Free Essay

Guide to Preparing Essay Outline

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By sadels
Words 981
Pages 4
Guide to Preparing Your Essay Outline

(N.B. This guide is to be read in conjunction with the ‘Introducing Philosophy’ booklet handed out at the beginning of the course)

An essay outline for this course comprises two components:

• A thesis statement

• A section-by-section summary of the developing argument.

• References

A thesis statement

Your essay should be a good philosophical argument. Such an argument, at minimum, provides good reasons in support of a conclusion. Thus, the first step in writing a good essay is to be clear of the conclusion, i.e. the claim that you are going to be defending. It should be possible to present the claim in no more than a sentence or two that tells the reader what it is that you will argue, and why and how. This is what is known as a thesis statement, and your essay outline should begin with this.

A good thesis statement should:

• Be no longer than a sentence or two

• It should be something philosophically controversial (though not necessarily sensationalist), in that it should not merely be a statement of fact, nor of style, nor of context.

• It should include a reference to the target idea or text.

Examples:

“Pascal’s (1632-62) famed defence of religious faith by appeal to the utility of believing in God rather than the truth of the belief is unsatisfactory since, although it professes to start from a position of metaphysical ignorance, in practice it smuggles in unwarranted assumptions about the utility of believing in the existence of God”.

“Pascal argues that the practical advantage of believing in God outweighs the disadvantages, although this has been challenged by many critics who contend that the argument only succeeds if one conflates pragmatic reasons for believing with epistemic reasons for believing. In this essay, I shall defend Pascal from this charge, by showing that such a conflation is warranted.”

A section-by-section summary

The remainder of the essay should proceed to defend the thesis articulated in the thesis statement. It should provide some context for the claim that you are defending (i.e. explain why anyone would make such a claim and why it is of interest), explain the claim clearly and precisely in your own terms, provide an argument or arguments in defence of the claim and defend the argument from counterargument(s).

Here’s an example (for the second of the theses noted above):

A. Introduction: 100 words

1. Outline difference between pragmatic and epistemic reasons for believing.

2. State that Pascal provides pragmatic reasons for believing that God exists.

3. Provide thesis statement as above.

B. Outline Pascal’s Wager: 300 words

1. Pascal’s assumes metaphysical ignorance, i.e. suppose we don’t have epistemic reasons for believing or denying that God exists.

2. In such a case, Pascal says we need to choose between believing this or denying this.

3. This choice, claims Pascal is not optional. (‘You must wager’).

4. According to Pascal, the potential benefits of believing are so vast as to make betting on theism rational

C. Recast Wager in terms of decision theory. 300 words

1. According to decision theory, it is rational pursue the outcome that has the maximum expectation.

2. To work out maximum expectation, associate each outcome with a utility and a probability of occurrence. Expectation = probability x utility. Compare maximum expectations or each possible outcome for a given course of action.

3. Recast Pascal’s wager using this terminology.

D. The Evidentialist Objection. 300 words.

1. Clifford claims that it is wrong to believe anything on insufficient evidence.

2. If this is true, it would be wrong to believe anything based on pragmatic reasons.

3. This undermines the conclusion of Pascal’s wager.

E. Clifford’s principle is wrong. 500 words.

1. There are certain kinds of cases where Clifford’s Principle does not hold.

2. Example> William James claims that the principle does not hold when faced with a live option that is forced and momentous.

3. Clifford’s principle needs to be limited; there are occasions when it is permissible to form beliefs on insufficient reason.

F. Counter Example: Even a limited Evidentialist Principle applies in Pascal’s case (400 words)

1. My argument assumes that the case of belief in God is such a case where Clifford’s principle does not apply.

2. Counterargument: Belief in god is not forced and thus the principle does apply.

3. My response: It is possible to formulate belief in God in just the way that choice does becomes forced and rules out agnosticism.

G. Conclusion: (100 words)

1. Repeat thesis statement

2. To stress: I have not endorsing Pascal entirely but have merely shown that one common criticism of Pascal fails.

References:

The purpose of the philosophy essay is to argue and not to survey. Thus provided you have read the target source(s) and thought carefully about it, it is not expected that you will have read all the secondary literature on the subject. That said, any source you have used in the essay, either from which you cite or from which you have taken an idea must be referenced formally. (See the plagiarism guide for help in this regard). Your reference section should thus contain the sources of all ideas that are not your own in the essay.

