Free Essay

Pace

In:

Submitted By mimis
Words 1418
Pages 6
This section tests your ability to identify relevant statutory provisions and apply them to a specific scenario. Read the provisions from the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 and answer the question set.
Martin and Kirsty have been arrested on suspicion of burglary. They are taken to the local police station, where they are questioned by DC Bright and DC Sharp. Early in the interview, Martin begins to shake and sweat symptoms which DC Bright recognizes as drug withdrawal. He knows that Martin is a heroin addict and that he will need to get a fix within a few hours. To increase the pressure on Martin DC Bright conducts the interview extremely slow and two hours later, Martin is very agitated and distressed. At this point, Dc Bright offers to let Martin go home on bail if he confesses to the burglary and Martin agrees, signing a statement that he broke into the house in question.
In another interview room, Kirsty is being interviewed by DC Sharp. He positions his chair right next to her and screams at her over and over again that she must confess to the burglary. Kirsty is crying and upset but DC Sharp continues to shout at her, banging his fist on the table in front of her. After an hour of this treatment, Kirsty signs a confession.

Assess the possibility of excluding the confession.

Introduction
The Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 ("PACE 1984") is an act designed to protect the public from unfair treatment and to allow Police Officers in England and Wales to pursue the course of justice and to reduce crime. Within the act there are rules to which all police officers must conform and a guide for the public to protect against unfairly obtained evidence. In this essay are two suspects who have against them a signed confession. This essay will assess the relevant sections of the act and assess the possibility of the evidence being excluded.
The question focuses on two suspects who have signed a confession. The following paragraphs will discuss the possibility of the evidence being excluded by examining the relevant sections of PACE 1984.

The two suspects Kirsty and Martin were brought into the station on suspicion of burglary. The PACE 1984 Codes of Practice are relevant in building an argument against the reliability of the confessions. The initial stage of Code C of the Code of Practice 3.1 states that all custody officers bringing a person into custody must ensure that the detainee has the right to let someone know that they have been arrested, and most importantly they must have the right to consult in private with a solicitor.

Martin v DC Bright.
The general rule of admissibility of confession is that it is admissible against the person who made it s76 (1). The exception to that general rule is found in s76 (2) (a) and 76 (2) (b).
Martin was interviewed by DC Bright. There are several circumstances which might be considered to contribute to unfairness under s78 PACE 1984, and which might also contribute to the confession being judged unreliable within the meaning of s76 (2) (b), PACE 1984. It appears from the scenario that DC Bright and Sharp may have failed to do the following:
During the course of the interview the suspect (Martin) began to shake and sweat displaying symptoms which is recognised by DC Bright as possible drug withdrawal. I believe that it is safe to assume that the interviewee (DC Bright) had no medical background and is therefore unable to make a diagnosis of the suspect symptoms, the suspect could have been suffering from something more fatal like a heart attack or that he could have been epileptic. According to the PACE Code of Practice C 3.6 DC Bright should have at this point conducted a risk assessment to ensure that the suspect was not a danger to himself or others around him. Since DC Bright suspected and it was evident from the physical signs such as shaking and sweating that the suspect the suspect was possibly intoxicated with drugs or unwell for other reasons, a health care professional should have been summoned (paragraph 3.10).
The case of R v Walker [1998] Crim LR 211 is relevant here. In this case a prostitute in custody had informed the police that she was a heroin addict and she had obtained medication to alleviate her withdrawal symptoms. She made an incriminating statement which she later did not want to be admitted before the court. She said that she had taken some heroin and was therefore under the influence of the drugs while making her statement. There was evidence given by a medical expert that she also suffered from a psychiatric disorder which would was made worse by drug use and therefore affected the reliability of her confession. The Court of Appeal held that s76 (2) (b) applied because the defendant's mental state had to be taken into account and could render her confession unreliable. It would be useful to have Martin assessed to determine whether he was under the influence of drugs and what effect that could have on the reliability of his confession.
When the suspect go agitated and distressed DC Bright offered to let him go providing he would confess to the crime. He agreed and signed the confession. A confession is a formal acknowledgement of a crime. S 82 (1) of PACE 1984 defines it as “any statement wholly or partly adverse to the person who made it, whether made to someone in authority or not, whether made in words or otherwise.” The general rule of admissibility of confession is that it is admissible against the person who made it s76 (1). The exception to that general rule is found in s76 (2) (a) and 76 (2) (b) which states “if in any proceeding the prosecution purposes to give in evidence a confession made by an accused person, it is represented to the court that it was or may have been obtained by oppression or anything said or done at the time to make the confession unreliable.” The case R v Fulling (1987) 85 Cr. App. 136 [1987] Q.B 426 provides a list of situation which would make a confession unreliable, the list covers; confession obtained as a result of inducement for instance a promise of bail for a confession, such which occurred between Martin and DC Bright, hostile or aggressive questioning, or failure to comply with the rules set out in the Code of Practice.

