Free Essay

Equal Protection

In:

Submitted By laron36
Words 1343
Pages 6
The Equal Protection Clause what is it and how does it affect you? So how many people out there actually know what our Constitution entails? This would be the part where we hear crickets. Why because unless you are super passionate about politics or want to eventually run for congress at some point in your life you, like so many other American citizens have no idea what laws and amendments are set in place. This is where I seek to educate at least on one small faction of the fourteenth amendment. Now I know that for some learning about our government is probably high on the list of things you would rather not do however, there is a lot that we could all stand to learn about protecting these rights we hardly know anything about. The Equal Protection Clause is part of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. The clause, which took effect in 1868, provides that no state shall deny to any person with its jurisdiction “the equal protection of the laws”. In other words it is the constitutional guarantee that no person or class of persons shall be denied the same protection of the laws that is enjoyed by other persons or other classes in like circumstances. With the amount of problems this country has faced and is facing dealing with discrimination and inequality I believe it holds a very valuable place within our Constitution and more importantly our society. The Equal Protection clause was the center piece of the Civil rights movement and it contributed to desegregation, integration and Affirmative Action. It also contributed to raising consciousness regarding equal treatment and concern regarding race, gender and most recently sexual orientation. Now I know many may not agree with the amendment and what it has contributed to but I do think that it has made an irreversible impact on the way we view equality in this country. This clause is not just about discrimination concerning race but also equality based on gender which also played a major part in our history as a country. How different would our country be without this clause? There would definitely be little to no diversity in the work place, I know for a fact as a women becoming a member of the military would more than likely have been a different experience; while I am sure I would have been able to join my career options would have been very limited. When considering my career as a military member and a women I think it is fair to say that without this clause and others like it my American dream may have been much different and the armed forces may have just been a fantasy never realized had this clause not been put into the Constitution. One of the movements that came with this clause is Affirmative Action which is the consideration of race, gender, or other factors, to benefit an underrepresented group or to address past injustices done to that group. Individuals who belong to said group are preferred over those who do not belong to that group. This sounds really one sided and biased when you look at it as the government or corporations are basically giving handouts to minorities at least that is how some view Affirmative Action and those people may have a valid point however; I view it as a means to give a chance to an individual that may not have otherwise been afforded that opportunity; not for their lack of experience but based on race or gender. I believe those who do not agree with Affirmative Action probably have no idea of where it comes from and the history of it again this article is meant to educate so allow me to explain, during the Reconstruction, Congress enacted race conscious programs primarily to assist the newly freed slaves who had been denied many advantages earlier in life. This legislation was created by many of the people who framed the Equal Protection Clause. The motivation for the clause was basically to unite each state on their interpretation of the clause this was to create less confusion and to provide a clear understanding of what equality meant. Now this is not to imply that there have not been any instances where the states have not violated an individual’s rights as they apply to the clause for example in the case of Plessy v. Ferguson (1896), the Supreme Court upheld a Louisiana Jim Crow law that required the separation of blacks and whites while on railroads and mandated separate railway cars. The court argued in this case that the Equal Protection Clause was intended to defend equality in civil rights, not equality of social arrangements. Another highly publicized case was Brown v. Board of Education in this case several local governments were separating students in public schools based on race. While these are examples of where the Supreme Court have upheld the standards under the Equal Protection Clause there is one case where they upheld racial classification in United States v. Korematsu (1940) thousands of Japanese Americans were taken to relocation camps throughout the United States during WWII. While I personally believe this was an infringement upon the rights of American citizens the courts viewed it as a way to decrease espionage and disloyalty against the war on Japan. This is the only time in history the court has upheld something like this. This clause does not just apply to discrimination based on race it also deals with discrimination based on gender and sexual orientation. More recently there have been several cases dealing with sexual orientation and same sex marriage and whether the rights of the individuals in these circumstances is being violated. If you have not heard about the issues regarding same sex marriage then you have been living under a rock. Same sex marriage has become a major matter of political controversy in the past few years and has been a steady topic for debate. Most importantly why some states will acknowledge a union and why others will not or do not; but is this truly a violation of the Equal Protection Clause? Despite the fact that several states have legalized gay marriage many ask the question can marriage be regulated by the judicial system. According to the Defense of Marriage Act (1996) states do not have to recognize same sex marriages from other states and that the federal government would not recognize same sex marriage. In theory the government is trying to protect the sanctity as they see it of marriage which in most states is between a man and woman. Some view this as being unconstitutional while others believe that marriage is something that is controlled by the state and since our Constitution does not specifically give that power to Congress, marriage should continue to be regulated by each state. The issue that many have is that the state and federal government do not distinguish between civil marriage and religious marriage whether it be performed by a member of the clergy, or a religious officiate. Supporters of same sex marriage argue that equal protection requires equal access to civil benefits of marriage while opponents of gay marriage argue that there is a legitimate rational basis for limiting marriage to heterosexual couples. As it stands now I do not know if this is something that will ever be overturned but I do believe that other major cases have been scrutinized by the courts and found to be liable for discrimination and maybe this and many other issues concerning America and its citizens deserve a more in depth look; I am more than certain that the framers of the Constitution did not intend for the Equal Protection Clause to consent to interracial marriage and yet in the case of Loving v. Virginia (1967) that’s exactly what happened. Perhaps that will be the same for same sex marriage if enough people fight for this right then lawmakers and states will have to wake up and pay attention.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Equal Protection Clause

