Free Essay

Ethical Dilemma Paper

In:

Submitted By rondabrininstool
Words 775
Pages 4
Ethical Dilemma Paper
Ronda Brininstool
November 4, 2013
CJA/324

Ethical dilemma is what these parents are facing when it comes to their 10 year old daughter Sarah Murnaghan. Sarah is in the end stages of her fight with cystic fibrosis at the Children’s hospital of Philadelphia. Doctors are saying her only way of being able to survive is with a lung transplant from another human. Since children’s lung transplants are in far and few between the only hope she has is to get an adult lung transplant and there are laws in place to stop that from happening. Without this transplant from an adult which is easier to come by then a child Sarah only have a few weeks to live. Because there is a policy in place that stops Sarah from getting an adult lung transplant she can only receive a transplant from another child. And children lungs are not readily available so Sarah’s parents are asking that she be able to receive an adult lung transplant and Sarah’s doctors are saying that it will be a success and that she would survive if she received one. Yet she cannot receive one because of the policy in place. Her parents are racing against the clock to ask law makers to make an exception this one time. There are several lawmakers that are joining Sarah’s fight to change the law so that she can receive a lung to be able to grow up and becoming an adult. Rep. Lou Barletta, R-PA is asking that the rules against Sarah receiving an adult lung be suspended until the policy can be looked at which she believes to be flawed (Quijano, 2013). Sebelius who is the Health and Human Services Secretary, who is saddened by what the Murnaghan’s are going through, has asked for a review of the policy but states that this policy is in place for a reason. The reason being that lungs are different than other organs and it is based on the person being able to survive the transplant and it is always been thought that children should have a child’s lung transplant. After the parents waged a battle to temporarily change the policy so that Sarah could receive an adult lung transplant, Sarah was so close to death before she received her two double lung transplant. The test show that Sarah is not rejecting the lungs at all and that she is actually doing well and has been taking off oxygen. Sarah is on the road to recovery and has several plans to live a young girl’s life and do all the girlie things that girls her age do. Even though the lungs are doing great and she is getting stronger she still has to relearn how to walk. Sarah is a fighter that is for sure and everyone that has met her and has helped her gain her life back can see that she is up for whatever challenge may come her way. The alternative courses of action could have been that lawmakers stuck with the policy that children could not receive an adult lung. They could have stated that it would not be safe for a child and that there could be major problems to the child. It could also be said that it would be taking away from another adult and what makes a child more important than an adult when it comes to a lung transplant. When looking at if a policy should be changed it needs to be proven that it would be a health and safe and that there is a good possibility that it will work. It cannot be just said that it is something they want to try and if it works it works. Doctor’s in Sarah’s case were sure that her receiving an adult lung she would be able to live a healthy life. They could see the fight in her and the determination of wanting to live. As of today Sarah is still living a healthy life and her receiving the lung was an amazing story one that she will be able to live to tell her children and friends. Sarah will have a long road of recovery and have to always live a little different than others but she is excited to start living her life to the fullest.
References
Quijano, Elaine. (June 5, 2013.)Childs Lung Transplant Need Presents Complex Ethical Dilemma. http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-505269_162-57587744/.
Welch, Chris and Carroll, Jason. (August 26, 2013). Lung Transplant gives Sarah Murnaghan Chance to Live Her Dreams. http://www.cnn.com/2013/08/26/health/sarah-murnaghan- update/

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Problem Solution: Remington Peckinpaw Davis Inc

...Running head: PROBLEM SOLUTION: Remington Peckinpaw Davis Inc. Problem Solution: Remington Peckinpaw Davis Inc. MMPBL510 / Implementing Organizational Initiatives University of Phoenix March 14, 2011 Problem Solution: Remington Peckinpaw Davis Inc. Remington Peckinpaw Davis is an asset group experiencing technical problems with its online trading services. The company needs to be more proactive in the research and development of its software and techniques and stop guessing the costs the project, given the failure of the first phase of the strategic implementation. “Successful implementation requires both technical and social skills. Project managers have to plan and budget projects as well as orchestrate the contributions of other” (Gray & Larson, 2006. p. 14). Table 1 Issues and Opportunities Identification | | | | |Issues |Opportunities |Reference to Specific | | | |Course Concept | |Data reliability: Harlan’s data, estimates |An effective project monitoring system can|“A project monitoring system involves determining what | |and development plans were not accurate, |assist (RPD) in ensuring that the...