Here’s a sample for the above essay:

References:

Blackburn, S. ‘Infini-Rien’, reprinted in: PHI1024F Course Reader 2010 (ed. J. Wanderer) pages 65-8.
Clifford, W. (1879) “The ethics of belief”, reprinted in: PHI1024F Course Reader 2010 (ed. J. Wanderer) pages 45-49.
James, W. (1897) “The will to believe”, reprinted in: PHI1024F Course Reader 2010 (ed. J. Wanderer) pages 50-58.
Saka, P. (2005) “Pascal’s Wager about God”, Internet Encyclopaedia of Philosophy (http://www.iep.utm.edu/pasc-wag/#H4). Last accessed on: 16th February 2010).

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Innovation

...and present views on a topic based on their readings or research. The rest of the group then joins in a discussion of the topic. Depending on your course, giving an oral presentation can involve: • reading background material • preparing and delivering a talk • leading a group discussion • preparing handouts and visual aids • preparing relevant and thought-provoking questions • submitting a written assignment based on the presentation topic Presentation topics are usually scheduled early in the semester. You may be able to choose your topic or one may be allocated to you. If you are able to choose a topic, select the one that you have some questions about and that interests you the most. Your presentation may be given as an individual or as part of a group. In some courses the oral presentation may be the basis for a written assignment. Check with your tutor for details. There may be specific requirements you may need to meet and these are usually detailed in your course outline or study guide. Preparing a Presentation Preparing an oral presentation is much like preparing any other assignment; it needs to be planned researched and written before it is delivered. Getting started • Examine the assignment criteria provided in your course outline carefully and make sure you know exactly what to do. Do you have to answer a set question, present an argument, explain or discuss something, be critical? If you are unsure, check with your tutor. • Analyse your audience. What...

Words: 2122 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Habits

...Effective Study Skills  Dr. Bob Kizlik Latest update: January 4, 2012 How to Study and Make the Most of Your Time This web page on study skills, and what some may refer to as study tips, is designed to help you improve your learning and understanding, and ultimately your grades. It is not so large that it would require you to engage in mind-numbing reading of chapter after chapter as is the case with many books on the subject. The information is written in a way to help you "see" and "practice" proven study techniques. This page is used in hundreds of schools and universities and is currently ranked by Google and Bing in the top ten for plain old "study skills" and "how to study effectively" and #1 by Google and Bing  for "effective study skills" Want more? Available now is a new, inexpensive download or CD on how to improve not just your study skills, but your learning skills as well. It is STUDY SKILLS FOR SCHOOL SUCCESS 2.0, that includes in one program a greatly enhanced version of all the information below, and much, much more, including a new section on how to get better math grades and self-motivation.  After all, isn't what works what really counts? Please click http://adprima.com/SSSS2/ssss2order.htm  and see for yourself. There is little doubt that no two people study the same way, and it is a near certainty that what works for one person may not work for another. However, there are some general techniques that seem to produce good results. No one would argue...

Words: 4421 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Types of Essay

...There are a range of essay types, and each of these types requires you to do different things. An important first skill, then, in preparing your essay is to identify what sort of essay you are being asked to write, and what this requires you to do. In general essays fall along a continuum between those that ask you to describe a particular phenomenon, and those that ask to discuss, analyse, criticize and debate particular issues. At university essays increasingly tend to fall into the latter discussion type. These types of essay require you to go beyond simply repeating what you have been told towards thinking about the information you have found and knitting it into an argument. TIP: If you are not sure what the essay requires you to do, ask the person setting the question about what they want. Analysing the Question: Answering the Question A key point to remember as you prepare you essay is that no matter how well you write the essay, if you do not actually answer the question you will not do well. This seems an obvious point, but in the heat of the moment it is often neglected. To help you stay on track you can do two simple tasks: first, have a close look at the essay question; second, as you prepare and write your essay continue to look at the question and think if what you are doing matches what the question requires. Essay Writing and Format Guide 6 It is important to pay close attention to the essay question because the way in which the question is worded often...

