Premium Essay

Hih Collapse

In:

Submitted By ryang
Words 7735
Pages 31
ABSTRACT
Auditing disclosures play an important role within accounting reports as they provide a level of assurance to the users (public). These disclosures will be discussed in light of the collapse of Health International Holdings (HIH). The HIH collapse warranted a Royal Commission investigation and also recorded the biggest corporate collapse in Australia's history. Corporate failures of similar magnitude such as Enron and Parmalat have occurred elsewhere and sparked large scale investigation and media scrutiny. In all of these corporate failures, the level or absence of disclosure has had a lot to do with the unexpectedness of the collapse. This paper analyses the HIH collapse within a Foucaldian framework to demonstrate the need for accountants and auditors to work together so as to avoid criticism of the profession arising from unexpected corporate failures in the future.
INTRODUCTION
The purpose of this paper is to analyse the collapse of HIH and the role of its auditor, Andersen, within a Foucauldian framework encompassing archeology and genealogy of power and knowledge. The mythical Jedi force is used as a metaphor for power attained by the accounting profession through its claim to superior knowledge and skill to be applied in the public interest. Accordingly, the force includes professional ethics. The dark side is used as a metaphor for the collapse of HIH because accounting standards and practices, the accounting profession's power base, were used to conceal impending collapse resulting in the escalation of losses to policy holders, creditors and the general public.
Regulatory responses to the Royal Commission into the collapse of HIH are viewed for purposes of this paper as the return of the Jedi in that the Corporate Law Economic Reform Programme (CLERP 9) proposals are aimed at strengthening corporate governance including auditor

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Miners

...To employees (memo) This afternoon there was a significant cave-in in the San Jose mine that resulted in 33 of our employees being trapped. They are 2300 feet underground. At this time we have no way to communicate with them. Therefore, we do not know how many, if any, are injured or if they are alive. We are working very hard to set up communication and come up with a rescue plan. We will do everything in our power to bring them home safely. We greatly value each and everyone of our employees. Please stay positive and keep the miners and their families in your thoughts and prayers. To family (face-to-face meeting) I have asked to speak with you to inform you that there has been a collapse in the San Jose mine today. The collapse has resulted in 33 men being trapped. Your husband/son is one of those men. I want you to know we are going to do everything we possibly can to rescue everyone. Unfortunately, at this time, we have no form of communication available with them. Therefore we do not know how many are injured or how many have survived. I know this is horrible news and you are very concerned about your loved one. Please take comfort in knowing we will do whatever is necessary to rescue all 33 men. We are working as fast as we can to set up communication and come up with a plan for rescue. We will keep you involved every step of the way. We will also be here to support you through this process. There is a good chance that the rescue could take...

Words: 359 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Asic V Adler Hih Insurance

...asic v adler hih insurance HIH Insurance was founded in 1968 by Ray Williams and Michael Payne, which was known as "M W Payne Underwriting Agency Pty Ltd". However, their company was acquired in 1971 by a British company called CE Heath PLC and appointed Ray Williams to be the board of CE Heath PLC in 1980. In 1989, the business operations of CE Heath PLC were transferred to CE Heath International Holdings Ltd. And the company floated on the Australian Stock Exchange in 1992. After 3 years, CE health international holdings became a subsidiary of Winterthur Swiss and was changed the name to HIH Winterthur. In 1999, HIH Winterthur acquired a large number of companies both in Australia and globally. The chief executive of FAI Insurance, Rodney Adler became a director of HIH and HIH changed its name to HIH Insurance Ltd. The reckless management by Rodney Adler, finally HIH collapsed in 2001 with debts of about $5.3billion; ASIC placed investigation into this case due to an intentional failure disclosure of financial statement by hih insurance company. The former HIH director Mr. Adler breached his duties under the sections 180, 181, 182 and 183 of Corporations Act. The criminal charges included the disclosure of misleading statement, conflict of interests and breach of director duty in good faith of the company. Mr. Adler was sentenced on 14 April 2005 to four and a half years jail, with a non-parole period of two and a half years. HIH insurance is currently in run–off...

