Free Essay

Hoplite Book Review

In:

Submitted By bondsjk
Words 1450
Pages 6
Book Review of Hoplites: The Classical Greek Battle Experience

Kyle Bonds
History 3300, Dr. Kicklighter
09 October 2013

Kyle Bonds
Dr. Joseph Kicklighter
9 October 2013
History 3300
Hoplites: The Classical Greek Battle Experience Review Collected and edited by Victor Davis Hanson, Hoplites: The Classical Greek Battle Experience is a collection of nine scholarly essays specifically about the Hoplite warrior: describing the weapons used, how the identification and retrieval of casualties was conducted, the style of phalanx battle from the perspective of the actual soldier fighting as well as sacrifices and battle rituals. He reveals a new experience to the reader using these works, one that sheds new light on the hoplite warrior. Born on September 5th, 1953, Victor Hanson is a military historian and columnist specializing in the study of the classics and ancient warfare. Most notably known for his contributions on modern warfare and contemporary politics for the National Review he has published a number of books on ancient warfare and the classics most on Greek warfare and the Peloponnesian Wars. Keeping his love for the classics intact he received his Ph.D in that field from Stanford University in 1980. Hanson recently relinquished his position and California State University where he began teaching in 1984 where his solely responsible for the creation of the classics program. He currently writes two articles per week for the National Review.

Although much scholarly research and publication has been made available on the topic of hoplite warfare, the collection of unpublished essays that Hanson has brought together has undoubtedly opened a new perspective of battle itself. Hanson may have very well been the first to successfully bring to light the events of battle. From the actions taken before blood had been spilled, those taken while fighting was in full swing, and until the last man who had so courageously fought, lay lifeless on the battlefield, no detail is overlooked by these authors in their works. The book opens with an imperative introductory essay by Hanson himself. In this essay he points out some of the many characteristics of the hoplite warrior. Speaking of the heavy armor worn but also of the hoplite’s background, saying “Greek warfare as something other than a deliberate, contrived contest between small farmers” (Hanson 8). He addresses the misconceptions and misconstrues that many leading experts and scholars have on the topic. In particular he cites Hans Delbrück’s blinded idea that Greek warfare could not be understood unless it were “explicable through analogy to the common practice of the German army” (Hanson 9). This collection of essays differed in from many works that are similar on the subject of hoplite warfare in that it didn't predominately examine Greek battle in terms of strategy, tactics, politics, or similar macro-issues. Instead, this truly observed the Hoplite soldier from personal view. The book seduces the reader into the very agonizing reality of battle. As if the reader was standing in rank beside the hoplite soldier as he faces brutal hand to hand combat, a much more personal aspect to a previously foreign ideology. The readers finds themselves taking roles in the ritualistic sacrifice of animals before battle, the invocation of the gods and the retrieval of their fallen comrades after the fog of war had dissipated. What was it like to wear the brass armor and carry a shield, what was the importance of sacrifice before giving battle? Why would someone willingly enter such a zone of death? Each author plays a pivotal role in educating the reader on hoplite warfare. Hanson’s own introduction on the ideology of hoplite warfare eases the transition to Anderson’s essay on weapons, Wheeler’s explanation of how hoplite command was utilized, Ober on the obstacles hoplite warfare faced, and most insightful was John Lazenby’s The Killing Zone. Lazenby speaks of how hoplite numbers were utilized and how different polis’ utilized them. He explains that the norm of hoplites was to have their files eight deep or more. However extraordinary cases would show the “greatest depth recorded [as] the ‘fifty shields’ of the Thebans at Leuktra” (Hanson 88). In addition to equipment used and logistics employed, the traditions of battle are also explored. Peter Krentz devotes his work on how the salpinx-a trumpet like instrument used by ancient Greeks- was utilized and how it affected battle. Mainly used to sound a charge, it was also a pivotal tool in battlefield communication. Pamela Vaughn discusses the importance the treatment of the dead were to the Greeks. Given the upmost priority due to the role of divinity played in battle as described by Michael Jameson and AH Jackson, it was imperative that each Greek killed in battle was given his last rites. Considering the magnitude of some of the battles, this posed a serious logistical problem. Never straying from the importance of tradition and the last rites of warriors, animal drawn carts would collect the dead with minute progress. Often over the rudimentary terrain of Greece, this act showed the dedication that Greeks had to the protection of their traditions. In the book, Hanson gives dedication to another historical writer’s work entitled The Face of Battle. Written by John Keegan, the book deals with the feel of battle rather than how it looks from a tactical standpoint. Admiration for the piece is given due the similar nature of Hanson’s collection of essays. Both sought out to bring the reader to the experience of battle and indulge a different perspective on how hoplite warfare is studied and analyzed. A key difference exists in the writers of the two pieces. Although both share the urge to feel the battle, Hanson was the only one to which opportunity would present itself to place him in the most similar situation as possible to the hoplites. Hanson’s collection should serve as more desirable education tool due to his military experience. While surely well written, Keegan’s lack of military service sheds more credibility towards Hanson. Hanson himself makes not of this very subtlety by referencing “what Eudamidas, the son of Archidamos, said when he heard a philosopher speaking about generalship: ‘The speech is admirable, but the speaker is untrustworthy, for he has never heard the salpinx’” (Hanson 119(Plutarch. Mor. 220E)). In addition to Hoplites: The Classical Greek Battle Experience, Hanson has authored many books on ancient Greece and their warfare. One in particular has sharp similarities to the title being reviewed. Published in 2009, The Western Way of War: Infantry Battle in Classical Greece, makes a point that not only did the Greeks invent the central ideas of western politics, but that they are responsible for the way the west conducts war in the decisive infantry battle. The book states that they devised a ferocious and destructive way to conduct war. He aims to link this then, new style of fighting, to the rise of the constitutional government in Athens and other city-states of Greece.

