Premium Essay

What Are The Pros And Cons Of The Patronage System

Submitted By
Words 721
Pages 3
The patronage system and the merit system are both unique systems used to fill vacancies in the staff of various levels and departments of the governments. The patronage system was used at all levels of the government, with local governments utilizing the patronage system to build powerful government machines in the early years of this country. (Dresang, 2016) There are pros and cons of both types of systems with favoritism towards one or the other depending on your point of view. Government contracting has been influenced in one way or another by each system. The patronage system which is has resulted in the spoils system can be referred to as the good old boys network. The ability to obtain and keep a position in the government is strongly related to who you know and what your social standing is. Generally speaking anyone being considered for an …show more content…
Often times with the merit system, standardized tests are given to determine an applicant’s eligibility as well as considering their level of education and experience. This system resulted in experienced managers and staff competing for available positions. Competent and experienced staff produced a more effective and efficient government that is able to transition from administration to administration without having to start from scratch with each new president. The merit system also provides employees with recourse when subjected to unfair hiring and firing practices by an administration and removes politics from personnel management. Employees under the merit system tend to resist change as they have been around a long time and want to continue to do things the way they have always been done. (Meshke, 2017) Unfortunately the merit system does not prevent the use of the good old boys network, the good old boys are just more careful about how they do

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Quality Control

...they play in the success ii. Firms adoption of roles and effects of nonexistent role modeling iii. Monitoring and Metrics within the quality management improvements III. General Quality Strategies and Tools i. Establishing customer expectations ii. Designing quality in iii. Defining metrics iv. Mistake-proofing v. Kaizen vi. Six Sigma IV. Quality Tactics and the Logistics and Supply Chain Functions i. What tools are applicable internally ii. What tools are applicable externally with vendors V. Week 5: Roll-Out i. A communication plan ii. Sequence of steps to get personnel trained iii. Stakeholders on board I. History Of Quality Management The history of quality management and the movement can be traced as far back as medieval times in Europe when craftsmen and tradesmen organized themselves in unions called guilds which predate the 13th century. It wasn’t until the 19th Century when the industrial manufacturers of the world adopted this model of craftsmanship. The system had its emphasis on the inspection process which started in Great Britain during the 1700’s and grew immensely during the Industrial Revolution of the 1800’s. In the 20th century these manufacturers began to implement these quality procedures and improve on its quality practices. As the U.S was engaged in WWII quality became paramount and more important than ever before and it became the foreground in the war. An example would be the bullets that...

Words: 3307 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

The Disney Hong Kong Casse

...prevailing on the Hong Kong leisure landscape. Alternative strategies have been suggested taking into consideration the nature of the brand, competition and the society in which it has to operating. Analysis The two major issues and management problems Strategy/mode of entry: Disney’s major challenges for entering the Hong Kong market centers on its strategic mode of entry into the Hong Kong leisure market and failure to device appropriate marketing systems that will make it acceptable and profitable. According to Daniels, Radebaugh, & Sullivan (2013) strategy is “management’s idea on how to best attract customers, operate efficiently, compete effectively, and create value that builds and sustains a company’s position within its industry (p. 809). Globalization and the need to broaden product and market coverage for increased profit and brand recognition are some of the reasons why companies expand overseas. However, the mode of entering a specific market must be examined particularly where the cultural and management systems are dissimilar. Options available are many but in the Hong Kong Disneyland case, Licensing or a fully integrated joint venture (management and capital) with a local company or government subsidiary might...

Words: 2505 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Labor Relations

...MG420 DL Labor Relations Research Assignment (Your name) (Date of submission) Instructor’s Name February 21, 2016 1. Define the term “collective bargaining” and list and describe four issues that are mandatory components of collective bargaining agreement. Collective bargaining is the act of negotiating employment conditions such as wages and roles between the employer and the employees. I researched collective bargaining and Funk & Wagnails New World Encyclopedia states, “The bargaining process is concerned with wages, working hours, fringe benefits, job security, and other matters relating to working conditions.”(2015) There are four issues that are mandatory components of collective bargaining agreement. The first issue is compensation. Compensation includes wages, fringe benefits, vacations, and holidays, shift premiums, and profit sharing. The second issue is personnel, policies, and procedures, which are layoffs, promotion, transfer policies, overtime, and vacation rules. The third issue is employee rights and responsibilities such as seniority rights, job standards, and workplace rules. Employer rights and responsibilities is the fourth issue and that includes management rights, just cause discipline and discharge subcontracting , and safety standards. Collective bargaining is needed and happening all over the world. An example of current events/acts of collective bargaining is what’s going on is Wisconsin right now. Wisconsin’s governor Scott Walker signed...

