Free Essay

Generational Diversity

In:

Submitted By anoopchutkay
Words 1508
Pages 7
Group Project
Team VIBGYOR – GMP 2015, Sec B, Group 8

The Topic:

Impact of Generational Diversity on Team Performance.

1. Introduction:

"A lack of understanding across generations can have detrimental effects on communication, working relationships and undermine effective services," says psychologist Constance Patterson.

Although these generational conflicts are often seen as larger social issues, they may play out every day on the team level in the workplace in ways that may affect productivity and may lead to frustration, conflict and poor morale.

For example, Boomers may believe gen Xers are too impatient and unwilling to try out the tried-and-tested strategies, while gen Xers may view boomers as always trying to say the right thing to the right person and being inflexible to change. Traditionalists may view baby boomers as self-absorbed and prone to sharing too much information, and baby boomers may view traditionalists as authoritative and rigid. And, gen Xers may consider millennial too spoiled and self-absorbed, while millennial may view gen Xers as too cynical and negative. 2. Background:

A generation is defined as an identifiable group that shares birth years, age location, and significant life events at critical developmental stages, divided by five-seven years into the first wave, core group, and last wave (Kupperschmidt, 2000). A generational group, often referred to as a cohort, includes those who share historical or social life experiences, the effects of which are relatively stable over the course of their lives. These life experiences tend to distinguish one generation from another (Jurkiewicz & Brown, 1998). A cohort develops a personality that influences a person's feelings toward authority and organizations, what they desire from work, and how they plan to satisfy those desires (Kupperschmidt, 2000).

Team performance is defined as the extent to which a team accomplishes its goals or mission (Devine & Philips, 2001). Because team members interact interdependently in order to be
Successful, team members must engage in a number of team processes or “interdependent acts that convert inputs to outcomes through cognitive, verbal, and behavioural activities directed toward Organizing task work to achieve collective goals” (Marks, Mathieu, & Zaccaro, 2001, p. 357). Successful performance for any team requires members who can complete the technical portions of the team goals or mission (i.e., have specialized expertise), as well as effectively navigate team processes. In general, team composition is thought to be related to team performance because it affects the amount of knowledge and skill team members have to apply to the team task—in terms of both task completion and working interdependently (Hackman, 1987).

3. Research: Frederick Herzberg’s well known Two-Factor Theory has introduce a simple yet distinctive factors of employees’ motivations. The setting of theory has separated employees’ motivation factors into Extrinsic and Intrinsic.

Intrinsic factors: Achievements, promotion, Recognition, Work Itself
Extrinsic factors: pay and benefits, Work condition, Company Policy and Administration

The study investigated by (MURRAY R. BARRICK, MICHAEL K. MOUNT) the relation of the “Big Five” personality dimensions (Extraversion, Emotional Stability, Agreeableness, Conscientiousness, and Openness to Experience) to three job performance criteria (job proficiency, training proficiency, and personnel data) for five occupational groups (professionals, police, managers, sales, and skilled/semi-skilled). Results indicated that one dimension of personality, Conscientiousness, showed consistent relations with all job performance criteria for all occupational groups. For the remaining personality dimensions, the estimated true score correlations varied by occupational group and criterion type.

The overall finding from more than 100 research investigations is that there is no significant difference between the job performance of older and younger workers. The average correlation coefficient is about +0.06 but separate correlations range from -0.44 to +0.66 (McEvoy and Cascio 1989, Warr 1994). Research results demonstrate differences between job and different dimensions of performance, but the general pattern is clear: there is no overall difference between the performance observed for older and younger staff in the same job. Incidentally in almost every case variations with in an age group far exceed the age difference between age groups.

Hypothesis1: There are personality and motivational driver differences across the generations in a team.
Hypothesis2:
Generational Diversity has a negative relation to the overall performance of a team. 4. Methodology Instruments, Interviewers and respondents:

Questionnaire is one way of collecting information. It is an effective research method, since it saves time and effort from the researcher. Research material can be vast; one can include a lot of respondents and questions in the same study. (Hirsijärvi et al. 2009, 195.) However, like Bell (2010) notes, there are several issues, which should be addressed in order to conduct a successful questionnaire. Those issues include a great discipline in the selection of questions, in question writing, in the design, piloting, distribution and return of the questionnaires. (Op.cit. p.140)

Multiple choice questions provide responses, which are easy to analyse afterwards. They will also decrease the amount of diverse responses, which will help the researcher to compare the results. (Hirsijärvi et at. 2009, 201.)