In examination of Hoplites: The Classical Greek Battle Experience the ever important style of highlighting the experience the soldier himself felt rather than the commanding general. Hanson believes it more educational to the reader to show the process of how the backbone of hoplite warfare, the Greek farmer, makes the transition from tending crops to donning nearly 80 pounds of armor in the hot summer. Lining up with his fellow soldiers and charging a murderous row of brass tipped spears to settle border disputes in a single climactic clash. Although we shall never know the true experience of lining up with Thebes “fifty shields deep” Hanson makes a valiant effort with the collection of these scholar’s essays to piece together the puzzle of hoplite warfare. With as much information as historians and scholars have unearthed about ancient Greek warfare, there is still pieces to be placed. From the book we are given an image of battle that will shape how western armies wage war and form the importance of decisive battle. It is to the common Greek hoplite farmer that we owe this legacy, and we owe it to them to understand what this form of battle was like. The interest now has shifted to attempting to gain as realistic experience as possible in order to further understand the human condition that is that of a hoplite warrior.

Works Cited:
Hanson, Victor Davis. Hoplites: The Classical Greek Battle Experience, Routledge; Reprint edition (November 15, 1993).
Hanson, Victor Davis. The Western Way of War: Infantry Battle in Classical Greece, Knopf; 1st edition (April 15, 1989).
Keegan, John. The Face of Battle, Penguin Books; Reprint edition (January 27, 1983)
Walcot, P. "Subject Reviews: Reprints." Greece & Rome 41.2 (1994): 253. Academic Search Premier. Web. 08 Oct. 2013

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Book Reviews

...1. Good Review – The good review I found was on goodreads.com for Life of Pi. The author of the review did not regurgitate the synopsis found on the back of the book nor laden the review with spoilers, but rather gave his/her opinion on the book, the narrative style, writing and structure and what was enjoyable about the book for him/her. 2. Bad Review – I found a bad review on amazon.com for The Girl on the Train. The reviewer, J.Regan, noted that the story was well written, that it keeps the reader’s attention but that the main character could be hard to like at times. There was no detail as to the writing style, nor why or how the author was able to keep reader’s attention. The reviewer also failed to explain why he/she did not like the main character at points in the book. With no further details, this review does not help someone interested in the book decide whether they may like it or not. 3. Fake Review – As I was looking for reviews on the book I’m reading for the critical review project, I Don’t Have a Thing to Wear: The Psychology of Your Closet, I found a title of a review that struck me as odd and the review itself was a bit over the top which to me comes off as fake. It was rated five stars and the review appears to be written by a girl’s boyfriend stating that “she can’t put it down” and “she just raves about it constantly” (Bouton, 2003). The one part that really puts me off about this review is that he says “and I wish I had a nickel for each time I've...