...Equal Protection to Students The Equal Protection Clause belongs to the Fourteenth Amendment of the United States Constitution and it states that “no state shall deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws” (“The Equal Protection Clause”). Being one of the amendments gained from the civil war, the framers envisioned that its primary purpose would be to protect the newly freed slaves from racial discrimination. However, the wording of the Fourteenth Amendment gives off that equal protection clause protects against any type of discrimination and gives equal protection of law to all persons. Equal protection in schools soon started to expand and develop. The equal protection for students allow for anyone to gain...

Words: 703 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Equal Protection Clause

...implemented the Equal Protection Clause. Throughout this essay, I will explain the Equal Protection Clause, where the clause originated from, give example of the clause being applied to cases, and show how the clause is enforced today. The Equal Protection Clause is part of the United States Constitutions 14th amendment. In the Constitution, it states “nor shall any State…deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws” (Epstein and Walker). Meaning that the State must apply equal application of the law to...

Words: 832 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The Equal Protection Clause

...racial equality by the Equal Protection clause. The clause was a deciding factor in cases that involved racism. Though it sometimes limited rights, the Equal Protection clause eventually became a key element to justice. Lum vs. Rice (1927) was a Supreme Court case where the Mississippi education board did not allow a nine year old girl to attend the all-white Rosedale Consolidated School because of her ethnicity. Gong Lum’s daughter, Martha Lum, was Chinese and a native-born in the United States. One day, a superintendent at Rosedale told Martha to leave school because she was not Caucasian. Gong Lum later filed for suit and the state trial court was in his favor. The state took the issue to officials to readmit Martha Lum, however, the Supreme Court opposed the state’s decision. The Supreme Court supported their argument from the Cumming vs. Richmond County Board of Education case (1899) where it showed that schools are allowed to be separated for white and “colored” students. They also focused on whether or not Martha Lum was being denied of her equal protection of the laws from the 14th Amendment. This brought the Supreme Court to uphold the Plessy vs. Ferguson case (1896) by approaching the concept “separate but equal.” They declared that Martha Lum was not white and the Board of Trustees was allowed to exclude her from Rosedale. In 1954, the Brown family went against the Board of Education because they believed segregated schools can never be equal despite their similar...

