Free Essay

Do We Need Illegal Migrants?

In:

Submitted By maali
Words 1117
Pages 5
Mohamed Ali
KCC Composition II
7 Dec, 2013 Do we need illegal migrants?

There are many heard misconceptions about illegal immigration. Immigration levels have increased by a significant extent. People migrate for a variety of reasons and purposes, some are economic and others are non-economic. Any average people know the economic reasons, such as pursuing economic advantages, and educational opportunities. One of non-economic purposes is seeking friends or family members who have tried to cross into the US illegally. People make influence decisions to migrate illegally. The debate on illegal immigration has been a controversial and significant issue that needs addressed.
It is a public flurry issue in the United State of America in the recent times. Others say illegal migrants caused a sharp increase in crime rates in the U.S. whatever people argument about; it’s easy to overlook the fact that illegal immigrants are real and they entered the country with their own issues. They affected the economy and the lives of citizens in different ways, such as structural and psychological factors There are many whys and wherefores explaining the psychological factors for migration? Some of the most important structural reasons are better opportunities for work, to escape from the tyrant rulers, join their families, and find the best opportunities for their lives. The suffering migrants endure as the endeavor to enter the country, such as difficult geographical hurdles getting to and crossing the border. In spite of illegal residence and prosecuting authorities these people work and are part of the economy, which help the interest of the country. They pay taxes through the payment of sales tax, property tax, and other taxes, depending on the individual situations. U.S. native citizens blamed illegal immigrants for being in the country. Yet, the U.S. government has knowledge of entry of those illegal immigrants. Basically, employers make higher business profits through illegal immigration, so it benefits US government also. Many migrants are encouraged to enter the country illegally, by a large number of groups. Large and small companies are remaining in the market because of illegal workers, who entered the country illegally at the request of those companies. The companies pay low wages for labor while wanting competent and reliable workers. Most people say that undocumented workers significantly depress the wages of native born workers. Thus deprived of illegal workers, many companies might have rough sledding to productize. Brendan Flanagan, director of legislative affairs for the National Restaurant Association, insists “Restaurants, hotels, nursing homes, agriculture — a very broad group of industries — are looking for a supply of workers to remain productive.” We should accept Obama's immigration policy as it provides an opportunity for illegal immigrants to work legally, with temporary work permits. The report illustrates the desire of U.S government to deport illegal immigrants and separate them from their children- who are born in the U.S. Thus, causing families suffering, and to feel a substantial sense of unfairness. Immigration law needs immediate legislative consideration American citizens argue that the U.S borders aren’t secure enough to stop illegal immigrants. Rep. Tom Tancredo, R-Colo., a leading immigration-control advocate in Congress said “The reason we do not have secure borders is because of an insatiable demand for cheap labor.” Furthermore, the Democratic Party and Republican Party see illegal immigrants as source of voters and profitable cheap labor coming through unsecure borders.
Some of the public claim that illegal migrants are criminal minded, since they entered the country illegally. Rep. Steve King, (R-Iowa), said to his opposition to immigration "Some of them are valedictorians, and their parents brought them in," King said. "For everyone who's a valedictorian, there's another 100 out there that weigh 130 pounds and they’ve got calves the size of cantaloupes because they're hauling 75 pounds of marijuana across the desert." And he said "doesn't mean that there aren't groups of people in this country that I have sympathy for." He called them, those how are "undermining our culture and civilization." However, many studies showed illegal immigrants have a lower crime rate than native- born. The fiscal impact of all migrants, including illegal migrants is ongoing argument for long time. Illegal immigration has been created fiscal deficit for the federal government, which is not put a massive strain on the economy. The debate on welfare costs of illegal migrants in terms of government expenditures for education, criminal justice, and emergency medical care. The benefit costs in general are significant. On the other hand, illegal workers pay tax to the federal government, and they don’t get anything back. In fact, government barring them from welfare programs to minimize fiscal costs. Thus, illegal immigration is critically important to determining the actual fiscal impact. Many illegals acts are impose some costs on government, like enroll their kids in public school, using the roads. However, they pay excise and other types of taxes to the government, like buying books for their children. In addition, illegal immigration and its effects has been an ongoing debate. I argue that illegal migrants should be legalized, since they are not undermining U.S security. Some people argue that illegal immigrants are good for this country because they work for lower wages, which has been led some businesses to profit from those illegal workers, and those are the more plausible. Opponents argue that illegal immigrants took many jobs from American citizens and the country overwhelmed by them, which has put national security and the culture at risk. It is better for this country to allow illegal immigrants to be legalized; they would use services and pay taxes like most U.S citizens, moreover, they are willing to work at the most dangerous and hard jobs in the country, which American citizens are not willing to do it. For that reason, both business owners and the U.S. government are inevitably profit from them. The proposal of US government is somehow to make sure those undocumented workers have followed the American law.

