Free Essay

Effects on Price Gouging

In:

Submitted By gabalaba11
Words 772
Pages 4
Gabriel Ramirez
Writing Assignment #1
18 July 2011
PHIL 205
A Different Look at Price Gouging
Zwolinski brings into question a very interesting view to the moral status of price gouging and how it should not be illegal. He uses a mix of several examples to express this idea, but shows us how there is no ultimately right answer to this complicated issue. Although Zwolinski brings into question many issues like exploitation and supply and demand there are three main points that he uses to defend his stance on the issue. These points include how state laws are not precise and include normative statements, how prices and allocative efficiency come into play, and how those that are in most need for relevant goods are made worse off.
One of the most important arguments for his take on this topic comes down to definition of price gouging and how it is stated in the state laws. Words like “unreasonable” “unfair” and “unconscionable” are normative statements and can be open for interpretation. What one may see as unreasonable or unfair to them, I may see as justifiable. One’s perception of what is justifiable will differ from person to person. The name gouging has a negative connotation to it and it can be seen as an action that is wrong. This is a strong opening argument for Zwolinski because it calls into question each state’s law about what exactly price gouging is. Each state may have to go back and rewrite these laws in order to make it more specific. This argument allows Zwolinski to question the law and its definitions pertaining to price gouging, which may have a positive effect on society in the long run as a more detailed definition would allow for better informed decisions. When studying the topic of price gouging, if there definitions are not clear, then there will be many ways to take advantage of the law and question its integrity. Information is important so that each individual can do what is best for them and their family.
Another main argument for Zwolinski pertains to the economics that come into play with price gouging. Pricing and allocative efficiency are important topics in economics, especially when it comes to natural disasters for a country. These two topics form a strong argument for price gouging because it explains how some people will purchase goods while others won’t and how those that need those goods the most will get them. Although this isn’t always the case, pricing allows suppliers know the demand for goods so they can adjust appropriately, so there is not a shortage. Zwolinski talks about Hayek’s example about the hotel rooms during hurricane Charley in Florida. There was an increase in supply for hotel rooms, but the increase in price of a room allowed those people who needed the rooms the most to get them. This forced people to become more economically conscience and make better decisions for themselves and their family.
Zwolinski argues that even if price gouging is immoral, it should still not be illegal. Even if there were people selling goods at high prices and exploiting others, those buying would be worse off if they weren’t able to make the conscience effort whether they wanted to purchase that good or not. Getting goods at a higher price than you wanted to pay is better than not getting any goods at all in times of emergency. If goods weren’t at a higher price, the supply for those goods would run out and would make more people worse off than they already are. It can be said that those that price gouge are at least getting out there and meeting the demands for people, while there are others that aren’t doing anything. Just because someone price gouges, doesn’t mean they are an immoral person. While some may take advantage, others try to meet the demand for these goods.
In conclusion, Zwolinski brings up many good points in favor of making price gouging legal. Three good arguments in favor how state laws are not precise and include normative statements, how prices and allocative efficiency come into play, and how those that are in most need for relevant goods are made worse off. Zwolinski addresses that there is no clear explanation of what exactly should be done, as this is a complex issue that affects many people. There are many arguments in favor and against price gouging. The most society can do is to come up with a clear definition of the problem, get as much information about the issue, so that the best informed decisions can be made.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Paper

...This article talks of rice gouging as a pricing strategy followed by US companies vis-a-vis Australian consumers. We start with the concept of the strategy and the conditions required for its effectiveness. Next it is applied on the current situation that is the focus of the article. Lastly we try and assess the benefits and costs of this strategy. Price gouging is a form of price discrimination, where the producer/seller is able to discriminate between different consumers on the basis of his selling power or some feature of the consumer itself. Price gouging is negative in its implication as it involves charging higher prices from consumers in times of emergency, as the consumer has no choice. It is even treated as illegal in some economies. For example, if there is a hurricane and plywood manufacturers charge a higher price from consumers wishing to rebuild their homes, it is price gouging. This is because there is no change in the good provided or the cost of manufacturing that good. Producers are simply using the consumers’ emergency demand for plywood to boost profits for themselves. Another example is the rise in essential items prices when there is a curfew in riot affected areas. For the producer this makes sense as demand becomes inelastic in times of emergencies and he can charge a higher price and increase his profits. “Everyone engaged in a business who…engages in a policy of selling products in any area of the country at prices lower than those exacted by him elsewhere...

Words: 1580 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Managerial Economics.