Words: 1796 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Comm101

...COMM101: Principles of Responsible Commerce Assessment 2: In Class Essay (45 minutes) The aim of this assessment task is to help you develop a deeper understanding of the difficult ethical questions in business, and how to respond to those using moral philosophies. In doing so, we hope that you will be able to make more considered and informed business (and consumption) decisions for the benefit of both yourself and the wider society. In your week 2 tutorial, you were required to produce a short summary of your understanding at that time of the meaning and importance of the term ‘responsible business’. Since then you have explored various historical, moral, governance and economic aspects of business both domestically and internationally. Task In COMM101, you have been exposed to several cases of corporate unethical behaviour. Ethical misconduct of senior executives appear to be at the centre of these scandals. In Australia, the James Hardie Industries ‘asbestos’ case has been featured in the media for some time. The company has been accused of causing over half of the number of documented cases of mesothemilia, a lung cancer caused by asbestos. In your in-class essay writing, you are required to do the following. 1. Using utilitarianism, discuss two reasons each in favour of, and against, James Hardie executives’ conduct. 2. As summarised in your week 2 tutorial exercise, reflect in your essay, how your views concerning ‘responsible business’ have been influenced...

Words: 441 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Math

...2014 Examination Guide These materials are owned and copyrighted by the College Board. They may not be posted on the Internet or on any other public document sharing site. The materials in these files are intended for PERSONAL USE ONLY. Violations of this policy may be subject to legal action including, but not limited to, payment for each guide that is disseminated unlawfully and associated damages. College Algebra Visit our website at clep.collegeboard.org for the most up-to-date information. © 2013 The College Board. College Board, CLEP, College-Level Examination Program, SAT and the acorn logo are registered trademarks of the College Board. inspiring minds is a trademark owned by the College Board. All other products and services may be trademarks of their respective owners. Visit the College Board on the Web: www.collegeboard.org. Introduction This is the only official guide to the 33 College-Level Examination Program® (CLEP®) exams. CLEP exams are administered on computers at test centers across the country. This Guide has been written mainly for adults who are making plans to enroll in college, but it contains information of interest to others as well. College-bound high school students, current college students, military personnel, professionals seeking certification and persons of all ages who have learned or wish to learn college-level material outside the college classroom will find the Guide helpful as they strive to accomplish their goals. CLEP is based...

Words: 8928 - Pages: 36

Premium Essay

Science Essay Topics

...what defines modern civilization are advances in technology and knowledge gained by investigations in the natural sciences. Statistics and mathematics provide the framework for this field, where quantifiable data and accuracy are essential components. The main goal of the natural science essay is to utilize problem-solving techniques that report results through analysis and observation. Expectations for writing in the natural sciences Whatever your topic when writing in the natural sciences, make sure you understand the assignment before you start. There are characteristics to take into consideration when writing an essay in this field, which include the amount of technical language you use, how much background information is adequate and the type of evidence needed. The composition of this type of written piece requires meeting these writing standards: Prepare by doing an extensive amount of background scientific research reading Select key references, and introduce a critical examination of the problem Introduce the essay topic, justify it as a scientific problem and completely discuss and recap the conclusion Use passive constructions in data interpretation to stay objective Essay structure for...

Words: 592 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Nothing

...Interpreting Literature 2012 Examination Guide These materials are owned and copyrighted by the College Board. They may not be posted on the Internet or on any other public document sharing site. The materials in these files are intended for PERSONAL USE ONLY. Violations of this policy may be subject to legal action including, but not limited to, payment for each guide that is disseminated unlawfully and associated damages. V isit our website at w ww.collegeboard.org/clep f or the most up-to-date information. © 2011 The College Board. College Board, CLEP, College-Level Examination Program, SAT and the acorn logo are registered trademarks of the College Board. inspiring minds is a trademark owned by the College Board. All other products and services may be trademarks of their respective owners. Visit the College Board on the Web: www.collegeboard.org. Introduction This is the only official guide to the 33 College-Level Examination Program® (CLEP®) exams. CLEP exams are administered on computer test centers across the country. This Guide has been written mainly for adults who are making plans to enroll in college, but it contains information of interest to others as well. College-bound high school students, current college students, military personnel, professionals seeking certification and persons of all ages who have learned or wish to learn college-level material outside the college classroom will find the Guide helpful as they strive to accomplish their...