Words: 794 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Case Study Presentation

...Case Study Presentation (Chapter 4 Page 104) Corey Airport Services Inc. versus Clear Channel Outdoor Inc. The deciding court was the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit Case decided on June 4, 2012 The events of this case began when the City of Atlanta issued a request for proposal for a five-year contract at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport in 2002. The lease arrangement envisioned in the request for proposal involved the winning bidder managing hundreds of advertising displays at one of the world’s busiest airports with a guaranteed portion of the revenue remitted to the city. Before the 2002 proposal, Defendant Clear Channel Outdoor in partnership with Defendant Barbara Fouch held the advertising concession through a month-to-month contract. Fouch had been awarded the contract by the City without entering into a competitive bidding process, and Clear Channel became Fouch’s partner by purchasing the ownership interest of Fouch’s previous business partner. The existing month-to-month contract guaranteed fifty percent of advertising revenue to the City, but the request for proposal required bid proponents to commit to paying at least sixty percent of their advertising revenue to the City. Three companies submitted proposals to the City as part of the bid process, the obligatory team of Clear Channel and Fouch was the top finisher. Plaintiff Corey Airport Services, Inc. finished in second place. After Corey failed to secure the contract...

Words: 1641 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Comp

...Annie Mueller Craig v. Boren Craig v. Boren is a very unique and exciting case to learn about. In Oklahoma at one point, the drinking age for women was 18 and for men was 21. Of course some men were not to happy about this so one man decided to take a stand. Craig, the Plaintiff, sued David Boren, defendant and the Governor of Oklahoma (Oyez 1). He was governor at the time and he is now the President of the University of Oklahoma. The differences for the drinking age between age for men and women were for the consumption of beer at a 3.2% alcohol level (Oyez 1). Craig claimed this violated Equal Protection clause from the Fourteenth Amendment of the United States Constitution (Casebriefs 1). The issue was does the Oklahoma statute violate the Equal Protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment (Casebriefs 1). The procedural history was that it went to the state court and the state provided reams of statistical evidence suggesting that young men were more dangerous drinkers (Casebriefs 1). The Supreme Court happened to disagree with the state and look at the case. The Supreme Court believed that “2% of the men and just under 1% of the women between 18 and 21 had been arrested for alcohol-linked driving violations hardly constituted grounds for different treatment” (Casebriefs 1). The Supreme Court ruled that the law was unconstitutional and many Oklahoma citizens were very mad and upset with Craig because now everyone in Oklahoma had to be 21 to drink (Oyez 1). Men just...

Words: 647 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Equal Protection Clause In Civil Rights Cases

...The Fourteenth Amendment of the United States Constitution helps protect certain peoples rights from the law. Many of the Constitutional experts have considered the equal protection laws to be the utmost important part of the U.S. Constitution. The Clause, which took effect in 1868, provides that no state shall deny to any person within its jurisdiction "the equal protection of the laws". The Equal Protection clause is an important clause within the Amendment, that was put there to make sure that every person regardless of age, race, and religion would be treated the same as the government. This Clause has been used in several civil rights cases including the landmark case of Brown v. Board of Education (1954). One of the major groups...

Words: 438 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Segregation In Schools During The 1950's

...African Americans were affected dearly during the 1950’s. African Americans were not allowed to go to the same school as whites. African Americans would have to go to colored schools in order to receive an education. Segregation ended in schools due to the fact that the fourteenth amendment was tampered with. “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside. No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws,”(website).  I remember the day when segregation ended in schools, especially in Topeka, Kansas. My school. The day I meant Linda Brown, was a day that went down in history.     Linda Brown and her family moved in down the street about a month ago. Linda is the sweetest girl on this side of Topeka. She is the same age as I am and  loves to play hopscotch, just like me. The only thing that is different about her and I is that she is what my parents call, “a nigger”. I don’t really understand what that word defines as or why my parents use it when they are referring to people who are just like Linda. Black people. Multiple people in this town who look like me, hate upon black people. Whites spit on them, call them names,...