1974 Questionnaire and resulting sample
To examine these research questions, we closely examined the research conducted by Cherrington in 1974 and reported in several publications (Cherrington et al, 1975-conference paper; Cherrington 1976—unpublished manuscript; Cherrington, Condie, & England, 1979), including his book on the study. The work ethic (1980). Cherrington's questionnaire served as a model for our questionnaire.
1999 Questionnaire
In final 1999 questionnaire we attempted to use identical or similar response choices, which included a 7-item Likert-type scale, a 10-item Likert-type scale, and semantic differential scales, using bipolar adjective pairs.
Sampling criterion and data collection
In an attempt to replicate Cherrington's sample, albeit on a much smaller scale, we mailed each participant ten surveys, asking the participant to complete one and give the remaining nine to team members so that we can cover generational diversity within that group.

5. Results:

This section of the report would summarize the number of teams from different organizations surveyed, their team size and the number of individuals in the team falling in to the various generational buckets there by indicating the rate of generation diversity, the responses received from each bucket quantified under the various sections of the questionnaire which tends to measure the performance based on factors driving personality and motivation. 6. Discussion/Conclusion:

This Project would seek to find objective answers to questions some of which identified so far are listed here

What the team members perceive are the positive and negative aspects of working with other members of the team who are from a different generational bucket?

What are the personality and motivational drivers of each of the team member? The drivers team members choose would be classified based on the generational bucket and quantified. This data would be summarized for the respective teams. The more evenly the teams are generationally diversified the better insights this data would give on the topic of research.

What the Managers think are the personality and motivational drivers of team members belonging to each of the generational buckets in their team?

The feedbacks from both the sides (team members and Managers) would help take balanced approach on analysing the survey data.

How the team members feel the members from a different generational bucket score/contribute in various performance measures like timeliness of delivery, exceeding the expectations, team cohesiveness, customer satisfaction, appraisals, promotions etc? The feedback from Manager on these questions would help cross verify the validity of the data. 7. Strengths & Weaknesses:

Strengths:

Firstly, A review of the existing literature suggests that while previous research has examined differences in work values across generations (e.g. Smola and Sutton, 2002; Yu and Miller, 2003), research findings examining generational differences in personality and motivational drivers in the workplace have been limited. Given the changing age demographic of the global workforce, it is now possible for up to four different generations of employees to be working together within one organization. As such, it is increasingly important for us to better understand these generational differences, and determine if these differences truly exist.
Secondly, By choosing the Questionnaire type of data collection method, we will be able to have a fixed pattern of questions and a fixed pattern of answers so that outcome would be of narrowed focus. Also, questionnaires are easy to reach people who are spread across a wide geographical area saving research time. Thirdly, our survey includes various sectors across the board so the internal factors of an organization may have minimal influence the outcome.

Weaknesses:

Firstly, Time being a restricting factor the possibility of soliciting out to multiple teams comprising of varying degree of generational diversity is constrained. Secondly, Reactive effects may occur e.g., interviewees may try to show only what is socially desirable.
Thirdly, The Survey includes Teams from various Organizations, Nationalities and Sectors. Cultures and Norms specific to the individual entity may tend to bias some of the Observations. Fourthly, Most of the Journals considered from the various Journal Databases are American whose relevance to “rest of the world” context is debatable. 8. Bibliography

