Revenue Recognition - Fasb
Revenue Recognition - FasbAmeriprise Financial, Inc.
802 Ameriprise Financial Center
Minneapolis, MN 55474
Via Email: email@example.com
October 22, 2010
File Reference No. 1820‐100
Financial Accounting Standards Board
401 Merritt 7
Post Office Box 5116
Norwalk, Connecticut 06856‐5116
Re: File Reference: No. 1820‐100, Revenue Recognition (Topic 605) – Revenue from Contracts
Dear Technical Director:
Ameriprise Financial, Inc., one of the nation’s leading financial planning, asset management and
insurance companies, appreciates the opportunity to offer comments with respect to the
Proposed Accounting Standards Update, Revenue Recognition (Topic 605) – Revenue from
Contracts with Customers (the “Proposed Statement”).
We support the FASB’s efforts to develop a single revenue recognition model across industries.
We also support the FASB’s efforts to achieve greater convergence with the IASB. However, we
believe the issuance of the Proposed Statement as written may create inconsistencies and add
complexity to revenue recognition for contracts that charge a fixed rate fee on assets under
We believe the timing of revenue recognition for certain nonrefundable fixed rate fee contracts
may become disconnected from the cash flows and corresponding economics of our
transactions. We enter into various types of contracts to perform services for a fixed rate fee.
The revenues for fixed rate fee contracts are based on a fixed percentage of assets under
management which varies based on market movements and net subscriptions or redemptions.
For example, revenue from mutual fund fixed rate fee contracts is generally accrued daily and
collected monthly over the contract period.
It is industry practice to recognize these fixed rate fees for asset management contracts as
earned over the service period as the fees are nonrefundable. We believe the industry practice
will continue for nonrefundable fixed rate fees earned based on our...