Words: 578 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Writing a Book Report

...Writing a Book Report Summary: This resource discusses book reports and how to write them. Contributors: Purdue OWL (owl.English.purdue.edu) Book reports are informative reports that discuss a book from an objective stance. They are similar to book reviews but focus more on a summary of the work than an evaluation of it. Book reports commonly describe what happens in a work; their focus is primarily on giving an account of the major plot, characters, thesis, and/or main idea of the work. Most often, book reports range from 250 to 500 words. Before You Read Before you begin to read, consider what types of things you will need to write your book report. First, you will need to get some basic information from the book: • Author • Title • Publisher location, name of publisher, year published • Number of Pages You can either begin your report with some sort of citation, or you can incorporate some of these items into the report itself. Next, try to answer the following questions to get you started thinking about the book: • Author: Who is the author? Have you read any other works by this author? • Genre: What type of book is this: fiction, nonfiction, biography, etc.? What types of people would like to read this kind of book? Do you typically read these kinds of books? Do you like them? • Title: What does the title do for you? Does it spark your interest? Does it fit well with the text of the book? • Pictures/Book Jacket/Cover/Printing:...

Words: 645 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

How to Write a Book Report

...How to Write a Book Review The purpose of a book review in the most basic sense is to convey to the reader what the book is about and whether it is worth reading or not. A good book review expands upon these two areas. When describing the book the following should be included: • The vital statistics: the title, author, publisher, price, paperback or hardback, length, illustrations, if it has been translated • The type of material: fiction, nonfiction, essay, poetry, biography • The contents: describe what the book is about, the plot, its purpose, its organization • Information about the author: what they have written before, other prominent work, their qualifications • A quoted passage: to allow the reader to see important information and a sense of the writer’s style. When providing judgment of the book it should be followed by the reason why that judgment was made. It should provide enough support for the reader to decide whether or not they want to read or buy the book. The following are examples of what to make judgments on: • Intent or purpose: how well the author realized their intent or fulfilled the purpose of the book • Relevancy: if the book is relevant to the real world and our time • Accuracy: whether the book works or fails based on its accuracy or errors • Uniqueness: comment on the unique qualities of the book • Audience: a comment on the intended audience of the book or its appeal to other potential readers In addition...

Words: 1197 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Driver License

...Before The Test Before you take the test reviewing is important like different kinds of review like: Daily review. It includes short preclass and postclass review of lecture notes and also textbooks. Do weekly reviews. It includes reviewing at least 1 hour per subject once a week. Do major review. It helps when conducted the week before finals or other critical exams. Schedule reviews. Schedule specific times in your calendar for review. Take a practice test. Take a practice test before the actual test. Get copies of Old exams. Old test can help to review stratify. During The Test Prepare self for test by arriving early. Used scratch paper to make quick note in the margins of test sheet. Read direction slowly and answer the easiest, shortest question first. Follow your time and plan your time. Read the entire question, read all possible answer and eliminate incorrect answer. Find out what is asking and make outline on essay writing question, make a point and write legibly. After The Test After the tests take a few minute to write discovery statement related to your experience of taking test. Describe how effective your review strategies were. Do differently to prepare for the next test. When test is returned look the test items that you missed. Carefully analyze the source of errors and find a solution. 2) Test score measure your accomplishment in a course is false because test score is measure what student scored on test. If you anxious about a test...