Words: 1940 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Arguments Against Senate Reform

...regarded in the country’s political sphere. Accordingly, rather than extensively detailing those criticisms, this paper will focus on the proposed ways to address the issues affecting the Senate (the most significant issue being that senators are appointed rather than elected). There are two main schools of thought in this regard. The first is abolishing the senate altogether. The second is reforming the senate, to resemble its American counterpart. Both alternatives will be assessed, following a brief historical overview of the Canadian and American Senates. Ultimately, it will be shown that adopting the American system is a much superior alternative, under which senators are democratically elected rather than appointed. To gain a strong understanding of the contrast between the Canadian and American Senates, one must first examine how each was founded and for what purpose it was established. Canada has a bicameral government that requires that any passing of laws must first proceed through its two houses of representation: the House of Commons and the Senate. While the House of Commons is composed of elected government officials, the Senate is often referred to as the “chamber of sober second thought” on account of the fact that it is composed of appointed government officials rather than those elected. In other words, the Senate was put in place to eliminate the concern that the participation of all Canadian citizens would be detrimental to government processes as well as to...

Words: 1670 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Business Economics

...FREE MARKET ECONOMY According to Pmiranda2857 (2009), the free market economy is an economy which promotes competitions between businesses. Basically, without this market system, consumers would not have a say in price determination of goods and services. Some consumers in some African countries have suffered with regards to pricing. According to Baye (2010), consumers do not have a say in the price determination of some services because the providers of such services enjoy the market monopoly. However, the free market economy is the best and only realistic alternative for determining the allocation of resources in an economy because of the following: i. Competition (Pmiranda2857, 2009; Rothbard, n.d.). Without competition, the free market economy will not be what it is supposed to be. The competition between the producers is the driving force in this market, providing the consumers with the most favourable product at the most affordable price. According to Pmiranda2857 (2009), a new product is priced high in the market. After sometime, the major competitors in the market begin to imitate the innovation in the market. This leads to price reduction in the once expensive product since new and similar products begin to emerge. Pricing therefore becomes a sensitive issue in competition. Rothbard (n.d.) also concluded that competition leads to the betterment in the standards of the market competitors compared to other markets. ii. It promotes entrepreneurship and innovation (Pmiranda2857...

Words: 3199 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Aussie Pooch Mobile

...in 2003 at the time of the case was USD 0.57 = EUR 0.58 = GBP 0.41. [More recent exchange rates reflect a sharp drop in the value of the U.S. dollar against the Australian dollar, euro (EUR), and pound sterling (GBP). By late 2006, AUD 1.00 = USD 0.76 = EUR 0.60 = GBP 0.40). These changes in exchange rates would not affect decisions by APM on expansion within Australia but could have an impact on the relative attractiveness of future investments in, say, the UK versus the U.S.] 1. © 2004, 2007 Christopher H. Lovelock 2. Compare and contrast the tasks involved in recruiting new customers and recruiting new franchisees. From a franchisee’s perspective, what are the key benefits of belonging to the APM franchise in (a) the first year and (b) the third and subsequent years? In planning for future expansion, what strategy should Christine Taylor adopt for APM and why? 3. 4. Analysis 1. How did Christine Taylor succeed in evolving the local dog-washing service she developed as a teenager into an international franchise business? Taylor’s success springs, first, from her...

Words: 9755 - Pages: 40

Free Essay

Case Studies

...in 2003 at the time of the case was USD 0.57 = EUR 0.58 = GBP 0.41. [More recent exchange rates reflect a sharp drop in the value of the U.S. dollar against the Australian dollar, euro (EUR), and pound sterling (GBP). By late 2006, AUD 1.00 = USD 0.76 = EUR 0.60 = GBP 0.40). These changes in exchange rates would not affect decisions by APM on expansion within Australia but could have an impact on the relative attractiveness of future investments in, say, the UK versus the U.S.] 1. © 2004, 2007 Christopher H. Lovelock 2. Compare and contrast the tasks involved in recruiting new customers and recruiting new franchisees. From a franchisee’s perspective, what are the key benefits of belonging to the APM franchise in (a) the first year and (b) the third and subsequent years? In planning for future expansion, what strategy should Christine Taylor adopt for APM and why? 3. 4. Analysis 1. How did Christine Taylor succeed in evolving the local dog-washing service she developed as a teenager into an international franchise business? Taylor’s success springs, first, from her...

