Free Essay

Discrimination Legislation

In: Business and Management

Submitted By nene0687
Words 1493
Pages 6
Discrimination Legislation
Vernecia Denson
American Intercontinental University
March 10, 2012

In this paper, you will learn and know how to recruit for a more diverse work team. The word affirmative action will be recognized and defined. You will learn what the initial intent of Affirmative-Action legislation was and why it was created. We will distinguish what the positive and negative results of the Affirmative Action legislation and is this legislation still appropriate today. We will learn what the landmark of Bakke v. Regents case included and how it applied and ties in with affirmative action. We will see what was the basis for the conclusion of this case?

When thinking about discrimination in the workforce, the words affirmative action comes to mind. Affirmative action was a law put into action to take positive steps that would increase the representation of minorities and women in areas of employment, education, and businesses from which in historical times were excluded (Fullinwider, 2009). Affirmative action wanted to increase not noticing the basic structures based off of race, gender, or ethnicity when making decisions (Fullinwider, 2009). This action is still around till this day.
Affirmative action was initiated first by President John F. Kennedy in 1961. This order showed that Federal contractors was suppose to take affirmative action to guarantee that job applicants and employees are treated fairly and would have a fair opportunity regardless of their race, color, or national origin (Fullinwider, 2009). Three years later, the Civil Rights act will take consideration and will be defined on the same terms.
Affirmative action was first started because people thought that if they just simply tried stopping discrimination against the minorities, than that would overcome the results from past employment and promotion patterns. Earlier before the 1960s, most employers were hired by word of mouth. This ment that friends or relatives of current employees were more than likely to be hired (Fullinwider, 2009).
Initially, affirmative action was to refer to numerous activities to guarantee the fairness of hiring and promotion decisions. This was more drawn towards individuals to encourage those who were previously excluded to apply for jobs, admission to colleges, and other business that they once was turned down the opportunity (Pasour, 2011).
Kennedy’s executive order implied equal access and nothing else. The act that has come about since the 60’s is a perversion of the original intent of affirmative action.
First, affirmative action promoted the hiring of the less skilled workers. It was forcing employers to choose the best of the minority workers they could find, regardless of whether they have the required job skills. Colleges and universities frequently also had quotas for how many blacks or minorities that was necessary to admit to meet their freshman class qualifications. Years later this action would go in to add women the same opportunities that this law gave to minorities (Pasour, 2011).
One case that comes to mind when talking about affirmative action is the landmark of Bakke v. Regents case. This case took place in 1978. This case was a landmark decision of the Supreme Court of the United States that ruled unconstitutional to the admission process of the Medical School at the University of California at Davis. Which because of affirmative action, this school had to set aside 16 out of the 100 seats for African American students. This diversity in the classroom was intended as justification for considering race as one of the factors in their admissions policies in which was changed and made different from the original purpose.
Allan Bakke, a 32-year-old white male, applied to twelve medical schools in 1973 and was rejected by all twelve schools. All schools pointed out his age, stating that it was higher than their age limit. He had high GPA scores all through school and even scored in the top 3 percent on the admissions exam but his age was his downfall. He never even took into consideration of that (McBride, 2007). In 1973 and 1974, Allan Bakke applied to University of California, Davis School of Medicine, but was once again rejected in both years. Special applicants were admitted eventhough, they had lower academic scores than Bakke's. Most people of the admission committee often turned down the well qualified minority applicants claiming that a 3.4 GPA was not a 3.6 GPA. These individuals were permitted due to the fact they fit into that minority group. This group that was accepted also included the economically and educationally disadvantaged individuals (McBride, 2007). Because of this action, a lot of the whites didn’t have an opportunity and it was kind of unfair towards them. After his second rejection, Bakke filed an action in the state court for mandatory, injunctive, and declaratory relief to compel his admission to Davis. He was alleging that the special admissions program that the committee or school used for admission excluded him on the basis of his race. This was in violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. UC Davis Medical School counter-claimed for a declaration that its special admissions program was lawful (McBride, 2007).
The claim went to trial and the court found that this program operated as a racial quota because the minority applicants in that program were rated only against one another, and the 16 places in the class were reserved for just for them (McBride, 2007). Because the Medical School could not satisfy its problem of representing that, Bakke would not have been admitted. The court ordered his admission to the Medical School. Bakke began his studies at the University of California Medical School at Davis in fall of 1978, graduated in 1982, and later served as a resident at Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota.
Since the Supreme Court decided to rule with Bakke, California has banned the state's use of race as a factor to consider admission into the public schools' policies. California's Proposal mandates that the state shall not discriminate against, or grant preferential treatment to any individual or group on the basis of the individuals race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin in the operation of public employment, public education, or public contracting (McBride, 2007).
The conclusion is that affirmative action cause’s reverse discrimination. Discrimination against white males is just as bad as discrimination against minorities. Some people say that affirmative action is justified as a way of making up for past discrimination. Discrimination still exists in the United States and it still exists in other parts of the world. Most blacks entering the job market today were born after the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and have suffered little or no prejudice in terms of salary. When this Civil Rights Act was passed, it was not planned to reverse discrimination but to get employers to consider all applicants who were filling out job applications for jobs within their companies. The Allan Bakke Supreme Court case showed that affirmative action can cause reverse discrimination. It showed that they were willing to accept a minority student at the expense of a white student who had better credentials. There are positive and negative effects when it comes to affirmative action. The positive is that it helps individuals who are minorities and who have an economic disadvantage have an opportunity towards something that they originally wouldn’t have had a chance to experience or achieve. A lot of black ancestors had nothing to leave to their children or pass down from generation to generation like the whites and this gave them opportunities.
The negative part is that affirmative action devalues the accomplishments of people who are chosen based on the social they belong too, rather than their qualifications. It is considered a reverse discrimination. This action replaced the old wrongs with new wrongs. This law included blacks and minorities but limited white men. This also undermines the achievements of minorities, and encourages individuals to identify themselves as disadvantaged. A lot of times they are not. This action also increases racial tension in the workforce. I believe that affirmative action can now be put to rest. The United States is more equal than it will ever be. The longer this law goes on the more lawsuits there will be. The change in our economy has changed this rule as well. Blacks, Hispanics, women are no longer the lower class or uneducated. This action will be discrimative against a lower class white man looking more at his skin color and not his background. We need to look more at the qualifications of an individual and do away with affirmative action. This rule is not making anyone equal.

