Free Essay

Instant Replay in Baseball

In:

Submitted By dangerman11
Words 535
Pages 3
Instant Replay in Baseball As of now, the only use of instant replay in baseball is to decide whether what appears to be a homerun is indeed a homerun. However, recent talks have began to arise on the expansion of this so called tool. These talks began after a controversial call that occurred a couple months ago between the Detroit Tigers and the Cleveland Indians. The Tigers pitcher, Armando Galarraga, had a perfect game going into the ninth until the first base umpire made a close call resulting in a hit. After a slow motion replay on T.V, it was clear that the umpire missed the call causing an uproar of critics, claiming baseball needs instant replay to save this from happening again. To prevent a once in a life time perfect game from being taken away due to a missed call. I disagree with this immediate request. Further use of instant replay in baseball would ruin the game America has enjoyed for a century. The main argument for instant replay is so that bad calls by umpires can be over turned. It would eliminate the need for raging manager arguments and ejections. It would make the league mistake free. I believe these mistakes are actually good for the game. Baseball fans enjoy watching the managers scream into the umpires' faces while vigorously throwing his arms up in the air. It adds a surge of energy through those in the crowd and those watching at home. It also gives his team motivation to play hard because they know that their coach has their back. To add instant replay would mean losing one of the most vital parts of the game. Instant Replay would dismantle the flow of baseball. Being a baseball fan, I admit its a long, slow game. Adding instant replay would make matters worse. The system would be similar to the NFL. Umpires would retreat to the viewing booth where they would review a play, which could take 5 to 10 minutes. This would take the rhythm out of the game. Pitchers and hitters have a rhythm when they play the game. When a pitcher steps on the mound, he repeats the same motion, the same steps every pitch. That's why hitters step out of the box at times and base runners step back and forth while taking a lead, to get a pitcher out of his rhythm. Hitters do the same, they have a routine. They step in the box, adjust their batting gloves, align their feet, and tap the plate. It's a groove. Instant replay would prevent players from getting into this groove and rhythm that has been a part of the game since it was created. Missed calls are part of the game. Players are taught not to worry about what the umpires to call but to work hard and earn it themselves. If the umpire misses a call out of your favor, the next play you work harder to earn it back. It adds drama, energy, and motivation that we've enjoyed for 100 years. It's not the NFL, they don't blow whistles and toss flags. The game has a pulse, further use of instant replay wouldn't fit.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Narrative of Learning

...7th, 2012, I went to a Detroit Tigers baseball game at Comerica Park with my parents and my two younger brothers, ages 15 and 12. It was the second game of the season for the Tigers, who were playing against the Boston Red Sox, and we were sitting in upper-level seats along the right field foul line. In the fifth inning, Detroit’s third baseman, Miguel Cabrera hit a pitch deep into left-center field that, at first, was ruled an automatic double because it looked as though the ball had rolled under the fence. Cabrera, however, kept running as though it was a homerun until one of his teammates told him that is was only a double. Looking for an explanation, the Tigers’ manager, Jim Leyland, jogged over to the umpire that had made the ruling on the play. After a somewhat lengthy conversation with Leyland, the umpire, C.B. Bucknor, had a brief meeting with the other three umpires, and then they all proceeded to go into the replay room behind home plate in order to review the play. About two minutes later, the umpires emerged from the room and ruled that the play was a homerun, giving Cabrera his second of the game. This was a perfect example of how unpredictable the game of baseball can be. I learned about instant replay in Major League Baseball when it was first used, late in the 2008 season. There had been a lot of discussion about it on local and national baseball telecasts, due to its highly-anticipated arrival in the sport. The baseball community was undecided as a whole on...

Words: 1387 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Pros And Cons Of Instant Display In Sports

...​“What a fantastic call right there from a highly trained referee whos been in the league 20+ years.” There are many different arguments for whether or not there should be instant replay in sports. The fact is however, Instant replay should not be allowed in sports for many reasons. Of the many reasons, some of them include, it would slow the game down too much, and it will save the referees from looking bad, and it ruins(I had a poor set of words to end off the paragraph.) the fan experience. One reason that instant replay in sports should not be allowed is that it slows the game down. For example, Baseball has a problem with keeping fans tuned in and with instant replay making the game longer. Since “the average Major League Baseball game...

