Free Essay

Madness in King Lear

In: Novels

Submitted By runty10
Words 1079
Pages 5
Though separated by hundreds of years, William Shakespeare’s King Lear and Jane Smiley’s A Thousand Acres share many common themes. One of the most prominent themes shared by both literary works is that of madness. In King Lear, the theme of madness is developed throughout the story and not only involves King Lear’s descent into insanity, but also is seen when Edgar feigns madness as Poor Tom and when Goneril and Regan are gripped by madness over their lust for Edmund. In A Thousand Acres, the theme of madness is most apparent in Larry, but it can also been seen in other characters as well such as Ginny. In both King Lear and A Thousand Acres, Shakespeare and Smiley alter how they use the theme of madness from story to story exposing the reader to varying degrees and types of madness throughout their works. Although the literary works are similar in that they both involve the theme of madness, they also differ in the ways they use and present madness and those differences give the reader varying perspectives on the other themes and plots. In King Lear, the theme of madness is most clearly visible in the main character of King Lear. Although King Lear displays potential signs of insanity from the commencement of the play, it can be said that it is his anger and lust for revenge that eventually drives him to madness. We first see King Lear beginning to manifest signs of madness in the opening scene, which starts with King Lear forcing his daughters to profess their love for him in order for his daughters to receive their share of his kingdom. It seems absurd that a king would divide his kingdom according to professions of love by his daughters, but it is worth considering that a long reigning king is accustomed to exercising his power irresponsibly. The most troubling aspect of the situation is that Lear had already previously decided to divide his kingdom even before receiving his daughters’ professions of love. Gloucester tells Kent “…but, now, in the division of the kingdom, it appears not which of the Dukes he values most; for equalities are so weigh’d that curiosity in neither can make choice of either’s moiety”(I.i). This narcissism and illogical thinking, or deteriorating memory of King Lear can be seen as an early sign of him slowly edging towards madness. In A Thousand Acres, Larry, the [character that] parallels of King Lear, is [constantly] on the brink of insanity much like King Lear. In A Thousand Acres however, madness not only envelops Larry, but it also affects other main characters such as Ginny. Larry’s madness is attributed to his drinking, retirement, and inappropriate relationships with his children. The plot in A Thousand Acres is similar to King Lear, only instead of King Lear dividing up his kingdom among his daughters; Larry is splitting up his farm among his three daughters. Larry’s madness is also first seen at the beginning of A Thousand Acres, just like in King Lear when early on Lear is splitting up the land. Caroline objects to the splitting of the farm because she does not think it is a smart decision for Larry. As the book progresses we see more and more instances where Larry exhibits moments of insanity such as when he purchased the new cabinetry to show off to his neighbors and then let it sit out in the rain. His growing madness begins to craziness disrupt his family’s daily life making the children fearful of what he might do next such as try and leave town by driving his truck while intoxicated. Ginny and Rose have to constantly call him and make sure he is not doing anything that could be dangerous to himself or others. Ginny, one of Larry’s daughter’s also suffers from severe madness. Her illness is blamed on her father’s sexual abuse, her jealousy of her siblings, and her family problems. Rose, one of Larry’s other daughter’s, was also sexually abused by her father when she was younger which causes problems for her later in life by not to the same extent as Ginny. There is no doubt that Ginny was affected by her father’s abuse more so than Rose, and this is seen in the way she acts around her father and the way she treats him. Rose is not as affected as Ginny because she has had more time than Ginny to figure out how to cope with the mental distress caused by their father’s abuse because Ginny is much younger and consequently too young to remember much of it, but after Rose reminded her about the sexual abuse, Ginny was never the same around Larry. The development of Ginny’s insanity throughout the story climaxes when she tries to poison her own sister. Ginny does this so she can take custody of Rose’s children because she is convinced that she can be a better mother than Rose. From these examples one can see that Madness and insanity is a common theme throughout both King Lear and A Thousand Acres that drastically changes the plots and relationships between the characters.

