Premium Essay

Reframing Leadership

In:

Submitted By metroman88
Words 658
Pages 3
In the article by Lee G. Boman and Terrence E. Deal, leadership is reframed by deliberately viewing a situation from multiple perspectives, which will in turn offer a way to get past the simplified views of leadership. According to the authors, there are perspectives or what they labeled as frames that are distinctive images for the leadership process. Every frame is examined and shown that they can be compelling and constructive. Four frames were identified by the authors. The first, structural leadership evokes images of tyrants and bureaucrats who encourage rules throughout the structure of the organization. The human resource leadership is the second frame that is discussed, which briefly notes that these types of leaders advocate openness, participation and empowerment. The third frame, political is viewed by the authors. Through this area, it points out that these leaders plunge into the political arena in order to move their organization wherever it needs to go. The fourth and final frame that is discussed in this article is symbolism. In the symbolic leadership frame, it views the organization as twofold, a theater and a temple. The theater is a stage for the actors to set out and play their roles, whereas the temple is an organization that consists of a community of different beliefs. The article notes that leadership is accepted as a cure of the sickness that ails organizations but is often misunderstood. The article urges the reader to redesign leadership to move forward and continue to restructure the organization. The relevance within the criminal justice system is very similar to the situations that are often confronted in the field. There is not just one frame that can be used and implemented at every moment for the different situations that confronted by leaders within their respective offices. Instead, there must be multiple examples that are

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Putting It All Together a Look at Pfizer Pharmaceutical Company

...facets of life. It is important to employ a solid employee workforce within an organization, this can either make or break an organization. “In 2012 Pfizer was ranked #40 among Fortune 500 with 2011 revenue totaling almost 68 million dollars, and a profit margin of over 10 million dollars”(CNN Money, 2013). The purpose of this paper is to break apart Pfizer into four different organizational perspectives, analyze them, and then put them back together again. Or as with the title of the textbook (Reframing Organizations: Artistry, Choice, and Leadership. Vol. 4) suggests to reframe organizations to a particular frame or frames. The frames that I will be using to analyze Pfizer Pharmaceuticals will be the Structural Frame, the Symbolic Frame, the Human Resources Frame, as well the Political Frame. To begin, I will describe the Pfizer organization using Bolman & Deal’s Structural Frame perspective. The structural components that I will discuss will be the Division of Labor, the Leadership Structure, and Roles and Responsibilities of the organization. Pfizer’s headquarters are located in New York, with numerous companies located throughout the United States and worldwide. At Pfizer geography plays a major role because by having numerous locations available. This would make the supplying of products easier, quicker and more efficient thus keeping up with demand. “This labor practice follows one of the six structural assumption...

Words: 5349 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Twelve Angry Men

...MBUS 957 Executive Leadership Julian Barling 12 Angry Men – Writing Assignment September 21, 2012, 11:59pm Calgary A – Team Redemption Order of files: Filename | Pages | Comments and/or Instructions | 12 Angry Men-Writing | 5 | | Assignment | | | | | | | | | | | | Additional Comments: Executive Leadership MBUS 957 Twelve Angry Men 12 Angry Men (1957) An examination of transformational leadership as portrayed by Henry Fonda “12 Angry Men” is a movie that captures various facets of leadership displayed by people with different social backgrounds and individual values. The movie demonstrates how an “Unstructured Group”, prominently displaying Laissez-faire transactional leadership, transforms into a “High Performing Team”. Davis (Juror #8), the character played by Henry Fonda, is instrumental in influencing this transformation. Davis demonstrates how one man can motivate and inspire a group, align them towards exploring the possibility that other explanations of the events exist and allow them to feel confident in performing the job they are entrusted with. A transformational leader is often charismatic, inspirational, and has the courage to challenge the status quo. Davis displays many transformational leadership qualities ultimately leading the rest of the jury to question their original assumptions, to consider that another life is at stake. In this highly emotional situation, Davis uses his ability to influence the...

