Free Essay

Investigating the Effect of Streaming on Performance of Students

In:

Submitted By MadalitsoSiyabu
Words 1231
Pages 5
LITERATURE REVIEW ON AN INVESTIGATION UNTO THE EFFECT OF STREAMING ON THE PERFORMANCE OF SLOW LEARNERS. This chapter is a reflection of what other researchers have come up with pertaining to the problem of streaming. It will help to gain understanding of the current state of knowledge about this problem. It will also help to stimulate and derive an initial list of pertinent questions to ask or behaviors to observe (Johnson and Christensen, 2012). Additionally it will show the originality and relevance of the research problem owing to the fact that, knowing what others have done makes researchers to be better prepared to understand with deeper insight, the problem under study (Leedey, 1985). One of the most controversial aspects of teaching is dealing with the many differences between students in the classroom (Reynolds, 2011), then (West and Muijs, 2009) observes that there is a need for personalization in order to offer education that is tailored to the learner, within systems responsive to learners’ needs rather than expecting the learner to adapt to the existing systems within the school. In order to address the differences in learning abilities teachers find themselves using the term streaming. There are a number of definitions of streaming. To begin with the Oxford English dictionary defines streaming as the policy of dividing school students into groups of the same level of ability. Daniel Muijs (2011), also defines streaming as a procedure where by students are segregated into different classes according to ability within their school. Likewise, in www.cea.ace.ca/factsoneducation it has been elucidated that streaming or ‘’tracking’’ means that students are placed into groups defined by their ability levels. Streaming policy has been a bone of contention among teachers and policy makers for many years. Carole Faithorn (2003) lists some of the arguments that are for and against streaming. She observes that certain subjects are hard and would be impossible to teach successfully in mixed ability environment. She goes on to elucidate that students are different and require different teaching approaches. She also claims that mixed ability grouping holds the best students back. On the other paw, she notes that streaming is deeply damaging to child’s self esteem .She goes further to explain that intelligent quotient testing is discredited and totally unfair way to determine a child’s future and prospects. Additionally, she argues that mixed ability groups in comprehensive schools are important in the social development of children and the progressive development of society. Furthermore, she argues that teachers’ low expectation of bottom sets results in less preparation and effort on the part of the teacher. Likewise, teacher labels become self fulfilling prophecies as slow learners are expected to perform badly. Kate Chopin (2012), argues that streaming of students is helpful to all kinds of students be it fast learner, average learner or slow learner. She goes on to elucidate that smart students face more competition, the average students develop confidence in themselves and the weak students don’t feel pressurized and can explore various career opportunities. Kate also notes that opponents of streaming agree that the gifted learners benefit from grouping in programs designed to accelerate their learning. However, Dimartino (2005) argues that while it seems true that streaming is easier and more efficient for the teacher to pitch lessons at the right level besides helping students to reach their potential, it is not possible to place students equitably or accurately into groups based on ability. He believes that the benefits of streaming are questionable when overall research evidence is considered. Dimartino also claims that streaming creates elitism; sets lower expectations for the lower stream students as well as teachers besides wasting time and resources. Hotter (1992), seems to agree with Dimartino’s view observing that any academic gains from ability grouping are too small to be significant. However, Linchevski and Kutscher (1998) reported that a study comparing mixed ability to same ability in the seventh and eighth grade mathematics class in Israel school found that there were significant losses for the middle and low ability students being taught in the same ability classes, and insignificant gains for high ability students. Thus Clark and Plewis (2002) also found that there were gains for the gifted or fast learners in streamed classes, and insignificant gains for high ability students. An analysis conducted by Slavin (1990), found that there were no significant positive effects of ability grouping for any programs except acceleration for the gifted. He excludes from his study those programs which offered different curricula for different ability levels. Mills and Durden (1992) found that within ability grouped class, students are able to contribute more equally to group work, and discuss ideas more easily. Likewise, students’ achievement standards can be raised since teachers can target instruction and use more resources cost effectively. However, he acknowledges that a research shows that grouping by ability has adverse effects on students’ attitudes towards schooling and their self esteem. Additionally, Bladdock (1995), cite several negative effects of ability grouping, especially on students in low ability groups who are frequently taught by less able teachers, cover less content than higher ability classes and suffer loss of motivation and self image. On the other paw, Boaler et al (2000) found many negative effects on ability grouping for the presumably able students in the highest set class. These effects included being taught at a pace two fast for students to grasp the concepts and being taught too prescriptively. There are several challenges faced by the policy of streaming. Firstly streaming assumes that intelligence is not enough to be able to predict pupils achievement in all subjects based on some prior measure. However this is not always the case as research suggests that there are differences in pupil performance over different subjects (Muijs, 1998). Muijs also observes that while correlations between performances in different subjects are significant; they are not high enough to suggest that one is measuring the same underlying concept. Reynolds and Farrell (1996) also points out that one problem with streaming is that it assumes that ability is the determining factor in achievement which is not always the case. He goes on to explain that effort motivation and self esteem can also affect achievement quite strongly. Another problem of streaming as noted by Ireson and Karweit (2002) is that there is a tendency for students from lower socio economic status background and from ethnic minorities to be put in lower streams. In conclusion, this chapter has covered some of the relevant literature on streaming, its advantages and disadvantages. It has been argued from several sources that ability grouping can slightly improve achievement of high achieving pupils, but may be detrimental to low achieving students. Whether streaming is helpful or not, it’s a thing which requires a research to clear all the misconceptions about the subject.

