Free Essay

Implementing Five-Step Strategy for Critical Reading

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By illuminatedmind
Words 956
Pages 4
Implementing Five-Step Strategy for Critical Reading
Jaydde Craig
HUM/111

Implementing Five-Step Strategy for Critical Reading
Five-Step Strategy for Critical Reading
Please refer to pages 73-77 in The Art of Thinking for this assignment.
Step One: Skim the Article * Take five minutes and skim the following article. http://www.foxnews.com/us/2013/11/08/stand-your-ground-law-survives-florida-house-vote/
Step Two: Reflect on Your Views * What ideas do you have about this subject that could create a bias for or against the author’s view and prevent me from giving it a fair hearing? Please explain in 25-50 words.

This article comes across as bias. The facts reported, are more about emotional responses from Rep. Matt Gaetz argued that the law had helped reduce the number of homicides in the state of Florida since its passage. There is no evidence of this stated in this article. It is compiled of remarks by various people that come from an emotional point of view and offer no statistics, proof, quotes, or anything that gives a convincing argument that this is a unbiased review.

Step Three: Read the Work
Step Four: Evaluate What You Read * Identify the issue of the article in 25- to 50-words. The issue of the article is that Florida legislators defeated an effort to repeal the state's controversial "stand your ground law" following hours of passionate testimony. It is emotional response and not based on any facts. In one part of the article the phrase sparked accusations used in regards to Zimmerman racially profiling Martin. This is not a fact but a speculation.

* In this article, the author uses words that are open to more than one meaning. Please provide examples and explain in 25- to 50-words. One of the words found in the article is the word right. The definition of right has several meanings. Defined as being correct, opposite of the left, or a moral or legal entitlement. In this article is also the word far. The definition of far can be used as a description for distance, or a remote or advanced time. Another definition is; as a great deal or too much.

* In this article, the author use emotionally charged language or quotes as substitutes for evidence. Please provide examples and explain in 25- to 50-words. “How ca an unarmed citizen defend themselves against an armed lunatic with a delusional sense of danger?” said Representative Slosberg. This quote is loaded with emotion. Anger is one of them and implying that Zimmerman is a lunatic and delusional. Lucia McBath states “Florida has become the poster child of senseless gun violence.” She implies that the state of Florida is out of control concerning gun violence. Again, this is an opinion and not a fact based statement, just as the one by Representative Slosberg’s was.

* Is the author’s evidence relevant to the issue? Why or why not? Please explain in 25- to 50-words. The evidence presented in this article is not relevant to the issue. At the end of the article, the author says that the House Criminal Justice subcommittee voted against the “stand your ground” repeal but was in favor of Florida’s “10-20-Life” mandatory sentencing law that allows for people to fire warning shots to avoid this law. The last sentence of the article says ‘The legislation was pushed in wake of the 20-year sentence given to a Florida woman who fired a shot at her estranged husband during an argument. This has nothing to do with the issue either’.

* What criticisms and counterarguments would someone who holds a different position make about this article? Please explain in 25- to 50 words. There are statements made in the article that declare that Zimmerman was racially profiling Martin. There is no real evidence of this in the article and someone could easily say that this was a way to start racial tensions. I already believe that the media did capitalize on this when the case was in the forefront of the news. As stated in the previous questions, this article seems to be emotion based as opposed to fact based. The only facts that not disputed is the defeat of the repeal. The second fact is that House committee voted decisively 11-2 against the repeal. There are too many open-ended questions.

* Does the author commit any errors in logic? If yes, please provide examples and explain. I do not think there are any errors in logic. The author seems to be just recapping events that took place but does not add any thoughts or opinions to critique.

Step Five: Express Your Judgment * Do you agree, disagree, or agree in part/disagree in part with the author? Please explain in 100- to 150-words. It seems that the author of this article is trying to get across that “stand your ground” will only lead to more senseless killings and the argument that I felt threatened will be misused anytime someone is sensibly killed. Most of the testimony he uses are from people that share the same opinion on the subject, which would be that it would be an excuse for people to commit violent acts so they can argue that the felt threatened. I am not sure if I agree with this. Human behavior seems to show that when a person knows that he or she might have the treat of physical encounter with another person, tend to rethink committing a crime. People should not have to be victims of senseless violence. A would be criminal is thinking of breaking into a home, reconsideration might be taken if there is a chance that the homeowner is armed.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Implementing Five-Step Strategy for Critical Reading

