Free Essay

Global Labour Fairness

In:

Submitted By emmanioashley
Words 1455
Pages 6
Essay based on the issue of sweatshop labour conditions in the global supply factory system.

It is no secret that millions, if not billions of people around the world suffer dangerous and abusive work conditions in the global supply factory system. Since the emergence of the global economy, multi national corporations have been able to reap in large profits while keeping their prices low for consumers, in part, by taking advantage of cheap outsourced labour. The dark side of the global market is the severe exploitation of sweatshop labour conditions such as, child labour, poor health and safety standards, indentured servitude, sexual harassment and abuse, excessive overtime and under compensation. National and International labour standards do exist, the problem is that many countries where global supplier factories are located are either unable or unwilling to enforce labour laws for one reason or another. Thus, because governments in certain countries around the world do not enforce decent labour standards, multi nationals have been able to take advantage of cheap labour without many repercussions. Corporate citizenship or social responsibility has become a very important business practice for many companies. Civil society groups and consumers are now becoming much more adamant on the issue of corporate social responsibility and global fair labour.

Multi national corporations, in the past, have been focused only on one objective, profit. With the increased pressure from consumers for business transactions to be more transparent, many companies have been forced to become more corporately responsible with their business practices. Many companies around the world have tried to become socially responsible; they have implemented detailed codes of conduct and factory on-site monitoring as well as factory system auditing which includes a health management and safety audit programme. One such business is Nike, who, after their sweatshop scandal came to light, noticed a detrimental decrease in their sales around the world, as well as a big hit to their reputation. Nike has developed a system of comprehensive monitoring and remediation. This includes a health management and safety audit programme and a significant global labour practice team that visits factories on an everyday basis and conducts training and awareness initiatives.

In response to the efforts of many companies around the world to implement these techniques, there are still some major issues. Factories, particularly in China, have simply developed more sophisticated methods of concealing labour code violations. Factories have reacted to company codes of conduct and internal compliance monitoring by adopting new approaches of deception. In many cases, companies are unaware or wilfully ignorant to the amount and scale of abuses. The reality is that multi national corporations are not designed to nor equipped to function as enforcement agencies.

Civil society organisations also known as non-governmental organisations are critical actors in the advancement of universal values around human rights, the environment, labour standards and anti-corruption. As global market integration has advanced, their role has gained particular importance in aligning economic activities with social and environmental priorities. Over the past century, there has been a rapid increase in civil society groups globally. They are forming strong organisations that put pressure on many issues regarding global labour and the importance of fairness. They are a precious resource for many multinational corporations because they can provide independent social audits, founded upon expert knowledge of labour issues, including local, national and international labour laws. There are many non-government organisations that have started up global programmes to combat human rights abuses and other pressing issues. One such NGO is the international programme on the elimination of child labour. In the programme to eliminate child labour in the brick sector in Huachipa, near Lima, IPEC is working with other NGOs including AIDECA, which has experience in the field of development, focusing on social and technological issues and forging strong public-private alliances, to provide a new economic model for families making bricks. AIDECA has developed a plan for a new kind of kiln and production system that combines efficiency with ease of operation, low maintenance costs and low energy consumption. A new community NGO has been established, managed by the beneficiaries, for community governance and management of a "Social Development Brick Factory," for families whose children are not allowed to work. Fifty per cent of profits are reinvested and the other half goes to social and educational projects. AIDECA has established programmes in governance and decision making to raise beneficiaries' capacity to run the brickworks. Other NGOs are also involved in education and monitoring of school attendance.

There is a need for governments to come back into the picture because self-implemented codes, while attractive to multinationals, are ineffective for that same reason- they are self-implemented rather than government enforced. Although transforming the codes into binding law is not politically possible at present, government involvement is the only way that a voluntary code of conduct will survive and be effective. Government involvement can include, being active and promoting better corporate conduct, and encouraging partnerships among multinationals and civil society groups. The problem is that governments are not able to legislate labour markets because globalisation is outstripping the power of governments. This is because private actors are assuming state functions. They are moving this way because consumers are pushing them. The most powerful force is when consumers demand social responsibility from corporations around the world.

Civil society groups, businesses and governments all have distinctive resources and competencies as well as weaknesses. For example, businesses have access to capital, specialized technical knowledge, networks of commercial relationships and the management skills to get projects completed on time and on a budget. On the other hand, businesses tend to disregard the impacts of their actions, especially in the long term. Government agencies have knowledge of public policy, an ability to enforce rules, and revenue from taxation, but are often inflexible, slow to mobilize and poorly coordinated. NGOs often enjoy strong community knowledge, volunteer assets, and inspirational leaders, but many lack financial resources and technical skill, and many suffer from a narrow, parochial focus. Many businesses have realized that these differences across sectors can be a resource to be exploited. In this view alliances among organisations from the three sectors, collaborative partnerships, can draw on the unique capabilities of each and overcome particular weaknesses that each has.

