Free Essay

Intrinsic and Extrinsic Aids

In:

Submitted By Gandalf544
Words 956
Pages 4
Intrinsic Aids to interpretation are found within the act itself. The judge may use other parts of the Act to understand the meaning of the word or phrase in question. These are long/short title of an Act, Preamble/objectives/purposes section, schedules, definition section and punctuation.
Long/short title may be used as a guidance for the judge to find the true meaning of an Act. For example, the long title of the Abortion Act 1967 is 'An Act to amend and clarify the law relating to termination of pregnancy by registered medical practitioners.' This was referred to by four of the five Law Lords who heard the appeal in Royal College of Nursing of the United Kingdom v DHSS (1981).
The preamble/objectives/purposes section that can be found at the beginning of an Act. A preamble is usually found in older statuses and it is a statement preceding the main body of the Act, setting out the purpose of the Act in detail. The objectives/purposes section is usually found at the beginning of the newer acts.
The schedules appear as additions to the main body of the Act. These are usually referred by judges to make some sense of the main text. In some cases it is necessary to look at the Schedules in order to fully understand the Act. For example s2(1) of the Hunting Act 2004 provides 'Hunting is exempt if it is within a class specified in Schedule 1.' The exempt classes of hunting are then specified in Schedule 1.
Judges can also refer to the definition section that most modern Acts contain. This section contains definitions of key words used in the Act to help judges understand the meaning of an Act.
The punctuation is also considered as an intrinsic aid as it can have an effect on the meaning of words and can be taken into account in determining the meaning of statutory provisions. In Hanlon v The Law Society (1981) Lord Lowry said: ' I consider that not to take account of punctuation disregards the reality that literate people, such as parliamentary draftsmen, punctuate what they write, if not identically, at least in accordance with grammatical principles. Why should not literate people, such as judges, look at the punctuation in order to interpret the meaning of the legislation as accepted by Parliament.'
Extrinsic Aids are materials found outside the Act that may be referred to by the judge. These are dictionaries, previous acts, Interpretation Act (1978), Reports of Law Reform bodies, Hansard, International Treaties, Explanatory notes and textbooks.
A dictionary is considered as an extrinsic aid, as it can be used to find the literal meaning of words. For example, in Vaughan v Vaughan (1973) the Court of Appeal had to interpret the word 'molest'. The defendant had been the subject of injunctions in respect of previous violence towards his ex-wife, who was afraid of him.The defendant argued that pestering his ex-wife to resume their relationship by going to her home early in the morning and late at night, and also calling on her at work did not amount to molesting her. The judges decided to look into the dictionary which defined 'molest' as to 'cause trouble, vex, annoy, or put to inconvenience' and held that the defendant's behaviour did amount to molestation.
Previous Acts are considered as extrinsic aids as they may be referred to by judges. For example, in Wheatley (1979) the Court of Appeal had to interpret the provisions of the Explosive Substances Act 1883. The long title of the Act was 'An Act to amend the law relating to explosive substances, amending the Explosives Act 1875.' The Court of Appeal therefore looked at the earlier Act to made sense of the 1883 Act.
The Interpretation Act 1978 provides definition of certain words which are often used in Acts to help judges understand the meaning and purpose of an Act. For example it provides that masculine shall include the feminine and singular words include the plural unless a contrary intention appears within an Act.
Reports of the Law Commission, Royal Commissions and other official law reform bodies are also considered as extrinsic aids. Those reports are important because they can highlight what is wrong with the old law and suggest options. A report usually includes a draft Bill.
International Treaties may also be referred to by judges in order to ascertain the overriding objective of the Treaty which the Act is intended to comply with. This extrinsic aid is very often used by judges interpreting EU law.
Hansard is also one of the extrinsic aids. Since Pepper (Inspector of Taxes) v Hart (1993) the courts have been able to refer to the Parliamentary debates recorded in Hansard. However the House of Lords in this case held that Hansard can only be referred to in certain circumstances : 'The Act must be ambiguous or obscure, or a literal interpretation would lead to an absurdity. Judges may look only at statements made by a Minister or other promoter of the Bill. The statements must be clear in order for them to be relied upon.'
Explanatory notes are written by the Government department responsible for the Act once the Act has been given Royal Assent. Since 1999 Acts have been issued with explanatory notes. These are not part of the Act and therefore are considered as extrinsic aids rather than intrinsic aids.
Textbooks are also considered as extrinsic aids, as they may be referred to for guidance as to the meaning of a word or phrase. For example, in Re Castioni (1891) J.F. Stephen referred to his own text, History of the criminal Law of England, when interpreting the words 'political crime'.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Factors Affecting College