Works Cited
Anderson, Oliver. “Illegal Immigration: Causes, Methods, and Effects.” Ed. Thomas Kenneth R. Illegal Immigration: A few psychological and structural considerations. New York: Nova Science Publishers. 2010. Library. Web. 30 Oct, 2013.
Katel, Peter. "Illegal Immigration." Letters, Arts & Social Sciences. 6 May 2005. Web. 30 Oct. 2013.
Kalita, S. Mitra. "Reaching for Legitimacy in the Immigrant Economy."
The Washington post. 10 Sept. 2006, Web. 30 Oct. 2013.
Tartar, Andre. "The Costs of Illegal Immigration: Education, Healthcare, and Remittances." Suite101.com: Online Magazine and Writers' Network. 14 July 2009. Web. 5 Dec. 2013.
Camarota, Stephen. "The High Cost of Cheap Labor Illegal Immigration and the Federal
Budget." Center for Immigration Studies. Web. 5 Dec. 2013.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

A Literature Review on Migration

...Table of Contents Table of Contents Migration Research Objective Introduction: ..................................... Part I Internal and International Migration 1. Linkages between Internal and international Migration 2. Characteristics of Migrants 3. Causes of Migration 4. Phases of migration Part II Temporary and Permanent Migration 1. Distribution of Egyptian migrants according to skill level 2. Distribution of Egyptian migrants according to Destination 3. Economic Effect of Migration 4. Impact of Migration 4.a. on the Labor Supply of Adults Left Behind 4.b. and remittances on household poverty 5. Remittances at micro-level 6. Remittances at macro-level 7. Remittances and Development 8. Volume of Remittances 9. Impact of remittances on poverty alleviation 10. Brain Drain/Gain (causes, effects and solutions) 11. Egyptian Migration To Arab Countries Part III Legal and Illegal Migration 1. Definition 2. Dimensions 3. Causes 4. Dangers 5. Methods 6. Legal and political status 7. Migration Stages 8. The gangs of illegal migration contrive new behaviors….. 9. Egypt youth migration ……….. Ideal cases Objective The whole theme of this paper is to vivid the magnitude of migration, to profile the workers who migrate, to identify the types of migration and to determine the extent to which migration affects the rate of poverty...

Words: 13903 - Pages: 56

Premium Essay

Immigration

...1. There are four important factors that cause international migration flows: economic pressures; social networks and connections between migrant sending and receiving countries; immigration policies; and cultural perceptions people in developing countries have about immigration and immigrant receiving countries. Indicate which of these you believe is the most important and second most important factors and explain why. There are four important factors that cause international migration flow. The most important factor is the economic pressures and second most important is the cultural perceptions people in developing countries have about immigration and immigrant receiving countries. Both these factors are relatively related and linked together. The most important factor that influences migration flows is the economic pressures. People who pursue better wages and a higher standard of living economically motivate most labor migrations. This is generated by the push- pull theory that explains how migrants are pushed to leave the areas of origin because of demographic growth, low standards of living, and lack of economic opportunities (Castles and Miller 22). Migrants are then pulled to move to receiving countries because they are attracted to the demand they have for labor, availability of land, economic opportunities, and political freedoms (Castles and Miller 22). The push-pull factor is one of the main explanations as to why the economic pressures are the biggest factors that...

