...Do you agree with the view that the main reason for Wolsey’s fall from power was his failure to secure the annulment of the king’s marriage to Catherine? 1)Failed to secure annulment 2)Factions against him-Aristocrats and anne boleyn out to get him 3)Combination of factors Thomas Wolsey’s rapid rise to power following the first French war is often overshadowed by his even faster downfall by 1529. The third source heavily implies that Wolsey’s downfall was due to factions in particular the Boleyn faction, but it also subtly suggests Wolsey’s previous failures i.e. the amicable grant “fiasco” made him much more susceptible to criticism and helped sow doubt into Henrys mind. Source 4 supports the third source and also brings to attention the role played by another group of people- the aristocrats- who despised Wolsey and as Loades claims Wolsey was a “victim of factional intrigues organised by leading aristocrats”. However the final source totally disagrees with the theory that it was purely factions that resulted in Wolsey’s downfall and instead supports the statement given to an extent, but believes it was a combination of factors that resulted in his downfall, something which the evidence tends to support. There is no doubt that Wolsey’s inability to secure an annulment of Henrys marriage to Catherine infuriated Henry and Wolsey’s sacking was a direct response to this failure. By 1529 the pope was under the control of Charles V after the latter’s victory at the battle...
Words: 1266 - Pages: 6
...who tried to persuade her to “enter a convent.” Wolsey, in source 6, was able to foresee Katherine’s potential opposition, even at the very start of the process: “In case the Queen rejects my authority.” Scarrisbrick argues that it was her refusal to go to the convent which started the process which was in turn made worse by the actions of others, notably Henry. Indeed we know that when such an offer was made she replied that she would, but only when Henry entered a monastery. This does seem to back up the idea that she opposed in a determined fashion. She had good reason to do so. Declaring that her marriage was annulled, would, in effect, be a declaration that the previous twenty years had been an aberration and that her beloved daughter Mary was illegitimate with no right to claim the throne in future. It is hardly surprising that she opposed, thus contributing to the failure to gain an annulment. Scarrisbrick goes on to argue that her opposition led others, notably Charles, her nephew, to take...
Words: 1689 - Pages: 7
...Do you agree with the view that the main reasons for Henry's failure to obtain the annulment of his marriage in the years 1525-29 was the determined opposition of Katherine of Aragon? Within the years of 1525-29 Henry failed to obtain an annulment of his marriage, it was suggested that the main reason for this failure was because of the determined opposition of Katherine of Aragon however it is also argued that other factors such as the pope keeping peace between England and Spain as well as the overall weakness of the kings case and his reliance’s on biblical reasons as well as Katherine’s of Aragon’s opposition all these factors also contributed to the failure to obtain the annulment. The view that the main reasons on why Henry didn’t receive his annulment was because of the determined opposition of Katherine of Aragon, within source 4 its suggested that Katherine was trying to uphold her dignity as Henry persisted for the annulment. Henry's reasoning for the annulment left Katherine feeling red-faced as well as full of anguish Henry was trying to declare (by the end of the marriage) his 23 years of marriage to Katherine of Aragon was a deception which supplied Katherine with the determined opposition to annul Henry their marriage which conducted to the failure to obtain the annulment. Another supportive evidence found in source 4 that encourages the view that the main reasons on why Henry didn’t receive his annulment was because of the determined opposition of Katherine...
Words: 1030 - Pages: 5
...There were many key factors attributing to the failed annulments plans, some were as result of Henry, such as the contrasting bible quotes presented and the diplomatic revolution caused by Henry’s thirst for European influence, other factors could be ofcourse contributed to the opposition of Catherine of Aragon who was continually persistent that her marriage to Henry was valid and the other main argument against the annulment was from the Catholic church. These combined factors essentially caused the break with Rome however one was predominantly more significant than the others. Source 4 makes reference to one of the reasons Henry’s claims were so flawed, “Wolsey worried about Henrys' reliance on biblical arguments.” This shows that Henry clearly had little other evidence to support his reasons for an annulment due to his “reliance” which rightly worried Wolsey as they were constantly being questioned by the Catholic Church. In 1527 Henry presented the case that his marriage to Catherine of Aragon was void due to the fact she had previously been married to his brother who had died. Leviticus claims that “Thou shalt not uncover the nakedness of thy brother’s wife.” Henry claimed that the dispensation that he had fought for was infact invalid afterall as it went against divine law. A dispensation that had gone against clerical teachings yet granted none the less by the pope, supporting the claims in Source 5 that the “pope would have been happy to please someone as important...