Words: 1631 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Marketing

...Change Agent Abilities Required to Help Create a Sustainable Future © ACPA – College Student Educators International (http://www.myacpa.org/) in collaboration with the U.S. Partnership for Education for Sustainable Development (www.uspartnership.org ) May be reproduced for educational purposes with credit given In order to be a successful sustainability change agent, an individual must have the following: 1. Knowledge of the environmental, economic, and social issues related to sustainability (understanding); 2. A value system and self-concept to support and under gird the actions of a change agent (motivation); and 3. Change agent abilities (skills). Change Agent Abilities: The following is a listing of change agent abilities compiled from numerous sources. For ease of use, these sources have all been acknowledged at the end of this document. Change agents are: • Resilient • Optimistic • Tenacious • Committed • Passionate • Patient • Emotionally intelligent • Assertive • Persuasive • Empathetic • Authentic • Ethical • Self-Aware • Competent • Curious They can: • Communicate ideas clearly, concisely, and precisely both orally and in writing • Listen to others and incorporate their ideas and perspectives • Accommodate individual differences (cultural, socioeconomic, global, etc.) in your decisions and actions and be able to negotiate across these differences...

Words: 885 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Harsha Attaluri

...COLLEGE OF EDUCATION Seattle University 900 Broadway Seattle, Washington 98122-4340 Department of Educational Leadership SCHOOL OF EDUCATION ORGANIZING THEME: Preparing Ethical and Reflective Professionals for Quality Service in Diverse Communities DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATIONAL LEADERSHIP MISSION STATEMENT: Preparing Effective Leaders for an Interdependent World COURSE INFORMATION Course Prefix and Number(s): EDLR 631, 632, 633 - 9 Credit Hours Meeting Place: Loyola Hall, Room 202/203 Meeting Date(s) and Time(s): Saturday, September 27, 2008. 8:30 - 4:30 (Loyola 301/302) Saturday, October 18, 2008. 8:30 - 4:30 Saturday, November 15, 2008. 8:30 - 4:30 Saturday, December 6, 2008. 8:30 - 4:30 (Loyola 301/302) Sunday, December 7, 2008. 8:30 – 4:30 Saturday, January 10, 2009. 8:30 - 4:30 Sunday, January 11, 2009. 8:30 - 4:30 Saturday, February 7, 2009. 8:30 - 4:30 Saturday, March 21, 2009. 8:30 - 4:30 Saturday, April 18, 2009. 8:30 - 4:30 Sunday, April 29, 2009. 8:30 - 4:30 Saturday, May 16, 2009. 8:30 - 4:30 Retreat Sunday, May 17, 2009. Retreat. Location to be determined. Leadership Conference: Location and date to be determined. Attendance required Course Instructor: Roberto A. Peña, Ph.D. Associate Professor Office: Loyola Hall, Room 407 Contact Information: Office Telephone: Home Telephone: Fax Machine: E-mail Address: (206) 296-6496 (206) 780-6970 (206) 296-2053 penar@seattleu.edu Program Administrative Assistant: Ms. Eunice MacGill Seattle University School of Education...

Words: 4169 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Leadership Transition

...IN MANAGEMENT SETTING HOW SHOULD A MANAGER HELP AN EMPLOYEE MOVE FROM A PEER TO A LEADER? WHAT METHODS SHOULD HE USE TO ENSURE A SMOOTH TRANSITION 1. HOW SHOULD A MANAGER HELP AN EMPLOYEE MOVE FROM A PEER TO A LEADER Transition of leadership is very challenging and costly for the company. Making leaders among the workmates is relatively easy as compared to hiring new managers from elsewhere. A manager can help an employee to grow into a leader and ensure smooth transition of leadership in several ways. First, the manager should give the employee a mentor for a period of time. The mentor can be from outside the company or the department or he/she can act as the mentor. Secondly, the manager through Human Resource (HR) can invest in either internal or external training on leadership skills to prepare the employee for the task. Third, the manager can guide them on how to be an example to others. Leading as an example is one of most important leadership skills. The manager should teach them time management, mastering time management is a key to developing team-leadership skills. This make sure that they are organized and can maximize on their time. Furthermore, the manager should reward the employees. People tend to work harder when they know their efforts are being recognized and appreciated. They should therefore be constantly motivated. New job levels come with new challenges, and therefore the manager should check in often to help them with new issues they'll deal...

