...marketplace of ideas, MBP is a direct competitor to Management by Objectives (MBO) - the prevailing style of organizational management for over 50 years. MBP is relatively new, but it is a very potent improvement over MBO. That's why I believe MBP is the next great frontier of organizational leadership and organizational management - if we can give MBP a strong foundation. This article defines MBP in a new way, so that it is more competitive with MBO. This article also shows how MBP can benefit from the "radically simple" implementation of Earned Value Management (EVM) that we explored in the previous two articles in this series [1][2]. What is MBO? Management by Objectives is a "technique used to manage people based on documented work statements mutually agreed to by manager and worker. Progress is periodically reviewed, and in a proper implementation, the worker's remuneration is tied to performance."[3](p.339). MBO "is the prevailing style of management in most organizations" and it "entails giving employees goals/targets, measuring their performance against these targets, and then ranking them against their peers or some other performance appraisal system."[4] The Case Against MBO In 2004, Joseph F. Castellano wrote a compelling paper that demonstrates how MBO can lead directly to unhealthy internal competition, unethical behavior, and a work environment of fear and greed. Castellano relates several MBO examples, including the story of one his graduate students who worked...
Words: 3094 - Pages: 13
...Innovation Management Assignment WS 2010/11 Case B: Introduction of Management by Objectives Problems when putting the change into effect Although many companies have found acquisitions to be highly beneficial to their operations, many more encounter problems that can have disastrous consequences to the future position of the firm. Specifically, a poorly executed acquisition can harm a firm´s financial and strategic situation and can have negative impacts on the firm´s management and overall culture. The most valuable resource a company has includes their employees and the skills and knowledge that they posses. If the acquiring company fails to retain these quality employees, the firm loses the value of their expertise for which they paid through the acquisition. Many companies have gone into an acquisition without evaluating the organization...
Words: 1935 - Pages: 8
...managers. Additionally, there was a lack of growth and development. Finally, the most obvious concern to Lancaster was that current managers were using a Management By Objective (MBO) type plan which is believed to be an outdated system that the United States has long since replaced. These areas of concern he found during his initial assessment of the Eastern Hemisphere organization led him to have fear for the future because without immediate attention and action, the future productivity and profitability of the Eastern Hemisphere was grim. Lancaster believed major reform in replacing outdated management systems was pertinent. 2) What problems does Lancaster want ADP to address? Lancaster wants to update the current employee review process with a more modern approach called the Appraisal Development Plan (ADP). Under the previous MBO program, superiors would meet on an individual basis with each subordinate to discuss that subordinate’s performance, etc. Lancaster wants the new and improved ADP system to address the problem of managers only seeing maybe 10 percent of their employees’ job performance, thus leading to ill-informed MBO reviews. Lancaster also believes the ADP system will help address the issue of employees sometimes getting contentious with a managers review under the MBO...
Words: 783 - Pages: 4
...3 I. Introduction In today’s world, a lot of organization has put much effort and focus on how to make their workforce be as much as efficient and effective as they can be. Organizations across the globe has developed structures and programs that help them get the best from their employees and in return they align such structures with their objectives and goals. Thus came the introduction of Performance Management. Organizations as a whole initiated this system of appraising and evaluating employees’ performance to gauge and measure productivity in work- related situations and operation. This work will try to seek a thorough discussion on the topic “Performance Management can be a useful tool to align company objectives and individual objectives. This results in successful operations.” A vast methodology of research has been done to find a correlation between theories and practices including examples. Literature reviews have been made in order to arrive at a definitive conclusion about the above-mentioned topic. This paper shows an in-depth analysis of the factors affecting Performance Evaluation system and likewise the underlying need for organizations to have a robust performance management system in place. The different Performance measurement systems were discussed to show the relevance of such in achieving organizational strategic goals. To further illustrate the points, data and information were derived from different...