The Fair Labour Association partners with international unions and other civil society organisations around the world to address complex labour issues. When workers are at risk, local organisations are poised to act swiftly and have the necessary relationships with key players in the region who need to be involved in finding solutions. The FLA creates a safe space for civil society groups, universities, and multinational corporations to come together and find solutions for pressing labour issues. The FLA is just one of the programmes out there that incorporates multinationals, NGOs and government agencies to finding solutions for global labor and other pressing issues.

Civil society groups are a precious resource for multi national corporations because they can provide independent social audits, founded upon expert knowledge of labour issues, including local, national and international labour laws, and can also serve to hold companies accountable to their own professed principles of corporate citizenship. Involving non-governmental organisations encourages more harmonized workplace standards, such as uniform code of conduct, which may be implemented to streamline the monitoring process and increase effectiveness and efficiency. One of the most powerful vehicles we have for insuring the implementation for labour standards in global supply chains is the multi national corporation, and we can avoid the danger of privatizing labour law enforcement by ensuring that those enterprises act in partnership with public and other private stakeholders in a transparent way to improve the conditions in the factories where goods are made.

Civil society groups are a precious resource for multi national corporations because they can provide independent social audits, founded upon expert knowledge of labour issues, including local, national and international labour laws, and can also serve to hold companies accountable to their own professed principles of corporate citizenship. Involving non-governmental organisations encourages more harmonized workplace standards, such as uniform code of conduct, which may be implemented to streamline the monitoring process and increase effectiveness and efficiency. One of the most powerful vehicles we have for insuring the implementation for labour standards in global supply chains is the multi national corporation, and we can avoid the danger of privatizing labour law enforcement by ensuring that those enterprises act in partnership with public and other private stakeholders in a transparent way to improve the conditions in the factories where goods are made.

A possible solution to the issue of factory deception is for companies to respond by seeking collaborative partnerships with outside organisations.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

International Business

...Ethical Issues in Global Supply Chains Bodo B. Schlegelmilch ∗ , Magdalena Öberseder ∗∗ Abstract Despite all technological advances, global supply chains are always based on the interaction of people. And wherever people interact, a kaleidoscope of ethical issues emerges. While consumer demands and concerns have undoubtedly led to an increased awareness of unethical conduct in the supply chain, contravening forces, such as the relentless pressures for low cost products and the ease by which consumers are purchasing non-deceptive counterfeits, should also not be ignored. Many retailers are now embracing ethical issues by emphasising, for example, that they take care of the production methods and working conditions pertaining to the goods they offer. Keywords: Global Supply Chains; Ethics; Fairness; Global Markets 1. Introduction 1. Introduction Despite all technological advances, global supply chains are always based on the interaction of people. And wherever people interact, a kaleidoscope of ethical issues emerges. Starting at the origins of the supply chain, the plight of individual farmers, minors or production workers is frequently examined in terms of working conditions or fair wages (Cotton et al., 2005; Locke and Romis, 2007). Other concerns pertain to the production itself. Issues like ecological soundness and infringement of intellectual property rights are frequently debated. Recently, the ethics of shifting production...

Words: 1291 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Australia's Declining Productivity

... 3.3 Policy Effectiveness 9 4.0 Conclusion 10 5.0 Reference List 11 1.0 Introduction Driven by its dependence on natural resources, Australia’s economy has performed well in the aftermath of the 2007-08 Global Financial Crisis. The relative ease at how Australia has fared post crisis has disguised a worrying trend, a lagging productivity growth. Commissioned by the House of Representatives Economics Committee this report will cover Australia’s productivity performance between 2008 and 2014, gaining a greater understanding of the factors behind Australia’s declining productivity performance. This report will cover productivity growth before and after the GFC, critical analysis of policies aimed at addressing lagging productivity and the effect of these policies on the recovery from the GFC. ‘Productivity is a measure of how efficiently an economy is operating…Australia’s future productivity performance will affect its rate of recovery from the current global financial crisis as well as its future prosperity and capacity to address the longer-term challenges of population ageing and climate change”(Productivity Commission, 2009). The Productivity Commission (2009) define two main measure of productivity, labour productivity and multifactor productivity. Labour productivity is the real GDP per hour worked. Multifactor productivity...

