Free Essay

True Cinderella

In:

Submitted By xcv42j8
Words 1050
Pages 5
What You Teach Your Kids Parents in modern day society love to scream about what people can and can't teach their children. After all, children are highly impressionable, and monitoring what one's kids see and hear is a crucial part of being a parent. It is this concern that causes numerous angry parents to show up at every school PTA meeting and yell at that the schools complain that they shouldn't be teaching their children subjects such as sexual education and evolution. While some may find these parents reactions ridiculous and bizarre, it is well with in their parental rights to protest. Although, what many of these parents fail to realize is they are teaching their children many of the the same things they are protesting using fairy tales. Nobody ever stops to think about the true meaning behind fairy tales, after all what harm can come from reading a bed time story, but the truth is that many of these stories have subliminal messages. Cinderella, for example, seems like it's just about a hard working girl who perseveres, though suffering, is payed off by her living happily ever after with a prince, right? One could not be more wrong, Cinderella contains messages which teach kids a sense of entitlement, vanity, and to not stand up for ones self. Children are constantly asking their parents for toys, junk food, and money. Parents should just be able tell their children yes or no when they make such requests, but sadly thats not the case. When a parent tells their kid no quite often that kid responds with yelling, screaming, crying, and slamming doors. Kids refuse to take no for an answer because they have learned form stories such as Cinderella that all they should have to do is ask for something, and it will be immediately given to them. Regardless of which version of Cinderella one reads, in every story she asks a magical entity for the clothing and amenities necessary to go to a ball, and then she immediately receives them. For example in Jakob and Wilhelm Grimm's version of the tale Cinderella goes to the hazel tree planted on top of her mothers grave and says, “Shiver and quiver my little tree, Silver and gold throw down over me. Then the bird threw down a gold and silver dress down to her, and slippers embroidered with silk and silver.”(Grimm 243) Furthermore in the Grimm's version, the next day Cinderella repeats these same word and receives an even grander dress. Those who say Cinderella abuse was her working for those beautiful garments couldn't be more wrong. Cinderella didn't know she was going to obtain these extravagant gifts prior to accepting abuse, these gifts were miraculously bestowed upon her. Not once does any version of the story say that Cinderella was accepting her abuse because she knew she was going to get her dress and slippers. If the tale was about a girl named Cinderella who sewed her own dress and then went to ball then it would be a tale teaching the value of hard work; but as it stands the tale is just giving children a sense of entitlement. Now more then ever children are being sexualized and have vast amounts of importance placed on their appearance. If one flips on the television they can watch shows such as “Toddlers and Tiaras”. A show about young children being dressed up in revealing clothing and being paraded around on stage. The sexualization doesn't stop there, Barbies, Bratz dolls, and Monster High dolls are all common children's toys that are all scantily dressed up in various outfits. Cinderella contributes to placing this importance on appearances by having the Prince that fall in love with Cinderella based on her looks. The Prince doesn't love Cinderella because she is a hard worker, he loves her simply because she is the hot chick at the ball. Even in the Disney version, “Cinderella was the loveliest of them all. The Prince never left her side, all evening long.”(Campbell 249) Cinderella isn't teaching children to be diligent workers, it teaches children to be vain. That who someone truly is isn't half as important as what someone looks like. Cinderella goes against what the vast majority of what parents teach their children: the importance of standing up for one's self. That if one is bullied, abused, or put down they should shouldn't accept it and cry in the corner, they should be proactive and tell a person of authority about this problem so it can be fixed. Just letting ones self be repeatedly victimized isn't displaying strength or courage. Parents who push stories like Cinderella on their children aren't realizing what they are actually teaching their children. What's being taught to children is that when those mean “stepsisters” pick on you to just accept it. After all that what Cinderella did, never once did object to the perpetual mistreatment she was subjected to. To take it a step further, Cinderella is rewarded with lavish gifts for accepting her abuse. That is the antithesis of what you should impress on a child. Cinderella is not the innocent tale most parents believe it to be. Like many fairy tales it has subliminal messages which are passed on to children. In this case these messages are creating a sense of entitlement, preaching vanity, and teaching children not to stand up for one's self. The ritzy clothing Cinderella get just by asking. A story about a girl who marries a prince isn't teaching children about love, it's teaching them that what they see in the mirror is what it truly matters. Someone who never once stands up for her self isn't someone who should be a role model. Yet parents insist on reading their children stories like Cinderella with out considering what they are actually saying. So it may not be the schools that are a problem, or the toys they play with, but rather its those innocent looking books on your shelves.