Words: 4807 - Pages: 20
...Performance Management and Appraisal Shaneece S. Thompson Long Island University (Brooklyn campus) Human Resource Management 355-001 November 14, 2014 Identify the Performance Appraisal Method Used Doing a good job setting performance expectations with employee is akin to sending them on a journey with a map, a timetable, and some end goal in mind. They have a good chance of being able to meet the expectations you have of them because you have set them up for success. Some leaders failed to give directions to their employees and then the evaluative process becomes complicated and unfair to staff. Performance appraisal methods should be chosen properly to guide employee in the right direction. Critical Incident Method The critical incident method of performance appraisal is used to identify and describe specific events where the employee did something well or something that needs improvement. The encounter between David and Hodgetts was to highlight the problems occurring on the work site and to inform Kennison that it needs to be addressed. It was a meeting to emphasize to Kennison his roles and responsibilities. This approach is that performance evaluations are based on actual performance that is observed firsthand by the employee’s manager such as why Kennison was not reporting work delays and problems with inspectors. Why did it failed to produce long-lasting results? This method failed to produce long-standing results because Kennison needed to communicate more with...
Words: 1099 - Pages: 5
...1. Self-Managed/ Directed Team Self-directed work teams, also known as self-managing teams, represent a revolutionary approach to the way work is organized and performed. It is a group of people working together in their own ways toward a common goal which is defined outside the team for example - James River Corporation’s Kendallville Plant ALPHA team. They manufacture cardboard boxes as defined by executive leadership. Team does their own work scheduling, training, rewards and recognition, etc. Minnesota-based 3M is among an increasing number of companies that involve employees in the daily management of their business through work teams. These teams are empowered to take corrective actions to resolve day-to-day problems. They also have direct access to information that allows them to plan, control and improve their operations. In short, employees that comprise work teams manage themselves. At 3M, the movement toward self-managed or directed work teams has been driven more by initiative and need than by corporate directive. Now most of 3M's manufacturing facilities, while at different levels of empowerment and different degrees of involvement, employ a team-based approach. In 1994, 3M's new Brockville, Ontario, facility came on-line as the organization's first "greenfield" site. It was designed and built to operate with self-directed work teams. Many work groups in line divisions and staff groups are moving more and more into self-direction. 3M's commercial office...
Words: 3679 - Pages: 15
...Introduction All companies have some formal or informal means of appraising their employees’ performance. If employees’ performance is good, organizations will want to reinforce it; and if it is bad, they will try to take corrective actions. Performance appraisal is the ongoing process of evaluating and managing both the behavior and outcomes in the organization (Carrell, Elbert & Hatfield, 2008). It is not a process that happens once a year or every six months, but one that happens every day. Stripped to its essentials, performance appraisal always involves setting work standards, assessing the employees’ actual performance relative to those standards, and providing feedback to the employees with the aim of motivating him or her to eliminate performance deficiencies or to continue to perform above par (Dessler, 2011). Indeed, performance appraisals are widely used for administrating wages and salaries, giving performance feedback, and identifying individual employee strengths and weaknesses (Mathis & Jackson, 2011). Definition of Performance Appraisal P erformance appraisal is the process of evaluating the behavior of the employees in the work place (Maxwell, 1992). This process assumes that the employees are aware of their performance standards, and that the supervisor also provides the employees with the feedback, development, and incentives required to help the person eliminate performance deficiencies. Basically, performance appraisal is...
Words: 7691 - Pages: 31
...management theory? Ques. 3 Describe the four basic stages in the rational model of decision making and problem solving. Ques. 4 Describe in brief the following a.Scientific management theory b.Classical organizational theory c.Behavioural science theory Section-B Kavita was excited. She had just returned from a manager's retreat where MBO had been discussed. This had never been used in her organization before, and she was enthusiastic about implementing the program in her department. She received the OK from her manager, the division head, who did remember having heard of the program several years earlier. Kavita looked over the handout she had received. She was still somewhat confused on who was to choose the goals for the employees. However, she knew that the goals once chosen needed to be specific and have explicit time periods attached. Even though there was a lot of work to do in order to implement the program, Kay was excited. She knew this would prove to be beneficial to the organization. Suggest a practical approach and the plan of action that Kavita could take to implement MBO. Give a hypothetical Objective Statement that could be used as a stating point for discussion with her employees. GM01 Management...
