Free Essay

Regents of the University of California V. Bakke (1978)

In:

Submitted By Alexandria2016
Words 553
Pages 3
The constitutional issue was Allan Bakke a white male who applied to and was

rejected from the regular admissions program, while minority applicants with lower grade

point averages and testing scores were admitted under the speciality admissions program.

Bakke filed suit, alleging that this admissions system violated the Equal Protection

Clause and excluded him on the basis of race. The parties that were involved in the case

were Allan Bakke, Supreme Court, Justice Powell, and also the Blacks, Chicanos, Asians,

American Indians.

The case had taken place by the Supreme Court of the United States which was argued

on October 12, 1977, and was decided on June 28, 1978. Before the Supreme Court

began when Allan Bakke applied at The Medical School of the University of California at

Davis which had two admissions programs for entering the class of 100 students the

regular admissions program and the special admissions program. Though he had a 468

out of 500 score in 1973, he was rejected, since no general applicants with scores less

than 470 were being accepted after respondent's application, which was filed late in the

year, had been processed and completed. In 1974 Bakke had applied early, and though

he had a total score of 549 out 600, he was again rejected. In those two years his name

was not placed on the discretionary writing list. In both years, special applicants were

admitted with significantly lower scores than respondent’s. After his second rejection,

Bakke filed his action in state court mandatory, injunctive, and declaratory relief to

compel his admissions to Davis, explaining that the special admissions program

operated to exclude him on the basis of his race in violation of the Equal Protection

Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The trial court found that the special program

operated as a racial quota, because minority applicants in that program were rated only

against one another, and 16 places in the class of 100 were reserved for them.

The Supreme Court, in a 5-4 decision written by Justice Lewis Franklin Powell, ruled

that a state may constitutionally consider race as a factor in its university admissions to

promote educational diversity, but only if considered alongside other factors and on a

case-by-case basis. And also since Bakke had established that the University had

discriminated against him on the basis of his race, the burden of proof shifted to the

University to demonstrate that he would not have been admitted even in the absence of

the special admissions program. The Supreme Court, agreed that the university’s use of

strict racial quotas was unconstitutional so that lead to help make their decision.

There was no single majority opinion. Four of the justices contended that any racial

quota system supported by government violated the Civil Rights Act of 1964. I believe

the case of Bakke was successful because if the Fourteenth Amendment is the Equal

Protection Clause then no person shall on the ground of race or color be excluded from

participating in any program receiving federal financial assistance. Furthermore i think

this case is considered a “landmark” because the landmark decisions in this area arose in

response to the continued exclusion of Negroes from the mainstream of American

society, they could be characterized as involving discrimination by the "majority" white

race against the Negro minority.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Discrimination and Legislation

...MGMT221-1004B-01 Nadeige Jovin American Intercontinental University 11/07/2010 Abstract In order to complete the diversity training manual; as a human resources manager, this paper will cover the definition of Affirmative Action, explain what the initial intent of Affirmative-Action legislation was. It will also talk about the landmark Bakke versus Regents case concluded, give the positive and negative results of Affirmative Action legislation, and tell if the Affirmative Action legislation is still appropriate in that situation.   Discrimination Legislation Introduction Some form of affirmative action had existed in the late 1800s but the extension and enforcement of it really started in the late 1900s. Effectively, the term “affirmative action” was first employed by President Lyndon Johnson in1965 in the Executive Order 11246. The order was applied to the federal government employees to make sure they were employed, treated without regard to their race, belief, color, and nationality. That order was expanded to protect women from discrimination in 1967 by Lyndon Johnson (www.wisegeek.com, Oct, 2010). Definition of Affirmative Action Affirmative action is a set of public positive policies and practices designed to help eliminate past and present discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin, against minorities in the search of employments, admission to colleges and universities or some government contracts. (www.thisnation.com, 1995)....

