Free Essay

Group vs. Individual Working

In: Business and Management

Submitted By vrivera80
Words 899
Pages 4
Paper # 3 Groups

When considering how to handle topics or problems, it is important to understand that there are different ways of reaching the end result and both must be evaluated equally. What are the benefits and shortfalls of working on it alone versus working on the situation with a group? After asking this question, it is important to take into consideration the time restrictions, the difficulty of the problem or issue, as well as the impacts of the result. Groups have both potential limitations as well as strengths. Objectives can vary drastically and those you are in a group with can quickly impact the group as a whole. To look at the potential limitations of a group, "there are two significant disadvantages of group discussions and it includes the time it takes for the group process as well as the potential of conformity pressures to interfere with high quality decision making." Operating in a solo manner can allow for thinking through ideas efficiently, where with a group each person is allowed to speak and others to respond. (page 235 Comm. 203 Wood) When you understand that each individual with get the opportunity to voice their thoughts, it is important to remember that some group members may have more to say than another individual. This may show that some group members are suppressing their thoughts or that the stronger opinions, may encourage conformity. This certainly would not be beneficial to the group and would not fall into the category of strength in the group. When I take into consideration two different groups, there were different issues within the groups but ultimately, neither benefitted greatly from being in a group setting. The first was in a work setting, where there were several different levels of personnel involved. It appeared that the less tenured individuals (though coming to the table with a fresh perspective) were intimidated by the different levels of management and, in turn, did not speak up frequently. Most could have their thoughts read when they disagreed, but unsuccessfully could convey a clear message. From this, several great ideas were not considered. There was also a lack of consistency in the upper level management or staff's presence in the meetings, so when it came to making the final decision, many things had to be repeated to ensure the vote (on that day) was appearing fair. Then, I consider being on a fundraising team for the local youth football squad. It was apparent that there was not a specific deadline put on the decision making process, nor was there a purpose outlined up front. There were several parents researching different ways of raising money, but an overall lack of organization within the fundraising team. There was a few egocentric parents (group members) that openly were out for self, instead of the team as a whole. In both of these specific groups, there was not a strong benefit of being in a group. Groups require structure, ground rules set and a deadline for results. Groups can also have great strength, if the group utilizes each individual's strength's and capitalizes on the use of several minds saving time. The book states (page 236 - 237 Comm. 203 Wood) "the primary potential strengths of groups in comparison to individuals are great resources, more through thought. A group obviously exceeds any individual in the ideas, perspectives, experiences and expertise it can bring to solving a problem. Groups can also be considered more thorough than individuals. A group can produce what many identify as synergy, which is a special kind of collaborative vitality that enhances the efforts, talents, and strengths of individual members." One very important group, that works best in this setting, rather than attempting this organization alone, is my PTA group. In this group, our main objective is to plan evening events that are both fun for the children but also with little to no cost for the parents. The purpose is togetherness with the parents, teachers and children, three different times within a calendar year. The group has a set budget provided by the PTA members and a specific date for each event. Our mission is to have a successful event and make the event worth it. I am the chair of the event, thus I have to schedule planning meetings and account for the budget. There is a total of 4 members in this group and each is very cooperative and task driven. Each individual, including myself has strength and a varying amount of time or financial responsibility. There is a very creative parent, who brings a unique addition to the decor, while maintaining the budget. There is another parent that has strengthens with written communications. This parent handles all the flyers, notes and tracking of expenses. Additionally, there is a teacher, that assist with getting volunteers for the activities and this is essential to any successful event.. She has likely encountered the parents; therefore her relationship has already been established with them. Each of these unique strengths brings a certain synergy to the group and it is clearly shown in the events outcome and attendance each year. As clearly seen with this example, there are benefits to groups, specifically small groups. Not every group is best, but there are certainly pros and cons, depending on the situations/members.
Work Cited
Understanding Human Communication 2010, Wood, page 235-237

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Polarities

...successful polarity management strategies maintain a stronger bottom line. (Johnson, PG 5). The Polarity Map In today’s business environment an ongoing polarity stems from the push toward a team environment. The marketplace stimulation has surfaced the polarity of Individual vs. Team in a hands on manor to help educate us on polarity management. Below is a polarity map that shows the strengths and weaknesses of Pegas They dynamic of the polarity for individual vs. team is one many companies face every day. In many cases a team environment can help produce better results. Teams have the ability to utilize the strengths of each individual member in order to develop the best possible strategy. The Pegasus team has had the fortunate strength of having 1 team member from the background of each of the areas of importance. By dividing up the responsibilities and giving feedback on decisions we each are able to learn from one another while offering insight into our area of specialty. On the other hand working on the simulation individually provides the experience of studying areas you may not otherwise have the experience doing. Additionally with the time constraints most business professionals have these days working individually...