...have been maximin rule – decisions made that identifies the worst outcome for each decision and choosing the decision with the maximum worst payoff (Thomas & Maurice, 2013, p. 647). 2. “A portfolio manager needs to pick winners—assets or securities with high expected returns and low risk.” What is wrong with this statement? This statement should read “A portfolio manager should choose a winning portfolio that matches the level of risk and provides the expected return of the investor.” A diversified portfolio carries a lower risk than individual stocks and should be the matrix for a successful investment, investing in securities with high expected returns involves a high level of risk. 3. Do you favor anti-gouging laws as a means of protecting consumers from high prices following natural disasters, such as Hurricane Katrina in New...

Words: 1017 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Teurig Pharm

...in the news for raising the price of prescription drugs. The price of Daraprim, a drug to treat toxoplasmosis, was increased by over five thousand percent. The increase has sparked people from both the AIDS and cancer organizations to reach out and attack the ethics of Chief Executive Officer, Martin Shkreli through social media. The increase in price may prevent hospitals from having treatment available for patients who need it. The practice of price gouging prescription drugs has now become an important political topic many candidates running for President of the United States in 2016 will be talking about. Significance of a Solution Recognizing that developing, manufacturing, and marketing pharmaceuticals is a very profitable business, the case of Turing Pharmaceutical’s purchase and marketing of the drug Daraprim spotlights a potentially serious issue with the way some companies “repackage” existing drugs to create higher profit margins. Daraprim (Pyrimethamine) was originally approved January 23, 1953 for the treatment of toxoplasmosis, an infection caused by a very common parasite (U.S. Food and Drug Administration, n.d.). Because most people never exhibit symptoms of this disease, sales of this drug were very small; and, no generic drug company ever bothered to duplicate the formula (Mayo Clinic, 2015). Seizing the opportunity to “corner the market” on this drug, Turing Pharmaceuticals purchased the rights and immediately raised the price from $13.50 per tablet to...

Words: 932 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Propofol Research Paper

...GABAA β3 receptors is theorized to lead to immobility, respiratory depression and hypnosis while GABAA β2 induction leads to hypnosis, sedation, hypothermia and Cardiac Depression. Along with its fast onset of action Propofol‘s pharmaceutical effects are quickly terminated if the i.v is stopped. The Quick Termination of therapeutic effects is due to decreased blood plasma concentration caused by redistribution of propofol from the CNS to other tissues and high metabolic clearance of the molecule. This leads to rapid recovery from sedation and quicker mobilization of patients. The Metabolism of Propofol by phase I and II hepatic enzymes produces an inactive form for hepatic clearance. Deactivated propofol molecules are mainly eliminated through kidney excretion into nephron tubules. The pharmacokinetics of propofol is not affected by gender or chronic hepatic cirrhosis, but it is affected by age and weight. With increasing Age, the dose needed to achieve anaesthetic effects decreases due to lower initial volume distribution and decreased clearance rate. These two variables are also affected by weight as it was observed that patients who were obese had significantly higher volume distribution and clearance rate. Toxicology Some side effects of propofol-induced anaesthesia are hypotension, cardiovascular depression and apnea along with other symptoms like nausea, and pain, most of these symptoms can be reversed by discontinuing the infusion. Propofol should not be used with drugs...

Words: 653 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Drugs

...become an addict when trying out a drug. Most people already know that pain medication is prescribed and available easy and too much and in turn this is creating addicts. In the year of 2010 pharmacies dispensed something like 42 tons of hydrocodone and 69 tons of oxycodone. That’s enough drugs to give each human being in the United States of America 24 Vicodins and 40 Percocet’s. Prescription drugs are exceeding all drugs in levels of abuse. The rates are staggering with deadly results all across the nation DRUGS The drug problem is not an enemy that can be easily vanquished. A side effect is usually regarded as an undesirable secondary effect which occurs in addition to the desired therapeutic effect of a drug or medication. Side effects may vary for each individual depending on the disease state...

Words: 2189 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Uber Surge Pricing

...it comes at a cost. Most of Uber’s prices are slightly cheaper than a street-hailed cab. But when demand spikes, the surge prices kick in: rates during the busiest times, such as New Year’s Eve, can be seven times normal levels, and minimum fares of up to $175 apply. During periods of excessive demand or scarce supply, when there are far more riders than drivers, Uber increases its normal fares with a multiplier, whose value depends on scarcity of available drivers. This so-called surge pricing uses microeconomics to calculate a market price for riders and drivers alike. The goal of surge pricing is to find the “equilibrium price” at which driver supply matches rider demand and riders’ wait time is minimized. Studies show that surge pricing achieves what it was designed to do: it brings more drivers online, and it allocates available rides to those who value them more. There is some evidence Uber’s surge pricing is improving taxi markets. The firm says drivers are sensitive to price, so that the temptation to earn more is getting more Uber drivers onto the roads at antisocial hours. In San Francisco, the number of private cars for hire has shot up, Uber says. This suggests surge pricing has encouraged the number of taxis to vary with demand, with the market getting bigger during peak hours. However, surge pricing has a major image problem. Hardly anyone has a good thing to say about it, and far too many people equate it with price gouging. This perception is a huge headache...