DC Sharp v Kirsty
Kirsty was interviewed by DC Sharp. It is essential to note that DC Sharp, like DC Bright did not allow the suspect the option of legal aid. Unlike Martin, Kirsty did not require medical attention.
While interviewing the suspect he exerted his authority by positioning his chair next to Kirsty, all the while pounding his fist on the table and shouting that she must confess. Under s 76 (8) of PACE 1984 oppression includes “torture, inhuman or degrading treatment, and the use of violent threats.” Lord Lane C. J in R v Fulling (1987) 85 Cr. App. 136 [1987] Q.B 426 used the definition from the Concise Oxford Dictionary to broaden what was placed in the act. It was described as “the exercise of authority in a burdensome, harsh, or wrongful manner, unjust or cruel treatment of a subject. It is my opinion that this definition is suited to DC Sharps behaviour because it related directly to the way he treated the suspect. It is important to elaborate that the 76 (2) (a) of PACE outlines that confession obtained as a result of oppression is not admissible in court.

Conclusion
Both officers adopted different methods of obtaining confessions from the suspects. With regard to Kristy’s case, her confession should be excluded because firstly she was not allowed the right to consult with a legal representative, so DC Sharp was in breach of the Code of Practice C and s 76 (2) (b) of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984.
Although Martin’s confession was not obtained by oppressive means, DC Bright was still in breach of the Code of Conduct C and s 76(2) (b) of PACE. Like DC Sharp he failed to provide legal aid, failed to provide health care and induced the suspect into confessing.

Fenwick, H. Fenwick, P. Phillipson, G, 2003, Text, Cases & Material on Public Law and Human Rights, London, Routledge Cavendish

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Pace

...PACE is a managed care plan that provides medical, social, and supportive services to medically fragile seniors over the age of 55 with the goal of enabling them to remain in their homes. The roots of the program were developed in the 1970’s by a public dentist in San Francisco in Chinatown, Dr. William Gee. He and others in the community we looking for ways to care for their elders. They hired a consultant to determine the feasibility of building a community nursing home. It was realized that this was culturally and financially inadvisable. They then developed the idea for an adult day care that expanded to offer comprehensive services. There are currently 24,000 seniors enrolled in PACE nationwide in 29 states. There are five PACE programs here in California located in San Diego, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Sacramento and Oakland and their contact information is listed in the handout. To be eligible for PACE you must: Be over 55 Live in a designated service area Be certified as needing nursing home care Be able to live safely in the community. The vast majority of PACE participants are Medicare and Medicaid/Medi-Cal. Clients with Medicare and Medicaid with no share of cost have no out of pocket expenses. Those with share of cost pay that share directly to the PACE organization and those with Medicare only have a $3900 monthly here in San Diego. The San Diego, the St. Paul’s PACE center is a free standing center near downtown open Monday-Friday, 8-4:30. It includes...

