Free Essay

Why Men Love War

In:

Submitted By vjulie
Words 533
Pages 3
William Broyles, Jr.: Why Men Love War (1984)

● In what way do the veterans feel a certain ambivalence towards the war, according to Broyles?
In one way, the soldiers is raised in the believe that war is a horrible thing you and you can’t like such things. In another way, the men loved being in war. It’s gives them an intoxication, that they can’t have any other way.

● How does he portray the life of a Vietnam veteran?
Invariably filled with boozy awkwardness, forced camaraderie ending in sadness and tears.

● Explain and comment on the following statement: "There were no metaphors that connected the war to everyday life." (p. 130).
Vietnam veteran why talk about everyday life it makes absolutely no sense when you’ve been in war and you’ve experienced so many things and you can’t connect war and everyday life, the difference is too big.

● Explain and comment on the following sentence: "War is the enduring condition of man …" (p. 131).
It is a male instinct to experience war at some point in his life. The text says; “There is a reason for every war and a war for every reason.” There is always an excuse for war.

● How does Broyles characterise himself? Why does he miss the war at some points?
Djdj

● Sum up the reasons Broyles gives for why men love war. In this connection, comment on the statements below. Find more statements that explain why men love war and comment on them: ◦ War is an escape from the everyday (p. 133) ◦ War is a game (p. 133) ◦ The enduring emotion of war is comradeship (p. 134) ◦ Isolation is the greatest fear in war (p. 134) ◦ War is beautiful (p. 139)
● Describe Broyles' feelings on his first encounter with the enemy (p. 134). Compare with Ambush.
● What did the Vietnam Veterans Memorial mean to the veterans according to Broyles? (pp. 135-36)
● What does Broyles say about the significance of war stories? "I have never once heard a grunt tell a reporter a war story that wasn't a lie…" (p. 136). Why is it so difficult to tell the truth?
● "And one of the most troubling reasons men love war is the love of destruction, the thrill of killing" (p. 137). Do you agree? Discuss.
● Comment on the sentence: "Language liberated us" (p. 137). What does Broyles mean? Could you give other examples from the texts you have read?
● "War is, in short a turn-on" (p. 140). Comment on this statement. What does Broyles say about war and sex? Compare with The General Goes Zapping Charlie Cong.
● How does Broyles describe and explain his attraction to the Vietnamese girl? Explain and comment on the following passage: "She was the suffering soul of war, and I was the soldier who has wounded it but would make it whole." (p. 141).
● Comment on the ending: "It's a long way from Nam, isn't it?" "Yes. And no."
● Collect evidence of the gap between veterans and civilians in the texts you have read. What are their problems in relation to re-integration and coming to terms with their experiences in Vietnam?
● Discuss how these vets seem to be haunted by the past.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

War and Love

...Women’s Power Thao Vo Monday 4:30-5:45 War, the word that has been and will always be the word that no one wants to hear or think about. Aristophanes, a writer of ancient Athens, wrote a comedy to discuss the serious topic of war and how it affected the Greeks. He is also the author of Lysistrata, a play where Aristophanes expressed his feeling and thought about the war during this period of time. “Aristophanes wrote to express his vision on life, his delight in life itself seen behind the warping screen of contemporary event.” In this play, we will get to see the importance and serious meaning of war toward the union, espectually the soldiers’ family. The play Lysistrata is about the war between Athens and Sparta. This play is about the story of “ an Athenian matron who convinces the women of Athens and Sparta to withhold sex from their husband until they sign a peace treaty.”The main character is Lysistrata, and she is one of the Athens’ women that willingly to stand up toward the men just to bring peace back. She does not want war between the cities in Greeks. Lysistrata wanted to save Greeks and she believed that if all the women agreed then they can achieve the tremendous goal. “So fine it comes to this--Greece saved by Woman!” She held a meeting with all the other women and told them about her plan to bring peace. There is only one way to save the union is to make all the women withhold sexual privileges with their husband. “sexually explicitly to a degree that can...