Words: 1236 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Discrimination Legislation

...Discrimination Legislation Vernecia Denson American Intercontinental University March 10, 2012 In this paper, you will learn and know how to recruit for a more diverse work team. The word affirmative action will be recognized and defined. You will learn what the initial intent of Affirmative-Action legislation was and why it was created. We will distinguish what the positive and negative results of the Affirmative Action legislation and is this legislation still appropriate today. We will learn what the landmark of Bakke v. Regents case included and how it applied and ties in with affirmative action. We will see what was the basis for the conclusion of this case? When thinking about discrimination in the workforce, the words affirmative action comes to mind. Affirmative action was a law put into action to take positive steps that would increase the representation of minorities and women in areas of employment, education, and businesses from which in historical times were excluded (Fullinwider, 2009). Affirmative action wanted to increase not noticing the basic structures based off of race, gender, or ethnicity when making decisions (Fullinwider, 2009). This action is still around till this day. Affirmative action was initiated first by President John F. Kennedy in 1961. This order showed that Federal contractors was suppose to take affirmative action to guarantee that job applicants and employees are treated fairly and would have a fair opportunity regardless of...

Words: 1493 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

California Regents V. Bakke (1978)

...and is considered a lenient form of judicial review, strict-scrutiny is more stringent. Any law that treats people differently because of race or ethnicity is subject to the strict scrutiny test, which presumes that the law is unconstitutional unless government can provide a compelling basis for it. Suspect classifications refer to laws that classify people differently because of their race or ethnicity are assumed to have discrimination as their purpose.  2. Explain de jure discrimination and de facto discrimination. How did affirmative action programs attempt to end both? Summarize University of California Regents v. Bakke (1978). What impact did it have on affirmative action programs? •...

Words: 436 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Affirmative Action

...Affirmative Action Julia Samsa The History of Affirmative Action: Landmark Cases and Legislation Affirmative action refers to policies designed to increase the presence of “underrepresented” demographic groups-such as racial or ethnic minorities and women-in specific sectors of the workforce or in the student bodies of American universities (Affirmative Action, 2010). Affirmative action policies are founded on the premise that any observed imbalance in a given workforce or student body is due, either wholly or in part, to past and/or present discrimination-the remedy for which consists of compensatory preferences in favor of the underrepresented group(s). These measures most commonly take the form of lowered standards for the hiring, promotion, or admission of members of the preferred groups and set-asides which reserve or earmark a designated percentage of slots for members of the preferred group. Historically, the origins of affirmative action were subtle and incremental. The term “affirmative action” was first introduced to the nation by President John F. Kennedy in March 1961. The President signed Executive Order 10925 which established the President’s Commission on Equal Employment Opportunity (Magee, 2011). By this order, any business working under a federal government contract must take affirmative action in hiring and not discriminate on the basis of race, creed, color, or national origin (Wilcher, 2006). JFK’s order did not advocate for the preferential treatment...

Words: 3125 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Paper

...should be used when determining whether to accept or reject the request of an applicant. Affirmative Action refers to policies taken into consideration that may boost someone’s application and thus help them be accepted. These extra policies can used in jobs, universities and other similar competitive based applicable positions, normally they include race, religion or sex. These policies limit the field of applicants and thus make applying for an opening unfair to all that are not helped by it. It also helps create a wider gap in what we would want to have, equality. Instead of focusing on the helping it hides the origins of the original problem which is insufficient help to specific areas of cities, states and counties. During the year of 1978, the court case, Regents of the University of California v. Bakke was a major debate towards that of Affirmative action. Bakke was a 33 year old that had applied to UC Davis Medical School. Even though he had outstanding perquisites he was denied because of the school’s affirmative action helping minorities gain entrance even though they had lower scores. Upon learning of this Bakke decided to take the UC system to court upon which he won and was allowed attendance to the university. Traditionally, we have believed that the highest positions in society should be awarded to those who are best qualified. Rewarding excellence both seems just to the individuals in the competition and makes for efficiency. Although this may lead to lack of diversity...

Words: 1351 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Phil 111 - Affirmative Action

...Looking at Affirmative Action Timothy Eby Southern New Hampshire University Introduction to Critical Thinking PHIL - 111 Dr. Jean Suplizio October 11, 2015 Looking at Affirmative Action THESIS: Explore segments of the inherent disadvantages associated with affirmative action, as experience by non-minority college applicants. Present a relevant objection(s) and a response to the objection. DEFINITIONS: Affirmative action is defined as: “… programs required by federal statutes and regulations to remedy discriminatory practices in hiring minority group members; i.e. positive steps designed to eliminate existing and continuing discrimination, to remedy lingering effects of past discrimination, and to create systems and procedures to prevent future discrimination; commonly based on population percentages of minority groups in a particular area. Factors considered are race, color, sex, creed, and age. National Labor Relations Board v. Fansteel Metallurgical Corporation, 306 U.S. 240” (Black, 1990, p. 59). An additional definition can be found in the widely accepted Random House law dictionary: “… any step by a public or private employer, school, institution, or program, beyond the mere cessation of intentional discrimination, to promote diversity, provide opportunities, and alleviate the effects of past discrimination on the basis of race, sex, national origin or disability” (James, 2000, p. 20). REASON # 1: Colin Powell, the 65th United States Secretary of...

