Free Essay

Poli3001

In:

Submitted By mcroy
Words 432
Pages 2
India and China are two countries that have historically experienced opposing political regimes. Both countries have extremely storied histories (political or not), and are two of the most prominent emerging countries out of the BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa) economies. To determine which environment is the best in which to do business in, one must look at the historical contexts of both countries, both economically and politically. With that in mind, this essay will attempt to determine the advantages of doing business in an Indian political environment as opposed to a Chinese one.
On the one hand, China has been (historically speaking) a quite stable country, being governed by a centrally run state. Being a single party state, China has been controlled by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) since 1927, when the 5th National Congress was held. India, on the other hand, has almost the exact opposite history. As of 1950 (when India became an independent sovereign nation, separated from the British Commonwealth), India is a democratic republic, with the President of India the elected head of state and the Prime Minister the elected head of government (CIA, 2015).
In terms of the environment in which both countries’ businesses operate in, much like their political history, they are radically different. The rules and regulations that govern China are described by many as restrictive. Regulation in China is central, resulting in particular industries not being able to foreign investors. This is due to the Chinese Communist Party wishing to restrict the level of external influences on its own population. This level of regulation also extends to restricting the level of communication between the Chinese and the outside world. The Chinese Internet filter (known colloquially as the Great Firewall of China, known internally as the Golden Shield Project) is a prime example of this. The Chinese Internet filter serves to “block potentially unfavourable incoming data from foreign countries”, and blocks websites such as Google and Facebook, as well as websites of potential use from a business perspective such as the NASDAQ website and LinkedIn (Norris, 2010). An estimated ninety one per cent of corporations listed on the Chinese stock exchange are partially or entirely state owned (Desai, 2013) and as such receive preferential treatment. As a result, any sort of level base of competition between a hypothetical firm (say, a manufacturing firm an outsider would attempt to bring into the market) and these state (i.e. government) owned firms is impossible. Regulations such as these are inherently damaging from the perspective of an individual attempting to do business in the country.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Compare the Political Regime of India and China - Poli3001

...Briefly compare the political regime type in China and India. Which of the two would you prefer to do business in and why? The political regime of a country attempts to protect the interests of its citizens through social, environmental and economic goals. These objectives often have significant, yet varying impacts on organisations operating within the nation; depending upon the nature of their business and the political ideologies of the country in question. As a result, international companies looking to expand their operations overseas must carefully consider the nature of the political regime and the resultant factors which will impact their ability to conduct business and generate profits. The Peoples Republic of China and India are two vast nations which over the past several decades have undergone considerable development and economic growth and therefore represent substantial opportunity for international businesses to expand or outsource their operations. Despite their geographic proximity, China and India have very different political philosophies and regimes which have resulted in variations in their regulatory framework, taxation policies, stock exchanges, intellectual property rights and the consequential foreign direct investment and growth. The Peoples Republic of China operates through a single party political system led by the Communist Party of China. Traditionally, Marxist ideologies dominated the nation’s economic regulation, however reform in 1978...

Words: 1943 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Short Essay China

...POLI3001 Short Essay (20%) - 2015 - Due Friday 21 August 5pm (Turnitin) Student: Criteria/ Standards Research/ Literature Knowledge/ Understanding Argument/ Analysis Submitted: Poor 85% Student demonstrates inadequate research skills; literature used is irrelevant or insufficient; did not use a minimum of 8 scholarly sources. Poor knowledge and understanding of the essay topic; student has not read sufficient and/or appropriate material to engage with key concepts and issues. Student demonstrates adequate research skills; some literature used is irrelevant but includes 8 scholarly references. Student demonstrates good research skills; good choice of literature; 8 relevant scholarly references. Student demonstrates very good research skills; very good choice of literature; 8 or more scholarly references. Student demonstrates outstanding research skills; excellent choice of literature; 8 or more scholarly references. Satisfactory knowledge and understanding of the essay topic; evidence of sufficient reading on the topic but limited critical engagement with key concepts and issues. Good knowledge and understanding of the essay topic; evidence of sufficient reading and emerging critical engagement with key concepts and issues. Excellent knowledge and understanding of the essay topic; evidence of substantial reading and sophisticated critical engagement with key concepts and issues. Unsatisfactory...

Words: 665 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Reference

...POLI3001 Short Essay: A Guide to Sources It is expected that you will use a minimum of eight (8) scholarly references (books and/or journal articles) as well as other sources. The following represent a sample of scholarly journals (in no particular order) in which to find articles to write your essay: * Applied Econometrics and International Development * International Economic Review * Industrial and Labor Relations Review * Journal of International Economics * World Competition * Business Law Review * Journal of World Trade * Journal of Economic Growth * Journal of Chinese Economic and Foreign Trade Studies * Business and Politics * Journal of Asia-Pacific Business * International Journal of Economics and Business Research * Global Business and Economics Review * Journal of Global Business Issues The following sources may also be useful (but note that these are not regarded as scholarly references so cannot be counted in your minimum): * The Economist - www.economist.com/ * The Wall Street Journal (Asia Edition) - asia.wsj.com/home-page * The International Economy - www.international-economy.com/ * MIT Sloan Management Review - sloanreview.mit.edu/about/ * China Brief - www.jamestown.org/chinabrief/ * China Development Brief - www.chinadevelopmentbrief.com/ * Business Standard [on India] - www.business-standard.com ...

Words: 831 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Briefly Compare the Political Regime Type in China and India. Which of the Two Would You Prefer to Do Business in and Why?

...POLI3001 Assignment No. 2 Briefly compare the political regime type in China and India. Which of the two would you prefer to do business in and why? India and China are two republics that have experienced very opposing political regimes throughout history. China has been fundamentally stable country with a lack of a distinct authority figure (Desai, 2003). Being a single party state China has been controlled by the Chinese Communist Party since the 5th National Congress held in 1927 (Wang, 2013). Correspondingly India, have always been a federal parliamentary democratic republic where the President of India elected is head of state and the Prime Minister elected is the head of government (U.S. Central Intelligence Agency, 2013). This essay will reflect on the political views of both China and India, and attempt to determine why it is more advantageous to do business in India. Government regulation is the process of dissemination, monitoring and enforcement of policy established by appropriate legislation. In, China regulation is central as particular industries are not accessible to foreign investors as the Communist Party aims to restrict external influences on its own population (Desai, 2003). An estimated 90 percent of companies listed on the Chinese exchanges are either partly or fully state-owned (Desai). Retaining a level competition base is significantly reduced, as the chances of competing against a government owned company is more than likely. A good example...

Words: 1484 - Pages: 6