References
Fullinwider, R. (2009). Affirmative Action Retrieved from http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2011/entries/affirmative-action/ Pasour, E. (2011). Affirmative Action: A Counterproductive Policy. Retrieved from http://www.thefreemanonline.org/columns/affirmative-action-a-counterproductive-policy/ McBride, A. (2007). Regents of University of California v. Bakke (1978). Retrieved from http://www.pbs.org/wnet/supremecourt/rights/landmark_regents.html

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Discrimination and Legislation

...Discrimination Legislation MGMT221-1004B-01 Nadeige Jovin American Intercontinental University 11/07/2010 Abstract In order to complete the diversity training manual; as a human resources manager, this paper will cover the definition of Affirmative Action, explain what the initial intent of Affirmative-Action legislation was. It will also talk about the landmark Bakke versus Regents case concluded, give the positive and negative results of Affirmative Action legislation, and tell if the Affirmative Action legislation is still appropriate in that situation.   Discrimination Legislation Introduction Some form of affirmative action had existed in the late 1800s but the extension and enforcement of it really started in the late 1900s. Effectively, the term “affirmative action” was first employed by President Lyndon Johnson in1965 in the Executive Order 11246. The order was applied to the federal government employees to make sure they were employed, treated without regard to their race, belief, color, and nationality. That order was expanded to protect women from discrimination in 1967 by Lyndon Johnson (www.wisegeek.com, Oct, 2010). Definition of Affirmative Action Affirmative action is a set of public positive policies and practices designed to help eliminate past and present discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin, against minorities in the search of employments, admission to colleges and universities or some government contracts...

Words: 1236 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Government Intervention

...Intervention from Governments can occur in many ways and also for many reasons. The main reasons for policy intervention are; to correct for market failure, to achieve a more equitable distribution of income and wealth and to improve the performance of the economy. When we have to evaluate the effects of the legislations put in place by the government it is important to consider the type of legislation implemented, its size and also the type of market that it is placed into as there will be different benefits and drawbacks for every business. That is why one of the most important factors to consider is the people who are being impacted within the business to see whether the government legislation is desirable. Regulation may be used to introduce fresh competition into a market. When a new business (competitor) enters a market, which may already contain businesses with high market share it can be extremely hard to attract and keep consumers. In order to provide opportunity and a chance to new businesses the government will help them for example breaking up the existing monopoly power of a service provider. An example of this is the attempt to introduce more competition for British Telecom, with businesses such as talktalk, Sky and plus net. This is known as market liberalisation. Here it shows it depends on which business in the market to see whether it does provide a level playing field and if it is desirable. For the new businesses this intervention from the government is priceless...