References Johnson, B. (2012) Educational Research, Sage Publications Inc. London. Reynolds, D. (2011) Effective Teaching and Practice, Sage Publications Inc. London Clarke, D. and Clarke, B. (2008) Is Time up for Ability Grouping? EQ Australia, autumn. Boaler, J. (2000) Students experiences of ability grouping. British Educational Research Journal 26(5), 631-648. Linchevski, L and Kutsher, B. (1998) Mixed ability versus same ability grouping in mathematics. Journal of Research in Mathematics Education. 29(5), 533-554 Ireson, J. and Hallam, S. (1999).Is ability grouping the answer? Oxford review of Education. 259(3), 343-358.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Whatever

...Chapter 1: INTRODUCTION TO QUALITATIVE RESEARCH METHODS This chapter introduces the fundamental elements of qualitative research methods, beginning with a definition of qualitative of research, followed by discussion on the evolution of qualitative research methods and how it is different from quantitative research methods. Also discussed is the importance of ethical considerations when doing qualitative research. Just like all research, qualitative research is a type of research that seeks answers to a question; is systematically conducted and involves the collection of evidence. However, the uniqueness of qualitative research is that you may produce findings that were not determined in advance and also the findings may be applicable beyond the immediate boundaries of the study. It is especially effective if you want to obtain culturally specific information about the subjects involved; i.e. the values, behaviours, and opinions of a particular population. However, the term qualitative research is a general definition that includes many different methods used in understanding and explaining social phenomena. The following are some definitions by prominent scholars in the field: • According to Denzin and Lincoln (1994), qualitative research focuses on interpretation of phenomena in their natural settings to make sense in terms of the meanings people bring to these settings. Qualitative research...

Words: 6033 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

Abbreviated Quantitative Research Plan Stress

...Chapter 1: INTRODUCTION TO QUALITATIVE RESEARCH METHODS This chapter introduces the fundamental elements of qualitative research methods, beginning with a definition of qualitative of research, followed by discussion on the evolution of qualitative research methods and how it is different from quantitative research methods. Also discussed is the importance of ethical considerations when doing qualitative research. Just like all research, qualitative research is a type of research that seeks answers to a question; is systematically conducted and involves the collection of evidence. However, the uniqueness of qualitative research is that you may produce findings that were not determined in advance and also the findings may be applicable beyond the immediate boundaries of the study. It is especially effective if you want to obtain culturally specific information about the subjects involved; i.e. the values, behaviours, and opinions of a particular population. However, the term qualitative research is a general definition that includes many different methods used in understanding and explaining social phenomena. The following are some definitions by prominent scholars in the field: • According to Denzin and Lincoln (1994), qualitative research focuses on interpretation of phenomena in their natural settings to make sense in terms of the meanings people bring to these settings. Qualitative research...