Words: 372 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Sports Ethics

...officials who are solely responsible for ensuring all calls are made correctly. Because of “human error”, as well as the possibility of biased officiating, the idea evolved of using camera systems whose sole duty is to record all plays that can be replayed to ensure that calls were correctly made. In this paper I will analyze two forms of technology – one from a pure technology perspective and one from a medical perspective - that have both positive and negative aspects in tipping the scale of fairness. For most sports, the sole purpose of a video replay system is to determine the correctness of close calls or controversial plays. Because of the high costs of television cameras and other ancillary equipment, the video replay system is primarily used only at the professional level. In this section I will discuss the use of replay systems in the three major sports which are most widely followed in the United States: baseball, basketball and football. Each has its own unique interpretation of...

Words: 3083 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Pdf, Exe, Doc

...technology ideas in the world of sport. One criticism of the use of technology is that it can slow down the speed of the game, but on the other hand for many people it makes watching it more enjoyable to see the correct decisions being made. Assisting the Umpires / Referees Most professional sports in the United States have long used instant replay and other high-tech aids to help referees make the right call. Gridiron has used video replay systems to check referees' calls for many years. Basketball referees use replay systems to make sure players are shooting within the time allotted by the shot clock. In international cricket, the third umpire has been used, one sitting off the ground with access to TV replays of certain situations (such as disputed catches and boundaries) to advise the central umpires. The umpires out on the field are in communication via wireless technology with the other umpire. The third umpire is also asked to adjudicate on run out decisions, which he makes without consultation with the two central umpires. One sport that has resisted the use of high-tech assistance until very recently is soccer/football. Replays could be used to decide off-side decisions, whether a ball passes over the goal line, and clarify penalty decisions. Hawk-Eye Technology Hawk-eye is the name of a computer and camera system which traces a ball's trajectory. It is being used in international cricket and tennis, and many other sports are also looking at making use of this...

Words: 853 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Internal and External Factors

...Internal and External Factors Leo Chrisman MGT/230 September 16, 2015 Thurman-Bowen, T. Internal and External Factors Internal and external factors greatly affect any business, and Major League Baseball (MLB) is no exception. MLB has grown as a sport and business both digitally and globally. They have done a good job adapting to the world as it evolves, ensuring presence technologically, which makes the game of baseball available to anyone, anywhere, with a capable device. This factor, along with the economy, fans, and the other competing major sports in our country has an effect on how the league has to be managed. MLB uses the four functions of management very frequently. There is always planning for the next season, postseason, or all-star game. There are the annual Winter Meetings, at which motions for possible changes are brought up. MLB is unique in the way that each team is organized in its own way, as well as the league office itself. Within MLB, there are thirty teams in total, with one team calling Canada its home. Leadership within the league has many facets. There are Owners and General Managers who make major decisions such as who will manage the players on the field and which available players will make their team a championship contender. The Managers of each team are responsible, along with their coaching staff, for player performance, the organization of lineups and pitching rotation, and ultimately, wins and losses. There are also veteran...

Words: 1488 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Bud Selig Case Study

...What Is it How it started Repercussions Joyce apologized to Galarraga and cried after the game after realizing that he had made the wrong call. Galarraga understood and forgave the mistake. He told reporters that nobody's perfect. He was one of the many people who voiced their support for Joyce. Joyce even appeared with Galarraga before the media and apologized for the error. Both men were praised for their sportsmanship when handling the situation. Joyce indicated while being interviewed by reporters that his family had been targeted. Officials inside MLB would confirm if specific threats of harm were made. Bud Selig, MLB commissioner, did not change the call in this game, but did decide to look into expanding the use of instant replay...

Words: 286 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Television and Baseball.

...Television and Baseball. Baseball has been drastically changed by the introduction of television. A few major ways it has been changed by television are the reaction to blown calls by umpires, the competitive balance between teams, and the way that players play the game. These are just a few of the major changes to the game of baseball as a result of the introduction of television. Before the introduction of television in baseball, if an umpire blew a call, the only people who knew were the players on the field and the umpire himself. More often than not even the players and the umpire didn’t know for sure. A perfect example of a famous blown call is the Armando Galaaraga and Jim Joyce’s not so perfect game. On June 2, 2010 Detroit Tigers starting pitcher Armando Galaaraga had a perfect game going into the last out of the ninth inning against the Cleveland Indians until umpire Jim Joyce called what should have been the last Cleveland out safe at first.(Johnson) After networks showed the slow motion replay to the fans at home, we could clearly see that the batter was out by at least two steps. The blown call had fans up at some went so far as to call for Jim Joyce’s resignation among other things. Some even went so far as to vandalize his wiki page and start up a web site called firjimjoyce.com. All the while, the only person to be nonchalant about the whole thing was the one person who should be upset- Armando Galaaraga. In fact Armando and Joyce teamed up and co-wrote a book...

