Free Essay

Is Life an Illusion

In:

Submitted By dscoulter
Words 834
Pages 4
Is life an Illusion?
David Coulter
Liberty University

Is Life an Illusion?
Each of the readings discusses aspects of man being deceived by his senses. In The Matrix, almost every human is plugged into a giant computer and lives out an illusion provided by the computer to the brain (Wachowski, 1999). In The Allegory of the Cave, a hypothetical situation where men are only allowed to see shadows of reality is discussed by Socrates and Glaucon (Plato, n.d.). Finally, in Meditation I of The Things of Which We May Doubt, René Descartes attempts to eliminate all beliefs that might be based on something uncertain. He proposes that a demon may be providing an illusion and his senses may not reflect reality (Descartes, 1641). With all of this investigation around human senses being deceived, is it possible for people to trust their senses?
The Matrix and The Allegory of the Cave both deal with how men react to reality when illusion and reality are recognized for what they are. However, they each deal with this recognition in different ways. In The Matrix, reality is far less pleasant than the illusion. Some prefer the truth rather than to be deceived, and one in particular prefers the illusion claiming “ignorance is bliss” (Wachowski, 1999). In The Allegory of the Cave, the hypothetical subjects when confronted with reality find it to be less real than the deceptive shadows that they have always thought was reality. Over time, they learn that the deceptive shadows were and are only reflections of reality and accept and are happy with the reality they have found (Plato, n.d.). However, in this hypothetical situation the reality is more pleasant than the illusion.
In Meditation I of The Things of Which We May Doubt, Descartes is searching for an inordinately high degree of certainty in his beliefs. Therefore, he is trying to eliminate his beliefs that rely on his senses (Descartes, 1641). He is not dealing with the reaction of himself or others to the recognition of reality versus illusion. Descartes is looking for truth. Some of the people in The Matrix are also looking for truth, but at least one man, Cypher, is looking for the illusion (Wachowski, 1999). In The Allegory of the Cave, the subjects are neither looking for truth or illusion. They are simply reacting to the circumstances.
The Matrix may be intended to reflect reality by showing that some people prefer illusion to reality particularly when the illusion is more pleasant than the reality. It may also be trying to show human integrity by showing more of those who have found reality prefer it over the illusion even though the illusion is more pleasant than the reality.
In all three of the readings, the illusion is brought on by a third party. In The Matrix, it is the computer (Wachowski, 1999). In The Allegory of the Cave, the perpetrator is not known (Plato, n.d.), but it is not very plausible to think men could fetter themselves in this manner as small children. It is also difficult to find this third party anything but malevolent due to the nature of the imprisonment. In Descartes’ meditation, the third party is a demon. This third party in each case is not good. Also, in each of these cases the conditions under which the senses are deceived are unusual or extreme. Descartes seemed to have to find an extreme malevolent circumstance to doubt his senses other than the small tricks of light or contrast that occasionally and briefly fool most of us (Descartes, 1641). Socrates set up a fairly elaborate, unlikely, and torturous scenario to investigate the reaction of men to reality versus illusion. In The Matrix, virtually the entire human race was connected to a giant computer that provided an illusionary life for everyone (Wachowski, 1999). In view of the unlikely and extreme scenarios devised to investigate reality versus illusion or find certainty without the possibility of doubt, it seems a reasonable inference that, for most of the time, most people can trust their senses. Therefore, I believe we can say with a high degree of certainty that we are not trapped in an illusion. I do not believe we can say with absolute certainty that we are not trapped in an illusion. Abduction tells us we should use the best explanation that fits the data. Since we communicate with people all over the world and understand one another with regard to descriptions of places, things, and activities that occur all over the planet, I believe the best explanation is that people can indeed trust their senses, and they really do live in a physical world.