Words: 555 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Pace

...After taking all of the career readiness assignments I was able to learn that I am not quite ready to approach my job related field. I was able to find out that from now till I graduate college I should not only be taking classes for my career, but also trying to activities that might relate to my job, and even trying to talk to other that are in the same study field as me. After seeing my score for self-assessment I was told since I scored so high I am very involved in examining what it is I like to do, my values, personality, and skills. I was also told I need to stay active and involved because this is the most important in career planning. My career exploration had a medium score, which means I am moderately involved in this area. I need to increase my involvement so that away it will help narrow down my option and map out my career goals. My career planning satisfaction also had a medium score suggesting I may be experiencing problems with my career planning. I am not sure if this is true or not, because before taking any of theses test I could tell you what it is I want to do after I graduate college and why I chose that career field. I felt as those there was a lot of questions that didn’t apply to me therefore, I picked the box that said does not relate to me. I also felt as though if there were more questions for me I would have gotten lot better scores on some of these topics. After taking the work interest assessment in self-assessment category I was very...

Words: 594 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Pace- What Is Pace and How Is It Used

...Ryan O’Malley- Law homework. 1. Under which section of PACE is the main power of arrest to be found? The main stop and search powers to which this code applies are set to tackle suspicions individuals without exercising their power of arrest. Officers may stop and search individuals authorised under section 44 of the Terrorism Act 2000. 2. Which 2005 Act of Parliament amended police powers of arrest? The Serious Organized Crime and Police Act 2005 3. 4. When can the police arrest a person? In some cases a person can only be arrested by a police officer with a warrant; in others she/he can be arrested without a warrant and not only by a police officer but by a private citizen. 5. What, according to s.117, can police use in order to carry out an arrest? Under Section 117 Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE), the police are empowered to use ‘reasonable force’ if necessary when exercising the powers conferred to them under that act. 6. What are police entitled to search an arrestee for? The police can stop anyone in a public place and ask you to account for yourself. For example, you could be asked to account for your actions, behavior, presence in an area or possession of anything. When the police stop you and ask you for an explanation, you don't need to provide your personal details. 7. What common law power of arrest has been preserved in s.26 PACE? Breach of the peace. 8. What power of arrest is associated with bail? A person accused...

Words: 481 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Pace Essay

...to be apart of the people who are "behind the scenes", the people that that contribute to bringing certain aspects of entertainment to life through the Business. So its safe to say that I have not only developed a strong interest in music, but also the vast areas of the Music Industry and Entertainment Business. After reviewing the numerous academic opportunities at Pace, I realized that this is the perfect school for me to study the Art and Entertainment business and develop the overall knowledge and skills to be successful in my career. Because my desired career has to do with not only the entertainment business but also the arts, I knew that New York City was the perfect place to study the many aspects of both. I was in search of an urban campus with professional and cultural diversity; also potential resources to help me progress throughout the next four years. Pace University seems to provide a nurturing environment to the students who attend, and as a freshman I am looking for a school that can provide me with the necessary tools I need to be successful in the entertainment and business world. I know that Pace has a lot to offer and I would welcome the honor to attend and advance my knowledge and cultural development, along with the comprehensive courses which will bridge the gap of providing an educational opportunity in my pursuit to a successful career in...

Words: 300 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Public Paces

...Summary. Commentary around the electronic media has raised issues of political action, com-munity formation and changing identities. This paper explores how the notions of 'public space' can inform this debate over electronic media. It examines the metaphorical adoption of urban models to look at electronic sociality and suggests four principle approaches: cities set in or against world flows, suburbanised telecities, communitarian visions and accounts that appeal to a renewed public sphere. The paper examines how these share many assumptions. However, instead of trying to sift these metaphors by contrasting them to a purported real world, the paper examines how they shape an electronic architecture. Spatial metaphors and electronic practices are seen as entangled and shaping each other. The paper suggests that the different metaphors for the city reflect a range of anxieties about and desires for urban life. In this sense, the 'real' city is the indefinable complexity and folding of spaces--lying outside the visualisations offered of cyberspace. Introduction Cyberspace as a whole, and networked virtual environments in particular, allow us to not only theorize about potential architectures informed by the best of current thought, but to actually construct such spaces for human inhabitation in a completely new kind of public realm. This does not imply a lack of constraint, but rather a substitution of one kind of rigour for another. When bricks become pixels, the tectonics...