Words: 1677 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

President Roosevelt's Affirmative Action (Rojas)

... In 1978 the case of Regents of the University of California v. Bakke took place when Allan Bakke, “a white California man,” applied to the University of California but because of racial quotas, was denied both times (“Bakke Decision”). Merriam-Webster defines quota as “a specific amount or number that is expected to be achieved” (“Quota”). “The medical school at the University of California, Davis, as part of the university’s affirmative action program, had reserved 16 percent of its admission places for minority applicants” (“Bakke Decision”). Allan Bakke provided proof of higher grades and test scores than minority students. Bakke used the “Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the equal protection clause of the U.S. Constitution’s Fourteenth Amendment” to win and be admitted to the University of California (“Bakke Decisions”). In 1997 a “white resident of Michigan” named Barbara Grutter applied for University of Michigan Law School. This case was argued in 2003 to the Supreme Court. “Grutter applied with a 3.8 undergraduate GPA and an LSAT score of 161. She was denied admission. The Law School admits that it uses race as a factor in making admissions decisions because it serves a "compelling interest in achieving diversity among its student body" (“Grutter v. Bollinger”). The District Court concluded that the Law School's stated interest in achieving diversity in the student body was not a compelling one and enjoined its use of race in the admissions process (“Grutter v. Bollinger”)...

Words: 890 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Bruin Diversity Case Study: Gratz Vs. Bollinger Cases

...the Equal Protection Clause, strict scrutiny, and the Grutter v. Bollinger and Gratz v. Bollinger cases? Your response should include a summary of the basic facts and holding of the Grutter and Gratz cases and clearly apply the legal test of strict scrutiny to the Bruin Diversity Plan. The “Bruin Diversity” plan is a proposed admission policy that’s goal is to promote greater student body diversity. The “Bruin Diversity” plan has four stated goals. Goals that aim to reduce historic deficit of ethnic minority groups, to remedy the effects of societal discrimination of ethnic minority groups, to increase the number of professionals who will practice in underserved communities, and to obtain an ethnically diverse student body. The “Bruin Diversity” admission process will utilize a “Selection Index” (point system). The ethnic minority applicants will also receive an extra 20 points and be evaluated by a special committee. Approximately 33% of all admission slots will be given to ethnic minority groups, thanks to...

Words: 1444 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

California Vs Bakke Summary

...The court case Regents of the University of California v. Bakke was marked as an important supreme court case. A man by the name of Allan Bakke decided to sue the University of California after being rejected twice by the school. The University used two different admissions programs. The first program was a regular admission with requirements of at least a grade point average of 2.5 or they were immediately declined. The second program was for minority or “disadvantaged” applicants. The special program was meant to increase the number of minority students in the university. Allan, a white male, applied to the University of California under the regular admission program a total of two times, one in 1973, the other in 1974, and was rejected both...

Words: 478 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Plessy Vs Ferguson Essay

...laws-minorities Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) Adolph Plessy who is ⅞ white, was arrested when he refused to sit in the “blacks only” railroad car. He said this violated his 14th amendment. Verdict: 7-1 decision for Ferguson, majority by Henry B. Brown. The court ruled that if the cars are separate yet equal then the louisiana law does not violate the 14th amendment. Brown v. board of education of Topeka, I (1954) African children were denied admittance into certain public schools that were segregated. The parents argued that denying them admittance was violating their 14th amendment. Verdict: unanimous decision for Brown , majority by Earl Warren. They said that separate but equal educational facilities was obviously unequal...