Words: 352 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Business

...using this information to base decisions upon which to buy or sell shares. The main defendant, Adler, was found guilty of  breaching ss 180, 181, 182 and 183 of the Corporations Act. The court held that Alder benefited both himself and his family in the transactions. http://www.scribd.com/doc/18531717/CO5121-Assignment Facts Adler was a non-executive director of HIH Insurance Ltd (HIH). William was a director and the CEO of HIH. Fodera was a director and the finance controller of Hih. HIHC was a wholly owned subsidisry of hih. Adler requested and williams and fodera arranged for HIHC ot advance $10 million to Pacific Eagle Equity Pty Ltd (PEE), a company controlled by Adler. The $10 million payment was arranged so that no other director of HIH would be aware of the advance. During the next two weeks PEE used some of these funds to purchse HIH shares to the value of approximately $4 million. Through these share purchases Adler sought to support HIH’s share price for the benefit of his substantial personal shareholdings in the company. Williams was aware of the intended use of the $10 million to acquire HIH shares. Soon after a unit...

Words: 1774 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Welfare Dilemma

...The  Welfare  Dilemma  in  America   Defending  Americas  Financial  Integrity   Michael  A.  Barron,  J.D.,  CPA     Credits  To:   Claude  Allen  Barron,  Ph.D.   Merwin  Michael  Scruggs,  M.D.,  M.B.A.   Reagan  Shea  Thomas,  M.S.   ABSTRACT   I  will  attempt  to  defend  the  ever-­‐growing  problem  that  lies  within  the  current  Welfare   system  in  the  United  States  of  America,  and  try  to  explain  why  it  must  be  reformed  so   that  the  country  can  continue  to  operate  on  the  perpetual  system  of  capitalism.     College of Business | School of Accountancy In a world of increasing demand and decreasing supply by way of domestic distributors, we may at times wonder why the prices of many different resources soar at astronomical prices. The answer to this question is very simple when you just think about it in its entirety; we can simply call the influences of these prices, market externalities. Market externalities often times are confused with how desire influences the world around us, but instead these externalities are caused by outside influences such as government mandate or outsourcing from one country to another. The externalities will continue with the times to keep up with a world of great demand, but there will be no greater supply. This seminar will be composed of only two parts...

Words: 2201 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Affection of Reinforcement Schedule to Pet Training

...According to B. F. Skinner (Science and Human Behavior, 1965), the Operant Conditioning is the process by which a response becomes more or less likely to occur depending on its consequences. The schedule of reinforcement is an important component of learning process under the Operant Conditioning. I would like to apply this theory on the 2 dogs with same age in 2 different educating situation.  The 2 objects of study are Yorkshire Terrier in my cousin’s home and Toy Poodle in ours. The Yorkshire Terrier was educated under random schedule, while the Toy Poodle was educated under continuous reinforcement schedule.  While house training the Yorkshire Terrier and Toy Poodle, classical conditioning was applied. In order to communicate the command and action to the 2 objects, we applied the motivational training. Motivational training engages the use of rewards to strengthen good performance, and overlooks all bad behavior (Marlo Shelby, 1999). It is based on Thorndike's Law of Effect (Burch Mary R. and Jon S. Bailey, 1999), which states that actions that generate rewards tend to increase in regularity and actions that do not generate rewards decrease in frequency. We brought both Yorkshire Terrier and Toy Poodle into the cage while saying the command “House” then gave them snacks, after that we reward them with snacks whenever they get into the cage. Both Yorkshire Terrier and Toy Poodle learnt to get to the cage with the command “House”. After learning the command, Yorkshire...