Words: 1983 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Ethical

...MHC608 Business Ethics for Hospitality Contents Introduction: 3 An overview of Bulgaria’s refugee’s crisis: 4 Stakeholders and Typology theories: 4 Definition of Stakeholders: 4 A typology theories of stakeholder: 4 Types of stakeholders: 5 Ethical Framework: 5 Applying stakeholder theories to this Bulgaria case: 5 Refugees: 5 Bulgarians: 6 European Union: 7 IS-terrorist attacks: 8 Apply the ethical approach into the view of the Bulgaria’s government: 8 Conclusion 10 REFERENCE: 10 Introduction: As we can see that ethics is perceived in different angles and aspects but it is, undeniably, an important role of ethics in our life. According to Noel Preston (2001, p.18) ethics indicates the general views of what is right, fair or good. It is also the core values, rules which we use to make our choices and actions. Similarly, (Boardman, 2005) said that ethics is applied naturally for many areas such as our own lives, business and an organisation. In our daily lives, making decisions and actions seem to be driven or motivated from/ by the certain standards or values. Furthermore, ethics target on evaluating the right or wrong behaviours of both individuals and the good or bad performance of an organisation. This report will evaluate the ethical approach which Bulgaria government uses to make the fence-line decision. This paper will be divided into four parts. The first part is going to summary the Bulgaria cases. The next part will come up with...

Words: 2802 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Human Resource Management

...from the seasonal employees, there need to be a work design in affect along with a job analysis. The work design is the process of assigning and coordinating work tasks among employees. The employment laws for seasonal employees that are from different countries are in the North Carolina General Statues 95-222.229. The migrant Housing Act of NC (S.B. 631; North Carolina General Statutes 95-222:229 were made into law in the U.S. state of North Carolina in 1989. It oversees migrant workers housing through regulations of housing inspections, standards to be met, and recognition of housing that meets all standards and requirements after the pre-occupancy inspection is done by the North Carolina Department of Labor and the local county health department. Its goals are to ensure safe and healthy seasonal housing conditions. Migrant workers can be described as people who come from their home country to the United States legally with limited advantages, to work in a selection of trades such as furniture, agriculture, and construction. In June 2003, I was working at Wal-Mart in Kitty Hawk and every summer, they would hire migrant workers from different countries and provide housing for them. I also had the opportunity to work with them, train them and see their work performance. I had a difficult time trying to understand their language but it really nice working with them. I also notice that there were no taxes taken out their paycheck. The migrant...

Words: 1916 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

The Rights of Illegal Immigrants in Kenya: Lessons from the United States of America

...THE RIGHTS OF ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS IN KENYA: LESSONS FROM THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. GODWIN KIPKIRUI LANGAT LAW/M/0985/09/12 ABSTRACT Many perspectives have been offered in the academic literature to explain the phenomenon of illegal immigration across the world. Unfortunately, most studies fail to adequately account for the rights of immigrants and how they are being violated. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT CHAPTER ONE 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Background of Study The purpose of this research is to show all the rights of illegal immigrants and the extent to which they are violated and/or respected in Kenya’s legal system by use of vital lessons from the American legal system. Respecting their rights is important because it shows that we are respecting the rule of law. It is important to note that all people are equal and therefore they should be treated equally without discrimination. People should also be allowed the freedom of movement and also that it should be ensured that the same freedom of movement should be regulated so that it ensures that one single country or state do not suffer the outcomes of immigration. Migration is a fact of life whereby people move to new countries to improve themselves economically and maybe to pursue their educations. Others leave to escape armed conflicts or other violations of human rights. Several statutory laws in Kenya provide means by which certain aliens/illegal immigrants can become naturalized citizens. Immigration law determines who...

Words: 10404 - Pages: 42

Premium Essay

Essay On Immigration In The United States

...States This week we have discussed full employment, which is having all able and willing citizens to be gainfully employed. One topic covered if the US should aim for a lower unemployment rate and how to achieve it. Also, we discussed the effect unemployment has on the economy. A conclusion is the more working and taxpaying citizens there are in the US, the better the economy is and the faster it can grow. Immigration in the United States has always been a controversial subject due to many conflicting issues. The main issue has always been about the effects is has on the economy. Many people think that immigrants...

Words: 870 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Advantages Of Migrant Workers In Thailand

...Myanmar Migrant Workers in Thailand The process of international relationship is relating with political, economic, law and others factor. There are combining with ten countries in ASEAN. Among them, both Thai and Myanmar are developing countries, and they are neighbor countries for each other. In addition, both countries are trading in economic. ''Myanmar and Thailand relations refer to the current and historical relation between Burma and Thailand. They focus mainly on economic issues and trade'' (Myanmar–Thailand relations - Wikipedia, the free). However, Thai can produce more products than Myanmar. There have many jobs opportunities in Thailand. Thus, there have about 3 million of Myanmar migrant workers who are working in Thailand. According...