Words: 862 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

How Technology Effects Sports

...allowed that increase the performance of athletes in training or developing equipment that help them to be more competitive. However, this technology is not available for all countries because, it will require financial resources from companies or people like stakeholders to invest in this. Although some critic are disagree, there is some evidence that the consequence of technology will be positive for society. One advantage of technology in sports is the application assisting the umpires or referees. For example “instant replay” is used in some countries to help make the right call (decision). Additional another tool that has been applied by umpires is “hawk-replay”, the name of a computer and camera system which traces a ball's trajectory, aid the information is analyzed electronically and sent to the referee's headset or a device on them wrist. This is evident in sports such as the National Football League, the National Basketball Association, Major League Baseball and International Cricket. Due to this system, sports fans do not feel disappointed by a “human mistake” (“Technology in sports”). Another advantage is the creation of devices to improve the performance of sports players. Automated measurement is an important part of an athletic training and preparation for competitions. For example, a tri-axial accelerometer based system developed by Queensland Sports Technology Cluster in Australia and “it contained two ADXL202 bi-axial accelerometers positioned perpendicular...

Words: 308 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Move over Baseball, Football Is America’s New National Pastime

...Move over Baseball, Football is America’s New National Pastime Abstract The argument over which sport actually ranks as America’s national pastime is as enduring and intense as American sports themselves. Each and every week millions of Americans tune in to watch their favorite sports. Over the years baseball has traditionally been known as the national pastime among all sports, but the rich tradition and history behind baseball is almost certainly being slowly replaced by the glamour of football season. Although baseball is still referred to as America’s national pastime, football is by far the most popular sport in this country today. This can be attributed to many factors including a superior television product, more controlled violence, and legalized gambling with fantasy football. Keywords: national, pastime, football, baseball, sports, television, violence, gambling Move over Baseball, Football is America’s New National Pastime Each and every week millions of Americans tune in to watch their favorite sports. Basketball, baseball, football, golf, soccer, and racing all have a place and a market with the sports fans in America. Over the years baseball has traditionally been known as the national pastime among all sports, but the rich tradition and history behind baseball is being slowly replaced by the glamour of football season. Over the past two decades, baseball has been left behind while football has become America’s new national pastime (Gramling, 2010...

Words: 1221 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Technology Affect Sports

...allowed that increase the performance of athletes in training or developing equipment that help them to be more competitive. However, this technology is not available for all countries because, it will require financial resources from companies or people like stakeholders to invest in this. Although some critic are disagree, there is some evidence that the consequence of technology will be positive for society. One advantage of technology in sports is the application assisting the umpires or referees. For example “instant replay” is used in some countries to help make the right call (decision). Additional another tool that has been applied by umpires is “hawk-replay”, the name of a computer and camera system which traces a ball's trajectory, aid the information is analyzed electronically and sent to the referee's headset or a device on them wrist. This is evident in sports such as the National Football League, the National Basketball Association, Major League Baseball and International Cricket. Due to this system, sports fans do not feel disappointed by a “human mistake” (“Technology in sports”). Another advantage is the creation of devices to improve the performance of sports players. Automated measurement is an important part of an athletic training and preparation for competitions. For example, a tri-axial accelerometer based system developed by Queensland Sports Technology Cluster in Australia and “it contained two ADXL202 bi-axial accelerometers positioned perpendicular...

Words: 809 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Nbpa Versus Mlbpa

...Players Association Position Paper The National Basketball Players Association, NBPA, and the Major League Baseball Players Association, MLBPA, are recognized for their security and support towards professional athletes. With similar qualities, both player’s associations negotiate terms of the collective bargaining agreement, CBA. They help improve the sports they represent on and off the court/field. The community surrounding these associations is greatly affected by the actions taken in regards to protecting and representing the players. One of the only differences between the MLBPA and the NBPA can be seen through the actual sports being played. Not only do the players reach out to the community but they have a similar CBA, player assistance programs and representative functions. Both player associations are equally as impactful on the players. A top priority for the NBPA is community outreach. With various initiatives in place, the goal of the player’s association is to impact the lives of others throughout the globe. With more than 400 players giving back to the community, they tackle social issues and are committed philanthropists. During Christmas, the NBPA distributed necessities and amenities to those less fortunate across the globe. An ongoing dedication to improving lives and impacting communities is a top priority for players, as they travel overseas to host basketball clinics for local children and distribute meals. With cooperation from the MLBPA and other...

