Free Essay

Gilbert Grape

In:

Submitted By whitees0812
Words 716
Pages 3
In this paper I'm going to discuss the two main differences between the movie and the book What's Eating Gilbert Grape. The first main difference I'm going to touch on is how Becky is in both the movie and the book, and the difference in the relationship she has with Gilbert. The next thing I want to talk about is the different ways that Momma is portrayed in the two versions. Both of these two points that I've stated above seem like minor details but they have a huge impact on the overall story, and in the methods of character portrayal. Becky is two completely different people when looking at the book and the movie. In the book she is only 15 years old while Gilbert is in his 20's. While this is true in the book, in the movie it seems that Becky is older. The age change may just be a culture thing so the movie seems better for a wider demographic, either way it still changes the way Becky is perceived. Gilbert and Becky have a lot less conflict in the movie, which is not the case in the book. The book has two main scenes that were cut out of the movie. The first one is the watermelon incident where Gilbert gets tired of chasing Becky and leaves her watermelon on the ground at the gas station without second guessing himself. Showing that Gilbert does care about Becky but he does not want to play her games. In the whole book, Gilbert seems to play by his own rules and does pretty much what he wants without regard to others peoples thoughts, actions or reactions. The second with the both of them was the mirror scene, where Becky holds a mirror up so Gilbert can see himself. Another big difference between the movie and the book Becky comes back at the end of the movie making it a happy ending, but the book never does this. Besides the character differences of Becky hers and gilberts relationship its totally different between the two stories. In the book they play this cat and mouse game where they both show signs of venerability, mainly Gilbert but he never really opens up to Becky until the end of the story. In the movie there is a mutual attraction between the two of them, and there is not the game playing that goes on in the book. Becky seems to be sure of herself and a lot more confident in herself in the book, while in the movie she is not that person. In terms of the character portrayal for Momma the book paints a completely different picture of momma than the way she is portrayed in the movie. In the book she is this bitter, unhappy person. But in the movie she is a more likeable character because the audience feels sympathetic towards her. Mostly because she is not that bitter unhappy person, the way she is portrayed in the book. In the movie the family moves the dinner table into the living room so that they can have dinner together, so this gives the audience they view that they are a "normal" family. In the book this does not happen. The last scene that the audience can tell a change in Momma is when she makes her way up the stairs. In the book Larry and Gilbert both have to help her up to her room, but in the movie she is driven to do this all by herself. Making her seem a lot stronger mentally and physically in the movie giving the audience another reason to feel her pain and be sympathetic towards Momma. There are big differences between the book and movie What's Eating Gilbert Grape, the book gives a bigger insight into what is going on inside Gilberts head. Giving the reader a view on his thoughts to go along with his actions, while the movie cannot do this it did a good job with the action it's the facial expressions that they have to work with since the movie can't give his thoughts. The movie and the book did good jobs telling the story but I do believe that, as in most cases the book was better than the movie.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Whats Eating Gilbert Grape

...English 101 Professor Ramshaw October 3, 2011 The Absence And The Crave That Eats Gilbert Grape Alive In the film What’s Eating Gilbert Grape, the main character Gilbert takes on the “Father Role” to support his family economically and financially. The fact Gilbert is the man of the house causes him to repress his anger. His sorrow begins to strengthen his rage in a very unhealthy manner. The melancholy that leads to Gilberts weakening has its roots in his family which is what begins to eat Gilbert alive. All his family members play important individual roles in finding out what’s eating Gilbert Grape. In the film, Amy, being the eldest sibling and daughter of the Grapes, plays the “Mother Role” having to take care of the household. “My older sister Amy is more like a mother”, explains Gilbert, making him portray the “Father Figure”; as he states, “My father built this house, and it’s my job to do the repairs.” Amy being the voice of reason tries her best to keep the family together, which causes Gilbert to repress his feelings the more Amy tells him “he has to do better”. In the scene when Gilbert leaves Arnie in the bathtub overnight, causes a fright to the family; which is when Amy begins to tell him, “You gotta do better” because without his help the family will fall apart quickly. This builds up Gilbert’s emotion because he knows just as Amy he has an important role in the family to fill in. Ellen, the youngest of the siblings, concentrates on appearances...