Words: 1190 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

AT & T-Time Warner Merger

...anti-trust laws set forth by the government itself. This deal is not in the public interest and federal regulators should scrutinize this deal and consider the effect it will have on smaller telecommunication businesses, consumers, and employees. Time Warner owns popular media companies such as CNN, HBO, and Warner Bros. Studios. AT&T is a major provider of telephone, internet and cable services across the nation. Both of these companies are incredibly large and prosperous on their own. Together, they would make the few number of companies that dominate the telecommunications market even smaller. This could have a negative effect on the free-market economy if they use this power to monopolize the market. This is exactly what Anti-trust laws were designed to prevent. The Clayton Act, an...

Words: 520 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Pros And Cons Of Epipen

...EpiPen is an injection containing epinephrine, this chemical narrows the blood vessel and open airways in the lungs. The effects of this injection can reverse severe low blood pressure, wheezing, hives, severe skin itching, and many different symptoms of an allergic reaction. They also use epinephrine to treat exercise induced anaphylaxis. Mylan offers the first authorized generic for EpiPen Auto injector at half of the wholesale acquisition cost . But as of 2016 , Mylan's EpiPen became the center of attention for scrutiny . Their prices increased by nearly 500 percent over the past seven years. American consumers are definitely not strangers to increased prices on drugs , but based on a few steep price hikes by the Mylan company and their decision to raise the price on EpiPen it caused an outrage. Mylan was at the center of criticism over rising drug prices. EpiPen is basically used by several parents of young children that suffer from food...

Words: 517 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Supply, Demand, and Government in the Markets

...is the equilibrium Price and Quantity in the market? This is where the quantity demanded and the quantity supplied are equal. The corresponding price is the equilibrium price and the quantity is the equilibrium quantity. *Let us take the first line of data from the Spreadsheet as an example: Price- $200 Quantity Demanded- 1000 Quantity Supplied- 2200 Here there is an excess supply amount, so there are more computers than that are actually wanted. At this point, the sellers would recognize there are fewer buyers for their product at the current set price. Now they would attempt attracting buyers for the excess supply available by offering these goods at a lower price. By doing so, according to the law of demand, buyers will now purchase more of the computers and the supply overage will decrease until it eventually disappears. Now the market will reach the intersection point in which supply is equal to demand. *Now we can look at a different scenario in which the demand of computers are higher than the supply. Looking at the last line of data from the Spreadsheet: Price- $25 Quantity Demanded- 2750 Quantity Supplied-1150 This would display a price that is below the intersection point. Because there is such a high demand for the product, the consumer would be willing to pay more to obtain it. As the market price increases, the demand will decrease and will eventually cease at the intersection of the two curves, thus reaching Market equilibrium price. 3. Now suppose...

Words: 793 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Mba 570

...by ways of open and honest communication. Media coverage has made public corporate scandals in the last few years, creating awareness of unethical practices. Issues with made up financial reports, product quality, poor customer service, out of court settlements without admission of guilt, has created skepticism amongst consumers, thus affecting profit for the organization and the overall socio-economic stability. Deceptive practices are noticed. An example of a common practice among the retail industry is price gouging. Human beings are creatures of habit; consumers like to frequent the same businesses for their own personal reasons. They become familiar with the prices and when there is a markup and then a sale for the original price before the markup, it gets noticed. It is a sure way to lose credibility and customer’s loyalty. Consumers do not like to be deceived. An organization that engages in unethical practices affects everyone, creating a cascading effect. Once it becomes public employees morale goes down, they become uncertain about their future with the...

Words: 603 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Template

...Everyone agrees that business managers must understand finance and marketing. But is it necessary for them to study ethics? Managers who answer in the negative generally base their thinking on one of three rationales. They may simply say that they have no reason to be ethical. They see why they should make a profit, and most agree they should do so legally. But why should they be concerned about ethics, as long as they are making money and staying out of jail? Other managers recognize that they should be ethical but identify their ethical duty with making a legal profit for the firm. They see no need to be ethical in any further sense, and therefore no need for any background beyond business and law. A third group of managers grant that ethical duty goes further than what is required by law. But they still insist that there is no point in studying ethics. Character is formed in childhood, not while reading a college text or sitting in class. These arguments are confused and mistaken on several levels. To see why, it is best to start with the question raised by the first one: why should business people be ethical? Why Should One Be Ethical? There is already something odd about this question. It is like asking, “Why are bachelors unmarried?” They are unmarried by definition. If they were married, they would not be bachelors. It is the same with ethics. To say that one should do something is another way of saying it is ethical. If it is not ethical, then one should...