Words: 6033 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

A Handbook on Inequality, Poverty and Unmet Social Needs in Singapore

...Lien Centre for Social Innovation Social Insight Research Series Inequality, Poverty and Unmet Social Needs in Singapore A Handbook on A Handbook on Inequality, Poverty and Unmet Social Needs in Singapore Lien Centre for Social Innovation CATHERINE J. SMITH (Additional research and writing by John Donaldson, Sanushka Mudaliar, Mumtaz Md Kadir and Yeoh Lam Keong) As this handbook is intended to provide an overview of the arguments of others, the role of the authors largely consisted of compiling, arranging, and contextualizing. Further, the ideas expressed herein, which are various and often contradictory, do not necessarily represent the views of the handbook’s authors, or of the staff and Board of the Lien Centre for Social Innovation. Copyright © March, 2015 by Lien Centre for Social Innovation. All rights reserved. Published by the Lien Centre for Social Innovation Singapore Management University, Administration Building, 81 Victoria Street, Singapore 188065 www.lcsi.smu.edu.sg No part nor entirety of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, or stored in any retrieval system of any nature without the prior written permission of the Lien Centre. Readers should be aware that internet websites offered as citations and/ or sources for further information may have changed or disappeared between the time this was written and when it was read. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and authors...

Words: 30222 - Pages: 121

Premium Essay

Uses of Ict in Nigeria

...various forms and roles which it performs in learning, especially in the teaching and learning of language. It is a powerful tool which can take the form of texts, pictures, tables, graphs, emails, fax, chat groups, discussion groups, SMSs, socializing portals, dictionaries, e-encyclopaedia, Power Point presentations, websites and audio-videos, etc. It can play instructional roles which include making learners feel more relaxed to learn various topics and tasks and making them active as learning is technologically based. The problem which we have identified in the use of ICT in tertiary education is lack of infrastructure and trained manpower (personnel) to use the ICT tools in teaching and learning. Most lecturers, technologists and students who are supposed to use the ICT tools are ignorant of what they are and their uses. Previous researches on ICT have focused on the hardware, software, professional development and support services. The purpose of this study is to identify the available ICT infrastructural facilities and to discuss how they can be put to effective use in the teaching and learning of language. The study will limit its focus on the University of Nigeria, Nsukka. Although the area of this study is the University of Nigeria, Nsukka, we are aware that many tertiary institutions in Nigeria face the same...

Words: 4988 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Research

...How do employment, age, and income influence the possibilities of a greater purchasing power? What contributes to a higher income level? Fahmeda Sultana ID: 4864712 Executive Summary ‘The Creative Life’, a company based on Huizhou, China is a multinational electronic company. The Creative Life (TCL) has been trying to capture the market overseas through merger and acquisitions. This research report is based on the study of how TCL can improvise demographic variables and use the data to extract results on the level of income and their buying power. Considering the scenario that the company is trying to launch a hi-end tablet in India or United States the data is collected. In order to examine the two markets the research problem has been identified: What are the attributes that will lead to higher purchasing power of the consumers for hi-end tablets? Research questions and hypothesis are constructed to find the relationship between age, gender income, type of employment, and level of education. The study involve the used exploratory research design to examine the objectivity, nature and the dependability. Income is used to assess the buying power of the individuals. How can income affect a greater buying power, how the type of employment caters to greater income level and how education can lead to high income is all discussed in details in the report. Questionnaire is completed...