Words: 659 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Peace

...How Did The Great Depression Affect the South? The Great Depression in the South came at a time when the South was still not fully recovered from the civil war. As a result the economy was already in worse shape than their thriving Northern counterparts. The South was the poorest section of the depression with a per capita income ½ of that of the northern states. Workers struggled to feed their families even before the stock market crash of 1929. As people who would be interviewed later on would state, “those were the good old days, but the good old days were pretty tough.” After the depression hit the south fell into even worse hardship. One county in North Carolina saw 3,500 Farm Foreclosures out of 5,280 farms in the county in a single year. This means if you were farming during that time period and lived next to two other farmers’ chances are two out of the three of you would have lost your farm within the year, an amazingly high figure. A swarm of Locus and a drought hurt farmers even more by making it harder for them to grow their crops. Governments in the South during the great depression responded to the economic disaster by raising the sales tax and cutting spending on government programs. These two things lead to an even greater disaster. All of the problems in the South lead Franklin Roosevelt to refer to the south during the great depression as the nation’s number one...

Words: 255 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

The United States and the Fall of Rome a Looking Similar

...The United States and The Fall of Rome a Looking Similar Rome had many downfalls to lead towards its demise like political corruption, military spending and greed. You would think those things don’t exist in the great nation of the United States, but if you thought that then you are clearly ignorant. There are plenty of similarities between the downfall of Rome and the United States, which are economic instability, spreading the military too thin and inflation. The Decline of Rome was due to numerous items such as economic instability, taxation, military dissipation and political corruption. During the years of the downfall Rome began to rely on imports from other countries such as Egypt. Rome imported more then they exported which was a deficiency in income. Once Caesar obtained power he then started to acquire more and more land, which was filled with greed. He wanted people to perceive him to be higher then the gods they people celebrated. This became a problem across Rome and so diversity among religions was considered, “ against the rules.” Caesar began to have relations with Cleopatra. This then turned into a rule of lovers, which they wanted to take over the eastern hemisphere. With the military spread to thin, sickness and zero surplus of food the nation crumbled. Without a military to defend them Rome would easily be invaded and dismissed as a civilization. Though the United States may not be the Fall of Rome, both civilizations had copious things in common. Such...

Words: 521 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Collapse

...Over the years, there have been so many societies that have collapsed. Jared Diamond, a scientist who studies societies and their declines, believes that a collapse results from environmental damage, climate change, hostile neighbors, friendly trade partners, or a societies response to the their problems (11). Diamond wrote about many societies in his engrossing book Collapse, but out of them all, the Greenland Norse seems to be the one that supports his ideas and opinions the most. The Greenland Norse was a landscape where Vikings settled, but unfortunately their civilization came to an end after being severely damaged. As Jared Diamond would say "collapse isn't inevitable but depends on a society's choices" (21). This shows that the actions of the colonist that settled in Greenland were the main prospect of its end. Overall the collapse of Greenland Norse is instructive because it declined from deforestation and soil erosion, colder climates, military issues with their neighbors, cut-off trade with Europe, and their inability to adopt useful methods from their surrounding societies; these problems fall into all of Jared Diamonds factors in his five point framework impeccably proving his theory. Firstly, the Norse caused ecological downfall by all the reckless logging and farming they did, which resulted in soil erosion and deforestation. Due to this, the settlers lost lumber, firewood, and iron (Diamond 250). Lumber and firewood were scarce because there was no trees left...

Words: 992 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

I Don't Know

...Zhiyi Song (Song) Principles of Macroeconomics G03 Professor Jean-Pierre Mulumba January 15, 2016 Summary of “Pitfalls to Sound Economic Reasoning” There are five common pitfalls to avoid when people are applying the economic perspective. The first one is biases. People usually bring their biases to the businesses. Government regulation is not always good for everybody’s economics. People should abandon their preconceptions of the economics, then they can avoid the pitfalls. The second one is loaded terminology. People get many information and loaded terminology from newspapers and broadcast media. Some people think that all the government workers are “mindless bureaucrats”,and all the high profits are “obscene”. Those wrong opinions make people far away from success. The third one is fallacy of composition. People should jump our of their own world to see the whole economics, so that people could get a better view and make good decisions. People should not let the fallacy confuse them. The fourth one is post hoc fallacy. Sometimes, people think event A is the cause of event B because A precedes B. But not all the situation are the same. There is an example that the Great Depression. Many people don’t think that the weaknesses in the economy caused the Great Depression, they think the stock market crash caused it. People should not look at the whole situation to find the cause of an event.The last one is correlation. Many people think that if variable X increases and Y also...