Words: 692 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Rh Bill: an Insight Fom the Ignorant

...addressed. | Catholic Church teaches that married couples may take advantage of the natural cycles of the reproductive system and use their marriage precisely those times that are infertile (natural family planning); in which case the RH Bill provided otherwise. | The RH Bill can greatly alter the increasing percentage of victims of sexually transmitted diseases like HIV, Syphilis, Gonorrhea and more. | INSIGHT: It is not fair for me to make a firm stand on the issue of institutionalizing the Reproductive Health Bill for the very fact that I, like most of us, have not read the entire provisions of the Bill. And I know for sure, that most of those who continuously blabber about the negativity of the bill have not read the entire legislation as well. It is pitiful to think that most of us battle and argue about this bill when most of us are half-blind about it. Despite this manifestation of my ignorance, I still find the passing of the Reproductive Health bill to become a national law, very fitting and timely considering the situation we have in our country. First and foremost, knowing...

Words: 575 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Planning the Tour

...Planning the Tour Visits by legislators to your company's facilities are an effective way for grassroots participants to build relationships with legislators. Plant tours illustrate first hand how plant processes relate to legislative issues and are an excellent tool for grassroots advocacy. Tours showcase your facilities' environmental, health, and safety standards and connect members with the interconnect technology industry first hand. The following guidelines will help you plan a successful plant tour: * Determine the objectives for the visit. Decide what issues you want to discuss and how best to link the issues visually with plant operations. Find out if the legislator has particular interests. * Issue the invitation in writing. Offer a range of dates to accommodate busy legislative schedules; dates during congressional recesses are especially appropriate. * Announce the legislator's visit to all employees. Once the tour is confirmed, promote it throughout the company by distributing a brief biography of the legislator and information about the legislator's importance. * Invite your company's government relations staff to participate in the tour. You may also want to consider inviting a few top community leaders and industry association executives. Be careful, however, to avoid a large tour group. * Arrange for photographs during the tour. Work closely with the legislator's press aide on publicity and news coverage. * Offer to provide or...

Words: 406 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Casinos Toronto Campaign

...No Casinos Toronto Campaign Student’s Name Institution No Casinos Toronto Campaign Conflict expansion is the incorporated use of advocacy and lobbying, in an attempt to influence legislation changes. In the No Casinos Toronto Campaign, the advocacy groups employed conflict expansion to carry out the course. The groups ensured that most individuals in Toronto are aware of the campaign, and what it entails. They also coerced councilors to make legislation in opposition of the intended casino in the city. In their campaign, the advocacy groups ensured that councilors did not have a wide room for voting in favor of the casino. Conflict expansion is the rigorous use of lobbying and advocacy to manipulate legislation, without giving legislators much of a choice. This essay will evaluate the efficacy of conflict expansion, in regard to No Casinos Toronto Campaign. The advocacy groups in the “No Casinos Toronto Campaign” first contacted the legislators in the city regarding their opposing views on the proposed mega-casino. They wrote to the relevant authorities, regarding the upcoming effects of the casino on the public, the businesses and the Toronto society in general. They tried to convince the councilors to legislate in opposition of the mega-casino proposition (TogetherToronto, 2013). After communicating their stand with the legislators, the advocacy groups then launched and online campaign. The online campaign was to...

Words: 840 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

To Some Extent, Government Investment Is the Most Important Factor in the Revival of British Industry

...manufacturing and the exciting careers that are available to inspire the next generation to go into engineering and manufacturing. This will assist with the skills shortage that the uk is currently facing. Airbus, the world’s leading aircraft company, received £1.4m in funding from the fund to help provide training to develop a £190m investment in the production of new low carbon diesel engines at its Dagenham, £8m of the investment coming from the Regional Growth fund, this investment will create 300 jobs in that area, further reducing unemployment and through the training scheme people will gain the necessary skills that they need to revive the British industry. Due to government legislation, companies need to become much more eco-friendly in order to perverse the economy, so to assist and support the new legislation, the government are providing funding into the low carbon vehicles, providing incentives to purchase electric vehicles, this allows the creation of more jobs to be created and more funding to be made for more research and...