Words: 904 - Pages: 4
...Janie Killicks/Stark/Woods: A Hero or A Failure? In Hurston’s novel, Their Eyes Were Watching God, the most prevalent imagery consistent throughout the whole novel is of nature, both beautiful and powerful. Nature’s temperament gradually shifts from an innocent ideal into a destructive force in synchronization with Janie’s life. Janie’s wish is to be in a loving marriage, represented by the pear tree and blossoms; however, once she finally achieves this desire, the hopeful nature she had once longed for gradates into a damaging monster that ultimately kills Tea Cake and consequently, her dream. Though Kubitschek believes that her quest for the pear tree is obtained through her marriage to Tea Cake, the violent hurricane reveals Janie’s ultimate failure in attaining the one thing she wanted the most. The change in nature that occurs once Janie believes that she has achieved her fantasy of a blossoming marriage represents an epiphany, a coming of age moment in which Janie’s childhood dreams are realized as unrealistic and naïve, as the true, destructive disposition of nature is unleashed. The most driving force in Janie’s early teenage years is the need for attainment of the ideal marriage filled with love and equality, which she was introduced to by a pear tree in full blossom filled with sexual images such as “dust-bearing bees sink[ing] into the sanctum of a bloom” (Hurston 11). She became obsessed with the spring and “attempts to harmonize her daily life with her ideal image...
Words: 1269 - Pages: 6
...Some may say King Henry VIII was the first King to go against the church to get what he wanted. It was not allowed to divorce in those days, however Henry was able to marry, divorce and even kill a few of his wives during his reign. Disparate for a male heir, Henry did everything in his power to produce a male child weather it was within or outside his marriages. Is it safe to say that Henry may have paved the way for such dysfunction in modern lives when it comes to family and marriage? What if his wife Catherine gave him a healthy son? Would marriage and the church be different today? Resentment, failure to communicate and disconnect are only a few reasons why some marriages end. Failure to have a male child was Queen Catherine’s biggest...
Words: 594 - Pages: 3
...Running head: CHICK-fil-A COMMUNICATION FAILURE Chick-fil-A Communication Failure Larry Boyd Southern New Hampshire University Sunday, July 5, 2015 CHICK-fil-A COMMUNICATION FAILURE !2 Introduction Every organization is prone to different crisis thus; they should learn the necessary procedures to follow when such an incident occurs. Failure to this, the company or organization may destroy its reputation in the market. In July 2012, the CEO of the Chick-fil-A (Dan Cathy) faced a media storm, when he publicly announced his ground on the same-sex marriage. His remarks wedged crisis from homosexual community and other supporters of the civil right movement (Clare, 2014). In this paper, it will discuss the crisis that faced Chick-fil-A and how the organization should respond to such scenario in the future. The paper will also analyze different leadership communication failures and explain how a leader should respond to such controversies. Leadership communication failures After the aftermath, Dan Cathy made several comments on the radio station that led to national anger. The company was under crisis when the leader made comments that his company has been, and will always be ran by a family that understand what definition of a family is; what the bible define marriage as being one man and one woman. People had different opinions towards Mr. Cathy’s comments. For instance, some thought that the company discriminated other cultures as the leader based...
Words: 1542 - Pages: 7
... Child Marriage Throughout the world, marriage is seen as a celebration where two madly in love individuals unite as one. Child marriage on the other hand, gives no such cause for a celebration or any type of happiness. Globally, especially in developing countries, many young children are ensnared and forced into marriage at a really young age to men twice or even three times their age. Robbing the innocence and purity of young girls is in fact an inhuman thing to do. Child marriage should come to an end throughout all countries. Child marriage is in fact a violation of human rights that exploits and strips young girls of their innocence, which then exposes them to the harsh realities of adulthood in countries where poverty and lack of education is high. Being a child means going to school, hanging out with your friends or just being at home eating junk food and watching television for long hours. In many developing countries children already know what being an adult means. Children are getting married, cooking and cleaning for their husbands, and even sleeping with them. According to Alexandra Hervish and Charlotte Feldman-Jacobs, “ In the last decade, 58 million young woman in developing countries – one in three – have been married before the age of 18, many against their will and in violation of international laws and convention of woman’s rights. Even more disturbing, according to new figures, one in nine girls, or 15 million, have been forced into marriage between the...