Words: 5412 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Social Effects of Facebook

...THE SOCIAL EFFECTS OF FACEBOOK ON FEMALES OF ISLAMIC UNIVERSITY IN UGANDA A CASE STUDY OF MAIN CAMPUS, MBALE BY ANGAIKA SYMPATHY 113-023051-09596 A RESEARCH REPORT SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF SOCIAL SCIENCES IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE AWARD OF A BACHELORS DEGREE IN MASS COMMUNICATION OF ISLAMIC UNIVERSITY IN UGANDA JULY 2016 GLOSSARY Acquaintances - A person whom one knows but who is not a particularly close friend. Cognitive - Based on or capable of being reduced to empirical factual knowledge. Collaboration - To work jointly with others or together especially in an intellectual endeavor. Consensual – Existing or made by mutual consent without an act of writing. Correlate – Either of two things so related that one directly implies or is complementary to the other. Cramming - To prepare hastily for an examination. Cravings - An intense, urgent, or abnormal desire or longing. Demography - The statistical study of human populations especially with reference to size and density, distribution, and vital statistics. Exclusion - The act or an instance of excluding. Flourish - To be in a state of activity or production. G.P.A. - Grade Point Average Gregarious - Tending to associate with others of one's kind. Immersion - The act of immersing or the state of being immersed. Inconclusive - Leading to no conclusion or definite result. Innocuous...

Words: 17771 - Pages: 72

Premium Essay

Business Development Planning

...Providing resources for staff and students in higher and further education in the UK and beyond Business Development Plan 2009–2012 EDINA is a JISC National Datacentre Table of Contents 1. INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 2. MISSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1 3. VALUES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1 4. CONTEXT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 5. BUSINESS PLAN FOR 2009–2012 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Strategic goal 1: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 To provide added value, high quality services, leveraged by research, enhancement activity and engagement with others Strategic theme 1a: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3-7 Providing a managed portfolio...

Words: 9567 - Pages: 39

Premium Essay

The Role of Information and Communication Technology in the Teaching and Learning of Literature in English in Senior Secondary Schools in Ondo West

...CHAPTER ONE 1.0 INTRODUCTION Information dissemination is an old as man’s ability to communicate meaningfully and intelligently among people to differentiate human beings from animals. There had been some existed channels of making meaningful transfer of information in form, facets and useful ideas through diverse kinds of tangible and intangible media. Since most of these early channels of communication were predominantly physical, they came with lots of problems and difficulties. Imagine in the olden days when teaching learning and communication were carried out through crude means. This research work would extensively examine the role of information and communication technology (ICT), up to the present age that can be called modern ICT age. 1.1 BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY The word is growing digital every second in time with the evolution of new ideas radically transforming every facet of human endeavors and lives generally. There is a great potential for significant improvement our lives as a result of the new technological advancement will depend entirely on the spread with which we adapt to it. Oxford advanced learners dictionary: Information is fact or details about something while technology is the scientific knowledge used in practical ways in industry. In the word of Hornby (1982), information is the giving of knowledge or news while technology is defined as the study mastering and utilization of manufacturing and industrial methods, systematic application of knowledge...

Words: 9555 - Pages: 39

Premium Essay

The Role of Information and Communication Technology in the Teaching and Learning of Literature in English in Senior Secondary Schools in Ondo West

...CHAPTER ONE 1.0 INTRODUCTION Information dissemination is an old as man’s ability to communicate meaningfully and intelligently among people to differentiate human beings from animals. There had been some existed channels of making meaningful transfer of information in form, facets and useful ideas through diverse kinds of tangible and intangible media. Since most of these early channels of communication were predominantly physical, they came with lots of problems and difficulties. Imagine in the olden days when teaching learning and communication were carried out through crude means. This research work would extensively examine the role of information and communication technology (ICT), up to the present age that can be called modern ICT age. 1.1 BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY The word is growing digital every second in time with the evolution of new ideas radically transforming every facet of human endeavors and lives generally. There is a great potential for significant improvement our lives as a result of the new technological advancement will depend entirely on the spread with which we adapt to it. Oxford advanced learners dictionary: Information is fact or details about something while technology is the scientific knowledge used in practical ways in industry. In the word of Hornby (1982), information is the giving of knowledge or news while technology is defined as the study mastering and utilization of manufacturing and industrial methods, systematic application of knowledge...

