Free Essay

Geothermal Energy

In: Science

Submitted By alisays
Words 10392
Pages 42
Geothermal Energy
EM 530 – Energy, Economics & the Environment

Josh Marder – Nicole Glick – Ali Yasir – Giovanni Rumbolo 4/20/2012

TABLE OF CONTENTS Problem Statement: Introduction: Page 2 Page 2

Past and Present Uses: Page 3 Energy: Economics: Environment: Risk Analysis: Recommendations: Page 7 Page 19 Page 28 Page 32 Page 34

1

PROBLEM STATEMENT There is a looming energy crisis in the United States, as the country is currently relying on a finite supply of fossil fuels. This energy crisis, along with economic growth and environmental stability must be sustained by developing alternative, renewable energy sources. Population is expanding at a geometric rate and each doubling will increase energy demand that will far exceed supply. China and India have recently developed into industrialized nations and several more will follow. Many leading scientists describe the “tipping point” for carbon dioxide emissions as having already passed, meaning it could be too late for renewable energy options to have an impact (McKibben, 2008). However, until the full impact is determined, scientists worldwide should be developing energy alternatives, in order to help stabilize the environment, secure national policy interests and boost to the economy. Geothermal energy represents a sizeable, renewable power source and is one of several alternative energy options that should be utilized. In order for this technology to be able to move forward with any success, it must achieve the highest efficiency, through smart thinking and conservation methods. Society needs to integrate energy, environmental, economic and political policies; otherwise, there is no chance for a sustainable future. INTRODUCTION TO GEOTHERMAL ENERGY Geothermal energy originates as heat from the Earth’s core and is constantly flowing, conducting outwards towards the surface. This is most easily displayed in the form of geysers, like Old Faithful in Yellowstone National Park; however, geothermal heat is available everywhere in the world. The majority of rainwater that seeps into the ground remains under impermeable rock in superheated geothermal reservoirs. A 2010 study of US capacity by researchers at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) and the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) placed geothermal in the following categories: 1) 2) 3) 4) Identified hydrothermal (6.39 gigawatts) Undiscovered hydrothermal (30.03 gigawatts) Enhanced Geothermal Systems (EGS) (7.03 gigawatts) Deep EGS (15,908 gigawatts)

2

Cumulatively, the energy potential for geothermal is substantial and will be available for several billion years (Trabish, 2010). PAST AND PRESENT USES FOR GEOTHERMAL ENERGY Ancient societies, such as the Romans, used geothermal heat for spas and to heat rooms; 10,000 years ago in the US, Native Americans used this heat source for cooking and medicine, and have a history with every major hot spring in the country (US Department of Energy, 2011). France has been heating up to 200,000 homes with geothermal heat since 1960. Today, geologists and engineers have better technology and equipment for identification and speculation of reservoirs for power plant electricity production. However, geothermal heat and cooling, whether from a power plant or small residential system, are not common in the United States, as of yet. Geothermal uses fall into three categories: 1) Direct-use, for example the Blue Lagoon spas in Iceland; 2) Dry-steam, flash or binary power plants for large-scale electricity generation, and 3) Heating, air conditioning and domestic hot water for small systems that replace existing HVAC applications The latest geothermal loops are made out of high-density polyethylene, which have excellent thermal properties, do not oxidize, and have some elasticity. “Low-level” geothermal involves geothermal loops that are no more than 250 feet into the ground. These systems are used for heating and cooling and have minimal risks in quake zone unless they are drilled into bedrock. Even in bedrock, the plastic is very durable and it has some elasticity. In terms of infrastructure, the municipal sewer and potable water delivery systems would be damaged first before a geothermal loop in the event of an earthquake. “Mid-level” geothermal consists of loops 250-1200 feet into the ground and are mostly used for commercial applications that also provide heating and cooling. The risks for quake zones are a bit higher then low-level, but still minimal. “High-level” geothermal are loops 400-2500 feet into the ground. These are for electricity generation and are far more complex than the other two methods.

3

For a small residential system operating in the winter, the liquid in the underground pipes absorb the geothermal heat from the ground, which is compressed by the heat pump and distributed throughout the home. In summer months, the ground acts as a heat sink, instead of a heat source in a residential system, and provides cool air to the home. Heating can be done either with conventional HVAC methods or hydronic floor heating. A residential geothermal system can also provide domestic hot water to the home and act as a 3-in-1 HVAC system (Exhibit 1). To fully understand the impact that geothermal energy can have on the home or office, hydronic flooring, building efficiency and energy conservation must be considered. EXHIBIT 1:

Hydronic Flooring Hydronic flooring is an example of a high-efficiency product combination that works very well for residential systems, by utilizing coils beneath floors to provide heat. This should ideally be done in new-construction projects, as part of an architectural and engineering plan. Retrofitting the hydronic flooring is possible but not recommended, due to the high costs of ripping up and repairing floors. Traditional forced-air heating requires that the air is initially

4

heated to approximately 130°F, goes through the vent at about 90°F, then dissipates at room temperature, to heat the space. The fluids inside hydronic floors remain at a level of 65 - 75°F; when coupled with a geothermal system, this is a more efficient system that will provide cost-savings over the long term. Other advantages, such as better air quality and the uneven heat supply of forced-air are additional values of hydronic floor heating (Hackleman, 2000). A long-term approach to the architecture, engineering, and design portion of the three E’s is essential to the success of newly implemented energy systems, like geothermal. Building Efficiency Techniques Efficiency will need to be a trademark of the future home and office; considerable advances have already been made in several areas. LED lighting is about nine times more efficient than incandescent bulbs and do not have the environmental concerns associated with CFL models. Energy Star products, such as refrigerators, washer/dryers and dishwashers are designed for efficient use. Architects can now use passive solar techniques and better windows and doors that work to conserve heat or cool as necessary. Green spaces are replacing blacktops, as the former lowers cooling needs for a building, while the latter heats surfaces up to very high temperatures. The technology and infrastructure already exists to utilize renewable energy systems, like geothermal, with all available building efficiency techniques to create the high-efficiency homes and businesses of the future. Geothermal / Solar Photovoltaic (PV) Hybrid Systems It is possible to combine solar PV with geothermal energy to create a hybrid system that provides 100% renewable energy, known as a net zero home. Geothermal systems do not require much electric power to operate; actually, with the right amount of PV panels and a battery backup, it is possible to power a home that is completely off the grid for power needs. The batteries will provide power when there is no sun and a backup propane heating system can likewise be installed. For grid-tied homes, the battery backup is not necessary, because at night the geothermal system will run on grid electricity and any excess solar generated power will be sent back to the grid. The takeaway here is that a Geothermal / PV hybrid system gives homeowners the ability to have total energy independence; even a small PV system can supply the electrical power necessary for a small geothermal system (GeothermalEnergy.org, 2011).
5

Conservation Measures There is no doubt that Americans have grown accustomed to an excessive and wasteful process in regards to energy consumption; unfortunately, this problem is being replicated globally by other nations looking to join the industrial and technological era. Europeans emit about half the carbon dioxide per capita compared to Americans, and this excess significantly contributes to global warming concerns. If the US does not lead the way to a new form of living that takes energy efficiency and conservation into account, what chance does the rest of the world have? A true shift in consumer and market behavior is necessary on every level of modern society for there to be a sustainable impact on the 3 E’s, and it may take a political policy solution to implement the necessary changes. Several conservation methods are already visible in modern society, but these methods need to become standard practice. Systems like smart-grid technology and automated business functions need to be better utilized. Exhibit 2 details the “Energy Pyramid”, with renewables at the top, efficiency measures in the middle, and conservation forming the base of the pyramid. EXHIBIT 2:

6

ENERGY Background The United States possesses vast underground stores of heat whose full potential has yet to be realized. The Earth’s interior reaches temperatures greater than 4,000°C (>7,200°F), and this geothermal energy flows continuously to the surface. The energy content of domestic geothermal resources to a depth of 3 km (~2 mile) is estimated to be 3 million quads, equivalent to a 30,000-year supply of energy at our current rate for the United States. While the entire resource base cannot be recovered, the recovery of even a very small percentage of this heat would make a large difference to the nation’s energy supplies. New low-temperature electric generation technology may greatly expand the geothermal resources that can be developed economically today. Unlike other renewable energies, such as wind and solar, geothermal power generation can operate steadily nearly twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week. Continual production makes geothermal an ideal candidate for providing nearly zero-emission renewable base-load power. In 2009, the 15.2 billion kilowatt-hours (kWh) of geothermal electricity generated in the United States constituted 13 percent of the nonhydroelectric, renewable electricity generation, but only 0.4 percent of total electricity generation (EIA 2010 Annual Energy Review 2008). The same year, nine states generated electricity from geothermal energy (AK, CA, HI, ID, MT, NV, OR, UT, and WY), but California alone accounted for 83 percent of U.S. geothermal electric generating capacity. Geothermal plays an important role in some of the states where it is installed. Geothermal facilities satisfy 4.5 percent of California’s electricity consumption and 2.1 percent of Hawaii’s (Energy Information Administration 2010, Hawaii Renewable Electricity Profile). Classification of Geothermal Energy Use Most of the heat inside the Earth originates from the natural decay of radioactive elements. Through various thermal processes, this heat is slowly transferred to the surface of the Earth where it can be accessed to provide for various human needs. The Geo-Heat Center at the Oregon Institute of Technology devised a simplified geothermal classification system based on the temperature of the resource. This classification system defines geothermal
7

energy in terms of temperature (low, moderate, and high temperature resources) and how the geothermal heat can be utilized. Geothermal energy has many uses besides the most well-known applications — electrical power production and geothermal heat pumps. For the purposes of this paper, geothermal resources are divided into three main categories:  Geothermal Electricity Production,  Direct Use  Geothermal HVAC systems Exhibit 3 shows that in the United States, more than 90% of geothermal production is from power plants. These plants, with aggregate capacity of more than 3,100 MW, accounted for 5% of the nation’s total renewable energy and almost 13% of non-hydro renewable generation in 2008. (EIA, July 2009) EXHIBIT 3:

Geothermal Electricity Production Geothermal power plants use the earth’s heat— in the form of underground steam or hot water— to spin a turbine and generate electricity. Wells hundreds to thousands of feet deep are used to deliver the hot fluid to the power plant on the surface, where the heat is converted to electrical energy. Nearly all the water is returned to the reservoir through injection wells to be reheated. Currently, geothermal electricity production is limited to certain
8

western states where the hottest resources are closer to the surface. Advances in drilling and energy conversion technologies could make it possible to expand the use of geothermal power plants to other states. The three types of commercial geothermal power plants are dry steam plants that use resources of pure steam, flash steam and binary cycle plants that tap reservoirs of hot water. Dry Steam Dry steam plants draw steam directly from under the earth’s surface to a turbine that drives a generator. The steam then condenses into water and is re-injected into the geothermal reservoir. However, these resources are rare; only five such fields have been discovered to date. The only commercially developed steam field in the United States is The Geysers, located in Northern California, which began the commercial production of electricity in 1960. Flash Steam Geothermal reservoirs that contain hot, pressurized water are much more common and provide energy for all domestic geothermal power production except The Geysers. Flash steam power plants use resources that are typically hotter than 350ºF. Before fluids enter the plant, the pressure of the fluid is reduced until it begins to boil, or flash. This process produces both steam and water. The steam subsequently is used to drive the turbine; the water is injected back into the reservoir. These types of power plants operate in California, Hawaii, Nevada and Utah. Binary Cycle This rapidly expanding technology uses geothermal resources with temperatures as low as 190°F. Rather than flashing the geothermal fluid to produce steam, this type of power plant uses heat exchangers to transfer the heat of the water to another working fluid that vaporizes at lower temperatures. This vapor drives a turbine to generate power, after which it is condensed and circulated back to the heat exchangers. This type of geothermal plant has superior environmental characteristics compared to the others because the hot water (which tends to contain dissolved salts and minerals) is never exposed to the atmosphere before it is injected back into the reservoir. Binary power plants were introduced in the mid-1980s and are
9

the fastest growing generating technology currently with more than 350 MW of binary generation capacity in California, Hawaii, Nevada and Utah. The Industry Despite its current limited application, geothermal energy has a very large potential for expansion; although most of the U.S. geothermal potential is in the western states. The U.S. Geological Survey estimates that current technologies could exploit nearly 40,000 MW of geothermal resources in America’s West, compared to a current U.S. electric generating capacity of roughly 1 million MW (Williams et al., 2008). The development of geothermal energy resources for utility-scale electricity production in the United States began in the 1960’s. Since that time, the continual development of geothermal resources and technology has positioned the US as a leader in the global geothermal industry. Exhibit 4 displays that the US currently has approximately 3187 MW of installed geothermal capacity, more than any other country in the world compared to the global capacity of 11224 MW for the year 2012. EXHIBIT 4:

10

Current Installed Capacity Geothermal companies continue to increase the development of geothermal resources in the US. In 2010 geothermal energy accounted for 3% of renewable energy-based electricity consumption in the United States (US Energy Information Administration, Renewable Energy Consumption and Electricity Statistics 2010). While the majority of geothermal installed capacity in the US is concentrated in California and Nevada, geothermal power plants are also operating in Alaska, Hawaii, Idaho, Oregon, Utah, and Wyoming. Exhibit 5 draws a picture of total US Geothermal installed capacity by technology for the period of 1975-2012. Due to the varying resource characteristics of different geothermal reservoirs, a variety of technologies are used to generate geothermal electricity in the US. Dry-steam power plants account for approximately 1585 MW (almost 50%) of installed geothermal capacity in the US, and are all located in California. Another sizeable portion of installed geothermal capacity in the US (900 MW) is comprised of steam-flash power plants, the majority of which is also located in California. The implementation of binary geothermal technology (capacity of 702 MW) has enabled the industry to develop lower temperature resources, which has expanded the geothermal industry’s geographical footprint beyond California, especially in the last decade. The US geothermal industry’s trend of sustained steady growth continued in 2011 and the first quarter of 2012. In that period two geothermal power plants and three expansion projects to existing power plants were completed for a total of approximately 91 MW of newly installed capacity.

11

EXHIBIT 5:

Direct Use Direct-use applications tap geothermal resources to provide thermal energy. These projects are feasible throughout a larger section of the country because they use more widespread, low temperature resources (generally from 70°F to 300°F). Direct use applications commonly support agricultural and industrial activities but are also an efficient means of heating and cooling buildings. Agricultural Applications Direct use of geothermal resources has been well received within the agribusiness industry, with the two primary uses being greenhouses and aquaculture (fish farming). Geothermal water (100°F/38°C and above) has been used in at least 40 greenhouses since the late 1970s, in the western states (Geo-Heat Center, Oregon Institute of Technology, 3201 Campus Dr., Klamath Falls). Many of these facilities cover several acres, raising vegetables, flowers, houseplants, and tree seedlings. The DOE Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy program reports that greenhouse operators using geothermal resources estimate energy savings of about 80 percent compared to fuel costs for traditional energy sources (U.S. Department of Energy, 2006).
12

Aquaculture ponds and ground heating to extend the growing season for specialty crops (85°F water and above) exist in 12 states. These Direct Use applications are usually in relatively rural settings due to the need for large amounts of land and can stimulate the economy for a rural area. District Heating During the 19th century, hot water began to be used for local space heating applications in the United States. However, it wasn’t until the 20th century that more widespread use of geothermal heat became popular. District geothermal systems distribute hydrothermal water from one or more geothermal wells through a series of pipes to several houses and buildings, or to blocks of buildings. District heating can save consumers 30 to 50 percent of the cost of heating compared with natural gas (U.S. Department of Energy EERE — Geothermal Technologies Program, Direct Use of Geothermal Energy 2006). The geothermal production well and distribution piping replace the fossil-fuel burning heat source of the traditional heating system. Boise, Idaho has a number of district heating systems to heat more than 350 buildings throughout the city, including the State Capitol. The first system has been in operation since 1892. In addition to heating buildings, Klamath Falls, Oregon, uses this technology for melting snow on some streets, bridges and sidewalks. Spa Health Facilities and Therapy Pools Warm water from hot mineral springs or shallow geothermal wells have been used by humans for bathing, soaking and recreation throughout history. Today’s spa facilities and therapy pools use warm water with methods similar to those used in ancient times as the primary means of health care and restorative recreation. This past decade has seen a revival in the spa industry with 1 in 4 Americans having visited a spa and over 32 million active spa-goers worldwide. In 2006 there were 110 million spa visits generating $9.4 billion of revenue in the U.S. with an increase of 16 percent from 2005 to 2006 (International Spa Association, Lexington, Kentucky, The North American Spa Industry Fast Facts, 2007). Spa facilities and pools range from multi-million dollar resorts with luxury spas to reasonably priced public bathhouses and natural pools. The economic impact to communities is largely due to the draw of visitors into the area, with related expenses for food, lodging, and recreation needs as well
13

as employment and housing for staff of the facilities (Altman, Nathaniel, Healing Springs, The Ultimate Guide to Taking the Waters, Healing Arts Press, Rochester, Vermont, 2000). Currently there are approximately 200,000 people employed in the U.S. Spa industry. In West Texas for example, at Chianti Hot Springs there are over 80,000 visitors annually (International Spa Association, Lexington, Kentucky, The North American Spa Industry Fast Facts, 2007). Geothermal Heat Pumps Geothermal heat pumps (GHPs) use the Earth’s huge energy storage capability to heat and cool buildings, and to provide hot water. GHPs use conventional vapor compression (refrigerant-based) heat pumps to extract the low-grade heat from the Earth for space heating. In summer, the process reverses and the Earth becomes a heat sink while providing space cooling. GHPs are used in all 50 U.S. states today, with great potential for near-term market growth and savings. Exhibit 6 shows an illustration of a geothermal heat pump for a commercial application. Although these systems are powered with electricity, the power is used to move, not generate, heat; consequently, a heat pump delivers three to four times more energy than it consumes. More than 1 million geothermal heat pumps operate across the country with a total capacity to generate approximately 8,600 MW of heat. Heat pumps use less energy than traditional heating and air conditioning systems because they use the earth as a heat source whose temperature is more constant than the outside air. For example, if the outside air temperature is 20°F a traditional air source heat pump requires electrical coils to boost that temperature to maintain a comfortable indoor climate of approximately 70°F. A heat pump, however, draws on the relatively constant temperature in the ground (usually between 50°F to 60°F) and thus does not require electrical booster coils to maintain that same comfortable indoor climate/air temperature. Heat pumps can reduce a building’s energy consumption by 30 percent to 50 percent, compared to conventional electric heating and cooling systems.