...Implementing Five-Step Strategy for Critical Reading Jessica S. Sims HUM/111 January 26, 2014 Maggie Dominguez, Med/MA Implementing Five-Step Strategy for Critical Reading Five-Step Strategy for Critical Reading Please refer to pages 73-77 in The Art of Thinking for this assignment. Step One: Skim the Article * Take five minutes and skim the following article. http://www.foxnews.com/us/2013/11/08/stand-your-ground-law-survives-florida-house-vote/ Step Two: Reflect on Your Views * What ideas do you have about this subject that could create a bias for or against the author’s view and prevent me from giving it a fair hearing? Please explain in 25-50 words. Being somewhat familiar with the trial against George Zimmerman and the situation that created the uproar; left me in a situation where I believed George Zimmerman should have been convicted, and the stand your ground law should have been reanalyzed. Step Three: Read the Work Step Four: Evaluate What You Read * Identify the issue of the article in 25- to 50-words. In a push to have the Florida state law, “stand your ground” repealed, the article reflects on the decisions of the legislature and some of the senseless crimes committed that should make the legislature want to change the law. * In this article, the author uses words that are open to more than one meaning. Please provide examples and explain in 25- to 50-words. When the author uses the word pushed, he/she is referring to being...

Words: 764 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Edu 669 the Reading, Writing Connection Entire Course

...EDU 669 The Reading, Writing Connection Entire Course https://homeworklance.com/downloads/edu-669-the-reading-writing-connection-entire-course/ This course will emphasis the connection of reading and writing with a focus on the content areas. Students will be exposed to a variety of approaches including vocabulary techniques, comprehension strategies, and study techniques to use with learners. Issues of assessment, motivation, and cultural as well as linguistic diversity will also be addressed. Offered online. EDU 669 Week 1 Assignment Culturally Responsive Instruction Culturally Responsive Instruction. You have been learning about issues of cultural and linguistic diversity and their impact on student achievement. In this assignment you are asked to use your own personal and professional experiences to write a paper analyzing and defending the use of culturally responsive teaching to support effective literacy instruction. In your analysis: Produce a research-based rationale for the use of culturally responsive teaching in literacy instruction. You must include at least Describe at least threeone scholarly source in this section; research-based techniques that educators can use to support this pedagogy. You must back your assertions with at least one scholarly source in this section; Discuss the instructional implications of this pedagogical approach. Your paper must be three-to five-pages not including the title or reference pages. It must be written in...

Words: 1056 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Bandon Group

...Step 1: Purpose and Scope of Study The scope and purpose of the integrated case study for the Bandon Group, Inc., is to determine how Information Technology (IT) can best support the overall mission, goals and objectives of the corporation. The motivation for the information systems study is to analysis the current information systems environment, assess problems and to evaluate the feasibility of implementing an ERP solutions, including SAP and the administrative information systems of Oracle ERP. The Bandon Group is a family owned office machine distributor, with four decentralized divisions in four different markets in the western United States, Portland, Oregon; Phoenix, Arizona; Salt Lake City, Utah; and Denver, Colorado (Sumner, 2005). The Bandon Group objective is to provide high quality equipment, excellent customer service, and excellent sales organization professional service organization at cost-effective prices. The Bandon Group initially distributed office machine such as copiers, electronic printers and faxes, but because of their exceptional growth in sales, reputation for quality and superior service, they began expanding into information systems consulting, digital imaging, color graphics, document outsourcing and management services. By 1994, the Bandon Group had outgrown its information systems and customers were requesting more streamlined operations such as web-based interface online meter readings, online invoicing, and e-business solutions....

Words: 1755 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Guidline

...Campus The purpose of this guide is to help you maximize your learning when using case studies. It outlines some key issues that will help you learn from the case analysis method. In most graduate courses, students use cases from actual companies to practice strategic analysis and to gain some experience in the task of creating and implementing strategy. A case describes, in a factual manner, the events and organizational circumstances surrounding a particular managerial problem. It’s as if the reader is inside the organization (at the time the case was written) and has most, if not all, relevant information, facts, and circumstances. The student’s role in case analysis is to diagnose and evaluate the situation described in the case. You then develop recommendations, supporting arguments, and the appropriate action steps that should be taken to rectify the problem presented in the case. After reading this guide, you will be able to: * Understand what a case study is * Appreciate the benefits of using case studies in the learning of strategic management and how their use can help develop your managerial skills * Use the key steps in analyzing case studies * Apply theoretical concepts and frameworks to the case material The case approach to strategic analysis is an exercise in “learning by doing.” Because cases provide you with detailed information about conditions and problems of different industries and companies, your task of analyzing organization...

