Free Essay

Health Bill Controversy

In:

Submitted By aiustudent2014
Words 830
Pages 4
R. Blake Flugence
HCM 620
Professor Michael Schmitt
American Intercontinental University
September 13, 2015

Abstract
President George W. Bush’s 2003 introduction of a new health bill policy was formulated to enforce changes to Medicare. Since its origination in 1965, policies of healthcare have experienced many phases in attempt to provide affordable benefits to patients in need of different services. With similar advancements in consideration, President Bush attempted to enact a significant affordable program for prescription drug coverage. Predictions of this healthcare agenda in partnership with the Medicare Modernization Act supported assistance that would cover a widespread of qualified beneficiaries in the U.S. However, as a result of the legislation, controversies arose affecting the decisions of patients as well as providers. The following document illustrates provisions of the health bill policy and formulated opinions by researchers.

In a 2003 CNN web article, shortly after Congress began proposals for the new Medicare reform, writers introduced stipulations of the form including its successes and failings. Supporters of the policy made predictions claiming that $400 billion provided by the Medicare Modernization Act would accommodate the nation’s 40 million citizens to purchase medication. In this aspect, the policy leaked an advantage for older Americans having capabilities for better coverage options through Medicare and also more control over services provided to them. In detail, 75% of costs would be paid up to $2,250. Recipients of the program would be required to pay $35 monthly with a $250 deductible for prescriptions. Subsidies would be provided to private insurers to compete with traditional Medicare to cut down the costs of prescription drugs. Additionally discovered, the new legislation would allow for the importation of more affordable drugs from Canada only if approved by the FDA. The idea for “modern medical care” is a chance for patients to receive the benefits they deserve. However, opponents of the legislation deemed otherwise to propositions of the reform; those who disagreed identified it as a giveaway to drug makers and insurance companies creating dismantle towards the coverage program (Policy, 2003). President Bush along with involvement of the US Senate developed the structure of the legislation in hopes of encouraging a successful healthcare plan. In favor of the legislation, the Democratic Party led the decision by voting in favor of the policy. The President addressed unique additions to the plan including Medicare payments to rural hospitals, payments to hospitals serving large numbers of low-income patients, hospitals avoiding future cuts, Doctors ability to receive pay increases, Medicare coverage of patient physicals, development of healthcare savings accounts, and Medicare Part B premiums. Based on data and the necessity for healthcare changes, the US government identified that approximately 10 million people did not have such coverage (Policy, 2003). Dr. Eric Henley, author of the public health issues from the University of Illinois College of Medicine discusses changes of the legislation in effect towards Medicare. Individuals involved in setting the policy’s agenda identified that the bill lacked to establish a mechanism to offset the rising costs of prescription drugs. While drugs would continue to increase annually this in turn would affect relative patient and governmental contributions. The administering of the drug benefit created an immediate controversy. A final major controversy of the bill developed from an experiment conducted in six cities beginning in 2010. The experiment included a private insurance plan competing directly with the traditional Medicare program. While Republicans believed the experiment was necessary for measuring the decreasing rates further supporting the program, Democrats were completely against the “private market” concept stating this to be the major cause for issues reflective of quality and cost within healthcare (Henley, 2004). Implementation of the new policy generated concerns by several groups affiliated both directly and indirectly with the agenda. For instance organizations such as the AARP and the Department of Health and Human Services obtained responsibility for presenting policy provisions to the public. This responsibility was looked upon as a preoccupation that would effectively deter Congress and President Bush from addressing other issues concerning the majority of uninsured individuals (Henley 2004). Efforts contributed to the 2003 health policy were necessary to establish methods for effectively addressing the changes towards Medicare. President Bush along with his team of agenda setters accomplished their plans for extensive healthcare services; however, the implementation alone was not successful due to the amount of controversial issues mentioned. I strongly support that having access to electronic patient health records was and will continue to be a beneficial tool for determining citizens who are uninsured and potentially will qualify to receive affordable coverage

References

CNN. Cable News Network, n.d. Web. 13 Sept. 2015.