14

EXHIBIT 6:

Geothermal HVAC One of the simplest ways to make use of the geothermal resource is through Geothermal Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning (HVAC) systems for homes and buildings. This application of geothermal resources can be used by anyone from the average homeowner to the large commercial developer for the heating and cooling of buildings. According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), geothermal heat pumps are the most energyefficient, environmentally clean, and cost-effective systems for temperature control (Environmental Protection Agency, Space Conditioning: The Next Frontier — Report 430-R-93-004, 1993). From 2002 to 2006 there was a 71 percent increase in Geothermal HVAC system installations for residential applications in the United States (Energy Information Administration, Renewable Energy-Geothermal Heat Pumps Data and Information, from form EIA-902). There are three components to a Geothermal HVAC system: 1) the local soil and geological environment; 2) the thermal transfer exchange system, or loop field; and 3) the mechanical system or heat pump and the ventilation ducts inside the building. Most installations are done by small to medium sized mechanical engineering or HVAC companies who coordinate with the building
15

contractor. Project coordination includes design of the loop system, a borehole drilling contractor, pump installation inside the building, and a ventilation contractor for the building. These systems have reduced maintenance costs because the equipment is typically inside the building and loops are below ground so they are not susceptible to vandalism or extremes in weather conditions. Recent Technological Developments Geothermal power plants need reservoirs that contain heat, water, and permeable rocks located less than 15,000 feet below the surface to generate affordable electricity. Researchers and geothermal developers are searching for ways to enhance the productivity of geothermal reservoirs and to use more marginal areas, such as those that have ample heat but perhaps are only slightly permeable to water, or which are at greater depths. Advanced power generation techniques may make it possible to generate electricity using much lower temperature resources while advances in drilling may allow developers to tap valuable resources located deeper underground. Low-Temperature Hydrothermal A hydrothermal system is defined as a subterranean geothermal reservoir that transfers heat energy upward by vertical circulation of fluids driven by differences in fluid density that correspond to differences in temperature. Hydrothermal systems can be classified into two types—vapor-dominated and hot water—depending on whether the fluid is steam or liquid water, respectively. Most high-temperature geothermal resources occur where magma (molten rock) has penetrated the upper crust of the Earth. The magma heats the surrounding rock, and when the rock is permeable enough to allow the circulation of water, the resulting hot water or steam is referred to as a hydrothermal resource. Exhibit 7 shows an illustration of a hydrothermal reservoir, showing the natural recharge, fractures, and heat source (Courtesy: Geothermal Education Office). Such resources are used today for the commercial production of geothermal power. They benefit from continuous recharge of energy as heat flows into the reservoir from greater depths.

16

EXHIBIT 7:

Enhanced Geothermal Systems Deep geothermal systems (a.k.a. enhanced geothermal systems or EGS) are defined as engineered reservoirs that have been created to extract heat from economically unproductive geothermal resources. The deep geothermal/EGS concept is to extract heat by creating a subsurface fracture system to which water can be added through injection wells. The water is heated by contact with the rock and returns to the surface through production wells, just as in naturally occurring hydrothermal systems. Fracking and stimulation techniques are used widely in the oil and gas industry to extend production, and can be used to greatly extend and expand use of geothermal resources. Exhibit 8 (Courtesy: Southern Methodist University Geothermal Laboratory) gives a graphic idea of the domestic scope of geothermal resources at just 6 kilometers (3.7 miles), a nominal drilling depth in the oil and gas industry. Exhibit 9 shows the steps involved to access heat energy stored in hot rock formations lacking a natural water source which is achieved by creating an artificial reservoir using EGS technology.

17

EXHIBIT 8:

EXHIBIT 9:

18

Geo-pressured Resources The geo-pressured resource consists of deeply buried reservoirs of hot brine, under abnormally high pressure, that contain dissolved methane. Geopressured brine reservoirs with pressures approaching litho-static load are known to occur both onshore and offshore beneath the Gulf of Mexico coast, along the Pacific west coast, in Appalachia, and in deep sedimentary basins elsewhere in the United States. The resource contains three forms of energy: methane, heat, and hydraulic pressure. In the past, DOE conducted research on geo-pressured reservoirs in the northern Gulf of Mexico sedimentary basin, and operated a 1-megawatt (MW) power plant using the heat and methane from the resource (i.e. Pleasant Bayou, TX, 1989 – 1990). Co-Produced Geothermal Fluids Sometimes referred to as the ‘produced water cut’ or ‘produced water’ from oil and gas wells, co-produced geothermal fluids are hot and are often found in water-flood fields in a number of U.S oil and gas production regions. This water is typically considered a nuisance to the oil and gas industry (and industry is accountable for proper disposal), but could be used to produce electricity for internal use or sale to the grid. Like geo-pressured resources, co-produced geothermal resources can deliver near-term energy savings, diminish greenhouse gas emissions, and extend the economical use of an oil or gas field. New low-temperature electric generation technology may greatly expand the geothermal resources that can be developed economically today. ECONOMICS Geothermal Power Plants Power plants are a large-scale application of geothermal resources that produce electricity for a large population base. These power plants work on the same basic principle of conventional thermal power plants, harnessing the Earth’s heat to provide the kinetic power needed to move a turbine to produce electricity. Exhibit 10 displays the three different power plant systems.

19

EXHIBIT 10:

DRY STEAM

FLASH

BINARY

Costs of Geothermal Power Plants There are a variety of financial factors that need to be taken into account when developing a geothermal power plant. These factors are mainly divided between Startup Costs and Operations & Maintenance Costs (O&M). Startup Costs Startup Costs are very capital intensive regardless of the type of power plant that is being developed. The follow are brief explanations of various factors that influence the startup budget of a power plant. Land survey costs are costs associated with locating sites with the best geothermal resources. This is time-intensive and expensive; however, this step is critical for the initial development of geothermal plants. Not all locations are suited for large-scale applications of geothermal energy, making it necessary to search areas with optimal ground temperature or suitable hydrothermal reservoirs. Land surveys provide planners with information regarding the suitability of a particular area, which allows the excavating decision to be made more appropriately and saves money on drilling equipment and labor.

20

The decision to purchase development land is made using the current regulations, which state that a developer is required to lease or purchase the rights to 2,000 acres or more to fully explore a geothermal resource. Rural land values fluctuate between $400 and $15,000 per acre based on the state and region. Earmarking funds towards land purchases can dramatically increase the amount of capital needed for the investment. Excavation and development of plant locations are the most cost intensive factors when it comes to startup costs: they can amount to up to 36 percent of the total initial capital investments. One of the main reasons for this is the high costs incurred due to frequent replacements of expensive drilling equipment. One way for developers to get around this cost is to utilize existing holes already drilled by mining companies or oil and natural gas companies that encountered a dry source. Commissioning costs, which are basically the construction costs involved in building the power plant itself, can vary based on the type of geothermal design chosen for the plant. Currently, binary cycle plants are the most expensive to construct due to the heat exchange technology utilized in the power generation method. Decommissioning costs are a common expense that developers encounter during the construction of facilities and power plants. Once a plant has run its lifetime it needs to be decommissioned in order to prevent any negative impact on the environment and the surrounding properties in the area (USDA, 2012). Operations & Maintenance Costs O&M Costs are the ongoing expenses of running the power plant. For a geothermal energy power plant these costs are going to be relatively low and steady due to the main fuel source being the heat generated by the Earth’s core. Workforce and administrative costs cover the overhead associated with providing the workforce necessary to operate the plant efficiently as well as any related administrative costs. Services and supplies covers the overhead incurred for the maintenance and replacement of the equipment used in operating the power plant. Taxes can either be an operating cost or a credit for the developer, depending on the location of the power plant and policies in place. Some states provide tax incentives to developers who invest in clean energy.