Words: 1671 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Diversity and Inclusion

...|BUSINESS |[pic] | ASSIGNMENT FRONT SHEET |Student Name: | |Certification : I certify that the whole of this work is the result of my individual effort and that all quotations from books, periodicals etc. | |have been acknowledged. | |Student Signature: |Date: | |Student Registration Number: | |Student email address : | |Programme :MBA |Year/Level : | |Academic Year : 20012/13 |Semester : 1 | |Module title : People Resourcing |Assignment...

Words: 2913 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Leadership and Organisational Behavior

...Image) Name: Zaheed Diwan Address: 127 Allerton Drive, Schaumburg, Illinois, 60194. Phone: (310) 357 4218 Email: zzdiwan@hotmail.com Instructor: Mae Hicks Jones Outline: Section | Description | Title Page | Leadership and Organizational Behavior in Action – J.P.Morgan case study. | Introduction | An overview of the organization and my role in it.  | Problem Statement | How is any problem identified & analyzed, and how effectively are decisions taken, necessary changes communicated & implemented, to avoid any repercussions? | Analysis | Detailed analysis of the problem statement. * Identification & Analysis of a problem * Effective Decision Making * Identifying and Implementing Changes * Communications | Solutions | Identification and critical evaluation of potential workable solutions to the problem.  | Reflection | Statement about how this assignment influenced my personal, academic, and professional leadership and managerial development. | References & Literature Review. | Reference to Scholarly reviews during the analysis. | * Overview of the Organization: (Source: Google Images) The Organization that will be the topic of discussion for this project paper is J.P.Morgan Chase & Co. & Co. (India operations are under J.P. Morgan Services India Private ltd). J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. is a leader in financial services, offering solutions to clients, in more than 100 countries with one of the most comprehensive...

Words: 4511 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Benchmarking

...classification, process and pitfall of the model LECTURER: PROF. MADYA DR. RIZAL BIN RAZALLI | | | | | | Summary of selected articles Article 1 | Benchmarking: a general reading for management practitioners | Author | Sik, W.F., Cheng, E.W.L., & Ho, D.C.K. | Year | 1998 | Setting/ Place/ Sample | Management Decision, Vol. 36 Iss 6 pp. 407 - 418 | Objectives | Introduce the basics of benchmarking to management practitioners | Analysis | Classification of benchmarking, benchmarking process model, components in a benchmarking project, hints for organization to conduct first time benchmarking project. | Findings | Identify the sources of best practices as a result of assisting in promoting management perspectives and facilitating the formation of various specific goals. | Article 2 | Benchmarking the benchmarking models | Author | Anand, G., & Kodali, Rambabu | Year | 2008 | Setting/ Place/ Sample | Benchmarking: An International Journal, Vol. 15 Iss 3 pp. 257 - 291 | Objectives | To classify the fundamental benchmarking model and the unique benchmarking model, propose a universal benchmarking model which can be applied for all types of benchmarking | Analysis | Benchmarking the benchmarking models revealed about 71 steps in which around 13 steps have been addressed by many researches. | Findings |...

Words: 3835 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Marketing

...MKC1 Market Environmental Variables Reading: Contemporary Marketing: Chapter 3 Questions: 1. How would you categorize Generation X using the five segments of the marketing environment? A: Competitive Environment B: Political-legal environment C: Economic environment D: Technological environment E: Social-cultural environment 2. Joe and Ryan both have storefronts in the local mall. Joe sells candies and Ryan sells pretzels. Are Joe and Ryan in direct competition with each other? A: Yes B: No Consumer Behavior and Marketing Reading: Contemporary Marketing: Chapter 5 Questions: 1. Rachel and Sarah’s parents always purchased groceries from the local Aldi marketplace. What is this type of behavior an example of? A: Cultural influences B: Social Influences C: Personal factors 2. Maryanne purchases Maxwell House coffee every two weeks from the grocery. What is this type of behavior an example of? A: Routinized Problem Solving B: Limited problem solving C: Extended problem solving 3. Aaron does research on several local colleges before applying to his first three choices. This is an example of: A: High – involvement purchase decision B: Low – involvement purchase decision Marketing Plans Reading: Contemporary Marketing: Chapter 2 + Ch. 2 Appendix Web sites: http://www.jpec.org/handouts/jpec33.pdf http://www.netmba.com/marketing/process/ Questions: 1. Strategies are designed to meet objectives. Tactics...