Words: 541 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...Ethical Dilemma Wilbert Thacker CMGT/575 December 1, 2014 Gordon Hodgson Ethical Dilemma Ethical dilemmas, also known as a moral dilemmas, are situations in which there is a choice to be made between two options, neither of which resolves the situation in an ethically acceptable fashion. In such cases, societal and personal ethical guidelines can provide no satisfactory outcome for the chooser. Ethical dilemmas assume that the chooser will abide by societal norms, such as codes of law or religious teachings, in order to make the choice ethically impossible (Your Dictionary, 2014). As a project manager it is their job to manage and get to know their team. The CIO has informed the project manager that his/her team will be released and the department will be outsourced. In this situation the first step that should be taken is gathering all of the facts. The CIO has informed the project manager that their department would be outsourced and their team would be released but there was no reason provided. As a concerned project manager it is almost their obligation to research to what led up to this decision. A decision this drastic couldn’t have possibly be made over night. The main ethical issue here is it has to be a trust issue between the company they are providing the service for and the project management team. Most of those issues revolve around project management teams not completing a service on time or a service not meeting expectations. Many people will...

Words: 778 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ethical Decision-Making in Psychology

...The Complexity of Ethical Decision Making Former U.S. Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart remarked, "Ethics is knowing the difference between what you have a right to do and what is right to do." In parsing out a virtuous ethical identity, psychologists strive to embrace several American Psychological Association [APA]-worthy overarching principles, to apply the enumerated guidelines within the Code of Ethics, and to cultivate personal and professional integrity in their quest to serve others. Furthermore, making an ethical commitment to placing the well-being of clients above one’s own personal feelings is paramount in providing effective therapeutic services that clients seek. However, the gentle human interplay of dependency, power, and will; the uniqueness and unpredictability of autonomous human beings; and the complexity of personality, behavior, and the inimitable experiences of each individual clearly drive and complicate the process of ethical decision-making. In espousing the “very highest ethical ideals of the profession (Hill, 2008),” eventually every psychologist must find a way to merge her purely objective, linear, and rational ethical catechism with her own intuitive responses to best reflect and balance her style, therapeutic orientation, and professional belief system with the needs of each distinct client. Conversely, a purely sensate approach to ethical decision-making, it seems, relies too heavily on subjectivity, whimsy, and emotions...

Words: 2319 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Ethical Dilemma Assignment

...CONSENT FORM Thank you for being willing to take part in this interview exploring ethical conflict or turbulence. I would like to transcribe the content of this interview to form a written document to be submitted to Sheffield Hallam University as a piece of assessed piece of coursework. It is important that you only take part in this interview if you want to. As such I would be delighted if you would complete and sign this confidentiality questionnaire prior to the interview taking place. (i) In general terms are you willing to take part in this interview: and an edited transcript of the interview submitted to Sheffield Hallam? Yes (ii) Are you happy for your own name to be used in the transcript: or do you want the final transcript to written up with a pseudonym? Own name (iii) Are you happy for the names of other people and organisations to be used in the final transcript: or do you want all other names to be content of this transcription to be submitted to Sheffield Hallam? Pseudonyms (iv) Are you happy for me to submit the final transcript without you reviewing it - or do you want to reserve the right to see the final transcript before I submit? Submit unseen (v) Sometimes the ethical dilemmas described in these transcripts provide real life case studies that can be helpful to show other students, and can provide rich data for research projects. Would you be willing for this transcript to be used in further teaching or research - or would you prefer...

Words: 1766 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Frameworks of Ethics

...nurse, ethical dilemmas can arise at any moment. It is imperative that through proper education and training registered nurses have the ethical capacity and intelligence to work through these issues with compassion and integrity. Take into account he following case scenario; a 6-year-old child develops a high fever, vomiting, and convulsions at school. After seeking medical care, the diagnosis of meningitis is reached and the physician requests to start treatment from the child’s parents. The parents are divorced; the mother has primary custody but is not the biological parent. The mother is a Christian Scientist who insists that no medical treatment be initiated per her religious beliefs. The biological father resides in another state, but he insists that treatment be initiated and seeks independent consultation from another physician. Through ethical decision making with assistance from Uustal’s nine-step model, it is possible to identify the ethical dilemma presented, integrate the decision-making model to identify an ethical solution, and incorporate family dialogue to both parents of the child regarding the issue at hand. When an ethical decision must be made, one must first identify the ethical dilemma. "...An ethical dilemma is a common type of situation that involves two, or more, morally correct courses of action that cannot both be followed” (Purtilo, Ruth & Doherty, 2011, p. 57). Ethical dilemmas involve both ethical conflict and conduct. "An ethical dilemma occurs...