Words: 615 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

5k Pace Research Paper

...Mile repeats build physical and mental fitness. The length forces you to adopt a race-like mentality. Changing the number of reps or the pace can change the physiological effect. The goal is to build a session that matches your fitness, goals, and recovery. Pete Magill, from Runner’s World, lists three types of mile repeats and the benefits of each one. 5K Paced Repeats Not many runners train mile repeats at a 5K pace or faster. Reps that this pace rev your aerobic system close to full capacity, so it’s counterproductive to train at that level for longer than 5 or 6 minutes. Actually, runners who are slower shout limit reps at a 5K pace to short distances. Because they use slow-twitch, intermediate- and fast-twitch muscle fibers, you’ll increase capillary and mitochondrial density for all of them. Workouts at this pace should include three to four reps, with recovery intervals that match the time of the rep, or half the duration for fitter runners....

Words: 425 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Pikus Pace Informative Speech

...I believe Noelle Pikus Pace is one of the greatest athletes of all time along with being one of the greatest skeleton sliders in the world. Although an athlete is not the only thing that is so astonishing about her. She is a 2 time olympian, 2014 Olympic silver medalist, 26 time world cup medalist, 2 time world champion, mother, Author ,Motivational speaker, product spokesperson\model, and a business owner. She is inspires many people including me with her quotes and speeches she shares throughout the world. Noelle was born in Provo UT on December 8th 1982, and is currently 35 years old. Noel is the youngest of 8 children. She went to Mountain View High School and played many sports including soccer, basketball, softball, track and field, bobsled and skeleton. Pace graduated from high school in 2001. She later attended Utah Valley University and later that year married Janson Pace. She continued sports through college she broke the school’s high jump record, was the NJCAA National Discus Champion, and 1st team All-American. She graduated college in 2005 a bachelor's degree in Community Health and Physical Education. Then she later was an assistant coach at UVU for track and field....

Words: 610 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Case Study Pace Technologies

...Group Case Study_Page 176_Pace Technologies The following answers briefly illustrate the culture of Pace Technologies and the reason as to why its culture can be considered to be in a preconventional level of ethical development. Through a detailed analysis of Ken, Cody and Ali’s personality, our group provides what we think is Ali’s best course of action. To conclude, a review of the company’s current development / performance and a Porter’s Five Forces analysis is conducted to better understand Pace Technologies’ competitive environment. For an easier read, we have divided our answers to the case study questions according to topics. Shaping Company Culture and the Preconventional Level of Ethical Development.Ken shapes the culture of Pace Technology based on his own personality which is aggressive, proactive, energetic and competitive. Ken only recruits people who share the same personality traits as him enabling the company to win over competition. Additionally, given Ken’s outstanding performance and track- record, he is seen positively by the Board, who is interested in maximizing profits and gives him the authority and power to make all day-to-day and strategic decisions. Our group considers the culture of Pace Technologies to be at the preconventional level of ethical development in which “individuals are concerned with external rewards and punishments and obey authority to avoid detrimental personal consequences”...

Words: 1416 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Summary: The Case Of Pace Vs. Alabama

...In 1883, the case of Pace vs Alabama involved an African American male, Tony Pace and a European or white woman Mary Cox. They were both residents of Alabama and they were arrested in 1881 because they violated the anti-miscegenation laws. They were both charged and sentenced to two years of imprisonment (Wallenstein, P 1998). They had been living together in Alabama at the time. The case went through the Alabama Supreme Court as well as the United States Supreme Court. The court eventually would rule that the law did not violate the fourteenth amendment because they were punished in the same way. The anti-miscegenation laws would stay intact for another sixty years (Wallenstein, P. 1998). In 1948, the state of California finally overturned...

