Premium Essay

Stand Your Ground Law Case Study

Submitted By
Words 449
Pages 2
When black women, who are defending themselves, are charged with assault or murder, it demonstrates how these individuals are marginalized and victimized all over again. There is no other female demographic group that is more likely to be assaulted, domestically abused or murdered, than black women (Jones-DeWeever). However, instead of these women receiving justice through the American legal system, they are charged and incarcerated at disproportional rates. Therefore, one must ask why the justice system contains such disparity and what can be done to rectify these injustices? Marissa Alexandra’s case demonstrates how the Stand Your Ground law was applied so randomly in one state. A Florida jury found George Zimmerman, who gunned down an unarmed black man, innocent of murder, on the basis of Stand Your Ground law. However, when …show more content…
Unfortunately, at this point in time, domestic violence reporting and laws differ greatly by states. The only way to rectify this is through federal legislation, which supersedes state laws (Daunt). Therefore, it seems appropriate to enact federal legislation that would impose harsher sentencing for abusers and guaranteed protection for victims and their families. Another vehicle to address this disparity would be to abolish all state mandated prison sentencing, thereby, allowing judges leniency when those who are victimized stand up to their abusers. While this would be ideal, it may be unrealistic. Therefore, one should propose federal legislation that would identify special circumstances in court cases, such as domestic abuse. When these issues are voiced and documented by prior reporting, the judge should be absolved from state minimum prison requirements, as federal laws supersede state laws. In addition, a national, public reporting of identified cases should be published

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Persuasive Research Paper Assignment

..."Stand Your Ground Laws Cat in the Hat ENG/757 December 7, 1941 Dr. Seus "Stand Your Ground" A Citizen's Right to Self Defense. As of 2012, 24 of the United States have put in place some form of “castle doctrine” or “stand your ground” law. These laws are designed to enable citizens to legally defend themselves with deadly force and eliminate the requirement for them to attempt to flee when they feel that an attacker is threatening their life. In the wake of the case in Sanford Florida in which self-proclaimed community watchman George Zimmerman shot and killed 17-year-old Trayvon Martin during a confrontation, much attention and public scrutiny has been brought to bear on these controversial laws. A few “stand your ground” states have claimed that abuse of these laws has fostered what some say is a shoot first ask questions later mentality, and in some cases, instances of what could be considered legalized murder. However, instances of abuse are minimal, and in states that have instituted these laws, homicide rates are the lowest in the nation. “Stand your ground” laws are also said by some to promote vigilantism, but even if in some cases this were true, law abiding citizens must be afforded the right to self-defense by any means necessary, without fear of prosecution. “Stand Your Ground”, “Castle Doctrine” What Do They Mean? In the growing debate concerning abolishment of the “stand your ground” laws in place in nearly half of the United States, there are several...

Words: 2285 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Stand Your Ground Law

...t Stand Your Ground Laws Name Institution Date Abstract The dissension encompassing Stand Your Ground laws have recently seized the nation’s heed. So far about eighteen regimes have accepted laws extending the right to ‘self-defense with no duty to retreat’ to any region a person has a legal right to be. Several governments are also debating the passing of similar legislation. Inspite of implications that the laws may have for public well-being, there has been less empirical investigation of their impact, not only on crime but also on victimization. This laws makes it easier for some people to use deadly force when their “reasonably fears” result in serious injury at the hands of others. In such cases, those persons may be entitled to immunity from prosecution and civil liability. In fact, these laws usually confer powers that police have on private citizens, without the need of training kind and accountability. Before the Stand Your Ground laws, right to use deadly force was strictly not allowed. An individual had to show that it was reasonable to believe that the use of such force was necessary to prevent sudden death or great harm to himself or herself or another or to prevent the imminent commission of a forcible ‘felony’. Only when a person was attacked in his home by a person not having an equal right to be there, she/he had a duty to retreat if he/she could do so in safety. Florida was unambiguous in protecting human beings.an individual under...