Henley E. What the new Medicare prescription drug bill may mean for providers and patients. Journal Of Family Practice [serial online]. May 2004;53(5):389-392. Available from: Academic Search Premier, Ipswich, MA. Accessed September 13, 2015

Kaplan, R. L., & Olson, R. W. (2006). Consumer Choice on Drugs: Medicare and Medications. Ageing International, 31(2), 118-137.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Rebuttal

...The article of controversial bills signed based of abortion would have two supporting topics. The first is abortion in its own and the second being the leadership of the governor. Through these two topics, it shows how the governor had signed the bills for abortion in Wisconsin in secrecy. The bill consists of multiple parts of procedures the doctor needs to perform before following through with the abortion. One bill is that doctors need to ask the patient alone if they want the abortion or if they have to oblige. The second bill is that no medical expense paid from insurance agencies unless the pregnancy is through rape, incest, or of people who need it medically. According to "Controversial Abortion Bill Among Several Walker Quietly Signed Into Law" (2012), "Another bill comes into play with Health Care Reform in 2014, banning abortion coverage sold through a health insurance exchange, except in cases of rape, incest or medical necessity” (para. 11). I do support the cause of why the governor is doing this; however, he is doing it for the wrong reasons. He signed these bills before he is leaving office and has done them secretly. According to "Leadership = Controversy With Civility" (2011), "Involve everyone in planning and problem solving. Avoid making decisions behind closed doors” (para. 10). This states that to avoid controversy that all decisions should avoid secrecy and allot everyone in the decision. This shows bad leadership by the governor. It also shows how the governor...

Words: 552 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Health Care Refrom

...luxury, it’s a necessity. Today the healthcare deduction is getting bigger and bigger. Despite a huge amount of complaints about “over insurance”, the amount people pay for healthcare out of pocket has risen tremendously. The Commonwealth Fund recently completed two massive surveys showing that the proportion of adults younger than 65 with health insurance who spent more than 10 percent of their income on health care out of pocket (5 percent for low-income adults) skyrocketed fro 13.8 million in 2003 to 21.8 million in 2007. (Jacob S. Hacker, Co-Director of the Center for Health, Economic and Family Security at UC Berkeley). This is in response to the hike in deductibles and co-payments in health plans. There are 40 percent of the working-age populations in an immediate economic bind because of medical costs. Second, because of the rising cost of healthcare, 2009 will be a critical year for health care. Sen. Charles Grassley (r-Iowa) says “healthcare reform must be a priority”. It will especially be a critical year for Medicare. It is clear that major changes in Medicare are offing. The Finance Committee will move forward on comprehensive health reform early this year says committee chairman Sen. Max Baucus (D-Mont.). Fixing...

Words: 987 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Planned Parenthood: the Next Great Debate

...Planned Parenthood: The Next Great Debate The ethical, legal, and religious fight of abortion has been a long and strenuous fight, with smaller arguments, such as the now newly publicized controversy of Planned Parenthood and it’s functions, spawning from the main issue. The opinions on abortion have been divided into two main arguments; pro-life and pro-choice. While there is great variation between the two opposing sides, there is little variation in the views belonging to the same side. Many ideas that propose a different solution to the issue of abortion and it’s offsets are often diminished to ‘unrealistic’ and ‘too hopeful’ for the main issue at hand. However, several solutions that have been proposed are well thought out and ultimately useful for the debate over abortion and Planned Parenthood. Planned Parenthood is a non-profit organization which receives almost 530 million dollars from the government each year. They receive almost $392 million from private organizations, $306 million from non-governmental services, and $78 million from other revenues. The organization, which focuses on the health and wellbeing of women and children, in notorious for it’s supposed high abortion rates, despite the fact that abortion makes up only 2% of services the non-profit organization offers. Most of Planned Parenthood’s revenue consists of helping women’s contraception and the treatment of Sexually Transmitted Infections. 15% of what they do is also cancer screening and prevention...