Words: 1917 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

The Lost Generation Through Cohn, Brett and Jake

...impacted by the outbreak of World War One. However, Cohn still lives by the pre-war values, mainly due to the fact that the war had little impact on him, unlike Jake who was injured in combat, or Brett, who lost her true love during the war. They all have characteristics that are similar with many people who were a part of what Gertrude Stein called “the lost generation”, a generation of people whose previous values were figuratively destroyed by the outbreak of World War I, and they wandered the post-war world without guidance, without a purpose. (Britannia 1 ) This is because Hemingway created these characters to symbolize a large portion of people in the 1920’s, through the characters attitudes, lifestyle and personalities. In doing so, Hemingway uses these three characters to represent different groups of people within the lost generation. Robert Cohn represents the people of the lost generation whose lives had been unaffected directly by the war, and those who still continued to live by failed the pre-war values of romance, morality and honor. Many of these people were outcasts; they were different, just like Cohn, and Cohn knew what it was like to be different. He spent a good portion of his life feeling like an outcast due to the fact that he was Jewish and Cohn never served in World War I, and was therefore typically scorned by people who had seen combat, like Jake. Cohn holds onto these traits because he had never seen the full extent of the war, and he reads books that are...

Words: 1731 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Henry V Paper

...women, once the throne was given to him, he owned up to his responsibilities and ended up becoming an amazing king that men and women of all ages still look up to today. As he grew up being heir to the throne, there was undoubtedly much pressure on him, but as one reads the book Henry V, written by William Shakespeare, they will see that once Henry inherited the crown, he proved to be a merciful king, a man of humility, and someone who gave all glory to God in everything he did. Henry was a merciful king. Throughout his reign, there were many times that he could have enacted his right as king and punished many a Englishmen who did not agree or come under his leadership, but Henry chose to show mercy when he did not have to. When Henry went through the camp on the eve of battle disguised as a regular soldier to find out what the men were thinking and feeling about the war, he came across men who did not show him the loyalty that he wanted in his soldiers, and he met men who did not view him in a good light, yet he did not do anything. Henry understood that many of the men were scared, that they felt the war was already won by the French because of the number of soldiers that they had. Henry had compassion on the men as he felt the most pressure as the one leading all these men into battle that he did not know the outcome of. Henry could have gotten angry with the men for not agreeing or seeing eye to eye with him, but instead showed them grace for coming this far along on journey...

Words: 1010 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Great Dictator

...of tenderness in the midst of war. French Capt de Boeldieu is shot down over German territory while on a mission. After being transferred to a Prisoner Of War Camp, de Boeldieu develops a friendship with von Rauffenstein, the camp's commander. Though of the same class and countries, the relationship of the two is stunted by hostile disagreements between their respective countries. Tragically, the bond is irrelevant to the nation. Each man's place of...

Words: 866 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Lysistrata

...should a person go to, for love? And to what lengths, would you go for love? In history, the power of love, has made many people go to some pretty extreme lengths. I know that I’ve done a crazy or foolish act for love. While many can relate to this, many my not and will find that the play Lysistrata extremely intriguing. Lysistrata, would do the impossible and unthinkable; to get her husband back, for what seemed to be an ever lasting war. Knowing that she needs to something, and that she would not be able to this alone, her marriage and love would depend on the outcome of her plan. This would not easy and would be a long hard journey, she sets out with a master planed scheme that would bring everything to a stop, by ending the war, bringing her husband home and earning the respect of both men and women of Greece. Lysistrata knew what she had to do to get her husband home from war, but needing all the other woman from various towns in Greece, to follow through with her master plan. Lysistrata‘s, most intriguing trait was her ability to communicate and encouraged other women to follow her plan of step one; making an oath, of no sexual encounters with men. Although not widely popular with the other women, setting out this strategic plan of cutting off sex to their husbands. Next, step two; of stopping the cash flow from the bank to supply the continuing of war. In the play, they put up barriers and barricades to block the citadel and when question why? To get your money so you...

Words: 759 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Metamorphosis In The Things They Carried

...insight into the minds of soldiers, and enlightens us to the emotional and psychological costs of war. Specifically, the stories of Mary Anne, the baby water buffalo and the chapter, “In the Field,” help us to relate to the metamorphosis that soldiers undergo. While the obvious correlation for O’Brien’s novel is to speak about the physical objects each soldier carried were much more significant, including such things as personal doubts, fears, and dreams. The soldiers have a crazy amount of mental baggage. O’Brien wrote this novel as a type of therapy for himself as a way to deal with everything he had experienced in the Vietnam War. They carried all they could bear, and then some, including a silent awe for the terrible power of the things they carried....

Words: 950 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Unbroken

...World War II, gets into a terrible plane crash. Leaving him stranded for 46 days before being found by Japanese troops. He then goes from camp to camp, being tormented daily for over 2 years. After the war, he struggles to find meaning and peace in life. Throughout this adventure, he must search for truth about his survival, love from himself and others, and his identity that has been lost in the crash. Louie is searching for the truth of his survival after the crash. When Louie was on...