...Factors Affecting College Students’ Motivation A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of requirements for the College of Arts and Sciences Major in Psychology By Imelda Tolentino Josan Alejandra Valle Charize Faith Laciste Mirriam Calimlim Arellano University-Pasig September, 2013 Chapter I Introduction Studying is said to be the primary key to achieve academic excellence, but what factors really driven students to study? Others might say that fears motivate students while others might claim that you should give them tough classes and they will pull through. Some teaching faculty would say that students are motivated because of their personal goals in life. Yes, you could ask everyone but they would just answer in different opinions. The disagreement about the sources of student motivation makes the question of academic motivation sound a great deal like that of workplace motivation. Management theory abounds with contradictory theories about what makes employees work. Maslow (1968) argued that needs drive behaviour, and that workplace (and, presumably, academic) motivation is determined by the level of the needs hierarchy at which the individual is operating. McClelland (1966) claimed instead that motivation is driven by an innate need to achieve, and Herzberg (1959) proposed that the content of the jobs themselves was the source of the elusive employee motivation. The purpose of this research was to align explanations for student motivation with classical workplace...

Words: 3514 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Statutory Interpretation

...Statutory interpretation is process of interpreting statutes by the judges. The definition of statutes have had very specific words but indeed the judges would still need the statutory interpretation to help them. The reason of this, even how, the words in the statutes are specific but sometimes the words contains ambiguity and vagueness in words. On top of that, each word could give us different meaning. For example, we can find in the Oxford Dictionary where a word would contain at least one meaning. Hence, without the statutory interpretation, a lot of judges would have trouble in deciding their judgments in deciding a case. This essay will analyse the four rules, intrinsic aids and extrinsic aids and presumptions in the interpretation of statutes. There are four different rules of interpretation in English law which are the literal rule, the golden rule, the mischief rule and the purposive rule/approach. Each rule take different approaches and some judges prefer to use one rule while other judges prefer another rule. Traditionally, the English courts have taken a literal approach to the interpretation of statutes. The Literal Rule is the cornerstone of this approach. The literal rule requires the courts to give the words of a statute their plain meaning. It is for a court to interpret Parliament’s intention from what it has actually said – not from what it thinks it meant to say. This can produce some surprising results as, in practice, words seldom have a single plain...

Words: 1109 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Motivation in Teaching and Learning

...Motivation in learning and teaching Introduction Teachers play the first and foremost role in undermining or enhancing the motivation of students. They can facilitate self determination and essential motivation to students if the teachers are in practice of autonomy supporting style. Such a motivation is also likely to create positive consequences among students. The students of such a teacher will be less distracted in their classes and will be anxious to what is being taught. He will be associated with more positive emotions and his learning will be comprehension centered and will be ready to put more effort in his studies. He will gain better grades in class and there is only very less chance for a drop out. Only those teachers who are motivated will be able to motivate their students. Within disciplines of psychology motivation is an important aspect in both teaching as well as in learning. Hence motivation is to be considered from the perspective of both teacher and student. Definition The word motivation comes from a Latin word meaning movement (Steers, Mowday and Shapiro 2004, 379 as cited in degree essays, 2011). Motivation can be defined as the state or internal condition that directs the behavior of a person. It is the process determining the action of a person or the fact on the basis of which a person chooses to act and not to act in another way. According to (Pintrich and Schunk. 1996 ) motivation is directly related to achievement made by a person. An...

Words: 715 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Design and Workplace Reward System

...or teachers aid. In this department the para’s work to help the teachers to help the teachers do their job in teaching the students. The position mostly entails doing small groups with the children and teaching them basic skills they need to move onto kindergarten. While the teacher does one on one work with the children also teaching them basic skills or assessing the things they have learned so far during the year. The job also means that if there are students who need more redirection you are expected to do that as well. Other parts of the job mean helping the children open food packages and taking them to the bathroom when needed as well as supervising the children in the absence of the teacher. There are times when the list goes on to include leaving to get meals, and placing those meals on the table for the children. If the teacher needs some extra things done such as laminating certain papers or labeling of the classroom, cleaning the tables after meals and helping get coats on. With this job there does come a sense of self management and choice to a certain degree. This comes by getting to help chose the lesson plan with the teacher and having the option of how to take that lesson plan and teach the lesson to the child. With having this freedom of choice as the aid can really help the children to learn and it helps the teacher and the aid to work together as a team to work towards a common goal of helping the children reach their academic goals. Intrinsic Motivation ...