The major differences between how the theme of madness is presented throughout King Lear and A Thousand Acres is the characteristics of madness that the characters display; how the characters manifest their growing insanity. In King Lear, Lear’s insanity was eccentric but harmless, his madness the product of naïveté. Conversely, the madness of Ginny's father, Larry, is much darker and more evil; it is best described as: malicious, underhanded, fickle, and--worst of all--incomprehensible. By portraying madness and insanity in different ways the reader is presented with two stories that are similar yet at the same time different. Similar in that they share a common theme, but different in that in one story the common theme, madness, doesn’t affect the play in a very negative way and in the other story madness significantly impacts the characters’ actions and views throughout the play.
King Lear and A Thousand Acres both use madness as a theme, but they portray it in different ways, which brings about different reactions and causes different feelings in the reader of each story. In King Lear because the theme of madness is portrayed in an almost comical way, it does not affect the story as much as it does in A Thousand Acres where madness is portrayed in much more serious and dangerous ways.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

The Madness of King Lear

...The Madness of King Lear Madness is a key theme throughout King Lear and has, therefore, been the subject of much debate by scholars and critics throughout the centuries. Samantha MarkhamSamantha Markham Samantha Markham is a professional freelance writer with a particular passion for literary and theatrical subjects. Ludwig Devrient as King Lear (1769)Written between 1603 and 1606, King Learis one of Shakespeare’s most celebrated tragedies. The story is based on the legend of King Leir of Britain in which a king divides his kingdom. However, Shakespeare’s interpretation of the legend is much darker than the original and is filled with deceit, death and madness. Much debate surrounding King Lear’s madness concentrates on possible early manifestations of it and its causes. While some assert that King Lear displays early signs of insanity from the commencement of the play, others believe that it is his anger and lust for revenge that drive him to madness. King Lear’s Madness in the First Scene The opening scene of King Lear is a fascinating exploration of flattery, self-love and the relationship between father and daughters. It seems absurd that a king would divide his kingdom according to professions of love, but it is worth considering that a long reigning king is accustomed to exercising irresponsible power. However, the problem with chalking the opening scene up to an old king’s desire to be flattered is that the kingdom has already been divided. Gloucester tells...

Words: 704 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

King Lear Madness Essay

...the source of mental illness of which Lear is no exception. Lear’s madness starts to be recognized when he and Cordelia are captured together. His madness continues to persist as he envisions a nursery in prison, preferring Cordelia’s existence solely for him. It’s after the death of Cordelia that the fantasy of maternal care ultimately fades away. He is exposed speaking his fears that he is sliding into madness, “O, let me not be mad, not mad, sweet heaven! Keep me in temper; I would not be mad…” (1.5.45-46). Even if it’s very difficult to determine situations where Lear becomes mad, his abnormal behaviors, unreserved exhibition thoughts, and the extreme irritability are just a few factors...

Words: 386 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Madness

...and to have "a disordered mind." Throughout King Lear, there are several different characters who one would question if they are in an orderly state of mind. The Earl of Kent, Edgar, the Fool, and King Lear all portray varying degrees of madness. Some have alternative motives behind their madness while others are simply losing touch with reality around them. The Earl of Kent is a close advisor to King Lear. Lear decides to split up his kingdom between his two daughters, Regan and Goneril, and to banish his youngest daughter, Cordelia, from the kingdom. Kent strongly advises Lear to keep reign over his own kingdom and insists that Cordelia should not be renounced. With these displeasing remarks to Lear, Kent is banished from the kingdom as well. Instead of leaving the kingdom, Kent returns under a disguise to continue to watch over Lear. While trying to gain a place in the king's company, Kent plays the role of a somewhat senile old man who has extreme loyalty to his king. Take, for instance, Kent physically and verbally attacking the servant, Oswald, for no more reason than to gain a laugh from the king and reinforce his loyalty to the king. These acts, while they do have good reason behind them, lead to Kent being put in the stocks. Some will say that to risk being caught while banished from the kingdom is mad. It is an even madder deed to take company with the one who has banished you in the first place. Kent's instance of madness is for greater good. He is there to help look...

Words: 1649 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

King Lear

...IV Ms. Gill 12/14/12 Madness and Blindness in King Lear King Lear by Shakespeare is a play that has many motifs and ideals that are supported by its characters. One motif that is introduced in the very beginning is the relationship between blindness and madness. Although the development of this relationship can be seen within characters such as Glouchester the Earl, and Goneril and Regan, the king’s daughters, it is best illustrated by the king himself. The relationship between blindness and madness illustrated in King Lear teaches that blindness will lead to madness, and madness will lead to enlightenment. No character in King Lear experiences the effects of this relationship like the main character himself, King Lear. In the very beginning he proposes a question to his daughters that he has no way of knowing the true answer of; in essence he asks his three daughters how much they love him to see who loves him the most. Two of his daughters, Goneril and Regan feed him lies, and basically tell him that they love him more than life itself. King Lear’s third daughter, Cordelia answers truthfully; she tells him that she loves him for giving her life, and as much as a daughter should love her father. Because of the King’s blindness, he is outraged by this response. He fails to see that Goneril and Regan were lying to get ahead while poor Cordelia, who he then banishes, is the one who truly loves him. The king then divides his land between Goneril and...