Words: 445 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Structural Framework in Schools

...ABSTRACT The purpose of this paper is to discuss the structural frame and how it applied to my former position with Leon County Schools. The four frames presented by Bolmen and Deal’s text “Reframing Organizations: Artistry, Choice and Leadership” lays the groundwork for intertwining theory with practice. The four frames are the structural frame, human resource frame, political frame and symbolic frame. With the structural frame as the groundwork a leader can decide what type of communication, decision making and leadership styles are a best fit for the leader and organization. Optimal leaders must master each of the four frames and hone their diagnostic skills, so that they can quickly move from one frame to the other, as the situation requires. This ability to frame and reframe is a key distinction between successful and unsuccessful leaders (Bolman & Deal, 2008). In 2009, I was the new District Director of Special Projects for Leon County Schools. The school district had three elementary schools who participated in what was called the Consolidated Application, a school plan that included goals, objectives, action steps for every grade level, resources needed, and a budget. Each school was required to submit their own unique plan each year. There were numerous state and federal laws that had to be met in the application document. I began with the school district in the 5th week of school and found that the Consolidated Application/School Plans had not yet been submitted...

Words: 1444 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Journal

...Leadership development refers to any activity that boosts the excellence of leadership within an individual. This activity has focused on developing the abilities and attitudes of individuals. Dissimilar personal traits and characteristics can help or impede a person's leadership effectiveness and require courteous for developing leadership competencies. Some assumed that a leader could act authentically through responsibility, reactions to uncertainty, and creativity. Others believed that authentic leadership is essentially more about how the leaders define their own role within an individual. In my point of view, a leader can study from others’ experiences and being genuine and authentic, but not by imitation of someone else. A leader constantly can be describe through their real life story and reframing their life stories to recognize who they were at their fundamental. In doing so, they discovered the purpose of their leadership and absorbed that being authentic made them more effective. Authentic leaders are defined as people of highest integrity, loyal to enduring organizations. Leaders who have a deep sense of purpose and are true to there core values, ability to motivate. Things that authentic leaders do on a regular basis are; 1. They voice their truth. They being clear, being truthful and being authentic and would never reveal themselves by using words that are not aligned with who they are. 2. They lead from the heart. They are not scared to show...

Words: 716 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Pico School Analysis

...Pico School Analysis What is the foundation of effective leadership? Reshaping the Path to School Leadership offers insight into the elements of school leadership by offering a case study through the political, human resource, symbolic, and structural frames. Analyzing this school and its framework offers the reader an opportunity to grow in leadership through the journey at Pico School. As the new principal and teacher begin to understand the structure of the school, they come to understand the norms in each frame of leadership. In the political frame the new principal, Jamie, becomes disappointed when his speech is not well received regarding the new school year. He had inadvertently offended veteran teachers with his personal vision statement before understanding the school’s status quo, which had been an environment of complacency. The human resources frame was an environment of severe concern with the new principal. He noticed signs of hostility varying from ethnic slurs to anonymous letters attacking him. As the year progressed, this frame was in a continuous state of flux. The system of structure continued to change throughout the school year, particularly the discipline program and the NCLB policies. As expectations changed, teachers were openly resistant and felt threatened. This norm needed to be addressed in order to begin the process of moving on from the constant presence of his reputation. The symbolic frame is present in the form of the former principal...