References
Plato (n.d.). The allegory of the cave. In The republic, Book VII, 514A1-518D8
Descartes, René (1641) Meditation 1 of the things of which we may doubt. In Meditations on first philosophy
Wachowski, Andy, and Lana Wachowski. The Matrix. Directed by Andy Wachowski and Lana Wachowski. Los Angeles: Warner Bros. Pictures, 1999

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

The Great Gatsby Essay

...What does Fitzgerald suggest about truth and illusion in The Great Gatsby? Truth and illusion are two of the key themes explored in the novel The Great Gatsby written by F. Scott Fitzgerald. Truth and illusion are explored with every character in the novel as we discover that no one is who they seem to be. There are multiple examples involving all characters in which their appearances are far different to how they are described. Jay Gatsby is one of the main characters that show he cannot see reality because his whole life is one big illusion. Another main character that portrays the theme of illusion is Daisy as we learn early in the novel that she creates an illusion to cover up who she really is. Nick is the only character that seems to be the only one who is really honest about who he is but he is only honest to the reader and not the characters. Perhaps his honesty is just an illusion about what he really is like. Jay Gatsby’s whole life is an illusion. Early in the novel we learn that Gatsby’s past was not the best and that he came from a poor background, which he tries to cover up. He gives this idea that he lives the perfect life with a huge house and always wears nice clothes and throws the biggest most amazing parties. The truth is that he does not really have any friends. This is evident when we learn that Nick discovers he was the only one who got an invitation to Gatsby’s party, this is also evident when we learn the rumours going around about Gatsby. The...

Words: 847 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Illusions

...Abstract: In this essay, Ibsen’s plays, The Wild Duck, and Ghosts are considered in relation to themes of illusions and realities. In both plays, families are held together by illusions, yet torn apart by truths that have been concealed to protect the children. Ibsen’s use of artistic realism is an ironic art form where illusions and realisms are contradicted to reveal the deeper conflicts of ordinary lives. Ibsen presents the complicated realities of ordinary lives and emphasizes the fact that there are always many realities -- just as there are many illusions. Title: Illusions and Realities in Ibsen’s Plays The Wild Duck and Ghosts Introduction In Ibsen’s The Wild Duck, illusions and reality are set into a conflict within the story of a son’s personal desire to confront idealism. Throughout much of the play, the son, Greger, argues the value of truth with the reluctant Dr. Relling. Relling insists on the importance of illusions, but fails to discourage Greger’s intentions and a play that begins as a comedy quickly turns into a tragedy because of these conflicts. At the heart of the illusions in this play are the ways that people assume many roles in a family, impersonating multiple ideals as ways for managing their relationships. This theme of impersonation is also developed in Ibsen’s Ghosts, where family relations are slowly undone as the illusions and deceptions are stripped away. In both plays, deceptions are strategic and designed to protect the children...

Words: 922 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

A Beautiful Mind

...with his wife, where in he had encountered an illusion ( conflict between the reality & his world of illusions ) which effects the people around him especially his wife) John Nash realizes that all of the characters of his illusion never get old. And thus he concludes that none of the characters in the series of illusions can be real. After this his mind is open to the facts of reality but he is still very confused & puzzled ( b’coz his mind is now telling him that the characters of his illusion are unreal but he himself is a little skeptical to accept the truth all this b’coz of the frame of mind he is in due to his illness ) This is where John Nash encounters one of the most critical turning points out of the many in his life His wife Alicia John Nash supports him further and motivates him she explains to him the difference between reality & illusions She explains to him that all that he sees may not necessarily be reality She tells him that reality is what one can feel, reality is like a heartbeat ………. That can be felt This very act of Alicia motivates him & convinces his confused mind to accept the truth and turn a new leaf over. And he begins on a new journey of life….. a journey of life full of self motivation and a fight against his illusion A turn on the highway of his life, his family and his career After this realization & motivation he now starts to ignore the three characters of his illusion ……… he is in a kind of war...