Words: 607 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Steelworkers V. Weber Case

...In further cases the Supreme Court supported the constitutionality of affirmative action, but it restricted its implementation. The court’s ruling in Regents of the University of California v. Bakke in 1978 announced it was “unconstitutional to provide a quota system by reserving a definite number of places for minorities in the classes in the medical school of the University of California at Davis” (Brunner, n.d.). However, the ruling supported the right of schools to take into account such factors as race, ethnicity, gender, and economic status evaluating applicants. In United Steelworkers v. Weber in 1979 the Court took decision which a short-term voluntary training program gave preference to minorities was constitutional. The Court ruled...

Words: 258 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Persisting Racial Inequality in the United States of America

...equally and held inherent rights. Our founding fathers immediately ingrained discrimination into the bones of this country and set the stage for years of struggle to achieve equal opportunity. After 185 years of denying equal social and economic opportunities to minorities and women, America’s leaders chose to act. The actions of John F. Kennedy and Lyndon B. Johnson brought forward a plan called affirmative action: to address the under-representation of qualified minorities and women in higher education and the workplace. With a foundation that contains discrimination in its core, affirmative action did not come without controversy. It has been the central topic of notable Supreme Court cases such as University of California Regents v. Bakke, Grutter v. Bollinger, and Fisher v. University of Texas. Many who oppose affirmative action argue that race-conscious programs lead to reverse discrimination and group preferences over individual merit. Through arguments, data and research, it will be shown that affirmative action is indeed an effective remedy for addressing racial inequality in higher education and other institutions. Without it in this current time, large negative effects would be felt throughout higher education and higher education. Affirmative action’s origins stem from an executive order that John F. Kennedy wrote in regards to the hiring practices of employers. It stated “...will not discriminate against any employee or applicant for employment because of race, creed...

Words: 2254 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Paper

...Affirmative Action Affirmative action is a government policy that gives opportunities to minorities, women, and any group who has been the victim of discrimination in the past. Affirmative action is the outcome of the 1960’s Civil Rights movement, growing out of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 which outlawed discrimination based on race, ethnicity, or gender. It was the 1978 Supreme Court decision, The Regents of the University of California v. Bakke, which allowed for the use of race-based preferences as a means of fostering diversity, allowing affirmative action to be used in admissions policies. It was created with the intention to provide equal opportunities for members of minority groups in education and employment. Initially affirmative action focused on improving opportunities for African Americans. Colleges and universities used Affirmative action in their admission process, with the hopes of increasing their enrollment of African Americans and later Hispanic students, two minorities that were falling behind in college acceptance rates. According to data from the National Center on Education Statistics (NCES), in 2007, 70 percent of white high school graduates immediately enrolled in college, compared to 56 percent of African American graduates and 61 percent of Hispanic graduates. As more and more educational institutions began using affirmative action policies in their admissions process, it became a target of great debate. With Americans taking sides as affirmative...

Words: 300 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Affirmative Acction

...Some of the arguments against affirmative action include: * It is unfair to judge applicants on anything other than their merits. – There are numerous factors that a college should take into account when considering applicants – grades, test scores, and extra-curricular activities. An applicant’s race is not a legitimate factor to take into consideration because it is outside of the student’s control. It is impossible for a college to consider every aspect of a student’s background when making decisions on whom to admit. Why focus on race when there are so many other things that differentiate students from one another? * Affirmative action does not lead to true diversity. – Diversity of opinion is important in an academic community, not racial diversity. Affirmative action provides an advantage to some people because of the color of their skin. This is not an attribute that is relevant to the academic mission of a college. Affirmative action gives preferential treatment based exclusively on race, which is a purely external characteristic. * Affirmative action does not help really disadvantaged groups. – In many cases, affirmative action does not achieve its goal of helping disadvantaged minority groups. What it does is perpetuates socioeconomic inequalities by making it easy for members of racial minorities from privileged backgrounds to get into prestigious colleges while not helping members of the lower classes. * White Men Win $11 million Lawsuit for Reverse...

Words: 1236 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Reverse Discrimination: The Ambassadors Of The World Trip

...Bakke (1978), in which the ruled: “quotas may not be used to reserve places for minority applicants if white applicants are denied a chance to compete for those places.” (The Editors) In this case I would say the quota is unjust, due to the fact that the cost of the trip is funded for these students- and white students are unable to compete for these positions; however the students that are minorities are able to compete for the other 15...

Words: 567 - Pages: 3