Words: 696 - Pages: 3
...help to show her how to be prepared for what could happen and what she wants to happen as a company. When there is so much growth and so much competition, Liz and CanGo need to have a plan. That is why we are here; to help the company stay successful even when they are considering expanding into a new market. During this research period, The Grads have come up with the top issues that the CanGo team needs to address so that they can ensure further successfulness. The six top issues that we are going to address here in this Week Two Analysis Report are: The lack of direction the company has; its poor management skills; absence of proper communication; the company has a lack of financial awareness; lack of Management by Objectives (MBO) as well as lack of...
Words: 2759 - Pages: 12
...Definition of Planning: The planning process is the first basic managerial function According to Koontz and O’donnell,” Planning is deciding in advance What to do, how to do it, when to do it, and who is to do it.” Importance of Planning: Planning is the first and most important function of the management. It is needed at every level of the management. In the absence of planning all the business activities of the organization will become meaningless. The importance of planning has increased all the more in view of the increasing size of organizations in the absence of planning, it may not be impossible but certainly difficult to guess the uncertain events of future. Planning is important because: 1. Planning reduce risk of Uncertainty 2. Focuses on objective 3. Ensures efficiency 4. Planning provides Direction 5. Planning establishes Standards for controlling Elements/Types of Planning: 1. Mission/Purpose: It describes the types of business. It defines the overall ‘working’ of the business. It is a long term plan. 2. Objective or goal: It means expected end result. It is the specification of mission. It may be qualitative or may be quantitative. 3. Strategy: It means determination of long term actions and selecting the best/appropriate options to achieve the mission/objectives. There are some considerable based on company’s strength and weakness. 4. Policy: Guidelines for managerial decisions. It’s the boundaries for...
Words: 1246 - Pages: 5
...Welcome to Human Resource Initiatives meeting! The goal of this meeting is to present Human Resource Initiatives around: Performance Evaluations, Team Evaluation and Implementing Succession Planning. 1 A Performance Evaluation is the means by employee performance is documented and assessed. The evaluation is based on pre-determined criteria. For example a manager would sit down with an employee and discuss clear goals for the current position they hold. Pre-determined criteria would give specific, measurable goals. Like the receptionist will return all messages with 48 hours of receiving them. The manager would have a system in place to ensure they could determine if all messages were returned within the 48 hours. Another area could be company citizenship. Company citizenship is what has the employee done inside the company that aligns with a companies corporate citizenship goals. This could be volunteering to conduct a Lunch & Learn meeting, or helping to plan an employee appreciation event. Accomplishments could be evaluated by listing all of the things the employee accomplished during the previous year. An accomplishment is usually something that goes above and beyond current job responsibilities. And lastly, Future Improvement is what an employee is doing to better themselves. This could be signing up for a course, pursuing a degree or designation. 2 Performance Evaluations are used to manager and align all of an organization's resources in order to achieve...