21

A power plant’s fuel costs are relatively low and stable due to its origin. Fuel costs are the lowest expense encountered in dealing with geothermal power plants. The average cost of power production over the life of the power plant takes into account all capital expenses and O&M costs, as well as fuel costs for plants that rely on external fuel sources. Major factors affecting geothermal power costs are the depth and temperature of the resource, well productivity, environmental compliance, location of the power plant, project infrastructure and economic factors, such as the scale of development and project financing costs (Renewable Project – Economics). See Exhibit 11 for a comparison of the levelized costs of electricity production for a variety of power plants. EXHIBIT 11: Cost of New Electricity Production (cents/kilowatt hour)
Technology Geothermal Flash 3.50 1.43 -0.54 4.39 0.12 0.01 0.13 4.52 Geothermal Binary 5.14 3.08 -0.91 7.28 0.08 0.00 0.08 7.37 Wind Hydro power 4.62 1.12 0.29 6.03 0.00 0.00 0.00 6.03 Natural Gas Combined Cycle (Baseload) 0.93 0.19 0.01 1.12 3.83 0.24 4.06 5.18 Turbine Simple Cycle (Peaking) 6.93 2.43 0.12 9.49 5.11 1.09 6.20 15.69

Capital & Financing Cost Fixed Operating Costs Taxes (credit) Total Fixed Costs Fuel Cost Variable O & M Costs Total Variable Costs Total Levelized Costs

3.49 1.79 -0.34 4.93 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.93

Source: Badr, M & Benjamin R. “Comparative Cost of California Central Station Electricity Generation Technologies, California Energy Commission June 5, 2003

Geothermal flash energy comes in as the cheapest form of energy produced, even compared to natural gas. Geothermal energy even tops more popular renewables like hydropower and wind power. This is due to the higher fixed costs associated with these technologies as well as the lack of tax incentives when it comes to the production of hydropower. There is a marked difference between the production costs of the two geothermal designs presented for comparison. Binary-cycle plants have a higher production costs due to the higher capital investments involved in the construction and operation. These

22

costs, however, may be reduced greatly with the creation of improved technologies. Final Observations on Geothermal Power Plants Geothermal plants require a large amount of capital to be invested, with startup costs often accounting for two thirds of the total cost of the plant, with financing often structured to pay back the capital costs in 15 years. All of these factors make this unattractive for any type of investor interested in obtaining a quick return on investment. However, with most plants staying in operation for 30 – 45 years, costs fall by 50 – 70 percent, to cover just operations and maintenance for the remaining 15 – 30 years for which the facility operates. This reduction in costs makes geothermal plants a viable solution for developers who are not necessarily concerned with a quick turnaround. Direct Use: Geothermal Heat Pumps (GHP) As with geothermal power plants, there are several factors that need to be taken into account when investing in GHP. Capital costs for these systems are quite high compared to conventional fossil heating oil, natural gas, or electric run HVAC units. These capital costs only increase if the system is being retrofitted into an existing building, due to factors such as the size of living area, the age of the home, insulation characteristics, the geology of the area, and location of the property, in addition to the ancillary costs associated with the additional labor and possible demo and reconstruction costs that may be encountered. Homeowners need to also take into account the economic benefits for them based on the relative costs of electricity and fuels at their location. It may not be the best investment for a homeowner that already has relatively low heating costs due to the large capital needed for the installation of a GHP system; currently the average geothermal system runs homeowners anywhere from $15,000 to $35,000, based on the location of the dwelling and the geology of the ground. However GHPs have the advantage of relying on an inexpensive renewable energy source like geothermal energy, providing homeowner’s savings in the ranges of 30 to 70 percent of their heating costs with conventional heating systems. Depending on the cost of heating and electricity in their area homeowners can end up recouping their initial investment in as early as 2 to 4

23

years, considering the typical maintenance costs of a GHP system is similar to that of a conventional system (National Geothermal Collaborative, 2010). Ideal GHP Scenario GHP systems are ideally suited to service the needs of new single family dwellings, in a rural setting with a considerable housing lot. In our specific case we chose a new detached single family home being constructed in a rural area of the Northeastern U.S. There are several reasons why we picked this as our ideal scenario. New constructions provide an ideal “canvas” to install a closed loop GHP system in the foundations, saving money on capital costs that would have incurred, if any additional excavation had been necessary. The choice to go with a rural location was dictated by the fact that most rural homes especially in areas with low population densities like in the Northeast, rely mainly on periodical deliveries of liquid propane to fuel their heating needs. Depending on the cost of fuel in the area, this can be a substantial part of a family’s living expense. This type of situation creates a perfect market for GHP to become a more than viable option to the conventional systems currently in use, mainly because of the very low operational costs associated with this technology. Based on data obtained from a comparable case study by RETscreen International, the residence would be outfitted with a 14.8kW ground source closed loop heat pump system. The costs associated with the system are the following:  Ground Source System & Ductwork = $10,541  Ground Loop= $8,742 The system qualified for a utility rebate of $200 per kW, which is not uncommon, depending on the state, county and municipality and its policy on the utilization of renewable energies. The cost of an average conventional fuel oil system was quoted at $16,200. Below are the resulting costs associated with the GHP system taking into account the utility rebate and how it compares to the conventional system.     Ground Source System & Ductwork = $10,541 Ground Loop= $8,742 Utility rebate= $200/kW*14.8 kW= $2,960 Total Cost=$10,541+$8,742-$2,960= $16,323
24

 Conventional system= $16,200 With HVAC maintenance costs being similar for both the GHP and conventional system, the cost to the homeowner of a new geothermal system is less than a couple of hundred dollars more than that of adopting a conventional system (RETscreen International, 2012). Knowing that operating costs for the GHP system will be completely negligible, this scenario demonstrates that adopting a GHP system is in the financial best interest of the customer. Even in cases where there are no rebates to incentivize the purchase of an energy friendly system like a GHP, the difference between the two systems could be recouped in a short period of time especially considering other factors of interest to the homeowner, such as comfort and environmental benefits . There are additional direct use options for geothermal resources that have a clear economic and environmental advantage. Below are brief descriptions: Agricultural Applications: greenhouses are a great way to utilize direct use geothermal energy. This method leads to a decrease in the operational costs of the greenhouse, resulting in thousands of dollars in savings. Small scale district heating: district heating provides geothermal heat to buildings and homes within a network of distribution pipes in a small area. The district heating offers a cheap and clean alternative to fossil fuel powered heating. Schools & long term use buildings: Long term use buildings, like municipal buildings or schools, are a great place to utilize direct-use geothermal energy due to the advantage these buildings provide in amortizing the initial startup costs over several years which, combined with the yearly savings generated by not using conventional heating, make geothermal an ideal technology to use. Tourism: for centuries, spas have utilized geothermal energy to fuel the relaxation and beauty needs of their frequenters. Communities that have access to geothermal sources can utilize them to supplement their economy through tourism. Iceland’s Blue Lagoon is one of the county’s main tourist attractions.

25

Small-Scale Geothermal Cost by Region Comparing geothermal systems for small residences in different parts of the country must take into account the systems that are replaced, in this case, heating and air conditioning. All renewables replace and offset something a homeowner already uses. In the case of solar PV, only electrical loads are being offset; since geothermal replaces both heat and air conditioning, both energy requirements must be evaluated to see the varying payback periods between regions. In the United States, heat typically comes from natural gas, propane or fuel oil. Natural gas is currently very inexpensive compared to propane and fuel oil. Air conditioning uses electricity, which is generally expensive and varies greatly in price between states. Therefore, these are the first variables considered: the price of heat and the price of electricity for air conditioning. Exhibit 12 displays the variables and payback periods for 5 different regions of the country using state-by-state data from the US Energy Information Administration. The most important factor in determining the payback period between regions is the balance of a particular area's heating and cooling needs. This is why California comes in as the worst payback (18 years) for geothermal, as most of their needs are related to air conditioning and they have really cheap natural gas as well. Also, California does not have as decent a balance of the heat to air conditioning ratio, as compared to states like Illinois, New York or Vermont. Vermont comes in as the best payback (4.5 years) due to the following variables: the heating and air conditioning needs are very balanced meaning it gets hot and cold fairly equally, they have a much higher cost for heat (propane), and they have a higher cost of electricity. To compare three additional regions, Illinois has an 8.7 year payback primarily because the state has a good balance of heat and cooling needs. Illinois has cheaper than average natural gas and electricity and does not have nearly as fast a payback as Vermont, but a much faster payback than California. Hawaii, which has a seven year payback, is an example of a state with a major imbalance of heating and air conditioning needs; however, due to extremely high electricity costs, the payback period is similar to that of New York, which achieves a seven year payback through a combination of balanced heating and air conditioning needs as well as higher than average electricity and natural gas costs. The primary takeaway is that all variables must be
26

taken into account to determine an accurate payback period, assuming that the capital investment is relatively constant between regions. EXHIBIT 12: Region Heat & DHW Natural Gas ($/therm) 0.91 4.33 1.36 0.97 1.57 1.109 Cooling Electric Simple Pre-Tax IRR ($/kWh) Payback 0.0975 8.7 yrs 16.80% 0.3013 7.0 yrs 20.30% 0.1731 7.0 yrs 20.20% 0.1578 18.2 yrs 8.40% 0.1573 0.1095 4.5 yrs 29.20% Capacity Delivered (MWh) Heating 22 1 21 16 22 Cooling 55 95 35 45 25