Words: 1335 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Essay On Affordable Care Act

...Many policies and bills are presented or passed by the Congress and by the president. A lot of these bills and policies stir up controversy with citizens of the United States. Recent bills that have caused tension in the United States as well as in the government include the Affordable Care Act, Voter Identification Law, and the Dream Act. The Affordable Care Act was created by the current president Barack Obama and since it has been introduced it has created much tension between him and Congress, and also between different political parties. The new Voter Identification Laws make it almost impossible for many people to vote, and discourages them from voting. The Dream Act will give illegal immigrants the right of citizenship for attending college or joining the U.S. military,...

Words: 604 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Uninsured Health Care Research Paper

...that that the U.S. also ranks highest with infant mortality rate and lowest with life expectancy compared to other developed countries ("Introduction To The Uninsured: Current Controversies"). These results probably have much to do with the fact that as of 2008, 15 percent of the U.S. population is not covered by any means of health care insurance ("Introduction To The Uninsured: Current Controversies"). Not having health insurance because of the fact of how costly it is can be a contributing factor to people putting off and doing without health insurance, even on the occasion...

Words: 1603 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Abortion

...Abortion is a very controversial social issue that has existed for many decades. The controversy behind this issue is caused by the different views that people and societies have regarding abortion. The social science disciplines of political science and religion will be used in getting a better understanding of the opposing views of abortion. In discussing the religious aspects of abortion, this paper will focus on the Jewish and Catholic views of abortion and how the two faiths effect an individual s decision upon having an abortion. When discussing the political controversy regarding abortion, this paper will discuss the abortion laws in Canada and the United States as well as the pro-choice and anti-choice movements of abortion. Society is greatly affected both socially and politically by abortions due to the different moralistic views regarding abortions and the controversies surrounding abortions. What are the views of the Catholic and Jewish religions on having abortions and how do their different views effect society? How is society effected by the political controversies behind abortions? Religion and Abortion Abortion is an issue that causes extreme divisions among various religious groups due to the laws of the religions, in particular, those of the Jewish and Christian religions. The Jewish religion is based on the belief in one G-d as well as respecting the laws that G-d imposed on the Jews. The Jewish people are expected to do what is just and merciful in the...

Words: 2587 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Arent We There Yet?

...there has controversy between advancing medicine through testing and preserving life. In the United States and around the world, there have been debates and laws created which demonstrate the controversy in stem cell research. One of the main debates is that stem research can be used to discover cures for illness. Many experts believe stem cell research can be used to help against diabetes, Parkinson’s disease and Alzheimer (Lacayo, 2001). However, many people worry that stem cell research will be used for unethical purposes such as human cloning. They also argue that money from the government should not be used to destroy a human embryo. In the United States and around the world there have been many laws regarding stem cell research. President Bush was the first President that made funds available for stem cell research. (Bush, 2007). According to the National Institute of Health, a government biomedical research organization, President George W Bush announced in August, 2001 a policy which advances stem cell research. Federal funds may be used for research on human embryonic stem cells if the following three requirements are met: 1) the destruction of the embryo must be prior to August 9, 2001, 2) stem cells were removed from embryo for the purpose of reproduction, which “was no longer needed.” 3) the donor had informed consent and did not expect money in return (2006). In July 2001, the House of Representatives introduced a broad anti cloning bill but it was...

Words: 629 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Planned Parenthood Controversy

...The Planned Parenthood controversy has been a recent hot topic in the media. Center for Medical Progress tried to discredit Planned Parenthood by saying they sell fetal tissues for profit. They secretly recorded lunches with Parenthood executives and their trips to the Parenthood Clinics in Texas and Colorado. The video that was obtained is close to being three hours long, and after selectively editing, it became an eight minute video. I think Center for Medical Progress edited the video not to reveal the truth of the meeting but to make false accusations for political reasons. Center for Medical Progress are a political organization who I think are propagandist. I think their strategy was to broadcast what appears to be incriminating evidence,...