Words: 8933 - Pages: 36

Free Essay

Eni Transformation Model

...ENI’s Turnaround & Transformation Model INTRODUCTION Since 1973, Evans Newton Incorporated (ENI) has partnered with educational agencies to provide custom educational solutions that improve student achievement. Designed in 1988, the TargetTeach* Five-Step Process has been continually adapted to the instructional innovations and performance requirements of the U.S. educational system. Today the theoretical and empirical bases of the TargetTeach design are established by independent research and program evaluations that demonstrate its capability to provide the support that schools need as they struggle to make Adequate Yearly Progress (AYP) under Title I of the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 (NCLB). These evaluations and research verify that TargetTeach negates the socioeconomic and subgroup challenges that schools face in making AYP. THEORETICAL BASE OF ENI’S TURNAROUND & TRANSFORMATION MODEL The TargetTeach Five-Step Process is a design-based intervention program built upon “a „logic model‟ that describes the „theory of action‟” that determines each implementation (Rowan, Correnti, Miller, & Camburn 2009): TargetTeach Five Step Process instructional practice instructional leadership student achievement TargetTeach focuses on both the short-term and long-term results that ENI customers seek as outcomes of their school reform endeavors. A school‟s instructional leadership interrelates with its patterns of instructional practice to comprise a system of transformation...

Words: 2329 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

The Cloud Computing Model Described in the Lecture Is an Example of Which Cloud Computing Model?

...Syllabus Course Syllabus | | Print This Page | | | Course Text | | Managing Organizational Change: A multiple perspectives approach 2nd Edition by Ian Palmer, Richard Dunford and Gib Akin © 2009, The McGraw-Hill Companies | First Time Using VitalSource?Step 1: View the VitalSource Video Step 2: Register with VitalSource Bookshelf Online 1. Select the "eBooks" tab at the top of the window. 2. Select the cover of your eBook. A new window will open. 3. Check the box next to "Accept license agreement" and click "Continue." Bookshelf Online will open. Step 3: Access the Desktop and Mobile Versions You must complete Step 2 prior to using the desktop or mobile versions. >> Complete Instructions | Already Registered? 3 Ways to Access Your eBooks Online 1. Select the "eBooks" tab at the top of the window. 2. Select your eBook. Bookshelf Online will open. | Desktop Download your eBooks and use them whether you're connected to the Internet or not. >> Learn More | | Mobile Download the app and get your eBooks on your iPhone, iPad, or Android device. >> Learn More | | | To find out more about VitalSource Bookshelf, check out the VitalSource FAQ. | | | | Course Description | This course addresses concepts and techniques required to successfully implement change across an organization. Coursework focuses on identifying an organization’s vision as well as opportunities that can align the vision with the organization’s...

Words: 2205 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

District Manager

...organizations actually achieve successful transformations. The Konosuke Matsushita Professor of Leadership, Emeritus at the Harvard Business School and a graduate of MIT and Harvard, Kotter’s vast experience and knowledge on successful change and leadership have been proven time and time again. The book Leading Change looks at an eight stage process for implementing successful transformations in today’s firms as well as the eight errors that are common to change efforts. The ideas and methods in this book should be considered a roadmap to successful change for any manager or leader in today’s modern organizations. Leading Change is broken up into three parts. Part one begins by discussing the potential downside of change and the eight errors commonly made during transformation efforts and their consequences. He then goes into detail on the economic and social forces that drive the need for major change in today’s organizations. This is also where Kotter introduces his eight step process for creating change. In Part two Kotter goes into great detail about his eight step process for successful change highlighting what to focus on and avoid at each step of the process. Part three looks at the implications for the 21st century, he goes into detail about the organization of the future and talks about sustaining that success through leadership and lifelong learning. “The Change Problem and its Solution”. Kotter starts off in chapter 1 by highlighting the eight most common mistakes or errors that...