Words: 2285 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

My Ideal Career

...in the law field. I have not decided on one particular law career yet because I do not yet know enough about the different types of law, but the ones that I think do sound interesting are mediation, family law, and paralegal. A paralegal can work in any area of the law. They can work in family law, criminal law, etc, and also in the mediation field. What made you interested in the law in the first place? I think mediation sounds interesting because a mediator helps people settle their disputes outside the court room in a peaceful way. Mediators need to have excellent reasoning, problem-solving, and peace-making abilities (The Princeton Review, 2012). This appeals to me because I am more of a peaceful person and do not really like conflict or arguing, though I can stand my ground if I need to. According to the Princeton Review, a good mediator is honest, neutral, encouraging, listens well, and has excellent communication skills (The Princeton Review, 2012). I have all of these skills, especially the honest part, down well. In fact, my dad is always telling me I am too honest and I could never get away with doing anything wrong when I was little because I would always give myself away. hahaha Family law is interesting because I like the idea of helping families through the hard parts of life. Family court lawyers handle divorce, guardianship, prenuptial agreements, adoptions, parental rights, custody cases, and the financial and tax implications from these cases. They need...

Words: 1034 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Music

...may be the cause. In the introduction of the text it states “On June 15, 2011, more than 150,000 fans assembled on the streets of Vancouver to watch game seven of the Stanley Cup Finals between the Vancouver Canucks and the Boston Bruins. Within minutes of the Canucks loss, a riot began. One aspect that made this event unique was that it was documented on Twitter” this would clearly indicate that there was a relationship between the fans knowledge of the current affair which was the hockey game and the Literary review-RQ- 1. Is there a relationship between social media use and KNOWLEDGE of current affairs? 2. What is the relationship between social media use and knowledge of stand your ground law? 3. What is the relationship between social media use and attitude toward stand your ground law? Methodology- In the text it is stated that Twitter is a fairly new medium within the sport communication scenery; a growing body of literature has examined its utilization among various user groups such as athletes. Sport-specific research regarding Twitter has largely focused on general usage trends, however, this particular event summarized a crisis event situation, where the framing and perception of the event and larger cultural frameworks could be examined on a digital medium. Variables were modified from Billings and Angelini’s...

Words: 6731 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Case 10: Anti-Nepotism

...XXXXX XXXXXXXXXXX Keller graduate school of management | hrm 586: labor relations ------------------------------------------------- Case study 10 An Anti-nepotism policy XXXXX XXXXXXXXXXX Keller graduate school of management | hrm 586: labor relations ------------------------------------------------- Case study 10 An Anti-nepotism policy CASE OVERVIEW Mr. Keith Walton applied for a job at Manatee Power plant by filling out application form (C-1) on January 5, 1999. The (C-1) form specifically asked the applicant whether or not he/she had any relatives employed at the company, to which Mr. Walton answered “no”. He was hired by Manatee Power Plant on April 30, 1999 where he worked until his release on November 2, 2006. Mr. Walton was discharged after the company learned in October 2006 that Mr. Walton did, indeed, have a relative employed with the company. At the time of the application, Mr. Walton did not know that his uncle, Bill Williams, worked for the company as well and there is no dispute regarding this fact and no question about Mr. Walton’s truthfulness on the application. UNION POSITION The Union makes several arguments in defense of Mr. Walton. First, the Union argues that the employee manual is not made readily available to employees. The Union testifies that, “….they had very limited knowledge of and access to the Company’s General Operations Manuals…” and that it is only in these relatively unknown manuals that this policy is in written form...

Words: 2464 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Racism in Work

...throughout investment downturns. Banters over the beginnings of racism frequently experience the ill effects of an absence of clarity over the term. Numerous conflate later types of racism with prior manifestations of ethnic and national clash. Much of the time ethno-national clash appears to owe to clash over land and key assets. In a few cases ethnicity and patriotism were outfit to wars between extraordinary religious realms for instance, the Muslim Turks and the Catholic Austro-Hungarians). As Benedict Anderson has recommended in Imagined Communities, ethnic character and ethno-patriotism turned into a wellspring of clash inside such domains with the ascent of print-private enterprise. An alternate conceivable wellspring of racism is the misconstruing of Charles Darwin's speculations of advancement. Some took Darwin's hypotheses to suggest that since a few "races" were more cultivated, there must be a natural premise for the contrast. In the meantime they spoke to organic speculations of ethical and erudite qualities to defend racial persecution. There is an extraordinary arrangement of debate about race and discernment, to some degree on the grounds that the notions of both race and IQ are themselves controversial. Handling racism is no simple assignment. Separation may be oblivious and administration may be unwilling to affirm that they may be unwilling to recognize that they could be segregating. Representatives may not dependably recognize the purposes behind the medicine they...