Illinois Hawaii New York California (Worst) Vermont (Best) US Average

Additional Economic Advantages Geothermal energy does not only provide direct economic advantages to individuals that utilize geothermal power or own a GHP system in their homes. Geothermal energy is a resource that can help provide economic and environmental advantages on a macro level. Adoption of geothermal energy, both on a large and small scale, guarantees the creation of jobs, both directly and indirectly. Geothermal power plants would guarantee a steady flow of jobs for the entire period the plants are in service, and an increased use in GHP systems will create the need for trained HVAC specialists, providing a way for out of work HVAC laborers to be retrained in a new skill or opening up a market for new labor to be gainfully employed. A steady increase in jobs will also guarantee additional economic output that could help stimulate local business around the power plants or in regions where GHPs are prominently used. Geothermal energy would also create the need for ancillary businesses like consulting firms, engineering firms, and design firms, all geared to fulfilling needs created by a stronger adoption of geothermal energy. Last, but not least, the savings generated by utilizing geothermal energy can be diverted into other needs by the consumers. Geothermal energy provides a cheap, renewable, environmentally friendly fuel; it has the potential to create
27

thousands of quality jobs around the country while boosting local economies; it reduces foreign oil imports as well as our dependence on fossil fuels and helps to diversify our indigenous energy supply. ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS OF GEOTHERMAL ENERGY Geothermal literally means, “Heat from the earth,” and is legally recognized as a renewable resource. Both wind and solar energy are excellent uses of renewable resources as well; however, both are dependent upon weather alterations and climate changes, which makes neither available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, like geothermal energy. Exhibit 13 represents a study comparing the emissions from a geothermal plant with those of a coal plant with emission-control technologies. The result was that the coal plant still discharged twenty-four times more carbon dioxide, 10,837 times more sulfur dioxide, and 3,865 times more nitrous oxides per megawatt hour as compared to a geothermal plant (Kagel & Bates & Gawell, 2007). EXHIBIT 13:

In addition to just emissions, there are other environmental impacts that can be had by a technology: noise pollution, water use, water quality, land use, resources, impact on wildlife and vegetation. There is a false thought that geothermal technology produces a lot of noise; however, the reality is that this is not an issue at all: geothermal plants produce about the same amount of noise as swirling leaves in the wind. Secondly, the amount of water used by
28

geothermal plants is approximately five gallons of fresh water per megawatt hour, compared with natural gas facilities, which use approximately 360 gallons per megawatt hour. Thirdly, the fluid used in geothermal plants is not released into groundwater sources; rather, these fluids are injected into reservoirs specifically designated for geothermal use. These wells are sheathed with a thick casing, in order to prevent cross-contamination. Next, the land used by geothermal plants is not a significant factor, as these plants can be incorporated into multiple-use facilities, to be used with farming, skiing, or hunting. Also, when compared using a thirty-year life cycle analysis, geothermal facilities use approximately 400 square meters of land per gigawatt hour, while a coal facility uses 3,632 square meters of land per gigawatt hour (Geothermal Energy Association, 2007). The impact on land development is represented in Exhibit 14. Bottom-line surface features, such as geysers, are used to determine the location of resources but are never used in the actual development of geothermal energy. Lastly, to address the impact on wildlife and vegetation; before any construction is to begin, there is an environmental review on the land, in order to assess any potential affects that might be had on the plant and animal life in the vicinity. Also, all geothermal power plants are built in accordance with state and federal regulations, which minimize that potential affect (Kagel & Bates & Gawell, 2007). EXHIBIT 14:

29

One of the big questions about geothermal energy is: Can this technology assist in the reduction of global warming? Carbon dioxide is one of the dominant components of greenhouse gas emissions, making up approximately 83%. The remaining percentage is made up of nitrous oxides and methane. Carbon dioxide is not emitted or is emitted at very low levels by geothermal facilities, and there are essentially zero emissions of nitrous oxides and methane. Using geothermal plants can assist in the reduction of greenhouse gases, due to the fact that using geothermal energy is cleaner and renewable while fossil fuels are neither clean nor renewable. Another question is: Can geothermal energy offset other environmental impacts? Utilizing this type of source eliminates the need to mine, process, and transport the required resources for fossil fueled-electricity generation. Also, there is a technology being explored that would allow for the minerals that are currently mined, to be extracted from geothermal water, in order for the environmental impacts of mining to be eliminated. MYTHS AND TRUTHS There are many challenges that are associated with geothermal progress, as there a lack of understanding of the underlying principles. This section will attempt to dispel some of the rumors surrounding this technology. Myth: Geothermal energy is experimental and not widely used. Truth: Geothermal resources have been used for thousands of years, archeologically speaking. As has been previously stated, geothermal energy is a clean, renewable resource that offers energy around the world. First, geothermal springs were used by the Paleo-Indians for warmth and cleansing. Secondly, Italy opened the first large-scale geothermal plant in 1904 and is still in operation today. Over twenty-one countries use geothermal energy for their power production. Lastly, as this technology advances, the cost and risk associated will decrease as the usage and contribution to energy needs increases. Myth: Geothermal resources are nonrenewable.

30

Truth: Geothermal resources are, both by legal classification and scientific definition, renewable. Geothermal energy, as it is from Earth, is literally inexhaustible. According to science, temperatures at the Earth’s core, which is approximately 4000 miles deep, is upwards of 9000°F; this has been the case for over 4 billion years and will continue for billions of years to come. Legally speaking, both the National Energy Policy Act of 1992 and the Pacific Northwest Electric Power Planning and Conservation Act of 1980 define geothermal energy as a renewable resource. Myth: Geothermal power plants emit smoke. Truth: The visible plumes rising from geothermal plants are actually vapor emissions, meaning steam, not smoke, caused by the evaporation cooling system. There is no combustion that takes place at geothermal facilities. If the facility employs an air-cooled system, then there would be no water vapor. If the facility employs a water-cooling process, then approximately fifty percent of the cooling tower fluids would be released into the atmosphere as water vapor and the remainder would return to the reservoir. Myth: Extraction and injection of geothermal brines contaminates drinking water. Truth: No contamination of groundwater has occurred as a result of geothermal activity. A lot of effort is put into the geothermal industry, in order to minimize the affects on groundwater systems, surface features, and local water. Brines from geothermal plants are injected into specific reservoirs, which use a special wall casing, made of a thick pipe encased in cement, to prevent groundwater cross-contamination. The EPA, along with the Underground Injection Control Program, in hopes of protecting underground water resources, regulates these determinations. Myth: Natural geothermal surface features are used during geothermal development.

31

Truth: While surface features, such as geysers, are typically useful in identifying the locations of geothermal resources, these features are not used during geothermal development. It is actually not possible to extract geothermal resources form these surface features themselves, for large-scale development purposes. Furthermore, most geothermal resources have already been, or are currently being, developed in these surface feature areas, and most of the geothermal resource that has yet to be developed is not located around these surface features. Myth: Current geothermal development alters geothermal land features. Truth: Although all geothermal development can potentially disrupt land features proper project management reduces or altogether eliminates land alteration. In the simplest terms, geothermal development is forbidden in sensitive areas, in order to prevent devastation of national landmarks. In the 70s and 80s, surface features, including surrounding geysers and fumaroles, were altered by geothermal development. The United States, with the retroactive intentions of protecting national parks and their associated thermal features, passed the Steam Act and other laws (Kagel & Bates & Gawell, 2007). Geothermal energy is defined, by law, as a renewable resource, as it is, by definition, heat from the earth. Geothermal energy has a multitude of environmental benefits. Geothermal energy is reliable and renewable. Secondly, not only are there minimal air emissions, but also it offsets the air emissions of fossil fuel-fired power plants. In addition to offsetting air emissions, using geothermal energy can offset other environmental impacts. Lastly, this is a combustion-free energy, with minimal land impacts, and also, is competitive with other energy technologies when environmental costs are considered (Geothermal Energy Association 2009). RISK ANALYSIS Geothermal energy, whether on the large or small scale, is a promising technology for the United States; however, there are several risk factors. Regarding the energy component, it is possible that geothermal technology will not move forward and will, therefore, suffer a similar fate to that of the fuel cell, which scientists have been working on for many years with limited results. The long-term payback periods, whether for the large or small scale,
32