Words: 3640 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Cis 5511

...CIS 511 Assignment # 1 Integrated Case Study: Bandon Group, Inc. Prof : STEPHEN HUBER Student : Karmon Jeneka Date : July 17, 2014 The Purpose and Scope Of Study: To determine the major initiative that evaluate organization and business management accomplish over time to move the company from the current situation to the development of an integrated information management strategy that will enable the organization to achieve it business objectives. This require investigation within the business and its needs, a good word about the use of SAP along with supported foundation and a comprehensible working model of SAP, configured and with master data. According to Sumner the overall scope or benefit of the study was to assure that IT plans support business plans, to provide a basis for linking IT spending to the business direction, offer context for functional managers and MIS professionals can make determinations, conveys the overall direction of data use and management throughout the business, present closer integration of like systems and networks while decentralizing at the same time technology and operational activities. The offer of guidance in choosing vendors for workstation-based solutions along with network and web-based solutions to problems as well as offering framework for using IT to gain a strategic improvement. Document high-level business direction: The high-level business direction as defined by executive management interviews discovered that...

Words: 1622 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Marketing Plan Phase 1

...Nike Marketing Plan; Phase I Eddie Chantaniyom, Lizbeth Geary, Chris Marlow, Dean Nicholson MKT/421 Marketing Stephen Oaks September 13, 2012 Nike Marketing Plan; Phase I Discussed in this reading will be the beginning phase of the marketing plan to customize and personalize Nike shoes. Discussed will be a summarization of the Nike Corporation along with a description of the new customization service being provided. In addition, this reading will also explain the overall importance of a proper marketing plan and provide critical data of a SWOT analysis to help determine product feasibility, marketing strategy, and tactics for the new service. Good intro. The largest market competitor in the world of sportswear for 2012 is Nike Inc. A company that opened the doors in 1962 by two individuals Bill Bowerman and Phillip Knight with a gentlemen handshake and became the supplier called Blue Ribbons Sports for Japanese shoe makers in Oregon later known as Nike Inc. They started selling supplies for Onitsuka Tiger, now known as ASICS, from Knight’s automobile making most of their sales at track meets. Bowerman handled the innovations for the company as Knight managed the business operations. Bowerman created the first shoe using his wife’s waffle iron, giving Nike the first ever waffle shoe. The waffle shoe helped the growth of the company position into the market, by starting their-own innovative brand of soccer shoes, called the Nike; that followed the first trademark...

Words: 1412 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Informative

...------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- Credit hours: 4.5 Contact/Instructional hours: 60 (30 Theory, 30 Lab) Prerequisite: IS3110 Risk Management in Information Technology Security or equivalent Corequisite: None Table of Contents Course Overview 5 Course Summary 5 Critical Considerations 5 Instructional Resources 6 Required Resources 6 Additional Resources 6 Course Management 8 Technical Requirements 8 Test Administration and Processing 8 Replacement of Learning Assignments 9 Communication and Student Support 9 Academic Integrity 10 Grading 11 Course Delivery 13 Instructional Approach 13 Methodology 13 Facilitation Strategies 14 Unit Plans 15 Unit 1: Information Security Policy Management 15 Unit 2: Risk Mitigation and Business Support Processes 25 Unit 3: Policies, Standards, Procedures, and Guidelines 33 Unit 4: Information Systems Security Policy Framework 42 Unit 5: User Policies 50 Unit 6: IT Infrastructure Security Policies 58 Unit 7: Risk Management 66 Unit 8: Incident Response Team Policies 74 Unit 9: Implementing and Maintaining an IT Security Policy Framework 83 Unit 10: Automated Policy Compliance Systems 90 Unit 11: Course Review and Final Examination 97 Course Support Tools 101 Evaluation of Student Learning 102 STUDENT COPY 103 Graded Assignment Requirements 104 Unit 1 Discussion 1: Importance of Security Policies 105 Unit 1 Assignment...

Words: 18421 - Pages: 74

Premium Essay

Information Technology Term Paper

...expense and liability, IT is now being thought of as strategic business enabler. Management of IT and the associated strategy, funding and security are top of mind for many in today's challenging environment.  Executives are under more pressure than ever to maximize return on their technology investments. However, our research has revealed that there are several key concerns that appear to be trending throughout corporations as they determine the exact roles IT should play.   READINGS         Members of the group read several chapters from the textbook, Information Technology for Management: Improving Performance in the Digital Economy (Turban and Volonino, 7th Edition), as well as numerous articles on various information technology subjects.           A topic which received a significant amount of attention throughout our readings is the importance of aligning IT strategies with the business priorities of the company, and how this is critical to the success of an organization.  An important component of this alignment is ensuring that the IT division in involved in the development of business strategies.  A company’s business strategy is basically the overall direction or plan of the business. Information Systems (IS) strategy defines what information is required and what systems are needed to support the business strategy.  Information Technology (IT) Strategy determines how services are delivered by the organization. IT-Business...

Words: 7761 - Pages: 32