Words: 320 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Crime

...CORRUPT PRACTICES Deborah Porter AIU Online Abstract While some people might believe that lobbying and bribery is wrong that depends upon the individual involved and probably the circumstances. Lobbying began in the 1830; the term lobbying is derived from the corridors and foyers of legislative chambers which are other wise as lobbies. Representative of special interest groups coming together to discuss issues in the lobbies of Congress and Legislature. Since that time lobbying has become the practice and profession of influencing government decisions and actions. Lobbying has become the practice for the agents of pressure groups gathering together to persuade legislators to support legislation favorable to them. Overall you can say lobbying is any sort of approach to obtain needed support. Bribery is the offering, giving, receiving, or soliciting something of value for the purposing of influencing the action of an official or individual. Most time a bribe is done when one wants to have their public or legal duties discharged. Usually bribery involves transferring cash or personal favors, the promise of paying at a later time and giving anything that the recipient deems to be of value. Bribery is a serious felony I most jurisdiction. The difference between the two is significant. Although both of these are used for personal gain; in lobbying there is no exchange of monies. In lobbying pressure groups mostly uses the power of persuasion to obtain the required...

Words: 514 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The President Has Ony the Power to Persuade

...Sates may been seen globally as one of the most powerful men in the world, it is argued that this is only a perception and in fact his power is restricted to persuasion of others who call the final shots. Due to the separation of powers in America the legislature, executive and judiciary are all completely separate which means to get items pasts of decisions made, people from each of these 3 main sections needs to do work. As the president is only head of the executive, he must rely on the support of other people to get hi desired bills and legislation passed. From this comes the argument that his only real main power is to persuade, as it is the 3 departments combined which actually do the work and all he has done is persuade people in these departments to side with him. The president actually has many specific powers he has responsibility for, ranging from the proposition of legislations, submitting the annual bill and veto of legislation, to acting as chief executive, negotiating treaties and acting as the overall commander-in-chief. These powers burden the president with great responsibility; he is looked to for advice and guidance from all areas of government. The president is the chief executive of the United States, putting him at the head of the executive branch of the government, whose responsibility is to “take care that the laws be faithfully executed.” To carry out this duty, the president is given control of the four million employees of the federal executive branch...

Words: 347 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Lobbying Essay

...Lobbying and Interest Groups Lobbyists can have both beneficial and negative effects when it comes to influencing government legislation for the sake of their respective interest groups. A lobbyist is someone who gets paid to speak on behalf of an interest group’s goals. These lobbyists can be former state legislators, legislative aides, and gubernatorial aides who try to educate congressmen and women, as well as a governors, legislators, or aides on the position of the interest group they represent. Currently, there are 1,666 lobbyists in Texas. In addition, one must register, by law, as a lobbyist if they make more than $1,000 on behalf of their interest group per yearly quarter or spend $500 or more influencing government decision makers. Some of the theoretical costs of lobbying are that since not all interest groups have as much money as others, they can not take as elaborate of steps to try to influence government decision makers, such as paying for things like entertainment, “educational” trips, etc. Some of these benefits for the wealthier interest groups (ie: business interest groups) can lead to misconstrued information and possibly seem to appear unethical to the average citizen, even if no laws are broken. After all, the interest groups that can, will take advantage of loopholes. On the flipside, the benefits are that these government decision makers will become educated, aware, and more understanding as to what a certain interest group’s goals are. So in conclusion...

Words: 255 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How Effectively Can the Judiciary Check Legislative and Executive Power in the Uk?

...the law to make it compatible with the HR Act. In this way, by notifying the government of a breach of the HR Act, the judiciary can prevent government and Parliament being too powerful. An example of this was in the case of A v Secretary of State for the Home Department (2004), where the detention without trial of 9 foreign nationals in Belmarsh prison under the 2001 Anti-Terrorism Crime and Security Act was ruled as in breach of Articles 5 and 14 of the HR Act. The government were forced to change the law and release the suspects demonstrating the definite check on power provided. Secondly, the process of judicial review is vital in checking the power of government, especially as regards the use of statutory instrument and delegated legislation. Judicial review is not like the above method of first instance where the rights and wrongs of the case are considered. Judicial review is a process of administrative justice that examines the procedure and legality of a government action. If the action has exceeded...