could be deemed too risky of an investment without heavy tax incentives or subsidies. The risk associated with operating a power plant and potential earthquakes actually revolve around fracking. Power plants are built to specifications that require certain parameters and as the underground temperature lowers with time (15-100 yrs), one of the ways that plant management recoups this loss is by fracking, which has associated environmental risks. For example, a plant in Switzerland caused a number of small earthquakes in the area through fracking. Since the Swiss building codes are not designed for earthquakes, the small 3-3.4 Richter Scale activity caused millions of damage as a direct result (Domenico, 2009). Therefore, the risk in this situation lies in a power plant’s managerial decision to use fracking methods, but not from the geothermal itself. This is still a risk, however, that should be acknowledged and incorporated into policy measures. Again, it must be noted that many leading scientists believe the planet is close to or already past the tipping point for carbon dioxide emissions; therefore, geothermal and all renewable systems could have no impact whatsoever. If that is the case, all scientific research and development should be deployed on the path of saving the planet and preserving the human race in some form. However, one of the rising threats to both geothermal and other renewables of the future is poor leadership from the government, in terms of designing and implementing energy policies. The United States government has no comprehensive energy plan, and this lack of policy extends to the state and local levels as well. Most current renewable portfolio standards are targeted at renewables as a whole instead of individually, which do not support individual strengths and weaknesses in a rapidly changing energy marketplace. Jimmy Carter preached conservation and renewables in 1977, and the country is nowhere close to the former president’s hopes from 35 years ago. The primary reason for this failure of leadership is a lack of scientific understanding of the complex issues interlocking energy, the economy, and the environment. Even when the government actually does create a helpful policy, there is not adequate marketing to the public, and the policy ends up deemed a failure because not enough consumers take advantage. For example, the USDA’s Rural Energy for America Program (REAP) expired in January 2012 and has not been renewed. The program offers up to 25 percent of
33

project costs for all renewable systems constructed on a rural business property for systems up to $100,000. Not enough people took advantage of this policy because the public generally did not know it existed. Creating sound policy is meaningless if it cannot be communicated and implemented properly by political leadership. RECOMMENDATIONS It is the primary recommendation that the US pursues and enacts policies to encourage geothermal development, along with other available energy options, in order to meet anticipated demand, help economic development, and preserve a fragile environment. Energy supply, access to clean drinking water, and devastating climate change are all connected and must all must be addressed. What is the point of elaborate energy systems if we run out of water or clean air? New policies must be enacted with the logical combination of efficiency and conservation, which means significant changes at every level of American thinking. Groundbreaking political leadership is needed to make this a reality. In reference to new financing options, the Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) financing could be an excellent vehicle that would make geothermal feasible for more households. It allows homeowners to get a loan for any energy efficiency and renewable energy system. Loans are raised via municipal bonds and the homeowner spreads the payments on a 10-20 year term, which is then attached to the current property taxes. Currently, PACE is being held up in congress by the FHA, but the measure has the potential to be the top financing vehicle for geothermal and other renewable energy systems. The system stays with the home and not the homeowner; therefore, it will transfer over once the building gets sold. The cost of the loan will be lower than what is saved on the energy reductions (Solar Financing, 2011). Specifically regarding geothermal, the team’s recommendations are for the United States policies to assist development on both the large and small scale. Geothermal electricity power plants have major potential, but the payback period may be too long for most investors; subsidies and incentives may be necessary to move this type of power production forward. At the residential level, it makes the most sense to target new construction projects in rural areas that also have a balance of heating and cooling needs, like Vermont, or that pay an extremely high average rate for electricity, like Hawaii. State and local governments also have the ability to provide incentives to dramatically
34

shorten the payback period for a geothermal system. There may only be a short window of time left to pursue these options before drastic climate change renders them obsolete; strong leadership is needed if the United States hopes to solve the complex issues intertwining energy, the economy and the environment.

35

BIBLIOGRAPHY
Alrobaei, Hussain. (2005). Hybrid Geothermal/Solar Energy Technology for Power Generation. Higher Institute of Engineering. Retrieved from http://www.environmentalexpert.com/Files%5C24847%5Carticles%5C14612%5Chgst.pdf Ebel, Fred. (2003). Exponential Growth and The Rule of 70. Eco Future. Retrieved from http://www.ecofuture.org/pop/facts/exponential70.html EIA 2010, Annual Energy Review 2008 http://www.eia.doe.gov/totalenergy/data/annual/ Energy Information Administration 2010, Hawaii Renewable Electricity Profile, http://www.eia.gov/cneaf/solar.renewables/page/state_profiles/hawaii.html Energy Information Administration, Renewable Energy-Geothermal Heat Pumps Data and Information, from Form EIA-902, Annual Geothermal Heat Pump Manufacturers Survey Table 3.1 2008, http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/solar.renewables/page/heatpumps/heatpumps.html) Geo-Heat Center, Oregon Institute of Technology, 3201 Campus Dr., Klamath Falls, OR 97601. http://geoheat.oit.edu/ Geothermal Education Office. (2000). Geothermal Facts. Geothermal Education Office Website. Retrieved from http://geothermal.marin.org/pwrheat.html Geothermal Electricity. Retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geothermal_electricity GeothermalEnergy.Org. (2011). Geothermal Energy – Heating, Cooling and Ground Source Power. Retrieved from http://www.geothermalenergy.org/ Geothermal Energy Association. (February, 2009). Geothermal Basics. Retrieved from http://www.geoenergy.org Geothermal Heat Pump. Retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geothermal_heat_pump Giardini, Domenico. (December, 2009). Geothermal Quake Risks Must Be Faced. Nature International Weekly Journal of Science. Retrieved from http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v462/n7275/full/462848a.html Hackleman, Michael. (July, 2000). Radiant Floor Heat. Backwoods Home Magazine Online. Retrieved from http://www.backwoodshome.com/articles/hackleman64.html International Spa Association, Lexington, Kentucky, the North American Spa Industry Fast Facts 2007, http://www.experienceispa.com/ Jenne, John. (2010) www.nbmg.unr.edu/Geothermal/Exploration.html Kagel, Alyssa, Bates, Diana, Gawell, Karl. (April 2007). A Guide to Geothermal Energy in the Environment. Retrieved from http://geo-energy.org/reports/environmental%20guide.pdf McKibben, Bill. (June, 2008). The Tipping Point. Yale Environment 360.Retrieved from http://e360.yale.edu/feature/the_tipping_point/2012/ National Geothermal Collaborative (2010). Geothermal Energy Technologies & Cost/Page 2. Retrieved from http://usda01.library.cornell.edu/usda/current/AgriLandVa/AgriLandVa-08-04-2011.pdf

36

National Renewable Energy Laboratory. (2012). NREL Website. Retrieved from http://www.nrel.gov/ Oregon Institute of Technology. (2012). Retrieved from (http://geoheat.oit.edu) Renewable Energy Policy Project-Economics. Retrieved from http://www.repp.org/geothermal/geothermal_brief_economics.html Retscreen International. (2012). Combined Heating & Cooling. Retrieved from http://www.retscreen.net/ang/case_studies_residential_united_states_of_america.php Solar Financing. (2011). PACE Program. One Block Off the Grid. Retrieved from http://solarfinancing.1bog.org/pace-program-solar-financing/ Svoboda, Elizabeth. (March, 2010). Does Geothermal Power Cause Earthquakes? Popsci. Retrieved from http://www.popsci.com/science/article/2010-03/does-geothermal-power-cause-earthquakes Trabish, Herman. (April, 2010). Latest Estimates of U.S. Geothermal Potential. Renewable Energy World. Retrieved from http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/rea/blog/post/2010/04/latest-estimates-of-u-sgeothermal-potential US Department of Agriculture. (August, 2011). Land Values 2011 Summary. Retrieved from http://usda01.library.cornell.edu/usda/current/AgriLandVa/AgriLandVa-08-04-2011.pdf US Department of Energy. (February, 2011). A History of Geothermal Energy in the US. US DOE Energy Geothermal Technologies Program. Retrieved from http://www1.eere.energy.gov/geothermal/history.html US Department of Energy. (2006). Geothermal Technologies Program, Direct Use of Geothermal Energy. Retrieved from http://www1.eere.energy.gov/geothermal/directuse.html US Energy Information Administration, Renewable Energy Consumption and Electricity Statistics. (2010) Retrieved from http://www.eia.gov/renewable/annual/preliminary/ US Energy Information Administration. (2010). Natural Gas Analysis and Projections. Retrieved from http://www.eia.gov/naturalgas/reports.cfm?t=66 US Energy Information Administration. (2010). Electricity Analysis and Projections. Retrieved from http://www.eia.gov/electricity/reports.cfm?t=98 Watkinson, Peter. (December, 2009). The Energy Pyramid. Conservation, Energy Efficiency. Retrieved from http://cleantechcompass.wordpress.com/2009/12/18/the-energy-pyramid/