Words: 2376 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Notes

...distance: Extent to which society members accept an unequal distribution of power. * Uncertainty avoidance: Extent to which people are uncomfortable with uncertain and ambiguous situations. * Masculinity/Femininity: More masculine cultures clearly differentiate gender roles. Support dominance of men. * Individualism vs Collectivism: Individualistic societies stress independence, individual initiative, & privacy. Collective cultures favor interdependence and loyalty to family. * Understanding cultural value differences can enable organizations to successfully import management practices by tailoring the practice to the home culture’s concern. * Appreciating global customers > essential to understanding needs and tastes of consumers around the world * Developing global employees > develop employees to have a much better appreciation of differences in cultural values and the implications of these differences for behavior in organizations. * Attitude is an evaluative tendency to respond consistently to some specific object, situation, person or group of people. * Attitudes often influence our behavior towards some object, situation, person or group. Function of what we think and feel * Belief + Value > Attitude > Behaviour * Persuasion designed to modify or emphasize values is usually emotionally oriented. * Job satisfaction...

Words: 603 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Fair Trade

...Source: DE ECONOMIST 150, NO. 3, 2002 HOW FAIR IS FAIR TRADE? ** BY ROBBERT MASELAND AND ALBERT DE VAAL* Summary This paper investigates to what extent fair trade programmes, are indeed ‘fair.’ This is accomplished by comparing fair trade with free trade and protectionist trade regimes on their compliance of the criteria set by the fair trade movement itself. This comparison is made using comparative cost based models and economies of scale models. It is found that whether or not fair trade is superior to free trade or protectionism is highly dependent on a number of characteristics of the products to which fair trade is applied as well as on the context within which international trade takes place. 1 INTRODUCTION A long-standing debate in development economics has been the one between advocates of free trade and proponents of protectionism in developing countries. While the former argued that free trade would offer large opportunities for poor countries to improve their situation, the latter considered trade to be harmful to poorer countries and typically preferred a combination of protectionism and development aid. This opposition tended to dominate the discussion about the role of international trade in the Third World. Bhagwati 1993 , Krueger 1990 However, in recent years, a third position has come up. This position maintains that international trade can be beneficial to developing countries as long as it is performed in a just manner. The idea behind this is that...

Words: 10145 - Pages: 41

Premium Essay

Resolving Industrial Conflicts

...Table of Contents Resolution of Industrial Conflict/Conciliation and Arbitration ............................................... 2 Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 2 The nature of conciliation and arbitration and mediation ........................................................... 2 The grievance machinery ............................................................................................................ 4 The Labour Relations Code & The Industrial Disputes Tribunal (IDT) ..................................... 5 Litigation ..................................................................................................................................... 6 Module 8 ........................................................................................................................................ 8 Industrial Relations and the Future ............................................................................................ 8 Globalization - competition and industrial relations ................................................................... 8 The 21st century and trade unions............................................................................................... 8 Pay and working conditions ........................................................................................................ 9 Time flexibility.................................

Words: 2770 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Staff Management and Care

...equipped to deliver outstanding customer service, McDonald’s consider people as their most important asset. providing training and career opportunities that allow our crew and managers to grow personally and professionally. McDonald’s aims to create opportunity by providing lifelong skills and career opportunities for their global workforce. It supports diversity and inclusion by building a working environment that appraises the unique contributions of all. * McDonalds conducts its entire activities in a manner that respects human rights, treats every employees with fairness, respect and dignity, ensures the employees are in such workplace that is free from harassment, intimidation or abuse, sexual or otherwise, or acts or threats of physical violence, embraces the diversity of employees , employees, Franchisees, customers and suppliers and provides equal treatment and equal employment opportunity  * These development opportunities for employees include second language instruction, organization skills, customer service acumen, literacy and math skills and accelerated degree completion through accreditation and financial support. McDonald’s Global Women’s Initiative supports the recruitment, development, retention and advancement of women at all levels of the Company, while creating a culture where women can thrive in their careers. Employees also complete regular training on the Standards, anti-bribery laws, and various other laws, regulations and company-specific policies...