Words: 9755 - Pages: 40

Free Essay

Exercise 1

...Duterte reveals platform of government Metro Manila (CNN Philippines) — Davao City Mayor Rodrigo Duterte and Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano were set to lay down their platform of government in a forum on Thursday (January 7) at the Plaza Independencia in Cebu City. In a press conference prior to the event, Duterte revealed some plans he had once elected as president. He said that his administration would be "left leaning" and he has a socialist principle. Duterte said that he would push for an end to the insurgency problem with communist rebels, having direct contacts with the NPA-NDF leaders such as Joma Sison. Duterte also said that he was against contractualization of laborers and would push for reforms in the income tax law which will cover more exemptions such as for those earning below P20,000 a month. The Davao chief executive also said that he would not declare martial law — unlike the "doomsday" scenario painted by his opponents. "But I tell criminals not to push me to go the extreme," Duterte warned. Duterte also specifically said that he would end the problem of illegal drugs in just three to six months into his administration. Organizers and supporters of Duterte said that it would be the first time for the tandem to lay down their platform of government. Duterte: Polls on federalism in 2 yrs DAVAO CITY—Presumptive President-elect Rodrigo Duterte projected a two-year timetable to submit to a referendum his proposal to dismantle the current presidential, unitary...

Words: 11531 - Pages: 47

Premium Essay

Transitional Care

...Implementing Successful Transitional Care: A structured move from Acute to Sub-Acute or Ambulatory Care Introduction Transitional care is defined as a set of actions designed to ensure the coordination and conti- nuity of health care as patients transfer between different locations or different levels of care. Representative locations include (but are not limited to) hospitals, sub-acute and post-acute nursing homes, the patient’s home, primary and specialty care offices, and long-term care fa- cilities. Transitional care is based on a comprehensive plan of care and the availability of health care practitioners who are well-trained in chronic care and have current information about the patient’s goals, preferences, and clinical status. It includes logistical arrangements, education of the patient and family, and coordination among the health professionals involved in the transition. Transitional care, which encompasses both the sending and the receiving aspects of the transfer, is essential for persons with complex care needs.1 Contents 1 Introduction 1 Historical Problems 2 Attempted Solutions 3 AmerisourceBergen Solution 3 Benefits 5 Outcomes 5 Summary Historical Problems with Transitional Care Despite considerable attention focused on improving 30-day readmission rates to hospitals, only modest change has been achieved according to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). Medicare Readmission Penalties Max Penalty 278 Hospitals ...

Words: 2906 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Biographical Analysis

...capitalism over socialism, explaining the "dynamic vitality" of free enterprise. The great economists of the 1930s and 1940s failed to see the dangers of socialism in part because they focused on the role of prices under socialism and capitalism, and ignored the enormous importance of ownership as the source of capitalist incentives to innovate. Moreover, many of the concerns that private firms fail to address “social goals” can be addressed through government contracting and regulation, without resort to government ownership. The case for private provision only becomes stronger when competition between suppliers, reputational mechanisms, the possibility of provision by private not-for-profit firms, as well as political patronage and corruption, are brought into play. 1 What kinds of goods and services should be provided by government employees as opposed to private firms? Should government workers make steel and cars in government-owned factories? Should teachers and doctors be publicly employed or should they work for private schools and practices? Should garbage be picked up by civil servants or employees of private garbage haulers? Should the whole economy be "socialized"? Although these are age-old questions in economics, the answers economists give to them, as well as the reasons for arriving at these answers, have been changing. In this paper, I describe some recent ways of thinking about government ownership. Half a century ago, economists were quick to favor government ownership...

Words: 8744 - Pages: 35

Premium Essay

Marketing Strategy

...STARBUCKS Case Study Alex Cochran May 2003 Starbucks – A Case Study. Table of Contents Alex Cochran 2003 Executive Summary..................................................................................................................................3 Market Segmentation ...............................................................................................................................4 Methods of Segmentation................................................................................................................4 Lifestyle Segmentation in the Specialty Coffee Market ..............................................................5 Segments ................................................................................................................... 5 Identifiable ................................................................................................................ 6 Sizeable...................................................................................................................... 6 Actionability .............................................................................................................. 6 Accessibility ............................................................................................................... 7 Sustainable Competitive Advantage......................................................................................................8 The Path to Protection. ...............................