Words: 1250 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Motivation and the Brain

...Motivation and the Brain Motivation and the Brain Scientists and psychologists alike have been exploring the relationship between addiction and the brain for decades. The motivations behind the core root causes of addiction and how it affects the brain have been speculated over and theorized about. Refraining from drugs can be very difficult for a person to do when they are an addict. Drugs have a way of taking over a person’s life and destroying all of their relationships around them. People start using drugs for different reasons. Some people start using drugs for fun, some use to mask the feelings they are feeling, and some use for pain. This paper is going to discuss the brain structure and functions, the impact of intrinsic factors, and the extrinsic factors, which will include hereditary and the environment. Brain Structure and Functions The brain is the most delicate organ of the body. Drugs release dopamine to the brain. “Dopamine is a monoamine neurotransmitter formed in the brain from the amino acid tyrosine. Dopamine is essential for the healthy functioning of the central nervous system; it has effects on emotion, perception and movement.”(Purse, 2009) This gives a person a feeling of pleasure. The brain makes less dopamine when people continue to use drugs. With this, when people stop using drugs the dopamine is low and your brain has a hard time with pleasure. The ways that drugs motivate the brain are two-fold, chemical and psychological. There are...

Words: 1163 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Uts Managing Work & People Spc Ardmona Individual Essay

...insight into the area of motivation, and some of the models in which motivational factors are articulated. From the review, intrinsic motivation is a key to the prolonged development of competitive advantage. Nevertheless, extrinsic motivation acts as a foundational support for the development of such intrinsic motivators. The report investigates the nature of the SPC-Ardmona enterprise agreement in 2012 in relation to its motivational capacity upon employees. Findings suggest that the agreement relies heavily upon extrinsic motivators through financial rewards to motivate employees. Nevertheless, intrinsic motivation is ignored, and thus prevent the ability for the employees to gain motivation. Maslow’s hierarchy of needs and Herzberg’s motivator-hygiene theories are applied in this instance to evaluate the advantages and flaws of such application of extrinsic motivation within the agreement. Furthermore, the report suggests that development of intrinsic empowerment of employees is a key factor in allowing greater productivity and competitive advantage to be developed. Finally, the report concludes that the enterprise agreement is not the ultimate cause of SPC-Ardmona’s performance failure. However, the cause can be attributed to the failure of unions and management in understanding the needs of the employees, and the requirement for intrinsic motivation within the organization. Introduction The SPC-Ardmona case highlights the importance of applying effective managerial...

Words: 3237 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Motivation

...Motivation and the Brain PSY 355 December 23, 2009 Motivation and the Brain The World Health Organization estimated that there are over one billion people in the world who smoke cigarettes and there are over five million people in the world who are very sick and dying from an illness that was directly caused by smoking. Everyone knows that smoking is not beneficial to one’s health, and in most cases can be detrimental. Although people know how addictive nicotine is and how harmful smoking can be, a large part of the population still continues to smoke. Smoking cessation depends upon motivation, the structure and functions of the brain, and many intrinsic and extrinsic factors. Brain Structures and Functions Smoking cigarettes is highly addictive. Studies have shown that 10% of the people who are addicted to nicotine become addicted within two days of smoking their first cigarette. Other studies have shown that 25% of people who are addicted to nicotine became addicted within the first month of smoking. When a person smokes one cigarette, it only takes enough nicotine from that one cigarette to affect the human brain. This happens because that small amount of nicotine can saturate receptors in the human brain known as nicotine receptors. Even after a person stops smoking and is no longer taking any nicotine in his body, the nicotine that was originally in the brain can affect that person’s brain for an extended period (Reiss, Ph.D., 2007). Specific brain structures...

Words: 1382 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Positive Reinforcements in the Workplace

...POSITIVE REINFORCEMENTS IN THE WORKPLACE For an organization, good work is rewarded with some type of a positive reinforcement. By doing the positive reinforcement, the act which was rewarded had a pleasant result and makes the employee want to continue to do good work. Behavior is a function of its consequences (Love, 2005). Managers have to do some type of positive reinforcement to keep the employees doing great performances and that leads to the organization’s good repetition and what keeps the business going. Some forms of positive reinforcements in the workplace are: • Contests- to recognize and reward top performance • Promoting fun and values • Rewards which should be symbolic, tangible, and anchor positive behaviors With the right reinforcement, everyone’s performance can improve. Applying that knowledge will bring about the behavioral changes you want from your employees. And that’s the best way to meet your company’s goals (Love, 2005). Being a manager, taking into consideration of positive reinforcements would only make what he/she has at hand better. Ways to let your employees know that they are valued and spur them on to success are to accentuate the positive by informing of the wrong but going easy on how it is said and what is said; open the lines of communication by encouraging group discussions where employees are able to just open up and get everything off their minds and as a manager, being there as a mediator. If you give your people a little more...