Words: 526 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Social Justice System

...on the desire of such society an economic society can promote individual freedom, individual accumulation of wealth or promote fairness through distributive justice. The aim of this essay is to find a model that not only creates financial freedom for the entire New Zealand population, but also promote fairness and equality through a social justice system. The New Zealand economic system is predominately a free market system. Free market systems inherently promote competition and drives efficiency. Free market systems work very well under a microeconomic model with small businesses owned by one or view individuals that drive efficiency with a high level of competition (Layton, 2009). Unfortunately it does not always promote fairness especially when companies become larger and the competition is reduced to only a few in the market (competing against each other). New Zealand markets are mainly driven by producing commodity-base products which are in high demand in the rest of the world (Treasury, 2010). This in turn creates a demand for labour, with workers offering their time and energy paid in wages. This wage system makes the worker dependent on his employer, to build his or her own wealth. This creates a shift in a society where the individual loses the financial freedom insofar as his only way of creating wealth is through his wage. In such a labour driven economy the worker may be paid well, but in the end he simply becomes a wage slave (Jimenez, 2010). Within the New Zealand...

Words: 2492 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Freek

...net/mayank210/vodafone-hr-practices-a-study Employee engagement (Open and regular communication is fundamental -> ‘Intranet’) Employee consultation (Consult to their employees directly, which is preferred over trade unions) Vodafone European Employee Consulvative Council (EECC), meets once a year Managing organizational change (Committed to treating employees fairly and with respect during periods of organizational change, by communicating changes clearly) Development and training (Development and training programmes, annual analysis of learning needs accros the business) Diversity and inclusion (Inclusive leadership, Valuing diversity, Individual responsibility) Reward and Recognition (Competitive and fair rates of pay and benefits, global short- and long-term incentive plans reward employees base on their performance, potential and contribution) Employee wellbeing (‘Group Health, Safety...

Words: 661 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

P1 Ethics

...products that Nestle sell are baby food, breakfast cereals, coffee and tea, ice cream, frozen food, snacks, pet foods, dairy product and bottled water but only 22% of sales are generated by selling hot drinks such as tea, coffee and etc. Nestlé have 29 brands which had an annual sale of CHF 1 Billion (about US1.1 billion) Example of them brands that Nestle specialises in is Nespresso, Kit Kat and Nesquik. Nestle have about 447 factories which are operating in 194 countries mainly in Americas (25% US) which means they are a global organisation. They are known to be a large organisation because they currently have 330,000 employees at Nestle. They are also the main shareholders of L’Oreal, the world’s largest cosmetics company. The annual turnover of Nestle is $92.6 billion and each year they make a profit of 10.02 billion. The founders of Nestle are Henri Nestlé, Charles Page, George Page and it was founded in 1866. Nestlé was registered No. 1 in the Fortune Global 500 in 2011 which meant they were the most profitable company in the world. Nestle main competitors at the moment are PepsiCo, Kraft Foods, Unilever and Mars Incorporated. Nestlé’s Corporate Governance statement is “We are committed to making a positive contribution to the communities in which we operate. We believe a healthy community life is vital to the long-term stability of our society and economy”. As we can see Nestle main aim is to make a positive contribution to the community and to maintain a long term stability...

Words: 1479 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Pepsi Co Swot

...Internet promotion and ordering processes • Broadening of product base • International expansion • Growing savoury snack and bottled water market in US Threats • Tough rivalry from competitors • Rising costs in raw materials and travel expenses • Substitutes (decline in carbonated drink sales) • Potential negative impact of government regulations • Potential disruption due to labour unrest PESTLE Analysis Political • Raw material prices becoming worrying • Land acquisition for new factories • Government focusing on stricter water pollution norms • Supposed to maintain firm standard laws set by the FDA • Competitive pricing Economic • New opportunities in other countries • Fuel price • Availability of labour • Economic downturn Social • Replenishing water • Partnership with farmers • Solid waste management program • Impact on youngsters • Different cultures • Communicate as a global brand Technological • Operates in almost all countries • Newer and more attractive designs • Newer and better manufacture • Social media Legal • Cross border policies • Standards and regulations • Health and safety...

Words: 428 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Business

...forms of discrimination and recent requirements on data protection and human rights. The role of recruitment in managing diversity is considered. Recruitment is seen as an attraction process subject to variations in labour market conditions and variation of interests. The importance of a strategic view is considered to align performance requirement with roles specified in terms of skills and attitudes – often expressed as competences. e-Recruitment is also considered. Coverage of various selection methods is provided, based on a consideration of reliablity and validity issues. Chapter objectives After studying this chapter, you should be able to: □ Understand the place of recruitment and selection as a stage in the formation of the employment relationship. □ Understand the key legal requirements relating to recruitment and selection □ Explain the nature of attraction in recruitment □ Explain the effectiveness of the selection interview □ Understand the value of psychometric testing CHAPTER OUTLINE Introduction Recruitment followed by selection are vital stages in the formation of the expectations that form the psychological contract between employer and employees. There are power considerations to bear in mind based on labour...