Words: 14147 - Pages: 57

Premium Essay

My Progress in Writing

...in communication. I have had many difficult times speaking and understanding English when talking to others. Writing an essay was almost impossible for me to think of. Realizing how difficult it was to experience these linguistic difficulties, I then decided to go back to school to improve my English skills. Therefore, English became especially essential for me to succeed in my educational goals. I was determined to earn an Associate’s degree then transfer to a university for a Bachelor’s degree. I started going to ESL classes and studied English very hard to make progress in my speaking, reading and writing skills. After spending one year in ESL classes, I qualified for English 43. I learned lots of grammar and how to write paragraphs efficiently during these classes. I noticed that writing an essay was more challenging when I got into English 49. However, since then I’ve learned how to write a five-paragraph argumentative essay which was one of my weaknesses in academic writings. I have made a lot of progress in writing skills since I started studying English 49. I now think that I’m ready to go on to English 101 due to the fact that I have learned useful strategies to follow a writing process and develop coherent paragraphs effectively. A writing process is the most important step that I learned in this class. First of all, before writing a complete essay, I need to come up with the pre-writing which consists of free writing and brainstorming. I found this step essential because...

Words: 1186 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Com/156 Syllabus

...|[pic] |Course Design Guide | | |College of Humanities | | |COM/156 Version 7 | | |University Composition and Communication II | Copyright © 2013, 2011, 2010, 2009 by University of Phoenix. All rights reserved. Course Description This course builds upon the foundations established in COM/155. It addresses the various rhetorical modes necessary for effective college essays: narration, illustration, description, process analysis, classification, definition, comparison and contrast, cause and effect, and argumentation. In addition, requirements for research essays, including the use of outside sources and appropriate formatting, are considered. Policies Faculty and students will be held responsible for understanding and adhering to all policies contained within the following two documents: • University policies: You must be logged into the student website to view this document. • Instructor policies: This document is posted in the Course Materials forum. University policies are subject...

Words: 4385 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Software Engineering

...for articles and books. * Develop strategies for searching the Internet. * Evaluate the validity of information. * Develop and improve effective writing skills. * Promote critical thinking skills. Grading guidelines: 1. An outstanding paper will: * Be clearly and concisely written, * Answer specifically the question(s) posed in the essay topic, * Be technically sound, * Be free of grammatical and spelling errors, * Use at least 4 scholarly publications as sources * Carefully provide proper citations for all references used, * Use APA style for citing and referencing, double spacing and between 10pt and 12pt font size * Follow the required outline. * Avoid plagiarism through citing sources correctly and identifying quotations. Paper will be submitted to Turnitin.com for plagiarism check before review. 2. The paper should not: * Simply parrot back information found in the text, lecture notes, or other references * Contain long passages quoted from other sources * Provide a general tutorial on the generic topic of the essay, rather than addressing the specific question Policy on Academic Integrity: Please review the UMUC policy on academic dishonesty and plagiarism. Your paper has to be in complete compliance with UMUC’s zero-tolerance policy regarding plagiarism. “Plagiarism includes, but is not limited to the following: copying verbatim all or part of another's written work; using...

Words: 635 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Engl101

...Prerequisite: COLL100 is recommended Table of Contents Course Description Course Scope Course Objectives Course Delivery Method Course Materials Evaluation Procedures Grading Scale Course Outline Policies Academic Services Selected Bibliography Table of Contents Course Description (Catalog) ENGL101 Proficiency in Writing (3 hours) This course provides instruction in the writing process with a focus on self-expressive and expository essays, and will include practice in the conventions of standard written English, responding to readings, and incorporating sources into essays with appropriate documentation. Table of Contents Course Scope This course gives students practice in the conventions of Standard Written English, responding to readings, and incorporating sources into essays with appropriate documentation. Thus the course prepares students for writing effectively in all undergraduate courses by sharpening the writing skills necessary to answer essay examinations, dialogue with reading assignments, and write term papers. Table of Contents Course Objectives Students who successfully complete this course will be able to: CO-1: Recognize and formulate the kind of writing required to respond properly to college-level assignments, examinations, and projects. (Essay types) CO-2: Use a process of writing from pre-writing (i.e. brainstorming) ideas to polishing a final draft. CO-3: Demonstrate writing techniques explained in this class through finished writing...