Words: 733 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

English P

...TiVo A case study analysis Group 5 Suthasina Chaolertseree (4802641060) Nutnaree Chaisirivichien (4802640583) Passamon Rattanawenawatee (4802641326) Jirawat Mahatraiphop (4802640302) David Eberle (5102940037) TiVo: A case study analysis MK 413: Group 5 1. Management vision There are four directions that TiVo’s management team can choose; each strategy has issues that the management team should consider before making a decision. The first direction is doing stand-alone business. TiVo can successfully compete with others in this type of business and earn high profits due to its unique offering. Standalone business also gives TiVo flexibility in developing its product technology and in enhancing its brand awareness, which allows TiVo to set higher prices. On the other hand, the company will have more marketing expenses in order to compete in the market since it needs to pay for advertising costs itself. Moreover, cable companies can become new potential competitors since they can outsource consumer electronics manufacturing to produce DVRs for them and distribute DVR devices to their subscribers. Doing Comcast and Advertising business may require TiVo to assemble its product equipment with another consumer electronics product and to use co-branding causing TiVo’s brand awareness to decrease. Moreover, the management team needs to put huge effort in turning advertising-related business into one of its core businesses. Furthermore, TiVo’s monthly average revenue per unit...

Words: 2564 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Ivo Has Not Yet Sustained a Competitive Advantage in the Industry.

...TiVo A case study analysis Group 5 Suthasina Chaolertseree (4802641060) Nutnaree Chaisirivichien (4802640583) Passamon Rattanawenawatee (4802641326) Jirawat Mahatraiphop (4802640302) David Eberle (5102940037) TiVo: A case study analysis MK 413: Group 5 1. Management vision There are four directions that TiVo’s management team can choose; each strategy has issues that the management team should consider before making a decision. The first direction is doing stand-alone business. TiVo can successfully compete with others in this type of business and earn high profits due to its unique offering. Standalone business also gives TiVo flexibility in developing its product technology and in enhancing its brand awareness, which allows TiVo to set higher prices. On the other hand, the company will have more marketing expenses in order to compete in the market since it needs to pay for advertising costs itself. Moreover, cable companies can become new potential competitors since they can outsource consumer electronics manufacturing to produce DVRs for them and distribute DVR devices to their subscribers. Doing Comcast and Advertising business may require TiVo to assemble its product equipment with another consumer electronics product and to use co-branding causing TiVo’s brand awareness to decrease. Moreover, the management team needs to put huge effort in turning advertising-related business into one of its core businesses. Furthermore, TiVo’s monthly average revenue per unit...

Words: 2564 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Reading Materials

...THE NEW YANKEE STADIUM LOOKS TO THE FUTURE Athough baseball is a sport, it’s also big business, requiring revenue from tickets to games, television broadcasts, and other sources to pay for teams. Salaries for top players have ballooned, as have ticket prices. Many fans now watch games on television rather than attending them in person or choose other forms of entertainment, such as electronic games. One way to keep stadiums full of fans, and to keep fans at home happy as well, is to enrich the fan experience by offering more video and services based on technology. When the New York Yankees built the new Yankee Stadium, they did just that. The new Yankee Stadium, which opened on April 2, 2009, isn’t just another ballpark: It’s the stadium of the future. It is the most wired, connected, and video-enabled stadium in all of baseball. Although the new stadium is similar in design to the original Yankee Stadium, built in 1923, the interior has more space and amenities, including more intensive use of video and computer technology. Baseball fans love video. According to Ron Ricci, co-chairman of Cisco Systems’ sports and entertainment division, “It’s what fans want to see, to see more angles and do it on their terms.” Cisco Systems supplied the computer and networking technology for the new stadium. Throughout the stadium, including the Great Hall, the Yankees Museum, and in-stadium restaurants and concession areas, 1,200 flat-panel high-definition HDTV monitors display live game...

Words: 4732 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

Work

...Race and Ethnicity Should racial profiling be a legitimate law-enforcement policy in some areas? Should Affirmative Action for state university enrollment be continued? Should the primary method of public school funding--property taxes in individual school districts--be amended to create more fairness in schools? Should high-school history classes and social-studies curriculum be changed to reflect diversity and multicultural perspectives? Should Christmas, Easter, and other religious observances be considered national holidays? If a university offers "African-American Studies" or "Black Studies" as courses, should it also offer "European-American Studies" or "White Studies"? How do certain television programs perpetuate racial or ethnic stereotypes? Should Columbus Day be discontinued in favor of a new post-colonial perspective? Should schools only purchase textbooks that offer revised or alternative histories of historical events? What should be done about racial disparities in the sentencing of criminals? Should the American government pay reparations and return land to Native Americans? Should hate groups have the right to distribute literature on university campuses? If research shows that certain racial or ethnic groups receive poorer medical care on average, how should this problem be corrected? Should governmental organizations have staffs that accurately reflect the racial, ethnic, and gender balance in society? Gender and Sexuality What should be...

Words: 4167 - Pages: 17