Premium Essay

Jane Elliott's Experiment

Submitted By
Words 666
Pages 3
In 1968 Jane Elliott was a teacher who used an experiment to teach her third grade students about discrimination, racism, and prejudice. Mrs. Elliott felt that after Martin Luther King was murdered, she needed to convey a message to her class concerning race. She separated the class into groups according to their eye color. The reasoning behind the experiment was to show tolerance for other races. In 1985, she used the same concept for employees of the Iowa State Correctional Facility. Most of these people already had preconceived issues concerning race and gender equality. The results of the 1985 study have been just as surprising as the 1968 study.
My reactions after watching the students ranged from empathy, tolerance to compassion. The innocence of a childhood before racism can be embedded is what I saw. The idea that training begins at home, therefore hatred for others is learned there. If parents were to teach love and understanding of others, then the experiment would have had a different tone. The kids would not have felt isolated from their peers. However, in 1968, America was in filled with hate and a lack of understanding for others. Most of the children did not understand what …show more content…
The general concept was the same, but this group consisted of mixed races and genders. As adults our perception of others has been instilled in us. The one person that stood out was the white woman who had a superior attitude, which came across as combative. On the other hand, the males in the study seemed to resent her authority, and did not want to follow her directions. Their entire demeanor prior to knowing what the actual exercise was about proved how they deal with others. The lack of respect for anyone in authority that they do not feel that fits into what they deem as appropriate. Consequently, at the end of the exercise their apologies seemed to be

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Ethics

...understand how people act. Jane Elliot did an exercise in which she divided the class in two groups. This exercise was unethical because it violates the principle E, respect for people's right and dignity, in ethics. According to the American Psychological Association, Principle E says that we should respect the dignity and worth of all people equally. We have to respect their culture and any differences (American Psychological Association). In the video of Elliot, this principle gets violated because Elliot is not respecting the difference among them. In this case, she does not respect that the children have different eyes color. This study is unethical because it also creates rancor among children and plays with the feelings of children. In the video, children expressed their feelings toward the experiment and they felt horrible. Furthermore, it causes psychological and emotional harm since they were not told that it was an experiment (Smithsonian). This documentary was harsh and heartbreaking to see how people could violate an important principle and their consequences of doing it. This experiment would have been ethical and harmless if Elliott would have told the children that it was an experiment beforehand. Then, after that ask them how they felt and talk about that people who are discriminated feel the same way too. This was an evil form of doing an experiment. Elliott´s idea was interesting and successful. She forgot that she was doing the experiment with children. When we...

Words: 658 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Self-Fulfilling Prophecy

...person acts towards the target, which may, in turn, influence the target to act in a way that confirms the first person’s prejudices (Taylor, Peplau, & Sears, 2006). A self-fulfilling prophecy includes three steps. First, one person must hold a false belief about another person. Second, the person holding the false belief must treat the other person in a manner that is consistent with it. A teacher who overestimates a student’s ability would have to treat the student as if she or he is highly capable. The teacher may often call on that student, spend extra time with that student, teach that student especially difficult material, and provide that student with feedback contingent on performance. For example, on the first day of Jane Elliott’s experiment, she told her students that possessing blue eyes indicated superiority in intelligence and conferred extra classroom privileges and having brown eyes indicated inferiority. Third, the person about whom the false belief is held must, in response to the treatment she or he receives, confirm the originally false belief. For example, quickly, the students with the “superior” color began to oppress those with the “inferior” color and those with the “inferior” color exhibited negative self-worth and fear. The student who is treated as if she or he is highly capable may enjoy and value school and, consequently, invest more time and effort on school work than other students do. In turn, this student may ultimately learn more than...

Words: 509 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Sleeping Car Porters

...must answer in complete sentences, using a short answer/paragraph format. 1. What is the title of the film you picked? A Class Divided 2. Why did you pick this film over the others offered? I chose this film mainly because of the strength of the message that was taught by Jane Elliott to her class. The controversial message in 1968 could have had a very horrible outbreak of speculation from the school district as well as the parents of the children she was teaching. Mrs. Elliott sought to open the eyes of her students by placing them in an experiment where their eye color is a discriminating factor, I was intrigued because they were so young and I wasn’t sure if they would understand the meaning of what Mrs. Elliott was trying to teach. I was very wrong in my assumptions of course. 3. What is/are the central message(s) of this documentary/fictional film? Be specific. Use examples from the film to support your choice. A Class Divided has several messages, primarily in regards to discrimination and the thought process behind it. Jane Elliott uses eye color as a discriminatory factor and a way to divide her classroom for her experiment. Mrs. Elliott sought to teach children...