Words: 1198 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Iggy’s Bread of the World Case Study Symbolic Assessment

...Iggy’s Bread of the World Case Study Symbolic Assessment Company Human Symbolic Frame Assessment All organizations have some degree of symbolic life with Bolman and Deal referring to this as an organization’s cultural tapestry and state (Bolman and Deal, 2013). Furthermore the symbolic frame, drawing on social and cultural anthropology, treats organizations as temples, theaters, or carnivals (Bolman and Deal, 2013). It abandons assumptions of rationality more prominent in other frames. It sees organizations as cultures, propelled more by rituals, ceremonies, stories, heroes, and myths than by rules, policies, and managerial authority (Bolman and Deal, 2013). Organizations can be viewed as theaters where actors or employees play their roles in the organizational drama while audiences or customers form impressions from what is seen onstage or in business practices (Bolman and Deal, 2013). However, problems arise when actors or employees blow their parts, when symbols lose their meaning, or when ceremonies and rituals lose their effectiveness (Bolman and Deal, 2013.) Iggy and Ludmilla’s bakery established itself as a symbolic organization right away (Grendon and McGinn, 2001). It set a standard of values, attitudes, beliefs, expectations, and organizational norms right away (Grendon and McGinn, 2001). Iggy and Ludmilla established a sense of pride and accomplishment along with personal responsibility for all employees to maintain and...

Words: 952 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Examination of Leadership Theories

...of Leadership Theories in Education and Organizations Katrenia McPhail-Dickerson Strayer University EDU 500 Adult Learning Theory Dr. Claudia Rosenberg May 5, 2012 Introduction There have been several research studies on leadership theories that have been conducted for a variety of purposes. The concept of Leadership is one of the most researched subjects in the world. Leadership theories have become more prevalent in all walks of life. By examining effective adult learning strategies, companies can gain valuable knowledge to advance their organization and prepare their future leaders with the necessary tools to be successful. This paper will examine some of the research conducted on the following leadership and educational theories: Spiritual, and Transformational. Finally, each of the theories will be compared and contrast to one another for the purpose of examining their strengths for possible utilization and integration of models within an organizational setting. Spiritual Leadership and Education Spiritual leadership consist of developing a focus on one’s self and achieving balance for the betterment of the individuals well being. Therefore, balance is achieved by spiritual interests and the ability to build and maintain leader-follower relationships (Wolf, 2004). The Spiritual leadership theory is relevant to current work environment challenges such as, disengaged employees, reduced employee morale and leadership which...

Words: 1425 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Interview of African American Leadership at the Community College Level

...Dwayne A. Grant ELRC 7603 Interview Paper: Leadership at an Anarchical Community College Dr. Owens November 30, 2014 Louisiana State University Though tempered by culture, history, and tradition that shape beliefs in particular directions and away from others, the presence of multiple realities within organized anarchies is undeniable (Manning, 2013). Louisiana’s oldest and largest community college sits in the heart of New Orleans.  Delgado Community College is known for distinctive programs and an extremely rich culture.  Recently, Delgado has experienced changes in leadership during a time of expansion and transition. Faculty at Delgado Community College are outraged that they have not received pay in seven weeks and would like the new Chancellor to reconcile this issue immediately.  This interview paper will discuss the issues faced by newly appointed Chancellor Joan Davis and her leadership in this anarchical institution. An organized anarchy exhibits three characteristics: problematic goals, an unclear technology, and fluid participation (Birnbaum, 1988).  Problematic goals and unclear technology lie at the forefront of Chancellor Davis’ service: prior to Davis’s arrival in May 2013, Delgado faced a budget deficit of $8 million, which led to the announcement of the layoff of 115 employees, including 64 non-tenured faculty members (Lipinski, 2014). Research had shown the underpaid status for both faculty and staff, in addition to the lack of growth or pay increases...