Works Cited
Campbell, Grant. "Walt Disney's Cinderella." Reading And Writing Across The Curriculum. 12th ed. New York: Pearson Education, 2013. 247-49. Print.
Grimm, Wilhelm. "Cinderella." Reading And Writing Across The Curriculum. By Jakob

Grimm. 12th ed. New York: Pearson Education, 2013. 240-45. Print.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Disney vs Grimm

...Encouraging children to believe in a fantasy that is unobtainable is what Disney has successfully done with the help of their fairytale movies. Altering the gruesomeness of blood soaked feet and empty eye sockets of Grimm, into a lighter hearted humorous version of Cinderella has changed the moral and what we are trying to teach our children. If Disney’s movies were made identical to Grimm’s versions would they still be as magical, would the movies still be geared for a younger audience? Has Disney taken away the true hardships and meaning of the classic fairytale by censoring the stories to fit their ideal mold? Children who have grown up with Disney have been given entertainment first and to believe in a fantasy world and where morals are no longer the focus. Children want to believe in characters and certain setting and events that occur and Tolkien makes a good claim at that by saying, “children are capable, of course, of literary belief, when the story-maker's art is good enough to produce it.” The story of Cinderella is a tale of a girl that goes through abuse and is made to be a servant in her own home and given a new name in mockery of her suffering. Grimm made Cinderella’s mother present and an important factor in her personality by saying "Dear child, be good and pious, and then the good God will always protect thee, and I will look down on thee from heaven and be near thee." That line in itself shows the way society thought at that time and the type of message...

Words: 1227 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Cinderella

...English 101 Mrs.Sonnier October 30, 2015 Happily Never After When most people hear about the story of Cinderella, the first thing that pops into their head is the animated movie Disney had created. They think about the poor servant girl who was dressed in nothing but rags who cleaned the entire house and was mocked by her cruel step sisters and step mother. As the story continues, Cinderella then receives help from her fairy god mother and ends up at the ball where she meets her prince. The animated Disney version had become a big hit towards younger children because of the moral lessons they receive at the end of the movie. When kids think about Cinderella all they believe and see are the good things that can happen to them. They see the little mice and the happy ending where Cinderella marries the prince and they live happily ever after. This story was originally created by a man called Charles Perrault. Little do they know that there are multiple stories about Cinderella, some even containing violent and aggressive behaviors unsuitable for a child to hear. For example another version of Cinderella was made by Jacob and Wilhelm Grim which told the tale the same exact way as Charles Perrault, the only difference was that the step sister’s eyes were plucked out by birds at the end of the story for treating Cinderella badly in the beginning. Also, before Cinderella was revealed the step sisters were so desperate to be with the prince that they ended up chopping their own...

Words: 1036 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Pixar And Cinderella

...I ran for my life. I didn’t grab no shoes or nothing Jesus. Cinderella is a fictional Disney Pixar character. She appears in many movies other than “Cinderella.” The movie “Ever After” is better than the Grimm’s tale “Cinderella.” In choosing either “Ever After” or “Cinderella,” I’d choose “Ever After.” For example, the evil step sisters did not get their body parts cut off in the movie. It’s an extremely .unpleasant thing to read. It could seriously scare a small child. Also including, one of the step sisters, in the movie, was willing to stand up for her. It is very important to stand up and be kind, even if you are standing alone. This teaches children a valuable life lesson. So, if you are looking for an appropriate movie...

Words: 277 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Princess Paradox Conniewozik

...“The Princess Paradox” Summary In his article “The Princess Paradox,” James Poniewozik, a writer who focuses on feminine topics, discusses his information about Cinderella, which he expresses her as practical and dressy. (323). Generally, Poniewozik explains how Cinderella has influenced society through movies, young girls, and has created a desire for the fairy tale romance. Poniewozik begins explaining about parents and their daughter regarding Halloween (323). Even though a young girl without the traditional Barbie dolls, that is more “tomboy,” may even want to dress up as a princess to celebrate the fall holiday (323). Poniewozik claims young girls desire to be princesses due to the Cinderella themed movies today. Then later on in his...