Words: 1756 - Pages: 8
...Bachelorhood vs. Marriage A research report on the above topic for ‘Eng 105-Advanced Composition’ course as a partial course completion requirement. Prepared for: Mr. Abdus Selim Lecturer Eng 105 Section: 6 North South University Prepared by: Safwan Dawood Shams Id# 093-0670-530 Acknowledgement I would like to express deep appreciation and thanks to all the students of North South University who helped me by sparing their valuable time and participating in the questionnaires of the survey allowing me to complete my research within the specified deadline. I would also like to thank my course instructor, Mr Abdus Selim for his valuable guidance, support, instructions and all out cooperation in writing the research paper. Abstract This research paper is on the topic “Bachelorhood vs. Marriage”. Marriage has been a usual norm through centuries. It is a bonding that binds a man and a woman towards a new relationship with the aim of sharing responsibilities, happiness and sorrows till the day they die. It has been a normal phenomenon in the society which recently has been faced by some changes from the new generation. On the other hand, bachelorhood is a state where a man/woman is not married or not in a pair bond. It includes men/women who lives independently, outside of their parents’ home and other institutional settings who are not engaged in a bond of marriage. Through this research, I wanted to find out whether the upcoming generation is in for marriage or in favour...
Words: 2600 - Pages: 11
...According to the general definition, divorce refers to a process of legally dissolving a marriage. The concept of divorce did not exist under Hindu law as the marriage is considered to be a sacred relationship. However, the concept of Divorce was introduced when a law to this effect was codified and presently section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act provides for dissolution of marriage. Mozley and Whitley define divorce, in their 1967 law book: "Divorce (is) the termination of a marriage otherwise than by death or annulment ." As Justice Gray of the Supreme Court of the United States of America wrote in Atherton case: "The purpose and effect of a decree of divorce from the bond of matrimony, by a court of competent jurisdiction, are to change the existing status or domestic relation of husband and wife, and to free them both from the bond. The marriage tie, when thus severed as to one party, ceases to bind either. A husband without a wife, or a wife without a husband, is unknown to the law ." Theories of divorce: - a) Fault theory: - under this theory marriage can be dissolved only when one of the parties to the marriage has committed a matrimonial offence. In this theory it is necessary to have one innocent party and one guilty party. If both the parties are guilty, then no remedy available...
Words: 1949 - Pages: 8
...questioned by the Catholic Church. In 1527 Henry presented the case that his marriage to Catherine of Aragon was void due to the fact she had previously been married to his brother who had died. Leviticus claims that “Thou shalt not uncover the nakedness of thy brother’s wife.” Henry claimed that the dispensation that he had fought for was infact invalid afterall as it went against divine law. A dispensation that had gone against clerical teachings yet granted none the less by the pope, supporting the claims in Source 5 that the “pope would have been happy to please someone as important as Henry.” However it was not the dispensation that caused concern, it was a text from Deuteronomy that claimed Henry was infact right in marrying Catherine as Deuteronomy claimed that if a mans brother dies and he and his wife are without child, then it is the brother’s role to raise his widow. This essentially proved Henry’s claim wrong, weakening his case. However, despite the opposition based on biblical teachings, this was not a large concern as Source 2 and 3 highlight, Wolsey... View Full Essay Join Now Please login to view the full essay... Essay's Statistics Submitted by: kirstymackinlay Date shared: 11/07/2012 02:21 PM Words: 904 Pages: 4 Save Paper Report this Essay Similar Documents Do You Agree With The View That The Main Reasons For Henry's Failure To Obtain The Annulment Of His Marriage In The Years 1525-29 Was The Determined Opposition Of Katherine Of Aragon...