Words: 292 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Distortion

...VISUAL DISTORTIONS NEAR A NEUTRON STAR AND BLACK HOLE ABSTRACT The visual distortion effects visible to an observer traveling around and descending to the surface of an extremely compact star are described. Specifically, trips to a "normal" neutron star with relatively weak surface gravity, an ultracompact neutron star with extremely high surface gravity, and a black hole are described. Concepts such as multiple imaging, red- and blue-shifting, conservation of surface brightness, the photon sphere, and the existence of multiple Einstein rings are discussed in terms of what the viewer would see. Computer generated, general relativistically correct illustrations highlighting the distortion effects are presented and discussed. A short movie (VHS) depicting many of these effects is available to those interested free of charge. I. BACKGROUND It is impossible for a human to travel very near a high gravity star which has a mass like that of the Sun. If, somehow, a person could survive the extremely harmful radiation that would be emitted on or near these objects, the high gravity itself would likely pose insurmountable problems. The person could not stand casually on the surface of such a star because the high surface gravity would tend to flatten them. (Lying down wouldn't help.) Were a person to orbit the star in a spaceship, however, the immense gravitational field would be overcome by a large outward centrifugal acceleration.[1] The problem in this case, however, is the...

Words: 885 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Bcom

...Knowing Your Audience Nicole Mills BCOM/275 2/27/2012 Mark Trollinger Knowing Your Audience Understanding the needs of your audience is always important, but even more vital when dealing with disasters such as the Chilean copper mine collapse in 2010. In a scenario as dire as this, a company must address the families, friends, co-workers of the miners, and the community. Public relations officers must remain composed, polite, empathetic, and optimistic when providing information to the internal and external audience members. Employees will typically become aware of the disaster as it happens. However, family members must be contacted immediately. The family members of the trapped miners should either be contacted by phone or in person, whichever is more viable depending on the number of employees affected and the capabilities of the company. After receiving the devastating news, family and friends should be allowed on site to be provided with support and as many answers as possible. Employees should be provided with information through a channel such as a memo until a meeting can be arranged to answer further questions and address pending concerns. Employees should be provided with more facts and guaranteed that the safety of their co-workers is the company’s number one priority. A support group or counselor should be offered to console family members and co-workers in distress. Communication Directed Toward Families Family members of...

Words: 1162 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Bees

...Life without Bees By: Aisha Walker The Current situation: Life without Bees Colony collapse disorder, as situation in which adult bees become crucial to the colony’s survival by abandonment of the hive by either dying or flying off. The disorder was uncannily reminiscent of the mysterious disappearance of the Mayans centuries ago, and as the crisis continued, researches scrambled to learn why our bees were declining and determine what to do. Colony collapse disorders has wiped out over 10 million bee hives percent annually in recent years and there are now about $2 billion over the past six years. The death rate for colonies has hit 30 the U.S; down from 6 million in 1947 and 3 million in 1990. That downward spiral leaves”virtually no cushion of bees for pollination’” the report authors write. In recent years, agricultural pesticides have become a leading suspect in bee deaths. Attention has focused on a class of chemicals called neonicotinoids as global concern grows over the bee population crash, which has affected several European countries too.But scientist increasingly believe several interacting factors from diseases carrying parasites to poor nutrition to pesticides and is responsible for the mass die off. For instance, the report says studies have shown that exposure to even non-fatal levels of neonicotinoids may make bees more susceptible to disease; and as agriculture becomes more industrial and natural habitats that formerly bordered farmland are destroyed...