Words: 9555 - Pages: 39

Premium Essay

The Role of Information and Communication Technology in the Teaching and Learning of Literature in English in Senior Secondary Schools in Ondo West

...CHAPTER ONE 1.0 INTRODUCTION Information dissemination is an old as man’s ability to communicate meaningfully and intelligently among people to differentiate human beings from animals. There had been some existed channels of making meaningful transfer of information in form, facets and useful ideas through diverse kinds of tangible and intangible media. Since most of these early channels of communication were predominantly physical, they came with lots of problems and difficulties. Imagine in the olden days when teaching learning and communication were carried out through crude means. This research work would extensively examine the role of information and communication technology (ICT), up to the present age that can be called modern ICT age. 1.1 BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY The word is growing digital every second in time with the evolution of new ideas radically transforming every facet of human endeavors and lives generally. There is a great potential for significant improvement our lives as a result of the new technological advancement will depend entirely on the spread with which we adapt to it. Oxford advanced learners dictionary: Information is fact or details about something while technology is the scientific knowledge used in practical ways in industry. In the word of Hornby (1982), information is the giving of knowledge or news while technology is defined as the study mastering and utilization of manufacturing and industrial methods, systematic application of knowledge...

Words: 9555 - Pages: 39

Premium Essay

Learning with Technology

...arise. Should we continue to pump money into educational technology for our schools? Do computers really help students learn? How can students and teachers best learn from the World Wide Web and its content? These questions are not new, nor unique to the dawn of Internet-connected schools. Earlier technologies, from textbook and illustration to film, television, and multimedia computer, have prompted similar ponderings. If technology is to have a significant role in schools, we need assurance that it works. More emphatically, we need confidence that use of educational technology results in learning. Research, both historical and contemporary, suggests that technology-based instruction can and does result in learning. Witness these examples of television, multimedia, and computer technologies delivering content to support learning: • Watching the television program Blue’s Clues has strong effects on developing preschool viewers’ flexible thinking, problem solving, and prosocial behaviors (Bryant, Mullikin, McCollum, Ralastin, Raney, Miron, et al., 1998). • Court TV’s Choices and Consequences program reduced middle school students’ verbal aggression — including tendencies to tease, swear at, and argue with others (Wilson, Linz, Federman, Smith, Paul, Nathanson, et al., 1999). • Viewing Sesame Street was positively associated with subsequent performance in reading, mathematics, vocabulary,...

Words: 19667 - Pages: 79

Premium Essay

Investigation of Web Users’ Interests Influence on Perceived Download Times for Websites

...Abstract Long loading times of the web pages increase users’ frustration. Continually this appears to be one of the main problems of World Wide Web which users need to face every day. Delays in loading a web page cause dissatisfaction and often loss of visits and in case of e-commerce websites it means also loss of income. Although many techniques have been applied to resolve this problem it is still coming back due to a high number of Internet users. Still, the problem is a also matter to human perception and how people classify slow or fast download times. Many theories and rules have been applied trying to measure a maximum time of a website response that users can tolerate. However there are some problems associated with evaluating the effects of download delays on a website in an experimental setting like not taking into consideration what personal interests are, usefulness of the websites, etc. The paper will investigate the significant impact of perception on loading times taking also into consideration the influence of user favorable websites. In order to identify the path of the experiment as well as the potential solutions a literature review was carried out. This was followed by a single lab based experiment where the participants were comparing their preferred websites with another one chosen by the author with similar contents. Since this research involved participants the evaluation...

