Premium Essay

Malcolm X vs. Mlk

In: Other Topics

Submitted By nnat68
Words 329
Pages 2
In his oxford union debate speech, Malcolm X delivered his thoughts on what he thought about the segregation issue at hand and at the same time expressing what he thought of King’s approach somewhat indirectly. Malcolm is aware of the “alternative” approach suggested by King, which results in his justifying of extremism is his speech. He explains why he believes in this method stating that his method of extremism is “intelligently directed extremism” (1:04). Perhaps suggesting that King saw extremism as illogical. Malcolm continues to justify his stance by addressing the circumstances in which laws that had been established were not in any way put to use. With this he implies that it is not reasonable to calmly negotiate for something when in turn all that will be received is hypocrisy. By mentioning these circumstances he provides the backbone to his stance, opposing King’s. Later in the speech, Malcolm introduces his suggestion as to what should be done which is quite obviously directed at King’s approach. Malcolm states “A racialist never understands a peaceful language, he never understands the nonviolent language” (9:00). With this statement he implied to turning to violence or as he put it “speak the language they understand” (8:57). Furthermore, he continues to justify his belief and express his opinion of nonviolence by asserting that he believes it is reasonable to engage in extremism as long as it is for the purpose of justice. He also suggests that anyone who stands for moderation should be considered a sinner. In his conclusion Malcolm restates his disposition that extremism is the better choice in regards to segregation and that whoever chooses nonviolence will surely be waiting longer for justice to come about. Malcolm X surely had taken King’s stance into consideration, however, Malcolm came to the conclusion that nonviolence was not sufficient for his

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Malcolm X

... 02 March 2016 MLK Jr vs Malcolm X Martin Luther King Jr and Malcolm X had many similarities and differences when it came to their roles in the civil rights movement. A huge similarity of the two is they fought hard for their people with getting treated bad. They both wanted to see black people in the best position possible. Risking their lives everyday for the rights they felt they deserve. They were both assassinated because of their leadership role positions they played during this time. Even though they had different beliefs/religions, both their religions played a significant role in their approaches. They both had the greatest impact on the civil rights movement during the 1960s. One of the main reasons why Malcolm X and MLK Jr is different is their approach to the civil rights movement. While MLK Jr wanted to keep the peace and have a non-violent protest, Malcolm X was very opposite. Malcolm X felt that if they wanted to be violent then so should his people. Also, MLK Jr thought more of people being equal and Malcolm X was more for his people being in high power and being controlled by themselves. Also, their religion was a extremely huge difference and had an impact on the way they went about things. MLK Jr grew up in a Christian home where his parents stressed necessary things such as education and religion. Malcolm X converted to Islam after being arrested for drugs and burglary. His outlook on things were far more violent than MLK Jr. MLK Jr believed that...

Words: 599 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Civil Rights Notes

...• NAACP-National Association for the Advancement of Colored People • Plessy Vs. Ferguson-1896-separate but equal • De facto segregation-segregation by custom and tradition • Sweatt vs. Painter-schools had to admit black people • Sit-ins---would sit and refused to move in order to shame managers into integration • Brown vs. Board-Thurgood Marshall-Linda Brown-ended segregation in all public schools • Montgomery Bus Boycott-Rosa Parks-MLK was a leader • MLK-inspired by Gandhi • Southern Christian Leadership Conference-set out to end segregation • Little Rock Nine-Eisenhower hand to order troops in-LBJ helped it pass, but it was weaker • Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee • Freedom Riders- rode buses in the south to protest-were beaten by Whites and KKK • Kennedy used civil rights to win election-promised support • James Meredith-applied to college, but was denied even with a court order • Kennedy assassinated, but Lyndon Johnson carries on his support of African Americans • Civil Rights Act of 1964- Gave power to made segregation illegal, gave power to federal gov. to prevent discrimination • Selma March-many were beaten in front of cameras-shocked nation • Voting Rights Act of 1965-allowed for many African Americans to vote-no more literacy tests • Even though discrimination was ending, it didn’t change people’s attitudes • Watts riot- African American neighborhood-had to send in National Guard • Kerner Commission- studied why the riots were happening ...

Words: 664 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Non-Violence Vs. The Civil Rights Movement

...Non-Violence Vs. Violence The civil rights movement started with an african American women refusing to give up her seat on a bus in montgomery Alabama. Her name was Rosa Parks. “ The only tired I was, was tired of giving in.” - Rosa Parks. This one women standing up for herself led to a bus boycott that would last 13 months. An organization that was the start to change was The montgomery improvement Association (MIA) helped to focus on the rights that african Americans had when it came to as simply as where they sat on a bus. This organization was started before Rosa Parks ever stood up for her right. Founded in 1946. This boycott happened when students start riding different busses integrated (black, white, black) on the bus seats so when other people would get on they would have no choice but to join in with the lack of segregating the busses. All of these events that have happened in the 60’s are examples of and the reason that non-violence protesting is the most effective....

Words: 569 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Scanning Applications

...U.S. Department of Justice Federal Bureau of Investigation 2012 The Strategic Information and Operations Center at FBI Headquarters is the 24/7 command post that monitors FBI operations and law enforcement activities around the globe. An FBI agent examines a potentially contaminated letter during a white powder training exercise. 2012 The FBI Story I A Message from FBI Director Robert S. Mueller, III For the FBI and its partners, 2012 was a year that reminded us once again of the seriousness of the security threats facing our nation. During the year, extremists plotted to attack—unsuccessfully, thanks to the work of our Joint Terrorism Task Forces—the U.S. Capitol, the New York Federal Reserve Bank, and other landmarks on U.S. soil. Tragically, on the 11th anniversary of 9/11, a hateful attack in Benghazi took the lives of the U.S. Ambassador to Libya and three other Americans. In the cyber realm, a rising tide of hackers took electronic aim at global cyber infrastructure, causing untold damages. High-dollar white-collar crimes of all kinds also continued to siphon significant sums from the pocketbooks of consumers. And in Newtown, Connecticut, 20 young children and six adults lost their lives in one of the worst mass shootings in American history, ending a year of violence that saw similar tragedies around the country. Working with its colleagues around the globe, the FBI is committed to taking a leadership role in protecting the nation. As you can see from...

Words: 67387 - Pages: 270