Words: 1456 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Managing Challenging Behaviors

...College of Saint Rose EDA 505- Introduction to Educational Leadership & Administration Instructor: Dr. Rich Hawkins Home Address: P.O. Box 707, Moriches, NY 11955 Phone & fax: 631 909 1388 ; 631 909 1452 Email: drrjh@optonline.net Course Description: The purpose of this course will be to explore the organizational setting in which schools function. Students will acquire an overview of organizational theory, culture, leadership, change, conflicts, and decision-making. Through involvement in self-study, class participation activities and discussions, individual projects, research and writing, students will gain insight regarding their own potential as school leaders. Students will be expected to begin developing their individual Professional Development Portfolios(PDP). Thisenables you to focus on your future developmental needs as an education leaders. The PDP will be a useful guide in your professional development throughout future EDA courses in general, and in particular will be used in conjunction with anNational Council for the Accreditation of Teacher Education (NCATE) rated Reflective Essay that will be completed at the end of your internship. Your portfolio will in part focus on the National Policy Board for Educational Administration’s “Standards for Advanced Programs in Educational Leadership”and the New York State Standards.These standards called the ELCC (Educational Leadership Constituents Council) Standards and the NYS Standards form...

Words: 1453 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Leadership

...LEADERSHIP IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING WORLD How business leaders are reframing success March 2012 Ashridge Business School http://www.ashridge.org.uk Produced on behalf of the United Nations Global Compact and Principles for Responsible Management Education for the Rio+20 Conference on Sustainable Development Lead Authors: Mathew Gitsham, Director, Centre for Business and Sustainability, Ashridge Jo Wackrill, Leadership Agenda Project Director, IBLF Supporting Authors: Graham Baxter, Senior Advisor, IBLF Mark Pegg, Director, Ashridge Leadership Centre © Ashridge & IBLF All rights reserved. Except for the quotation of short passages for the purposes of criticism or review, no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of Ashridge and IBLF. ISBN 978-0-903542-85-2 Ashridge Business School http://www.ashridge.org.uk CONTENTS 1 4 7 7 12 12 17 22 27 28 28 29 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY INTRODUCTION LEADERSHIP IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING WORLD A different perspective: reframing the business leader’s role and purpose LEADERSHIP ROLES OLD AND NEW A familiar leadership role: leading change and innovation across the business A new leadership role: leading change beyond business boundaries HOW CAN THIS TREND BE ACCELERATED? IMPLICATIONS FOR THINKING ABOUT BUSINESS LEADERSHIP CONCLUSIONS NEXT STEPS POST-SCRIPT: HOW...

Words: 20470 - Pages: 82

Free Essay

Mount Everest Case

...[pic] Executive Summary: The Mount Everest case can be summed up as inefficient distribution of leadership, skills and resources in the face of imminent natural disaster. Teamwork consist of interdependency, mutual accountability and understanding common goals and working with respect to each other’s complementary skills. Effective team’s consist of understanding perceptions of others and help motivate each other to continually work towards the common goal. Working towards a goal in a team usually does not run a straight course. In order to offset these issues that can come into play one may need to optimistically receive suggestions, abstain from narrow perceptions and outlook and trust on the team. Trust helps to create path for communication, collaboration, competence, commitment and ideas. Problem Statement: The goal was to reach the summit of Mount Everest and return safely. However the teams were unable to accomplish the task and this failure eventually led to human casualties. Causes: In the case Mount Everest -1996, Roberto and Cardioggia, factors that contributed to failure would include 1. Ineffective leadership (overconfidence, ego, and personality issues) 2. Lack of planning, 3. Poor communication 4. Poor teamwork. Precisely in this case, one of the main cause of catastrophe was that both Mountain Madness and Adventure Consultants proved to be a group but not a team. The members of the team did not share...

Words: 1432 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Problems Managers Have to Face When Managing Team and the Solutions

...circumstances. However, being an effective manager has to handle with a problems during a job such as a relation between manager and subordinate, some manager might fail to do what they are expected to do. Famous business leaders, and academic professor in management science are putting efforts through the experiments and experiences to find out the causes of the management failure and the solution to prevent the problems occur in the future. Although those management theories might be a complex concept and hard to understand, it could provide an easier way to identify and solve problem (Montgomery Van Wart, 2013). This essay will discuss more in details about the cause of the problems manager has to face when managing a team, especially in a leadership and decision making problems, and then provide various suitable solutions. Finally, each of solutions will be critically...

Words: 1731 - Pages: 7