Free Essay

The Case Analysis for the Rob Parson Case

In:

Submitted By automanxi
Words 488
Pages 2
1. Evaluate the effectiveness of the Morgan Stanley performance assessment and management system. The primary source of performance assessment at the firm is a multi-source 360 degree feedback tool. The secondary source is an employee’s self assessment. There are a number of issues as to why the primary tool is not effective in truly assessing the performance of an employee at Morgan Stanley. The first issue surrounds the reliability of the raters in the 360 degree process. The raters are from the Capital Markets group and other groups within the firm with little definition if the raters are all at the same organizational level. This calls into question inter-rater reliability as reliability tends to be low when the raters are not from the same level. The second issue is one of freedom from bias. As the 360 degree feedback tool is highly subjective with regard to the comments it records, it does not address how a manager would assess either leniency or severity errors within the comments. Each of the raters may experience peak-end utility at the time they provide their comments. Unfortunately, this clouds their commentary. Instead of focusing comments on their complete experience with an employee, they may focus only on their last experience. A third issue involves the employee assessment tool. It vaguely addresses the concepts of goal-setting and employee development. In its current form, the tool is mainly used for administrative purposes (promotion and compensation). The sign of a good assessment tool is that it ties the goals of the employee with the goals of the organization. It also provides feedback on areas in which an employee needs to develop their skills and establishes an action plan. Lastly, the intended behaviors of the organization are not formally defined in the 360 degree tool and are not well understood by the company employees including the managing directors. If the company wants to change its culture through this performance appraisal system, the design will have to be modified to better focus on specific behavior expectations. Similar to the employee performance assessment tool, the performance management system at Morgan Stanley also lacks effectiveness. It is a loosely defined and subjective system that appears to be missing substance in two critical areas. The first area lacking substance is its definition of performance. Performance is not set with clear, measureable goals nor does it take into account developmental plans for the employee. A well defined, well communicated set of goals would have an immediate impact on improving the alignment of the corporate expectations with the goals of the employee. The second area of concern is the lack of quality feedback and coaching. In order for Morgan Stanley’s performance management system to be effective it must train its managing directors on how to provide concise and objective feedback. It must also give them the tools (access to trainers) and empower them to implement employee development.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Rob Parson at Morgan Stanley

...dimensions of performance” and that “these raters observe different behaviors and may interpret them with divergent standards.” Therefore, the purpose of 360-degree feedback is to give staff a better understanding of their strengths and weaknesses which, in turn, allows them to better identify aspects of their work needing professional development. The fact that Morgan Stanley introduced a 360-degree performance assessment tool is commendable. However, the effectiveness of this tool in its current state has not yet been optimized. In particular, the company’s vision statement appears to be very solid as it clearly articulates how employee abilities should be harnessed to help the company enforce its vision. It is not clear from the case if Morgan Stanley considered the strategic usefulness of their performance appraisal, if a communications plan was developed for this change management initiative or if an appropriate level of training is offered for raters, managers and staff being assessed on evaluation and feedback. There is a clear...

Words: 1107 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Rob Parson

...Situation Analysis: This is a case of a young banker by the name Rob Parson who had just joined Morgan Stanley. Parson who was a managing director of a small firm is having difficulty adjusting to the culture of a large financial firm like Morgan Stanley. Key Issues Analysis: 1) Adopting the Company Culture: Rob Parson who is new to Morgan Stanley was unable to adapt to the firm’s culture which fosters integrity, teamwork, innovation, dignity and respect. Despite being one the firm’s division’s star performers and an outstanding producer, Parson was seen as sharp-tongued, impatient and often difficult to work with. His team player skills’ rating was low. He was perceived as occasionally aggressive, temperamental, lacked respect and possesses traits that did not fit the profile of a Morgan Stanley’s managing director. 2) 360 Degree Performance Evaluation: No doubt the 360 degrees evaluation is a valuable tool to help employees improve their performance however due to its limitations it may not be as effective when it comes to decide on employees’ promotion. Morgan Stanley’s 360 degree performance evaluation did not include clients’ valuation, developmental opportunities such as coaching and training. Furthermore, there were no performance standards that measured the individual in comparison to the performance of the group and it failed to take into consideration job functions, performance standards and departmental goals. Recommendation: Rob Parson may not be ready...

Words: 266 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Rob Parson at Morgan Stanley

...knowledge but were also skilled at responding to client needs by designing products in collaboration with product specialists within Morgan Stanley. Market coverage professional to be compatible with the staff of other departments, but can't rely entirely on product designers, because they do not understand markets and customers, do not know the customer's needs. It is important to fully understand the market, product, and customer information in three areas and needs. That person must be energetic, aggressive and innovative. It was these requirements that led to the appointment of Rob Parson, a managing director at a smaller firm with connections to some of the players in banking and insurance industries, as market coverage professional. That’s why he recruited Rob Parson. Rob developed relationships with the important players in the banking and insurance industries and a strong reputation. Rob is...