Words: 936 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Evaluate the Mechanism for Protecting the Rights of Children and Young People

...The COAG National Framework refers to the protection of children. The slogan “protecting children is everyone's right” ensures that children within Australia are kept nourished and safe. The COAG is invested by the government and non-government sector to protect the rights of children and their families. The purpose of COAG is to ensure children are not violated through collecting data and conducting investigations. The ‘COAG report’ found that in 2007-08 there were over 55.000 reports of child abuse and neglect within Australia. However since the report has been conducted there has been a dramatic reduce in the number of abuse and neglect cases within Australia. The COAG National Framework is effective in meeting the needs of children and protecting them as the highest priority. The child's welfare within Australia is unsuccessful in prioritising the rights and protection of children however the COAG National Framework addresses these issues and has been pushing for change in the recognition of child welfare. Furthermore, the COAG promotes a safe and welcoming environment for children to assist an early tertiary child protection program. The COAG National Framework ultimately aims to protect the most vulnerable families and children from neglect and abuse. The effectiveness of the COAG can be measured by the successful cases used through welfare benefits and assistance. For example, Holzer, Lewig, Bromfield and Arney (2008) which protects the rights of children to establish...

Words: 1056 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

What Is Safeguarding

...making sure that people get safe and empowering care. Safeguarding should make sure that people get the support they need to make the most of their lives and get their full equal rights. Employers must still make sure they do not employ bad staff or volunteers to care for vulnerable adults and children. They should make sure that staff and volunteers have a Police Check before they are left to work alone with vulnerable adults and children. If an organisation has sacked or planned to sack a member of staff or volunteer who has left because they have harmed a child or vulnerable adult, they must tell the Independent Safeguarding Authority. A person who is or may be unable to take care of him or herself. A person who is unable to protect him or herself against serious harm or being taken advantage of. All organizations that work with or come into contact with children should have safeguarding policies and procedures to ensure that every child, regardless of their age, gender, religion or ethnicity, can be protected from harm. Setting up and following good safeguarding policies and procedures means children are safe from adults and other children who might pose a risk. The information and advice on these pages have been provided by Safe Network to help organization’s understand and meet their child protection...

Words: 291 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Women in Saxon Time vs Women in Modern Time

...husbands or Masters vs. women of modern times that had more “Say so” or rights. The women of modern times made mostly of their own decisions. Women in Anglo-Saxon society were expected to be dictated to their husbands or fathers. The women were only allowed a certain time of freedom away from their husbands or father. The only way a woman could work was through her husband or father until they died. Over all the setbacks there still was some opportunities for women to be involved in things or lifestyles above their responsibilities. Women during this time also had a high rate of the dangers of things like pregnancies. Overall the women spend their whole lives under the protection of the men folk. On other hands women in modern times have laws in place that now protect them. A modern woman is now a equal person to any other person. There is nothing a women cannot do without her husband. Women are now seen as sisters, mother, Grandmother etc. In modern times littler girls grew fast, dreaming of their wedding. Women during this time lived as single parents with no problems. Women are now free to choose their life and the way they want to live. Women in Anglo-Saxon time are so indifferent from modern women today however they shared so much alike. They both deal with putting up some type of fight to make away. It didn’t’t matter what both Anglo-Saxon and Modern women did, they was always hard worked. Them both had opportunities to be involved in things and were not taking out...

Words: 480 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Security

...Assignment 1 Lee Holland Identify what you see as the main purpose of security management and discuss what is meant by the statement that ‘security measures must be commensurate with the threat’. Within this essay I seek to break down the main assignment into the two phases that are within the title, the first being; What is the main purpose of security management? a role that to some would be undervalued, inconvenient, poorly funded and a hindrance, where to others, it is an effective, well-co-ordinated and highly desirable position, which when funded correctly, will have a positive effect on an organisations financial goals in the aid of preventing the loss of their assets through ways that were not before protected, this both in the corporate business and the commercial world. A reliable and effective security function is an asset to any organisation wishing to protect their tangible and intangible assets from compromise. In the second phase I will discuss what is meant by the statement that “security measures must be commensurate with the threat” In a world where the threats are changing daily, it is imperative that security procedures, policies and counter measures are kept up to date, and in line with the current rules and regulations of the security industry, they must also work within the National law within the county that they might be operating in. With financial constrictions and fierce competition within the business world it is only natural that an organisation...