37

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Geothermal Energy

...The Home is heated by geothermal energy. To access this constant heat source they Drilled down 250 ft and inserted a vertical pipe. Fluid is pumped down, heated by the earth internal temperature and pumped back up. Heating the home thru radiant tubes in the floors. Wiki Closed loop geothermal heat pumps circulate a carrier fluid (usually a water/antifreeze mix) through pipes buried in the ground. As the fluid circulates underground it absorbs heat from the ground and, on its return, the now warmer fluid passes through the heat pump which uses electricity to extract the heat from the fluid. The re-chilled fluid is sent back into the ground thus continuing the cycle. The heat extracted and that generated by the heat pump appliance as a byproduct is used to heat the house. The addition of the ground heating loop in the energy equation means that more heat is generated than if electricity alone had been used directly for heating. Switching the direction of heat flow, the same system can be used to circulate the cooled water through the house for cooling in the summer months. The heat is exhausted to the relatively cooler ground (or groundwater) rather than delivering it to the hot outside air as an air conditioner does. As a result, the heat is pumped across a larger temperature difference and this leads to higher efficiency and lower energy use.[9] This technology makes geothermal heating economically viable in any geographical location. In 2004, an estimated million ground...

Words: 609 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Geothermal Energy

...GEOTHERMAL ENERGY Geothermal energy is one of the oldest sources of energy. It is simply using and reusing (reusable energy) heat from the inside of the earth. Most of the geothermal energy comes from magma, molten or partially molten rock. Which is why most geothermal resources come from regions where there are active volcanoes. Hot springs, geysers, pools of boiling mud, and fumaroles are the most easily exploited sources. The ancient Romans used hot springs to heat baths and homes, and similar uses are still found in Iceland, Turkey, and Japan. The true source of geothermal energy is believed to come from radioactive decay occurring deep within the earth. Electricity is one of the biggest outputs of geothermal energy. It was first recorded to produce electricity in 1904 in Italy. There are now geothermal power plants in operation in New Zealand, Japan, Iceland, the US and elsewhere. For the generation of electricity, hot water, at temperatures ranging from about 700 degrees F, is brought from the underground reservoir to the surface through production wells, and is flashed to steam in special vessels by release of pressure. The steam is separated from the liquid and fed to a turbine engine, which turns a generator. In turn, the generator produces electricity. Spent geothermal fluid is injected back into peripheral parts of the reservoir to help maintain reservoir pressure. If the reservoir is to be used for direct-heat application, the geothermal water is usually...

Words: 714 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Geothermal Energy

...Geothermal energy represents the inner heat of the earth, produced largely by the decay of radioactive elements in the mantle and center. The three ways that the heat is found is both wet and dry steam (wet steam has drops of water in it), hot water and dry volcanic rocks. We know that the temperature of the earth at depths of 25 to 50 km range from 200`C to 1000`C. There are areas of the earth where local concentrations of heat occur, just as mineral concentrations do. Most of these are located along oceanic ridges and continental rifts, such as the ‘Ring of Fire’. Geothermal energy is not free from environmental problems. The steam contains large amounts of hydrogen sulphide with its smell of rotten eggs, and both steam and hot water contain substantial amounts of dissolved minerals, many of which are poisonous to the aquatic life in the streams and rivers into which they are eventually discharged. Also, the removal of steam or water causes the earth to subside in that region. Geothermal energy was first used in the era of the ancient Roman bath house, in which they bathed in hot salt springs. Even though the Romans found an easy way to use geothermal energy, and we still enjoy natural hot springs, the process of removing geothermal energy from the earth to use it efficiently is rather difficult. The only three ways to use geothermal energy is for hot water, space heating and generating electricity. In order to turn geothermal energy into...

Words: 498 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Geothermal Energy

...Geothermal Energy is the use of the energy in the earth, the natural heat the earth produces. There are several ways to harness this power, and frequently these sources are totally renewable and re-usable. These natural alternatives have been preferred by many over using the fossil fuels so prevalent in society at this time, in that they can be used without the environmental arguments presently going on about fossil fuels. Geothermal energy was first discovered in the seventh century, when mines dug were found to be actually hotter than the surface. This was assumed to be resulting from a heat source located inside the earth, termed Geothermal Energy. Both Romans and Chinese used geothermal springs to heat buildings and gather warm water. The Maoris in New Zealand used geysers to cook their food. Currently, it is also in use in Japan, Iceland, New Zealand, and California as a commonly seen source of energy. All these locations use the energy to heat homes, power electricity, and other such uses. Geothermal is gathered from three sources – Dry Steam Fields, Wet Steam Fields, and Hot Water Fields. Dry Steam, the easiest one to harvest, is also the one seen very rarely. The conditions of having large amounts of steam underground ready to come up and power turbines are not seen often. A few, however, do exist, and for example, one in Larderello, Italy, has been producing electricity for over a hundred years. Wet Steam Fields are more common, but also not...

Words: 850 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Essay On Geothermal Energy

...Geothermal energy which is heat energy can be found in almost everywhere on Earth. It is a renewable energy derived from heat deep in the Earth’s crust. The word “geothermal” comes from Greek words meaning “Earth” (geo) and heat (thermal), it means using the nature heat produced inside the Earth. (Davor Habjanec,2008)The use of geothermal energy occurred more than 10,000 years ago with the settlement of Paleo-Indians in hot springs. The technology of geothermal energy improved each year. In 1904, the first geothermal power plant was built in Larderello, Italy. Although geothermal energy's installation is expensive, it is an efficient and reliable energy resource which does not cause significant pollution, it is renewable, and we can predict the output power with remarkable accuracy. Commercial geothermal power projects which is the geothermal power plant, are expensive. The exploration and drilling of new reservoirs come with a steep price tag. Total costs usually end...

Words: 1014 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Research Paper in Geothermal Energy

... A Geothermal power plant uses its geothermal activities to generate power. And this type of natural energy production is extremely environmentally friendly and used in many geothermal spots. And to harness this geothermal energy, a deep hole are being drilled into the earth (much like when drilling for oil) until a significant hot spot is found. And this geothermal power is one of the most renewable energy sources that exist on our planet today. It is also defined as a renewable energy that taps into the heat emanating from earth’s core. And it can be used for many energy uses. Here in the province of Antique on evidence that there is a possible spots for geothermal energy source is located in Brgy. Nato, Anini-y, Antique where hot springs exists. And for this, the assessment of geothermal energy is the first best step (basis for geothermal power plant). Geothermal energy here in Antique is not the concern of the government even though there is evidence and possibility that geothermal energy source here exists. This process required full attention from the government. This energy will be the solution for the major problems in which the province experiencing today. That is why Antique is extremely dependent in power supplies to others in such a way that this power supply can sustain the demand for industrial productions as a whole. Objectives of the study The general objectives of the study enumerates the following * To determine if the geothermal energy...

Words: 395 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Pros And Cons Of Using Geothermal Energy

...Nuclear Energy is made from the nucleus from the particles whom make up matter. Canada mainly uses nuclear power plants to keep up with 52% of Ontario electrical energy supply. This happens when the nucleus from the power plants make uranium to supply power around Canada. They take the uranium and apply it so it would change to Thermal Energy. Nuclear energy comes in many shapes and forms. One of the main nuclear energy would be called uranium and plutonium. These energies makes it a nuclear power plant a source of energy since they use these two. Uranium nuclear energy is a silver element in the actinide series. Plutonium energy is a chemical element as known as Pu. Nuclear energy is made with two fundamentals resources, fission and fusion. Fission is when the fission kinetic energy separates the uranium and plutonium into smaller...

Words: 2113 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Geothermal Energy a Better Alternative Than Coal Power

...Geothermal Energy a Better Alternative than Coal Power For many years, people have been developing technologies that can improve the quality of life; help save human labor, provide entertainment and make life more comfortable. This technology has led us to depend on different energy-consuming machines like computers, electric motors, televisions, cars, motorcycles etc. because this technology needs energy to function, energy supply is very essential to sustain for the energy-consuming machines that people use. There are renewable and non-renewable sources of energy that are available in the world. Some are fossil fuels like coal, oil and natural gases. Geothermal energy and hydrothermal power are also available. In the Philippines, coal power is the most common source of energy. However, this source of power brings about pollution that can cause harm to the environment. With these observations, some sectors and environmental groups propose an alternative source of power which is geothermal energy. This paper aims to compare geothermal energy and coal power in terms of social implications, environmental impacts and feasibility. Furthermore, this paper aims to know geothermal energy and coal power as well as their advantages and disadvantages. Most energy consumers are not aware of a good energy source as long as it can sustain the technology that they use. This study aims to inform the power consumers on which is a better power source. This will also help them understand...