Words: 484 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Web-Tech

...com/questions_otherbooks.html In depth study questions for various well-known YA books. Favorite Teenage Angst Books http://www.grouchy.com/angst/ Read books reviews for older teenagers, arranged by themes. Secondary English http://www.secondaryenglish.com/ Book reviews, articles, columns and powerpoint presentations. Teenreads http://www.teenreads.com Contains book reviews, new books to read, suggestions for creating your own book club. Reading Rants – Out of the Ordinary Teen Booklists http://members.tln.lib.mi.us/~amutch/jen/ As its title suggests, this site contains book lists and reviews according to unusual categories, such as Slacker Fiction, Out of the Closet, Teen Tearjerkers, etc. Harper Teen Fanlit http://forums.harperteenfanlit.com/blogs/the_daily_blog/default.aspx Contains a daily blog written by different YA authors about their texts. Teaching Literature http://www.teachingliterature.org/teachingliterature/ Companion website to a text book; contains a great section on YA literature with a comprehensive list of web sites related to teaching YA literature. Reviewers Checklist http://www.reviewerschecklist.com/ Online database to help children, teens and families find books by topic, publisher, series, etc. Middle & High School: Literature in Mathematics http://sci.tamucc.edu/~eyoung/middle_school_literature.html Contains a chart of books organized by the math topic being addressed. Just One More Book...

Words: 1025 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Book Critique

...How to Write a Book Critique PURPOSE OF THE ASSIGNMENT: The idea behind this assignment is to give you the opportunity to read a detailed historical account on a particular subject and to analyze the book critically. The paper you will be writing should be a book critique, rather than a book report. In a book report, you simply summarize the book. In a book critique, you go much further - you analyze and evaluate the book. WHAT A BOOK CRITIQUE SHOULD INCLUDE: There are many things you should do in a good book critique. How much attention you give to these different components of the critique may vary depending on the book you are analyzing. 1. Summarize the book. Yes, despite what I said above about the difference between a book report and a critique, you nonetheless need to do some summarizing in your critique. You need to describe what the book is about in enough detail that someone who hasn’t read the book has a clear idea of the topic the author is addressing, the parameters of the book, and how the book is organized. If you don’t give your reader some idea what the book is about, then you may lose your reader when you start analyzing the book. Note that a chapter-by-chapter summary of the book is not needed. A general summary of the main points will be sufficient. 2. Identify the author’s purpose. What does your author want to accomplish with this book? What audience is the book intended for? Your author may want to fill a gap in historical literature...

Words: 1195 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Research

...INTRODUCTION Background of the Study Pre-Exam review is a paid service the school offers two weeks before the exam proper. It reviews the student about his or her lessons during the quarter. It usually starts after dismissals and ends at five-thirty to six in the evening. This review usually has Saturday review sessions. The said review is only exclusive for the ones who paid. Josephian teachers are also the ones reviewing the students. However, subject teachers of a certain level are not allowed to review the same level of students. Sometimes, non-examinee distracts the session. Students that paid for the review sometimes skip sessions of their review and do other things like play sports or just laze around. However, students should be listening attentively to the teacher reviewing them. They should be present during the scheduled sessions until the end of it. Pre-exam review (definition from SJS handbook) Statement of the Problem The study will be conducted during the researcher’s free time. The questionnaires will be given to the subject/s of the study. It will be gathered after they answer or during free time. The papers will be labeled with their data and control number so that the researcher won’t have a hard time gathering or tallying answers. The subject/s of the study shall answer the set of questions prepared for them. Objectives of the Study The general objective of the study is to determine the effects of pre-exam review amongst Grade 8 and Grade 9 students of St...

Words: 298 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

The 7 Habits

...Center Book Reviews Like 17 people like this. What this handout is about This handout will help you write a book review, a report or essay that offers a critical perspective on a text. It offers a process and suggests some strategies for writing book reviews. What is a review? A review is a critical evaluation of a text, event, object, or phenomenon. Reviews can consider books, articles, entire genres or fields of literature, architecture, art, fashion, restaurants, policies, exhibitions, performances, and many other forms. This handout will focus on book reviews. Above all, a review makes an argument. The most important element of a review is that it is a commentary, not merely a summary. It allows you to enter into dialogue and discussion with the work’s creator and with other audiences. You can offer agreement or disagreement and identify where you find the work exemplary or deficient in its knowledge, judgments, or organization. You should clearly state your opinion of the work in question, and that statement will probably resemble other types of academic writing, with a thesis statement, supporting body paragraphs, and a conclusion. Typically, reviews are brief. In newspapers and academic journals, they rarely exceed 1000 words, although you may encounter lengthier assignments and extended commentaries. In either case, reviews need to be succinct. While they vary in tone, subject, and style, they share some common features: First, a review gives...