Words: 685 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Hardware

...Hardware and Software Firewalls Explained A firewall is a protective system that lies, in essence, between your computer network and the Internet. When used correctly, a firewall prevents unauthorized use and access to your network. The job of a firewall is to carefully analyze data entering and exiting the network based on your configuration. It ignores information that comes from an unsecured, unknown or suspicious locations. A firewall plays an important role on any network as it provides a protective barrier against most forms of attack coming from the outside world. Firewalls can be either hardware or software. The ideal firewall configuration will consist of both. In addition to limiting access to you computer and network, a firewall is also useful for allowing remote access to a private network through secure authentication certificates and logins. While many people do not completely understand the importance and necessity of a firewall, or consider it to be a product for businesses only, if your network or computer has access to the outside world via the Internet then you need have a firewall to protect your network, individual computer and data therein. Hardware Firewalls Hardware firewalls can be purchased as a stand-alone product but more recently hardware firewalls are typically found in broadband routers, and should be considered an important part of your system and network set-up, especially for anyone on a broadband connection. Hardware firewalls can be effective...

Words: 837 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Pass 4

...to hold inside in the conversion for the safeguard of human rights and fundamental freedom. With this Act in place it allows users of a health and social care profession to not get discriminated upon and for everyone to have the opportunity to be able to use services. Furthermore, it allows everyone to be able to use A&E which is an Accident and Emergency service for free regardless of who they are. Equality Act 2010 The whole Equality Act is brought together by 116 single different fragments of legislations within one Act. The Act offers a legal framework to protect the rights of an individual and improve equality of opportunity for everyone. This Act protects individuals from being treated unfair and to create a fairer and more equal society. The Equality Act 2010 protects characteristics of any individuals. One of the Acts protected age which protect employees regardless their age, this allows employers to justify straight discrimination. There are many other important characteristics such as disability, gender...

Words: 620 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

1. Explain Whether or Not the Fact That Gabby’s Surname Is Rally Gives Her the Right to Use It Any Way She Wishes.

...or not it matters that Rally is associated with pizza.Tradename protection extends to zone of reputation, zone of expansion, and zone of marketing in addition to being the first in the area. Because Rally is associated with Pizza andwith Motors, it is not as much of a conflict as it would have been if Gabby had a used car dealership and decided to call it Rally¶s Used Cars. According to Robert Wayne Olson Jr¶sexample, ³The Rose Cafe (a restaurant) does not conflict with The Rose Law Firm (legalservices), nor does either conflict with Rose Story Farm (a nursery). However, if Violet Rosewants to open the Violet Rose Bistro, that name could be sufficiently confusing to bar its use inthe same area as The Rose Café.´ In my opinion it is not distinct and therefore can beconsidered as confusing. In order to be protected under tradename laws, the business owner must not have a confusingly similar name to a company that was registered in the same 4 Running head: RALLY ROUND THE TRADE NAME geographic area first. Rally is associated with pizza as well as with motors and as a result in thevideo, many consumers were confused and were calling the car dealership and placing orders for pizza.3. E xplain how important the fact is that Herman started to use the name Rally first in that particular geographical area.The fact that Herman began using the name 40 years ago protects him under common law,trade name protection by registration and he used the name first in the area. Under each...

Words: 549 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Safety Inspection

...month I s tasked to inspect all the companies safety equipment and personal protective equipment. My inspection was broke down into three categories, availability, serviceability and whether it was within calibration standards. During the availability portion I was to find out how easy it was to get if needed, and if there was enough available according to how many personnel used it. Having enough PPE was the biggest issue that I found. Safety glasses, hard hats and leather gloves were items that I found not every person had. We did have adequate amounts of disposable earplugs. I had my supply order the shortages and ordered earmuffs that attach to the hard hats, so everybody had them. We have several generators at our company; hearing protection is a high priority. Serviceability was next on my agenda. There is a lot of equipment in my company that is getting old and out dated. This equipment is very expensive, so I needed to justify major purchases. I did not find much that was not functional. I was able to get little tools purchased, and put an order in for more updated equipment. We are very reactive, not proactive. When things break they are purchased, if they’re not broke we won’t fix them. Lastly I had to check to see if the equipment has been properly tested within the allotted time frame. This area had been neglected, and I found numerous deficiencies. I found test equipment that was out of date with calibrations and PPE that was out of its window for inspection...

Words: 421 - Pages: 2