Words: 973 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Business

... Chapter 1 Summary Francis describes in stark and brutal detail his injuries sustained during the war, and how after the war he came to lodge with Mrs Belander in Frenchtown where he lived as a boy. He visits the church and says prayers for various important people in his life; thus we are introduced to some major and minor characters: Enrico, his mother and father, whom we learn are dead, and Nicole Renard and Larry LaSalle. Tension is created- he states his intention of killing Larry, but at this stage we do not know why. A flashback to the war introduces the theme of heroism- Francis has a Silver Star Medal, although he refuses to believe himself heroic – and reveals his love for Nicole. Language use My name is Francis Joseph Cassavant and I have just returned to Frenchtown in Monument and the war is over and I have no face. – compound sentence – pared gives only what he considers as essentials metaphor ‘ I have no face’ why is this effective? simile ‘ my nostrils are like two small caves’ – why is this effective? Narration follows the patterns of speech – how? What do we need to be aware of with a first person narrative? Characters Francis – disfigured and hiding, ‘I am like the hunchback of Notredame, my face likee a gargoyle and the dufflebag like a lump on my back’ – why is this allusion effective? Mrs Belander – how do her actions show attitudes towards veterans at this time in America? Structure Starts...

Words: 3714 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Helen Of Troy Research Paper

...ten year war, destroyed an entire city, left thousands dead, and changed the entire course of Greek mythology. This woman is Helen of Troy, daughter of Zeus and the most beautiful woman in the world. The reason the war took place was because of her, and the entire war seemed to revolve around which group- the Greeks or the Trojans- got to take her back. Helen of Troy plays the role of a villain in the Trojan War because she ran off with a Trojan prince while she was married, was very intimate with many men throughout the war, and was unfaithful to both sides of the war. To illustrate how self-interested this woman is, I will first point out that Helen of Troy decided to run off with...

Words: 1065 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Things They Carried By Tim O Brien: An Analysis

...In the novel The Things They Carried, Tim O’Brien presents the truth of war by using the recurring image of the physical objects each soldier carries to and from the war. While they all carry heavy baggage, they also carry emotional baggage, made up of grief, love and guilt. O’Brien emphasizes on the tangible and intangible objects each soldier brings to the war. Each soldier's physical burden draws attention to their emotional burden. Even after the war, many of the soldiers can still hear the choppers in the background along with the unremovable baggage. O’Briens tells the stories of many of the honorable soldiers such as Lieutenant Jimmy Cross, Henry Dobbins, and his own firsthand experiences during the war; his poetic realism and comic fantasy illuminate the raw and gruesome reality of war. Lieutenant Jimmy Cross exemplifies the role of a leader; he comes across grief, love, and guilt throughout the novel. “As a first lieutenant and platoon leader, Jimmy Cross carries a compass, maps, code books, binoculars, and a .45-caliber pistol that...

Words: 781 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

How Does “Anthem for Doomed Youth” and “Dulce Et Decorum Est” Present Wilfred Owen’s Thoughts and Feelings Towards the War?

...feelings towards the war? Wilfred Owen was born in Oswestry on 18th March 1893. After school, he became a teaching assistant and in 1913 went to France for two years to work as a language tutor. In 1915 he returned to England to enlist in the army and was commissioned into the Manchester Regiment. After spending the remainder of the year training in England, he left for the western front early in January 1917. He was diagnosed with shellshock after experiencing heavy fighting and was evacuated to England to recover at Craiglockhart War Hospital near Edinburgh in June. Anthem for Doomed Youth and Dulce et Decorum est were written in 1917, during Owen’s time at Craiglockhart. Here, he was able to write some of his best work. He also met the poet Siegfried Sassoon here, who was already a well-established poet. Sassoon agreed to look over Owen's poems, gave him encouragement and introduced him to literary figures such as Robert Graves. Owen conveys his feelings towards the war through the many poems he wrote, especially while being treated at Craiglockhart. His poems give the reader a sense of what it was like to be a militant during conflict. His poetry is characterised by powerful descriptions of the conditions faced by soldiers in the trenches. His poems are sometimes violent and realistic, challenging earlier poetry which communicated a pro-war message. His first-hand experience of war is one reason why there was such a shift in the attitude towards war. He returned to France...