Words: 435 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Example of Literary Essay

...Abstract: In this essay, Ibsen’s plays, The Wild Duck, and Ghosts are considered in relation to themes of illusions and realities. In both plays, families are held together by illusions, yet torn apart by truths that have been concealed to protect the children. Ibsen’s use of artistic realism is an ironic art form where illusions and realisms are contradicted to reveal the deeper conflicts of ordinary lives. Ibsen presents the complicated realities of ordinary lives and emphasizes the fact that there are always many realities -- just as there are many illusions. Title: Illusions and Realities in Ibsen’s Plays The Wild Duck and Ghosts Introduction In Ibsen’s The Wild Duck, illusions and reality are set into a conflict within the story of a son’s personal desire to confront idealism. Throughout much of the play, the son, Greger, argues the value of truth with the reluctant Dr. Relling. Relling insists on the importance of illusions, but fails to discourage Greger’s intentions and a play that begins as a comedy quickly turns into a tragedy because of these conflicts. At the heart of the illusions in this play are the ways that people assume many roles in a family, impersonating multiple ideals as ways for managing their relationships. This theme of impersonation is also developed in Ibsen’s Ghosts, where family relations are slowly undone as the illusions and deceptions are stripped away. In both plays, deceptions are strategic and designed to protect the children...

Words: 923 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

War Is Kind

...interpreted several times as a satire on war. War is portrayed as a medium that brings life to the end. Death has been taken as something that is cruel, something that is evil. With the insights from the teaching of Eastern school of philosophy, looking into the lines of the poem, new directions can be provided to the vision towards death. This paper drags the poem out from the stream of satire and portrays death as a force responsible for ultimate freedom and realization. Stephen Crane, in "For War is Kind", tries to portray war as a medium that makes the span of illusion short. In the darkness, one easily gets frightened believing rope a snake because of illusion. Because of illusion death seems as an end to everything and life only truth. Life appears as the only 'ultimate truth'. We believe after life everything is put to an end. If so, where were we before the birth? We were nowhere. We are expressed for a moment of time as the air and water are manifested into a bubble for a couple of minute. This manifestation is temporary and illusive and they are "neither permanent, nor the possessions themselves everlasting" (Goyandaka 58). Life is like a tide, which arises from the same bottom of ocean where it settles. Just for a moment of time we distinguish tide and ocean, an illusion that tide is different. When tide falls, it becomes ocean. The real form is the vast ocean not the tide. Tide is an illusion to the perception. Denying his own perception, Crane asks us not to weep "for war...

Words: 1332 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Illusion over Reality in the Martian Chronicles

...04861318 The Martian Chronicles: Illusion over Reality The Martian Chronicles can be interpreted as the choice of illusion over reality. There were many events where the Martians shaped their bodies to the humans’ deepest desires or the humans themselves created illusions to fulfill these desires. By doing so, it could be seen that the characters chose to follow their illusions instead of accepting the reality they were facing. “The choice of illusion is related to the strong emotions of love, hate and empathy.” (Taylor, 2013) In chapter six –the third expedition- is clear that the humans’ illusion is to have their beloved dead ones back. Despite the Captain’s reservations and warnings, everyone accepts the illusion of Green Bluff, Illinois in Mars, which suggests unreality given that it may not be possible to copy an identical place in a different one. However, this acceptance brings comfort to the crew who are blinded by the emotion of having their resurrected family back; these families “were given a second chance to live in a new world” which, at the same time, is unreal because there is no way to bring back a dead person. The Martians linked this illusion to the strong empathy with the crew’s emotions through telepathy in order to carry out a dreadful funeral. Earth men never suspected what was happening until the last moment when they were killed because they couldn’t resist this emotion. In another story, Spender is under the illusion that everyone will understand his...

Words: 1153 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Hanne Darboven's Clockwise From Right

...The artistic display at the Albright-Knox Art Gallery of Hanne Darboven titled, “Clockwise from right”, proves to bring light upon the thoughts of Friedrich Nietzshe. One of Nietzsche’s important topics includes the idea of a rational and intuitive man. This essay will explore the question of whether Nietzsche was right when he said that it is important to live an extra-moral life. In a society where there are many practical careers, such as accountants and scientists, it is difficult to reach back to the ancient Greek society to understand how the rational and the intuitive once blended together in a flourishing society. However, there could be a way in which the rational can become more intuitive. Nietzsche’s claim that the rational could make an attempt at becoming more intuitive in today’s society holds true. Hanne Darboven was a German artist who is primarily known for her systematic charts, sequences of numbers, and her long strands of looped forms that evoke handwriting. Before becoming an artist, Darboven first trained as a pianist, and in the 1960s she studied graphic design in Hamburg, Germany. In 1966, Darboven left Germany for New York, where she met and exhibited with several artists of the burgeoning Minimalist and Conceptual art...