Words: 1488 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

European Integration Report

...Content Content 0 1. Introduction 1 2. History 1 3. Reason for the Large Scale of Immigration 3 4. Policy and Regulation 4 5. Problems 7 5.1. Illegal Immigration 7 5.2. Religious and Cultural Conflicts among Immigrants and Natives 9 5.3. Social Unrest 11 5.4. Affecting the Education System 12 6. Solutions 14 7. Concession 17 7.1. Alleviate the Pressure of Aging Problem in EU 17 7.2. Boost the economy in Europe 18 8. Conclusion 19 9. Bibliography 19 1. Introduction The issue of immigration has been the hot debated topic in the European Union for a long time. And there is obvious evidence that the upsurge of immigration into the Europe will not be calmed down within a short time. The European Union has developed its competences in the fields of policies and regulations regarding the immigration issue. But the problems still exist and more things need to be done for creating a better balance. The report will first quickly go over the history of human migration and reasons for the recent large scale of immigration into Europe will be analyzed. After, the policies and regulations implemented by nations of Europe and the European Union will be introduced before going deep into the problems brought up by immigration. Then some solutions as to how to settle the current problems will be provided and concessions will be made to maintain a balanced and objective knowledge of the influences of immigration. 2. History While there...

Words: 6668 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Arizona Immagration

...After Arizona passed a series of tough anti-immigration laws, Rob Knorr couldn’t find enough Mexican field hands to pick his jalapeño peppers. He sharply reduced his acreage and invested $2 million developing a machine to remove pepper stems. His goal was to cut the number of laborers he needed by 90% and to hire higher-paid U.S. machinists instead. “We used to have many migrant families. They aren’t coming back,” says Mr. Knorr, who owns RK Farms LLC, an hour’s drive from Phoenix. Few issues in the presidential campaign are more explosive than whether and how much to crack down on illegal immigration, which some Republican candidates in particular blame for America’s economic woes. Arizona is a test case of what happens to an economy when such migrants leave, and it illustrates the economic tensions fueling the immigration debate. Immigrants Push Down Wages for Low-Income Workers—But How Much? Economists of opposing political views agree the state’s economy took a hit when large numbers of illegal immigrants left for Mexico and other border states, following a broad crackdown. But they also say the reduced competition for low-skilled jobs was a boon for some native-born construction and agricultural workers who got jobs or raises, and that the departures also saved the state money on education and health care. Whether those gains are worth the economic pain is the crux of the debate. Gordon Hanson, a University of California at San Diego economist who has studied...

Words: 2246 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Migration, Xenophobia & New Racism Post 1994

... _________South Africa________ VAN EN VOORLETTERS SURNAME & INITIALS :__________Murray R_________ STUD NR/ STUD NO :__________ MODULE KODE/ MODULE CODE :__________SOC 120_________ DOSENT/LECTURER :______Ms Vangile Bingma______ INHANDIGINGSDATUM DATE OF SUBMISSION :______16 September 2013_____ Table of Contents Introduction 2 Question 1 2 Question 2 4 Question 3 5 Conclusion 6 Bibliography 7 Plagiarism Declaration 8 Introduction Post-apartheid South Africa was intended to bring together people of all races and ethnicities; however, black South African citizens are discriminating against and showing prejudice towards African migrants. Research has shown that the main causes of xenophobic attitudes are a result of politics of access and the struggle for political and socio-economic resources (Adjai & Lazaridis 2013:192). Question 1 Old racism is discrimination based on race which is a group that is different biologically to one’s own group. New racism is discrimination based on someone else’s national origin or ethnicity (Adjai & Lazaridis 2013:192). Old racism is exclusion based on biological features whereas new racism is exclusion based on cultural and national features. New racism claims to be moving away from prejudice views and judgements but as simple pointing out the differences between different groups. Although by pointing out these differences it encourages...