Words: 2547 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Literature Research

...Literature Research Literature reviews are completed by students to learn the proper format for setting up their own research projects. The following is information gleaned on what a literature review is, why it is conducted, and how to understand completing one . Additional information on how to write a review is covered as well. A literature review surveys scholarly articles, books and other sources relevant to a particular issue, area of research, or theory, and by so doing, providing a description, summary, and critical evaluation of these works. Literature reviews are designed to provide an overview of sources you have explored while researching a particular topic and to demonstrate to your readers how your research fits into the larger field of study. A literature review may consist of simple a summary of key sources, but it usually has an organizational pattern and combines both summary and synthesis, often within specific conceptual categories. A summary is a recap of the important information of the source, but a synthesis is a re-organization, or a reshuffling, of that information in a way that informs how you are planning to investigate a research problem. The analytical features of a literature review might: * Give a new interpretation of old material or combine new with old interpretations, * Trace the intellectual progression of the field, including major debates, * Depending on the situation, evaluate the sources and advise the reader on the...

Words: 887 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Online Image and Reputation

...Online Image and Reputation: Mitigating Negative Impact of False Reviews on Service Industry Businesses Texas A&M University-Commerce Texas A&M University-Commerce Table of Contents Abstract 3 Chapter 1: Introduction 4 Chapter 2: Review of the Literature 6 Chapter 3: Methodology 11 Chapter 4: Findings 12 Chapter 5: Summary, Conclusions, and Recommendations 14 References 15 Appendix 17 Abstract Online reviews are becoming an increasingly important component in generating a business’s image and reputation. Service industry businesses, particularly those that rely on positive word-of-mouth, are exposed to the negative influence of fake reviews and false ratings. This paper explores the ways that online reviews are manipulated, highlighting the effects of the social and anonymous nature of the Internet and online review sites. Additionally, this paper examines several methods that can be employed to mitigate the long-term impact of false or manipulated reviews, including a brief review of US law, and the monitoring of review sites to ensure that identifiably false reviews are removed. Keywords: online ratings, service industry, review manipulation Online Image and Reputation: Mitigating Negative Impact of False Reviews on Service Industry Businesses Chapter 1: Introduction Background Businesses, especially service industry businesses like hotels, restaurants, and rental agencies, rely on several methods of reaching out to potential...

Words: 3850 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

The Impacts of Social Media

...able to rate, review and share opinions on products at the palm of their hands. The high usage of social media sites is creating a new medium for companies to communicate with consumers on a personal level they were not able to years ago. With the usage of smartphones sky rocketing consumers are now able give their “two cents” about products or services the second they experience them. This is an essential element for companies and consumers because social media allows them to view reactions about new products, whether they are negative or positive. Where would you like to eat tonight? Be daring and try the new bistro that just opened down the street or play it safe and go to Applebee’s? This could be one of the most daunting decisions someone may have to make throughout their day. When it comes to where one would like to spend their hard earned dollar on a meal 45% of consumers turn to leading social media sites like Yelp for recommendations (Pann). 57% of consumers rely on the reviews from these sites on restaurants to determine where they will dine that night (Pann). But how reliable are these reviews that consumers are putting such high importance when it comes to their dining experiences? When it comes to the reviews on websites such as Yelp, a recent study by Gartner a tech research company has determined by 2014 that 10% to 15% of reviews found on these sites are falsified (Pann). These falsified reviews are hurting the reputation of social media review sites because...

Words: 1472 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Engineer

...How to Write a Book Critique PURPOSE OF THE ASSIGNMENT: The idea behind this assignment is to give you the opportunity to read a detailed historical account on a particular subject and to analyze the book critically. The paper you will be writing should be a book critique, rather than a book report. In a book report, you simply summarize the book. In a book critique, you go much further - you analyze and evaluate the book. WHAT A BOOK CRITIQUE SHOULD INCLUDE: There are many things you should do in a good book critique. How much attention you give to these different components of the critique may vary depending on the book you are analyzing. 1. Summarize the book. Yes, despite what I said above about the difference between a book report and a critique, you nonetheless need to do some summarizing in your critique. You need to describe what the book is about in enough detail that someone who hasn’t read the book has a clear idea of the topic the author is addressing, the parameters of the book, and how the book is organized. If you don’t give your reader some idea what the book is about, then you may lose your reader when you start analyzing the book. Note that a chapter-by-chapter summary of the book is not needed. A general summary of the main points will be sufficient. 2. Identify the author’s purpose. What does your author want to accomplish with this book? What audience is the book intended for? Your author may want to fill a gap in historical literature...