Words: 1294 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

What's Eating Gilbert Grape

...What’s Eating Gilbert Grape? Introduction Growing up is the process of maturing physically and emotionally. It helps develop a sense of individuality and identity. Lasse Hallstroms 1993 film ‘What’s Eating Gilbert Grape?’ shows the stages of growing up such as childhood, life experience, maturity and family and friends. Growing up is a significant part of our lives. Childhood Childhood is an important factor of growing up as children begin to develop their sense of identity. This occurs during the period of birth and puberty in a person’s life. Arnie Grape, from the film ‘What’s Eating Gilbert Grape?’ (1993), is the definition of childhood. He is turning 18 years old but has developmental disability where he is stuck in a childhood state forever. A high angle shot of Arnie when he climbs the water tower is used to show how he was unsafe and helpless. The reverse shot shown while he was climbing the tower highlights his innocence and child-like manner. The montage of Arnie at the beginning of the film shows snippets of Arnies behaviour and attitudes. This give the audience an insight and brief understanding of his everyday life. Repetition/motif of Arnie playing hide-n-seek in the tree shows that he still has the playfulness in him as he did at the beginning of the film. The personality of an individual emerges through the stages of childhood and continues to develop as they grow. Maturity Maturity is influenced by the different factors of growing up such as childhood...

Words: 905 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Arnie In What's Eating Gilbert Grape

...What’s eating Gilbert Grape is a novel written by Peter Hedges that was adapted to a motion picture in 1993. In the novel, Gilbert Grape is the fourth child of Bonnie Grape and Albert Grape. He is the story’s narrator. He takes the reader through the life of his family and that of the other people that are living in Enora, Iowa. The novel gives a description of the trouble that the family goes through including their father’s suicide. The story is touching on the struggles of the dysfunctional family. Arnie is a joyful and loving character; he is accurately and honestly portrayed particularly in scenes with high emotion. Arnie has classic autism which means that life is stressful for the family and not just for Arnie. He struggles to comprehend...

Words: 1401 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

What's Eating Gilbert Grape Analysis

...The movie ‘What’s Eating Gilbert Grape’ directed by Lasse Hallstrom is a fictional film, displaying the troubled life of a young man in the late 20th century. Gilbert Grape lives with his dysfunctional family in Endora, Iowa, who have created a series of challenges for Gilbert. Throughout the film, Gilbert finds it difficult to manage the problems he’s facing. He is expected to tend to his mentally challenged brother, carry out the mother’s duties, and support the family both financially and physically. These matters affect Gilbert’s decision making, self confidence and encourages a pessimistic view in life. Arnie is the main cause to the family’s burdens, and Gilbert is typically the one to solve them. Gilbert spends majority of his spare...

Words: 571 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Whats Eating Gilbert Grape Research Paper

...What’s Eating Gilbert Grape In the film What’s Eating Gilbert Grape, the main character Gilbert takes on the “Father Role” to support his family economically and financially. The fact Gilbert is the man of the house causes him to repress his anger. His sorrow begins to strengthen his rage in a very unhealthy manner. The melancholy that leads to Gilberts weakening has its roots in his family which is what begins to eat Gilbert alive. All his family members play important individual roles in finding out what’s eating Gilbert Grape. What's Eating Gilbert Grape is a beautifully shot movie of tenderness, caring and self-awareness that is set amongst the fictional working class one street town Endora. Centred around the Grape family Ellen and Amy and their two brothers Arnie and Gilbert, who, along with their morbidly obese widowed mother Bonnie Grape are striving to survive and coexist with the absence of a father figure, low wage work and seventeen-year-old Arnie's severe mental condition. It is in this awkward and extremely one sided affair that the unfortunate Gilbert has to constantly, while working for the town's slowly dying Convenience Store, take care of his younger brother Arnie. Gilbert's life, his future, is thwarted he knows this, but it is in this Guardian Angel that his love and bond for Arnie cannot, and will not, be let go. That is until the free spirit of Becky arrives in town, and with her grandmother are stranded for the ...