Words: 388 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Parent’s Influence on Children’s Expectations

...shows, and books are always coming up with new strategies to help parents cope with children’s expectations for life and other material goods. “The House on Mango Street” by Sandra Cisneros and “Cinderella” by Anne Sexton both show how kids grow up expecting perfect situations in life like fairytales; the main difference is that Cisneros’ story shows a young person waiting for the parents to provide her with happiness whereas in Sexton’s piece the young girl shows initiative to make her dreams a reality. In “The House on Mango Street,” by Sandra Cisneros, a child details her living situation with her parents. She talks about how they lived in apartments and moved around before finally moving to a house. The house the family finally moves to does not meet her expectations that were created by her parents. Although the house is “a real house that would be ours for always so we wouldn’t have to move each year” (Cisneros 392) it has lots of problems and things seem to break a lot. At one point her teacher passes by the house where she sees the girl playing and reacts in a way that makes her embarrassed of her home. The story ends with her expressing a desire to move to “A real house. One I could point to.” (Cisneros 392) but her parents just say this is how it is for now. “Cinderella” by Anne Sexton starts by giving examples of...

Words: 1230 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Cinderella (1950)

...themes the film Cinderella (1950) portrays is how the “Dreams come true.” However, when I watched Cinderella (1950) again, my attention was brought to this one scene of Cinderella at the grand ball (51:24-56:00). Disney put out a branched out theme of when the main character’s dreams come to face the reality. The scene starts with Cinderella dancing with her Prince Charming at the ball to a soft music that allows both sense of magic and elegance to step in. This diegetic music played by the orchestra at the ball goes well with Cinderella’s flowy dress as she smoothly slides across the fancy floor. In the music, the heavy bass played by Cello gives a palatial feeling. Also when the couple starts dancing, the spotlight is turned on them, which makes it seem like if Cinderella is dreaming which related to Disney’s theme “Dreams come true.” In the middle of the dance, some diegetic sound is added to the music when the scene switches over to the king and his doorman. In this quick shot, not only they have a quick dialogue but also a breaking noise of the doorman’s magnifying glasses. After dancing at the ball, Cinderella and Prince Charming gracefully dances out to the garden where they are by themselves. During the scene, the diegetic music played by the orchestra slows down as Cinderella starts humming. However, the music doesn’t end but puts an accent by using crescendo in the tune giving the feeling of hope and curiosity in what is going to happen next. As Cinderella sings about...

Words: 803 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Cinderella

...Cinderella & Sleeping Beauty Once upon a time, most young girls grew up watching Disney’s classic princess films. Most of these films ended with the princesses marrying the prince and living happily ever after! For example “Cinderella” and “Sleeping Beauty” they are both princess that have evil villains trying to ruin them, but their stories are not the same. For example, they have different struggles, and how they overcome them. They both sing magically, but have different songs. They may be two of the most known princess in the world, but they also have many differences. However, in the end either the glass slipper fits, or true loves kiss wins. Cinderella and Aurora are two of the most beloved Disney princess of all time. How they got to be the most loved princesses is two completely different stories literally! Cinderella is a good-hearted girl, who is a servant in her own home to her cruel step-mother and two step-sisters because her father died at a young age. As Aurora is a kind hearted princess born into royalty. Although she is living with misfortune, as Cinderella, because and evil fairy named Maleficent curses her to die on sixteenth birthday. So Aurora is a more tragic story. However, Cinderella is a more hopeful and optimistic story that one day things will turn around. She dreams of a day that she will no longer be a servant in her own home. Her chance comes true when there is a ball at the castle, where the prince is looking for his future wife. With the...

Words: 1229 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Analysis of Cinderella

...Good Triumphs Evil: Cinderella Cinderella, as told by Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm in Household Tales, is a tale most of us are familiar with. Most know the version of the tale as told in the Disney classic animated film. However, when told by the Grimm brothers it is a bit more elaborate and quite unlike the Disney version. Yet it is a tale I can relate to, as I’m sure many others can as well. I find the moral of the story the authors were trying to get across is that good will triumph evil, even in what seems to be the most impossible of situations. It all began with Cinderella suffering the death of her mother, who was quickly replace by an evil stepmother and her two daughters. They tell her cruel things and force her to do the household cleaning as “He who wants to eat bread must earn it; out with the kitchen-wench.” With that one sentence they have explicitly made it clear they feel she is beneath them and if she wants to eat she will earn her keep and meals. They take all of her possessions and give her, mock her, and even taunt her. She is forced to work in kitchen from the morning to nighttime, force her to sleep in the ashes by the fireplace. She has been reduced to nothing. She has nothing and is made to feel as though she is nothing, even to her father. The ways I can relate to her aren’t the exact same circumstances, but similar nonetheless. At one point I was in a relationship that was very abusive. I was to do all the cooking, all the cleaning, and under no circumstance...