Words: 2318 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Rsm260 Sample Midterm with Answer

...University of Toronto Faculty of Arts and Science and Rotman School of Management RSM 260H1S – Organizational Behaviour Duration: 110 minutes Aids allowed: one aid sheet (front side only of an 8.5”x11” piece of paper) Paper foreign language dictionary for international students Please answer all questions in this exam. Answers to the multiple choice questions need to be filled in on the scantron sheets (remember to use pencil to fill in the circles) and also circled on the exam itself. Answers to the short answer questions should go in the exam booklet provided. All three components (scantron sheets, exam booklets, paper copy of exam) should be turned in at the conclusion of the exam. This exam consists of 25 multiple choice questions, 10 true/false questions and 2 short answer essay questions – you must answer ALL questions. The exam consist of 9 pages (including cover sheet) Name: ___________________________________________________________ Student #: ___________________________________ Question | Grade | 25 multiple choice questions(2 points each) | /50 | 10 true/false questions(1 point each) | /10 | Essay question #1 | /20 | Essay question #2 | /20 | Total: | /100 | Note that all page numbers refer to the 8th edition of John and Saks SECTION 1: Multiple choice questions (25 questions x 2 points each = 50 points total) Answer all multiple-choice questions. Circle the ONE best answer to the question, and fill it in on your...

Words: 2318 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

The Use of Intrinsic and Extrinsic Rewards on Improving Job Performance in an Organization

...Introduction In the world of rapid changing environment and globalization, for an organization to compete favourably and competitively, the performance of their employees goes a long way in determining the success of an organization (Ajila and Abiola 2004). Both public and private sectors organizations are putting increasing attention on human resource management to maintain and motivate its most valuable and worthy assets, the employees. According to Catalini (2012), organizations are taking more of a proactive stance towards ensuring employees are satisfied with their place of employment and feel a level of commitment and connection to employers. Back then, employee satisfaction is often not a primary focus of an employer. Organizations routinely focus on finances, production, and pleasing customers and neglect the impact their actions or lack of action has on employee satisfaction. The consequences may be seen in products or services that are not up to standards and an increase in turnover and increase in cost for employers. Hence, finding the right balance between employee satisfaction and its enhancement of employee motivation and performance is imperative as it will have positive effects on several aspects of an organization, including lowering turnover rates and increasing productivity and profit. The use of rewards has been found over the years to be one of the management tools in the organization to increase job performance. Besides, it is common...

Words: 5061 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Global Operations

...provide you with some information I retrieved from analyzing a survey that was done by our organization. I will provide you with some information that can be valuable to improving job satisfaction in our employees. The survey that was conducted gathered the following the following set of data ; the age and gender of our employees the department they work in, what position they hold, if they have tenure, if they are satisfied with their jobs, what their intrinsic and extrinsic job satisfaction is and how satisfied they are with their benefits. The qualitative data is gender and age and the quantitative data is the intrinsic and extrinsic job satisfaction. Data collections, analysis, and graphing are very important. Many industries, manufacturing specifically now use statistics to monitor their processes in order to ensure a quality products. Statistics help in making product decisions and financial managing. (Unknown, N.D.) Statistics can be used in an organization to make budgeting decisions about their future and aids in making decisions about how to improve a product and hence probability can be used to predict how well the changes in the product will do. Mr. Doe I will now present some distribution tables that will show you the percentage of men versus women we have on staff and the percentage of which gender get tenure. This...