Words: 1800 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

What's Eating Gilbert Grape Life Stages

...What’s Eating Gilbert Grape: A Look at Various Life Stages Writer COUN5004- Survey of Research in Human Development for Professional Counselors Abstract The life stages for an individual changes as a person grows older and has various experiences in life. There is a change in the physical, intellectual, social, and emotional growth as an individual age. “The process of development is linked to internal conflicts, changing self-awareness, and a dynamic social environment” (Newman & Newman, 2012). Understanding the current stage, assist the counselor in therapeutically preparing for treatment. This paper will view the members of the Gilbert family including Gilbert, Arnie, and Bonnie Grape through various life stages from school age to middle adulthood. As the individual grows, the family dynamics are changing and will need to adjust to the current life stressors. A struggle that often presents through the various life stages is a need to further develop personal identify. This may not always be easily achieved if depression, caregiver stress, or mental illness hinders a person from achieving it. Title of Paper What’s Eating Gilbert Grape (1993) is the story of a family living in Endora, Iowa. The narrator, Gilbert Grape, describes the story of his family and the trials of the Grape family. The story centers on preparing for Arnie Grape, Gilbert’s youngest brother, 18th birthday party. The story follows as the family prepares for Arnie’s birthday while viewing the...

Words: 2378 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Whats Eating Gilbert Grape

...“What’s Eating Gilbert Grape” is a film of psychological troubles and difficulties for almost every main character. Gilbert Grape is a young man living in a small town with big responsibilities. His mother, who is too overweight to leave the house, and Arnie, his younger brother, is mentally impaired. Betty, Gilbert’s mistress, is in distress about her home and sexual life. Becky is the new girl with an adventurous mindset and the only kind of relief for Gilbert. Gilbert grape uses free recall of the sound of sirens throughout the movie. If Gilbert hears sirens and Arnie is not around, he rushed to the water house to find Arnie climbing it. He is extrovert and ignores his inner feelings until they build up and he snaps. Gilbert Grape can be disobedient and randomly leave the house and disappear for a while resembling his older brother, upsetting his mother. Gilbert creates a new phobia of water for his little brother Arnie after leaving him in the bathtub overnight. Arnie was freezing by morning and did not like to swim or bathe after the incident. Gilbert’s mother suffers from a long-term depression that leads to an eating disorder. Events placing her in this depression are her husband killing himself and her oldest son suddenly disappearing and never coming back. Ever since her husband died in the house he built himself, and which they live in, she has not left. She was attached to the house, especially the couch downstairs. She is not able or willing to go outside or even...

Words: 824 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

What's Eating Gilbert Grape Essay

...film “What’s Eating Gilbert Grape?” have characters that explains the situation of Gilbert throughout the film and it makes him realize what he can do outside the town. What is eating Gilbert is his family and the responsibilities that he has to do to support them, but later on with the help of Becky, Gilbert realizes that he can do more than just supporting his family, he can move on and be happy without worrying about his family members. In the beginning of the movie Gilbert and Arnie were waiting for the travelers to come across the road and they just were standing and watching them pass the...

Words: 824 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Leo Not Winning an Oscar

...was dating every supermodel in sight." Beer's statement proves that DiCaprio is out of control and that people are starting to notice his ridiculous behavior. The Academy pays attention to celebrities and their actions outside of filming. Many people assume that just because a person is acting like an animal, they won't get the opportunity to receive an Oscar. In DiCaprio's defense, I don't think his personal life should determine whether or not he wins an award. Dedication and hardwork should be what gets recognized, not the decisions an adult is making outside of his career. DiCaprio has taken on major roles throughout his twenty years of acting. At a young age, he was nominated for Best Supporting Actor in the film What's Eating Gilbert Grape, where he portrays an 18-year-old boy with a developmental disability. His most recent film, The Wolf Of Wall Street, earned him a nomination for an Oscar, but he lost to Matthew McConaughey. McConaughey starred in the film Dallas Buyers Club,...

