, (2) discuss and evaluate the options Wal-Mart has for geographic expansion and (3) discuss and evaluate the options Wal-Mart has for diversifying into another industry (pick one). Following I provide you with ten possible source of information on Wal-Mart and its strategy. You can use more, but do not get lost in research for more and more information. Keep in mind that the most important part of your grade will be the evaluation and critical parts of your paper. In other words, spend enough (more) time and effort in evaluating Wal-Mart’s strategy and expansion options. Possible Sources: 1. http://corporate.walmart.com/ 2. Freeman, R. 2006, The Wal-Mart Effect and Business, Ethics, and Society. Academy of Management Perspectives, Vol. 20 Issue 3, p38-40 (you can find this from ABI) 3. Ghemawat, Pankaj, 2006, Business, Society, and the "Wal-Mart Effect" Academy of Management Perspectives, Vol. 20 Issue 3, p41-4 (you can find this from ABI) 4. Case on Wal-Mart from Grant, R.M. (2005/8) Contemporary strategy analysis. 5th or 6th ed. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing HD30.28.G72 2005/8 – or any subsequent edition (latest edition is 9th) 5. http://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3AWMT&fstype=ii&ei=mRRxUOiwHIOwkAXYpgE ...

Words: 310 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Hrm 430 Course Project

...Benefit Strategy of an Organization Jane Q. Student DeVry University Professor Dibenedetto June 23, 2013 Abstract: The aim of this paper is to examine the compensation challenges within Owens & Minor and create a compensation strategy that will benefit not only the company, but the employee. With the constant change in today’s business world, to have a competitive advantage makes it difficult for employers to attract and retain the most talented employees. Identifying the company’s compensation strategy ensures the organization offers the right pay and manages the pay increases to retain top talents. When we hear the word compensation we think about compensating an employee for their work performed, but there is much more to compensation and a company’s strategy than what a person is paid. Compensation and benefits, “includes not only salary, but also the direct and indirect rewards and benefits the employee is provided with in return for their contribution to the organization. To determine compensation, organizations should develop a compensation and rewards program that outlines an equitable process for compensating employees” (“Compensation and Benefits,” n.d.). This plan is an extremely important piece of the overall HR approach to keep the company competitive and successful in the global market. Throughout this paper we will discuss the compensation and benefits strategy of the organization and recommendations on how to create a well-structured program. As...

Words: 2720 - Pages: 11