Words: 1915 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Rob Parson at Morgan Stanley (a)

...Stanley’s weak areas was Capital Market Services, an area where he had been successful in the past. Paul also knew that it would take more than a traditional corporate banker to penetrate this market. That person must be energetic, aggressive and innovative. That’s why he recruited Rob Parson. Rob developed relationships with the important players in the banking and insurance industries and a strong reputation. Rob is not easily discouraged or intimidated and knows what it takes to get the job done. His drive and ambition allows him to connect with his clients but sometimes distances him from his co-workers. The position that Paul needed to fill was difficult to perform and had a very high turnover rate. He thought that Rob was the perfect person to fill that billet. Rob accepted the position with the understanding that there was a potential for growth because the effort was in need of repair and that the Morgan Stanley had done very little business in Capital Markets. Paul implicitly promised Rob a promotion to managing director during recruitment. Rob never thought that he would have to tip-toe on egg shells when dealing with co-workers. The new president wanted people who could shake things up and Rob had been successful in bringing Morgan Stanley into this Market. However, it seemed that he has created some animosity among his peers....

Words: 1261 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Rob Parson Situation Analysis

...Situation analysis: The Capital Markets Services(CMS) division, which was established as an interdisciplinary concern to address the issues of focused client attention and cross-divisional collaboration, required professionals who not only had domain-specific industry knowledge but were also skilled at responding to client needs by designing products in collaboration with product specialists within Morgan Stanley. It was these requirements that led to the appointment of Rob Parson, a managing director at a smaller firm with connections to some of the important players in the banking and insurance industries, as a market coverage professional The financial services industry is characterized by firms where individual professionals attract business and the ability of the firm to retain clients is solely dependent on the entrepreneurial skills of professionals. Thus, in a market typified by clients demanding immediate solutions, Morgan Stanley’s attempt at creating a consensus-based interface can be seen as a process projecting the firm – and not the individual – as the business facilitator; this necessitates the appointment of skilled executives who not only possess the ability to market and sell but also display the willingness to obtain approval through franchise and collaboration. The nature of Rob Parson’s responsibilities, though challenging, involved resurrecting Morgan Stanley’s capital markets’ business and had witnessed a high turnover rate in the past. This position...

Words: 1188 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Leading Complex Organizations

...and Managing Work by Tony Watson will be used. The book by Tony Watson covers issues about organizational, managerial and strategic behavior. In particular, the author argues for a critical common sense and the use of philosophical pragmatism (Watson, 2006). He also questions the way work is organized and managed. Finally, the process-relation perspective, a critical perspective of how to think about organizations and their relations and interactions with people, is taken by Watson (2006). This paper will start with a description of the two theories “System-control framing” and “Process-relational framing”. Afterwards the three concepts strategic exchange, negotiated order and double control will be defined and exemplified by different cases from the course. Finally, the paper will look into the complexity of managing knowledge at organizations supported by examples from Danone and McKinsey. In the field of leadership and management studies, there are two main perspectives “System-control framing” and “Process-relational framing”, which can help to analyze and make sense of complex organizations. The system-control perspective recognizes organizations as an entity that is “a system of managerially designed rules and roles existing on its own terms […] based on an organization design with a set of structural and cultural characteristics” (Watson, 2006, p.30). According to the system-control perspective, an organization that matches these characteristics will succeed in reaching...

Words: 3258 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Leadership

...LEADERSHIP IN ORGANIZATIONS(Draft Syllabus) B01.1302.25 Spring 2010 Professor R. Kabaliswaran Office: KMC 7-56 E-mail: rkabalis@stern.nyu.edu Office Hours: 11:30 AM– 1:00 PM on class days and by appointment Class Hrs: Wed 1:30-4:20 PM on Jan 27; Feb 3, 10, 17, 24; Mar 3, 10, 24, 31; Apr 7, 14, 21, 28. Due Dates Team Case Write-up: 2/24. Final Team Project : 4/28. Indiv Take Home Final: 5/2. ____________________________________________________________ _________________ Course Overview Welcome aboard! What do leaders do? What happens inside organizations? And how do these relate to each other? In a nutshell, that’s the stuff this course is made of. Business organizations of all types face chronic management problems that pose significant challenges to them. These problems include the difficulty of designing organizations capable of coping with highly dynamic business environments, the challenge of developing strategies and structures for hypercompetitive conditions, the greater complexity of managing global enterprises, the difficult task of shaping a corporate culture, managing politics and conflict between individuals and organizational units, motivating employees who are more mobile than ever, designing attractive incentive systems, managing and harnessing intellectual capital, and so on. Such challenges and how the top leadership can deal with them are the subject of this course. The course has two major components. The first is “macro” in nature. It focuses on organizational...