Words: 2413 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Acfi 2005 Source Outline

...Course Outline Newcastle Business School ACFI2005 Finance Semester 2, 2011 Callaghan Campus Unit Weighting: 10 Units Lecturer and Course Coordinator: Paul Docherty CONTENTS 1. Teaching Staff 3 2. Contact Hours and Teaching Methods 3 3. Blackboard 3 4. Student Email 4 GENERAL COURSE INFORMATION 4 5. Brief Course Description 4 6. Assumed Knowledge 4 7. Course Objectives / Learning Outcomes 5 8. Link to Graduate Attributes 5 9. Course Content 5 10. Continuous Course Evaluation and Improvement 6 TEXTBOOKS AND REFERENCES/READINGS 6 11. Textbooks and Readings 6 12. Prescribed Text 6 13. Recommended Texts/Readings 6 TOPIC AND LECTURE OUTLINE 7 14. Course Schedule 7 ASSESSMENT DETAILS AND POLICIES 8 15. Types and Due Dates of Assessment 8 16. Details of Assessment 8 17. Penalties 9 18. Academic Integrity, Plagiarism and Turnitin 9 19. Cover Sheets for Assessment 10 Assessment Grades and Percentages 10 ACADEMIC SKILLS RESOURCES 10 20. Academic Skills Resources 10 UNIVERSITY POLICIES AND GENERAL INFORMATION 11 21. Extension of Time for Assessment Items, Deferred Assessment and Special Consideration 11 22. Students with a Disability or Chronic Illness 12 23. Changing Your Enrolment 12 24. Other Policies Related to Your Enrolment 13 25. Alteration of this Course 13 26...

Words: 4834 - Pages: 20

Free Essay

International Business Environment (Man4139M)

...Module Assessment 4 5. Length 6 6. Structure of essay 7 7. How to start writing your essay 8 8. Grading 8 str. 2 1. Module Staff Office: Internal (direct) phone: E-mail: Office hours: str. 3 Room C/15 22 519 -21-65 kmprystupa@kozminski.edu.pl Please see current information on www.alk.edu.pl 2. Teaching and Learning Strategy Class Organization Please see detailed timetable below: dates may differ depending on which group you are attending – you will receive specific timetable with dates on the first day of class). Attendance and Participation As a general policy, I do not accept latecomers in this class. People who are more than 5 minutes late for the class will not be allowed to participate in the course. 3. Recommended Readings Several copies of “Organizational Behaviour and Management” by D. Knights and H. Willmott are available in the library. This book is an excellent companion to this course and should be also helpful in preparing your final assignment (Essay). It may also be a useful supplementary resource in preparing presentations. Besides, books (study guides) as these mentioned below provide advice for assignment writing. I would strongly suggest that if you are not confident in your report writing or feel you would benefit from further help in this regard to look to these. The study skills handbook / Stella Cottrell The good study guide / Andrew Northedge The...

Words: 2845 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

History

...Elements The basic elements of academic essay writing are two: a thesis and evidence, divided into three parts: an introduction, the systematic development of an argument, and a conclusion. All scholarly writing, from the most concise paper to the longest book, follows these basic guidlines. Thesis Historical essay writing is based upon the thesis. A thesis is a statement, an argument which will be presented by the writer. The thesis is in effect, your position, your particular interpretation, your way of seeing a problem. Resist the temptation, which many students have, to think of a thesis as simply "restating" an instructor's question. The writer should demonstrate originality and critical thinking by showing what the question is asking, and why it is important rather than merely repeating it. Your own informed perspective is what matters. Many first-year students ask whether the "thesis" is not just their "opinion" of a historical question. A thesis is indeed a "point of view," or "perspective," but of a particular sort: it is based not only on belief, but on a logical and systematic argument supported by evidence. The truism that we each have "our own" opinions misses the point. A good critical essay acknowledges that many perspectives are possible on any question, yet demonstrates the validity or correctness of the writer's own view. Thesis and Evidence To make a good argument you must have both a strong central thesis and plausible evidence; the two are interdependent...

Words: 2351 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Luther

...Geography Programme, School of People, Environment and Planning ESSAY WRITING AND FORMAT GUIDE FOR GEOGRAPHY STUDENTS Essay Writing and Format Guide 2 Essay Writing and Format Guide Table of Contents Introduction: Why Write Essays? ........................................................ 4 Types of Essay........................................................................................ 5 Analysing the Question: Answering the Question............................ 5 Planning Your Essay ............................................................................. 8 Writing Your Essay................................................................................ 9 Introduction ..................................................................................... 10 The Body of the Essay.................................................................... 10 Concluding ....................................................................................... 12 Editing............................................................................................... 13 Writing Style ......................................................................................... 13 Spelling.............................................................................................. 13 Writing numbers.............................................................................. 14 Grammar: plurals and apostrophes .............................................. 15 Syntax: The...

Words: 6393 - Pages: 26