Words: 517 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

King Lear

...The True Nature of Lear’s Madness Out of all of Shakespeare’s works, King Lear is by far his greatest tragedy. Tragedy, not in the sorts of horrific blood shed, but in terms of the hostile nature of humankind, that was thoroughly explored within the play. The brilliance of the play does not only lie in its brilliant storyline, it ultimately lies in the numerous universal, yet controversial themes. Themes of familial obligation, metaphorical blindness, political disarray, cruelty, betrayal, insanity and madness, these are only a few of the many conveyed. The critical summation of King Lear is as such: King Lear, ruler of Britain, decides to abdicate his throne and leave Britain in the charge of his three daughters. However, due to his weakness to flattery he bestows the entire kingdom to his daughters, Goneril and Regan. Unlike her malevolent sisters, Cordelia is banished by Lear. Ultimately, as a result of the committed acts, Lear sets not only himself, but also his entire country into civil strife. The natural order originally established by Lear falls apart and disorder engulfs the realm. Lear’s, ‘fall from grace’ in addition to the abuse he attains from his offspring causes him to go temporarily insane. However, insanity leads Lear to self-realization, completely stripped from his royal pretensions. Such a realization causes Lear to overlook his values and finally learn of humility. One is able to state that before the climax took place Lear, in fact was ‘mad’, this...

Words: 1117 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Disowning Cordelear

...G.W. Knight takes a completely different stance on King Lear, referring to the play as a “comedy of the grotesque.” Knight begins Chapter VIII of The Wheel of Fire by describing Shakespeare’s purpose in writing King Lear as a means to blend realism with imagination (160-161). Knight goes on to analyze several elements of the play and explains what makes them comical. Knight starts with King Lear, explaining how asking for love is silly yet part of human nature. In addition, while King Lear’s act of disowning Cordelia is childish, it is also representative of how he was unable to understand his children. These scenes help explain the play’s theme of greatness and immaturity, as King Lear is portrayed with heroic instincts, but no sense...

Words: 627 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

King Lear

...King Lear Themes Table Themes Act 1 Act 2 Act 3 Act 4 Act 5 Critics Overview Shakespeare's dark tragedy, King Lear begins with the fictional King of England, King Lear, handing over his kingdom to daughters Regan and Goneril whom he believes truly love him. King Lear intends to stay with each daughter consecutively, accompanied by one hundred loyal knights.! Angry that Cordelia his youngest daughter does not appear to love him as do Goneril and Regan, Lear banishes his youngest daughter Cordelia, and Kent, the servant who attempts to defend her. Cordelia leaves and is taken by the King of France as his Queen...! Edmund, the loved but illegitimate son of the Earl of Gloucester plots to have his elder brother Edgar's reputation ruined. Edmund tricks his father Gloucester into believing that Edgar wanted to kill him...! The disrespectful Goneril conspires to have her guest and father, King Lear, driven out of her house.! Kent, who has now disguised his identity to serve King Lear, earns King Lear's respect by defending his name. Goneril offends King Lear and dismisses fifty of his knights. Lear starts to realize Cordelia was not so disrespecting. Lear decides to leave for Regan where he is sure to be treated properly...! Lear instructs Kent to deliver several letters to Gloucester. The Fool teaches Lear several riddles. We learn of possible conflict between evil sisters Regan and Goneril. Edmund further manipulates...

Words: 5549 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

King Lear

...KING LEAR Act One The play opens at Lear’s court, where we meet the main characters. The opening scene is in itself shocking, as Lear forces his daughters to declare their love for him. The one who loves him the most will receive the largest part of his kingdom, which he intends to divide between the three. Lear himself wishes to hand over the ruling of the kingdom to his daughters, while retaining the ‘Pre-eminence, and all the large effects / That troop with majesty’ (Scene 1, Lines 131-2). Goneril and Regan acquit themselves well at this love test. Cordelia, however, dismayed by her sisters’ ponderous words, refuses to take part in the ‘contest’ and tells Lear that she loves him as her duty instructs her. When Cordelia refuses to speak again, Lear casts her off without a moment’s hesitation. Ken attempts to argue with the King, accusing him of ‘hideous rashness’ (Scene 1, Line 151). When Kent further warns Lear that his elder daughters are false flatterers, Kent too is banished. Lear invests Albany and Cornwall with power, and, after Burgundy refuses to take Cordelia as his wife, now that she is without dowry, France takes her for her virtues alone. Goneril and Regan complain, in private, about Lear’s harsh judgement and unpredictable behaviour and worry that they too may be treated unfairly. Edmund, Gloucester’s bastard son, soliloquises about his own situation, revealing his devious intentions towards his brother. When his father enters, Edmund’s...