Words: 799 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Culture

...Culture is one of the basic things in life. Whether when we are working, dealing with people, spending time with family or even doing our daily routine. Culture is learned since we were born, no matter we as human realized the differences or not. Culture is the full range of learned behaviour patterns that are acquired by people as members of a society like in a family.  A culture is a complex, interrelated with anything that consists of the knowledge, belief, art, law, morals, customs, skills, and habits learned from parents and others in a society.  Culture is the basis of transparent material of adaptation for humans. The word culture itself comes from the Latin term pronounce as cultura, which is related to cult or worship. In general, the term refers to the feedback of human interaction. Culture is knowledge that acquired that people use to interpret experience and generate social behaviour. This knowledge forms values, creates attitudes, and influences behaviour. Somehow, culture also has the characteristics of being learned, shared, trans-generational, symbolic, patterned, and adaptive. There are also many dimensions of cultural diversity, which is focus on centralized vs. decentralized decision making, safety vs. risk, individual vs. group rewards, informal vs. formal procedures, high vs. low organizational loyalty, cooperation vs. competition, short-term vs. long-term horizons, and stability vs. innovation area in this assignment. This assignment will...

Words: 2242 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Energy Crises

...------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- Group Studies Vs Individual Studies Submitted To Sir. Syed Hassan Naqvi Submitted from Abdul Majeed MBA3Y02111014 University of Lahore LBS Lahore Business School Contents Chapter 1 3 Introduction 3 Objective: 3 Research questions 3 Hypothesis 3 Null Hypothesis 3 Chapter 2 4 Literature 4 Chapter 3 5 Methodology 5 Chapter 4 6 Strategies for data analysis 6 Chapter 5 7 Findings and Conclusion 7 Bibliography 8 Chapter 1 Introduction Most successful careers involve team work. Study groups can help you in classes with huge reading lists, multiple writing assignments, lots of course specific jargon, and long problem sets. It’s helpful to recognize that everyone brings value to a group and to be aware of making assumptions or judgments. Studying in groups…refreshes my memory on course material, makes aware of information missed during class or didn’t quite understand, and gives new ideas and perspectives on class topics. On the other hand, Most of the students choose to enroll in independent study because they have educational needs and interests not covered by the standard curriculum. Others may only need an additional credit or two to fulfill a requirement, and it's more economical to choose an independent course with variable credit hours than to enroll in an elective course costing twice as much. In some fields...

Words: 704 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Benefits and Challanges of Multicultural Teams

...Introduction "Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships."  -Michael Jordan When talking about accomplishing success in any type of organization, we must mind the essential role of team working. A team that provides high performance is one of the most important assets for a company. But even if an organization has the best talents in its field, it is not enough unless their aptitudes are incorporated into collectively performing unit. Turning an average performing into high performing team can be done by utilizing the strengths of each team member and the cultural diversity of the entire group. In the contemporary world we live, it is very common to work in multicultural teams. These teams are perceived as highly potential based on the perception that the greater the diversity, the greater the creativity and productivity of a team is. Yet, there are certain challenges that international teams encounter and that is why it is of great importance to be aware of the cultural diversity around the globe. Despite of how influential is our own culture on our beliefs and behaviours we must be aware that we are not coming from the one and only “valuable” culture in the world. People often tend to believe that their own values and beliefs are the only “right” ones as they are embedded in their particular cultures. We must be aware that each of us, each singular culture might shine in a different way, but that does not mean someone...