Words: 778 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Compare And Contrast What's Eating Gilbert Grape

...The leading characters in “What’s eating Gilbert Grape?” and “I’m not Scared” each confront physical, mental and emotional obstacles which they usually deal with using similar strategies. Similarities can be drawn at certain points in the texts when Michele and Gilbert both attempt to outrun and completely ignore their dilemmas all together. Conflicting coping mechanisms are used to handle their sense of shame and disappointment they feel for their parent’s, highlighting major differences between the ages of the two main characters. In times of need the protagonist’s look up to their role models and idols for inspiration, Gilbert depends on Becky to reveal what it’s like to be free from responsibilities and Michele looks to the fictional hero, “Tiger Jack.” From these comparable techniques the protagonists are able to attain enough confidence and strength to face their hurdles head on....

Words: 680 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Business Analysis

...Table of Contents 1. Introduction 1 2. Wine Manufacturing Industry and External Environment 2 2.1 Wine Manufacturing Industry 2 2.2 External Environment 6 3. Porter’s 5 Forces Analysis 10 3.1 Threat of New Entrants 11 3.2 Bargaining Power of Buyers 12 3.3 Threat of Substitutes 14 3.4 Bargaining Power of Suppliers 16 3.5 Rivalry within the Competitive Arena 17 4. Conclusion 19 Reference 21 1. Introduction Captain Arthur Phillip brought grape vines from Brazil and the Cape of Good Hope to Australia when his fleet arrived in Botany Bay, located in Sydney, in 1788, according to Wine Australian which is one department of Australian government. Since that Australia had made a history of producing and exporting wine. In 1854, a barrel of fortified wine was exported to London, which is the first reported Australian wine export (Wine Australia, 2012). Subsequently, Australian exports in wine have boosted at an extraordinary rate especially in recent years, reaching the record level in 2007. Today, Wine Australian also point out that Australia is the fourth largest wine exporter in the world, constituting about 4% of total world wine production, and export over 800 million liters to international wine market and as a result, it produces a contribution of around A$3 billion per year to Australian economy. Australian wine exports to more than 100 countries; mainly two biggest markets are United Kingdom and United State. Besides, there are other significant markets...

Words: 5380 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Making Black Grape (Vitis Vinifera) as an Ink (Not a Real Investigatory Project! Only Made Up by an Amateur! This Is Only an Example! Hope That It Can Help You to Make an Ip! )

...Black Grape (Vitis vinifera) as an Ink Submitted by: Group 2 Submitted to: Teacher's name February 2014 Acknowledgement The researchers thank their parents and family members, for the unending love and support that they gave to them. The researchers thank their adviser, theacher's name, for teaching them the fundamental of research, investigatory writing and showing a great deal of patience through the times they tend to be naughty and having a lot of mistakes in doing their investigatory project. The researchers thank the panellist, for correcting their mistakes in this project. The researchers thank the observer/respondents, for their integrity and the cooperation. Above all, the researchers thank God for His gift of wisdom, for helping the researchers to understand the study topic and for answering their prayers in their times of need. Chapter I Introduction A. Background of the Study With a unique combination of crunchy texture and sweet, tart flavor, grapes have gained extreme popularity throughout the world. Grape is the second most popular fruit after oranges. It can be eaten as a refreshing snack as well as used in vegetable and fruit salads. It can be consumed in fresh or preserved form. It can be canned in jellies, crushed to prepare juices or wines and dried to prepare raisins. Grapes were introduced to America by the Spanish explorers approximately 300 years ago. There are more than 60 species and 8000 varieties of grapes all over...