Words: 1180 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Women and Discrimination

...Share your thoughts on the Review Questions Q3 in Schafer’s textbook (p. 368) (one paragraph) I feel very strongly against the patterns of women in the workplace differing from those of men. Women have historically been viewed as caretakers and or as worthy only of dead-end jobs (Schaefer, 2012). The pattern of pay inequity between employed women and men has been a continuing problem. To this day there is pay inequity and women struggle with the glass ceiling barrier. The patterns of discrimination, sexual harassment, and lack of opportunities still plague a women’s future in the workplace. In addition, there is a pattern that has been established by the societal roles women are assigned. Women are expected to clean the house, take care of the children, and work. While the man typically works and does occasional yard work on the weekends. After discussing this observation from my own relationship, my fiancé agreed that he could do more chores in the house and help with the children. This week my son has been battling a bacterial infection in his throat and I took two days off from work to take him to the appointments and hospital. I asked my fiancé why I always have to take time off for the children and why he does not believe in sharing this responsibility. He just looked at me and said, “Because that is how it has always been.” I am happy to announce that this pattern will be changing in my home. Furthermore, we as a society need to become more accepting of both men and...

Words: 622 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Made to Stick

...This book has been optimized for viewing at a monitor setting of 1024 x 768 pixels. MADE TO STICK random house a new york MADE TO STICK Why Some Ideas Survive and Others Die • • • C H I P H E AT H & D A N H E AT H Copyright © 2007 by Chip Heath and Dan Heath All rights reserved. Published in the United States by Random House, an imprint of The Random House Publishing Group, a division of Random House, Inc., New York. Random House and colophon are registered trademarks of Random House, Inc. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Heath, Chip. Made to stick : why some ideas survive and others die / Chip Heath & Dan Heath p. cm. Includes index. eISBN: 978-1-58836-596-5 1. Social psychology. 2. Contagion (Social psychology). 3. Context effects (Psychology). I. Heath, Dan. II. Title. HM1033.H43 2007 302'.13—dc22 2006046467 www.atrandom.com Designed by Stephanie Huntwork v1.0 To Dad, for driving an old tan Chevette while putting us through college. To Mom, for making us breakfast every day for eighteen years. Each. C O N T E N T S INTRODUCTION WHAT STICKS? 3 Kidney heist. Movie popcorn. Sticky = understandable, memorable, and effective in changing thought or behavior. Halloween candy. Six principles: SUCCESs. The villain: Curse of Knowledge. It’s hard to be a tapper. Creativity starts with templates. CHAPTER 1 SIMPLE 25 Commander’s Intent. THE low-fare airline. Burying the lead and the inverted pyramid. It’s the...

Words: 91454 - Pages: 366

Premium Essay

Asdfasdfasdfas

...towards mastery in the practice of problem solving Assessments MODULE 4 Technology 1. You are the manager of 2 small stores with production functions q = K¼L¼ and a larger store with production function q = 2K¼L¼. You hire capital for $4, labour for $1. When you took over this role, your boss told you that Q = 24 was the profit maximizing output for this multi-plan firm: 24 = q1 + q2 + q3. Now, the price of labour rises to $4. Provide (i) Isoquant/Isocost diagrams, (ii) Total Cost and (iii) Marginal Cost diagrams. Illustrate the substitution effect (point a to b) and output effect (point b to c) on these diagrams. Explain why your firm uses less capital even when the price of labour increases. (September 2010) For the production function q = K2 + L2 (A) Demonstrate that the elasticity of substitution is negative. (B) Provide a labelled diagram showing the q = 100 isoquant (C) Briefly explain what a negative value means for σ 3. 4. A special production function is q = min( 80K, 4L1 + 2L2). Discuss the production process described by this function. Is this production function constant returns to scale? Five-year-old Jack has set up a hot chocolate stand outside his home. His customers like hot chocolate made in only one way, one unit of chocolate and 3 units of milk to go into each unit of hot chocolate. Jack’s mother, Naomi, provides him with heat, cups and cleaning free of charge. However, she charges him $0.25 for each unit of chocolate and $0.50 for each unit of milk. What...

Words: 50660 - Pages: 203