Words: 456 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...Option 2: EthicsGame Dilemmas ETH/316 Option 2: EthicsGame Dilemmas Introduction The project that was presented included the application of personal values in working through two different ethical dilemmas. In order to work through each of the dilemmas two analytical skill sets were used to come to a resolution. The first skill set involved the use of the four ethical lenses. The lenses include the Results Lens, Rights/Responsibility Lens, Relationship Lens, and Reputation Lens. The second skill involves the use of the Baird Decision Model which is a five-step process that gives a systematic approach to the resolution of an ethical dilemma. The five steps of the Baird Decision Model include: * Step 1: Be Attentive * Step 2: Be Intelligent * Step 3: Be Reasonable * Step 4: Be Responsible * Step 5: Be Reflective The combination of the ethical lenses with the decision model provides the groundwork to come up with, good value based, solutions to ethical conflict (Rian Brown,  2014). Mysterious Blogger The first ethical conflict that was presented was that of the “Mysterious Blogger.” In this simulation the Director of Information Technology, who is responsible for managing all internal information system functions which include systems programming, application programming, networks, and computer operations, is presented with an employee who is leaking the proprietary company information to the public through a blog sight as an anonymous...

Words: 1292 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma Paper

...Ethical Dilemma Analysis Paper Making A Difference In analyzing the ethical dilemma in this case, I take cognizance of the environment in which my organization operates and I understand that the moral standards of behavior differ among individuals. I also recognize that moral problems in business are complex and difficult to resolve. I employed the application of Hosmer’s rule in my analysis of the ethical problems so as to reach an objective decision. The question arising from this case can be viewed and analyzed in two different dimensions. Both dimensions would however reach the same or similar conclusions. Why do I have to sign a document realizing that some of the fund is going for bribery? One dimension of analyzing this is to assume the whole decision making process is based on my appending the signature on the document – and not subject to further questioning. Another dimension is that even if I append my signature, the project is still subject to further testing and approval. Based on the premise that the road project will not executed if I do not sign the inflated contract document, and choosing not to sign, some groups are going to be hurt or harmed in ways outside their control while others will be benefited or helped. The right and benefit of residents of Maryland local government area to have their roads constructed will be denied. Even, delay in implementing this project will hurt this group. The construction company, ABC will also be hurt by losing the...

Words: 973 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma Paper

...Most of the time when nurses face situations that neither would benefit the decision maker or the individuals involved, it becomes an ethical dilemma. When Arthur refused to perform an activity and the personal support worker (PSW) proceeded anyway, it violated autonomy for his care. Arthur struck the PSW and the PSW hit Arthur back. Clearly, it compromised the client’s well-being when the assault occurred. In long term-care facilities, PSW’s needed to maintain specific routines for the day. However, when clients refuse and does not meet the PSW’s schedule, it is neither acceptable to disrespect a client’s refusal nor coerce the client in performing activities against their will. Additionally, striking a client is abuse. According to CNO,...

Words: 374 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma Paper

...Week 7 Ethical Dilemma Paper Jered Gordner Professor Cuzzone HUMN-232 Week 7 Ethical Dilemma Paper As with many industries today, the healthcare industry is fraught with ethically dilemmas one can be involved with on an almost ongoing, daily basis. Since there are so many different arms and hands in so many different cookie jars, it’s easy to get lost in all the ethical dilemmas that could amass before your very eyes. On the professional side of the equation you may run into the dilemma of having a child from humble beginnings, without the means to pay, become struck down with a disease undocumented and unlike anything that is currently on the books. Do you treat the child pro-bono or do you let them go untreated and more than likely die? On the insurance side (something I’ve personally run into) one of the men in a gay couple, who has been together for 30 years, is in the hospital and the other man needs to know the medication his partner is on so the pharmacy will release it to him. Since they are not legally married they do not have the same rights and access to information as a straight married couple. Do you go against HIPAA and release the information or do you withhold it because of the law? These two dilemmas are not uncommon in the health industry. Doctors and nurses come across patients with no insurance on a daily basis and more often than not, they are forced to turn them away untreated. This ethical decision can weigh heavily on their heads. I find this...

Words: 1620 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Ethical Paper Dilemma

...Ethical Dilemma Paper Ulises N. Sosa Professor: Jack Shippee Ethics in Criminal Justice University of Phoenix South Carolina police officer fired after classroom confrontation with students. Officer Ben Fields from the Richard county sheriff's department lost his job after he was witness throwing a student across the room during an altercation. The officer was called to the classroom after an unruly student had refused several times to stop using her phone and to leave the classroom. Officer Fields is seen struggling and consequently tossing a student off her chair by what it appears to be excessive force. The student repeatedly refused to stop using her cellphone. The student the strikes the officer several times on the neck are when the officer attempts to remove her from the classroom using physical force. This is when the officer is seen dragging her and tossing her across the room, and finally subduing the student by placing her on mechanical wrist restraints. The ethical dilemma here is the actions taken by the school resource officer Deputy Fields. He repeatedly directed the student to surrender the cell phone device and then to leave the room. He then used means of physical force and physically handle a student resulting on the tossing around of the same. Is believe that the officer was justified during the entire process up to the point when he is seen throwing the student across the room in what it appears an unorthodox method. The question that emerge after...