Words: 27223 - Pages: 109

Free Essay

A Comparison of Two King Lear Portrayals

...Different portrayals of King Lear and different uses of colours and costumes in Richard Eyer’s representation of King Lear and Trevor Nunn’s King Lear. Martin Sasseville Ms. Sheri McCready Friday, October 3, 2014 ENG4UBd The representation of King Lear that was directed by Richard Eyer focused a lot on the motif of madness and deceit. Trevor Nunn’s representation differs as it focuses on the motif of illness instead. Through the characterization of King Lear and the costumes, Richard Eyer’s representation of King Lear portrays the motifs of insanity and treachery while, through the characterization of King Lear and the costumes, Trevor Nunn’s representation of King Lear portrays the motifs of sickness, passion and hidden disloyalty. The character of King Lear has a massive impact on which motifs are portrayed through the first scene. Both versions had some similarities but they were not as great as the differences. The main similarity is the speech of the Kings. In both versions, King Lear speaks very quickly as he disowns Cordelia. This represents the utter anger of King Lear and how he cannot even put his rage into controlled words. When looking at speech, quick speech is representative of nervousness or rage. Both directors effectively showed Lear’s rage through his quick speech. However, the differences are much greater. In Richard Eyer’s production, King Lear uses his body a lot. He spreads his arms to seem more intimidating and he climbs up onto the meeting table to show...

Words: 801 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

King Lear Theams

...Themes Themes are the fundamental and often universal ideas explored in a literary work. Justice King Lear is a brutal play, filled with human cruelty and awful, seemingly meaningless disasters. The play’s succession of terrible events raises an obvious question for the characters—namely, whether there is any possibility of justice in the world, or whether the world is fundamentally indifferent or even hostile to humankind. Various characters offer their opinions: “As flies to wanton boys are we to the gods; / They kill us for their sport,” Gloucester muses, realizing it foolish for humankind to assume that the natural world works in parallel with socially or morally convenient notions of justice (4.1.37–38). Edgar, on the other hand, insists that “the gods are just,” believing that individuals get what they deserve (5.3.169). But, in the end, we are left with only a terrifying uncertainty—although the wicked die, the good die along with them, culminating in the awful image of Lear cradling Cordelia’s body in his arms. There is goodness in the world of the play, but there is also madness and death, and it is difficult to tell which triumphs in the end. Authority versus Chaos King Lear is about political authority as much as it is about family dynamics. Lear is not only a father but also a king, and when he gives away his authority to the unworthy and evil Goneril and Regan, he delivers not only himself and his family but all of Britain into chaos and cruelty. As...

Words: 1095 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

How Does King Lear Affect Society

...play, King Lear. They are rapidly thrown into a world of strife. King Lear’s most favored daughter, Cordelia, has been driven away by Lear himself, not to mention Gloucester is betrayed by his bastard son, Edmund. Then Lear is sent out into a storm by his two older and selfish daughters. The list just flows on. But what is it that causes these pathetic consequences? The answer is the impact that society has taken on these individuals. By reading some of Shakespeare’s previous work, it is almost no surprise that there will be tragedy...

Words: 876 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Themes and Motifs in King Lear

...King Lear In Shakespeare’s Tragedy King Lear understanding the themes and motifs is as important as interpreting the dialogue. The emotional effect is highlighted in King Lear with Shakespeare’s use of themes which mirrors the father-child relationships, the different definitions of blindness and the degrees of complete madness. Blindness can normally be defined as the inability of the eye to see, but according to Shakespeare, blindness is not a physical trait, but a mental imperfection some people possess. Because of Lear’s high position in society, he was supposed to be able to distinguish the good from the bad however his lack of sight prevented him from doing it. King Lear’s first act of blindness came at the beginning of the play. First, his two eldest daughters easily deceived him by their lies then he could not see the reality of Cordelia’s true love for him, and as a result, banished her from his kingdom with the following words:“for we have no such daughter, nor shall ever see that face of her again. Therefore be gone without our grace, our love, our benison.” (Act I, Scene I, Ln 265-267) Lear’s blindness also lead him into getting rid of one of his most loyal men. Kent was able to see Cordelia’s true love for her father, and tried to protect her from her blind father’s irrationality. After Kent was banished, he disguised himself and was eventually hired by Lear as a servant. Lear’s inability to determine his servant’s true identity proved once again how blind...