Words: 2295 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Fruit of the Loom

...Fruit of the Loom Crystal Hendren Professor Gregorio Business Law I August 24, 2012 Fruit of the Loom headquarters are in Bowling Green Kentucky. It was founded in 1851. It is owned by Berkshire Hathaway. The company is one of the largest manufacturers it markets men’s, boy’s, women’s, and girls underwear. They also do T-shirts and fleece, casual wear, and women’s jeans wear. Fruit of the Loom emploees more than 32,000 people world wide. There logo is an apple, leaves, green grapes, currants, and purple grapes. The first thing that I will talk about is what they are planning to do in the next 5 years. The second thing is the upcoming initiative(s) and what the impact of those laws will be. The third thing is the applicable sales, licensing, and e-Commerce laws and what the company will need to take into consideration during their initiative(s). The fourth and final thing will be the recommendations for the company to minimize the threat of lawsuits relating to privacy protection. The product liability, or intellectual property rights. The first thing is they are going to reduce carbon emissions, such as reducing packaging, recycling and reducing transport distances. The second one is that they are going to start making kids clothes. The third one is that they are going to have more people working for them. The fourth thing is that they are going to try to get people to buy more of there stock so that they can do better. The fifth and final one is that they are going to...

Words: 960 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Factors Explaining Nature, Spatical Patterns and Future Directions of a Winery

...temperature for growing grapes depends on the type of grape. For growing white grapes, ideally the temperature should be 19°C and for red grapes, 21°C. Reaching this ideal temperature is important because it is how the vine produces the sugar needed for plant growth, which influences the colour and flavour of the grape. The scientific reason for this temperature requirement is due to the enzymes involved in sugar production, and the ideal working temperature for these enzymes. Insolation refers to the level of solar radiation; this has an impact on the rate of photosynthesis and therefore affects the amount of plant growth. For this reason there is a certain longitude where grapes grow best. Aspect affects the amount of sunlight received on the vineyard. In the southern hemisphere north and west facing slopes are ideal as they receive more sunlight. Excessive wind results in grapes being damaged and vines become stressed, if there are strong winds it can break off shoots and cause damage which results poor growth and decreasing levels of photosynthesis. Vines generally require approximately 700mm of rainfall per year, if the natural rainfall falls below this irrigation and other technologies are used to supplement the natural rainfall, for this reason a reliable source of water is needed, such as the Hawkesbury River in the case of Tizzana. Heavy rainfall damages the grapes and increases humidity and disease, for this reason it is important to grow grapes only in areas where the...

Words: 1662 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Grapes so Magical

...Grapes can not spit grape skin, grape because the body is a treasure! Will be eaten with the grape skins and grape seeds, is particularly useful for those with ischemic heart disease and atherosclerotic heart disease health. The grape skin color is more black, the more containing flavonoids, better protect the heart rats. Grape Vitaceae Vitis woody vine, fruit spherical or oval-shaped, flowering from April to May, fruiting period from August to September. Grapes are one of the world's oldest fruit trees, grape plant fossils found in Tertiary strata, indicating that they have been found in Europe, Asia and Greenland. WEST grapes native to Asia, all over the world are cultivated grapes from around the world about 95% concentrated in the northern hemisphere. Grape glucose, organic acids, amino acids, vitamins on the brain excitatory effects, eat neurasthenia and fatigue were also beneficial. Long-term smokers may be more grapes, grapes can help lung cell detoxification, but also has expectorant effect, can ease the smoking-induced airway inflammation, itching and other symptoms. Grape juice and frail patients, hardening of the arteries and the rehabilitation of nephritis patients have secondary effects. Can help reduce organ rejection in patients implanted surgical promote a speedy recovery. Keep fit people should be aware that the grapes are not easy to get fat eating fruit. Women have to eat a dozen pieces rich in vitamin fresh black grapes or green grapes, can achieve the purpose...

Words: 401 - Pages: 2