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Generational Diversity

...Generational Diversity 1. Define the millennial generation, explain their major characteristics and discuss what makes this group so significant in today’s society. The millennial generation includes Americans ages 18-29. This generation is more ethnically and racially diverse than older generations, less religious, and less likely to have served in the military. This generation is also on track to become the most educated generation in American history, making them very significant to society. The millennial generation is also consumed with technology and social networking. 2. Compare and contrast the Millennials with the other generations identified by Pew.  Drawing from your own experience, identify and describe an example of an individual from your own experience that reflects the characteristics of each generation. The millennial generation is less likely to have served in the military compared to Gen Xers, the Baby Boomers and the Silent generation. The use and knowledge of technology is the reason Millennials feel they are distinguished from other generations, however, Gen Xers also cite technology as their generation’s biggest source of distinctiveness. Of the four generations, Millennials are the only one that doesn’t claim “work ethic” as a contributor to distinctiveness. Millennials, however, are the most open to change followed closely by Gen Xers. My great-grandmother would be an example from the Silent generation. She experienced the great depression...

Words: 800 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Generational Diversity

...With the above observations in mind, let’s look at a few work situations and how one might handle them. • At annual appraisal time, a manager from the Veterans generation gives out a nice bonus for a project well done. The Generation X employee is ungrateful and says, “Why didn’t I get this six months ago, when the project was completed?” Gen X wants instant gratification, whereas a person in the Veterans generation is happy to get money anytime. The solution here may be for the company to explore reward plans geared to the different generations, or things like monetary rewards and recognition given at the time when it is earned. • A Generation X manager tells a Boomer he has been working too hard and should take time off to take the family on vacation. Instead of saying thanks, the Boomer replies, “I work to get ahead, to get a promotion, not for a vacation.” The next time that situation comes up, the manager might elect to give this particular employee a bonus, rather than suggest a vacation. • A top-notch, cross-functional team with individuals from several different generations has been set up to recommend a solution to a nasty manufacturing problem. After a couple of weeks, the manager responsible for the team cannot understand why there is constant bickering and nothing is getting done. If the manager were aware of just one characteristic of each individual relating to communication needs, he or she might understand the stalemate. The Veterans on the team are looking...

Words: 543 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Generational Diversity in the Workplace

...Generational Diversity in the Workplace Managerial Communications 10/14/2011 Today, the workplace environment is comprised of people, both males and females from all different cultures and generations. For the first time in U.S. history there are four different generations out in the workforce. A generation can be defined as a group of individuals born within a term years having similar ideas, goals, attitudes and experiences. It can also be defined as the average period between the birth of parents and the birth of their children. Resources differ as to when some generations start and end; a generation is usually around 20 years long. generational differences are based on broad variations in values that develop based on the contrasting environment and social dynamics each generation experiences as they come of age. In the workplace, these differences seem to be generating clashes around work-life balance, employee loyalty, authority, and other important issues.Generational differences are based on broad variations in values that develop based on the contrasting environment and social dynamics each generation experiences as they come of age. In the workplace, these differences seem to be generating clashes around work-life balance, employee loyalty, authority, interpersonal relationships and other important issues (Notter, 2007). Sometimes contradictions and problems arise when identifying the characteristics of a generation. Some studies in the 1980’s described...

Words: 1445 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Workplace Diversity

...Workplace Diversity: Challenges and Opportunities Jane A. Hannon Southern New Hampshire University Workplace Diversity: Challenges and Opportunities The fastest growing segment of the workforce in the United States is adults over 55 years of age (Robbins & Judge, 2015). Given advancements in medical treatments, diagnosis, and wellness initiatives; a forecast of continued sluggish economic growth; and the changing landscape of employer-sponsored benefit programs, the increase of workers in this age group does not show signs of slowing down. An aging workforce presents challenges and opportunities for organizations. While some of these challenges are unique to the demographic, many are similar to the challenges and opportunities of managing other “surface-level diversity,” which includes race, gender, culture, and disability (Robbins & Judge, 2015). By effectively addressing diversity through the creation of policies and their consistent implementation, organizations have the potential for greater productivity and growth. Changes in Employee Relationships Generationally diverse workplaces pose distinct challenges for employers and employees. Because workers of different ages bring their own perceptions and personalities to the workplace, there exists the potential for misunderstanding and conflict. “Diversity involves not only how people perceive themselves but also how they perceive others. Those perceptions affect their interactions” (Patrick & Kumar, 2012)...