Words: 934 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma Paper

...Moral dilemma in the video is there are 3 people stuck on an island a highly skilled heart surgeon, the Pope, and myself. There is enough material on the island to build a two-man boat and I need to decide between us three who would be saved from the island. The desired goal would be to save all three of us. The ethical dilemma is one would need to be left behind or we all three leave in a two-man boat, knowing that none of us will survive. In this decision-making process, all my emotions will have an impact. If I stay on the island, fear of death, anxiety, and hopelessness will occur. I do not have the skills to survive on an island. But neither would the Pope or the surgeon. The fact of knowing whoever is left behind on the island will not survive means I am putting someone’s life in my own hands....

Words: 659 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemmas Of Cloning Research Paper

...De-extinction or not? The ethical dilemmas of cloning extinct species have been a...

Words: 2296 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemmas In Law Enforcement Research Paper

...Abstract Police Officers, Agents or management personnel face a plethora of ethical and legal dilemma on a daily basis. It doesn’t matter if they are just regular police officers, federal law enforcement officers(DEA), or in a management position, they face these dilemmas every day. This paper will outline the dilemma that most affects law enforcement personnel. The paper will also give a overview of what ethics is and also some examples of when someone’s ethics has been compromised. Ethics Overview It doesn’t matter what job an individual has; all position requires their employee to stay ethical. Dempsey and Forst (2016) define ethics as being a study of what constitutes good or bad behavior. People sometimes use ethics and moral...

Words: 396 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cjs 211 Empower Learning/ Indigohelp

...211 Week 1 Individual Assignment Ethical Dilemma Paper CJS 211 Week 1 DQ 1 CJS 211 Week 1 DQ 2 CJS 211 Week 2 Individual Assignment Ethical Dilemma Worksheet Law Enforcement CJS 211 Week 2 DQ 1 CJS 211 Week 2 DQ 2 CJS 211 Week 2 Team Assignment Ethical Decision Making Paper CJS 211 Week 3 Individual Assignment Ethical Dilemma Worksheet Prosecutors CJS 211 Week 3 Team Assignment Ethics Issue Presentation CJS 211 Week 3 DQ 1 CJS 211 Week 3 DQ 2 CJS 211 Week 4 Individual Assignment Ethical Dilemma Worksheet Corrections CJS 211 Week 4 Team Assignment Ethical Scrapbook Part I CJS 211 Week 4 DQ 1 CJS 211 Week 4 DQ 2 CJS 211 Week 5 Individual Assignment Victims’ Rights and Vengeance CJS 211 Week 5 Team Assignment Ethical Scrapbook Part II CJS 211 Week 5 DQ 1 CJS 211 Week 5 DQ 2 ………………………………………………… CJS 211 Week 1 DQ 1 For more classes visit www.indigohelp.com Acceptable Lying Can you think of any situations in which lying is acceptable? Explain your answer. ………………………………………………… CJS 211 Week 1 DQ 2 For more classes visit www.indigohelp.com Deontological versus Utilitarianism If you had to choose one ethical system, deontological or utilitarianism, which one most closely conforms to your own beliefs? Explain your answer ………………………………………………… CJS 211 Week 1 Individual Assignment Ethical Dilemma Paper For more classes visit www.indigohelp.com Write a 700- to 1,050-word paper in which you discuss an ethical dilemma from a current story in the news...

Words: 484 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Psych 545 Week 3 Individual Ethical Decision Making Paper

...PSYCH 545 Week 3 Individual Ethical Decision Making Paper To Buy This material Click below link http://www.uoptutors.com/PSYCH-545/PSYCH-545-Week-3-Individual-Ethical-Decision-Making-Paper PSYCH 545 Week 3 Individual Ethical Decision Making Paper Resources: Ch. 11 of Ethics in Psychology and Counseling, Internet, and University Library Select an ethical dilemma in professional psychology. Obtain faculty approval prior to beginning the assignment. Write a 1,400- to 1,750-word paper based on your selected ethical dilemma. Be sure to address the following items in your paper: •    Describe your selected ethical dilemma. •    Apply each one of the first 14 steps (located in Ch. 11) in the ethical decision making process to your selected issue. •    Explain the importance of ethical decision making in professional psychology. Format your paper consistent with APA guidelines. Click the Assignment Files tab to submit your assignment. PSYCH 545 Week 3 Individual Ethical Decision Making Paper Resources: Ch. 11 of Ethics in Psychology and Counseling, Internet, and University Library Select an ethical dilemma in professional psychology. Obtain faculty approval prior to beginning the assignment. Write a 1,400- to 1,750-word paper based on your selected ethical dilemma. Be sure to address the following items in your paper: •    Describe your selected ethical dilemma. •    Apply each one of the first 14 steps (located in Ch. 11) in the ethical decision making process to your...

Words: 269 - Pages: 2