Words: 1205 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Matrix, Plato and Cescartes

...philosophers. Comparing the Matrix and Plato’s, the similarity is they both agree that the life we are experiencing is not as real as what it appears to be. It is simply an illusion and a life that we can question and doubt about. From Matrix’s story this happens when Neo ‘the hacker’ had a dream that made him think about the reality and the thought that there is something more to life. When Morpheus came and told him “that the world is an illusion, an elaborate system of deception perpetrated to keep people contentedly under control” (Wachowski & Wachowski, 1999). Neo then choose to eat the pill and see the truth that the human race is only relying on a machine to keep their bodies alive. Human beings are actually unconscious, therefore they are controlled by the machine. Because of this, what we see or do today happens because we are programmed into a computer simulation called Matrix. From Plato’s allegory, we see it when Socrates described men’s nature being as prisoners since childhood; being chained inside a cavern not being able to move their heads, but only looking. When one of the prisoners was released and was given the opportunity to see the light; and guided with what was going on. The human being that has seen the light will think what “he had seen before was all a cheat and an illusion. He will then want to turn toward real things” (Plato). He suggests that life or “reality to be nothing else than the shadows of the artificial objects.” From Descartes’...

Words: 809 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Invisible Gorilla How Our Intuitions Deceive Us

...because of an illusion, or a perception that occurs when a sensory stimulus is present but is not perceived correctly and often distorted. Throughout the book, it is explained how a person processes information, how certain...

Words: 726 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Do Thin Models Warp Girl's Body Image?

...Illusions are Destroying our Daughters Exchanging illusions for reality brings freedom and a clear mindset. Living in an illusion means to live in a world of misperceptions and contradictions between the senses. This lifestyle selectively accepts only the desirable aspects of life. On the other hand, living in reality entails accepting all things for what they truly are. This lifestyle requires embracing both positive and negative situations that occur. In today’s society illusion is applauded while reality is frowned upon. Suppressing life’s realities and living a fantasy will never lead to true satisfaction. In the play The Glass Menagerie all of the characters struggle with accepting their realities. For example, Amanda refuses to accept Laura’s disability and is controlling her daughter’s life. In Nanci Hellmich's "Do thin models warp girls' body image?" it clearly states how the perfect body image is an illusion, such as the one Amanda wants for Laura in The Glass Menagerie proving that people choose deception over reality because they feel inadequate compared to society's expectations....

Words: 548 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Reluctant Messiah Book Report

...If there is any book out there that can influence oneself intellectually, physically, and mentally if would primarily be Illusions: The Adventures of a Reluctant Messiah written by Richard Bach. This book reveals many different viewpoints from both Western and Eastern societies. These are indeed concepts that are usually questioned and reviewed. Along a spiritual journey two men meet and so much knowledge is exchanged. Richard is a pilot on a spiritual journey who gets involved in a one on one student-teacher relationship with Messiah in which he learns how illusions are a substitute for reality and he ideally questions what is the point of living then if everything is an illusion. There are initially two viewpoints that are well known around...

Words: 1157 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Literary Analysis of Garden Part

...conventional family’s’ lavish life of living. Mansfield portrays the correlation between different social classes and the contrasts of illusion versus reality. In detail, this can be exhibited through Laura Sheridan, when she opens herself up to the external world and discovers the death of her neighbor, Mr. Scott. Laura experiences many self-inflicting conflicts throughout the story with the correlation of different social classes and the ideal themes of illusion versus reality. Mansfield begins by setting off a turn of events when Laura expresses self-curiosity of Mr. Scott’s death. At this point Laura is awakened of this phony life she has been trapped in by her mother. She expresses feelings of anguish when she is conversing with her mother, “ you’re being very absurd, Laura…people like that don’t expect scarifies from us”(Mansfield 1344). Mansfield achieves the use of much absurdity coming from Mrs. Sheridan, who believes in the idea that one class is superior towards another and they should not face contact with one another. Mansfield at this point recognizes Laura’s revelation and begins to give emphasis to the idea that Laura can’t accept the idea of death; she is too young to understand such things. Accordingly, Laura becomes aware that death is part of life, and she becomes also aware about their life of the upper class. In fact, this disillusions Laura when she realizes that she is living in a dream, where everything is good; their life is only about fine things. She...