Words: 2059 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Cooperate Culture

...NO:____________________________________________________ PROGRAMME: Edexcel BTEC Level 7 Professional Diploma in Strategic Management and Leadership UNIT NO/TITLE: Unit 04 / Developing Corporate Culture ASSIGNMENT NO: Individual Report Credit Value: 05 Learning Outcomes: 1.0 Understand how the characteristics of corporate culture affect the achievement of organizational objectives 2.0 Be able to propose organizational values that will influence corporate climate 3.0 Be able to develop strategies to communicate with stakeholders of an organisation who belong to different cultural groups Issue Date: December 6th 2013 Due Date: January 5th 2014 Submission Date: Assessor’s Name: PROGRAMME: Edexcel BTEC Level 7 Professional Diploma in Strategic Management and Leadership UNIT NO/TITLE: Unit 04 / Developing Corporate Culture ASSIGNMENT NO: Individual Report Credit Value: 05 Learning Outcomes: 4.0 Understand how the characteristics of corporate culture affect the achievement of organizational objectives 5.0 Be able to propose organizational values that will influence corporate climate 6.0 Be able to develop strategies to communicate with stakeholders of an organisation who belong to different cultural groups Issue Date: December 6th 2013 Due Date: January 5th 2014 Submission Date: Assessor’s Name: Assessor Comments: Assessor: Signature: Date: ____/____/______ Assessor Comments: Assessor:...

Words: 4342 - Pages: 18

Free Essay

Budget Restriction

...Budget Restriction In the given scenario, based on the new budget restriction that requires a budget cut of $70,000, I believe that the best option would be to lay off personnel and cut personnel working hours. To solve this problem, I believe the initial step would be to inform the workers of the budget restrictions. I would have a detailed discussion with the employees about the options that I have to solve the problem. I believe it is important to temporarily reduce the population we serve until we can obtain grants for hiring more staffs. The solution to this situation would be to give employee #1 the option to do early retirement or to be laid off. With laying off employee #1 or giving her the option of early retirement, the company would save a total of $65,000. Even though employee # 1 has great experience, and works as a RN, employee # 2 who is an RN and dietician could fill that position. She will be promoted to salary employee and will obtain a $4807.36 increased. The other option would be to decrease the working hours for employee # 3 and employee # 5. Employee # 3 current salary is 26,000; this means that employee # 3 currently works $13.54 per hour. If I cut employee #3 working hours by 8 hours, I would save $5199.36 per year. If I cut employee # 5 working hours by 8 hours I would save $4608 for the year. With laying off Employee # 1, and reducing the work hours for employee # 3 and employee # 5 I would save a total of $74, 807.36. I choose to cut employee...

Words: 449 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Jive Sofware

...Jive Software Case Submitted to: Prof Written by: MBA Group A – Assignment 1 This case study is about Matt Tucker and Bill Lynch when they first meet in 1992 at high school at City High School in Iowa city, Iowa. Friendship continue when they entered in 1996 to the University of Iowa with major of computer science and programming area. We will see that mentioned major in computer sciences further will play extremely important role in future activities. Also in case we can see the key issues and challenges associated with the management /controlling and creation of a professional organization with the main idea in sales. Let’s describe all details of the case by answering the related questions. 1.  Put yourself in Wilson's shoes when he is first hired. You have to formalize Jive's sales functions. What are the core building blocks of the sales function you need to put in place? We have to start with the facts that in general Jive sales level was not so bad (in 2004) and company easily meet all goals and expectations annually. After all company moved from New York, the main reason is New York city itself is very expensive taking in consideration that on this moment Jive company was so called in starting-up line and was decided to move to the smaller city to Portland where the prices for all kind of appropriate necessary staff for company wasn’t expensive. Shortly after necessity of formalize Jive’s sales functions...

Words: 1504 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Group and Organizational Dynamics

...According to Meriam-webster a group is defined as two or more figures forming a complete unit in a composition or a number of individuals assembled together or having some unifying relationship. Group and organizational dynamics are in all areas of our lives. From the corporate jobs, small business owners to family and friends, each area of our lives consist of different groups. Working in groups can be challenging at times. Knowing your strengths as individuals as well as knowing your role in group settings can make the challenges easier. I will discuss group and organizational dynamics from six different areas: group vs. individual decision making; motivational patterns in group dynamics; conflict; competition; task functions; and maintenance function. Group vs. Individual Decision Making It has been said that two heads is better than one. When it comes to making a decision rather it’s in your personal or professional life many seek the opinions of others before making a final decision. When I worked in 911 call centers there were times when you had to work with a group of dispatchers on task throughout the city and then there were times when I needed to make a quick decision to make sure that officers in the field were safe on my own. I found myself at ease when making the group decisions because I knew that the bulk of what happened wouldn’t be on my shoulders. There was someone else to share responsibilities with me. When working with a group of people communication with...