Words: 2313 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Jimmy Cross Symbolism In The Things They Carried

...Just Physical: The Things They Carried Through Vietnam Soldiers of the Vietnam War marched miles and miles through the humid broiling forests of Vietnam. So the question every soldier asks themselves is, to hump or not to hump, though maybe not in those exact words. As Tim O’Brien so eloquently puts it in his novel, The Things They Carried, “To carry something was to hump it” (O’Brien 3). Already carrying twelve to eighteen pounds of necessities, an item must be of great significance for a soldier to lug the extra weight. Ted Lavender carried six to seven ounces of “premium dope” and an extra twenty pounds of ammunition, Kiowa carried an illustrated New Testament, and Henry Dobbins carried his girlfriend’s pantyhose wrapped around...

Words: 1235 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Why Go to War

...Ms.Johnston English 4a 24 November, 15 Motivation Why do men and women go to war? This was one of the questions that stuck out to me during the Socratic seminar. It stuck out to me the most because no matter what reason I come up with, it wont be true for every person who dedicates their life to their country. Meaning that this entire essay would only be an opinion or theory based off of the information that I encountered and the way I interpret it. When I think of a reason people decided and will decide to go to war, I come up with so many different answers. All of which can be correct for hundreds but incorrect for hundreds more. Be that as it may, I decided that some people go to war for selfish reasons and some for unselfish reasons. The selfish section contains the men who go to war to get the monetary benefits, the physique of a soldier and for self-fulfillment. Self-fulfillment can be the thought of equality for women, or even the thought of fighting just to build a name like Achilles of the Iliad. Achilles had no opinion about why the world was fought; he just simply fought to be remembered. This is selfish to me because he signed himself up to take the lives of others just to fulfill his sought out legacy. It’s different if he felt strongly about the conflict and wanted to make a difference but in his case he could careless. Soldiers like Achilles disregard the lives that they destroy including the lives that they take away and even the lives that they leave...

Words: 619 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Annotated Bib

...John A. Plag. “Family Separation and Reunion: Families of Prisoners of War and Servicemen Missing in Action”. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1975. Print. This book delves into the lives of children that have an absence of their fathers caused by the assignment of the military. These authors pinpoint some of the difficult obstructions these children have to face while these men are MIA (missing in action). They talk about the adjustment and the adapting to the prolonged and seemingly indefinite absence of a father, and how a relationship between a father and child changes over the long period of time until the veteran returns. Moreover, they collected data from 42 families of returned prisoners of the Vietnam War and attempted to identify a combination of factors that could explain the variability in the quality of the father-child relationship subsequent to the returning from the War. This information from this book will help convey emotional lives that these children have to endure. This book will strengthen my research by pointing out how children are affected when there is a nonattendance of one of the parents for a long period of time. Bowen, L. Gary, Dennis K. Orthner. The Organization Family: WORK AND FAMILY LINKAGES IN THE U.S... New York, NY: Praeger Publishers, 1989. Print. This book depicts how marital relationships get torn apart because of soldiers that come back from the war with post traumatic stress and have the need to have an aggressive and...

Words: 2776 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Key Poems Aqa as

...English Literature, Key Poems List Thomas Hardy: Men Who March Away - Volunteers marching to war tell those who watch them pass by of their faith in the justice of their cause. Thomas Hardy: In Time of ‘The Breaking of Nations’ - The routines of life and love continue during conflict, and will continue long after it is over. Rupert Brooke: Peace - This sonnet is an expression of thanks for being able to respond to the call to arms and leave behind the stale and empty concerns of civilian life. Rupert Brooke: The Dead - Celebrates those who have given their lives. The sacrifice of the lowliest of them has given the world honour and nobility. Rupert Brooke: The Soldier - A solider reflects that, should he die, his grave will become a little piece of England in a foreign country. Herbert Asquith: The Volunteer - Celebrates a city clerk whose dreams of military glory have been fulfilled. His death in battle is rewarded with a place alongside the heroes of the Battle of Agincourt. Julian Grenfell: Into Battle - Celebrates spring and moves on to describe the validity of the warrior, whose sacrifice will be rewarded. Nature and the solider are at one and this gives him peace and a sense of destiny. John McCrae: In Flanders Fields - The dead, lying beneath ground covered with poppies, urge the living to continue the struggle against the enemy. Charles Sorley: All the Hills and Vales Along - Addressing men marching past, the poet urges them to sing while...

Words: 1545 - Pages: 7