Words: 810 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Essay On Juvenile Delinquency

...methods. Data was collected individuals who have conducted cases studies on juvenile delicense who have committed a verity of crimes. This study was examined whether a child is more likely to rehabilitate by using alternate resources other than incarceration, at the same focusing on the issues that incarcerating a delinquent cause. This research attacks the concept that juveniles should have the same penalties as adults who commits...

Words: 1528 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Is the 2nd Amendment Worth Saving?

...Is the 2nd Amendment Worth Saving? Is the 2nd Amendment Worth Saving? “Good people don’t need laws to tell them to act responsibly… and bad people will find a way around the laws.” – Plato “The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants” - Thomas Jefferson “The Constitution preserves the advantage of being armed, which Americans possess over the people of almost every nation… (Where) the governments are afraid to trust the people with arms.” - James Madison -The Federalist Sandy Hook: Littleton, Colorado (Columbine): Newtown, Connecticut. These names strike fear in to anyone who was alive to hear about them as they happened. These were mass shootings in very public places, schools. Between the years of 1996-2013 a total of 84 attackers committed 77 attacks on schools in 15 countries killing 502 students and teachers and wounding 496 others worldwide. (See Table 1) It is my belief that these attacks were orchestrated upon the most helpless in our society in order to incite mass fear and chaos! Each crime was perpetrated with both handguns and rifles, or what these days are referred to as “assault rifles.” The term “assault rifle” is yet another mainstream media scare tactic designed solely for fear because many believe that for a civilian to possess what looks like a military weapon they must intend to murder. Hatred of other people because of race or status and the belief that “Someone” is holding them back is truly...

Words: 3879 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

International Law

...Positivism • Realism • International law • Conclusion • List of works cited ​ Introduction ​Law is a concept of governance that involves the stipulation and establishment of rules and regulations that are enforced to shape politics, economics, and society. It is put in place by various governmental institutions to govern a community. Law moderates our day–to-day lives with regards to human relationships. It has various concepts to it; company law, property law, trust law, criminal law, constitutional law, administrative law, international law, and civil law. The study of law allows for review and revision of these rules and regulations ensuring that none is faulty or biased in any manner to a single party of the human population.​ Definitions ​The above mentioned concepts are in light of the various activities we indulge in. Contract law deals with regulation of trade terms relating to establishments of contracts. Property law deals in ownership rights and ownership transfers of personal property. It is often called Chattel law. We can say that Trust law applies to assets that are secured for financial reasons. A concept of law that was not mentioned previously in the introduction part is Tort law. This law enables one to apply for compensation in the case of loss of or damage of personal property (Byers 22). Criminal law establishes the way and reasons for perpetrator prosecution. Constitutional law protects the human rights as well...

Words: 1314 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Ethics in Criminal Justice

...Please Follow These Procedures: If requested by your mentor, use an assignment cover sheet as the first page of the word processor file. The assignment header should include the Learner’s last name, first initial, course code, dash, and assignment number (DoeJXXX0000-1) justified to the left and the page number justified to the right. Keep a Photocopy or Electronic Copy of Your Assignments: You may need to re-submit assignments if your mentor has indicated that you may or must do so. Academic Integrity: All work submitted in each course must be the Learner’s own. This includes all assignments, exams, term papers, and other projects required by the faculty mentor. The known submission of another person’s work represented as that of the Learner’s without properly citing the source of the work will be considered plagiarism and will result in an unsatisfactory grade for the work submitted or for the entire course, and may result in academic dismissal. | | | |CJ7011-8 |Gabriele Suboch | | | | |Ethics and Criminal Justice |Assess a Case Scenario to Foster a Culture of Ethics ...

Words: 3572 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

The Pros And Cons Of Civil Rights And Civil Liberties

...people for based on their race, religion or ethnicity for crime suspicions by police officers. Criminal profiling is the use of features believed to be connected to criminal activities. Law enforcement is significantly affected by profiling. Police officers use racial profiling to determine the individuals to the stop and frisk on suspicion of illegal goods and for minor traffic violations. It is mostly directed to people of color. The terrorist attacks in the nation have led to targeting of Arabs without substantial evidence of criminal activities. These actions are injustices against the people...