Words: 1885 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Geothermal Energy for a Business

...Report Five Research Report The upper management at Eyre Enterprises is considering incorporating new ideas in technology As an Eyre Enterprises engineer or scientist, you have been asked to write a research report so they will have the information to make these decisions. Choose your topic from one of the technical fields listed below. You may also want to define ; this will help you narrow the scope of your topic. Artificial intelligence Fiber optics Forestry management Geothermal energy Human-powered vehicles Lignite-coal mining Organic farming Satellite surveying Solar power Wind power Aquaponics For this report, not all sources will come from books, magazines or websites; some may actually come from personal or telephone interviews, emails, information from experts in the field, or other reliable/credible sources. One of the major tasks for this assignment will be finding out where to seek out the information needed to build a persuasive report. You may want to begin by exploring Requirements: Before you begin Report 5, you must send an email to your instructor explaining the specific and narrowed topic you have chosen (EX: organic farming in an urban environment). o You r topic must be app roved before you begin w riting. o Your email must be of professional quality. If you are asked to revise your email, you may lose points on the assignment. N O T E : The email must be sent by 11:59 p.m. on Wednesday, November 20 th or the report grade will be reduced by ten (10)...

Words: 676 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Great Hair Care

...Geothermal energy is created through power plants similar to the ones that burn coal. However, the heat that turns the water into steam to spin the turbines is derived from the magma in the earth’s mantle, and indirectly from the earth’s core. This is a pretty much renewable, emission free source of energy. The more common way of harnessing the heat from the earth’s mantle is with Flash steam power plants. This is when plants drill down to natural reservoirs, pump cool water down, and pump the hot water up. The water that’s pumped up is way hotter than the boiling point of water (212°F). With Flash steam power plants, the water needs to be between 350° and 700°. When this water is given room to expand, it turns immediately into steam and spins a turbine. Another type of power plant is the Dry steam. This power plant just pumps water down and, and steam up. This is the oldest and simplest design. Water for this design must be above 300°. The last and latest design is the binary power plant. This can take water that is as low as 135°. When the water is pumped up, it goes through a heat exchanger, which transfers heat from the water to another substance with a lower boiling point, like butane. The second substance is then used to spin the turbine. Some of the pros to geothermal energy is that it is pretty much completely reliable, completely renewable, is a steady source of energy, and doesn’t release a much smaller amount of harmful emissions than burning fossil fuels (only...

Words: 648 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Wala

...CHAPTER 2 Geothermal Energy Geothermal energy is a form of renewable energy derived from heat deep in earth’s crust. This heat is brought to the near surface by thermal conduction by intrusion into the earth’s crust of molten magma originating from great depth. As groundwater is heated, geothermal energy is produced in the form of hot water and steam. The heated groundwater can be used for direct heating of homes and greenhouses, for vegetable drying, and for a number of other uses. These are known as direct uses of geothermal energy. Geothermal energy is also used for electricity production. Geothermal power generation is used today throughout the world where good geothermal resources exist, including many locations in the western United States. The REPP geothermal issue brief on this page provides a general background on the fundamentals of geothermal power including discussions of the technical, economic, and policy dimensions of geothermal power worldwide. Economic data and current U.S. geothermal policy help illustrate the concepts of the issue brief. Extensive references to reports and internet links to be the latest developments in geothermal power’s role in clean energy generation are included. “Ecologists also agree that geothermal energy could be used at little or no cost to the environment. Unlike fossil or expensive fissionable fuels, it does not pollute the atmosphere with combustion products or radiation” explained Escobar in ‘Geothermal Energy supply to sustain...

Words: 842 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Religion

...in partial fulfillment of the mentioned course. | Introduction Kenya’s energy sector faces daunting challenges, characterized by high cost and insufficient supply. Nearly 80% of Kenyans are living without access to basic Energy services; a top priority for the government is to improve access to adequate and affordable energy supply. The existing energy supply is heavily dependent upon hydroelectric power thus due to the rapid growth in demand for energy means that Kenya must find new ways to provide crucial energy services to its people. The available options include Renewable energy resources like geothermal. Kenya has nearly 7,000 MW geothermal potential, yet it remains largely undeveloped due to economic and financial limitations, insufficient technical and human capacity, and various social constraints. However the government has now turned around and is aiming at producing about 16000MW of power by 2030. The country currently produces about 1500 MWs primarily from hydro stations (57%-hydro power, about 32%-thermal and the rest comprises geothermal and emergency thermal power). To bridge this huge deficit in the short time, courses as EMM 516 were developed to provide man-power needed to sustain the projected growth. First we visited the Kiambere power station the Tana station and Kangaita tea factory for a boiler’s experience. We later visited the Embakasi gas turbine then to Olkaria II geothermal power generation plant. In this report I will basically describe the outlay...

Words: 5403 - Pages: 22

Free Essay

Case-in-Point Analysis

...Case-In-Point Analysis Geoff Manbeck University of phoenix Environmental Issues and Ethics SCI-362 Brian Hoeft December 31, 2012 Case-In-Point Analysis The Salton Sea, once known as the accidental sea, became a popular tourist attraction which people would travel to for vacations (Ransriggs, 2011). People bought homes, built schools, restaurants, and yacht clubs; it was considered to be a miracle in the desert. Over the years the water at the Salton Sea became saltier than the ocean. Botulism poisoning killed millions of fish, and the heat, which reach the temperature of 120 degrees, made the air unbearable to breathe. A consequence was the sea began to flood (Ransriggs, 2011). The water at the Salton Sea was fed only by agricultural run-off, which increased the salt levels of the Salton Sea to levels that the fish could not survive. The death of 200 million fish had a large effect on the rest of the ecosystem, causing the death of the bird populations who rely on fish for food, increasing severe decaying of the dead fish, and creating a increased number of flies and other pathogens in their rotting carcasses (Ransriggs, 2011). The loss and harm to the populations of wild species at the Salton Sea is critical importance of migrating birds. The sea supports over 90% of the North American population species such as eared grebes, 30,000 American white pelicans, 2,000 brown pelicans, 25,000 snow and Ross’ geese, and 120,000 shore birds, which consist of 44 species (Ransriggs...

Words: 1229 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

No Trends Big Trends

...government, Storengy was asked by the BEE to study the basement part of a geothermal power plant construction project. The island of Dominica (73 000 people) is a republic within the Commonwealth, independent since 1978. Its capital Roseau is counting approximately 24 000 people. It is located exactly halfway between the islands Guadeloupe 41 km north and Martinique 40 km south. It relates to evaluate the potential of Wotten Waven geothermal field (initially presented with a capacity of 120 MWe in 2012 before the three exploration wells and 90 MWe in 2013) and estimate if it can provide enough energy for electricity production not only for home market but also for export to Guadeloupe and / or Martinique.This geothermal field is located in the southern part of the Dominica island approximately at ten kilometers east of Roseau, in an area known for its geothermal surface manifestations including mineralized hot springs, fumaroles, sulfur deposits and phreatic explosion craters (whose "Boiling Lake", one of the largest known in the world). The main conclusions of the analysis and integration of data provided in data room, but also from additional bibliographic research carried out in support, are the following: Geological context and conceptual model of the geothermal system Three exploration wells (WW-01 to 03) were drilled in 2012 at depths of 1200 to 1600 m. They helped prove the existence of a deep geothermal reservoir and provide important information on its thickness, its temperature...

Words: 1483 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Geophysics

...Joseph N. Frederick III PSC 1121C Spring 2011 Geophysics Geophysics can be broken down into several groups that deal with physical science and the earth. It is a field and profession that combines geology, mathematics, and physics all in an effort for people across the world to understand the ways of the world and exactly what it takes for certain seemingly unnatural events to happen. Geophysics covers a range of ideas from gravity, heat flow, seismic waves that cause vibrations through the Earth’s layers, radioactivity both geothermal and geochronological, electricity, electromagnetic waves and magnetism, fluid dynamics, and even condensed matter physics. So as we see, geophysics is indeed a very broad subject, yet when looked at under specific lights, we see that geophysics is no more than a name, a container, for all matters Earthly related. Most of these topics will most definitely be covered in this essay and if not talked about in depth, definitely mentioned seeing as how all of these ideas are valuable to everyone worldwide in getting to know and understand the way our home planet works in relation to ourselves and the space we occupy in the universe. (Beroza, Nelson, and Ilich, "The Department of Geophysics"). History The first traces of anything geophysically related first appear in regions inside of China during the Qin dynasty somewhere between two hundred twenty-one and two hundred six B.C. when Chinese fortunetellers used lodestones to create their fortune...

Words: 3126 - Pages: 13