Words: 2647 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Pf16

...and low in others. The following personality trait list describes some of the descriptive terms used for each of the 16 personality dimensions described by Cattell. 1.Warmth: Outgoing vs reserved 2.Reasoning: Abstract vs concrete 3.Emotional Stability: Calm vs high strung 4.Dominance: Forceful vs submissive 5. Liveliness: Spontaneous vs restrained 6.Rule Consciousness: Conforming vs non-conforming 7.Social Boldness: Uninhibited vs shy 8.Sensitivity: Tender-hearted vs tough-minded 9.Vigilance: Suspicious vs trusting 10. Abstractedness: Imaginative vs practical 11.Privateness: Discreet vs open 12.Apprehension: Worried vs confident 13.Openness to Change: Flexible vs attached to the familiar 14. Self-Reliance: Self-sufficient vs dependent 15. Perfectionism: Controlled vs undisciplined .16.Tension: Impatient vs relaxed Cattell also developed an assessment based on these 16 personality factors. The test is known as the 16 PF Personality Questionnaire and is still frequently used today, especially in business for employee testing and selection, career counseling and marital counseling. The test is composed of forced-choice questions in which the respondent must choose one of three different alternatives. Personality traits are then represented by a range and the individuals score falls somewhere on the continuum...

Words: 1757 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Organization Behavior

...Midterm Study Guide All definitions Chapter 1 A. Defining Organizational Behaviour Page 4 • A field of study that investigate the impact of individuals, groups, and structure on behaviour within organizations; its purpose is to apply such knowledge toward improving an organization’s effectiveness. B. Challenges in the Canadian Workplace Page 6 Challenges at the Individual Level 1. Individual Differences 2. Job Satisfaction 3. Motivation 4. Empowerment 5. Behaving Ethically Challenges at the Group Level 1. Working With Others 2. Workforce Diversity Challenges at the Organizational Level o Improving Customer Service o Stimulating Innovation and Change o The Use of Temporary (Contingent) Employees o Improving Quality and Productivity o Developing Effective Employees o Helping Employees with Work-Life Balance o Creating a Positive Work Environment o Responding to Globalization Chapter 2 A. Perception Page 38 What is Perception? • The process by which individuals organize and interpret their impressions to give meaning to their environment. Why is it important? • Because behaviour is based on perception of what reality is, not on reality itself. • The world as it is perceived is the world that is behaviourally important. Why we study perceptions? • To better understand how people make attributions about events. We don’t see reality. We interpret what we see and call it reality. The attribution...

Words: 2385 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Personal Effectiveness

...Title page Executive summary The purpose of this report is to evaluate personal effectiveness of three members, Ajai Ratnakumar, Melissa Jayawardena and Shannelle Abayasekara who are to be working together as a team. The main objective of this report is to compare and fit the different characteristics of the three team members who are to work together as a team , so as to compliment each other’s working style, for the benefit of the team, and ultimately for the company. Third Eye Event Managers provide individuals and companies with an unforgettable and unique event that would be remembered for years to come. The company’s main aims are to achieve a balance of creativity and competent implementation of all undertaken events, be it a private or commercial One. Based on the tests conducted the report contains information about preferences, strengths, and techniques for increasing effectiveness of each individual. Conflicts that are likely to arise within this team and solutions for these conflicts have been suggested. Short Term and Long Term recommendations have been stated which would help the company increase efficiency and minimize conflicts within future teams. Contents 1 Introduction 4 2 Discussion 5 2.1 What is personal effectiveness?. 5 2.2 The importance of personal effectiveness 5 2.3 Indicators used to assess personal effectiveness? 5 2.3.1 Learning Style Preferences 5 2.3.2 Hemispherical Dominance 7 2.3.3 Big Five Locator 7 2...