Words: 2843 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

The Effects of a Hurricane on the Principles of Supply and Demand

...The Effects of a Hurricane on the Principles of Supply and Demand Econ 365 Jacob Owen The principles of supply and demand state that supply is the availability of a good or service desired by a consumer. Demand is a measure of the public’s desire for that good of service. As a rule of thumb, if something is very popular, or very necessary, it generally will be in high demand. The demand for a specific good or service can literally change overnight. Case in point when a hurricane enters the Gulf of Mexico, certain products become in high demand especially along the United States Gulf coast. Sudden increases in demand can have both positive and negative results for the producer as well as the consumer. Some of the products that will suddenly go into high demand are batteries, flashlights, gasoline, gas cans, canned food etc. With this sudden increase in demand, producers will likely order and stock more of these items than they normally would. This sudden change in demand makes the usual supply decrease. This results in the suppliers having to increase their production numbers. With a sudden increase in demand and decrease in supply this sometimes leads producers to increase their prices as a result. While the price increase is sometimes necessary to handle the sudden change in demand, some produces engage in “price gouging,” that is artificially inflating prices to take advantage of the increased demand which is highly illegal. Sometimes, when a hurricane...

Words: 644 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Gasoline Prices and the Effect on Americans

...Running Head: GASOLINE AND OIL PRICES EFFECT ON AMERICANS Gasoline and Oil Prices Effect on Americans Cindy Gasoline and Oil Prices Effect on Americans A well-known fact to Americans is gasoline and oil prices have soared over the last several years. Virtually every American has made changes in their day-to-day life related to this higher cost. Even though gasoline/oil companies and the people who invest in them are making money, prices are too high; many Americans have to decide between buying gasoline and paying for their prescription medications, healthcare, mortgage, and food. The government needs to step in and set guidelines to prevent gas companies from raising prices so quickly. “While drivers have been painfully paying up at the pump, oil companies have been racking up eye-popping profits” (Krantz, 2005, ¶ 1). During the second quarter of this year, one gasoline/oil company recorded profits each minute were in excess of what an average American earns in one year. According to Clifford Krauss’ article in the New York Times, “Exxon’s profits were nearly $90,000 a minute over the quarter” (2008, ¶3). Mr. Krauss’ article also states, “Record earnings for Exxon, the world’s largest publicly traded oil company, have become routine as the surge of oil prices in recent years has filled its coffers” (2008, ¶2). This is only one company; the other oil companies are showing earnings of the same, if not more. Americans are scaling back on...

Words: 806 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Economic Principles

...Analysis: Propane shortage The Economic Principles of the Propane Shortage of 2013-14 Analysis: Propane shortage The Economic Principles of the Propane Shortage of 2013-14 During the winter months, propane is a necessary resource for many families and businesses. In an article written by Elisha Fieldstadt with NBC news, the details of the shortage, and the plans to ease the effects are detailed for the public. Propane is a versatile fuel sourced used in households and in a variety of businesses. In some households, propane is used as the major heat source for furnaces or fireplaces. It can also be used for stoves, clothes dryers and hot water heaters (Propane Education and Research Council, 2014). In fact, more than “14 million families across the U.S. use propane to fuel their furnaces,” (Fieldstadt, 2014) according to the Propane Education and Research Council. Due to extreme winter weather conditions this season, parts of the U.S. are experiencing a severe propane shortage. The supply of propane stock in many states have hit extreme lows this winter. As continued severe cold temperatures and accumulating winter storms blanket much of the northern half of the United States, supplies will continue to suffer and millions of Americans will be without heat. Government officials in 17 states have taken swift action to focus on getting much needed propane to homes and businesses. In Ohio, the governor declared an energy emergency that “permits propane shippers...

Words: 1067 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Role of a Stakeholder

...stakeholders must be taken into consideration when implementing a quality management process. Employees must be treated fair and must be afforded the rights that are governed by law. Each level of employment adds value to the organization. Structure must be created for a safe work environment. The employee must have good working relationships with the customers. This information should be shared with management to ensure proper procedures are being followed. Analyst in the company should track travel data to assist with pricing of fairs. The customers are the airlines most precious cargo. They should be treated with respect and not taken advantage of. The experience the customer has should be noticeably different from other airlines without price gouging. The customer should have various ways to provide feedback to the airline. The feedback should be in the form of survey’s or phone calls. The investors want a positive return on their investment. Measures must be in place to provide accurate financial data and expense...

Words: 528 - Pages: 3