Words: 795 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Ever After – Still the Same Old Cinderella Story

...Ever After – Still the Same Old Cinderella Story In the movie, Ever After (1998), director and co-screenwriter Andy Tennant attempts to put a spin on the fairy tale we all knew growing up, Cinderella, by trying to empower the heroine and updating the film to appeal to a modern audience. Tennant explains, "I wanted to tell a very different version of Cinderella because I have two daughters, I did not want them growing up believing you have to marry a rich guy with a big house in order to live happily ever after" (Friedmeyer, p. 4). Did he accomplish? On the surface it would seem that Ever After is a modern feminist film, empowering women, but under the disguise, it still has the underlying traditional gender roles and stereotypes that Tennant tries to discourage and remove. In both Disney’s Cinderella and in Tennant’s Ever After, the male sex is ranked higher than females and has real power and social status. Kelley (2003) explains, “Males are seen as rescuers; females are more passive" (p. 651). The King and his son Prince Henry are the two highest ranking males in the film and they are shown to have ultimate power; the power over life and death. After Danielle hits Henry with apples, making him fall off the horse she thought he was stealing, she feared for her life because she assaulted royalty and the heir to the kingdom. In the same scene, in an attempt to quiet Danielle as to not cause a ruckus which may alert the royal guards, Prince Henry drops coins to the...

Words: 1855 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

An Analysis of Gender Roles in Disney Princess Films

...An Analysis of Gender Roles in Disney Princess Films Jasmit Singh 213749361 Traditional and Popular Culture – 1900 9.0 Susan Niazi – Tutorial 6 Whether it’s the colours they wear, the activities they engage in or how they behave, men and women are known to play different roles in society. These established gender roles “are not innate or natural but a product of society”. Children, adolescents and adults all learn gender roles through the environment they’re surrendered by. One of the many huge influencers that help shape gender roles is media. Although “there has been a lot of change over the years in terms of what is considered appropriate societal roles for men and women, this change is not reflected in contemporary film”. The ideology of mainstream media continues to focus on the males being the heads of society, which in result, shows an unequal representation of the females. From an early age, media puts an image into young minds, informing them how males and females should think, act, behave and appear. In many television shows and films, one can easily see the distinct difference between the role of a male and a female. Often films are enforcing stereotypical gender roles where the male is seen to holds more importance in society than the female. Amongst many film producing companies, Walt Disney Pictures for decades have been enforcing stereotypical gender roles in their princess films. Though it may not be outright obvious, Disney productions play a huge role...

Words: 4008 - Pages: 17

Free Essay

Cinderella

...The obstacle which Cinderella encounters is her stepmother who is determined to keep Cinderella at home doing chores, while her own biological daughters, Anastasia and Drizella, are given all the privileges and opportunities to enjoy life. When the king announces that there will be a grand ball at the palace, dresses are bought for Anastasia and Drizzella. The stepmother wants to show her two daughters off for the ball, but Cinderella is expected to stay home and do chores. While not strictly forbidden to go, the stepmother assumes that Cinderella will stay home because she has work to do and nothing appropriate to wear. With the help of her fairy godmother and magic, Cinderella is overcomes the obstacle of not being able to attend the ball. The fairy godmother equips Cinderella with a magical carriage made from a pumpkin, footmen created from mice, a fancy dress and glass slippers. The godmother warns Cinderella that the finery will disappear at the stroke of midnight. Because of the magic, Cinderella attends the ball where the Prince dances with her and falls madly in love with the beautiful girl in the glass slipper. At the stroke of midnight, Cinderella flees from the Prince's embrace, accidentally dropped her glass slipper. Distraught at losing the love of his live, the Prince sends an note throughout the kingdom, looking for the owner of the glass slipper. Every young woman in the area is asked to try on the slipper. When the note arrives at Cinderella's house...