Words: 820 - Pages: 4
...A Study of What Makes Marriages Succeed or Fail Priscilla Mullennix Liberty University Abstract Marriage is a very special gift for the human race, God knew that we are a people of loneliness and He did not want us to go through this life alone. Unfortunately society does not see it this way. Many marriages fail at not putting God first. They fail at not looking at their marriages as being a covenant. And they fail at not communicating their feelings to each other. With this they end in separation and divorce. From the start we should put God first in marriages, realizing that marriage is a covenant with God and your spouse. Having your marriage become a success or a failure is all up to the couple, it is their choice on what path they will choose for their marriage. They need to consider what path they take and the outcome of that path at the end. A Study of What Makes Marriages Succeed or Fail Marriages today have become under the direct line of fire from our adversary, the devil. Our day and time seems to have diminished the value that is placed upon marriage and the great treasure and gift that this is from God. As with many things in our day and age, many ask the question of how they can have success to prevent a failure. Nobody likes to fail in the matters of life. It doesn’t matter what it is, owning a business, going back to school as an adult, and even the marriages and relationships we find ourselves in. How does a marriage succeed? And what is the...
Words: 2420 - Pages: 10
... Don’t allow the devil to be a foothold in your marriage Satan keeps ur pass afloat Jesus remember ur sin no more and he looks to ur future No matter what the circumstances look like if he is still not doing things nice to you u still pray and honor Christ by treating ur husband as a loving, caring, respectful individual Bad sprits using his daughter and sister to get tom I rebuke them in the name of Jesus. Are you, as a wife, bringing honor to God in the way you treat your husband? We are to “love each other with brotherly affection and take delight in honoring each other” (Romans 12:10, tlb, emphasis added). Are you taking delight in honoring your husband? Matthew 5:11-12 Proverbs 19:11 gentle answers Proverbs 31:11-12 Romans 15:2-3, 12-10-17( NKJ) Reap coals of fire on there head I Peter 2:21‑3:6 emphasizes that a believer's willingness to stay in his marriage and suffer quietly may be the only means by which the other partner will eventually be healed. Also be submissive, obey, respect The realization then begins to dawn that, “Everything in my life that is not like Christ has been a contributing factor to the failure of my marriage.” I encourage these individuals to make a list of every area in their life (attitudes, values, priorities, actions, words) that is not like Jesus, and to ask God to change them, so He will then be free to change their mate Ask God to reveal to you from His Word any failures in your own attitudes, actions, or spirit. Then cooperate...
Words: 508 - Pages: 3
...III Introduction “A successful marriage requires falling in love many times, always with the same person” –Mignon Mclaughlin The above quotation by Mignon Mclaughlin says that for a marriage to be successful, it requires falling in love many times with the same person we are married to. My topic is about “fixed or arranged marriage” being better than the usual marriage in which both falls in love first before entering into a union or marriage. For us to be able to determine whether or not fixed marriage is successful or not, we should first define what marriage is. Marriage is define as a socially or ritually recognized union or legal contract between spouses that establishes rights and obligations between them, between them and their children, and between them and their in-laws. The definition of marriage varies according to different cultures, but it is principally an institution in which interpersonal relationships, usually intimate and sexual, are acknowledged. Today many people prefer “love first before marriage” than the traditional “fixed or arranged marriages”. No one could tell which of the two types of marriages is better or which of them is likely to be successful, because both sometimes tend to be a success and both sometimes seems to be a failure. This paper would like the readers to understand that, “fixed or arranged marriage” is better than the “love first before marriage” type of marriage by giving some examples from real life stories and by giving...
Words: 394 - Pages: 2
...our presentation. We hope it truly benificial for you. To summarize, I’d like to recap on somemaint point. As you know, both love marriage and arranged marriage have their advantages and disadvantages. Neither all of love marriage are failure nor all of arranged marriage are successful. A marriage is built on a very strong foundation. No matter what kind of marriage it is, to sustain forever, it requires a lot of patience, understanding, compatibility, respect, trust, care between each other, not just love. Therefore, I think, that is nothing like an ideal marriage. It depend on the way you preceive it. Now… Have you had the answer for our question? If you are enjoying a happy marriage, you should be proud of that because we have true happiness in the world. Are you single? Have you fallen in love with someone who love you unconditionally? Get ready to share that love for the rest of your life in a long marriage! Have you been looking for a prince or a princess in your dream for a long time…? Don’t be too nervous! Open your mind! Thinking about an arranged marriage could be a great ideal for you. Try it! Marrige, whether it is love one or arranged one, could be an ultimate gift and wonderful experience. It is a journey, not a destination. The important is flow your heart and intuition, you can make a right choice leading to a successful marriage you really want. That bring us to the end of our presentation. Many thanks for your listening. If you have any question, feel...
Words: 279 - Pages: 2