Words: 1244 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Diversity Audit

...April 08, 2012 DIVERSITY AUDIT Company Highlights Merck and Company, Inc., a pharmaceutical leader, has a clear vision which is to make a difference in the lives of people globally through their innovative medicines, vaccines, biologic therapies, consumer health and animal products. The company’s core strength is the skill, integrity and creativity of its people. Merck employees, while remarkably diverse in background, training and life experiences, are all motivated by innovation and their mission of providing products that save and improves lives around the world. Under the leadership of Kenneth C. Frazier, who serves a threefold role: Chairman of the Board, President and Chief Executive Officer, Merck and Company reflects its corporate values and guides in day-to-day decision making. Merck recognizes that the world is changing and they have to keep up with the changing demands. The company’s vision is “a commercially sustainable business that both increase the accessibility of products globally and helps build local capacity for quality, healthcare services for those who need them most. Background Merck and Company is an innovative, global healthcare leader that is committed to improving health and well-being around the world. Merck and Company is a very unique leader in its diversity outlook. The company, sort of like IBM, encourages diversity through their employees by: Diversity Acknowledges...

Words: 1032 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Sagara

...Feature articles Workplace diversity: developing a win-win-win strategy Joan Marques iversity as a topic earns more attention today than it has ever received before, and the reasons are easily understandable: global migration is increasing, the internet is enabling communication on a worldwide scale, and business leaders are continuously in search for less expensive resources and lower wages to pay. All these trends result in progressively diversified workforces locally and internationally. D Joan Marques is Instructor, Business and Management, Woodbury University, Burbank, California, USA. Increasingly, companies allocate special room for diversity practices on their web sites. Yet, there are some interesting observations that may not necessarily be new, but should nevertheless regularly be brought to the attention of business leaders. Why? So that they can keep track of the best way to develop and implement diversity in their organizations. Let us briefly look at the right reasons and the right way, beginning with the right reasons. The right reasons Often, organizations pride themselves in implementing diversity in order to accommodate customers. But there is only limited reason to be proud of this way of bringing diversity to the workplace. What these companies overlook is that they apply diversity only as a means toward an end, not as an end in itself: B They apply diversity with the primary mindset of profits. They reach out to their customers, but do not...

Words: 1363 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Seven Reasons Why Xerox Should Be Motivated to Diversify Their Workforce

...workplace diversity. The reasons why Xerox should be motivated to diversify their workforce is more talent will be employed at Xerox if employees of all cultures and race are hired because diversity is a key to achieving critical business results. Furthermore, there will be more knowledge sharing employees can share cultural traits, market demographics and help develop companies develop robust knowledge management and market intelligence systems that create productive people and an innovative company by recognizing and respecting diversity and empowering individuality. Enhanced Productivity by processing varied skills, competencies and capabilities of different races and cultures, Xerox can increase its productivity worldwide (Xerox) that will make them a prominent player despite the economic slowdown in technology spending. Reduced Discrimination at Xerox woman and minorities make up for 52% of the workforce and 42.5% of Xerox senior executives are women or people of color or both (Xerox). This motivates employees in a way that they feel like they appreciated and valued. Besides, its make them challenge each other’s underlying assumptions, freeing everybody from convention and orthodoxy. Xerox has strict discrimination policies as well. With the inclusion of women in the workforce, Xerox developed a form of “flex time” that allowed for a better work/home life balance which has increased productivity which clearly shows how Xerox shows its values workplace diversity. They also...

Words: 822 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Gender and Diversity in the Workplace

...Abstract Diversity encompasses characteristics that categorizes individuals and allows for self-identification. Diversity presents itself in two different forms, visible and invisible. Those that are visible forms of diversity include ones physical appearance, sex, race, age, ethnicity, speech patterns and language. Those that are nonvisible include characteristics such as religion, national origin, illness and sexual orientation (Clair 2005). When discussing diversity in the work environment, most often times they are discussing the outward, visible characteristics, however invisible social identities are common in the workplace. Gender is one of the most common viewed issues when looking at diversity in the workplace. The glass ceiling and equality issues are analyzed and discussed frequently. Discoveries have been made that support the idea that woman should be on more Boards and should be making more decisions on allocations of monies. This paper seeks to address how diversity impacts an organization and how managers can make diversity work for them.   Introduction According to Gibson, Ivancevich, Donnelly, and Konopaske (2012), Diversity is a term that describes the cultural, ethnic and racial differences in a population. A more comprehensive definition by Gibson et al (2012) indicates that diversity is “an array of physical and cultural differences that constitute the spectrum of human attributes. There are six dimensions of diversity which include: age...