Words: 6197 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

Managing People for Competitive Advantage

...------------------------------------------------- Case Analysis Guidelines Choose two (2) Individual Case Write-Ups from these found in your textbook, one from group A, one from group B: Group A Meg Whitman at eBay Inc. Matsushita Electrical Industrial Co. GSK’s Acquisition of Sirtris Utah Symphony- Utah Opera Merger Group B JetBlue Airways Rob Parson at Morgan Stanley Netflix Compensation Your Objective Using the information provided in the text and additional research, your goal is to answer the questions that are implied or stated at the end of the case, and to describe the case using the ideas, models, and concepts of this course. This is an essay, not a consultant’s report, so you will not directly be making recommendations. See examples of suggested questions for some of cases in the final section below. Length: 1200 minimum (4+ pages of double-spaced, 12-point font text). Due date: See Class Schedule for date on which your selected case is due. Submission: Via upload to the corresponding ASSIGNMENT area on EIDOS. The Cases All of the cases used in this course are based on real situations. Each case contains a different blend of information and anecdotes about the firm, its business environment, and the people who manage it. No case will ever contain all the facts you would like to know in order to make a totally comprehensive assessment. In preparing your write-up, make your analysis from the point in time of the conclusion of the case description. NOTE:...

Words: 846 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Portfolio

...This reflective account demonstrates an ability to critically reflect on experiences within my nurse training, particularly within my third and final year. The reflective model selected is Gibbs (1998) (appendix 1) which incorporates description, feelings, evaluation, analysis, conclusion and an action plan which is divided into sections for ease of reading. All names have been changed in accordance with the NMC (2008a) guidelines regarding confidentiality. This piece includes reflections on my own learning using the NMC proficiency, managing care. As this covers a vast array my focus is primarily on medicine management, managing risk and delegation. Description of events During placement within the Accident & Emergency (A&E) department I saw my paediatric mentor on three occasions, the remainder of the time I worked with adult trained staff. As a consequence of this when a child was admitted, I was given the responsibility of caring for them. For the duration of a particular shift I worked with Sue, an adult nurse. Sue recognised that I was competent in my practice as I had worked with her on previous occasions with adults and consequently praised me. Sue, qualified for over twenty years, indicated that she only knew the basics of children’s nursing and suggested that I probably had more knowledge of children than her. This comment left me unsure of her depth of knowledge of paediatric nursing and somewhat concerned me. During my shift, Jay, a two year old was admitted...

Words: 3382 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Wolf Keller

...Professional Services Fall 2007 I. POSITIONING AND ALIGNMENT a) Developing and Implementing Strategy: Wachtell Lipton Wachtell Why has Wachtell been so successful? - Niche o M&A, hostile takeovers o General counsels, CEOs come to Wachtell when they have a problem - Size: small o 1 office (140 attorneys in 1995, 193 today); organic growth (no mergers/acquisition of other firms & only 2 lateral partners in entire history) o Benefits = control over quality of work; quality of recruits; sense of collegiality; maintenance of position in niche (if it stays significantly smaller than the market for its services, no matter how bad business gets, it will always have enough work); avoids inefficiencies of partnership model b/c decisions made quickly w/ little process - Bills o Based on value, not time o Wachtell does not pursue bills aggressively – they call twice, and that’s it. Clients can literally stiff the firm… only consequence is that it will never take you on as a client again and it will tell all its other clients that you didn’t pay. ▪ Wachtell’s realization rate ~90% (vs. ~80% at other firms) - Clients o By matter, not long-term relationships ▪ Gives the firm independence from clients – fewer conflicts o Can pick & choose interesting, innovative, and high-paying work o Doing only transactional work expands the market because no conflicts o Business...

Words: 11144 - Pages: 45

Free Essay

Research Proposal on Impulse Buying Behaviour

...RESEARCH PROPOSAL | To study the relation between the various types of consumers, according to VALS segmentation and the consumer impulse buying behavior. | | TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary | 3 | Background of the problem | 3 | Problem Statement | 4 | Research Objectives | 4 | Review of Literature | 4 | Segmentation Plan | 5 | Research Hypothesis | 6 | Research Design | 6 | Results and Practical utility of the research | 6 | Scheduling the research | 7 | Results and outcomes of the research | 7 | Glossary of Terms | 8 | References | 9 | 1. Executive Summary The vibrant and exotic atmosphere of Delhi local markets can make shopping lots of fun.  One of the biggest sectors is apparel sector. Local apparel markets in Delhi sell hundreds or thousands of products daily. It is not only famous in Delhi but people from all over India do their wedding shopping from Delhi shops which are cheap and of new fashion. People do planned as well as unplanned shopping from these local shops. It is usually seen that buyers purchase products which they have not planned and this phenomenon of unplanned purchasing is termed as impulse. There are many factors which lead to unplanned or impulsebuying. This leads us to determine the factors that lead to impulse buying behaviour in consumers as well as to determine which segment (based on VALS classification scheme) of consumers show the most impulse...