Words: 640 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Blanche Dubious

...important is illusion and fantasy to the understanding of A Streetcar Named Desire? After analyzing “A Streetcar Named Desire” written by Tennessee Williams in 1947 we are able to find many well-defined characters, where Williams highlighted their flaws to make them memorable. The play revolves around Blanche Dubois meaning that many of the themes concern her directly. Blanche is seen as a tragedy as an individual stuck between two worlds, which are the past and the present and does not pretend to let go of the past and live in the present. With the idea of living in the past Blanche creates her own world and all she ever does in it is live a fantasy and an illusion and so she catches our attention because of her fragile and sincere personality which as the play proceeds turns to be a illusionistic image of herself. And I believe she does this to protect herself from the “threats” outside and her fears as well. So the main themes being discussed in this essay relate to how illusion and fantasy is important. She lives in the world of illusions in order to protect herself against outside threats and against her own fears. In the play Tennessee Williams contrasted Blanche’s delusions with Stanley’s realism while in the end, Stanley and his worldview wins. Blanche’s hope throughout the play is to salvage her life in the world of brutality where the inner anxiety clashes with the outside threats by using different coping mechanism: delusions, alcoholism and illusions. Blanche...

Words: 913 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Comparative Study Woolf & Albee (Including Reflection Statement)

...by Edward Albee both address gender inequality and truth and illusion even though their contexts and form starkly contrast. An analysis of similar themes will provide a greater understanding of meanings and perceptions of the texts. AROO, written in the post-war period of the late 1920s, was composed in a time of great social change due to the destruction and turmoil of the War. Modernist writing highlights the absence of, and search for, meaning and features experiments with new forms. Loss and absence lie at the heart of Woolf’s art, resulting from the experience of loss as an adolescent – her half sister, father, brother and mother. Her refusal to give one single view of anything, offering instead multiple, often conflicting views which the reader has to balance and bring together is another modernist trait. In contrast, WAVW was written in a far more conservative context, and although Albee does challenge societal roles, he does it in a more blatant way. Written during a time of Cold War tension, where fear and instability was disguised beneath the facade of the Great American Dream, Albee is still able to paint a dystopian image of the stereotyped family unit. Post-modernist writing abandons all meaning and the Theatre of the Absurd, emerged at the time, as a theatrical technique used by Albee to reflect a post-modern world. Interestingly, AROO and WAVW are both representations of a privileged intellectual life and criticise the values in the society they lived in because...

Words: 2190 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

The Flowers

...The Flowers “Growing up is losing some illusions, in order to acquire others” This was once said by Virginia Woolf. As a child you grow up having your own idea of what life is - one can even say that you live in an illusion. The child have no experiences to build his/hers world view on. When the child then grows up she is learning how the world actually works and the illusions shatters. This is a theme in the short story “The Flowers” (1976) from the collection titled “In Love and Trouble: Stories of Black Women” by Alice Walken. Based on what I know about Alice Walken and her work, I assume Myop is a young girl from a dark colored family in the south, which world limits to the wood behind her family’s house. In the beginning of the story Myop is a happy child with a child’s innocence and illusions. The atmosphere in the beginning is also very calm and peaceful. All these changes when Myop steps on a dead body in the wood. “.. and she reached down quickly, unafraid, to free herself” (p. 107 l. 33) As you see in this quote Myop is not afraid of the situation, but looks at it with a child’s eyes of interest, and trying to make her own experiences. She doesn’t know yet that she has to be afraid. The calmness is then broken and the sentiment changes. Something is wrong and when Myop wants to go back to the peacefulness of the morning, she can’t. The calmness she knows and is pursuing is gone, as Myop has left her childhood. The point of no return would be when Myop steps upon the...

Words: 575 - Pages: 3