Words: 333 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Fuel Reforms Gather Pace

...18 JAN 2013 / Sector Update OIL & GAS SECTOR OIL & GAS Fuel reforms gather pace; ONGC best bet Government has provided a roadmap to diesel deregulation by authorizing OMCs (BPCL, HPCL, IOC) to take minor price hikes periodically. This implies diesel under-recoveries could vanish over next 2 years, which would be a huge trigger for Oil PSUs. Cooking fuel under-recoveries may also vanish once direct cash subsidy scheme is rolled out pan-India. Though this would remove all subsidy concerns and re-rate the entire space, we expect roadblocks due to political fallout of the ~20% diesel price hike. We expect 80% reduction in diesel under-recoveries over next two years. We upgrade ONGC, OIL to BUY with ~12% upside from CMP. BPCL (maintain BUY; 10% upside) is our preferred bet among OMCs due to its E&P exposure. Maintain HOLD on IOC and HPCL as they price in the development. PRICE PERFORMANCE 140 Sensex 130 120 BS E Oil & Gas Index 110 100 90 Jan-12 Jul-12 Jan-13 Source: Bloomberg Axis Capital Does government have the will to go ahead with 20% diesel hike over next two years? Diesel deregulation would imply ~20% hike in prices over a two-year period. Government may find it challenging to implement this given 14 state elections and general elections are due over next 18 months. Any roll-back or delay in implementation will indicate government lacks grit. Upstream stocks to benefit; ONGC top pick Upstream stocks (ONGC, OIL) would be direct beneficiaries...

Words: 2386 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Setting the Pace: Getting Started in Ngo Corporate Governance

...Setting the pace and getting started in NGO Corporate governance. An Assessment of corporate governance for Non Governmental Organizations in Zimbabwe By Lasford Flackson lasyflackson@gmail.com .Tel:+263773931949 Table of contents Introduction Chapter one An overview of corporate governance The evolution of governance Development of corporate governance Approaches to corporate governance Chapter two Adaptation and adoption of corporate governance Ngo sector in Zimbabwe Requirements for NGO operation in Zimbabwe Guiding principles for good corporate governance Chapter three Conclusion and Recommendations 2 Introduction The collective problem of business today is increasingly attributed to the failure of corporate governance. This means that far too many boards are failing to execute their duties responsibly, both collectively and individually. Despite increasing awareness, there is a general lack of understanding of the principles of effective corporate governance in most quarters. The study sought to assess corporate governance issues and challenges for non governmental organisations. The study takes a point of departure in explaining how non governmental organisations can adapt and adopt effective corporate governance practices viz- a- viz, how NGOs can adapt and adopt to corporate governance. Several non governmental organisations do not observe good corporate governance and this to the collapse of many. There are no set rules ...

Words: 10898 - Pages: 44

Free Essay

How Does the Use of Management Approaches Keep Pace with the Changing Trends of Worlds?

...How does the use of management approaches keep pace with the changing trends of worlds? Union is strength. This common saying has existed between people for a long period of time. With the start of cooperation between different people, they tend to start forming groups when facing a problem that requires much effort. David Premack (2010) suggests that there are fundamental differences between humans and animals. Humans alone can reinterpret the higher order relations between these relations. This gradually leads to differences on mind set in different unique individuals. Different people do not always share the same thoughts as compared to one another. Conflicts or misunderstanding usually come up, making team productivity unfavorable. As a result, management approaches are always essential to maintain the unity of the whole team. Management approaches are important in remaining team productivity. However, these approaches were not exactly the same in the past. The approaches changed from time to time in order to suit the exact needs of that certain period of time. I find out that it will be interesting to discuss and search more deeply about the ways and reasons on the changes of management approaches. In this essay, I will be identifying different main management approaches, then applying and analyzing the reason why it was used at that time. The first type of management approaches comes from the ancient management. Its history can be followed back to at least...