Words: 358 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Violant

...thinking about the research topic, the one thing pulled my attention was why there are villains in almost all fairy tales. It is very interesting to think that all fairy tales have villains. In this paper I am going to talk about who the villains in the story are, why authors talk about villains in their stories and what readers learn from them. I will use mostly about fairy tale villains such as my favorite fairy tale’s villain, Cinderella’s stepmother. When we read the stories, we can tell who the villain in the story is. They are usually described as stepmothers, witches, monsters, sneak, thief, robber and traits. For example, in the Cinderella story, Lady Tremaine is a villain. In the article “Top 10 Most Evil Disney villains”(Antonia) the author described the Lady Tremaine as self centered and wicked person. She physiologically abuses Cinderella. When I see the characters I listed above, they all are wicked. It is easy to see that some stepmother usually abuses their children. A student wrote on her term paper about step mother as “Sadly, the term stepmother is almost unheard of unless the word "wicked" is attached to the front of it. To become a stepmother one must first...

Words: 3266 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Cinderella Comparisons

...Cinderella Story Comparisons The Disney version in some aspects is quite different than Perrault’s version, but in some cases it is also very similar. First major different that is obvious is that in the Disney version it is shown that Cinderella loses her mother at an early age which causes her father to remarry to another woman for her upbringing. In the Perrault version, there is no mother mentioned in the story. It is just told that the father “married, for his second wife, the proudest and most haughty woman that was ever seen (Perrault). Another major difference between the two stories beginning of torment for Cinderella. In Disney’s version, the stepmother and the stepsisters begin to show their true nature after the death of Cinderella’s father. The stepmother became cold, cruel, and jealous of the little girl’s charm. However, in Perrault’s version, it is explained that the ugly nature was revealed immediately after Cinderella’s father married his second wife. After the wedding ceremonies were over, “the stepmother began to show herself in her true colors. She could not bear the good qualities of this pretty girl, and the less because they made her own daughters appear the more odious. She employed her in the meanest work of the house” (Perrault). The similarity between the two is that both versions involved Cinderella being a house maid while her stepsisters received the opposite treatment. Also, in Perrault’s story, the father does not die. He is very much there but...

Words: 1808 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Fantasy and Poetry in Children’s Literature

...selections of literature are Cinderella for the fantasy story and a poem by Eloise Greenfield called “Tradition”. Both selections are from different cultural traditions, but portray positive messages to children and adults in today’s society. Every little girl dreams of finding her prince charming. There are more than 1500 different versions of “Cinderella” from cultures all over the world. The story of Cinderella has been in existence since 1865 and published by George Routledge. This fairy tale is one of the oldest and most familiar to young children that inspire them to believe anything is possible. The literary elements in Cinderella include the setting, characters, plot, conflict, climax, and ending. The setting was in a faraway kingdom a long time ago. The characters included a young girl name Cinderella, her stepmother, two stepsisters, the prince, and fairy godmother. The Plot of this fairy tale is a young girl who is being treated unfairly, but dreams of finding her true love. She is being mistreated by her stepmom and sisters and works as a maid in the home. Cinderella begs to go to a ball and is told she could go after all chores are completed. Once she completes the chores and finds a dress, she is maliciously attacked by her stepsisters and destroys her dress. Cinderella was shattered and thought she would never recover from this. The conflict in this story is the continual dislike from the stepmother and stepsisters against Cinderella. The climax is so exciting...

Words: 569 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Cinderella

...was kind and sweet with a gentle nature. But her two stepsisters had their mother’s (wicked stepmother) mannerisms and bad temper. In-turn, the kind young woman (Cinderella) got her kind and gentle nature from her mother, the first wife of the worthy man. The second wife showed her true colors shortly after getting married to the worthy man. The stepmother’s bad temper and wicked ways came out into the open. Cinderella was given very hard tasks around the house to do. After the chores, Cinderella was to sit among the cinders around by the fireplace chimney, from this she was to be known as Cinder-clod. Cinderella also had to sleep on a wretched mattress in a garret on the top of the house. Even though Cinderella was a pretty girl, her wretched clothes still did not prevented her from being hundreds of times more beautiful than her stepsisters. Plus her stepsisters had resplendent garments. In this classic story, I had originally forgotten it to the point that all I reread in the packet was mostly new to me. But after being familiarized with it, this wonderful story stored in memory came back in full force. When the king’s son (the prince) gave a ball, he invited all the higher up people. The two mean stepsisters of Cinderella were invited, but not her. What I found mean and reprehensible was the fact that Cinderella had went over the two meanies linen and ironed out their ruffles so they could talk of nothing else but their glorious fashion and clothes. I dislike reading about...

Words: 1080 - Pages: 5