Words: 1089 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

101 Chambers Review

...institutions "have greatly influenced the design of the new Congress under the Constitution" (Squire and Hamm 34). The bicameral system had its originations in colonial governments and the original colonial constitutions had a large impact on the future constitutions. The bicameral legislation structure that is now common in the United States began in the colonial era. The original colonies has systems that greatly resembled that of the English system during the Tudor reign with an unicameral system made up of the governor, the councilors, and the general assembly that was made up by the colony's freemen. Massachusetts became the first colony to separate into two chambers, one made up of the council and the other made up of the general assembly. In the 1630s "the councilors and the members of the assembly developed different interests and concerns, and these differences led to conflict between them" (Squire and Hamm 34). State constitutions became more prevalent as the idea of independence from the crown grew stronger. The states wanted to have control over who would be appointed to represent them in their legislatures. Many of the structures had not been changed from the colonial legislations because the states already had experience of self-government and the bicameral system. The biggest changes came in the upper houses where the representatives became elected instead of appointed. The state constitutions included many new qualifications to serve in the legislatures including...

Words: 1269 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Role of Government in Policy-Making

...enact laws. It is the business of the executive branch to see that the laws are put into effect through various governmental departments and it is the business of the judiciary (the court system) to preside and rule over who is right or wrong according to the criminal, civil law and often administrative law. Before a social policy or program can come before the judiciary branch of government, someone must believe that a law has been broken. One of the most important parts of policy making are legislative tasks and these tasks are necessary for paving the way for getting a bill passed into law. First task: for an interest group is to clearly define its issue, have complete unanimity on what the problem is and what it wants by way of legislation. This task is crucial if they want any legislative or public support. Second task: create a position paper that organizes the arguments (pro and con) and summarizes what is known or unknown about the issue. Third task: create solutions for the social problem of concern such as a public policy, provision, or program design that...

Words: 795 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Role of Government in Policy-Making

...enact laws. It is the business of the executive branch to see that the laws are put into effect through various governmental departments and it is the business of the judiciary (the court system) to preside and rule over who is right or wrong according to the criminal, civil law and often administrative law. Before a social policy or program can come before the judiciary branch of government, someone must believe that a law has been broken. One of the most important parts of policy making are legislative tasks and these tasks are necessary for paving the way for getting a bill passed into law. First task: for an interest group is to clearly define its issue, have complete unanimity on what the problem is and what it wants by way of legislation. This task is crucial if they want any legislative or public support. Second task: create a position paper that organizes the arguments (pro and con) and summarizes what is known or unknown about the issue. Third task: create solutions for the social problem of concern such as a public policy, provision, or program design that...

Words: 795 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Global Pharmaceutical Industry

...pharmaceutical industry and the substantially significant factors that shape this industry; the industry is primarily defined by very few yet critically influential factors; these consist of: governing bodies, the role of corporate social responsibility, and the emphasis put on the industry and firms by the Research and Development process. The most consequential factor placing emphasis on the industry is the governing body, with it being the legislative body and largest purchaser of the industry exclusive of the USA creates a strategic dilemma for the corporations in terms of profit maximization. Patent limitation, regulatory controls, price or reimbursement controls and extensive safety legislations are methods adopted by the government to legislate control and limitations over the industry. These legislations construct a paradigm that the main objective behind the intervention is to keep medicinal costs low as the majority of the population i.e. under 18’s, over 65’s and people primarily on benefits, medical costs are paid for by the government and with the ageing population the expenditure is ever increasing hence the various limitations. Being the legislative body and the largest purchaser gives the government various types of buyer control; the case study implies that the industry is a “monopsony”, giving the corporations very little bargaining power in terms of profit maximization and can often alter the strategic outlook of a firm, a strategy synthesis states that in some opinions...

Words: 867 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The Rule Makers (Bookreview)

...BOOK REVIEW THE RULEMAKERS HOW THE WEALTHY AND WELLBORN DOMINATE CONGRESS The congress or the House of Representatives and the Senate or the upper house are the two components of the legislative branch of the Philippine government. They are meant to pass bills, create laws, and approve budgets that benefit their constituents and the nation as a whole. In theory, this is the ideal upon which they were built, they would legislate for the people to best serve them and to ensure the nations capacity to carry out the legislation that they pass and that they are aligned with the needs of the people they represent. This is not the case however, even as we step in to the 15th congress the House of Representatives is still truly not representative. Since the 1898 Malolos Congress to our 15th congress, The Filipino people have witnessed, participated, fought and experienced how senators and congressmen handle the power and opportunity they gain from membership in this institution. The way in which the power and privileges that come from their positions are used are often kept secret and outside the knowledge of their voters and even if it was known it is beyond the power of the citizenry to interfere in most cases. The Constitution imposes limitations and prohibitions and there are also general guidelines and principle of law that should be followed, however they do not seem enough of a deterrent to reduce or eradicate the illegitimate, illegal, manipulative, selfish...

Words: 2196 - Pages: 9