Words: 8985 - Pages: 36

Premium Essay

Mtn Internal Analysis

...by a monopolist (Nigerian Telecommunications Limited (NITEL), but this changed after the auction of telecom licences to other operators, leading to stiff competition. Operators in the telecommunication industry are relentlessly competing for market share, making managers to employ different strategies to place them ahead of their competitor. (Esonwume, 2010), yet one operator was able to beat its rivals. MTN is regarded as the most profitable and widely subscribed operator in Nigeria. This paper gives a background of the industry and firm, examines key areas where MTN has been successful and the extent to which this advantage can be sustained in an attempt to answer the research questions. The research questions are as follows: 1. What strategies has MTN Nigeria adopted to become a leading telecom operator? 2. Does the firm have competitive advantage? 3. Is MTN Nigeria competitive advantage sustainable? Background of the industry. As at 2000, communication in Nigeria was deficient, with approximately 500,000 lines serving 100 million Nigerians. NITEL, the sole operator in the telecommunications sector provided substandard and inefficient service, making...

Words: 3092 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Jft Task 2

...high, which include salaries, benefits, and taxes. It is 60% of the total expenses. The expenses are too high, without enough revenue to keep it going. Without the aid of grants and contributions, the symphony would not be sustained. The symphony is not sustainable without contributions and government grants. Furthermore, there is $1,164,026 in bad debt expense from pledged dollars that were not paid. Unfortunately, this is potential income cannot be used to pay for the organizations expenses. The symphony goal is to increase profitability in the future to $500K annually. Utah Symphony Leadership weakness: Leadership is lacking the connection with their staff and patrons alike. Thus far leadership is out of touch with performances and what the desires are of the customers. They are not attuned with their goals of raising the bar for their performances. Being in touch with the...

Words: 5044 - Pages: 21

Free Essay

Union Change

...Northeastern University | Union and civil service reform | Increasing productivity in the public sector | | Lauren Patrick | Professor Marion Mason | POLS7305 34800 Institutional Leadership SEC 01 April 22, 2011 Executive Summary The target audience is the City of Boston labor management commission and the Massachusetts legislature. The current collective bargaining agreement between the City of Boston and AFSCME and the Massachusetts Legislature, Title IV, Chapter 31 creates controlling and overly-bureaucratic policies. These policies outline employee procedures, in particular hiring, disciplining, promoting and evaluation procedures that are outdated and ineffective. Unions protect employees from unfair employment practices, yet some have hurt the overall staff morale and productivity. There is a deep and long standing perception of public employees that they are lazy and incompetent. This is far from the truth, but certain policies regarding hiring, promoting, and disciplinary actions are decreasing employee productivity. To incorporate motivational elements in the public sector and give more discretion to public managers, policies must be changed. When a manager would like to promote an employee, it is a long and drawn out process, that often after much effort is exhibited, the potential promotion falls through. Where the private sector motivates through financial incentives and promotions, the public sector has no tools to promote good...

Words: 5539 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Termpaper on Entrepreneurship & Small Business Management Binimoy.Com

...business-to-business communication, as well as business-to-client communication. The core product is a card a business might send to its customers to, for example, thanks them for their patronage, or to remind a patient of a checkup. The focus of this business plan is to put forth objectives to solve the present cash-flow squeeze, and to increase profits from the present break-even level to net profits of tk.54,650 by the end of the first year. We intend to accomplish this by focusing on modifying our website, repackaging our more popular products for the large retail chains, and to concentrate on our designated target markets. TABLE OF CONTENTS Serial Number | Subject | Page No | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | INTRODUCTION This Internet business plan gives details of the proposed venture, along with expected needs and results taking into account the unique nature of electronic commerce. The business plan outlines how the company can take advantage of e-commerce to allow it to gain greater efficiencies of scale in management, marketing, and other business processes. Electronic Commerce in its broadest form incorporates the integration of public and private sector computer systems through the use of Electronic Data Interchange (EDI), Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT),...

Words: 3878 - Pages: 16