Words: 1952 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

A Competitor Firm Has Outsourced Its Production Abroad. You Could Do the Same. You Are the Major Employer in the Town Where You Are Located. You Have to Decide Whether Also to Outsource Your Production

...Our company has a strong ethical and moral feel and image due to a strong involvement in charity fund raising and organising events for under privileged children to get involved in sports and activities they wouldn’t usually have the opportunity to do. We are seen locally as an incremental part of the local infrastructure and through feedback sheets its apparent that on the whole our employees are happy and our staff turnover and productivity reflects this. The main issue we have recently encountered is that in October 2011 the minimum wage went up 15p to £6.08 an hour therefore increasing the cost of labour and due to the rise in oil prices to £61 has increased the cost of production due to 80% of our clothing being made for gore-tex and other heat insulating plastic based materials. In a move to decrease labour costs our main competitor has decided to outsource its labour to Taiwan. This has created a major issue for us as a company as it creates the problem that if we cannot stay competitive we could get pushed out of the market....

Words: 2065 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Analyze Marshall’s Conceptualization of Citizenship and Its Relevance to Social Planning

...Analyze Marshall’s conceptualization of citizenship and its relevance to social planning The focus of this paper is to critically examine the content of contemporary understandings of Marshall `s conceptualization of citizenship and its relevance to social policy. The main agenda of the paper is to realize a theoretically informed definition of citizenship advanced by Marshall and concentrate mainly on the rights and obligations of citizenship; but also address the increasingly multi-tiered nature of the framing of membership, both in national and supra-national contexts, as well as the emergence of new citizenship claims and claims making. Lake (1994) holds that citizenship is defined by the sociologist guru Marshall as a “status, given to all full members of a community.” The status establishes the rights and duties of the individual in the society to achieve equality for all citizens. Marshall`s contribution shaped the policy in politics, health, education and rights of women in society. According to Marshall (1950) there are three elements of citizenship rights namely civil, political and social which will be analyzed in this essay and their relevance to social planning will be evaluated. Marshall spoke of the development of civil, political, and social citizenship as an evolutionary sequence. The rights embodied in the first pointed to those of the second, and the second to the third. Each, in succession, was secured over the three centuries following the 1688 Revolution...

Words: 1529 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Labour Relations

...MANAGEMENT ADVANCEMENT PROGRAMME 120 LABOUR RELATIONS INDIVIDUAL ASSIGNMENT Facilitator : Mrs Vanessa Botha Student Name : Carine Sanama Student Number: 1311024 Date : Monday 29 June 2015 Words Count: 1189 Table of Contents i. Executive Summary ii. Introduction and Background iii. Literature Review a. Definition of Terms b. The Evolution of the South African Labour Relations : Pre and Post-Apartheid c. The right to strike in South Africa : Legal VS Illegal iv. Discussions v. Conclusion vi. References Appendix 1 I. Executive Summary The rising number of labor strikes in South Africa should be a wake-up call the government. They should take the following into consideration so the improve on the country socio-economic state: First, look at labor markets with a renewed interest to revise laws governing the role and powers accorded to collective bargaining unions with a view to streamline them. Second, revise minimum wages, wage increases and dispute resolution policies in line with the latest economic developments in the country and international standards to ensure fairness and equity. Third, ensure that negotiations involving unions that represent essential emergency professionals do not break down and go to strike since people’s lives could be at stake. Finally, deliberately incorporate wage increase policies in the national budgeting process. These reforms would go a long way in minimizing the growing number of strikes...

Words: 1508 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Case Study

...child slavery. The foremost struggle with Utilitarianism is that it is not capable to deal with rights and justice. For example, from the point of social justice, it is clear that child slavery is the result of unequal distribution of burdens. Utilitarianism only looks at the utility, not the distribution of it among the members of society. The important ignorance on ethics in Utilitarianism, bring the consideration of justice and rights. Justice looks at how the benefits and burdens distributed among the society. On the other hand, rights look at the individual entitlements to freedom of choice and well-being. From the rights point of view, there are no clues about the legal rights of the children. I do not think that government has labour or child labour rights. Also, poor children deprived of the moral rights. They tortured, they are beaten and sometimes they even die or killed on the cocoa farms of the Ivory Coast and Ghana. Regardless of the legal system under which they live, every human being of every nationality have a right to not tortured, have a right to life. In terms of contractual rights, U.S. Senator Tom Harkin, U.S. Representative Eliot Engel, the members of the Chocolate Manufacturers...

Words: 1127 - Pages: 5