Words: 3288 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Bdhs

...Social Change and Modernity Edited By Hans Haferkamp and Neil J. Smelser UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA PRESS Berkeley Los Angeles Oxford © 1992 The Regents of the University of California INTRODUCTION Hans Haferkamp and Neil J. Smelser Haferkamp is grateful to Angelika Schade for her fruitful comments and her helpful assistance in editing this volume and to Geoff Hunter for translating the first German version of parts of the Introduction; Smelser has profited from the research assistance and critical analyses given by Joppke. 1. Social Change and Modernity Those who organized the conference on which this volume is based—including the editors— decided to use the terms "social change" and "modernity" as the organizing concepts for this project. Because these terms enjoy wide usage in contemporary sociology and are general and inclusive, they seem preferable to more specific terms such as "evolution" "progress," "differentiation," or even "development," many of which evoke more specific mechanisms, processes, and directions of change. Likewise, we have excluded historically specific terms such as "late capitalism" and "industrial society" even though these concepts figure prominently in many of the contributions to this volume. The conference strategy called for a general statement of a metaframework for the study of social change within which a variety of more specific theories could be identified. 2. Theories of Social Change Change is such an evident feature of...

Words: 171529 - Pages: 687

Free Essay

Ameya

...COMPARING PERCEPTIONS OF THE SYSTEMS ANALYSIS AND DESIGN COURSE BRANDI N. GUIDRY University of Louisiana at Lafayette Lafayette, LA 70504 DAVID P. STEVENS University of Louisiana at Lafayette Lafayette, LA 70504 ABSTRACT Information Systems (IS) practitioners and educators have equal interest in the content of the Systems Analysis and Design Course (“SAD”). Previous research has examined instructors’ perceptions regarding the skills and topics that are most important in the teaching of the SAD course and the class time devoted to each. A similar assessment evaluated SAD course content from a practitioner perspective. Both studies used entropy calculations. A comparison of these studies is presented in this paper. For traditional topics, the group (either faculty or practitioner) with greater agreement believes the topic to be deserving of less class time. For structured and object-oriented topics, the group with the greater agreement also believes the topic to be of greater importance. This analysis demonstrates that practitioners and academics agree on approximately 40% of the SAD skills and knowledge areas. Keywords: Systems analysis and design, Structured analysis, Object-oriented analysis, Management Information Systems curricula, Entropy INTRODUCTION It is important that an education in Management Information Systems (MIS) is reflective of practices and techniques that are currently used in industry. Given the pace of technological innovation, there are ever-changing...

Words: 6702 - Pages: 27

Free Essay

Econ

...ANSWER: F PAGE: 6 type: N 8. State constitutions are supreme within their respective borders. ANSWER: T PAGE: 6 type: N 9. Statutory law does not include county ordinances. ANSWER: F PAGE: 6 TYPE: = 10. Every state has adopted the Uniform Commercial Code in its entirety. ANSWER: F PAGE: 7 TYPE: N 11. Common law is a term for law that is common throughout the world. ANSWER: F PAGE: 8 TYPE: = 12. Damages is the normal remedy at law today. ANSWER: T PAGE: 8 TYPE: = 13. Equitable remedies include injunctions and decrees of specific performance. ANSWER: T PAGE: 8 TYPE: = 14. In most states, a court cannot grant a legal remedy and an equitable remedy in the same case. ANSWER: F PAGE: 9 TYPE: + 15. Judges use precedent when deciding a case in a common law legal system. ANSWER: T PAGE: 10 TYPE: = 16. Courts do not depart from precedents. ANSWER: F PAGE: 10 TYPE: = 17. How the courts...

Words: 9675 - Pages: 39

Premium Essay

Patriarchy

...Bargaining with Patriarchy Deniz Kandiyoti Gender and Society, Vol. 2, No. 3, Special Issue to Honor Jessie Bernard. (Sep., 1988), pp. 274-290. Stable URL: http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0891-2432%28198809%292%3A3%3C274%3ABWP%3E2.0.CO%3B2-W Gender and Society is currently published by Sage Publications, Inc.. Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/about/terms.html. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use. Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at http://www.jstor.org/journals/sage.html. Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed page of such transmission. JSTOR is an independent not-for-profit organization dedicated to and preserving a digital archive of scholarly journals. For more information regarding JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. http://www.jstor.org Fri Jun 15 11:56:33 2007 BARGAINING W I T H PATRIARCHY DENIZ K A N D I Y O T I Richmond College, United Kingdom T h i s article argues that systematic comparative analyses of women's strategies and coping mechanisms lead to a...

Words: 7674 - Pages: 31