Words: 1021 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Stem Cell Research

...cells in the United States should go in the future and why. Make sure you use ample research and cited sources to support your arguments but make sure to state your own opinion on the issues as well. Stem Cell Research TJ AS OF: 2/4/2009--Introduced. Stem Cell Research Improvement Act of 2009 - Amends the Public Health Service Act to require the Secretary of Health and Human Services to conduct and support research that utilizes human embryonic stem cells, regardless of the date on which the stem cells were derived from a human embryo. Limits such research to stem cells that meet the following requirements: (1) the stem cells were derived from human embryos donated from in vitro fertilization clinics, were created for the purposes of fertility treatment, and were in excess of the needs of the individuals seeking such treatment; (2) prior to donation, it was determined that the embryos would never be implanted in a woman and would otherwise be discarded; and (3) the individuals seeking fertility treatment donated the embryos with written informed consent and received no financial or other inducements. Requires the Director of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) to issue guidelines on research involving human embryonic stem cells. Authorizes the Director to issue guidelines on research involving other human stem cells, as scientifically warranted. Provides for updates of guidelines under this Act. Directs the Secretary to take into consideration guidelines on human stem...

Words: 3563 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Homelessness in America

...studies indicate that Americans are at a high risk of becoming homeless. More than 30% of the low incomes earning Americans spend more than 50% of their earnings to paying rent (Surveys/Studies/Stats, 2012). The most common reasons for homelessness are emergency health problems, missed paychecks, and pending bills. However, most cases of homelessness are caused by poverty (Karger & Stoesz, 2010). Although policies to control homelessness have been implemented, there is a need for reforms and further amendments to state laws. Controversies Surrounding Homelessness in America A section of the people argues that it is their morally responsibility to assist the homeless people while others may claim that it is the choice of the people to remain homeless. Those who maintain that it is morally right to help the homeless individuals in the society cite the following critical issues: The Homeless Access to Health Insurance and Critical Medical Services The use of Urban Emergency Departments in America presents a significant controversial topic. The homeless people are not often insured hence fail to treat some treatable diseases. Research indicates that homelessness falling between 50 to 60 years have almost the same health problems with people in their 70s or 80s (Kushel, 2016). Therefore, it is important to help the homeless move...

Words: 952 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Bed Bugs- Long Report

...Bedbug Hype: Public Health Issues and Recent News Katie Povis Missouri Baptist University Ancient bugs that are believed to exist in the time of cave dwellers are known as bed bugs ("Bedbugs- a health," 2011). Although many people allegedly thought bed bugs were a myth, in reality bed bugs are a serious problem that most people choose to ignore. Experts say that bed bugs resemble the body of a flea, in that it appears flat. The microscopic insects are almost impossible to see and are able to squeeze into small crevices on any object or surface. Common places for bed bugs to hide include mattresses, box springs, and picture frames as well as floor and wall moldings ("Bedbugs- a health," 2011). Humans are the perfect prey for bed bugs. Compared to other mammals, humans have less hair which is preferred by bed bugs because direct access to skin makes their feeding much easier ("Bedbugs- a health," 2011).” It is believed by scientists that the ideal temperature for the parasites to thrive is between 60 and 70 degrees. Research at Virginia Tech shows that the lifespan of bed bugs may expand when cooler temperatures are consistent, so rather than living on their host, they feed and return to the cool, dark hiding places they favor (Harrison, & Lawrence , 2010). There are many theories as to why these insects have surfaced again. The tiny insects cause a good deal of controversy especially in court cases trying to decide who is liable ("Bedbugs- a health," 2011). One article...