Words: 714 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Theories of Motivation

...Theories of Motivation Abstract Motivation is the enthusiasm that one possesses in order to complete a certain task, action or desired outcome. If one lacks motivation the likelihood of a prolific product or outcome is unlikely. In education, two forms of motivation are focused on in being pertinent to student learning: intrinsic motivation and extrinsic motivation. Examining the five theories of motivation: self-determination theory, attribution theory, expectancy-value theory, social-cognitive theory, and the goal-orientation theory gives educators an insight into various factors that influence the motivation or seemingly “lack of” motivation in everyday students. Educators are made aware of techniques they can use and those to avoid helping to influence each student’s academic motivation constructively. Realizing that motivation does not solely come from the student, but that other variables, controllable and uncontrollable, influence the academic motivation of the typical learner will allow educators, parents and the community to ignite an inexhaustible motivation in “all” students. Theories of Motivation Education for all students, regardless of their abilities, is a constant, increasing concern in our nation. Standards have been put in place for “all” students to achieve, despite learning disabilities, special needs, personal interests, backgrounds, or confidence/motivation levels. Many students are labeled as being unmotivated about learning and lazy...

Words: 2153 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Motivational Plan for Team C

...Motivational Plan for Team C Virginia Allen LDR/531 April 27, 2015 Franz Gottleib Motivational Plan for Team C Devising a motivational plan requires several elements to increase motivation, satisfaction, and performance of a sales team. The plan is based on individual values to be effective. Second, managers have to apply extrinsic motivators to affect their intrinsic motivators. Third, leaders have to lead by example to reinforce and evaluate team performance. The following describes a motivation plan for cautious and dominate type personalities based on the DiSC Assessment and the position of territory managers for DermaTran Health Solutions for members of Learning Team C. Territory Manager Position Description “DermaTran Health Solutions is a group of compounding pharmacies that specialize in the compounding topical pain creams based on a prescription from a physician” (DermTran Health Solutions Compounding Pharmacies, 2015). Territory Managers are sales people hired to increase market penetration of compounded topical creams. Successful, Territory Managers must develop relationships with physicians and physician assistants to explain the compounding benefits of topical creams to influence them to write prescriptions tailored to the patient’s treatment. Determining Values Territory Managers have high-risk jobs and endure several challenges, constant rejection, fear of job loss, and face bruises to their ego every day. They are sales people expected to perform...

Words: 1387 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Devry Hrm 430 Compensation and Benefits Week 3 Assignment

...DeVry University HRM-430 Week 3 Assignment Compensation embodies both the intrinsic and extrinsic rewards employees obtain for accomplishing their jobs. Collectively, both intrinsic and extrinsic compensation refer to a company’s total compensation system. Innate compensation replicates employees’ psychological mind-sets that stem from accomplishing their duties. Extrinsic compensation consists of both financial and nonfinancial benefits. Organizational development professionals promote intrinsic compensation through effective job design. (Martocchio 4) Compensation is based on the following: • market study regarding the value of comparable jobs in the marketplace, • employee contributions and achievements, • the accessibility of employees using comparable skills in the marketplace, • the need of the employer to appeal and retain a certain employee for the value they are recognized to add to the employment relationship, and • the profitability of the company or the funds available in a non-profit or public sector setting, and thus, the ability of an employer to pay market-rate compensation. “Compensation moreover comprises payments such as bonuses, profit sharing, overtime pay, recognition rewards and checks, and sales commission. Compensation can also consist of non-monetary perks such as a company-paid car, stock options in certain instances, company-paid housing, and other non-monetary, but taxable, income items.” (Heathfield) Overview of Compensation Philosophy ...

Words: 812 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Impact of Motivation on Employees Performance

...(quantity and quality) from every organizational member. Theorists of both cognitive and a cognitive orientations agree that managers should give considerable emphasis to tying organizational rewards to performance on the job Hamner, 1974; Porter & Lawler, 1968). The assumption (often implicit) in these attempts to encourage increased performance is that there is an additive relationship between externally mediated rewards and rewards which arise out of task performance itself. Therefore, if either one or both types of reward outcomes can be increased, total motivation or performance behaviors can be increased. In the late 1940’s a psychology professor called Harry F. Harlow (Harlow, Harlow & Meyer 1950) conducted one of the first true intrinsic motivational experiments ever performed, using a simple puzzle where a rhesus monkey needed to perform 3 simple tasks in a specific row to complete it. A simple task for a human, but a much more complex task for a little monkey. The experiment was performed on 12 primates over a 3-week period. Almost immediately the monkeys were able to solve the puzzle and they continued to solve it every time they were near it, without receiving any kind of rewards or recognition from doing so. Nobody showed the rhesus monkeys how to solve the puzzle or taught them that they even could solve it, but they still did it. Harlow concluded that it must have been due to an internal biological motivator that gave the monkeys a satisfaction or enjoyment...

Words: 25213 - Pages: 101