Words: 1195 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Book Review

...Test Object Thing(ness) 1. Read this (this thing 1 cm. below) P. J. O’Rourke, the political satirist, reviews in this issue a new book about Starbucks. He told us, in an e-mail exchange, how he brews his own reviews: “I read something I’m reviewing the same way I read other things except more so. That is, I already keep a commonplace book (a file folder, really) for quotations, ideas, information, etc. If I’m going to write a review I mark the work for myself, but besides underlining what interests me I also underline what — as far as I can tell — interested the author. By the time I’m done I have an outline for the review. All I have to do is figure out a smart-aleck lead sentence and a wiseacre ending.”[1] 2. Then read the “How to write a Book Review” article on the very next page. Yes, it is a bit long but the information is really quite good. 3. Over the week go to www.salon.com or to http://www.nytimes.com/pages/books read at least five reviews and then divide them into good and bad reviews. Think about the specific qualities that define the better ones. The article from step two of this process will be helpful at this point. At the end of the day a good book review sees an interesting pattern or spins your understanding of the book in a new and delightful way…and importantly is enjoyable to read (as a writer you need to have fun savaging the book, exploring it, dwelling on it, falling in love with it, etc.). Finally remember that your job is to convince...

Words: 2230 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Citations

...Bibliographic Citations I. Each of the following resource citations has three parts. ❑ The first part is the type of resource (for example, “Book, one author”). The BOLD Comic Sans font in 14 pt identifies this part of each citation. ❑ The second part is a template containing the components needed to cite the resource. The grey boxes       identify the template in each citation. This part is in 12 pt Times New Roman. ❑ The third part provides an actual example of a resource found in a Lexington County District One Library Media Center. The red font in 12 pt Times New Roman, double-spaced lines and hanging indent identify this part of each citation. II. To use the citation template, highlight the template for the resource you need to cite, then copy and paste into your paper. 1st_Author's_LastName, 1st_Author's_FirstName, and 2nd_Author's_FirstName 2nd_Author's_LastName. Title. City_of_Publication: Publisher, Date_of_Publication. III. Select one of the grey boxes and type the correct information. As soon as you click on each grey box to select it, it is highlighted—do not delete the grey box—just start typing. Notice in the sample below, “Warhol” has replaced the grey box that said “1st_Author’s_LastName” in Step II above. Warhol, 1st_Author's_FirstName, and 2nd_Author's_FirstName 2nd_Author's_LastName. Title. City_of_Publication: Publisher, Date_of_Publication. IV. The punctuation, italics, and underlines will be inserted automatically...

Words: 5909 - Pages: 24

Free Essay

How Does J.M Coetzee Present David Lurie and What Do We Learn About Him?

...How does J.M. Coetzee present David Lurie in chapter one and what do we learn about him? Coetzee’s novel Disgrace appears to be centred around an immature, arrogant, self-centred David Lurie. In the novel as a whole but particularly chapter one Coetzee demonstrates, through Lurie, the loss of power due to age and the loss of ‘white rights’ as the novel is set in South Africa after the apartheid. The loss of power links with Tennessee Williams’ play ‘A streetcar named Desire’ as both the protagonists demonstrate the loss of power and their unconventional coping strategies. Coetzee shows the reader the negative impact breaking away from the norms of society can have upon an individual. I think David Lurie is a character with whom the reader should sympathise with as he does not know who he is which may be what causes him to act in an irrational way. Furthermore I believe Coetzee aims to make the reader feel detached and uncomfortable in the first chapter thus reflecting Lurie’s feelings about this ‘new world’. The theme of age and maturity is presented heavily throughout the novel. Growing old appears to be an unfortunate thing in the novel as Coetzee claims ‘for a man of his age’ Lurie has ‘solved the problem of sex rather well’. The beginning of this statement gives a disparaging view of again and could cause the reader to believe that growing old is something we should resist. However this is contradicted by the second part of the sentence as it gives the impression that...

Words: 1330 - Pages: 6