Words: 1709 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Abortion

...The Right to Choose Women have been fighting for equal rights and to be able to make choices for themselves. Although much has changed in the past two-hundred years one of the most debated women’s rights is still being fought over. Mental and physical health has been a major consure with women who are having abortions; the apposing side has been giving out unclear information about abortion and health problems. With the way of the economy money is tight, people are loosing jobs, and children are being neglected. For the safety of the children being born into poverty, it is best for some to not have to live in such a way. Women living in this country have the option to choose and having the freedom to choose could result in less children being born into poverty. Many different documents have been passed about abortions and how women’s rights are in danger. “In 1992 Planned Parenthood v. Casey reaffirms the core holdings of Roe that women have a right to abortion before fetal viability, but allows states to restrict abortion access so long as these restrictions do not impose an ‘undue burden’ on women seeking abortions” (House). What this is saying is, Planned Parenthood fought for the right of women to have an abortion in other states although these states may have restrictions. Although the state in which the abortion is taken place, the patient still has the right to have the abortion according to that states laws. This will increase the ability for women to have abortions...

Words: 1549 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Foundation Paper

...chosen The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundations. We live in a world today were everyday the economy grows weaker and weaker and with the world being in such great desire it is people like Bill and Melinda Gates who makes so much possible for people like you and I to survive. Through their foundation so many lives are being save every day, so many children are being educated with technology made for this generation of children to learn. I will explore several aspects of the Bill and Melinda Gate Foundation to show just how they truly make a difference in the world today. Bill and Melinda Gates are two very high profiled people their foundation is one of the largest in the world. With the founders being some of the richest people in the world with a net worth in the billions dollars, Bill and Melinda Gate Foundation has become a source of endless fascination and discussion in the nonprofit world. This foundation is about giving everyone an equal opportunity to thrive. It helps to reduce or eliminate obstacles in people lives things like poor health and nutrition and weak educational systems. Although there are a lot of things this foundation does most of it spending goes toward three main issues improving education in American, global health, and global development. When it comes to global health in January of 2010 Bill and Melinda announced their foundation would double the amount of money being spent on vaccine within the next 10 years to a sum of 10 billion dollars. Bill himself...

Words: 877 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Roosevelt and the Social Security Act

...influenced by the events of The Great Depression to pass a series of legislation. His most notable legislation that he signed into law was The Social Security Act of 1933. While Roosevelt’s original version of the bill was modified in order to pass congress, he was still extremely proud of its passing. The Social Security Act of 1933 has effected almost every working citizen since being signed into law and has had a profound social impact on our society. Much of Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s presidency was on the passing of this bill. He had enacted a similar state law while he was governor of New York. He experienced pressure to address the issue of older unemployed Americans after the great depression by supporters of Dr. Francis E. Townsend. Townsend advocated that people over 60 should be able to stop working and receive financial benefits from the federal government (Quadagno, 1984). Once Roosevelt signed the bill into law, he performed a speech for the American people. In his speech he stated, “This social security measure gives at least some protection to 50 million of our citizens who will reap direct benefits through unemployment compensation, through old-age pensions, and through increased services for the protection of children and the protection of ill health” (American Rhetoric, 2001). In his speech, Roosevelt was able to appeal to the uncertainty of employment in order to garner support for The Social Security Act of 1933 from citizens. Of course, his speech focused...

Words: 1046 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Obamacare

...policy as well as explain the history and the meaning of this policy, pro's and con's of the Obama Health Care Policy and the issues that come with it in regards to Federalism. I will also be evaluating the pro's and con's from two other perspectives. It is to my understanding that the biggest controversy with the Act would be that it is required that you purchase private health insurance or you will be faced with a fine. Although that does not include those that fall under a certain income bracket in which those that do qualify in this category Medicaid would be provided for that person for example to someone with a lower income. In other words though every person in the United States will be required to have health care insurance through a private provider or through the Federal or State assisted programs that are available by 2014. So what happens if you fail to possess the medical coverage well you are faced with penalties. The insurance will start at $95 or up to 1 percent of income, whichever is greater, and will rise to $695, or 2.5 percent of income, by 2016 (Galewitz, 2010). The history of Obama care all began back in 2008 during his election President Obama promises were to create a government program, similar to the one used in Congress, that would provide health care insurance coverage to everyone. In 2009 the controversy heightened as critics attacked Obama's health care reform plan although Obama modeled the government healthcare plan to be more like Medicare...

Words: 1320 - Pages: 6