Words: 977 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

How Far Was the Slow Pace of Change for Black Americans Due to the Power of the States from 1945-1962?

...Martin Luther King was born on 15 January 1929 in Atlanta, Georgia (US). Originally named Michael, he was later renamed Martin, like his father, a Baptist minister. His mother, Alberta Williams King, was a schoolteacher. He entered Morehouse College in 1944 and forged a lifelong friendship with his teacher, Benjamin Mays. Together with his father's influence, it was partly his respect for Mays which led him to the Church. He was ordained in his last semester. He graduated from Morehouse in 1948 and undertook postgraduate study first at Crozer Theological Seminary in Pennsylvania and then, in 1951, at Boston University's School of Theology. Once there he completed his dissertation which, it was later revealed, had been partially plagiarised, and won his doctorate in 1955. It was in Boston that he met his wife Coretta Scott, who he married in 1953. In 1954, he became pastor of Dexter Avenue Baptist Church in Montgomery, Alabama, where Rosa Parks was famously arrested for refusing to give up her seat to a white man on a bus. National awareness After Parks' arrest, King came to national prominence in the US. He was a leading figure in organising the boycott by African Americans of buses in Montgomery. "It was thrust upon him in many respects," says John A. Kirk, Chair of History at the University of Arkansas. "In 1955-56 he came to prominence. He didn't seek out leadership. They needed a leader...King was a neutral choice. He was young and new to town and wasn't a threat." ...

Words: 363 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Discuss How the Rules Governing Stop and Search as Set Out in Pace Protects the Rights of the Individual Whilst Also Allowing the Police to Investigate Crime.

...Discuss how the rules governing stop and search as set out in PACE protects the rights of the individual whilst also allowing the police to investigate crime. The police and criminal evidence act was introduced in 1948 to carefully balance the rights of the individual against the powers of the police.  There are a number of codes in this act which inform the police clearly up to what extent their power allows them to investigate a potential crime against an individual. For a police officer to carry out a stop and search, they must have reasonable grounds for suspecting that the individual or their vehicle is in possession of a stolen or prohibited item. A police officers can not raise these suspicions based on the persons age, race, ethnic background, nationality, faith or previous convictions. Also when carrying out a stop and search the police officer must record the incident in a written report as soon as possible. However when a police officer is actually searching an individual there are a number of concerns, for instance if the individual does not cooperate this could lead to the police officer misusing their power and could also go against the persons rights. However the police have very little to base their suspicion on, as some of the things they have to look out for are possibilities such as a person carrying an illegal item e.g drugs or a weapon or if they’ve been involved in a local crime such as burglary.In this situation it is hard for a police officer to...

Words: 767 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Using These Four Passages and Your Own Knowledge, Assess the View That Russians Opposed Peter the Great Mainly Because the Pace of Change Was Too Rapid.

...Russians opposed Peter the Great mainly because the pace of change was too rapid. Pares, in an attempt to support the argument, says ‘it was not so much what Peter did that gave shock to the Russian consciousness but in which he did it and the pace it was done’ He expresses the idea that if change to modernise Russia was introduced at a slower rate people would be less likely to oppose. There is evidence that gives credit to Pares argument is that Peter tried to introduce a wooden plough with iron edging, but the peasants wanted to carry on the slash and burn method that they had been using for generations. Pares enhances his own interpretation because he writes ‘by racing against the wind as Klyuchevsky puts it, Peter increased the velocity of the wind against him.’ This enhances his argument because it proves that the faster he moved with the change the more opposition he would face. (Evidence) In passage B, Lisk contradicts Pares because she believes that it does not matter how fast the change came the country would always oppose it. She writes ‘Peter ordered that no serf could leave his masters estate without written permission’ the peasants would always oppose this because they would not like being treated as the property of their master.(evidence) Lisk supports her earlier statement that ‘the situation of the peasants in Russia grew worse and the gulf between the classes even wider’ the noblemen would not oppose this because they would become even more powerful and wealthy...

Words: 878 - Pages: 4