Premium Essay

The Misfit's Justice

Submitted By
Words 1293
Pages 6
In Flannery O' Connor's short story "A Good Man Is Hard to Find," a character who calls himself The Misfit murders random, innocent people. When he crosses paths with the protagonist of the story, an overbearing grandmother, he attempts to justify his murders, claiming that there is "no pleasure but meanness" before he murders her as well (O'Connor 1295). At this point, a reader must question why The Misfit finds pleasure in killing and punishing people. The true answer to this question, while contradictory to his previous statements, is that he does not truly find pleasure in killing people; rather, he feels that his murders provide a form of justice and equality in a world that lacks these attributes. The actions of Matt Fowler, the vengeful …show more content…
He obsesses over the fact that Jesus raised the dead, declaring that this act has "thown [sic] everything off balance" (O'Connor 1295). From The Misfit's belief that the resurrection of the dead has interrupted the balance of justice in the world, readers can draw certain conclusions about his views on death and punishment. One can assert that he believes death to be somewhat of a final judgment, and if a person is able to escape this final judgment, then he has gained an unfair advantage over everyone else. The Misfit believes that Jesus "shouldn't have done it (raised the dead)" because in doing so, he granted an immensely valuable second chance at life to an undeserving person. In The Misfit's eyes, the very fact that a person is dying and being subjected to his final judgment qualifies him as undeserving of a second chance. He feels it is his job to restore the balance, which Jesus disturbed, by bringing death, since death is the polar opposite of resurrection and life; this mindset is shared, in part, by Matt Fowler. Instead of believing Jesus disrupted the balance of justice, though, Fowler believes Richard Strout committed an unjust act in killing Fowler's son, and Fowler believes it is his duty to restore equality by killing Strout (Dubus 1225). Although Fowler and The Misfit differ in their opinions about what disturbs or has disturbed the balance of justice and equality, they both take justice and the restoration of equality upon themselves by committing

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Flannery O Connor's Misfit And The Mystery Of Evil

...Morality and religion are common themes throughout Southern literature. In "Flannery O'Connor's Misfit and the Mystery of Evil," John Desmond examines the actions of the Misfit and determines how morality and religion relate to themes within Southern Literature. Desmond suggests the Misfit's actions are fueled by a desire to understand ethics; as well as a desire to cure his spiritual suffering. Desmond provides examples of the Misfit's anguish, such as the symbolism behind his name, his internalized isolation, and his reaction to simple kindness. Desmond also provides insight into the morality of other characters, such as The Grandmother. The Misfit's isolation and resistance to change is also exhibited by Hulga in "Good Country People". With each text comes examples of how morality changes a person and dictates their actions through desire. The Misfit is a self-sufficient, morally isolated character. Throughout "A Good Man is Hard to Find," the Misfit shares with the Grandmother details concerning his name. The Misfit claims...

Words: 851 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

A Good Man Is Hard to Find

...Fiction Assignment In A Good Man is Hard to Find, O’Connor displays to us the theme of an unsympathetic character that is surprisingly touched when one of his victims of his senseless crimes tries to convert him and persuade him to not kill her. With O’Connor’s Catholic influenced writing, a closer look through the short story shows the theme of unlikely, undeserving characters finally understanding the error of their ways and knowing that they could change, through the help and belief of religion. At the end of the story we see irony along with a sort of justice to the killing of the grandmother, who led her family down on a trip to their death because she was insistent of reliving and glorifying the former times. We also see the Misfit find out that there is no pleasure in his way of life, which makes him reflect on how different his life could have been. The first example of the Grandmother’s ability to compare and contrast the present time she is in and the ways of the past is in the backseat of the car with her grandchildren. When her grandson says that he wishes to get through their home state, Georgia, quickly, the grandmother admonishes him by telling him that children were more respectful of their states and parents. This seems to have little effect on the two disrespectful children. Further along the vacation, the family goes to The Tower for lunch. The place is run by a man named Red Sammy, whom advertises his restaurant by appealing to people just like the grandmother...

Words: 1182 - Pages: 5