Words: 607 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Colony Collaspe Disorder

...Colony Collapse Disorder LaTisha R. Caldwell-Bullis Columbia Southern University Abstract The mysterious, yet abrupt disappearance of honey bees from the beehive is known as colony collapse disorder or CCD. The disorder used to be known as disappearing disease, May disease, and even fall dwindle disease yet was given its current name, Colony Collapse Disorder, late in 2006. It was renamed after the abrupt and disturbing vanishing of Western honeybee colonies here in North America, yet the same occurrence was noticed in Europe in areas such as France and the Netherlands (Wikipedia, 2014). The shortage in honeybees and their natural pollination services has led to an increase in farmers having to rent pollination services to service their crops. There are many factors to blame for the shortage of honey bees, for example, pesticides and insecticides such as neonicotinoids, malnutrition, pathogens, genetic factors, immunodeficiencies, loss of habitats, and declining beekeeping practices, antibiotics, and miticides. Some other causes of CCD are contamination, parasite loads in bees and brood, nutritional fitness of adult bees, stress levels, and a total lack of genetic diversity (Sutphin, 2014). The focus for this particular case study will be on neonicotinoids, antibiotics, and they were developed because at the time, they showed less of a toxic effect on humans and crops, as compared to organophosphate and carbonate insecticides. The mysterious, yet abrupt disappearance of honey...

Words: 1603 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Collapse

...Collapse- book is about a history topic about how societies choose to fail or survive. The main characters are historical people and unknown kings of Mayan cities or Easter Island villages. Jared Diamond tells the story of the Viking explorer Erik the Red, who discovered Greeland and Vinland (Terranova, in Canada). Another character is captain Olafsson, a norse sailor who wrote the last news about Greenland in 1410. Another main character is Christopher Columbus, who arrived at Hispaniola in 1492, but now this island is two countries, the Dominican Republic and the Haiti. Diamond studied the politics of two presidents. the dominican Rafael Trujillo, who protected the enviroment and the dictator François, Papa Doc, Duvalier, who decided on politics of deforestatation of his country, Haiti. The author considered the bad politics of another main character, king George II, who was interested in sending merinosheeps from Spain to Australia, an idea which was succesful from 1820 to 1950 but then the farmers understood their lands lost fertility. Another main character is Tokuwaga Jeayasu, a shogun of Japan in 1600, who prohibited Christianity in 1600 and protected his country againt deforestation.  The book takes us to a lot of places around the globe: Mayan cities, Rwanda, Viking colonies of Vinland or Greenland, Haiti and Dominican Republic, Easter Island and Polynesian colonies in Pacific, and the Chaco villages in New Mexico (United States). The time period was from 800 AC, when...

Words: 22095 - Pages: 89

Premium Essay

Miss

...study in corporate collapse: HIH 1 Briefly describe the ‘HIH story’ On 15 March 2001 the HIH Insurance group required liquidation. Formal winding-up orders were made on 27 August 2001—the corporate equivalent of death. By then the deficiency of the group was estimated to be between $3.6 billion and $5.3 billion. The collapse of HIH is the largest corporate failure in Australia. That’s because HIH failed to see, remedy or report what it should be do, and even ignored and concealed the true state of HIH’s steadily deteriorating financial position. The collapse of HIH has reverberated throughout the community, with the following serious consequences: harming to individual, community distress, consequences for the public. 2 Who was affected by its collapse? Firstly, the collapse affects most individual who got benefits from HIH. For example, About 200 permanently disabled people no longer receive their regular payments from HIH. These people have joined other unsecured creditors and policyholders, and they all face a wait of up to 10 years before receiving what the liquidator has predicted will be a ‘very poor’ payment. Secondly, many local industries and organizations are involved by the collapse. For instance, some non-profit organizations have been forced to shut down businesses. A local theatre had to close its doors, with the loss of 70 jobs, because it did not receive sponsorship funds that had been promised by HIH. Thirdly, the collapse caused bad effects...

Words: 557 - Pages: 3