Words: 3207 - Pages: 13
...Week 1 & 2 Video Analysis Report Week 1 & 2 Analysis Report “Poor strategic planning is worse than no strategic planning. It can be a big waste of time and money” (“Strategic Thinking”, 2011, p.1). Strategic planning plays a very crucial role in helping organizations achieve their goals. The strategic planning process requires both managers and their subordinates to work together as a team to design, plan and implement those goals. We have noticed that there have been some deficiencies in the leadership of CanGo Inc. We have also provided some recommendations for the management team to improve their weaknesses so that the company can continue to stay successful in achieving its goals and launching itself to the online gaming industry. (1) There is a lack of mission, vision and value in CanGo Inc. Liz, the founder and CEO started her company with an emergent strategy process. This strategy would not allow the company to stay successful in the long run. Liz thinks that the success of the company has nothing to do with strategic planning. As a result, she fails to recognize the importance of strategic management planning. This issue is the top priority to be addressed because it is the core foundation of the success of the company (BUSN 460, Week 1 Video, 2003). (2) However, the management fails to analyze the company’s position in the market to set reasonable long-term and short-term goals. The goals and expectations seem to be unrealistic or unachievable. Goals that...
Words: 2204 - Pages: 9
...Ashford University Introduction A district manager has many different responsibilities. These responsibilities range from participating in the day to day operations of the business to carrying out the key aspects of the company's goals set forth in the business plan. When a district manager is assigned to n area that includes a group of start up franchises these responsibilities are magnified. District managers are directly responsible for hiring training and overseeing these new teams. They are also responsible for the ordering receiving and control of the initial inventory. Starting a new franchise has added responsibilities including job and organizational design, staffing selection and recruiting as well as introducing and implementing a training and performance appraisal model and ensuring it is carried out. Job Design Job design aims to cut down on job dissatisfaction and employee disconnection by reducing the repetitive and mechanical tasks. Companies implement job design to attempt to increase productivity levels, satisfaction and motivation in employees. Job analysis, job description, and job specification are the three standard approaches to job design (Baack, Reilly, & Minnick, 2014). Job Analysis Job analysis is the process that follows position identification and building in an organizational chart. Job analysis is the first step in hiring an...
Words: 1504 - Pages: 7
...Project Course Exercise If businesses/organizations are to succeed, it is imperative that there be definitive and attainable objectives and results. The organization will define objectives by looking at the marketplace in which the organization is competing, the core competencies of the organization, recognizing how these can be applied to the goal of success, and then applying the organization's skills and competencies to accomplish the successes. This also means that the organization needs to identify areas it will not pursue – those that are not directly related to the core elements and competencies of the organization. As an example, if a company were focused on developing and manufacturing sporting equipment, it would need to determine if this includes all sporting equipment or a selection of products. Further, the company would need to determine what would be the various levels of support it would provide to its customers. For example, would the company take its equipment directly to the consumers for demonstrations and lessons on how to gain the optimal results with the equipment? All of these types of decisions would be the result of the organization developing a strategy for how it will conduct its business. All of this translates into Strategic Management with the intended result of gaining a competitive advantage in a business niche. Very simply, developing a Strategic Management Plan means having defined what is the best set of results the organization can attain...
Words: 6210 - Pages: 25
...Cango Week 1 And 2 Video Analysis Report Week 1 & 2 Analysis Report “Poor strategic planning is worse than no strategic planning. It can be a big waste of time and money” (“Strategic Thinking”, 2011, p.1). Strategic planning plays a very crucial role in helping organizations achieve their goals. The strategic planning process requires both managers and their subordinates to work together as a team to design, plan and implement those goals. We have noticed that there have been some deficiencies in the leadership of CanGo Inc. We have also provided some recommendations for the management team to improve their weaknesses so that the company can continue to stay successful in achieving its goals and launching itself to the online gaming industry. (1) There is a lack of mission, vision and value in CanGo Inc. Liz, the founder and CEO started her company with an emergent strategy process. This strategy would not allow the company to stay successful in the long run. Liz thinks that the success of the company has nothing to do with strategic planning. As a result, she fails to recognize the importance of strategic management planning. This issue is the top priority to be addressed because it is the core foundation of the success of the company (BUSN 460, Week 1 Video, 2003). (2) However, the management fails to analyze the company’s position in the market to set reasonable long-term and short-term goals. The goals and expectations seem to be unrealistic or unachievable. Goals...
Words: 2296 - Pages: 10