Words: 14550 - Pages: 59

Premium Essay

Linguistic Impacts of Instant Messaging

...Contents Introduction 2 Literature review: 4 Methodology 14 Secondary Research: 15 Primary research: 15 Sample size: 15 Data analysis: 16 Questionnaires: 17 Interview: 19 Findings 19 Social Interaction: 19 Emotional Interaction: 20 Expression: 20 Culture: 21 Conclusion and recommendations: 22 Limitations 23 Appendix 1 24 Appendix 2 29 Questionnaire 29 Interview Questions: 30 Appendix 3 32 Codes 32 Response Sheet 33 Abstract IM is a text based, real time communication tool that has swept the world and altered how people interact with each other. It has created its own culture and ‘language’ and its effects can clearly be seen especially in teenagers. IM is a phenomenon that has countless effects on different parts of language, culture and society. This research aims to examine some of these effects based on one interview and questionnaires that were filled out by 25 young people. The key findings are drawn on the basis of responses given by respondents and the interviewee as well as the research done of the existing literature. Introduction By definition, instant messaging is a set of communication technologies used for text-based communication between two or more participants over the Internet or other types of networks. It basically offers real-time direct written language-based communication. Instant messaging falls under the broader term of ‘Online chatting’. This is because it is text-based, exchangeable in many directions...

Words: 6876 - Pages: 28

Free Essay

K-12 Math Curriculum

...Principles and Standards for School Mathematics (2000). The K–12 MCC offers a variety of products and services to assist mathematics teachers and administrators. Our seminars address selecting and implementing new curricula, designing professional development and support, aligning curriculum with assessment, and examining leadership in curricular change. Our other resources include: About This Publication This publication, an annotated bibliography of articles relevant to Standards-based mathematics curriculum reform, is intended as a resource for educators and communities considering the selection and implementation of a Standards-based mathematics curriculum. It also may assist individuals who are interested in learning about the student achievement, classroom practices, and implementation challenges associated with the use of Standards-based materials. When gathering resources for this publication, the K–12 Mathematics Curriculum Center staff reviewed articles that either addressed important issues in mathematics curriculum change or shared experiences, views, and data relevant to the selection and use of 12 comprehensive mathematics programs based on the NCTM Standards and developed with support from the NSF. These programs are listed on the back cover of this publication. This bibliography does not attempt to be comprehensive and certainly does not include every article written about mathematics curriculum reform. Rather, the goal...

Words: 26387 - Pages: 106

Premium Essay

Krashen

...Second Language Acquisition and Second Language Learning Stephen D Krashen University of Southern California Copyright © 1981 Stephen Krashen All Rights Reserved. This publication may be downloaded and copied without charge for all reasonable, non-commercial educational purposes, provided no alterations in the text are made. First printed edition 1981 by Pergamon Press Inc. Print Edition ISBN 0-08-025338-5 First internet edition December 2002 i Acknowledgments I would like to thank the following journals and organizations for granting permission to reprint material: Newbury House, the Center for Applied Linguistics, Language Learning, TESOL, the SPEAQ Journal, Academic Press. I have had a great deal of help and feedback from many people in writing this book. Among the many scholars and friends I am indebted to are Marina Burt, Earl Stevick, Heidi Dulay, Robin Scarcella, Rosario Gingras, Nathalie Bailey, Carolyn Madden, Georgette Ioup, Linda Galloway, Herbert Seliger, Noel Houck, Judith Robertson, Steven Sternfeld, Batyia Elbaum, Adrian Palmer, John Oller, John Lamendella, Evelyn Hatch, John Schumann, Eugene Brière, Diane Larsen-Freeman, Larry Hyman, Tina Bennet, Ann Fathman, Janet Kayfetz, Ann Peters, Kenji Hakuta, Elinor Ochs, Elaine Andersen, Peter Shaw, and Larry Selinker. I also would like to express my thanks to those scholars whose work has stimulated my own thinking in the early stages of the research reported on here: John Upshur, Leonard Newmark, and S...

Words: 54067 - Pages: 217