Words: 1222 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Masters of Disguise

...of Lord Angelo. Yet, if any elaboration is to be made on the use of disguise in King Lear, defining the term as it adheres to Shakespearean scholars must first be made. In “Disguise in King Lear: Kent and Edgar,” a scholarly journal by Hugh Maclean, he discusses “Disguise in Elizabethan drama [to be] ‘the substitution, overlaying or metamorphosis of dramatic identity, whereby one character sustains two roles; this may involve deliberate or involuntary masquerade, mistaken or concealed identity, madness or possession’” (Maclean 49). In much of Shakespeare’s work, according to this definition, the development of one’s character can often be seen as close to the margin of disguise. Yet, King Lear exhibits characters whose disguises make significant class distinctions, favorably casting a positive light on the lower class. For some examples of this; King Lear finds himself without a home and caring daughters, he learns to sympathize with a beggar, and unclothes himself in an act to regain his lost innocence. Edgar, the victim of deceit, traverses into the disguise of a beggar with which Lear sympathizes, and dismisses his past identity. He has seen the life of “poor Tom” preserved and deems that the only way he will remain is by disguising himself in that same class (II.vi.20). Even the banished Earl of Kent disguises himself as a peasant in order to reclaim his association with nobility. Thus, King Lear discloses on...

Words: 1938 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Shakespeare’s Critique of Power in King Lear

...ENG 241 12/15/11 -Illustrate Shakespeare’s critique of power in King Lear In King Lear, Shakespeare paints a brutal picture of power, and what people will do to attain it. He does this by the themes of betrayal, madness and blindness, the things that power can often lead to. During the whole flattery scenario, Goneril and Regan commit the ultimate act of betrayal, not only to their father, but to each other. They conspire to snatch the throne from their father, by offering meaningless praise to their father. They then stripped what little authority he had left, and kicked him out, disregarding and disrespecting the one responsible for raising them. Goneril and Regan then turn on each other because of the character Edmund. Goneril goes as far as to poison her sister for Edmund, and then betrayed herself my committing suicide. The theme of madness is also current throughout the play. Goneril and Regan go mad out of their lust for power, in contrast to King Lear, who goes truly goes mad out of grief. Honestly, the entire tragedy is madness, the things that Lear’s daughters did to usurp the throne from their father are insane. They don’t stop at taking over the throne; however, they eye-up the same man, Edmund. This triggers another outburst of madness, that concludes with Goneril poisoning Regan, then killing herself, which is not only the ultimate act of self-betrayal, but also the ultimate act of madness. The final thing and the theme that really summarizes the entire...

Words: 297 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Reduction

...Title: The Tragedy of King Lear Author: William Shakespeare DOP: 1606 Genre: Shakespearean tragedy Writing Style: Play Setting: King Lear's castle in Albion England. Goneril's home. Gloucester's castle. The Cliffs of Dover Plot: Act I. Shakespeare's dark tragedy, King Lear begins with the fictional King of England, King Lear, handing over his kingdom to daughters Regan and Goneril whom he believes truly love him. King Lear intends to stay with each daughter consecutively, accompanied by one hundred loyal knights. Angry that Cordelia his youngest daughter does not appear to love him as do Goneril and Regan, Lear banishes his youngest daughter Cordelia, and Kent, the servant who attempts to defend her. Cordelia leaves and is taken by the King of France as his Queen. Edmund, the loved but illegitimate son of the Earl of Gloucester plots to have his elder brother Edgar's reputation ruined. Edmund tricks his father Gloucester into believing that Edgar wanted to kill him. The disrespectful Goneril conspires to have her guest and father, King Lear, driven out of her house. Kent, who has now disguised his identity to serve King Lear, earns King Lear's respect by defending his name. Goneril offends King Lear and dismisses fifty of his knights. Lear starts to realize Cordelia was not so disrespecting. Lear decides to leave for Regan where he is sure to be treated properly. Lear instructs Kent to deliver several letters to Gloucester. The Fool teaches Lear several riddles. Act II....

Words: 1288 - Pages: 6