Premium Essay

Dr. George Gey's Argument Against Henrietta Lack

Submitted By
Words 630
Pages 3
In 1951, at John Hopkins Hospital, Dr. George Gey, without permission, took Henrietta Lacks’ cancer cells because he wanted to do research. His intentions were respectable, and he ended up growing the cells and distributing them to the scientific community. Gey had discovered a scientific breakthrough, HeLa cells, but did so without the knowledge of Henrietta Lacks or the Lacks family. Even though many people do not agree with Gey’s decision, his actions helped develop many vaccines and cures, so some people agree with the decision to take the cells, whether permission had been granted by Lacks or not. Gey did not know that what he was doing was wrong so he cannot be put to blame. The fact that there was not a law stating that someone needs consent before taking the cells of another person for research is more to blame than Gey was. However, Gey should not have distributed the HeLa cells without the knowledge and consent of Lacks and her family. …show more content…
Even though there is no law that states that the hospital needs consent to take cells for research, Gey should have asked Lacks for permission out of respect. If Lacks was white then maybe the treatment would have been a little different and permission would have been requested. Nobody will ever know the outcome if Lacks was white. I think that it is great that because of the research was made, cures and vaccines of multiple illnesses were developed, but the Lacks family was not taken into consideration at all. It was not until August of 2013 that the Lacks and her family would finally be recognized by the National Institutes of Health (Burki 1). If the family knew that Gey took Lacks’ cells at the time, the situation might have come off little less

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Ethical Principals

...Ethical Principals of Cancer Cell Research Brian Bocock PSY/305 March 9, 2015 Dr. Joycelynn Flowers-Ashton Ethical Principals of Cancer Cell Research October 4, 1951 has become one of the most memorable dates in the eyes of cancer cell researchers. On that date at Johns Hopkins hospital a destitute African-American woman named Henrietta Lacks passed away due to cervical cancer. Henrietta left behind her husband, David, and their four children. At only 31 years of age, this woman was going to be extremely influential in cancer research, and she had no idea. The worst part was neither did her family. Her cells were like no other cells ever seen and have provided for exceptional results for medical research since her passing, including the polio vaccine. However, the debate is over researchers taking her cells without her consent and made no immediate family members until 19 years later. Bringing this situation to the forefront of the implications and role ethics play in research today. Since the early 1970’s the story of Henrietta Lacks and her dominate cells has provided a great debate on a topic that will forever be in question, ethical principals. Dr. George Gey is the doctor that obtained the cells in order to find a cure for cancer. He was a great professional, I believe, that wanted nothing more than to find a cure for cancer, including profit. Because of this he wanted to keep Henrietta’s name private due to her passing and the understanding of a lawsuit by the...

Words: 1085 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Medicare Fraud: the History, Incidence, Costs and Institutional Remedies

...Health Care Law Fall 2015 Professor: Dr. Lloyd L. Cannedy, Ph.D. Book Review of “The Immortal Life of Henriettta Lack” Student: Abraham S Lincoln “Henrietta Lacks, a young black mother of five children, entered the colored ward of The Johns Hopkins Hospital to begin treatment for an extremely aggressive strain of cervical cancer. As she lay on the operating table, a sample of her cancerous cervical tissue was taken without her knowledge or consent and given to Dr. George Gey, the head of tissue research. Gey was conducting experiments in an attempt to create an immortal line of human cells that could be used in medical research. Those cells, he hoped, would allow scientists to unlock the mysteries of cancer, and eventually lead to a cure for the disease. Until this point, all of Gey’s attempts to grow a human cell line had ended in failure, but Henrietta’s cells were different; they never died.” (USF 2013-14 Common Reader, The immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks, Pg1) The cells, called HeLa, became one of the most important tools in medical research, vital for developing the polio vaccine, cloning, gene mapping, and more. Less than a year after her initial diagnosis, Henrietta’s cancer was too much for her to bare, and the cancer took over her body. Because of her poverty she was buried in an unmarked grave on her family’s land. She was only thirty-one years old. Her family never knew, at that time that a portion small piece of Henrietta was still living, and that small piece...

Words: 2817 - Pages: 12