Words: 2636 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Diversity in the Workplace

...Short Essay | Diversity in the Workplace | How it can create business related advantages | | Madison Roney: 7660183 | 5/15/2013 | | In modern western society, the diversification of culture has increased dramatically in recent years. With this shift, along with the growing competitiveness of the labor market, corporations have been forced to hire more employees who are not familiar with the spoken language or societal norms present in western culture. Many corporations, as much as 80% according to equity activist Trevor Wilson, consider cultural barriers to be a burden on their managers and fellow employees. As a result, these corporations fail to treat their employees equitably. (Hayes, 1999). One could argue, however, that the diversification of employees within the workplace has various business related benefits such as improved efficiency, bottom line revenue, and relationships formed with co-workers, managers and customers alike. However, to ensure its success, principles of transformational leadership must be used on the part of managers and various challenges must be overcome in order for these benefits to take full effect. This is not the first time in Canada's history where ethnic equality in the workplace has been a subject of interest. In 1993 the New Democratic Party in Ontario, whom was the provincial government at the time, enacted an employment equity law to ensure fair employment opportunities to workers from select minority groups. This legislation...

Words: 1570 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Diversity

...group in the U. S. by the year 2010. In order for companies to fully and aggressively compete in the marketplace, they will need to consider these statistics and work towards attracting, recruiting, developing and retaining a diverse workforce. This will be critical if they are to survive. They will also need to recognize that the market they cater to is becoming more diverse. Diverse groups are a growing percentage of the buying power in the United States. In order to maintain competitive advantage in the sector they serve, organizations will need to truly understand its customers, clients, members and employees and will need to create an organizational climate that is welcoming to all. The Birth of the Diversity Movement The “Diversity” Movement was born in 1987, when the Hudson Institute launched a study titled “Workforce 2000”. The study projected demographic trends that would impact the workplace, as we knew it by the year 2000. One of the predictions made was that there would be a marked growth in the number of women and minorities entering the workforce. In fact, the report suggested that women,...

Words: 2841 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Diversity and Inclusion

...Diversity and Inclusion SOC/315 November 09, 2011 Diversity and Inclusion Diversity refers the inclusion of different types of people in a group or organization. Many people with different backgrounds work together every day to accomplish tasks assigned on daily basis. Before working together the group should know the different dimensions of diversity. “Dimensions of diversity exert an important impact on our early socialization and a powerful sustained impact on our experiences, values, assumptions and expectations throughout every stage of history ” (Harvey, 2009). The different dimensions of diversity are race, gender, age, education, sexual orientation, and geographic origin, or employment. “Dimensions adds layers of complexity to individual identity, it is the dynamic interaction among all the dimensions that influences self-image, values, opportunities, and expectations” (Harvey, 2009). Dimensions of diversity apply an effect on each of us at home, work, and in society giving definition to our lives. “The United States is a very diverse nation and becoming more” (Schaefer, 2011). Concerning ethnic, cultural, or other groups I identify with all. My social circle is consistent with people from all groups. My social circle consists of individuals not a group. I think of all my associates as individuals with different personalities. My social circle member’s personalities are very different and the dimensions play a part from the way we dress, race, gender, and sexual...