Words: 2276 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Illegal Immigration

...Illegal Immigration Maricela Vega CJA 446 May 2013 With over 11 million immigrants in the United States illegally (as of 2011), the issue of illegal immigration continues to divide Americans. (ImmigrationProCon.org, 2013) Illegal immigration has become a major concern to the government in the U.S today. This was not a major concern until lately in the past twenty years. There has been an alarming increase of illegal immigrants in the U.S. A debate has arisen over the amount of action that has been exerted on the purposes. There are immigrants coming to America from all over the world today in search of the American dream. However, the greatest concern at this time is Mexico. Smuggling aliens has become more frequent every year. The smugglers are willing to go to great steps to smuggle people across and are escaping before they get caught. These smugglers are making hundreds and thousands of dollars to get these immigrants across the borders. Very few are actually caught and the illegal immigrants enter this country and disappear. Most of the illegal immigrants at this time are coming from Mexico, which means the bordering states are the major concern. When it comes to the topic of illegal immigrants or anytime the term “illegal immigrant” is brought up it is safe to say that many, or most Americans conjure up images of desperate migrants sneaking across the Mexican border. There is another side to America’s immigration problem, however, that most know very little about;...

Words: 2114 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Is Australia A Migrant Nation Essay

...Is Australia a migrant nation? The population of Australia is built up by migrants and true Australians. They come from all over the world. Most of the migrants come from the United Kingdom and New Zealand. Australia has a long history with both illegal and legal immigration. The first refugees started coming in 1834 from Prussia and the first migrants started in 1880s. Australia currently is facing lots of big decisions with migrants and refugees. Migrants have improved some parts of Australia much as population, migrant background, but some of them go in to detention centres. In World War II Australia had with the threat of a Japanese invasion. Australian prime minster John Curtin recognised that Australia did not have enough power or military strength to defend our self’s against the Japanese. Afforestation World War II ended, a new enemy threatened to invade Australia the communists. Australia prime minster recognised that we need a long term plan to make sure we could defend our self for more invasion. What Australia needed to do was populate or perish. The government in 1944 they began to discuss the plan to populate or perish to strengthen the industry. One of the first policy's where natural growth. They worked out that Australia needed an immediate boost so the solution was immigration. The first migrants arrived from Britain in September 1947 in Western Australia. Only certain skilled...

Words: 657 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Illegal Immigration Research Paper

...Do you really think that illegal immigrants are a danger to Americans? Do you really think they want to harm Americans? This issue is about reasons behind why immigrants migrate to the U.S and I will tell you why they mean no harm to the United States. Illegal immigration is not a threat to America's national security. They come to the U.S for a better life. Second reason is because illegal immigrants decrease criminal rate. Last reason is that by blocking them, it will not make them go away. Immigrants come to the United States for a reason. The that they want a better life. They are leaving their country because of the problems their countries are having. Issitt Micah L. stated that "immigrants leave their countries of origin for a variety...

Words: 922 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Illegal Immigration Research Paper

...Do you think preventing the flow of undocumented illegal immigrants can help the social and financial future of the United States? Illegal immigration can cause a myriad of different issues, often more than most people expect. The population of legal citizens of the United States is being overcrowded by people leaving their countries for various reasons, and entering ours illegally. Illegal immigration is hurting the job market for tax paying workers, and those same taxpayers are being forced to watch more of their hard earned money than ever before be taken by the state only to be directed towards the welfare of people who are here illegally. Immigration often can be an increasingly controversial topic, however, there are a lot of reasons...

Words: 1258 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Migration

...its remotest areas. Migration is taking place within very different contexts: f.e. military conquest, refugees, expulsion or enslavement. But migrants have also traveled in search of economic opportunities, new settlement areas or trade routes. Currently approximately 216,000,000 people are living away from their place of birth. This number equals about 3% of the world population. Analyzing the reasons for migration one distinguishes between push and pull factors - often both appear together. Push factors are circumstances in the country of origin that lead people to emigrate, for example poverty, war or environmental disasters. Pull factors are conditions in the destination country that make immigration attractive such as economic opportunity and political freedom. Overall trends By far the most immigrants live in the United States followed by Russia and Germany. The main countries of origin are Mexico, India, China and Russia. In proportion to the population Persian Gulf countries host the largest share of migrants - about 35% of their population. They mostly come from South Asia and Egypt. Most migrants in the US come from Latin America, particularly from Mexico. In Europe the origin of immigrants differs considerably between countries and reflects their historical development: in Germany and Denmark a large share of migrants are of Turkish origin, most immigrants in France, Portugal and...

Words: 2232 - Pages: 9