Words: 2091 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Cultural Context of Ihrm

...Management, it is the IHRM Department’s job to educate any expatriate about the foreign country they will be moving too. The main reason to do this is preventing cultural shock causing a smoother transition for the expatriate. Culture can be defined as “the beliefs, customs, arts, etc., of a particular society, group, place, or time” or is a more business related sense “a way of thinking, behaving, or working that exists in a place or organization.” Throughout the years there have been many intercultural management studies and there are four most widely accepted theories: The Hofstede study, The GLOBE study, The Trompenaars & Hampden-Turner study, and Hall & Hall’s cultural dimensions. These studies broke down cultures and behaviors around the world and are valued resources for IHRM departments. First, there is the Hofstede study. Geert Hofstede was a professor who conducted an extremely comprehensive study of how different cultures place value in the workplace. It was Hofstede who first made an empirical model and had different dimensions of national culture. These dimensions were: power distance, uncertainty avoidance, femininity vs. masculinity, individualism vs. collectivism, and long-term orientation. Each different country would get scores in each section and from these scores one could better understand the country’s way of doing things. To gain a better understanding, below is a comparison between the United States and Portugal. The first of the dimensions...

Words: 2331 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Managing Individual Performance

...Managing Individual Performance Abstract A team leader is faced with many responsibilities, from the beginning to the end, of everyday operations that occur within organizations. An individual's personality plays an important role to the success of the team. Personality is also important to take into consideration how the team's dynamics may formulate once the team is working together. Will the various personalities raise conflict on interest? Will this impact completing tasks and reaching tram goals? Is it important to make sure a team leader selects members than they can motivate? Using techniques like MBTI and the Maslow's Hierarchy to ensure optimal productivity within the group. This paper intends to demonstrate the outcome of the simulation Managing Individual Performance and the way that these two techniques were used to get to this outcome. Managing Individual Performance The best criteria for selecting team members are an individual's interest in the overall plan and the facilitation skills they possess. Teams need facilitators more than they do leaders, especially if numerous stakeholder groups are involved. The facilitators should have adequate training and should not have a personal interest in the specific project's outcome. The facilitators, then, will not be tempted to use their power to force personal agendas on team members. (Bill Roth) When selecting the team members, be sure to evaluate their interpersonal and communication skills as well as their...

Words: 1837 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Applied

...Length: Learning outcomes: 9 am 18 November. 2012 30% of final mark Individual write-up and video with a group component via Moodle forum. 1 minute video (avi or mp4 format) (no video = no marks) 800 (+-10%) words report (not including bibliography or Moodle forum) Not respecting the word count will result in a reduction of 5 percent of the total value of this assessment. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 Task: Dr. Fons Trompenaars has developed a model that describes countries from a cultural perspective using 7 dimensions. Advertising agencies use these dimensions to understand their target audience better and tailor their advertisements based on these dimensions. Advertising agencies from abroad do not always understand the culture of this region. You, as an advertising consultant, have been asked by your manager to analyse the Gulf Arab audience using some of the dimensions of this model and develop a 1 min video to sell a product or service of your choice to the Gulf Arab audience based on its cultural make up. You need to write a report that justifies the communication you have used to sell the product or service to the Gulf Arab audience based on your research on the cultural make up of the Gulf Arab audience on the dimensions: Universalism vs. Particularism, Neutral vs. Affective, Achievement vs. Ascription and Individualism vs. Collectivism. Your company has asked you to set up a virtual discussion group as a resource for this project to familiarise yourself with Trompenaars’ Model...

Words: 1922 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Assessment 2

... 9 am 12 May, 2013 30% of final mark Individual write-up, video and a group component via Moodle forum. 1 minute video (mp4 format) (no video = no marks) 800 (+-10%) words report (not including bibliography or Moodle forum) Not respecting the word count will result in a reduction of 5 percent of the total value of this assessment. Not respecting the video file format will result in a zero grade for this assessment. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 Task: Dr. Fons Trompenaars has developed a model that describes countries from a cultural perspective using 7 dimensions. Advertising agencies use these dimensions to understand their target audience better and tailor their advertisements based on these dimensions. Advertising agencies from abroad do not always understand the culture of this region. You, as an advertising consultant, have been asked by your manager to analyse the Gulf Arab audience using some of the dimensions of this model and develop a 1 min video to sell a product or service of your choice to the Gulf Arab audience based on its cultural make up. You need to write a report that justifies the communication you have used to sell the product or service to the Gulf Arab audience based on your research on the cultural make up of the Gulf Arab audience on the dimensions: Universalism vs. Particularism, Neutral vs. Affective, Achievement vs. Ascription and Individualism vs. Collectivism. Your company has asked you to set up a virtual discussion group as a resource for this project to familiarise...

Words: 1938 - Pages: 8