Words: 1342 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Gun Control

...defensive gun uses with only 0.00852 percent that led to a death (David Frum). That’s close to nothing. If a gun wasn’t involved who knows how many more casualties there would have been. How many more families would be making one less dinner plate at night? When owning a gun, you have to be well educated in how to use it. If you don’t know how to properly use the weapon, it could lead to injury or even death. If someone broke into your house and had a gun, what could you do if you didn’t know how to use it safely? You would be shot or even killed. Good for you, you just wasted money on a gun that could have saved your life if you knew how to use it. It’s like buying a car with manual transmission and never learned how to drive one. It is just wasted money and space. It could even lead to death to you or another person. A gun in trained hands can be a very lethal weapon. Owning a gun and knowing how it operates creates a sense of security. Not only can you use your gun for protection, but you can also use it to provide food for your family. To get a gun, I do believe that you should have a background check. The reasoning behind this is that 10 percent of all murders are by people with some sort of mental illness. Almost all mass killings are done by the...

Words: 2134 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

American Revolution Impact on Historical Figures

...of America. Many different battles were foraged, taxes and laws imposed that contributed to the Patriots wanting freedom from the control of Great Britain. The effects of war along with culture and ethnicity affected many during this time in many different ways due to their position or status during this fight. Abigail and John Adams are important known historical figures from the American Revolution. Abigail and John communicated through letters widely documented and used for the study of the war. The American Revolution affected this couple in many ways individually and as a married couple. John was a member of the Continental Congress, a select group to lobby for American independence. Being a part of this group required John to be away from his homestead while Abigail stayed behind to provide local support of the war and care for their home. Long or short time periods of distance in a relationship can bring many complications and in some cases a greater appreciation of the other. Abigail took on the responsibilities caring for the farm, educating children while dealing with reduced income, lack of goods due to the war and overall difficult living conditions and being alone. In letters between them, Abigail pleads for John to remember the rights of women in negations for independence, not to put too much power into the hands on men. Abigail also touches on the passion women have and their ability to take a stand if they are not represented. John responds in agreement, however...

Words: 642 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Onflicts of Law and Equity in the Merchant of Venice William Carlos Williams Once Said That “Shakespeare Is the Greatest University of Them All” (Qtd. in Kornstein Xiii). This Is Especially True with Respect to the Law:

...onflicts of Law and Equity in The Merchant of Venice William Carlos Williams once said that “Shakespeare is the greatest university of them all” (qtd. in Kornstein xiii). This is especially true with respect to the law: a dedicated scholar can discover a wealth of information on legal issues in Shakespeare’s works. Measure for Measure and The Merchant of Venice are, of course, explicitly “legal” in content, but more than twenty of the plays have some form of trial scene (Kornstein xii). Virtually all of the plays are tangentially concerned with some aspect of the law; at the very least, Shakespeare uses complex legal jargon to elicit a laugh. When one of the title characters in The Merry Wives of Windsor tosses out a line like: If the devil have [Falstaff] not in fee simple [absolute possession], with fine and recovery [as of an entailment], he will never, I think, in the way of waste [despoiling], attempt us again (IV.ii.197-99, emph. added) the law students who made up a large portion of his contemporary audience must have roared with laughter, even if few others got the joke. It is therefore not surprising that the interdisciplinary study of law and Shakespeare has grown into a fully recognized field, with major law schools offering advanced degrees. Such interdisciplinary examination has opened for us a new vista of understanding. The Merchant of Venice “has spawned more commentary by lawyers than any other Shakespeare play” (Kornstein 66). One can easily...

Words: 1927 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Judicial Review

...copyright material you will need to obtain permission from the copyright holders concerned. Any enquiries regarding this publication should be sent to Michael Odulaja, Administrative Justice, Court and Tribunal Fees and Coroner’s Policy Team, Ministry of Justice, Post Point 4.34, 102 Petty France, London, SW1H 9AJ. This publication is available for download at www.official-documents.gov.uk and on our website at www.justice.gov.uk ISBN: 9780101851527 Printed in the UK by The Stationery Office Limited on behalf of the Controller of Her Majesty’s Stationery Office ID 2529331 12/12 Printed on paper containing 75% recycled fibre content minimum. Judicial Review: proposals for reform Contents Foreword 1. Introduction 2. Background 3. The case for change 4. Time limits for bringing a claim 5. Applying for permission 6. Fees 7. Impact Assessment and Equality Impacts 8. Summary of questions 9. How to respond 3 4 6 9 12 18 25 28 30 32 1 Judicial Review: proposals for reform 2 Judicial Review: proposals for reform Foreword Recently, the Prime Minister set out the Government’s plans to tackle red tape, promote growth and stimulate economic recovery,...

Words: 11446 - Pages: 46