Words: 850 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Groups and Teams

...When defining diversity, one must acknowledge the differences between groups on human beings. These differences may include attributes such as ethnicity and race, religious and spiritual beliefs, educational and economic backgrounds, physical abilities and disabilities, age, gender, marital status and occupational status (McRae, 2012). By having all this diversity, individuals can have positive and negative impacts on the workplace. Diversity in the workplace can be perceived as a function of forced societal tolerances (McRae, 2012). No one employer has the right to turn down an applicant based on race, age or gender, it is a law. The workplace should have a diverse group of people. Diversity in a working environment could be seen as evidence of fair hiring practice within an organization (McRae, 2012). The most important impact of diversity in the workplace is perspective. By having different groups of people in the workplace there are different viewpoints to discussions and more than one resolution of issues. By having all these attitudes and ideas, the groups can provide valuable input to brainstorming sessions and issues demanding creative solutions. Businesses should strive for diverse groups and teams. When individuals are able to work with others whom are different from each other it challenges people’s preconceived notions about how the world works and it forces people to step outside their comfort zones and consider new thought processes. By opening people up to new...

Words: 357 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Value of Diversity in the Workplace

...Value of Diversity in the Workplace Carolina Silva Soc/315 April 11, 2011 Ashraf Esmail Value of Diversity in the Workplace Introduction In the active times that we are living now, every company faces challenges that could be better handled if a diverse environmental workplace is put into play. Some issues may arise leaving some of the protagonists defenseless and the majority of the time unable to deal with the daunting situation at hand. Diversity is one of the most useful tools that any company at any point in time could ever possibly used, due to the fact that trends of growth in the population—in the US particularly—is becoming more diverse than ever. “Diversity in the workplace is about learning from different groups enabling a Company to benefit from the diverse perspectives and achievements.” (Cornell University ILR School, 2009) I am a real estate agent and a few years ago when I first started working my profession as a realtor in Florida, I joined a big franchise to get acquainted with the market and to make a name in the business. As a big franchise, one of the duties of the realtor is to stay at least one day in the office to provide information and to help any walk-in client that might happen to walk in. On one occasion, I was the one doing “floor duty” when a middle-aged Korean couple sat and waited for me at the office. I welcomly introduced myself, asking “How may I assist you?” Beyond obviously looking for a place to live they mentioned how they would...

Words: 1235 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

“How Can Diverse Workforce Affect the Organization”

...ABSTRACT Workplace diversity exists when companies hire employees from various backgrounds and experiences. Many companies see workplace diversity as an investment toward building a better business. Although workplace diversity provides many benefits, it also poses many challenges to employees and managers. To reap the benefits of workplace diversity, employees and managers must understand the challenges and know how to effectively deal with them. Diversity is commonly interpreted in relation to ethnicity, gender and culture. Diversity also captures the differences and similarities between individuals and group, encompassing race, ethnicity, gender, culture, age, sexual orientation, religion, language, education, family status, physical and mental ability. These demographic variables are related to other important diversity characteristics such as values, attitudes, interaction styles, physical and cognitive abilities and non-work commitments. The impact of diversity is both positive and negative. The research questions was: How can diverse workforce affect the organization? Table of Contents Chapter 1. Introduction 4 Background of the Study 4 Statement of the Problem 4 Purpose of the Study 5 Research Questions 6 Chapter 2. Literature Review 6 Chapter 3. Methodology 12 Data Analysis 12 Final Results 14 References 15 CHAPTER 1. BACKGROUND Today, globalization has become...

Words: 3487 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Diversity Within the Workplace

...Throughout the many issues in the workplace, diversity is an issue that needs immediate attention. Our culture is continuously evolving and with that being said diversity in our work environment should be evolving as well. It has been said, “Top performing companies have long recognized that diversity is good for business. But a just released report from The Economist Intelligence Unit finds that a new definition of workforce diversity is emerging. It’s no longer just about avoiding race, ethnicity, and gender discrimination, or even compliance with legal regulations. Diversity now encompasses values, meaning what motivates someone to join a company, embody organizational passions, and be productive for a long time.” (Galer, 2014) It is crucial for an organization to be diverse, lack of diversity can cause several issues in the workplace such as miscommunication, unproductivity, and creates a hostile work environment. By managing the problems with diversity the organization would benefit greatly in many ways. There are many reasons for why the issue of diversity needs to be addressed in the workplace. Specifically in the organization I work in there are many problems with diversity, many of the workers in my organization have brought up the fact that the race is predominantly white, it is also made aware that the engineers for the company are males and the females in the office are usually the subject of jokes and labeled as ‘non workers’. Since the site I currently work in...

Words: 682 - Pages: 3